Kara Swisher Says New AI Executive Order Is “Idiotic” | Pivot

Kara Swisher Says New AI Executive Order Is “Idiotic” | Pivot

PivotDec 16, 202559m

Scott Galloway (host), Kara Swisher (host), Guest (guest), Narrator

Recent mass shootings at Brown University and Bondi Beach and gun policy contrasts between the U.S. and AustraliaRising antisemitism, illiberalism, and the psychological climate for Jews globallyRob Reiner’s murder, Trump’s response, and Reiner’s cultural and political legacyAI industry dynamics: OpenAI ‘Code Red,’ competitive positioning vs Google Gemini, and atoms vs bits defensibilityDisney’s deal with OpenAI and the broader content–AI bargaining landscapeOracle’s AI/data center build-out, stock drop, and its connection to media M&A financingTrump’s AI executive order, federal vs state authority, and big-tech-aligned deregulationMedia consolidation stakes: Paramount vs Netflix vs Warner Bros. Discovery vs Disney vs AppleMedia responsibility and reproductive rights: CBS/Face the Nation’s Mifepristone segmentPersonal reflections on friendship, caregiving, and the sources of happiness

In this episode of Pivot, featuring Scott Galloway and Kara Swisher, Kara Swisher Says New AI Executive Order Is “Idiotic” | Pivot explores kara Swisher Blasts Trump’s ‘Idiotic’ AI Order, Media and Guns Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway open with the weekend’s mass shootings at Brown University and Sydney’s Bondi Beach, linking them to broader trends in gun access, radicalization, and rising antisemitism, while contrasting U.S. inaction with Australia’s likely policy response.

Kara Swisher Blasts Trump’s ‘Idiotic’ AI Order, Media and Guns

Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway open with the weekend’s mass shootings at Brown University and Sydney’s Bondi Beach, linking them to broader trends in gun access, radicalization, and rising antisemitism, while contrasting U.S. inaction with Australia’s likely policy response.

They discuss the murder of Rob Reiner and Trump’s inflammatory reaction, using it to highlight the normalization of cruelty and illiberalism, and then pivot into AI: OpenAI’s ‘Code Red’ posture, Disney’s partnership with OpenAI, and Oracle’s risky AI bet tied to its OpenAI deal.

The conversation turns sharply political with Trump’s new AI executive order, which they describe as an anti-regulation power grab designed to pre-empt state-level AI rules, calling it legally dubious, idiotic, and a pure play for big tech interests.

Closing segments cover media consolidation (Paramount–Warner–Netflix–Disney–Apple chess), a stinging critique of CBS/Face the Nation’s Mifepristone framing, and personal reflections on friendship, mortality, and the importance of having people to love and advocate for you.

Key Takeaways

Gun violence frequency is a policy choice, and the U.S. keeps choosing inaction.

Australia’s first mass shooting in 27 years versus America’s 1. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Antisemitism today is framed less as dislike and more as conspiracy, which legitimizes violence.

Galloway distinguishes typical prejudice (“I don’t like your customs”) from antisemitism as a belief in a Jewish conspiracy to oppress others, arguing that chants like “Globalize the Intifada” and normalized hate speech create “cloud cover” for violent actors.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Physical infrastructure (‘atoms’) creates more durable business moats than pure software (‘bits’).

Comparing SpaceX and OpenAI, Galloway notes SpaceX grows slower yet is more valuable because no one can quickly replicate its rockets and launch capacity, while OpenAI’s digital products are easier to disrupt—an “atoms are more defensible than bits” thesis.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Content owners should treat AI firms as bidders, not saviors, to avoid value leakage.

Disney’s OpenAI deal is portrayed as a pragmatic move to learn and retain leverage—provided the term is short and non-exclusive—so that Disney can later play OpenAI, Google, Meta, and others against each other rather than let a single AI platform capture the value of its IP.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Oracle’s massive AI spend highlights how fragile the current AI investment boom may be.

Oracle’s stock drop, huge CapEx, and loosely defined $300B OpenAI ‘framework’ deal are seen as more PR than firm commitment, illustrating how quickly investor sentiment can swing against infrastructure-heavy AI bets that may not be fully contracted or sustainable.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Trump’s AI order is less about coherent regulation and more about blocking any regulation.

Swisher calls the executive order “idiotic,” arguing it weaponizes federal power to pre-empt stricter state AI laws under the guise of ‘dominance,’ even though Congress has not set any baseline federal AI rules; she expects courts to block it and labels it a big-tech subsidy.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Media framing can subtly launder extremist talking points into the mainstream.

Galloway slams CBS’s Face the Nation for a question implying Mifepristone’s safety is in doubt, calling it a repackaged far-right narrative that undermines an FDA-approved, evidence-backed drug and women’s bodily autonomy under the guise of neutral concern.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Notable Quotes

We live in a country with a passive majority weaponized by well-funded special interest groups.

Scott Galloway

Atoms are more defensible than bits.

Scott Galloway

They don’t want to pass federal laws that would make sense. They just want to stop all regulation.

Kara Swisher (on Trump’s AI executive order)

This is the mandatory federal regulation they’ll have. DICK. They won’t have anything.

Scott Galloway (on the administration’s AI posture)

The happiest people aren’t the ones who are loved the most, it’s the ones who have the most people to love.

Scott Galloway

Questions Answered in This Episode

How should democratic societies balance fostering AI innovation with the need for meaningful regulation at both state and federal levels?

Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway open with the weekend’s mass shootings at Brown University and Sydney’s Bondi Beach, linking them to broader trends in gun access, radicalization, and rising antisemitism, while contrasting U. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

To what extent do campus rhetoric and social media amplification genuinely contribute to real-world violence or merely reflect long-standing prejudices?

They discuss the murder of Rob Reiner and Trump’s inflammatory reaction, using it to highlight the normalization of cruelty and illiberalism, and then pivot into AI: OpenAI’s ‘Code Red’ posture, Disney’s partnership with OpenAI, and Oracle’s risky AI bet tied to its OpenAI deal.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Given the ‘atoms vs bits’ argument, how should investors and policymakers think about the long-term resilience of digital-first AI firms compared with infrastructure-heavy companies like SpaceX or Disney’s parks?

The conversation turns sharply political with Trump’s new AI executive order, which they describe as an anti-regulation power grab designed to pre-empt state-level AI rules, calling it legally dubious, idiotic, and a pure play for big tech interests.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

What is the most constructive way for legacy media companies to engage with AI platforms without repeating the mistakes they made with early YouTube and social media?

Closing segments cover media consolidation (Paramount–Warner–Netflix–Disney–Apple chess), a stinging critique of CBS/Face the Nation’s Mifepristone framing, and personal reflections on friendship, mortality, and the importance of having people to love and advocate for you.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Where is the line between legitimate journalistic questioning and inadvertently amplifying extremist narratives, and how should newsrooms police that boundary in coverage of abortion, AI, and other polarized issues?

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Transcript Preview

Scott Galloway

This is the mandatory federal regulation they'll have, dick. They won't have anything.

Kara Swisher

(instrumental music) Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.

Scott Galloway

And I'm Scott Galloway.

Kara Swisher

How you doing, Scott?

Scott Galloway

I'm doing great. Thanks, Kara.

Kara Swisher

Weird weekend of-

Scott Galloway

Yeah.

Kara Swisher

... shootings and killings-

Scott Galloway

It's, it's upsetting every time.

Kara Swisher

... and pretty horrible stuff. We usually banter here, but I think we, we, um, should just get right to it, don't you think?

Scott Galloway

Yeah, I think so.

Kara Swisher

Yeah, so we wanna briefly acknowledge the horrific events of gun violence over the weekend. Uh, on Saturday, two people were killed and nine were injured at a shooting at Brown University. And on Sunday, at least 15 people were killed in a shooting at a Hanukkah celebration in Bondi Beach in Australia. Um, uh, eh, the authorities are still looking for the Brown shooter. They had a person of interest who they let go, which was, see, it probably disturbed people around that uni- university campus. The Bondi Beach shooters have been identified as a father and a son, what a terrible parent and bystander, and a bystander whose refugee parents had just arrived from Syria, wrestled a gun from one of the alleged attackers during the Bondi Beach shooting. As if that violence weren't enough, director and actor Rob Reiner and his wife Michelle were found dead in their LA home on Sunday, uh, eh, supposedly by hi- uh, apparently, according to, uh, lots of reports this, her, their son, their youngest son is being held up in the, um, in this, what looks like a murder. Donald Trump, of course, had to weigh in on this tragedy, posting on Truth Social a little while ago, "Rob Reiner, a tortured and struggling, but once very talented movie director and comedy star has passed away together with his wife, Michelle, reportedly due to the anger he caused others through his massive, unyielding, incurable afflictions with the mind-crippling disease known as Trump derangement sy- uh, sy- uh, syndrome." Uh, I can't believe he wrote this but, once again, of course I can. Um, so he said, "The raging obsession, uh, has, have driven people crazy and obvious paranoia is raising, ri- rise- reaching new heights as the Trump administration surpassed all goals and expectations with greatness," and then he said they should rest in peace. He's a terrible, terrible son of a bitch. Anyway, um-

Scott Galloway

Yeah, I just can't wait for the right to be as inflamed by the notion-

Kara Swisher

Yes.

Scott Galloway

... that anyone was dancing on Charlie Kirk's grave.

Kara Swisher

Yeah.

Scott Galloway

Uh, but this, this will, like, you know, this will just be Donald being Donald, right?

Kara Swisher

Yeah, exactly.

Scott Galloway

Uh, they won't, they won't-

Kara Swisher

I mean, it just-

Scott Galloway

... they won't-

Kara Swisher

... what a heinous piece of shit. Um, let's start with the shootings. Um, just for, personally, Amanda went to Brown, um, and, uh, it's, uh, knows the area very well. "It's a very open campus," she was telling me, and, uh, you know, it's sort of such a, uh, you know, very peaceful. I've been there a number of times with her, uh, in the area where it was taking place. Um, nobody knows why this particular... Well, 'cause people have guns, but, uh, why, the reasons, reasoning behind. The one in Bondi Beach was, uh, horrific, um, except for that one bystander who, who was just, uh, we- the, the video of it was astonishing that they-

Install uListen to search the full transcript and get AI-powered insights

Get Full Transcript

Get more from every podcast

AI summaries, searchable transcripts, and fact-checking. Free forever.

Add to Chrome