Skip to content
The Joe Rogan ExperienceThe Joe Rogan Experience

Joe Rogan Experience #1478 - Joel Salatin

Joel Salatin is an American farmer, lecturer, and author whose books include Folks, This Ain’t Normal, You Can Farm and Salad Bar Beef. His latest book, co-authored with Dr. Sina McCullough, Beyond Labels: A Doctor and a Farmer Conquer Food Confusion One Bite at a Time is available for preorder now.

Joe RoganhostJoel Salatinguest
May 21, 20202h 9mWatch on YouTube ↗

EVERY SPOKEN WORD

  1. 0:011:43

    Pandemic stress test: local food thrives while industrial supply chains crack

    1. JR

      Good to see you again, sir.

    2. JS

      Good to be here-

    3. JR

      Thanks.

    4. JS

      ... thanks for coming back, man. I really appreciate it. This is a perfect time to talk to someone like you about, uh, our food. Um, we're in a very strange crisis now, and you just keep hearing time and time again in the news, uh, how much ranchers and farmers and people are really suffering right now. And how much folks who don't have anything to do with that are now forcing... They're, they're being forced to understand the, the importance of the food supply chain and ranchers and farmers, and all the stuff that we've taken for granted for quite a long time now. Well, they sure have, and what's interesting about it is the juxtaposition between the... I'll just call it the industrial, the, the more, you know, uh, commercial industrial food sector, versus the sector that I'm in, which is a, um, a, a local-centric, you know, uh, uh, direct, direct sale branded product, you know, directly from the farm. Uh, the pandemic is the best marketing strategy we've ever seen.

    5. JR

      (laughs)

    6. JS

      We're having, we're having the best season we've ever had, and, um, a- a- a- and, and, and the same thing was with farmers around the country as I talked to them. Uh, everyone that's like us, that, that, that did not go into the supermarket system basically-

    7. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    8. JS

      ... that, that's selling in their community, in their, in their region, regionally, uh, directly off the farm, having the best, best year we've ever had. It is the, it is the, um, it's the industrial, uh, mega-system that's cracking. And so for the first time, we're hearing talk of, "Well, maybe, maybe we need to add, uh, resiliency to efficiency." (laughs)

    9. JR

      Hmm.

  2. 1:432:38

    Processing bottlenecks: why meat plants became outbreak hotspots

    1. JS

      And so, um, so yeah. The, the, the system that's cracking, there's plenty of food. I mean, there's plenty of food on farms being r- produced. Uh, but of course as you know, milk is being dumped. Pigs are being euthanized. The problem is not at the farm level. The problem is in the chain of custody between the farmer and the consumer, and primarily in the, in the, uh, the large-scale processing, uh, situation.

    2. JR

      Yeah, these large meat processing places, uh, they, they've, they've been hit hard by the coronavirus.

    3. JS

      Th- they have been. I mean, if you think about it right now, Joe, probably, uh, in, in the, um, in the United States, the only places right now where every day thousands of people, um, come together in crowded conditions are these big meat processing plants. I mean, the offices are closed. The theaters are closed. (laughs)

    4. JR

      Mm-hmm.

  3. 2:387:19

    Small abattoir vs. mega plant: craftsmanship, safety, and contamination risk

    1. JS

      The convention centers are closed. Uh, a- and so the only place where people are coming shoulder to shoulder, thousands every day, are in these mega processing facilities. Uh, Therese and I, my wife, actually co-own a very small, um, abattoir, a slaughterhouse, uh, community slaughterhouse. We have 20 employees. And, um, and the, the differences, th- the difference in the vulnerability, in, in the exposure and risk factor between our little 20-person facility where we do, you know, maybe, um, 50 to 70 beeves a week, 100 hogs, versus these mega-plants that have, you know-

    2. JR

      When you say beeves? What, what-

    3. JS

      Beeves, like beef.

    4. JR

      What is that?

    5. JS

      Beef. Um-

    6. JR

      Oh, beeves.

    7. JS

      Yeah. Well-

    8. JR

      Oh, I thought you said beeves. I was like, "What is it?"

    9. JS

      There's no such word, there's no such word as beeves. It's beeves, B-E-E-V-E-S.

    10. JR

      Oh, okay.

    11. JS

      (laughs)

    12. JR

      That is what you're saying. Okay.

    13. JS

      Yeah, beeves. Um-

    14. JR

      Beeves. Have you heard that before, Jamie? (laughs) No. Okay.

    15. JS

      S- so the plural of beef is not beeves. It's beeves.

    16. JR

      Oh, all right.

    17. JS

      Interesting, right? Uh-

    18. JR

      I always thought that beef was just-

    19. JS

      (laughs)

    20. JR

      ... the meat. I never thought... I, I would have assumed you would say cows.

    21. JS

      Well, uh, as a farmer, cows are, are females who have had calves.

    22. JR

      Right.

    23. JS

      So it's a very... As opposed to steers-

    24. JR

      Oh, steers. Right.

    25. JS

      ... who would be cal- or bulls, which would be intact males.

    26. JR

      Mm-hmm. Right.

    27. JS

      Steers are non-intact. So as a farmer, all this nomenclature is real, you know... It's, uh-

    28. JR

      Yes. Normal for you.

    29. JS

      It, it, it's real... Like, like a theologian teases out, you know, Presbyterians and Methodists and, and, uh, we just say, "Well, they're Protestants." (laughs) So, so, um, so... You know-

    30. JR

      So you own a small place.

  4. 7:198:26

    Density as a design flaw: decentralizing processing for resilience

    1. JS

      ... you know? So, you know, for sure, um, we don't know a lot about this virus. For, I mean, we're learning every day and, you know, you gotta kinda take a little bit, a grain of salt too. Um, but one of the things we're certainly learning is that there's an advantage, th- that there is a density factor, a people density factor.

    2. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    3. JS

      Like, an urban rural, uh, you know, uh, uh, spreading out, the whole social distancing, spreading out thing, is, is, is, um, seems to be a valuable thing. And so if we take that into the food system, wouldn't it be an amazing thing if instead of having 150 to 200 mega processing facilities doing 98% of the nation's meat, uh, if instead that were 200,000 small scale, community based, ecologically nested facilities, ch- ch- ch- ch- you know, all around the countryside, that would be an incredibly, uh, resilient system.

  5. 8:2611:10

    Regenerative farming ethos: letting animals express their ‘pigness’ and ‘chickenness’

    1. JR

      Well, it sounds like a much better system. Like, as you, you were talking before about your relationship with your customers, it's a direct to farm. I mean, that's really ideal, right? Cut out the middle person. There's, you cut out the confusion of whether or not the animals are ethically raised or ethically slaughtered, like, what are the conditions they're living under? I mean, you're, uh, Polyface Farms, right? It's got-

    2. JS

      Yeah.

    3. JR

      That, that whole video that you have, that ex- that I've seen, that explains-

    4. JS

      Mm-hmm.

    5. JR

      ... the way you do regenerative farming and you let these animals live the way these animals are supposed to live. They're not confined to cages, they're roaming around, they're eating natural foods. And y- you get a better product, you get a healthier product, and you get a better relationship with both the animals and the people that you sell this, this food to.

    6. JS

      Well, sure. A- and, and ultimately what we're looking for is a habitat that allows, uh, you know, each life form, whether it's a plant or an animal, to fully express, w- we call it, you know, expressing the pigness of the pig-

    7. JR

      Right.

    8. JS

      ... or the chickenness of the chicken. You could say the tomatleness of the tomato, you know? Uh, and, and creating a habitat that allows that life, um, that life to express its, you know, i- i- its, its, uh, what, phenotypical and physiological distinctiveness. Um, i- in humans, we would call this self-affirmation, you know?

    9. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    10. JS

      The, the, the, the Tomness of Tom, the Joeness of Joe, right? Uh, i- i- it's that a- affirmation. And, um, a- and one of the things that we're seeing, uh, as a result, as we move into the, kind of the social consequences of this whole, uh, uh, uh, pandemic, is a, um, is, is, uh, well, there's, there's a new phrase called, um, the Screen New Deal, where everything is going to AI, we're gonna, you know, we're, we're, we're dehumanizing. And so at a very time when people need to be personally affirmed, they're being denied their, (laughs) y- you know, their, their, their social humanity, uh-

    11. JR

      Yeah.

    12. JS

      ... element. I mean, y- you can't even see whether a person's smiling or frowning.

    13. JR

      Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's the worst part about this, other than the, the tragedies.

    14. JS

      Yes.

    15. JR

      The, the worst part about this-

    16. JS

      Yes.

    17. JR

      ... is that, like, people aren't getting hugged, people are scared-

    18. JS

      Right.

    19. JR

      ... to shake hands. Everyone's separated from everybody. It's just very strange.

    20. JS

      It is. It is. A- and, and, uh, you know, our, our, our personal energy that we get from each other, uh, you know, I've, uh, like you, I'm sure, I, I've done numerous Zoom things la- l- lately, more (laughs) than ever. Zoom conferences, Zoom phone conferences, different things. And, uh, there's just not the energy. There's just-

    21. JR

      No.

    22. JS

      ... there's just not, you just don't get the energy that you get when you're-

    23. JR

      Right in front of each other.

    24. JS

      ... yeah, absolutely.

  6. 11:1016:54

    Pause for COVID test, then immunity: microbiome, exposure, and fear as a health cost

    1. JR

      I feel the same way about podcasts and, you know, Jamie, I screwed up.

    2. JS

      (clears throat)

    3. JR

      I forgot the nurse. Yeah, it's fine. We started early. Yeah, you wanna-

    4. JS

      Yeah.

    5. JR

      ... we can pause and stop it. Can we? I mean, yeah, yeah, we can. It's, yeah.

    6. JS

      Okay.

    7. JR

      We're gonna, we, we have, we wanna give you a coronavirus test.

    8. JS

      Okay.

    9. JR

      You down with that?

    10. JS

      That's fine.

    11. JR

      All right, we'll pause right here. Okay. So we, uh, did your little test and, uh, found out you have not had it. You didn't fight it off.

    12. JS

      Bummer. (laughs)

    13. JR

      But the doctor did explain to us that there is primary immune system and there's secondary immune system. Your primary immune system most likely, if you've been in contact with it, and his has, you know, his, he's, uh, the doctor's been around many, many people that have had it. But, uh, your primary immune system, if you're healthy, he was saying fights it off. Your secondary immune system is if you have had it, the infection, and your body has developed those antibodies as your second line of defense. So most likely, your first line of defense, since you have been in contact with people that have had it, your first line of defense beat it.

    14. JS

      Well, that's cool.

    15. JR

      Yeah.

    16. JS

      Well, I, I, I work on it. (laughs)

    17. JR

      Yeah, we were talking about that.

    18. JS

      (laughs)

    19. JR

      And I said, "Please save this."

    20. JS

      (laughs)

    21. JR

      Because it's so crazy. You, you drink... Explain what you do-

    22. JS

      Yes, so, yes.

    23. JR

      ... to strengthen your immune system.

    24. JS

      So, you know, and this whole thing, like you, I've been, I've been screaming, "Let's talk about the immune system." You know?

    25. JR

      Yes.

    26. JS

      So, so, um, I, I literally, I literally have not been, um, sick a day basically in 20 years. I mean, not the flu, not a cold, not... I mean, just nothing. Um, and, and I'm 60, 63. So, um, I'm not saying that arrogantly or proudly. I'm saying it gratefully that, uh, that I, I think there are things that we can do to really build up our immune system. One of the things that I do (laughs) that kind of makes all my staff laugh is that I routinely bend down with the cows and drink the, drink water out of the cow tank. Um, I don't drink it when it's pond water, although I've drunk pond water. But when it's-

    27. JR

      (laughs)

    28. JS

      ... you know, when it's, when it's like well water, you know, when it's fairly clean water, I get down. Of course, you know, the cows are dripping saliva and stuff in it, you know, and I just drink right out of it just like a cow. And I, I'm serious, you know, I believe that that, that... What? It, it, it builds your microbiome, you know? I want all those bugs, all that diversity. We, we live in the most amazing microscopic soup. I mean, it's, it's just... It's a soup. If you could take an electromagnetic photograph of, of, of the air, um, of, of where we are, I mean, the very... I mean, our skin is exuding stuff. Um, y- you know, our, our noses, our, our, our clothes, everything, we're... It would, it would look like a, uh... It would look like the, uh, the cloud over Pigpen in the Peanuts comic strip, you know?

    29. JR

      (laughs)

    30. JS

      I mean, that's literally what we're living in. And, and, and, uh, all of this life, all of, you know, bacter- viruses, bacteria, um, um, microorganisms, all of this life is, is literally having, uh, a conversation. "Hey, uh, you know, I'd like to hook onto you in a symbiotic relationship." "Hey, man, I'm a parasite. I'm gonna take you down," you know? (laughs)

  7. 16:5421:37

    Population health reality: obesity, diet, and the missing public message on immune strength

    1. JR

      I think one of the things that you said, though, when you said most of us that are healthy, I think that's not really true. I think most of us are not healthy.

    2. JS

      (laughs)

    3. JR

      And I think that's one of the things we're finding out from this crisis.

    4. JS

      Yes.

    5. JR

      Is that when you talk about protecting vulnerable people, there's a lot of us that are vulnerable. Maybe not you or me.

    6. JS

      Right.

    7. JR

      But a large number of people that are overweight, that eat poor food, and that don't take care of themselves.

    8. JS

      Yes.

    9. JR

      And those people are particularly vulnerable. And so they're right to be afraid, but they're wrong to think that this... The only way to solve this is to make sure that you stay away from everybody. The way to solve this is to stop eating shit and become a healthy person. It's-

    10. JS

      Right.

    11. JR

      While you're alive, there's always a... There's a moment, a chance to be healthier while you're alive. If you're alive- (laughs) ... and you're not terribly ill and dying, then you could start drinking water, stop drinking soda, stop eating chips, start eating fruits and vegetables, start eating lean meats, healthy foods. Not even lean meats. Eat, eat a good rib eye steak.

    12. JS

      Pastured-

    13. JR

      Yeah.

    14. JS

      ... pastured meats.

    15. JR

      Yeah.

    16. JS

      Pastured meats.

    17. JR

      Eat food.

    18. JS

      But yeah, you're right. Well, uh, you know-... whenever I watch a newscast and watch the, you know, the daily, uh, like, you know, coronavirus briefing-

    19. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    20. JS

      ... from the White House, right? And you've got all these experts standing around, and they're... And, and everybody's standing there waiting for this magic, um, vaccine.

    21. JR

      Right.

    22. JS

      And, (clears throat) of course, you know, the CDC gets, uh, $4.6 billion a year selling vaccines. They have, whatever, 20, uh, patent vaccines. Um, and, and so really, the CDC is, is a very vested interest in trying to develop a vaccine. There, there's, there's a lot of money in sickness. Yeah, there's a lot of money in sickness. And so, so, you know, we didn't get this, this, uh, coronavirus because of a lack of vaccine. (laughs) We got this coronavirus because something in this, in this beautiful life bath that I described was out of whack. Uh, that's, that... Now, you know, we can, we can start discussing where it possibly came from. I think right now that's conjecture. Uh, I mean, I think we, we do know that it came out of Wuhan, but, but, you know-

    23. JR

      Right.

    24. JS

      ... just how we... I mean, we're not sure. But, but the fact is, that there was an imbalance in life. And just like in your... in, in our lifetime, Joe, we've learned, uh, to say words that when I was a child, did you ever hear the term, you know, salmonella, E. coli, Campylobacter, um, uh, bovine spongiform encephalopathy, uh, uh, food allergy even? I mean, how many kids in elementary school did you know that had food allergies?

    25. JR

      None.

    26. JS

      None.

    27. JR

      Yeah.

    28. JS

      Nobody. You, you, you have a birthday party? Mom isn't having to email... We didn't have email back then, but Mom isn't calling all the other mothers saying, "Well now, what can your child eat and what can, what can your little Mary have?" And, you know, "Oh, pea-... Oh, we better not have any peanuts." And I mean, that didn't exist. A- and what's happened... The way I look at this is that, that humanity, that we, as collective humanity, we've essentially taken this, this beautiful benevolent Earth, this benevolent, (sighs) uh, sustainer, partner, m- mentor, uh, uh, abundant provider, and taken it, taken this partner to the boxing ring. (laughs)

    29. JR

      Hmm.

    30. JS

      And, and instead of caressing this abundant, wonderful partner provider, we've pummeled it and pummeled it. We've, we've, we've pulled the water out of its aquifers. We've, we've destroyed its soil. We've, we've put a dead zone the size of the, uh, Rhode Island in the Gulf of Mexico. We've, uh, we've used antibiotics in animals and made MRSA and C. diff and superbugs. And, and, and so nature has been gently, gently begging for, for relief as we've essentially, you know, put our fuck- uh, put our foot on her neck, right?

  8. 21:3724:49

    Factory farms as pathogen incubators: unnatural confinement and disease pressure

    1. JR

      Yeah. And I think a, a real parallel is when you were talking about th- these large-scale meat processing plants are a, a perfect sort of Petri dish for viruses to grow, so are factory farms, so are these farms where you're stuffing pigs next to each other. You're doing all this unnatural stuff, right? It's unnatural for people to be stuffed into a warehouse right next to each other, shoulder to shoulder, working all day. It's unnatural for them to be stuffed in these homes, shoulder to shoulder, bad food and, and all the things that you would need to keep your body healthy and strong. The same can be said about these factory farm situ- situations. One thing that I- I find so attractive about the way you run your farm is that there's no weirdness in watching these animals during the day. They, they seem like animals just doing normal stuff. If you see a chicken wandering around just pecking at the grass, looks normal. See a chicken in a cage-

    2. JS

      (laughs)

    3. JR

      ... getting fed out of, of a little cup or something, it does- it looks all kinds of fucked up, right?

    4. JS

      (laughs)

    5. JR

      It doesn't feel right.

    6. JS

      No, no.

    7. JR

      Right? Right?

    8. JS

      That's, that's why we, you know, we, um, we have the phrase, uh, respecting the pigness of the pig-

    9. JR

      Yes.

    10. JS

      ... and the chickeness of the chicken.

    11. JR

      And we know that these-

    12. JS

      (clears throat)

    13. JR

      ... diseases are all coming from these place... I mean, there's a, a ton of agricultural diseases, you know, that are based from these factory farm-

    14. JS

      Yes.

    15. JR

      ... situations where these animals live in these really horrific conditions and then the bacteria jump and-

    16. JS

      Look, I mean, they're, they're, they're e- Look, if you ate in your toilet every-

    17. JR

      (laughs)

    18. JS

      ... you know, would you like to eat your toilet every day?

    19. JR

      Good point. (laughs) Right, exactly.

    20. JS

      Uh, that's, that's how they eat. You're... They're breathing in their fecal particulate matter, which is, um, you know, uh, uh, putting lesions in their, uh, tender respiratory membranes, uh, uh, making, making, uh, lesions there. Uh, a- and, and so wh- when you have those kinds of conditions... And, and they're not getting exercise, they're not getting fresh air. And so, uh, I mean, the, the, they're not getting salad, they're not getting any vitamin D from the sunshine. (laughs)

    21. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    22. JS

      Uh, and, uh, and so what happens is you get an extremely concentrated host, host facility for pathogenicity.

    23. JR

      Hmm.

    24. JS

      Tha- that's what happens. You get a very concentrated host facility because there's always a host, they're close to each other, the pathogen doesn't have to say, "Wow, boy, I, I wonder if I can make it that, you know, that half mile over to another..." No, no, they're, you know, they're always right there and so you're right, it- it's like, it's like an incubator. And so, you know, if, if we wanted to sit down... Look, if we wanted to sit down and say-... let, let's say we had a James Bond, uh, conspiracist, you know, uh, and said, "We're gonna form a committee and, uh, and make a pathogen-friendly farm." (laughs) You know-

    25. JR

      (laughs)

    26. JS

      ... the ol- the old, uh, James Bond nemesis, right? And so we form a committee to say, "How can we make a pathogen-friendly farm?" Well, we would have only one species. We'd crowd it up. We'd take out the oxygen, the, the fresh air, the sunshine. We'd give it, we'd, we'd give it a, a minimal, a minimalistic diet. Uh, what I've just described is modern, efficient, industrial factory farming. Y- you couldn't design a better system, uh, uh, for, for, uh, conductivity of pathogenicity.

  9. 24:4930:27

    Can regenerative methods feed big cities? Processing, labor needs, and realistic tradeoffs

    1. JR

      Now, here's the big question. Is it possible to feed all of Los Angeles using your methods? Can you, can you feed-

    2. JS

      (clears throat)

    3. JR

      ... big urban areas-

    4. JS

      Sure.

    5. JR

      ... using these regenerative methods?

    6. JS

      Sure. Absolutely. So, uh, so, so two things to realize is the, the bottleneck in the food system right now, the reason the supermarket is low on meat is not because there aren't animals in the field. It's because of the pro- the processing is the bott- it's not the trucking. It's not the production. It's not even the, it's not even the store shelf. It's, it's the processing. So it's the processing that's the bottleneck. And so, uh, so, so my vision is that (clears throat) so, so, so we ... so two questions. First of all, let's deal with the production. Uh, with the production, absolutely if we, if we spread out the production, i- i- if we, if we did, for example, you know, uh, i- i- if we took all the confinement chicken houses and put those chickens on pasture, no problem. Okay? It doesn't take any more land to grow the feed for a chicken on pasture than it does in a confinement house.

    7. JR

      Don't you get a lot more loss, though, due to r- raptors and things along those lines?

    8. JS

      No.

    9. JR

      Coyotes.

    10. JS

      No, no. We, we put 'em, we put 'em in, uh, in little, uh, protected shelters. Uh, then we move 'em every day across the pasture. Well, yeah, you, you can get losses from, from raptors, but we use guard geese, there are guard dogs, guard llamas. There's all sorts of guard animals. There's, there's really cool, uh ... and there's, and there's a lot of, uh, research being done to jam the radar of, you know, eagles and stuff. There are, I mean, uh ...

    11. JR

      Really?

    12. JS

      Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

    13. JR

      They jam the rad- I didn't even know they had radar.

    14. JS

      (laughs) Well, that's figurative. Uh-

    15. JR

      Right, what are they using when they, when they, when an eagle ... it's just not just ... their vision's insanely good, right?

    16. JS

      Yeah. It, it-

    17. JR

      Eagles in particular.

    18. JS

      It, it really is. It really is. And so, for example (clears throat) , I know one guy that's, uh, he's, uh, it, it's not, it's not ready to sell yet, but he claims to have had great success, um, putting reflective, uh, Coke can bottoms on, like, a traffic cone, hanging it out with his chickens and that splays the sun rays all out and messes up the eyesight of the, of the eagles and the hawks. They, they can't zero in.

    19. JR

      Really?

    20. JS

      Yeah. In, in fact, this was exactly, um, one of the defensive measures the US Navy used, and still uses, for incoming missiles, that they, they, they have a cannon that blows out pieces of, um, aluminum foil, basically, and it ... like, graffiti, aluminum foil graffiti out into the air, and it jams the, whatever, the, you know, the, the honing devices of a, of a missile.

    21. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    22. JS

      (smacks lips) The, the hawks are the same way. What I'm getting at is that there, there are ... we don't lose very much. We protect them, uh, greatly. There are a lot of things that you can do to, you know, to mitigate that kind of, of pressure. But, but the fact is, the industry loses tons of birds too, in a flood, in a heatwave, in a whatever, you know? And, uh, and so the idea that these birds in this big confinement house are actually protected from malady is, is simply not, is simply not true.

    23. JR

      T- then they're gonna be ... much more of them are gonna get sick and-

    24. JS

      Sure. Sure.

    25. JR

      ... yeah, it's in-

    26. JS

      Sure. Sure.

    27. JR

      They might have losses in that way.

    28. JS

      Sure. Sure. So, so can we produce, can we produce the food this way? Absolutely. Now, one of the things that it would require is many more people on farms. So, you know, I've thought a lot about, um, o- obviously as unemployment has skyrocketed through this. (smacks lips) Right now, sitting here, it's hard for us to imagine what it'll take to bring, you know, f- to fill football stadiums again, to f- (laughs) you know-

    29. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    30. JS

      ... to fill Caribbean cruises, to fill theaters, um, you know, uh, music venues, you know, um, whatever, boxing matches. I mean, it, uh ... right now, it- it's hard to conceive what it'll take. People are so terrified. It's hard to appreciate how much of this is gonna come back, the hospitality industry and all that. So, so, so what's gonna happen? So, so where are the jobs? W- what are people gonna do? And, and I would suggest that one of the things that, that people can do is that we can have a lot of these smaller plants and we have a way more people actually growing food, participating in food production personally. Is food gonna be more expensive? Maybe so. But you get to be healthy, and we have a healthy planet, and what's that worth? And-

  10. 30:2743:36

    Hidden costs and regulatory barriers: externalities, paperwork, and the PRIME Act

    1. JR

      And it also ... Would it be fair to say that food prices might go to where they should be? Like a- a cheeseburger really shouldn't be 99 cents.

    2. JS

      No, no. A- absolutely. Uh, the, the ... As, as you're very familiar with the argument of the externalized cost.

    3. JR

      Yeah.

    4. JS

      They don't, they don't get captured. What's, what's the cost, you know ... Right now, 50% of the cases of diarrhea in the US are caused by, uh, foodborne, you know, bacteria. Well, what's a, what's a case of diarrhea worth? You know, I mean, if we start-

    5. JR

      Right.

    6. JS

      (laughs) If you, if you start ... (laughs)

    7. JR

      Yeah. That's a good point. Very good point.

    8. JS

      If you start putting dollars on these externalized costs, you know, a r- ... The, the dead zone in the, in the Gulf of Mexico, the fact that we have, you know, squ- ... Uh, uh, uh, hundreds of square miles that don't grow shrimp anymore.

    9. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    10. JS

      You know, because it's, it's toxic from the runoff from the Mississippi, uh, from, from chemical farming. So there's, there's a lot of these externalized costs. And not only that, but if this actually became norma- ... Uh, the, the, whatever, the new way, the new orthodoxy, uh, there would be definitely economies of scale that we don't have right now. Um, I mean, I'll just give you one example that probably nobody would think of. So we play, we pay workman's compensation at our farm. So how do you determine the exposure level, the risk factor of a poultry worker? I mean, think about if, if you have a Tyson chicken farm and you hire a, a, a, a, an employee to be in the chicken house, think about his workman's comp risk. I mean, there's fecal particulate all day long that he's breathing. Uh, you've got augers, chains, feed bins, electrical connections, dust. I mean, it's, it's a very ... Um, it's a high-risk situation. For us, a poultry worker goes (laughs) out in the field and moves some, moves some chickens in a field. There's no fecal particulate, there's no dust, there's no, uh, you know, uh, uh, uh, it ... There's no augers, there's no, um, uh, whatever, spinning fans, uh, vent shafts. You know, there's none of this. A- and so, so part of the cost, the reason that our chicken is more expensive than what's in the store, is not only externalized cost, but it is, it is unrecognized, unrecognized savings that we offer that can't be captured in a, a square peg in a round hole.

    11. JR

      Mm. I see what you're saying. Yeah. The l- the overall big picture of health for you, health for the food. How much is that worth? Yeah.

    12. JS

      Right.

    13. JR

      That's interesting that we're not really taking into consideration these secondary costs that come about from doing it the wrong way.

    14. JS

      Yeah.

    15. JR

      Yeah.

    16. JS

      We're not. We're not. Uh, I mean, there's, there's a lot of those ... (sighs) Uh, you, you can ... Much of, much of our increased cost has nothing to do with actual production cost. It's, it's the non-scalable regulatory overheads. Uh, a- and, and this, and this, of course, is why we don't have more community small-scale abattoirs around the country. Uh, is not because there's not a demand for them, it's because the, the, the paperwork, the HACCP plans, hazardous analysis critical control point plans, and the paperwork to be able to launch a business like this require the ... are so high that the, the ... both time and money are so high that it's very difficult to launch a small business.

    17. JR

      Mm.

    18. JS

      You know, 'cause you can't spread the overhead, uh, of capitalization over-

    19. JR

      Is there a solution to that?

    20. JS

      ... uh, uh, uh, nothing.

    21. JR

      Is it ...

    22. JS

      Well, uh, there's a, there are a couple solutions. Uh, certainly one, one that's, um, that's being championed right now by Congressman Thomas Massie called the PRIME Act. He's had it in for five years, and, uh, amazingly, it's kind of just floundered for five years. All of a sudden, in the last two months, he's got 18 new co-sponsors-

    23. JR

      Mm.

    24. JS

      ... because of this. And what the PRIME Act would do, it would allow, it would allow uninspected custom-processed meat in state to be sold by the piece. That's not legal right now. Right now, the only way that you can sell a T-bone ... If you want to buy a T-bone steak from me, the only way for you to get it is for me to go to a federal-inspected slaughterhouse, get the animal processed, packaged under inspection, and put in for you. Custom houses are where if you want to buy a half a beef, a quarter beef, all right, and it goes in with your name on that quarter and they're custom processing it for me, yeah, then, you know, then I can buy it. And what, what Congressman Massie is saying with the PRIME Act is, why should we discriminate and only allow people to tap into the lower cost and lower, lower, uh, uh, overheads of the custom processing facility to only those people who can afford to buy a quarter of beef at a time? That's, that's very poverty discriminatory. Let's open that up so that people can buy it by the piece. We're not gonna ship it interstate, we're not gonna sell it at Walmart, okay? There's ... But if you and I, as neighbors (laughs) , want to do business together as ... uh, and I'm using a powerful phrasing here, as consenting adults, if we want to exercise freedom of joy, uh, of choice, and participate in a consensual relationship of commerce, why should that be a bureaucrat's-... uh, uh, business between, you know, between two consenting neighbors.

    25. JR

      Right. So what you're saying is, is long- but is the, the regulatory process in place to make sure that people are using the proper sanitation methods, making sure that the animals are healthy, making sure that all these things are in place so that unscrupulous characters don't take advantage of the system and then screw over the consumer and then the consumer gets sick? Like, this is, like, best case scenario for the regulation, right? That it's there to protect us.

    26. JS

      Well, that's, that's the, um, that's the assumption, yes.

    27. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    28. JS

      Um, and, and I would simply ask, uh, that at some point when you have a very close, transparent relationship, one-on-one, you don't, you don't have, you know, truckers and warehouses and big slaughterhouses and, and, and, you know, supermarkets, blah, blah, blah in between us. There is, there is a, a lot of protection in that relational transaction that beats all the paperwork you can amass on the industrial scale. We, we recognize scale in a lot of things in life. For example, in Virginia where I'm from, if you wanna open a... If you wanna do daycare, let's say you wanna do a, a work at home deal, you know, you wanna do a side gig and, and, and keep children, you can keep up to three in your home without subjecting yourself to the licensing and compliance of daycare regulations. Because they know if all you're gonna do is keep three in your homes, those parents, you're gonna have a close relationship with them. It's, it's... This is not a, this is not a daycare center, all right?

    29. JR

      Right.

    30. JS

      All right? The same thing is true with eldercare. Uh, my wife's grandmother spent her last year in a lady's home who is allowed to keep three people as eldercare. She was an RN. She wanted to not have to go to the hospital every day, and started a side gig in her home. She cooked for them, she took care of them, three of them in her home.

  11. 43:361:19:01

    Land-use myths: factory farms hide their land footprint; integration beats segregation

    1. JR

      Is it... O- o- what... Is it a land issue, though? Like if you wanted a... Like the, the factory farms that I've seen in videos, where they have these pigs-

    2. JS

      Mm-hmm.

    3. JR

      ... they're stuffed next to each other-

    4. JS

      Right.

    5. JR

      ... in this large warehouse, and the same with the chickens.

    6. JS

      Right.

    7. JR

      How much space would you need to have the same amount of chickens and the same amount of pigs-

    8. JS

      Right.

    9. JR

      ... you know, if you let them free-range?

    10. JS

      All right. Here's, here's my point. What you don't see in those videos is you don't see the hundreds of acres growing corn and soybeans (smacks lips) to feed them in that house. The industry wants you to think that this is some sort of a, a... you know, a, a... an island, you know, where, where, "Boy, look, we're cranking this out of this house." They're not showing you the tractor trailers bringing in the grain, bringing in the f- and hauling out the manure and the square miles of, of fields to spread the manure, okay? They're not showing you how dependent that is on this massive land base. And so, so on... in the pastured model, the decentralized pastured model, instead of having 15,000 ch- I mean, our farm, we're, we're gonna raise like 45,000 chickens this summer. We're not, we're not backyard, by any means. But guess what? Those are in 200 75-bird shelters that are moved every day across pastures. It doesn't take one more acre to produce the feed or handle the manure whether the chicken is outside or inside. The difference is, when you come and see our operation, you see all the land.

    11. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    12. JS

      When you see the, the factory farm, you don't see any of the land.

    13. JR

      But isn't it possible that these factory farms are set up where the farms where the animals are raised are completely separate, it's a separate business from the farms where the soybeans and the corn are raised-

    14. JS

      Oh, yeah. Well, ours is too.

    15. JR

      ... and it's not on the same property?

    16. JS

      No, it's... Ours is too.

    17. JR

      Right.

    18. JS

      We, we, we buy, we buy our grain from neighbors. Absolutely. We, we-

    19. JR

      Right. But if they had to grow these animals and grow that food, would they have enough land to do everything together in the same farm?

    20. JS

      But there's no need to do it on the same farm. I'm a big believer in mutual, mutual interdependence.

    21. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    22. JS

      Uh, not complete independence. We don't have any intention to grow our own grain. We, we don't have the soils for it, we don't have the equipment for it, we don't have the skillset for it. So we buy from neighbors who do GMO-free, non-genetically modified, GMO-free grain, uh, and, and we give them more than they would on a commodity, on a commodity scale. Um, and so they love us because we're giving them more per bushel and they have a nice secure buyer and they're local, they're close. Uh, you know, we're not getting it from, you know, uh, foreign countries and it's all close. So what happens is, in, in the kind of this, uh, situation I'm describing, instead of having a fundamentally segregated food system, you have a fundamentally integrated food system.

    23. JR

      I see what you're saying. So you have a-

    24. JS

      That's, that's what happens.

    25. JR

      ... strong relationship-

    26. JS

      Yeah.

    27. JR

      ... with the people growing that grain.

    28. JS

      So, so for example, I mean, you started the discussion with, "Can Los Angel- you know, is there enough land to feed Los Angeles?" You know, the, the... uh, and, and we, and we could discuss whether there's... whether Los Angeles should be as big as it is. I mean, that, that's a valid discussion, but-

    29. JR

      It's a very valid discussion.

    30. JS

      But, but, but l- l- uh, we, we can go there, but first let me just say that if California, for example, did not export, I don't know what the percentage is, but it's huge, you know, almonds, uh, uh, all over the world. If California's centered on feeding California, there's absolutely enough here to feed California. Okay? I mean, Iowa, Iowa imports 90%. Iowa is probably the most fertile place in the world and they only eat... Only, only 10% of the food consumed in Iowa is grown in Iowa and processed in Iowa.

  12. 1:19:011:23:17

    Soil, water, and carbon: composting, forestry ‘fertilizer factories,’ and wildfire prevention

    1. JS

      They don't make their money on gas. But anyway, um, so, so one of the things that, that we're, uh, key on because, uh, our fertility program is carbon. Okay? That's what feeds the soil, carbon. Right? Not 10-10-10 chemical fertilizer. Carbon. And so, at our-

    2. JR

      Do you use fertilizers at all?

    3. JS

      No. No, we don't.

    4. JR

      That's amazing.

    5. JS

      We don't.

    6. JR

      So just manure and-

    7. JS

      But-

    8. JR

      ... natural fertilizers.

    9. JS

      But we have a big industrial chipper. You'd love this machine. (laughs) I mean, it's the ultimate, you know, boy toy. You know, it, it's, it's a 120 horsepower diesel engine that can, that can chip 19-inch... You can take a 40-foot tree and just huck it in there, and it just (imitates machine noise) , you know, it just chips that-

    10. JR

      I've seen those online.

    11. JS

      All right. Well, I mean, they're, they're like the ult-, they're, they're the coolest machines. All right.

    12. JR

      That scares the shit out of me.

    13. JS

      S- all right. So, so, but, but that's, that, that-

    14. JR

      Remember Fargo?

    15. JS

      (laughs) That, that's our fertilizer factory.

    16. JR

      Oh.

    17. JS

      Th- that, that, okay, so carbon... So, so we integrate forest with open land, and, and we integrate the carbon, uh, from the forest. So we cut junk trees, dead trees, crooked trees, weak trees, and thin the forest, and that enables the good trees, the healthy trees, to grow more vigorously, better, reduces fire, uh, potential because you're, you know, you're thinning it out, taking out all the dead stuff. And that then becomes our carbon base for bedding the animals, for, you know, and for all the composting that we do. And we do, you know, mountains and mountains of compost. Where I'm going with this is, when we talk about costs, right now, how much is our country spending fighting wildfires? And how much are we losing fighting all these fi- and, I mean, we're in California. Right? I mean, look at the, the devastation that fires have caused. Imagine, imagine if those... if we had thousands of people with chippers thinning the forest, turning them into almost park-like, like they were before the Europeans came. The Native Americans kept them going with, you know, with fire, but there were, there was mega fauna here. Mega fauna. And so we graze through, we convert a lot of it into, you know, silvopasture, widely spaced trees that are growing unimpeded, uh, with, with grazing animals underneath so that there's no fire damage, there's no buildup of fuel. And suddenly, we're producing our own food and we're eliminating the danger of wildfire with technology called chainsaws and chippers. And that carbon becomes the fertility for the vineyards and the, and the, the agricultural lands. It feeds the soil, so now we have earthworms instead of hard soil. We don't have erosion because our organic matter is up. On our farm, using these principles, we've gone in... we've gone from 1% organic matter to over 8% organic matter in the soil, and every 1% holds another 20,000 gallons of water per acre.

    18. JR

      Whoa.

    19. JS

      So, so, if we... (laughs) So if we... so, uh, in, in our 60 years of being there in Neshano at polyphase, um, we have gone from 1% to eight- over to 8%. Let's just say that's seven clicks. Seven times 20 is 140,000 gallons of water per acre now that we can hold that we couldn't hold before. And it's because of the grazing, the perennials, and the composting that's building up the organic matter in the soil. That could be done in California. When you start talking about holding water, it's not just about how much rainfall are we getting, it's how much are we actually holding in, in the sponge-

    20. JR

      Right.

    21. JS

      ... uh, to reduce, you know, flooding and runoff and things like that.

    22. JR

      So it sounds like your method could keep from, uh, b- the situation they find with some farms of eroding topsoil where they-

    23. JS

      Right.

    24. JR

      ... have to s- constantly supplement.

    25. JS

      Right.

  13. 1:23:171:46:30

    Rethinking corn/monocrops: food waste, circular systems, and urban chickens

    1. JR

      But how would you... how do you grow enough corn? Like, if you wanna have, like, those monocrop agricultural fields-

    2. JS

      Mm-hmm.

    3. JR

      ... where you see hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of acres of corn, just corn, or just soybeans, or just alfalfa, whatever it is. Like, if you wanna do those monocrop things, you... how are you going to re-fertilize the soil in the same manner with that large a scale?

    4. JS

      You don't have them. You don't have them.

Episode duration: 2:09:16

Install uListen for AI-powered chat & search across the full episode — Get Full Transcript

Transcript of episode 4-7O3fOXXKo

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.