Simon SinekWhy Young People Don't Have 'The Hunger' for Work (And What Leaders Need to Hear) | Dr. Eliza Filby
EVERY SPOKEN WORD
60 min read · 11,979 words- 0:00 – 1:41
Rethinking The Generational Divide at Work
- SSSimon Sinek
Young people come into your office and be like, "Give me a raise and you'll see what I can do."
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
And older generations are like, "Pay you before you do it? What?"
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
[laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
But I think they have it right. Because there's no guarantee that they're gonna have a job by the end of the year because of layoffs-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
The biggest question that leaders need to ask themselves is h- what am I offering in the age of uncertainty? If I can't offer stability, if I can't offer you that life script, what is it that leaders are offering their people?
- SSSimon Sinek
Are you a Boomer? Millennial? Gen Z? Wait, where's Gen X? Why did you leave out Gen X? Gen X always gets left out. Regardless of which generation you're from, we all complain about each other. I mean, they really are entitled. Or are they?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Do you think we live in an inheritocracy?
- SSSimon Sinek
My guest, Dr. Eliza Filby, encourages us before we complain to consider through what lens does each generation see the world. Eliza is a generational historian in a world that has more generations working alongside each other than at any other point in history. In her bestselling book, Inheritocracy, Eliza challenges the idea that we even live in a meritocracy anymore, and what that means for every generation trying to get ahead. Eliza helped me see connections I never saw before-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
12
- SSSimon Sinek
... what?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
12
- SSSimon Sinek
... and realize just how much more difficult the world will be for our younger generations, and how the rest of us are gonna get ahead, too. Maybe, just maybe, we have to learn to win together. This is A Bit of Optimism. [upbeat music]
- 1:41 – 4:34
How Dr. Filby Became a Generations Expert
- SSSimon Sinek
I was forced to be interested in generations. Like, I started talking about generations and generational differences at work-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm
- SSSimon Sinek
... not because I had a particular hankering, but because the single most common question I used to get, literally any size audience, whether it was public or private, was, "How do we lead Millennials?"
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yes.
- SSSimon Sinek
And this was a bunch of years ago. You have sort of made a career out of understanding generations. H- how does somebody-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yes
- SSSimon Sinek
... like wake up in the morning and be like, "You know, I wanna be a fireman. I wanna be, you know-"
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
[laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
"... I wanna be a generational expert." Like, how did you, like, where did that come from? [laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
So, so I've invented a job title that didn't previously exist, and I have always been interested in change and how one is defined by time. There's lots of things that make us, us. You know, it's gender, it's, you know, racial identity, it's sexuality, it's hobbies. There's all sorts of things that make up our identity, but the time at which you enter the world-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... is really important, too. And I, you know, was an academic and studied history, became a, a historian, taught at universities across the world, and found that there was a real disconnect between academic history-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... right, the study of time-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and kings and queens and all, all those wonderful things, and actually sort of how people experience time. It was sort of me understanding my own family-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and how when we talk about generations, that being a category of analysis that actually historians really poo-poo and attack, but actually within the family makes total sense.
- SSSimon Sinek
Well, I mean, it's, it's clearly-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
It is the unit of time
- SSSimon Sinek
... it's clearly defined.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
Grandparents-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... parents, me.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Exactly. So actually, generational analysis was something that as someone who came from a family who lived in, grew up in a multi-generational household, my father had, and his family had lived in the same house for 100 years. My family was from the same area for over 250 years. The sense of generational identity was so strong within me.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And I was like, actually, I think there's some real sort of gaps missing in the analysis-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... within the academic study of generations, but then on the societal level as well. It's full of stereotypes, it's full of generalizations, it's sort of lazy labels. You know, Gen Z are entitled. You know, Millennials used to be entitled, and then we had Gen Z. Gen X used to be entitled, they were called slackers, you know? Boomers were sort of defined as the, the first me, me generation. So there's lots of lazy generalizations, but actually what I'm really in- sort of interested in is how we're shaped by time.
- 4:34 – 10:51
The Fragmentation of Generations + Shared Experiences
- SSSimon Sinek
in. When I studied social anthropology, um, we were taught that generations were about 20 years, and they're fuzzy, right?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm. Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
And-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm
- SSSimon Sinek
... and so it was relatively clearly defined. You know, if you start with the Greatest Generation, the generation that lived through the Second World War-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm
- SSSimon Sinek
... then they came back from war and all got busy, and there was the baby boom.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
They got seriously busy, yep.
- SSSimon Sinek
So a generation starting to be born around 1945-ish.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yep.
- SSSimon Sinek
And so that lasted about 20 years, and then 19, mid-1960s-ish-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Gen X
- SSSimon Sinek
... you get Gen X. That's another 20 years.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yep.
- SSSimon Sinek
Then you get Gen Y or Millennials, but for s- but what I'm struggling with, and this is where I need your help, which is that clear definition of approximately 20 years marked by significant events.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm.
- SSSimon Sinek
I don't know what happens before-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm
- SSSimon Sinek
... the, the, the Greatest Generation, quite frankly. We sort of start generations-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm
- SSSimon Sinek
... you know, after World War II. [laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
And again, you could be leading edge, trailing edge, in the middle.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yep.
- SSSimon Sinek
But it, it bracketed us, and it doesn't mean that everybody's personality is the same. But for some reason now, generations are becoming, like, five years long, which-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah. [laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
... as an anthropologist, that doesn't sound right to me-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah
- SSSimon Sinek
... that every time that something happens in the world, you don't suddenly have a new generation. There's starting to be too many of them.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right, so you've got Gen Z, and now you've got Gen Alpha, and actually you've got Gen Beta. You know, it's, it's, it's endless, and they're truncating-
- 10:51 – 14:32
The Death of Shared Truth
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right, and, and Benedict Anderson's book called Imagine Communities, why he emphasizes the rise of the newspaper as so formative, um, in the alignment of the rise of nationhood was that sense of shared information generates a shared identity and a shared sort of unity over what the nation is, what it stands for, and what we seek to protect. And so, uh, one of the things that you are seeing with the fragmentation of information-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and we're about to see that accelerated with AI, is no one has a shared truth, for sure. No one has a s- a shared understanding of what the nation even is.
- SSSimon Sinek
This is so good.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
So you're seeing the decline of shared values, shared definitions, shared sense of trust and truth, but also the disintegration of trust at a, at an institutional level and, as I say, um, in various sort of arenas, whether it's the church, whether it's the workplace, whether it's, you know, any form of associational culture. There's all sorts of ways in which trust has been eroded.
- SSSimon Sinek
This idea of access into, uh, to information and shared information is part of what creates our national identity.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
But if the media landscape-... is fragmented and diffused and now hyper politicized for financial gain.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
For political, uh, not even for political reasons.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
It's politically, uh, uh, fractured for commercial reasons.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yep.
- SSSimon Sinek
Which is the, you know, uh, let's be honest, if all of the newspapers were conservative, Rupert Murdoch would've started a liberal TV station. Like, it was purely commercial. And so what we end up having is fractured identity because of fractured media. Is that a fair statement?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Uh, yes, but I also think let's not rose tint the past and that there was this wonderful time when we all believed the truth and we all had this shared truth and shared identity and shared moment. You know, there's a lot of conspiracy culture [laughs] um, before the internet. The internet didn't invent conspiracy, nor did it invent cynicism, um, and distrust in institutions. I think that there's an element here in what you say that's also slightly missing. The idea of the individual seeking out the truth or seeking out their own community, their micro community, or their own sort of narrative or worldview. One of the things that's really sort of typical of Gen Z, if we're gonna go into the generations, uh, [laughs] generalizations here, is that desire to seek out the information rather than just be passive consumers of information. It's, it really interesting. If you look at the data around which generation is most likely to spread fake news, it's Baby Boomers. Now, they grew up with verified media. They trust it.
- SSSimon Sinek
So if it comes in, it must be true.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
They grew up with, you know, three TV channels. Gen Z grew up with their own TV channel, but also-
- SSSimon Sinek
[laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... deep fakes, the ability to edit, airbrushing, and, you know, spam.
- SSSimon Sinek
And they know how to do that too, yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right? So this, this idea of, okay, I'm gonna seek out the truth-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... whatever that means to me, and however that aligns with me. We know we're living in an era where my truth is essentially the truth, right? [laughs] Then there's an empowerment to that, but then it also is often combined with a cynicism around official sources of truth, official media, and also a, um, I think a sort of unwillingness to maybe hear things that the algorithm tells you you, you don't believe in. I mean, you're seeing that play out in the workplace, if you wanna go there. But the conspiracy
- 14:32 – 16:06
Conspiracy Culture Infiltrates the Workplace
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
culture you're seeing in politics-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... is infiltrating corporations.
- SSSimon Sinek
Say more.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
So if you go on Fishbowl or if you go on TikTok or if you go, frankly, any sort of forum where people are talking about their lives, you will find, okay, if you're in this job, are you earning this? Because I'm earning this. And if you're in this job, if they let you go because they, they let these people go, or you wanna hear what's happening in Australia, you know, and that's impacting what's happening in the US. What I'm saying is that conspiracy culture that's in politics is infiltrating the workplace when things go wrong. Internal communications with, is massively problematic because Gen Z are having those conversations, not down the pub or in the cafe. They're having them online, and that is a sort of contagious culture where people go, "Well, do you know what? I'm not gonna trust a word the CEO says. I'm not gonna trust a word HR is saying, because those people have laid off, and you see what they're saying on LinkedIn or Fishbowl." I think there's this, there's this sort of empowering nature to that sort of fragmentation of information and, and owning the narrative and finding out your truth, but there's also a conspiratorial sort of culture that's very corrosive to our politics, we know that, and very corrosive to other areas of, of, of people's lives.
- SSSimon Sinek
But don't conspiracy theories come out of uncertainty, fear? You know, uh, I mean, there's always conspiracy theories, of course. I'm not romanticizing that the past doesn't have them, and they can spread a lot more easily now. It's, it's seeds of doubt.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
And we are living in times... And forget about
- 16:06 – 20:33
The End of Job Security + the Rise of the Solopreneur
- SSSimon Sinek
political uncertainty, all that stuff. I'm talking about just the workplace, where-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah
- SSSimon Sinek
... work used to be a, a safe place. You used to work your whole career in one company, and, and then that would be it. And then public companies started embracing redundancies and mass layoffs as a means of balancing the books at the end of the year. And so work no longer became stable, which it didn't matter how hard you worked, it wasn't a meritocracy. We missed our arbitrary projections. Sorry, you get to lose your job. And it was always considered, okay, well, public companies are unsafe, but private companies are safe. And then the rise of venture capital-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... and the pressures from another investor class now creates, you know, cost-cutting as a mechanism to protect the investor's investment, not the company's-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... wellbeing. And so now you're not safe in a public company. You're not safe in a private company. And I see younger people now who are fashioning their own careers-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm
- SSSimon Sinek
... with multiple kinds of gig e- gig experiences. Like, I know one woman, she's a comedian, she's a tour guide, she's a something else. Like, she's got-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah
- SSSimon Sinek
... three or four things going on.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
And they all pay a little bit, and she can put together an income through all of it, but she's doing it her way. And it's not because she's, like, dreamed of being her own boss one day.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
And I'm seeing more and more of young people being very, very open to the uncertainty and the craziness of an entrepreneurial or solopreneur life, but they've got a little bit here and a little bit there. It's not like, "I'm gonna start a business to do this," or, "I'm g-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah
- SSSimon Sinek
... it's got, they got a little bit of everything going on.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
And I think it's in response to the total lack of security that is offered by any company now. It makes sense to me why we would see a rise of conspiracy theories, not just because media spreads it more easily, which is definitely a factor, but also that there's just more insecurity in the system.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And, you know, amen to all of that. And I, and I think the biggest question that leaders need to ask themselves... is h- what am I offering in the age of uncertainty? If I can't offer stability, if I can't offer you that life script, what am I offering you?
- SSSimon Sinek
Exactly.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Am I offering you a place to learn? Am I offering you a, a place to belong? Am I offering you a place that'll be one step before you make the big step? What is it that leaders are offering their people? Because you're absolutely right. What we have seen is the gradual, and it's not sudden, it's gradual erosion of the narrative we were told.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And I'm a Millennial, right? I was told, "Go to university. Do well in school. Get to university. Get on a professional track, and access to financial stability, home ownership, and that pathway to retirement-
- SSSimon Sinek
Just like the previous generations
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... will be there."
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Will be there.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Okay? My mom worked for the same company her entire working life.
- 20:33 – 28:24
The Inheritocracy: When the Bank of Mom and Dad Replaces Work Loyalty
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
the family now offers the stability that work used to. You are-
- SSSimon Sinek
Which is why young people-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... there's no shame in moving back home-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... in your 20s, even 30s.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
Like, my generation looks at that and be like, "What?"
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Well, let's, let's put it a different way, 'cause you're absolutely right. The Bank of Mum and Dad is offering the stability that the corporation never used to, right? So I say to leaders all the time, "You know, you do realize that your employees are more likely to get on the housing ladder by being loyal to their parents than being loyal to you." So how, then, do you adapt your leadership, your company culture, your raison d'être as an organization-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... in that economy, right?
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Number one. Number two, you are seeing the rise not just of, of family support, but as you've alluded to, solopreneurship. And I think there's a real distinction. I think we casually say we're in this culture of entrepreneurship in the gig economy. I think we're actually seeing squiggly careers-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... that are non-linear.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
But also solopreneurship, because that comedian that you talked about doesn't wanna employ a team.
- SSSimon Sinek
Nope, nope.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
You know? And I-
- SSSimon Sinek
Zero
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and I-
- SSSimon Sinek
And I, I'm thinking of literally three or four people off the top of my head who have gone the solopreneur way, have no desire to have employees.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
But they are making their own way.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And, and that was me five years ago. I now have a team. I call myself a reluctant entrepreneur [laughs] 'cause I-
- SSSimon Sinek
But that was by accident
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... I'm learning. I'm so learning.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
I'm learning every day how to be a leader. But I'm, I'm learning how to be a g-
- SSSimon Sinek
It's hard, isn't it?
- 28:24 – 31:29
Why Young People Don't Have 'The Hunger'
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
the thing I hear most from companies is, "Why don't young people have the hunger?" The hunger. It's always the hunger, okay?
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And I'm like, "How do you treat your kids? How, [laughs] how do you parent? How do you parent?"
- SSSimon Sinek
Well, I bought them a house and a car.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah. [laughs] Did you buy them everything they asked for? We have a generation in Gen Z who've grown up looking at their parents going, "You worked really hard in a dehumanized workplace. You earned loads of money, and the rewards today aren't the same. And you're also gonna support me if you can."
- SSSimon Sinek
And I will leverage-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
The other-
- SSSimon Sinek
... all of the guilt you have-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
[laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
... by working so hard and missing all of my school plays.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
[laughs] Right. So the, the thing-
- SSSimon Sinek
[laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
The thing that's really ... I ran this focus group, fascinating focus group of, um, Gen Z young women who'd had professional mothers, right? And then we asked Gen X mothers who were still professional women, and the Gen Z daughters of professional mothers were like, "Do you know what? I don't wanna work as hard as my mother." The overriding conversation was not, "My mother was a feminist pioneer. She broke that glass ceiling. I wanna ape her example." It was, "She was really stressed even when she was on holiday." And then you asked, we, we asked the Gen X mothers. They weren't related, by the way. The Gen X mothers were, "My daughter ha- my daughters have a point. They all think I work too hard, and I think I did." And that, I, I know it, I feel it, I sense it, I'm a mother, is partly to do with mother's guilt, right, and these strange perceptions we have as mothers that we pretend we don't have a job, um, in front of our kids. But I think actually it's a broader question of the role that work plays in our lives, and what it used to play and what it does play now in what I call an inheritance economy. And I think-When, going back to the original point, leaders say, "Why don't people have the hunger [laughs] that young peop- why can't they put up, shut up, work their way up like I did?" Is because the economy isn't encouraging that. Actually, you want hunger, you want real hunger in your new recruits, find the people that are not being supported by the Bank of Mum and Dad, but they themselves are supporting their parents, because that's a large percentage of the population. And the real truth is, of course, is we've seen a decline of meritocracy, we've seen the closing of doors and, and increasingly, particularly with AI, the lack of access and the leverage that parents have in getting their kids jobs and opening those doors, and the rise of, of greater nepotism. Those people aren't getting through in a way that they used to.
- SSSimon Sinek
And it's an entirely new way of evaluating somebody, right? Like, evaluating what school you went to because your mum and dad paid, or evaluating, you know, the opportunities you had because your mum and ba- dad paid. We're l- we're actually potentially looking for the wrong behaviors if you want somebody who's got the grit, the push-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... whatever you're looking for.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
That's super interesting.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
You know, I talk about sort of the rise of the inheritance economy in inheritocracy and the rise of, of the Bank of Mum and Dad.
- 31:29 – 35:57
Changing Life Cycle: Delayed Adulthood + Pressured Midlife
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
But there's actually a bigger story, because yes, money is cascading down the family tree, but, and this is the subject of my, um, my next book, and I'm researching it at the moment, is the, is our life cycle has completely changed. And the fact is, governments, um, financial institutions, educational institutions, um, haven't caught up. So we've delayed adulthood. We now have a slow, meandering path into adulthood. And that's partly to do with economic constraint, but it's also freedom. I didn't want kids at 21. Slower adulthood, pressured midlife. No one talks about this. When they... We fixate on living longer and longevity, but actually the life course has completely changed. So most people think they become an adult around the age of 30. It used to be 21, it used to be 18, it used to be 16, it used to be 13, if we're going right back. So this pathway into adulthood has changed. Midlife has become this pressured point. We don't talk about a midlife crisis anymore. That's very much a kind of '80s kind of masculine corporate sort of collapse. But now we talk about midlife crisis as, you know, Gen Xers right now, particularly Gen X women, are going through this midlife where they are squeezed between looking after their children, which is now a 30-year financial commitment, okay? But also caring for the elderly. You know, and eldercare now is a, as big a pressure as childcare on people, and actually quite often lasts longer in terms of that direct need to help your parents. And in an aging society, we need to think about not how aging societies impact the elderly, but how it impacts-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... those in midlife.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And so we're getting this sort of really pressured midlife point where people are changing their retirement plans to get their kids through college, or coming out of work to look after their mum, you know? Your mother who has dementia, you could be looking after her for 20 years.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And then, of course, this, this need to potentially work longer, or this desire to work longer, okay? So this, this fixed point of retirement is changing. But then also, what does retirement look like? Is it golf courses and cruises anymore? No.
- SSSimon Sinek
Starting another business for some people. [laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
No, it's starting another business. It's having a complete-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... flowering of, of things that you wanted to do. You know, and for Millennials, you're not gonna wanna go to, you know, traveling in the way that Boomers have because you kinda did that in your 20s.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
So what does retirement look like is, I think, super interesting. And then what does life look like when basically our minds and our bodies stop working? Because you're gonna need care, you're gonna need that community, you're gonna need that support.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And you become reliant on others. So have you built that infrastructure financially? It's interesting, I was looking at the data on this last week, is that the ri- what you're seeing is the rise of multi-generational houses, homes in the US.
- SSSimon Sinek
Whose houses is everybody moving into?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm. So if you look at Gen X, they're building multi-generational homes. With Millennials, at the moment you're seeing Millennials moving to where the Boomers are. Quite often the maternal grandparents, and the grandparents are doing childcare, and then obviously that care reversal process that happens in every family.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
You know? And, and it happened with- within my own family when my father died.
- SSSimon Sinek
Your mum moved in?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
My mum moved in. We all took time off work to look after my dad. My dad s- when he was ill, said two things to me, which I reflect upon quite often because he was quite a brutal man, my dad. He kind of [laughs] spoke the truth harshly. And he was like, "I'm glad I had three daughters, not three sons." You know? And I was like, "Okay, Dad." [laughs] As we're slaving away, you know, looking after him.
- SSSimon Sinek
Well, I get that.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And, and it... He was right.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
He was right. And he also said, "I'm gonna make this quick."
- SSSimon Sinek
Wow.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah. And, you know, thinking about it sort of gets me highly emotional, but what he was basically saying is, "You've got better things to do."
- SSSimon Sinek
Like, "Thanks for looking after me, but-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah
- SSSimon Sinek
... I, I, I got this." [laughs]
- 35:57 – 41:39
Rise of Dual Income Households
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
gives sort of due appreciation for is that Millennial couples are working in majority dual income households, right?
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And they're working twice as hard-... quite often to be half as rich as their parents. [laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Dual income households are the norm now-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... not the exception. And what we're really talking about is, and companies need to be thinking about this as well as, you know, couples themselves, is if women have stepped up financially in the home and contributing to the household finances, men have no choice, literally no choice, but to step up on the domestic front. And it's great because Millennial dads push more pushchairs, change more nappies, you know, spend more time with their kids than any other generation of fathers before them. It's not because they love their kids more.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right? [laughs] Let's just be clear on that than any other generation of fathers.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
It's because there is a requirement.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
There is a need in a dual income household for men to step up domestically. What you're not seeing to the same degree is men doing the eldercare in the same way that they're doing the childcare.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And actually fundamentally, that's one of the biggest challenges I think that companies need to get their heads around-
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... is actually in an aging society, what's happening to your midlifers with those kinds of responsibilities, and are you promoting eldercare as much as you're promoting fatherhood in the workplace?
- SSSimon Sinek
What is your prediction for this young generation that's entering work?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm.
- SSSimon Sinek
What is their identity? Where are they gonna get their belonging? You know, now they're being battered by messages of AI taking their jobs, whether it's true or not.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm.
- SSSimon Sinek
You know, time will tell. You know, companies are already using AI as a justification to make layoffs, which I think is a bit premature.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm.
- SSSimon Sinek
I, I don't believe them.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm. Mm. Yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
But that's a different conversation. The young generations that have been accused of being entitled, and I have my own sort of theories on that, um, which I can share with you quickly, which is it is an entitlement. That's how it does appear.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
You know? What I think that the corporate world is missing is that the young generation that enters the workforce, and has been for, you know, I'd say probably a good 10 years if not more, they're playing by the rules that companies set. So just as we were saying before, where in the past you could get a job and you could work there as long as you wanted to work there. They would look after you, and you would look after the company.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right.
- SSSimon Sinek
But now with the rise of mass layoffs to balance the books, I can't rely on the fact that I'm gonna have a job, so if you're offering me no loyalty, I offer you no loyalty.
- 41:39 – 44:21
Hyper-Individualism: From 12% to 80% Thinking They're Important
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
No, no, no, you're absolutely right, and I, I'm, uh, the word I wanna kind of interrogate is transactional, 'cause I think it's the right word. So in, in the 1950s in the US, there was this great psychologist that, that ran this survey, and it was asking people in 1952, "Do you think you're an important person?"
- SSSimon Sinek
[laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Do you think you're an important person, Simon? [laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
I think I, I would be curious-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
I do
- SSSimon Sinek
... I-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
You're very important
- SSSimon Sinek
... that is very nice of you.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
You're very important.
- SSSimon Sinek
Well, if you said it, who am I to disagree?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right. [laughs] Okay.
- SSSimon Sinek
I mean, you're the PhD. I'm not.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
What percentage of people in the US, right?
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah. I think Americans think they're more important than-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Nat- Right, in 1952-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... said they were very important.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah. I'm gonna say it's d-High above 50%
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
No
- SSSimon Sinek
Re-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
12%.
- SSSimon Sinek
What?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
12%, right? The survey was run again in 1990.
- SSSimon Sinek
Okay.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And let me just be clear, right?
- SSSimon Sinek
[laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Millennials weren't in the group.
- SSSimon Sinek
Right, right.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Gen Z weren't even born or conceived. What percentage of people in the US-
- SSSimon Sinek
Go on. Go on. I can't even guess
- 44:21 – 46:58
Dirty Kitchen Syndrome: Transactional Work Culture
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
at data at communal spaces at work, kitchens. So what you've seen post-COVID, and COVID's I think a really important demarcation here, is the decline of people cleaning up after themselves in the communal kitchen. So the coffee cup-
- SSSimon Sinek
Whoa
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... you use. You know, cleaning the microwave if your soup goes everywhere. People aren't cleaning up after themselves in the communal spaces at work.
- SSSimon Sinek
Whoa.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Now, it could be that obviously there's workers in there that are c- you know, cleaners that are clean-
- SSSimon Sinek
So what?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
But it's not. It's not, because there's always been office cleaners. It's because people have a much more atomized view of the world, but an increasingly transactional view of work. And it's not just because the contract is broken. It's also because of a hyper-individualized culture.
- SSSimon Sinek
Wow. Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Now, COVID created, obviously, this enforced, um, remote working scenario.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah, yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Many of whom entered the workforce, that was their first experience of work, staring at a green dot 12 hours a day. Those people are now, you know, managers, and some of them are now leaders, right? They were never sort of, you know, baptized in good management and good leadership because they were living through a global crisis. But you have COVID, and now we have hybrid and remote working. And so those points of connection, those points of low-stakes socialization in the workplace have completely gone, which is why, you know, I spend a lot of my time helping companies not just help leaders understand their young people and go, "Look," you know, "stop being scared of them. They're understandably this way," but helping young people understand what does reciprocal relationships and dynamics and responsibilities look like in the workplace? Because you are just thinking about I. You are not thinking about we. And if I, if I just focus on leaders, helping them-
- SSSimon Sinek
Sure
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... because it's a combination-
- SSSimon Sinek
Sure
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... of listening to what's your irritations. What are your thoughts? What's your challenges in your daily life? What's your, you know, your needs, wants, and desires? Let's get that out. Let's get out your moans. But then let, let me tell you what your leaders are saying about you, and let me tell you how you can have the confidence to ask the right questions, how you can just in a moment switch people's expectations of you or how they give you feedback, you know? And so we do it in a, a real-world way and help them understand that it's not just I, it's we. I think this is all about power.
- 46:58 – 51:14
AI as the Next Generation in the Workplace
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Now, we have had, pretty much throughout history [laughs] Marx would concur, um, a power balance that swings-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... between workers and employers, right?
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And post-COVID, that pendulum swung in favor of employees.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And now it's swinging back-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... to employers. You have this new generation in the workplace, and they're really keen. They work throughout the night. They sometimes get things wrong. But do you know what? They're really praising of you and everything you do, and it's Gen AI. Because Gen AI is the next generation in the workforce. Gen AI is the plucky young intern [laughs] who's doing all the work at double speed. They sometimes get things wrong, um, but they're always wanting to please you. And so I think a really useful way of thinking about this, all generations in the workplace, is AI is the latest generation in the workplace that needs to be integrated, that needs to be put in its place [laughs] that needs to be managed, just as previous generations have.
- SSSimon Sinek
All right, you had me hook, line, and sinker for so long. I completely agree with you in terms of the ... And that's what triggers me, like, people that don't know that there's other people in the world. It drives me nuts.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah, yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
It drives me absolutely nuts.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah, yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
Right?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
That's horrible
- SSSimon Sinek
... and, uh, you know, in, in every respect.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
Sitting in a restaurant, I actually talked to a guy who, he's a restaurant owner, and he was telling me that his business is down.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Mm-hmm.
- SSSimon Sinek
His restaurant is full, but his business is down. Because at the end of the meal, they've all paid the check-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right
- SSSimon Sinek
... and then they all sit there on their phone after the meal-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Oh
- SSSimon Sinek
... and all go through all their texts and start checking their Instagrams and all the things that they've missed for the whatever hour that they were sitting in the restaurant, and he, he, he'll lose 20 minutes.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Wow.
- SSSimon Sinek
So he gets fewer turns on his tables.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Wow.
- SSSimon Sinek
Not order another drink, nothing.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
No.
- SSSimon Sinek
And so he, he's making less money with a full restaurant. My rule is, and all my friends know this, which is you can stay in the restaurant as long as you want. The minute you pay the check, the contract is complete. There's an exchange of consideration. You leave. That's the deal. You make room for another person.
- 51:14 – 58:44
Let Humans Do What Can't Be Counted
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... the AI does the stuff that dehumanized the workplace.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
It's really good at output. We know it's really good at productivity. It's really good at clearing our inbox. It's really good at the stuff you can count. But actually what you wanna do is get humans doing the stuff that can't be counted. And what's that? What is the stuff that actually oils the wheels of an organization but is never awarded, you can never count it, and you never task someone with it, and it's definitely not under the line of productivity?
- SSSimon Sinek
A good cup of coffee.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Three things.
- SSSimon Sinek
Oh, sorry.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
No, three things.
- SSSimon Sinek
[laughs]
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Three things. Listen up.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah, sorry.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Three things. Number one, and we, you talk about this so brilliantly, and I think we are beginning to talk about this much more, thankfully, in the workplace, is care.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
That ability to understand, tap into, without prying, people's family situations or, you know, um, their wellbeing.
- SSSimon Sinek
Things, things, things, conversations that used to be completely forbidden at work-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Having conversations that are-
- SSSimon Sinek
... done skillfully
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... that demonstrate-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... care.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Okay? Not procedures done by HR, not wellbeing initiatives done by external providers. Number two is that wisdom sharing, collective wisdom sharing. Now, we have seen over the last 30 years the erosion of learning in the workplace. It's, didn't happen with COVID. If you look at the, even the numbers, the investment that companies used to put into learning on the job, and the erosion of that is staggering. So you've seen the loss of apprenticeship, the loss of learning, and now the loss of mentorship and those touch points and observation. Thing I hear most of, most, most complaint, the biggest complaint I hear about young people is, "Why can't they just pick up the phone?" Because many of them didn't have a landline at child- childhood. They didn't have what you and I had, which was that was the only way we could speak to our friends, and we'd phone up our, our, our friends and speak to their parents first. So that formality was built in. But they're not seeing you do it, and you're not giving them the time to learn from you and see you do it, and then you're not giving them the time to do those low-stakes phone calls before they do the big-ass scary phone call to the big client. So that, even learning those basics of professional etiquette aren't, aren't happening, so that collective wisdom. But also in the age of AI, what you need is those digital natives, they need to be teaching the elders. So that, that collective wisdom doesn't just flow down the organization, it has to now flow up. So we're talking care, collective wisdom, intergenerational sharing of learning, and then the third thing is that communication. And I know you talk beautifully about this, this active listening, this pr- this clarity, uh, in communication. And one of the things that I see companies suffer from is everyone's trying to be too nice. "Oh, I didn't wanna give feedback because I didn't want to upset her in her annual review," or, you know, "I don't wanna tell them to not wear a hoodie. They should know." There's a lack of clarity in people, in how people communicate.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And that is about listening and communicating. So going back to my original point is what we need here is companies to allow the humans to do-The things you can't count
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And that connection point, that sense of belonging, and along with that, learning is the way that humans can thrive and connect-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and build trust, and clean up the kitchen after they've ye- made a cup of coffee-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and let AI do the thing that AI does best.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- 58:44 – 1:00:44
Taylor Swift Tickets + the Future of Business Relationships
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
very, um, senior managing partner at a law firm, one of the top law firms in London, and, um, I said, "You know, what are you, what are you thinking about this [laughs] AI stuff?" And y- and, and, and he said, "You know, I'm gonna tell you two things that seem bizarre and disconnected but totally are connected." He said, "We are actually employing fewer paralegals, okay? Some of that grunt work, been automated, okay? And we, more importantly, we trust it, okay? We're beginning to trust it."
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
"But we need people to oversee-
- SSSimon Sinek
For now
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... the automation-
- SSSimon Sinek
For now. Mm-hmm
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... right, of the grunt work. And the second thing is we have spent so much money on Taylor Swift's Eras tour." And I was like, "Eh?" And he said, "Yeah, we have realized that building relationships with our clients-"
- SSSimon Sinek
There we go
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... okay, and particularly inviting their kids to the [laughs] Taylor Swift concert [laughs] is gonna be the defining trait of a great lawyer, okay? Now, a great lawyer is about judgment, of course. You're asking, and you're paying for that judgment, okay? And we can talk about the transition from a knowledge economy to a judgment economy in the age of AI. I always think this is the best question when we think about AI. What is the thing that AI is exposing? Not what is it doing. What is it exposing? Well, it's exposing, I think, how weak our education system is. It's exposing a lot of bullshit work, okay? But it's exposing, I think, right now, is the lack of human interaction at work. And why he was buying Taylor Swift concert tickets [lips smack] was because business is based on trust.
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Okay?
- SSSimon Sinek
Mm-hmm.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
And trust is built on human connection. That skill of building those contacts, that connection, and that trust-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... can only be delivered by the human-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... at a Taylor Swift concert. But, but the point is, is that-Two things. We're disrupting the path to mastery.
- 1:00:44 – 1:03:04
Disrupted Path to Mastery + Nurturing Human Skills
- SSSimon Sinek
Amen.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
That is a serious-
- SSSimon Sinek
Amen
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... serious-
- SSSimon Sinek
That's a real problem
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... point. And there's all sorts of things that are happening now where you-
- SSSimon Sinek
Amen to that
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... you are r- ridding the, the path of the grunt work, okay? I did a PhD. It was three years of grunt and grind, okay? It really was. But I learnt how to constantly question.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right? That's what it was.
- SSSimon Sinek
I wrote books.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Yeah.
- SSSimon Sinek
And it was the writing of the books that made me smarter-
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Undoubted-
- SSSimon Sinek
... not the existence of the books
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... exactly.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right? We are disrupting that path to mastery. And in, in, in some professions, that path to mastery is really clear and really rigid-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... and will probably be disrupted at a slower pace-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... than others.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yep.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
So what is the route to mastery? What are you asking of young people? How are you also enabling your people that are halfway through that route to mastery and need to be agile? And then the second thing is you have to nurture your human skills within your organization. And, and when you have a scenario where your young lawyers are not emailing their seniors to ask for a holiday or telling them they can't do the work because they booked the theater that night, but are actually asking ChatGPT secretly, you have a disconnection problem. Because that Gen Z-er doesn't want the friction and the awkwardness of asking you face-to-face, "I can't do the work," or, "I need that day off on holiday." They're asking ChatGPT to script the email-
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah, yeah, yeah
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
... that then goes to you.
- SSSimon Sinek
I c- you can start to spot them now. They all s- they all look the same.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Right. And so you've got this, this real sort of challenge, is how do you nurture those human skills as a generation where they've actually been massively under-nurtured and are gonna have to be overly nurtured? And again, it goes back to my point, is, and organizations need to encourage the things that can't be counted. And a lot of this stuff is highly gendered. Let's not pretend that it's not. There's an evolution of what I call the team mum, and it's quite often a middle-aged woman in the office that everyone goes to for emotional support, administrative help, every question, and she's burdened and never rewarded, certainly never paid for the extra work she puts in. And quite often she gets burnt out and leaves, and when she leaves, a lot of things collapse. But those, um, human interactions and that collaboration and those human skills are not being nurtured in the way that they should.
- SSSimon Sinek
Yeah, yeah.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
So that's where I think
- 1:03:04 – 1:03:47
How Can Generations Come Together?
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
the generations genuinely have an opportunity of coming together.
- SSSimon Sinek
Magic. You're wonderful.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Thanks, babes. You're wonderful. [laughs]
- SSSimon Sinek
You're really good. This is great. I mean, your s- your, your, I think your perspective is so helpful and so clear, and, uh, I'm really, really, really, really glad you came on.
- EFDr. Eliza Filby
Thank you.
- SSSimon Sinek
Thanks. A Bit of Optimism is a production of The Optimism Company, lovingly produced by our team, Lindsay Garbinus, Phoebe Bradford, and Devon Johnson. Subscribe wherever you enjoy listening to podcasts, and if you want even more cool stuff, visit simonsinek.com. Thanks for listening. Take care of yourself. Take care of each other.
Episode duration: 1:03:47
Install uListen for AI-powered chat & search across the full episode — Get Full Transcript
Transcript of episode 0kgEtkVG5zw
Get more out of YouTube videos.
High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.
Add to Chrome