
No Priors Ep. 68 | With Zapier Co-Founder and Head of AI Mike Knoop
Elad Gil (host), Mike Knoop (guest), Narrator
In this episode of No Priors, featuring Elad Gil and Mike Knoop, No Priors Ep. 68 | With Zapier Co-Founder and Head of AI Mike Knoop explores zapier’s Mike Knoop Challenges LLM Dominance With New AGI Prize Mike Knoop, Zapier co-founder and Head of AI, discusses why he believes progress toward AGI has stalled despite rapid advancements in large language models and economic applications.
Zapier’s Mike Knoop Challenges LLM Dominance With New AGI Prize
Mike Knoop, Zapier co-founder and Head of AI, discusses why he believes progress toward AGI has stalled despite rapid advancements in large language models and economic applications.
He contrasts the prevailing “economically useful work” definition of AGI with François Chollet’s definition centered on efficiently acquiring new skills, arguing that current LLMs are powerful memorization systems but not generally intelligent.
Knoop outlines the ARC Prize, a $1M+ nonprofit challenge to beat Chollet’s ARC-AGI benchmark with open-source solutions, intentionally designed to attract outsiders and new paradigms like program synthesis and neural architecture search.
He also explains how Zapier is productizing AI through tools and agents, advocates for open-source and open research, and cautions against prescriptive AI/AGI regulation without empirical evidence of capabilities.
Key Takeaways
Redefine AGI around skill acquisition, not just economic usefulness.
Knoop favors François Chollet’s definition of general intelligence as the efficient acquisition of new skills, arguing that the popular “can do most economically useful work” framing overestimates our proximity to true AGI.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
LLMs are powerful memorizers, not yet true general reasoners.
He characterizes current language models as high-dimensional memorization systems that can recombine existing patterns but struggle with open-ended problems whose solution patterns don’t appear in training data.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Beating ARC-AGI likely requires new paradigms, not just scale.
State-of-the-art performance on the ARC-AGI benchmark has only moved from ~20% to ~34% in four years, and has resisted LLM and scale-based approaches, suggesting we need fundamentally different techniques.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Program synthesis and relaxed neural architecture search are promising paths.
Knoop highlights approaches that search over program or architecture space (rather than just gradient descent on fixed models) as promising ways to discover more general reasoning systems.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Outsiders and small teams may drive key AGI breakthroughs.
The ARC competitions have attracted many one- and two-person teams outside major labs, and Knoop believes the winning approach may come from someone not entrenched in current LLM orthodoxy.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Agentic AI is already economically valuable but must be carefully constrained.
Zapier’s AI bots show that users will pay for agent-like workflows today; the challenge is giving customers tools to ‘clamp’ what agents can and cannot do so risk scales appropriately with the use case.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Open-source and open research are critical to unlocking new AI ideas.
Knoop argues that closed frontier labs and reduced publishing slow foundational progress, and that open protocols, code, and datasets dramatically increase the chance of genuine AGI breakthroughs.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Notable Quotes
“My belief is that AGI’s progress has really stalled out over the last four or five years.”
— Mike Knoop
“General intelligence is a system that can effectively, efficiently acquire new skill.”
— Mike Knoop (describing François Chollet’s definition)
“Effectively, what large language models do today is they are high-dimensional memorization systems.”
— Mike Knoop
“Language models do not work to beat ARC. And people have tried.”
— Mike Knoop
“If you care about actually discovering AGI in our lifetime, then I think it’s sort of incumbent to try and promote things that increase the likelihood that we’re generating new ideas.”
— Mike Knoop
Questions Answered in This Episode
If ARC-AGI resists LLM-based approaches, what concrete characteristics might a successful, more general architecture need to have?
Mike Knoop, Zapier co-founder and Head of AI, discusses why he believes progress toward AGI has stalled despite rapid advancements in large language models and economic applications.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
How could existing LLMs and program-synthesis-style systems be combined into hybrid models that perform better on ARC and similar tasks?
He contrasts the prevailing “economically useful work” definition of AGI with François Chollet’s definition centered on efficiently acquiring new skills, arguing that current LLMs are powerful memorization systems but not generally intelligent.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
What practical milestones, short of beating ARC-AGI, would indicate we’re making real progress toward systems that can efficiently acquire new skills?
Knoop outlines the ARC Prize, a $1M+ nonprofit challenge to beat Chollet’s ARC-AGI benchmark with open-source solutions, intentionally designed to attract outsiders and new paradigms like program synthesis and neural architecture search.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
How should startups balance building on today’s economically powerful LLM stack with investing in riskier, more speculative AGI-oriented research?
He also explains how Zapier is productizing AI through tools and agents, advocates for open-source and open research, and cautions against prescriptive AI/AGI regulation without empirical evidence of capabilities.
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
What governance or safety mechanisms should be in place once we start seeing empirical signs of systems that genuinely exhibit general skill acquisition?
Get the full analysis with uListen AI
Transcript Preview
(music plays) Hi, listeners, and welcome to No Priors. Today, we're talking with Mike Nute, the co-founder and head of AI at Zapier. Mike co-founded the company in 2011 and was an early adopter of the power of AI in the enterprise. Recently, he's joined forces with François Chollet to launch a competition to accelerate progress towards AGI called the ARC Prizes. Mike, welcome to No Priors, and, um, maybe you can start off just by telling us a little bit more about what you're up to on the prize side. That sounds really exciting.
Yeah, thanks for, uh, having me. I'm super excited. Uh, I've been a No Prior listener since, uh, literally episode one. So, uh, finally, excited to- to get on and, uh, e- introduce yourself. So I'm Mike. I'm one of the co-founders of Zapier. Um, I've run and advised all of our AI projects over the last, uh, two years or so. And my day job has been, um, you know, building AI at the application layer for Zapier. But my, kind of nights and weekends, um, have been more interested in this, like, AGI research and progress. In- in fact, this kind of curiosity goes all the way back to kind of my college days, pre-Zapier. Um, you know, I think actually this is one of the reasons why Zapier got- was so early into some of the AI stuff, was kind of this curiosity (laughs) in, like, AGI. Uh, the- the chain of thought paper that came out in Jan 2022 was what kind of, like, shook me loose. I- I was, uh, running half the company actually at that point, and, um, I gave up my exec team role to go, like, kind of back to being an IC, and answer for myself, like, "How close are we to AGI?" And, um, as it turns out, uh, we are not that close. Um, you know, I- my belief is that AGI's progress has really stalled out over the last four or five years. Um, and I think there's a- kind of a handful of reasons for that. I think the- the biggest one is that the kind of consensus definition of what AGI is, uh, the definition of it is wrong. I think we're measuring the wrong things, and this leads people to think that we're closer to AGI than we actually are. Uh, this causes, like, AI researchers and kind of generally the world to be overinvested in exploiting this large language model, like, paradigm and regime, ex- as opposed to exploring, like, new ideas, which are desperately needed. Um, and, like, frontier AI researchers also basically, like, completely stopped publishing. You know, the GPT-4 paper had zero technical details. Uh, the Gemini paper had zero technical details on a lot of the context stuff. Um, and I- I just wanted to help fix this, so I- I wanted to see if there was something I could do to help accelerate. And so yeah, I'm excited to share, uh, we just launched ARC Prize. It's a million dollar plus non-profit, uh, public challenge to beat François Chollet's, um, ARC AGI Eval, and open source the solution to it, and open source the progress towards it. Um, ARC AGI, to best of my knowledge, is the only true AGI eval that actually exists in the world, and measures a actually good definition, correct definition of what AGI is, which we can talk about. Um, this- there's an AI lab called Lab 42 out of Switzerland that's been running a small annual contest over the last four years, uh, to try and beat this eval, and state of the art today is 34%. Um, state of the art four years ago when it was first introduced was 20%, so we've made very, very little marginal progress towards it. And, uh, this was pre-L and pre-scale, right? So it's like it has successfully resisted the advent of scale and LMs. Um, the ARC AGI actually looks like an IQ test if you go look at some of the puzzles. Maybe we can, like, uh, overlay some of the puzzles, uh, and- and show some stuff.
Install uListen to search the full transcript and get AI-powered insights
Get Full TranscriptGet more from every podcast
AI summaries, searchable transcripts, and fact-checking. Free forever.
Add to Chrome