Skip to content
The Joe Rogan ExperienceThe Joe Rogan Experience

Joe Rogan Experience #1158 - Chuck Palahniuk

Chuck Palahniuk is a novelist and freelance journalist, who describes his work as "transgressional" fiction. He is the author of the award-winning novel Fight Club, Choke, Lullaby, and many others.

Joe RoganhostChuck Palahniukguest
Aug 23, 20182h 7mWatch on YouTube ↗

EVERY SPOKEN WORD

  1. 0:0015:00

    Four, three, two, one.…

    1. JR

      Four, three, two, one. (claps) And we're live. How are you, Chuck?

    2. CP

      I am great. Look at this place.

    3. JR

      Thanks for being here, man. Appreciate it.

    4. CP

      Ha. Thank you.

    5. JR

      I've read your books, I've, I've watched movies based on your books, so it's very cool to meet you in real life.

    6. CP

      It's always a disappointment, it is always so heartbreaking, because people expect somebody, uh, somebody so not me. And I am constantly breaking their heart when they meet me.

    7. JR

      Well, I expect you, so you're not breaking my heart at all. I'm very pleased to meet you. So I didn't have any weirdo expectations or any delusions of who you are.

    8. CP

      And don't, just, just, just, don't, don't-

    9. JR

      (laughs)

    10. CP

      ... kill yourself, okay?

    11. JR

      (laughs)

    12. CP

      I meet Anthony Bourdain and he kills himself.

    13. JR

      Well, I think there was a lot of other factors involved there.

    14. CP

      I, no, I don't know. I, I see this-

    15. JR

      (laughs)

    16. CP

      ... so many of my peers, it's like the, the moment I meet them, boom, they're gone.

    17. JR

      Um, yeah, I'm, I'm not gonna do that, okay? So don't worry, everything's fine. Um, listen, I wanna talk to you about a bunch of things. First of all, uh, I, I would love to talk to you about your writing process, 'cause one of the, one of the things that I read once is, uh, I believe you were writing down ... It was on the cape, it was in Massachusetts? Were you ever writing down there?

    18. CP

      That-

    19. JR

      Were you, were you ever writing somewhere-

    20. CP

      (laughs)

    21. JR

      ... where you made a deal with yourself where you wouldn't turn the heat on unless you were writing?

    22. CP

      Oh my gosh, you think I'm a white person, don't you?

    23. JR

      A white person?

    24. CP

      That is so weird. The cape? The cape?

    25. JR

      You never been to the Cape Cod?

    26. CP

      That's like in England.

    27. JR

      Is that all white people?

    28. CP

      That's in England, right?

    29. JR

      New England.

    30. CP

      New England.

  2. 15:0030:00

    Whoa. …

    1. CP

      and a very good friend of mine said, "You're not bringing that word into workshop. You're not writing anything with the F-word." And, and it just became more and more tightly strictured that way. And so eventually I realized we were kind of writing to em- make each other happy instead of to kind of confront each other. And, uh, one of the writers in our workshop is a writer named Cheryl Strayed, who wr- who had written a book called Wild, which was a hugely successful book. It was chosen as an Oprah book and it will be on book store shelves for the rest of history, Cheryl's book, Wild. But while she was writing it, she had written a segment about how as a child she would be sat on the sofa with her grandfather and her f- grandfather taught her how to masturbate him. And so as a child she would masturbate her grandfather until he achieved orgasm. And then later she would find these featherless, featherless birds that had fallen out of a nest and she picked one up and she knew it would die, so she crushed it between her bare hands. This is a very small child. And she wrote how as that bird died crushed between her hands, it, its death throes, its spasms of death felt exactly like her grandfather's penis ejaculating in her little hand.

    2. JR

      Whoa.

    3. CP

      That was the best thing she ever wrote. And her editor at Knopf said, "That is not going in this book because we want this book to be a big book, and if we see you jerking off your grandfather and then killing baby birds, that is not gonna make Oprah Winfrey happy." So it was a magnificent piece of writing and a magnificent kind of parallel and awareness for a child to have. And this juxtaposition of sexual abuse and death was magnificent. Oh my God, it worked on every level. But the publisher said, "This is not gonna be in the book."

    4. JR

      Did she send it to you or did she show it to you?

    5. CP

      She brought it to workshop and she read it. And there was even a newspaper reporter pre- uh, present there. And we all realized it was fantastically powerful. But then she said, "Uh, they won't take this. This can't go in."

    6. JR

      Wow. Did she do anything with it? Did she publish it online or ...

    7. CP

      No, and, and there were so many parts of that book that were so much better than what they actually did publish.

    8. JR

      Really?

    9. CP

      And, and so it's that kind of censorship where you're trying to reach a reader standing in line at Starbucks, and this has got to go in that, uh, point of purchase stand and it's gotta be a face out. And I understand for a long time if you wanted a face out at, uh, Barnes & Noble, especially on the Discover New Writers face out stack, you could not have the word fuck on the first page because they did not want people picking up that book and opening it and seeing the F-word, that that just did not fit their corporate culture.And so, you know, so much of the censorship is, is because people really wanna reach the largest audience, uh, without offending people.

    10. JR

      Whew. But there's giant problems with that, right? I mean, one of the more fascinating things about books is that the story plays out in your mind.

    11. CP

      Exactly. The nature of consumption makes it about the only medium which, in which you can go to those places.

    12. JR

      Yeah, literally. You, you couldn't ... There's no way you would be able to find the, I mean, to put that in a book, her story about her grandfather and the bird. Maybe you could put the bird in, but the grandfather part, there's just no way.

    13. CP

      Yeah. You know, and I, I, I, I, I feel like I'm telling stories out of school, but it's such a perfect example of that kind of self-censorship. Uh, and it's also something so magnificent that I feel it should come out. It should sort of be stated. Uh, I don't wanna steal her thunder. I, I, I wanna honor the story. But it's like so many stories that people tell me. Uh, I'm kind of seen as a safe person, you know, kind of a degraded monster maybe. But as a degraded monster with no self-esteem whatsoever, they feel (laughs) safe telling me these things because in a way, they, they probably feel a little morally superior to me.

    14. JR

      (laughs)

    15. CP

      Um-

    16. JR

      Why do you think people would consider you a degraded monster?

    17. CP

      Because I can read a story like Guts that is so completely humiliating, because as I read it, it's in the first person, so people more or less assume that it's my story even though-

    18. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    19. CP

      ... the story's garnered from many different people. But the fact that I'm presenting it means that I'm the person that is, that is losing face. And afterwards, people feel like they can risk losing face by telling me their story that's very much like, uh, the Guts story.

    20. JR

      So, when someone is writing something that's deeply disturbing like that, when you, when you, when you hit those parts of your mind and you come to this pathway, do, do you consider, do you say, "Well, no one's ever gonna allow this to be in a book. No one's ever ..." Uh, uh, do you consider those thoughts or do you just go through with it first and then review it, or do you d- not do that at all?

    21. CP

      You know, I, my formative years were the punk years, the '70s into the '80s, and we always used to have a saying. People would say, "Uh, don't hit the brake until you hear a glass break," or, "Don't stop until you hear a glass break." And so, I always think the point of writing is to coach yourself to that point that you would never have gone voluntarily, and also to coach your reader to the point where the reader would never have gone voluntarily. In a story like Guts, you know, it's very funny on the front end and if you told people on the front end where it was gonna go, they'd never read that story. But it's very funny and charming and well-paced on the front. And then once people realize where it's gonna go, they're already trapped. (laughs)

    22. JR

      (laughs)

    23. CP

      And so in a way, it's, it's a way-

    24. JR

      You seem to enjoy that, though. Your, like, the way you said they're already trapped, you seem to take some satisfaction in that.

    25. CP

      But in writing it, I'm also sort of springing the trap on myself.

    26. JR

      Hm.

    27. CP

      Starting down a path that I have no idea is gonna be so humiliating or so, uh, emotionally upsetting or so dark. Because if, if I did, I would never go d- go down that path.

    28. JR

      When you write a story like that, how much of it do you plan out in advance?

    29. CP

      I might plan out up to the, the end of the second act. You know, at the moment of greatest crisis, this will happen. You know, in Fight Club, the moment of greatest crisis is gonna be when everyone in the support groups figures out that this guy is lying to them and they're all given the choice of either accepting him for his transgressions or rejecting him. Same thing in Choke. There's gonna be that moment in, uh, when people realize that he has faked choking and that he's made them into a fake hero and they're gonna either kill him or accept him. And so, I typically know that the second act is gonna end with the transgression being revealed. But beyond that, I don't wanna know because I want the story-

    30. JR

      Mm-hmm.

  3. 30:0045:00

    But some people do,…

    1. CP

    2. JR

      But some people do, right? I mean, isn't it... it's kind of like, uh, pretty much all forms of art whether it's music or movies. I mean, there's superhero movies and then there's movies like No Country for Old Men where the bad guy gets away at the end and you, you leave the movie theater and you're like, "What the fuck?" You know? But those, those are all satisfying in different ways to different people, and isn't that sort of the point?... of creative expression, is that y- you're getting surprised, you're getting taken down a road that it's here's the world through this person's eyes, and they create this world. If you put limitations on that, you're gonna ... yeah, you're gonna eliminate some disturbing aspects that might bother some people, but you're also gonna eliminate some magical moments that might just car- that might ... literally might change the way you view people.

    3. CP

      You know, and part of it has to do with the nature of, you know, movies. Movies are gonna always kind of attract, uh, a more dynamic audience. Movies carry their own authority through emotion. Um, and books are gonna be a slower medium that's harder to consume. And so, maybe books are always gonna, at this point, uh, be seen of ... as kind of a sedative, as a kind of thing that lulls you and comforts you and puts you to, to sleep.

    4. JR

      Yeah, but by who? By some people, right? I mean, I mean, maybe there's a market for those kind of books, but there's also a market for your books. There's a, there's, there's clearly a market for people that w- that wanna tap into those more disturbing aspects of consciousness-

    5. CP

      Y-

    6. JR

      ... and of reality.

    7. CP

      And that market is moving to video games, and that market is moving to edgier films. Uh, there's just other forms of storytelling that are serving that market better.

    8. JR

      Really?

    9. CP

      Oh, yeah.

    10. JR

      Better than books?

    11. CP

      Oh, yeah.

    12. JR

      But why is that? Is that because of the censorship, or is it because artists aren't exploring those ideas as much anymore?

    13. CP

      You know, and part of it is because books are harder to consume.

    14. JR

      Mm.

    15. CP

      Books take an enormous, uh, amount of, uh, commitment of time and effort to read a book, where everything else is 30 minutes to two hours.

    16. JR

      And to write a book as well, I mean, that's such a solitary discipline to-

    17. CP

      No.

    18. JR

      ... sit alone with your computer.

    19. CP

      No, it is not.

    20. JR

      No?

    21. CP

      Not for me.

    22. JR

      No?

    23. CP

      I, I hate that model. You know, I wanna be in The Mermaid Tavern talking about my ideas with my compatriots, and getting their take on them, and finding out how it re- resonates with everything else in people's lives.

    24. JR

      What's The Mermaid Tavern?

    25. CP

      Oh, it's, uh, the, the reference to where, uh, (tongue clicks) . Um ... (sighs) Not Coleridge. All the famous writers of Shakespeare's time-

    26. JR

      Oh.

    27. CP

      ... uh, basically hung out at, uh ... it was like the White Horse Tavern in New York, but The Mermaid Tavern was in London during that time. Um, and, uh, Boswell, um, all the writers hung out there and exchanged ideas and entertained one another.

    28. JR

      Hmm.

    29. CP

      And so, uh, yeah, I want writing to be my social outlet.

    30. JR

      But you have to write it by yourself, right? I mean, when you're, when you're sitting alone, actually putting your fingers on the keyboards.

  4. 45:001:00:00

    (laughs) …

    1. JR

      that. You can like it, but don't tell anybody you like it." Like, what am I supposed to do? And, uh, I didn't do anything. I just let her smile and she walked out of the bathroom laughing like it was great. And it was no, there was no issue, but it was this moment where I was like, wow, if I was a religious person or a suppressive person or some person with some sexual issues, this could be a real problem for this little girl. Instead, I was like, "Okay, let's get out of the bathroom now." (laughs)

    2. CP

      (laughs)

    3. JR

      I guess you're done, all righty. And she has no idea that this was even, like, a moment of, you know, crisis in my mind where I was like, okay, how do I handle this? I'm in the bathroom with my seven-year-old daughter just getting water shot up her ass and she's enjoying it. What-

    4. CP

      You, so you talk about it on the radio? Is that how you deal with it?

    5. JR

      I enjoy it too.

    6. CP

      (laughs) Sure.

    7. JR

      I enjoy it too. We all do. We talk about these toilets. They're amazing.

    8. CP

      (laughs)

    9. JR

      It's warm water. It shoots into your ear. It's great. It feels awesome. But it's not supposed to feel awesome for, like, a little girl for some reason, right?

    10. CP

      See, you tell that story and people will have so many versions of that story.

    11. JR

      Oh, yeah.

    12. CP

      For me, I was in Germany. I went in a bathroom in the airport. I didn't know what this button was, so I pressed it. I looked down just in time to see this little plastic arm swing out. I didn't know what that thing was gonna do. So I jumped off the head and this thing shot up with such force-

    13. JR

      (laughs)

    14. CP

      ... it knocked a ceiling panel out of the ceiling.

    15. JR

      (laughs)

    16. CP

      And all this hot toilet water came sprinkling down on me.

    17. JR

      Uh.

    18. CP

      And that's the only time I've ever been around one of those.

    19. JR

      Well, we have one here if you wanna try it out.

    20. CP

      I, uh, no-

    21. JR

      I don't know. It scares me. There's two of them. There's one in that bathroom, one in that one. One in that bathroom, you could lock. It's private.

    22. CP

      And see, that's my process-

    23. JR

      Yeah.

    24. CP

      ... is you, you tell these stories and you kind of gather the stories that people tell related to these stories and you choose the ones that escalate the fastest, that escalate the best. And that gives you a gradual sort of, you've established the precedent and then something worse, escalating worse, escalating worse, escalating to the most atrocious or extreme version. And that's what brings a story to crisis.

    25. JR

      I, I have a hard time believing that someone would be angry at that woman for her story.

    26. CP

      You know, and it's not, it's har- it's about her and her story.

    27. JR

      Right.

    28. CP

      Her relationship to that story.

    29. JR

      That one you're gonna get away with. You'll get away with that one. The j- jerking off the grandfather one is in a different place. Like, she's, she's a victim of sexual abuse. She's a victim of vi- it's w- strange that violence, for some reason, is more acceptable than sexual abuse in a lot of ways. Sexual abuse seems to be transformative, like there's something about sexual abuse that it, it ruins. You introduce, uh, an experience, a memory into a person's life that ruins them.

    30. CP

      Uh, uh, this is a rough segue, but I find with so many beginning writers is that they have absolutely no, uh, capacity to be with tension or suspense. So they might start to create suspense, but then they'll resolve it instantly, and so the story never really gets off the ground.... because something has happened to them, whether it's violent or whether it's sexual abuse, that, uh, that makes them cling to a kind of calm serenity. And that's all they want and that's all they ever want. And then writing, in a way, seems to be a way of coaching them back to a greater and greater tolerance with the unresolved, with the, with the tense, with suspense.

  5. 1:00:001:15:00

    (laughs) …

    1. CP

      "And that's why we have Sarah Jessica Parker."

    2. JR

      (laughs)

    3. CP

      And I said this in New York. And in New York, Sarah Jessica Parker is worshiped like a god. And that whole crowd hissed and booed and did everything but throw excrement at me.

    4. JR

      Wow.

    5. CP

      But then later in line, half of them came up and whispered, "That was really funny."

    6. JR

      (laughs) Yeah, that's... Well, that's one of the things about dark comedy clubs. Y- You want them dark.

    7. CP

      Mm-hmm.

    8. JR

      You know? You don't want everyone illuminated. Like, the... When the, the crowd is... Like, the... When... It's one of the real issues with doing a comedy special is that, uh, especially the old way they used to do them, they used to like to light up the audience, which completely changes the dynamic of the, the room, changes what you'll laugh and what you won't laugh at.... you know, and a scene like the Sarah Ca- Sarah Jessica Parker joke. It's a perfect example. Like, you don't wanna be caught dead being the one person that throws their head back and howls at that.

    9. CP

      (clicks tongue) You know, cheap shots, uh, just, just stay away from them. But that's another... I'll ask you, ask you a question. You know, with so many colleges becoming these kind of strident, safe places that demand their own aesthetic, what is it like doing comedy?

    10. JR

      Well, it, it hasn't changed that much. People have gotten a little, gotten a little bit more sensitive because they're aware that other people are more sensitive. With the, the audiences that come to nightclubs, which is primarily where I perform... If I do a theater, those people are there to see me, so that's, they're, they're usually pretty loose, pretty fun. But if you're in a nightclub, they're there to see especially The Comedy Store. One of the good things about The Comedy Store is there's literally two dozen people in the lineup. They're not necessarily just there to see you. They're there to see Anthony Jeselnik and Chris D'Elia and all these other comedians that are also there as well. So you get a, uh, a real- a much broader comedy audience. But they're nightclub audiences. They have a few drinks in them. Maybe they smoked a little pot before they got there. Those people are there to have a good time. Colleges are a nightmare now.

    11. CP

      Hmm.

    12. JR

      It's a nightmare because it's recreational outrage. It's, it's kids who have been under the control of their parents for most of their life and haven't had their own sovereignty and identity and now they're free. And they, uh, are very quick to, uh, be outraged. They, they wanna point out their moral superiority. They wanna virtue signal on every opportunity. They wanna shut down anything they think is, air quotes, "problematic." They don't want things to go in a bad way, and they think for some reason that comedy should be uplifting, and it should only punch up. Like, I've, uh, I had this conversation once with a professor who wrote a book on comedy, and he said, "All great comedy punches up." And I said, "That's bullshit." I said, "One of the greatest bits of all time is Sam Kinnison's bit about starving children in Africa, about watching those commercials, where starving kids are in Africa and, you know, and the, 'Couldn't you please help?'" And he goes in... you know, and Kinnison's like, he just wanted to grab the guy with, "Hey, why don't you help them? You're right fucking there! Or send someone like me!" He goes, "Send someone like me, who's gonna take these people and go, 'Hey, we just drove here 5,000 miles with your food, and it occurred to us you wouldn't be world hungry if you people would live where the fucking food is!'" He goes, "Come here! You see that? That's sand! We got sand in America too! We just don't live in it, asshole!" And he's go- he goes, and one of the greatest bits of all time is literally about starving babies in Africa. It's one of the greatest bits of all time, and he didn't have anything to say. He didn't know where to go with it. I'm like, don't, don't say comedy is only about punching up. That's crazy talk. That's... What you're doing is you're f- you're... There's, there's a, this moral thing that they're trying to achieve that literally is completely independent of humor. It's not what's funny. It's like they're, they, they want to, they want it to be a, a multipurpose tool.

    13. CP

      Hmm.

    14. JR

      They want it to be funny as well as morally uplifting and great for people who are discriminated against and amazing for folks who are marginalized and uplifting for those who are disenfranchised. Well, that's not what comedy is. What comedy is, is funny. Those things are wonderful in ter- uh, if you wanna do a spoken word show or poetry or writing or, you know, a one-person play. Those, those are great. But that's not funny. Comedy is funny. So it's either funny or it's not funny. And some things are funny that are fucked up. You know, Kinnison had a bit about homosexual necrophiliacs who were paying money to spend, uh, a few hours undisturbed with the freshest male corpses. And he, so he would lie down on his stomach, and he goes, "You imagine these people? They're on the slabs. They're like, 'Well, (sighs) went through life and had a good time and everything, and now I guess I'm gonna go and be with Jesus, and hey, what the hell is this?'" And he's rocking back and forth. "'It feels like some guy's got his dick in my ass! You mean life keeps fucking you in the ass even after you're dead? It never ends! It never ends! Oh! Oh!'" He would close on it, 'cause it was th- he couldn't follow it. It was such a powerful bit. It was about a dead guy getting fucked in the ass. There is no further down that you could punch other than starving babies in Africa.

    15. CP

      (clicks tongue) You know, and I'm not sure about if this is punching down, but do you remember the s- the, the routine that kind of put Whoopi Goldberg on the map a million years ago about being a Black surfer chick?

    16. JR

      No.

    17. CP

      Oh, you know, she did it on television. I must have seen it on cable when I was, like, 19 years old. But she talks in valley speak. Nobody's seen this Whoopi person before. She's brand new. Nobody's ever seen her on television. She's got this funny name, and she's doing this valley speak about being the only Black surfer chick on the beach, and she loves surfing, and she loves this one white surfer guy, and she finally hooks up with him, and then she realizes she's pregnant, and it's all very funny. The whole front end, you're just roaring with laughter. And then then, she's pregnant, and she doesn't know what to do, so she gets a rusty wire coat hanger, and she goes into a public bathroom on the beach, and she gives herself a coat hanger abortion.

    18. JR

      (gasps)

    19. CP

      And it spills out there on the concrete floor. And everything's okay, and now I'm back on the beach, and I'm just doing fine, and, and why don't you come on down and see me here on the beach? It's great down here. It's great.

    20. JR

      Holy shit.

    21. CP

      It's a fantastic piece, and she-

    22. JR

      She did that on television?

    23. CP

      She did it on TV, and it started so light, like an Ira Levin novel...... and then it went to such a dark, horrible place. And then it came up with just this kind of token, everything is okay ending. Every- I'm gonna be all right.

    24. JR

      Don't worry.

    25. CP

      This is just something that happened.

    26. JR

      Be happy.

    27. CP

      (laughs) Yeah.

    28. JR

      Do, do, do, do, do.

    29. CP

      That it just leaves you shaken.

    30. JR

      Ah.

  6. 1:15:001:25:21

    How much does he…

    1. CP

      came through. And every time I requested them, the publisher said that they had been paid, but the accountant said that there were, uh, technical difficulties with wiring me the money or he had personal problems in his life caring for his mother. And so there was always some reason why the money never came through. And finally, um, I kind of... I told my agent I didn't want to do any more deals until we had this money thing resolved. And at that point, the accountant, uh, made a videotaped confession, and has since pled guilty, uh, and I believe his sentencing is gonna be in November. Um, but according to the district attorney, they can't seem to find any of the money. So, the money seems to be gone.

    2. JR

      How much does he steal?

    3. CP

      You know, it's kind of up in the air. It's, uh... Initially they said it was 3.5 million, and now they're saying it could be as much as 25 million. And this is from not just me. This is from Mario Puzo's estate, the man that wrote The Godfather. This is from a lot of different estates. Uh, the agency handled the estate of- of, uh, Lillian Hellman and Jacqueline Susann, and a lot of very big, big writers. Uh, Edward Gorey, who wrote those creepy, wonderful cartoon books. Uh, a lot of different writers, a lot of different estates lost money.

    4. JR

      So was this guy doing this from the jump or does this... somewhere along the line, he lost his mind?

    5. CP

      Nobody really knows.

    6. JR

      Yeah. Wow.

    7. CP

      Jamie, can you hit that pause button while I go out and take a leak?

    8. JR

      Just go out and take a leak.

    9. NA

      Okay.

    10. CP

      Oh, thank God.

    11. JR

      Go ahead. Don't worry about it, man. I know it's rough.

    12. CP

      Um-

    13. JR

      Get used to it, though.

    14. CP

      What, uh... Are we anywhere close to 3:30?

    15. JR

      We... No. It's, it's 2:30, but we can end any time you'd like.

    16. CP

      Oh, 3:30. No, 3:30 is kind of my, uh, drop dead.

    17. JR

      Okay.

    18. CP

      But, uh, I'll be right back.

    19. JR

      Okay. Uh, Neil deGrasse Tyson's here, ladies and gentlemen. He's waiting. He got here way early though, right?

    20. NA

      Yeah, he... That was the plan. He's just got some work to do before, so...

    21. JR

      Oh, okay. He's probably in the tank right now.

    22. NA

      Yeah, maybe.

    23. JR

      I hope. This dude's intense, right?

    24. NA

      Yeah, man.

    25. JR

      I can't believe I fucked up that original story.

    26. NA

      Yeah, that's all right. I was trying to look to see if it was someone else, but-

    27. JR

      I thought... Man, I really thought it was attributed to him. But that's me.

    28. NA

      Yeah.

    29. JR

      My fucked-up brain. He's intense, though.

    30. NA

      Yeah.

Episode duration: 2:07:03

Install uListen for AI-powered chat & search across the full episode — Get Full Transcript

Transcript of episode v8ZCX0eywXw

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.

Add to Chrome