By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
The Twenty Minute VCWhy Now is the Time for the App Layer | Why Startups Should be TokenMaxxing | Mike Mignano, USV
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
70 min read · 13,825 wordsIntro
Mike Mignano 0:00 We have never handed over so much of ourselves to a technology before than we're about to do with agents. As a startup, you need every advantage you can get right now.
Harry Stebbings 0:09 Today, I'm thrilled to welcome Mike Mignano, who is the newest general partner at USV, to the show.
Mike Mignano 0:14 If I were the CEO of a startup right now, I would actually still be pounding the table to maximize token spend. We like to bet on businesses that literally obliterate markets and existing business models.
Harry Stebbings 0:25 He's also one of the early investors in Suno and Granola in his prior days. He's a former founder, having sold his business, Anchor, to Spotify many years ago.
Mike Mignano 0:34 This era of building AI products is, in many ways, about being first and about moving really, really fast. I think traditional media, in many respects, is dead.
Harry Stebbings 0:45 Ready to go? [upbeat music]
Fear of Failure vs Thrill of Winning
Harry Stebbings 0:57 Mike, dude, I am so looking forward to this. We first did our show when you were co-founder of Anchor.
Mike Mignano 1:04 Correct.
Harry Stebbings 1:04 And, uh-
Mike Mignano 1:04 10 years ago
Harry Stebbings 1:05 ... 10 years ago. I-
Mike Mignano 1:06 I looked it up
Harry Stebbings 1:07 ... I was underage. And-
Mike Mignano 1:09 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:09 And I remember Anchor was, like, the hottest thing in New York and in startups at the time. And I was, I was legit 18, 19, and I was absolutely shitting myself before our show 'cause, like, you were the-
Mike Mignano 1:21 Really?
Harry Stebbings 1:22 Yeah. You were the it boy of venture at the time.
Mike Mignano 1:24 For a minute. Like, five minutes-
Harry Stebbings 1:25 Yeah
Mike Mignano 1:26 ... maybe, at most.
Harry Stebbings 1:26 Well, now you get 20 seconds-
Mike Mignano 1:28 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:28 ... so I'd appreciate it. Um, dude, I, I wanna start, actually, with something that I ask a lot of great founders, but given your founding roots, I wanna ask it of you. It's are you motivated more by the fear of failure or by the thrill of winning?
Mike Mignano 1:44 I think both to some extent. I think the fear of failure is very, very, very important. I actually strongly believe that great, great things, great companies, great products, great people come from constraints, and I think that failure is the ultimate form of a constraint. You know, you talked about Anchor. Somebody just asked me the other day, they said, "At what point in your life did you do your best work?" And I thought about it, and the, the honest answer to that question was, [laughs] I believe I did my best work when we were three months out of cash. When we were about to run out of money and when we were about to fail is when we did our best work. It's so clarifying to know that you're gonna fail unless you turn the thing around. And so I think failure can be an incredible motivator, but I also think that you have to have insanely ambitious mission that you're trying to accomplish, right? You want, you wanna win. You have this hunger to achieve something really hard and really, you know, impossible-sounding. So I actually think you need to hold both things in your head to be successful, and I, and I try to do that.
Harry Stebbings 2:51 We were talking before about, like, insights that we had years ago. Um, years ago with Anchor, you wanted a very natural, conversational style record and let people listen in, and I was always like, "Nope, we want manufactured." Um, [laughs]
Mike Mignano 3:07 You were doing clips way before clips were cool.
Harry Stebbings 3:09 We were doing, we were doing clips. I was absolutely into the airbrushing of audio as we do today.
Mike Mignano 3:14 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 3:14 And we disagreed on that.
Mike Mignano 3:16 Yep.
Harry Stebbings 3:17 What are your thoughts on that now?
Mike Mignano 3:18 There's so much content, and the tools have gotten so much better that out of the box you can have a really, really decently sounding or looking podcast with almost no effort. And so if you wanna break out, you actually have to go above that. The baseline has to be excellence. The baseline has to be incredible editing. The baseline has to be, you know, a, a phrase that you used back, I remember, 10 years ago, insights per minute. And so now I'm actually a, a huge fan of insanely high production value when it comes to podcasts, when it comes to YouTube videos. Um, you know, we, we were talking a little bit before. You, you asked me about some of the content I've been producing and, um, you know, we've tried to do something very, very different where we actually break out of a studio, and we bring in multiple cameras and multiple mics, and we try to do something very, very, very high production value because I think that's the only way to stand out. So anyway, I think you were right.
Harry Stebbings 4:15 Uh, uh, but, but I mean-
Mike Mignano 4:16 But it took me 10 years to agree with you. [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 4:17 Listen, I was totally fishing for that. I was right.
Mike Mignano 4:19 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 4:19 I, I do, I do think insights per minute is important. I also think time to value is very important.
Mike Mignano 4:23 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 4:23 Pe- people ask the most stupid fucking question, which is, like, tell me, like, where did you grow up? Very little actually is often learned in the where did you grow up.
Mike Mignano 4:31 Where's y- what's your version of that question?
Harry Stebbings 4:33 Oh, I, I wanna go straight to the, like, are you motivated more by fear of, uh... Like, straight away there I have, like, someone on a hook.
Mike Mignano 4:39 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 4:39 You have to create hooks in content pretty early. I also think very much like venture. You have to be either really big or really small in content. You have to be very natural, kind of teenager putting their phone up on the side and hitting record, or you are Logan Paul or MrBeast or, like, us of venture.
Mike Mignano 4:59 Yep.
Harry Stebbings 4:59 Studio's all over London. It's much bigger. The, the mid-tier firm doing it from their kind of conference room office don't work, baby.
Mike Mignano 5:07 Yeah. Y- yeah, you gotta be on the extremes.
Harry Stebbings 5:10 Yeah.
Mike Mignano 5:10 I, I, I totally agree with you.
Harry Stebbings 5:12 So speaking of being on the extremes and constraints, you know, Lightspeed is a cash-constrained world to be in. It's tough over at Lightspeed, and you made the move to the extremely well-funded USV. No, I'm obviously joking. We're going from the very large to the very small, constrained USV in comparison. Why did you decide
Why Mike Left Lightspeed for USV
Harry Stebbings 5:34 to make that move, dude?
Mike Mignano 5:35 I decided to go to USV because I am from New York. Uh, I've always been in or around New York, and as a builder, when I was building Anchor in New York 10 years ago, I got to meet USV. And I had an incredible ex- despite them passing, had an incredible experience. Started a very, very long friendship. I ultimately became an LP in the funds, and I just really always appreciated their ability and their willingness to be really opinionated and to be very, very thesis-driven, even at times in which the market said it makes s- made sense to be very consensus-driven. And by the way, there have been times in the market, including recently, where being consensus-driven has been extremely valuable and extremely lucrative as a fund, so. But the way I like to work, the way I like to build, the way I like to bet is, is by being thesis-driven. And, and I recognize that Being thesis-driven can also be super risky, right? If you bet on a thesis and you're wrong, you miss and you fail.
Harry Stebbings 6:37 Well, the, well, the trouble is a thes- thesis, thesis-driven can also be conventional. And, and so, and so what I'm actually worried about is that what if the winners of venture and what if venture is just from this point out consensus-driven?
Mike Mignano 6:50 So I think that we are coming out of a time in the market where we have undergone-- we, we have went through a massive infrastructure build-out in AI. We've had these new companies, these new, these companies building these brand-new technologies which has, which have required vast amounts of capital to build out the infrastructure. And obviously, I'm talking about the labs. I'm talking about OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI, SpaceX, et cetera. And those required a lot of capital, and they produced magical technology that has generated billions. We're, we're about to see trillions of dollars in value. Um, but now that infrastructure is built, and it reminds me a lot of the early days of the inter- of the internet when we built out fiber and we built out broadband, and then we had these new technologies to play with. And the internet came along, and an application layer came along and took advantage of that new technology.
We're Past the AI Infrastructure Phase — Now It's About Applications
Mike Mignano 7:43 To me, it feels like we are back in that mode right now where we've got this infrastructure and now it's time for the applications to be built. And I think there's gonna be so many applications, so much software, uh, that you're not really gonna be able to make a bet unless you know what you're looking for. And I think that's what USV has always been great at, knowing what they're looking for and placing the bet when they see it.
Harry Stebbings 8:05 Brendan McCaw said the other day, uh, we will see much greater value accrue in the next 24 months at the infrastructure layer than we will at the application layer. Agree or disagree?
Mike Mignano 8:17 I think there is still value to be created and accrued to the infrastructure layer. We're not done. The build-out's not done. Um, but I also think now that we've got, uh, enough new toys at the technology that we will see massive value crea- creation in the application layer as well.
Harry Stebbings 8:34 Do you think the future of AI is always on? Sam Altman is suggesting so more and more in his kind of verbiage. God, it makes me excited for Nvidia if [laughs] the future of AI is always on. Do you agree with that?
Mike Mignano 8:48 I do think that we're entering a world in which context is increasingly valuable for the labs and also for the application layer, right? And so I think we will see products and businesses increasingly try to push us further and further along the edge to an always-on world. I mean, I can remember 10 years ago when I got, you know, an Alexa in my home and thinking to myself, "Wait a minute, this is, this is always listening for the wake world-- for the wake word?" And now we've, I think to your point, we've kind of moved past that, where, you know, let's say you're in a meeting. Uh, in-- you know, you're, you're, you're having a meeting. You're having a-- You're in a conference room. I think, you know, more often than not, I'm hearing somebody say, "Hey, I'm Granola-ing this," right? So I think we are moving more and more towards that world, for better or worse.
Harry Stebbings 9:36 Do you think the multi-stage funds deliver an amazing pre-seed and seed product? Because I, I... Okay, so I say this. I, I, I think you're probably also-- and there's no problem with this, but I think you're a little more protective of your brand than me. I don't worry about upsetting
Is AI "Always On" the Future?
Harry Stebbings 9:50 people.
Mike Mignano 9:50 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 9:51 I-- The worst place to be is a $50 to $100 million seed fund. You will get crushed by the large funds who are able to write large checks and lead rounds, but you're also not small enough to be collaborative. Very difficult middle ground to be in, I think. Do you agree?
Mike Mignano 10:07 I think the best funds in the world at doing seed are really, really good about building their networks and meeting amazing people. I think you've been doing a good job recently at empowering a new class of entrepreneurs here in Europe and in London, uh, with very, very, very early-stage seed checks. So I think you have to build a great network. I also think to do seed well, you have to put your ideas out there into the world. You have to show the market what you're looking for. You have to b- be willing to take a stand and take a position and say... You know, I, I just put out a, a, a post yesterday about, uh, the Rebel Alliance and saying, "Hey, at USV, we're really interested in the Rebel Alliance," this new univer- this new universe of open weight models and open source harnesses and distributed compute and agents, right? Human-aligned agents. And I think when you put things out into the world, you're, you're sending up a bat signal that's telling these early-stage founders that maybe haven't gone out into the world yet with a product, "Oh, this is the VC," or, "This is the person," or, "This is the team I should be talking to." So I think you need a great network, I think you need to ship your ideas, and I think you need to be willing to take bets on people, which again, I think you've done a, a good job of with your program.
Harry Stebbings 11:20 Can I ask you on the-
Mike Mignano 11:21 Sure
Harry Stebbings 11:21 ... kind of sh- shipping ideas, and this is why I love asking Advice Bun, is what if the ideas aren't fully formed? What if I'm just wrong and, and then I get a deluge of companies and actually the thesis wasn't what I thought it would be?
Mike Mignano 11:34 I think that's totally okay.
Harry Stebbings 11:36 It is?
Mike Mignano 11:36 I think much like building a startup or building a product, I think if you're investing, you also have to be willing [chuckles] to put yourself out there and take a risk and, and place a bet. Now listen, you can hedge that bet a little bit. You can place a counterposition bet in something else maybe to offset the risk of that. But I think you have to be willing to put yourself out there if you wanna succeed at anything in technology, whether it's a startup or a venture capitalist.
Harry Stebbings 12:04 Open weights, open harnesses, open models.
The Rebel Alliance: USV's Thesis on Open Weights & Human-Aligned Agents
Harry Stebbings 12:07 Ding, ding, ding, ding. We're gonna do a prediction round. Fun.
Mike Mignano 12:10 Okay.
Harry Stebbings 12:10 We-- I told you we had this like truth or like donate round with Chia.
Mike Mignano 12:13 Sure. Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 12:13 This is a new prediction round. The model landscape in five years' time, what does that mature-er, not mature, but mature-er market look like in terms of composition? The players, their weightings, what does that look like?
Mike Mignano 12:29 You know, one future is that the labs, especially the ones that are starting to approach something that feels like super intelligence, once they reach it, uh, if they reach it, once they reach it, we will have some form of recursive self-improvement such that we hit this exponential- ... growth of intelligence. And, you know, the h- the, the thinking goes that whoever gets there first will run away with it, right? Once you reach recursive self-im- self-improvement, you're gone. No one can catch up. And I think that is, uh, yeah, that's, that, that's not necessarily the future [laughs] that I am hoping for.
Harry Stebbings 13:11 For everyone who doesn't know-
Mike Mignano 13:12 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 13:12 ... what is recursive self-improvement?
Mike Mignano 13:14 This is, this is, this is self-improving AI, right? This is, this is super intelligent AI that can do its own AI research, right? So once you have it, once you deploy it, it can just continually re- improve itself on the exponential forever until it plateaus, until it self-limits in some way. And by the way, we don't, we don't know what that self-limiting factor may be. It may be that for some reason these architectures, you know, the transformer architecture, let's say, doesn't scale past a certain point. We don't know if that's going to happen. It could be that, uh, the model needs, uh, s- some amount of data that it can no longer access, right? There's a limit to the amount of data. It may mean that we can't keep up with the hardware infrastructure build that we need to, to keep, uh, recursively self-improving. So in the, in the past, in the history of new technology adoption, I mean, if you study them, they actually all follow S-curves, right? They have a slow takeoff, then they have what feels like an exponential ramp up, and then they plateau for some reason, like we just discussed. And that's potentially the second future for AI, right? We, we reach some plateau in terms of intelligence, and I think if that happens, then the technology might start to look somewhat more like a commodity, right? If it plateaus, then we're at a point where all the other labs can catch up, and they can all have the same technology. And if they all have the same technology, then we're gonna have a lot of competition. We're gonna have a lot of competition on, in terms of price, in terms of product experience, um, and in terms of the various components that make up the new intelligence stack.
Harry Stebbings 14:51 Okay, so if we go on the route one, recursive self-improvement, and it leads to this kind of exponential advancement, is that done by an OpenAI or an Anthropic or a leading model provider today, or is that done by a Recursive or one of the
What Happens If We Hit Recursive Self-Improvement?
Harry Stebbings 15:07 many others going after it? I was literally for two hours in Shoreditch yesterday with one. Uh, it... Or is that done by an entirely new company focused on recursive itself?
Mike Mignano 15:16 Yeah. I th- I think it's probably done by one of the labs that already has all these advantages, these vast compute advantages. They already have models that are at the frontier. They have the infrastructure. They have the chips. So I think it's probably done by one of them. That said, there are a bunch of amazing researchers working on incredible new architectures that maybe haven't broken through yet, but maybe they can. Maybe they're building something that is better than the transformer, right? There are a number of these labs out there, thinking machines, safe super intelligence from Ilya and Daniel. I think if I were to, to bet, I would, I would say the labs that already have the advantages, but that doesn't mean there isn't a new architecture being worked on in a lab somewhere that could leapfrog all of it.
Harry Stebbings 16:00 Okay. Number two is that actually we have less of this kind of exponential and more of a linear style. When you look at that kind of more mature market-
Mike Mignano 16:09 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 16:09 ... on the S-curve basis, what does that composition look like in terms of market between open and closed and Anthropic and OpenAI?
The S-Curve Future: AI Plateaus & the Market Commoditises
Mike Mignano 16:17 I think in that world, enterprises and, and, and individuals are probably optimizing for a couple of things. I think they're probably optimizing for cost, right? They're starting to think about the trade-offs between intelligence and spend and how they can optimize their token spend. So what does that mean? It probably means, you know, leveraging things like open weight and open source models. It probably means leaning into things like the routing layer to optimize the token usage towards, you know, the, the model that maybe gives you the most bang for your buck rather than always just token maxing and picking the most powerful model. I think the other thing it looks like is choosing tools and products and, you know, uh, one of y- you know, hate to use the new, the new buzzword of the past six weeks, harnesses that are maybe a little more human aligned. And-
Harry Stebbings 17:08 Can you help me? What the fuck is a harness?
Mike Mignano 17:10 [laughs] A harness-
Harry Stebbings 17:10 No, seriously, I feel so bad for that.
Mike Mignano 17:11 No, I know.
Harry Stebbings 17:12 Do you know, on, on X, I really want to do grok what is a harness, but I know everyone-
Mike Mignano 17:15 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 17:15 ... will be like, "Oh, harness."
Mike Mignano 17:16 I think of the harness as the application that tightly, tightly couples with the model. So in the case of, you know, Claude, it's like the Claude desktop app, and I would say specifically Claude Code and Claude Cowork that are sort of having this, this loop, this, this flywheel of product and model sort of engagement. Um, you know, some other harnesses that I think people are pretty excited about are, are things like Hermes. I consider Hermes a harness that you, that takes over your Mac Mini. I don't know if you've set it up yet. Um, Pi from Irondale is another great harness, European company. Um, so-
Harry Stebbings 17:50 Someone, someone legit called a harness after, like, one of the greatest fashion brands.
Mike Mignano 17:55 What's that?
Harry Stebbings 17:55 Hermes is, like, a fashion brand.
Mike Mignano 17:57 Oh, right. That's... Well, isn't that Hermès?
Harry Stebbings 18:00 Well, it's spelt the same, dude [laughs] .
Mike Mignano 18:02 [laughs] Good point. So a- anyway, I think, I think having products, agents, harnesses that are human aligned and aligned with your own goals and incentives, I think is gonna be really, really important. I think people are going to be a little more self-conscious about the incentives of the model they're using. Obviously, the incentives of the models that come out of the big labs are to make the lab's models smarter, better,
Who Is Your Agent Actually Working For?
Mike Mignano 18:28 faster. And you might, you might think to yourself, "Hey, if I'm outsourcing all of my agency and all of my personal information and these goals and my credit cards and all these things to an agent, I want that thing to work for me. I want that thing to be completely aligned with my incentives." Um, you know, I published a thing a few weeks ago, a few weeks ago on X called, um, Who Is Your Agent Working For? And- That was the big idea we were trying to get across with that, and that I think in the future, as you become more and more comfortable handing over the keys to an agent, you're want- you're gonna wanna know that it's working for you. So I think that's a little bit like what that second future looks like.
Harry Stebbings 19:09 I have to say, I think people will get incredibly comfortable handing over the keys in the same way that we got incredibly comfortable putting our credit cards online, using Apple Pay, finding our, our husband or wife online. Um, and I think that will be de facto in five years.
Mike Mignano 19:23 I, I, I think there's a chance you're right, but I-
Harry Stebbings 19:25 But I, I don't think anyone gives a shit about privacy other than hardcore technologists, and I know that's blunt and I'm gonna get killed for that.
Mike Mignano 19:31 No, no, no, you're not. I, I think there's a good chance you're right. Uh, you know, if we're just thinking in terms of bets and probabilities-
Harry Stebbings 19:37 Yeah
Mike Mignano 19:37 ... I think the history of the internet and personal computing suggests that you are right, Harry. But two things. First is I think we have never handed over so much of ourselves to a technology before than we're about to do with agents. Yes, you're right. We browsed the web. We used Chrome. We used, um-
Harry Stebbings 20:00 But it didn't do shit for us.
Mike Mignano 20:01 It didn't do shit for us.
Harry Stebbings 20:02 Yeah.
Mike Mignano 20:03 Right. We, we still got to control it, right? Yes, maybe we, we, we let these companies learn about our interests and the things we care about, but it wasn't out buying stuff for us, right? It wasn't out sending very personal messages to family members and loved ones. It wasn't a second self, right? It wa- it wasn't us. I think now we're gonna be doing stuff like that, and it might just make us think a little bit more about the incentives of the model that are doing those things for us. That's number one. Number two, I'm not sure that every model and every agent needs to be superhuman aligned. I'm not sure every person needs to care about it. I just think enough people have to care about it such that one player or a few players keep the others in check, right? I think we need market forces where a couple of good actors keep the rest of the other actors in check. So I, I, I think it's possible now. Is it gonna happen? I don't know. History says it won't, but I think it's possible.
Engineering Teams Are Getting Smaller
Harry Stebbings 21:04 Do you think Dario's had a massive own goal in terms of marketing and messaging? He, he's been saying about labor displacement for years. "Oh, everyone's gonna be unemployed." And telling your customers they're gonna be unemployed is always a bold statement.
Mike Mignano 21:14 What I see in Anthropic is I see an extremely mission-driven company, and I believe that mission-driven companies can be very, very successful. And Anthropic, you know, love 'em or hate 'em, there's no doubt they've been extremely successful. I think at the time of us recording this, they're the most valuable privately held company in the world.
Harry Stebbings 21:33 You know, I think core to the will they continue the exponential revenue growth that they've had is percent of spend in terms of developer salaries on tokens, and Marc Benioff said that he spent $300 million on Anthropic, which equ- on specifically for the dev team, which equates to 3.8% of dev salaries spent on tokens. Now, if that goes to 20%, Anthropic's grossly undervalued, that exponential revenue will continue, and well done everyone who's invested and all their employees. Great. If it goes to 100%, holy shit, this is just so much more big, larger than we ever thought-
Mike Mignano 22:09 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 22:09 ... it could be. But if it stays or if we see migration to open models, it's a very different game.
Mike Mignano 22:16 I think it's a risk. I think there are two schools of thought playing out right now w- with regards to token spend. I think one school of thought, which we're seeing, and I think when I really think about it probably applies more to the incumbents and the big companies, the Salesforces of the world rather than the startups, is that if every employee is just spending like crazy on tokens, the fundamentals of these businesses are gonna be in trouble. They're just too big, right? There are too many employees at a Salesforce or, I don't know, a Microsoft such that every employee can just have an unlimited token spend budget. So I think we're gonna see a lot of those companies start to constrain their spends, and we've seen mentions of things like these on X recently.
Harry Stebbings 23:02 We've seen Meta, Uber, Microsoft this week.
Mike Mignano 23:04 Totally.
Harry Stebbings 23:04 Yeah.
Mike Mignano 23:05 I think if you're a startup, the calculation probably looks a little bit different. Your organization is smaller, right? So you're not gonna have a situation where you have 5,000, 10,000, 50,000 employees just spending out of control. You can, you can more tightly control the spend. But also, I think as a startup, you need every advantage you can get right now. And so if I, you know, if I were the CEO of a startup right now, I would actually still be pounding the table to maximize token spend on the, on the right things, right? Definitely with coding, maybe not with other things. Just for simple tasks like summarization or, you know, operations type work, I'd probably be leveraging Sonnet or something. But if, if I'm at a startup and I'm coding, I wanna be using the frontier. I want every advantage I can get against Salesforce.
Harry Stebbings 23:52 And so if you are the best dev, are you gonna go to a big incumbent who are gonna give you a budget and really constrain your abilities in terms of model usage, or are you gonna go to a startup where fundamentally they say, "Hey, it's a free-for-all. Be your best self"?
Mike Mignano 24:04 I think you're gonna go to a startup, especially the startups right now that are mission-driven, especially the startups that are mission-driven, which by the way, I don't know that we've really been in that mode for the past couple of years. Yes, Anthropic's been mission-driven, but there's so much money and capital sloshing around the valley in this ecosystem, I think a lot of companies haven't needed to be mission-driven. I think now they will, and it's gonna work to their favor.
Harry Stebbings 24:27 Do you not think we enter a world though now where Fable will come back in some rejuvenated form one way or another, where Fable comes back and newer and better models come back, and you just have the 100X engineer, and you pay for that token spend, which is enormous, with the replacement of the 10 other mid engineers?
Mike Mignano 24:49 I do think eng- engineering organizations are going to evolve. Um, I don't know exactly what it looks like yet, but I think you will increasingly have- Probably somewhat smaller teams of higher caliber and higher quality engineers, because I think a lot of the lower level tasks increasingly can be delegated away to agents.
Harry Stebbings 25:11 In terms of the open ecosystem, when we look at it today, what percent of enterprise workflows do you think can be done
80% of Enterprise Tasks Don't Need Frontier Models
Harry Stebbings 25:18 with open?
Mike Mignano 25:19 80% of non-coding tasks in the enterprise can be done with models that are not at the frontier. I think if you're coding, you probably wanna be leveraging frontier models, but I think things like, you know, um, summarization or the generation of docs and briefs and things like this, I, I, I don't think you need to be at the frontier, and so you probably can leverage open source models. I think a lot of the open source models we're seeing are catching up faster than they were previously. So, um, I, I don't know that you need to be at the frontier if you're not coding.
Harry Stebbings 25:52 China have the best open source models. It's unbelievable to see the rate and the evolution of that open source ecosystem. Is that concerning, do you think?
China's Open Source Lead
Mike Mignano 26:00 I think, look, I think startups and teams go where the incentives are. I think as we shift to a world in which this Rebel Alliance might actually have a fighting chance, we're gonna see a lot of smart teams going more and more towards open.
Harry Stebbings 26:12 I'm really intrigued. You said about the routing layer. Do you fundamentally think there will be $10 to $50 billion companies built in the routing layer, or do you think, candidly, your inference providers like Fireworks or Baseten eat into that? Or candidly, if you wanna go a step above that, you've got Nebius who sits on top. When I had the founder of Nebius on, he's like, "We need..." I'm not gonna put on his accent 'cause I'll sound like a Bond villain, then he'll fucking kill me. But like, "You need to eat all of the stack."
Is There a $50B Company to Be Built in the Routing Layer?
Mike Mignano 26:39 I do think routing is interesting and important right now, right? I think, again, as enterprises are trying to optimize their token spend, they wanna make sure that the model they're using is the right model for the job, not only in terms of its capability and what it can get done, but its cost. And so you're gonna have companies that are singularly focused on this, companies like OpenRouter, uh, out of New York, which is doing some really interesting work. And then you're also gonna have companies that are leveraging, uh, other parts of the stack for their products that build their own routing layer, uh, as an opportunity to monetize. Actually, we've talked to a number of companies building at various different levels of the stack that when you talk to them about their business model, they talk about building a routing layer and monetizing the routing layer. So I think it's a really interesting area that has a lot of opportunity, and a lot of different companies are gonna go after it, uh, because they see the potential.
Harry Stebbings 27:36 How do you monetize a routing layer without becoming just a commodity pipe?
Mike Mignano 27:42 It's a good question. I think a lot of companies right now are thinking about, you know, charging a small margin on top of it, and I think to your point, that might not be a great business model. Um, I put out a piece on X about this a few weeks ago, and a number of people chimed in with some of their ideas. And one interesting idea I heard was this notion of almost a bounty model at the routing layer, where the m- where the routing layer gets, um, gets rewarded for choosing the right model, right? So if you choose the most efficient model or the best model for a certain task, that's when they collect a fee, and I thought that was kind of an interesting idea. Haven't necessarily seen it built out yet, but I thought it was a pretty interesting idea.
Harry Stebbings 28:24 I think it's hard to see that $50 billion company built in routing alone, I have to say.
Mike Mignano 28:29 Maybe. Uh, on the other hand-
Harry Stebbings 28:31 And then you-
Mike Mignano 28:31 ... you know, we've seen time and time again in the enterprise, in infrastructure specifically, that these infrastructure companies, they become deeply embedded in the developer work- workflows and in the developer ecosystems, and you just can't rip them out because it just becomes the gold standard. So maybe somebody will build that routing layer that every developer d- adopts and never wants to remove.
Harry Stebbings 28:54 Would you say it's unfair of me to say that USV missed the model game?
Mike Mignano 28:58 I think USV was playing a different game, and that's actually been the history of USV. USV-
Harry Stebbings 29:03 Is the game not unbelievable returns in generational defining companies?
Mike Mignano 29:08 [laughs] So USV, again, I think has never been afraid to take a position, and I think USV maybe, uh, did not invest in any of the big model layer companies. Um, but what USV now has been doing for a number of years, and, and I'm, I'm a big believer that we haven't seen the full circle of this narrative play out, is they've been betting on energy. And they've been b- they've been betting on energy since 2001. Um, and the idea has been for a long time now that [clears throat] no matter what model wins, if you believe in AI and if you believe in intelligence, there's going to be an energy layer underneath that is gonna be needed to power these
USV's Long Bet on Energy Since 2021
Mike Mignano 29:49 things. And over the time since 2001, we've, we've learned that we only need even more energy than we thought, and we need more portability of energy than we thought. And so, um, you know, energy is a big theme at USV. It was starting in 2001, and it still is to this day in 2000-- or 2026. Did I say 2001? I meant 2021.
Harry Stebbings 30:08 How do you think about investing in energy given the CapEx intense nature of it? You know, we're investing in a company called Fuse Energy, which I think is incredible. I'm so happy with. But it, it, it's a CapEx intensive business-
Mike Mignano 30:21 It is
Harry Stebbings 30:21 ... in terms of, like, the energy space.
Mike Mignano 30:23 It is, but I think there's also a lot of innovation happening. And where there's innovation, you can, you can find early teams that are doing science experiments before anyone else is thinking about them. USV a few years ago, uh, invested in a great company called Radiant, which is building small nuclear reactors that literally come off of a factory line, you know? And it's gonna be one of the first companies in the world to test, um, in the dome in the United States, um, for, for nuclear energy. And so I think there are a lot of interesting models and ideas happening on the edge of, of innovation, and I think those are the best places to bet as a venture capitalist because in the earliest days, they're actually not that- Um, capital intensive
Harry Stebbings 31:05 Do you know what story I fucking love? Boom Supersonic
Mike Mignano 31:08 Crazy
Harry Stebbings 31:08 Yeah. Like turbo, like you know. Don't get me wrong, we all love Concorde-
Mike Mignano 31:12 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 31:12 ... and Blake. I love flying too, dude
Mike Mignano 31:14 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 31:14 Game on. But like, it's like, but there's this massive business in turbines for AI.
Mike Mignano 31:19 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 31:19 What a wonderful world
Mike Mignano 31:21 We, we have a bet in a company called Roon. Amazing company. Have you heard of Roon?
Harry Stebbings 31:24 No
Mike Mignano 31:24 They're building micro data centers that sit directly next to generators, wind- you know, wind farms and things like that, to solve the portability issue. How do you get the energy as close as possible, as quickly as possible to the compute, to the data centers? And so, you know, I think we're, we're, we're on the lookout for things like this that are sort of innovating the model of energy and portability of energy
Harry Stebbings 31:48 Isn't this just like the joy of capitalism? I met Panthelassa, you know, this company that does data centers-
Mike Mignano 31:52 No
Harry Stebbings 31:53 ... at sea
Mike Mignano 31:53 Oh, wow
Harry Stebbings 31:53 Um, and it's just like fundamentally to Adam Smith's invisible hand, kind of the market solves itself-
Mike Mignano 31:59 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 32:00 ... in terms of we got an energy crisis, and then you get Roon and Panthelassa and Elon building data centers in space
Mike Mignano 32:06 It's crazy
Harry Stebbings 32:07 Fucking love-
Mike Mignano 32:07 It's awesome
Harry Stebbings 32:08 Isn't it-
Mike Mignano 32:08 It's a cool time. It's a fun time to be investing
Harry Stebbings 32:11 It is, and this is why I get really pissed off with a lot of European entrepreneurs who are still building SMB accounting solutions
Mike Mignano 32:17 Mm. Mm. Hey, look, I mean, I think that there's an opportunity for, for automation in, in the enterprise. Personally, I, I, I would much rather, uh, build products and companies that obliterate. That's actually something we talk about at USV all the time. Don't automate, obliterate. Um, but hey-
Harry Stebbings 32:36 So what does that mean-
Mike Mignano 32:36 ... some people wanna automate
"Don't Automate - Obliterate": How USV Picks What to Invest In
Harry Stebbings 32:37 What does that mean, don't automate?
Mike Mignano 32:38 Well, you just talked about automation and you talked, I, I think you were talking about SaaS in a sense. I think there have been amazing companies built that automate existing workflows, existing processes. Um, but at USV, we like to bet on businesses that obliterate, that literally obliterate markets and existing business models. And so, you know, we're-- we, we actually don't do a lot of enterprise investing for this exact reason. Enterprise investing often requires selling to a middleman, you know, selling to, um, selling to customers or building things that just make existing businesses faster. We want to invest in businesses that literally reinvent the way something is done. Take Doctronic as an example. Are you familiar with Doctronic?
Harry Stebbings 33:24 No
Mike Mignano 33:24 USV led the seed in Doctronic a couple of years ago. At the time, it seemed like a crazy idea. It was the idea of AI putting a doctor in literally everyone's pocket. Now, we could've invested in AI that make medical practices faster or more efficient or help you with, you know, insurance claims, or-
Harry Stebbings 33:42 That's what I did. [laughs]
Mike Mignano 33:43 ... we can put doctors in everyone's pocket and totally reinvent the model with AI. So I think that's what we're talking about when we talk about obliterate, don't automate
Harry Stebbings 33:53 Doctronic, doctor in your pocket, da, da, da. It reminds me of education. Sorry, I didn't mean that disparagingly. That's awesome. I'm like-
Mike Mignano 34:00 Yeah. [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 34:01 [laughs] But it reminds me... Sorry. Education kind of reminds me of the same actually. And do you know who the biggest winners are in both education and in, um, uh, medicine in most cases?
Mike Mignano 34:13 Who's that?
Harry Stebbings 34:13 It's the horizontal players.
Mike Mignano 34:15 Mm.
Harry Stebbings 34:15 It's YouTube
Mike Mignano 34:15 Mm
Harry Stebbings 34:16 And my worry is, especially with like health, ChatGPT is second most used thing-
Mike Mignano 34:23 Maybe
Harry Stebbings 34:24 ... is health. And so my question to that tide is not tied to Doctronic, it's how do you think about where model providers will go and eat into the application layers and not kill
How Abridge Built a Healthcare Moat Over 8 Years
Harry Stebbings 34:36 our lunch?
Mike Mignano 34:36 May- maybe. We just talked about Abridge. I think you had Shiv on here recently
Harry Stebbings 34:40 Yeah
Mike Mignano 34:40 Abridge has been working on this problem for close to 10 years now, and it's given them a massive advantage. It turns out in highly regulated industries like healthcare, you can't just walk in the door and, and say, "Hey, we're gonna do healthcare now." You have to actually build relationships, build partnerships, clear through regulatory hurdles, and that ends up being a form of a moat. And so, you know, USV invested in Abridge, I think in 2018, right? Eight years ago now. And it took that company, you know, five, six, seven years to hit this inflection point now where this product is being used by so many doctors in so many different healthcare systems because they were able to clear those hurdles. And so, look, I think we can say that we live in a world where the labs and the hyperscalers can take over any product in any market, but the reality is that's been the story of technology and innovation since the beginning of time. There are always going to be startups and founders and entrepreneurs that specialize and do the really hard things before anyone else has thought of them that end up prevailing. I mean, just take Spotify, which we talked about at the beginning, right? Spotify went up against a, a behemoth. It's a classic David and Goliath story, and they could've be k- could've been killed 50 different ways along the way, but they specialized, and they did the hard thing early and often, and now they're obviously the winner. So I hear you, uh, that the labs can kind of go into any application layer, but not only do I think that that's not true, I also just think it's not really fun. And what fun can we have as venture capitalists if we don't believe that startups can take down the Goliath?
Harry Stebbings 36:21 I'm also not sure if it's as binary, even if they do. You know, you saw Claude and Anthropic dedicate an entire team to design and to go up against Figma. Figma's still a business that does multiple billions in revenue, and there's still multiple players in the space
Mike Mignano 36:34 Great product. Yeah
Harry Stebbings 36:35 Great product. It's not-
Mike Mignano 36:37 Trusted brand
Harry Stebbings 36:38 Uh, trusted. You know, my biggest mistake also, especially on the developer landscape, was I thought that there would be like a runaway, and of course Claude has run away and done amazingly well. But Lovable's at 500 Million AR, Cognition is, Replit is, uh, you know, Anthropic Co-Codex is crushing. They've all crushed
Mike Mignano 36:55 There usually isn't a market winner that takes 100% of the market or, you know, 80, 80% of the market. Usually what you see is that the market winner takes something like 30% of the market Right? Which means the 70% remaining is totally up for grabs. And if the market's big enough, that can produce some really large winners.
Harry Stebbings 37:16 Can I ask you, do you see different deals at USV to the types that you saw at Lightspeed? I'm not saying bad or worse. Do you just see different?
Mike Mignano 37:24 I think that when, you know, going back to what we talked about earlier with Seed, I think if you put yourself out there in the world, you're gonna see deals that match those themes and ideas. Not to say I didn't do that at Lightspeed. We did that at Lightspeed as well, but to the point earlier about being very focused on energy, right? We're now being very focused on this Rebel Alliance. We're gonna see a lot of those companies come to us. And I think when you're small, you kinda have to pick your spots. You have to have constraints and focus on a small number of things. And so I think to the extent that we see things different, it's because we focus really, really deeply,
The Model Provider Threat to the Application Layer
Mike Mignano 38:01 and for a period of time, we may only look at a couple of different areas that we have theses on.
Harry Stebbings 38:06 What are you unsure of right now that is worrying you? Like, to my point earlier, um, I think a lot of people are concerned by the intrusion from model providers into the application layer, where investors in Agora, Anthropic are, are very openly suggesting they wanna come into legal. I think that's fucking moronic for multiple reasons [chuckles] . When you're chasing AGI to be like, "Ah, we're gonna go after your lunch, Clifford Chance or Slaughter and May." Doesn't make much sense.
Mike Mignano 38:34 Look, I, uh, as much as I say that there's always gonna be opportunity for startups and that, you know, one model or one camp- company can't, can't do everything, of course, you still worry about competitive threats. Um, you know, I, I, I'm... As you know, like, I, I partnered closely with, uh, Granola when I was at Lightspeed, Suno as well. I mean, those are two startups going up against massive, massive incumbents. Granola in particular, you know, OpenAI launched a directly competitive product, right? Notion, a very well-funded startup, launched a directly competitive product. And so I, I do worry about that, but I think again, that's, that's always been the worry when you're building in startups.
Harry Stebbings 39:15 Is the worry not for Granola just breaking into enterprise? Like, like traditional enterprise. Like Notion have found it incredibly hard to break into traditional enterprise. These are startup and venture-funded products, which is amazing, and you can get to 500 million in revenue, but you need to be 5 billion in revenue.
Mike Mignano 39:33 I think the nice thing about Granola, what it really has going for it, and one of the things that I, I believe has helped that company in enterprise penetration is being really focused. Right? They're just doing notes. They're just doing notes. I think there are other companies, startups selling into the enterprise, that try to do, you know, many different things.
Harry Stebbings 39:55 But dude, I think you gotta do more.
Mike Mignano 39:57 Maybe, but I think you wanna get your foot in the door, and I think when you wanna get your foot in the door, you wanna sell one thing. And once you're in, then you can, you can expand horizontally to different categories. But I think if you come in expanded really, really wide, now you have to convince the enterprise to give up all these different things,
Why Being First & Moving Fast Is the AI Product Playbook
Mike Mignano 40:17 right? You gotta give up your Gmail and your Google Docs and your Google Sheets and your calendar, right? And this and that. Whereas if you're just doing meeting notes, it's like, "Hey, we're just gonna be your second brain for your company," right? "We're not gonna do anything else. We're just gonna be your second brain. Oh, and by the way, we're the best at it."
Harry Stebbings 40:35 Do you not worry about the enduring wave of Microsoft and bundling, whether it's Teams that crushes or whether it's, you know, Copilot, that it's... I mean, these products are-
Mike Mignano 40:46 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 40:46 ... Microsoft has built a business on doing 65 to 70% meh products-
Mike Mignano 40:50 I-
Harry Stebbings 40:50 ... but with the power of bundling, beat the competitors.
Mike Mignano 40:53 I do worry about that, of course. Absolutely. We saw this play out with Slack. By the way, Slack is still around. It's still a massively valuable product. But yes, I do worry-
Harry Stebbings 41:00 And like 27 bill... I love the way we say this. It's like 27 bill... I'll, I'll take it.
Mike Mignano 41:03 Yeah. I do worry about it. What I've also learned about AI products and Granola is that context is extremely valuable, right? If Granola gets inside of your organization and everyone in the organization starts using it and producing and accumulating all of this amazingly rich and valuable context, that's not something you as an enterprise wanna give up. You don't wanna give up that context. You've built out this incredibly rich history of information, um, that actually helps you work better. So I, I, I think, I think this era of building AI products is in many ways about being first and about moving really, really fast.
Harry Stebbings 41:50 You know what worries me is just, like, the meh of such large outcomes. And, and again, this all sounds incredibly disparaging-
Mike Mignano 41:57 [chuckles]
Harry Stebbings 41:57 ... and it's not meant at all because, fuck, I'm a podcaster, so incredible disclaimer.
Mike Mignano 42:02 And a VC.
Harry Stebbings 42:03 But my point being, like, when you have a SpaceX that's 3 trillion, j- Elon Musk made more money overnight than Warren Buffett has done in his entire career.
Mike Mignano 42:12 Credit to him.
Harry Stebbings 42:12 Credit to him. Well done. God bless capitalism.
Mike Mignano 42:14 What an amazing entrepreneur.
Harry Stebbings 42:15 Amazing entrepreneur. God bless capitalism. But my point is, like, when you have the outcome sizes of Anthropic and OpenAI and the trillion-dollar companies, the kind of... The company that does 500 million in ARR are [sighs] tough.
Mike Mignano 42:32 I think it all goes back to what are you optimizing for? What's your mission? What are your constraints? We talked about VC early on, um, before we stepped into the studio here. USV has always had small funds. It's the game we like to play, and, you know, you can be very successful in terms of what you're trying to accomplish as a venture firm with a small fund. Now, maybe it's, maybe that same model can't work if you have a $10 billion fund, but we're playing a different game, and I think you're playing a different game too.
Harry Stebbings 43:06 I sp- A hun- I would not do venture without media. I said to my LPs the other day two things that really ch- shocked them. Um, I said, "You can't do Series A unless you have a $400 million fund today. Absolutely no chance."
Mike Mignano 43:17 Well, Series As are expensive now. They're, you know, they're 100 million post. Um, there are 80 million posts. There are occasionally 150 million posts. And so yeah, if you wanna write a check into a round that size and get decent ownership for your, your f- your fund, you have to have a slightly bigger fund than you had three years ago.
Series A Valuations Are Now $80–150M Post
Harry Stebbings 43:35 Are you being more elastic on ownership?
Mike Mignano 43:37 I think it depends on stage. I think at the, you know, the way we think about at USV is at the, the Seed and Series A stage, ownership is important, and the reason is the outcomes are bigger right now. You talked about it. And the companies that end up doing really, really well raise a lot of capital a lot- very, very quickly, and the valuations get very high. And in those later rounds, it's actually very, very hard to buy ownership, especially if you're a small fund. And so you have to get that ownership early on. And Seed at the Series A-- Seed and Series A are kind of the rounds where you can do that. Now, once a company sort of crosses that chasm, maybe into the Series B or to the Series C, and you can identify them as being market leaders and potential generational companies, then I think it matters less. Then it's just about getting capital into those companies and underwriting it as a cash-on-cash type outcome. Forgetting about percentages, just imagining, okay, if we put $25 million into this, you know, what can the multiple be on that? Is it a 10X? Is it 100X? Is it 1,000X? [laughs] If it is, you know, if it's something really big like that, then you don't really need to think about ownership.
Harry Stebbings 44:51 We just did a deal together, uh, and by the time this comes out, it'll be announced. I actually got a message from the founder overnight, which is why I'm able to talk about it. Paul at FOMO.
Mike Mignano 45:00 Oh, nice.
Harry Stebbings 45:01 Yeah.
Mike Mignano 45:02 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 45:02 And you guys did that round later.
Mike Mignano 45:05 Later for us.
Harry Stebbings 45:06 Yeah, and that was why I asked that question.
Mike Mignano 45:08 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 45:09 But you saw the size of market, and for people that don't know, it's the next-generation trading app in many respects.
Mike Mignano 45:15 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 45:15 Um, I guess you saw that multiple expansion at the entry price you came in at.
Mike Mignano 45:19 Th- that's a perfect example. You know, we, we saw that where it was, and we said to ourselves, "How big can we see this getting? We think it can be a lot bigger than it is now." And so for this one, we're not gonna be ownership focused. We're just gonna, we're gonna put a check in. You know, we, we may not be able to bet every round from here out because, again, we have constraints to the size of our funds. Uh, but we think there's enough opportunity and enough upside from here that it's worth it.
Harry Stebbings 45:43 Should you do it if you don't think there's, like, a mega outcome? I know that sounds strange.
Mike Mignano 45:47 I'm not sure. At, for, for us, for USV at the later stages, if we don't think that there's a gigantic outcome, it probably doesn't make sense for us to bet.
Harry Stebbings 45:56 But even should you do it early if it's not a gigantic outcome is my kind of question.
Mike Mignano 46:01 Look, I think in general, you always wanna believe that the things you're betting on are playing in large markets with very, very large surface areas, and we're gonna look at every company that way. But I do think that because our funds are smaller, similar to yours, there's probably more downside protection for us in that model than, say, at a larger fund where you have to multiply billions of dollars. For us, the fund that we're investing out of now, the core fund, it's a $275 million core fund. And so you can, you can multiply that a lot easier than multiplying, say, several billion dollars, especially if you get the same type of ownership that a, that a larger fund is getting.
Harry Stebbings 46:38 I think it will be the best time ever, though, for the very large platform funds, and I think they'll be able to deliver venture-like returns because of the expansion in outcome sizes. Do you think that's true or not? When you look at, like, a Thrive-
Mike Mignano 46:51 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 46:51 ... I mean, their numbers are better than 90% of seed fund numbers on their growth, growth vehicle.
Mike Mignano 46:57 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 46:57 When you look at... I mean, you know, they have made a precursor phenomenal. We, uh, the OpenAI fund obviously are incredible. Like, they are getting venture outcomes on multi-billion dollars.
Mike Mignano 47:08 W- w- we think that we are coming out of a period where there has been a massive infrastructure build-out and very, very capital intense companies. Um, I think that firms, large firms that were able to invest in those very capital intensive companies have done phenomenally well. But again, I think we're also now playing in a world where there w- will be a proliferation of startups and apps at the application layer that are less capital intensive. And for those, again, I think you're gonna need to know what you're looking for, and I think you can, you can get in those companies at more modest check sizes. Now, I don't think you can have a fund that's in the middle to do that. I think you need to either be on the, on the large end and play the consensus game or be really small and really opinionated and multiply a much smaller fund.
Harry Stebbings 47:58 Are you elastic on price? You know, I, candidly, we, we've lost two deals in the last year.
Mike Mignano 48:04 Mm-hmm.
Harry Stebbings 48:05 Um, and listen, we got outbid. Um, I don't know if we would've won if we'd paid the same price. I hate people that say that as a-
Mike Mignano 48:11 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 48:11 ... but by, like, two or 3X, we bid 150, and another we got b- outbid by 300, another we outbid 400. Should I have just paid?
Mike Mignano 48:21 I, I talked to my partner, Fred Wilson. Gotta shout out Fred, one of the, one of the GOATs, and I asked him a question. I said, "What is, what is the biggest lesson you've learned in VC?" Actually, I asked him, "What are a couple of the biggest lessons?" And one of them was never pass on price. So Fred says never pass on price. I think in reality, there's probably some nuance. Just to bring it back to the USV strategy, I think for us, again, if we're investing a little bit later stage, we need to really believe that it's a market winner, and the multiple can be very, very, very high. And in that case, I think we can be a little bit more elastic on price. But I think at the earliest stages, especially when we're investing out of our, you know, our, our small funds, um, I, I do think there will always be a limit for us on price just because otherwise we can't make the fund math work.
Harry Stebbings 49:14 You know why my job is just incredible is 'cause I, I, I really am a student of this business. And by the way, you said shout out to Fred. I emailed Fred when I was 17 years old, and him and Brad Feld both responded to me within 30 minutes.
Mike Mignano 49:27 Wow.
Harry Stebbings 49:27 Like, that is the testament to giving time to people when, you know, candidly, I was, I had nothing. Um-
Mike Mignano 49:33 I, I told a story on that, that podcast, uh, where When Anchor first launched, I had never met Fred, and, um, the Anchor app accidentally auto-tweeted for Fred. And he has a big follower count on Twitter at the time, uh, now it's X obviously, and he was not happy about that. He, he started lighting me up on, on, on Twitter. This is one of the day, like the day after we launched Anchor. And, um, obviously that was uncomfortable for me as a first-time founder. But to your point, I cold emailed him right after the fact, and I apologized and I offered to troubleshoot it with him, and he responded immediately, and he was super gracious and, and forgiving and understanding. And so I, I had a similar experience.
Harry Stebbings 50:20 And I think all publicity is good publicity.
Mike Mignano 50:22 [laughs] Yes, true.
Harry Stebbings 50:23 Actually, you probably gain-
Mike Mignano 50:24 Yeah, we, we got a lot of publicity from that. [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 50:26 Yeah, you probably do. Um, never pass on price. Where I was going with the student adventure style is-
Mike Mignano 50:30 Sure
Harry Stebbings 50:31 ... I think it actually goes something that Peter Fenton told me-
Mike Mignano 50:33 Mm
Harry Stebbings 50:33 ... which is use price as a litmus test for your conviction.
Mike Mignano 50:36 There you go.
Harry Stebbings 50:36 And it's like-
Mike Mignano 50:37 That's good
Harry Stebbings 50:37 ... actually there are founders like Alan Chang at Fuse or Jack at Airwise. You could treble the price and I'd still pay it today.
Mike Mignano 50:44 Yeah. Absolutely.
Harry Stebbings 50:45 You have founders like this where if you doubled the price, you're like, "I'd still pay it. I'd still-"
Mike Mignano 50:48 Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I can think of some of the best deals I've done and y- you know, even though I'm, I'm happy with where the price landed, in hindsight, I'd probably pay double the price if I could go back and do it again.
Harry Stebbings 50:59 If I were to ask you what are your biggest lessons now having been in venture, in the same way that you asked Fred-
Mike Mignano 51:04 Mm
Harry Stebbings 51:04 ... what would you say they are?
Biggest Investing Lesson: Never Project Your Own Ideas on Founders
Mike Mignano 51:06 You, you can't project your own ideas on the founder. Sure, you can offer ideas, of course, if the founder wants. But especially as a f- as a former operator, you know, you often think, "Oh, I, I know how this business should be built," or, "I know how this product should work." And I think that can really, really get you into trouble. You know, one of my, uh, former partners, uh, Jeremy Liew at Lightspeed, I, I made this mistake a few times and, and he called me up one day and he said, "Hey, I, I think you're, you're, you're projecting as a former founder." And he's like, "In my experience, that's very, very dangerous and very risky." And I think it was a great lesson. Um, the reality is, even if you have great ideas and you think you know the answer, even if you're right, by the way, the reality is it's the founder's company, and they may wanna build it a completely different way. And not only that, if you project your ideas on a team that you're evaluating, um, you might get it completely wrong, right? You might look at a business and say, "I know what this company needs to do. It needs to do A, B, C, D, and then it's gonna win." But if you make your bet based on that evaluation and that judgment, and that team doesn't do those four things, you made a bad bet. So don't project. Don't project. You have to really believe in the team and the team's judgment and the team's ability to execute on their own plan. So that was a, that was a big lesson for me as a former CEO.
Harry Stebbings 52:26 Founder, Market, Product.
Mike Mignano 52:28 There you go.
Harry Stebbings 52:28 Rate them one through three.
Founder, Market, Product
Mike Mignano 52:30 When I first started this job, I would've said product, market, founder. I've completely flipped that. Now founder, market, product. Um, I think that the founder is the most important thing. Um, at the end of the day, most startups, especially early stage startups, they're gonna pivot in, in some form or another. What's most important is are they resilient? Can they execute? Can they adapt to change?
Harry Stebbings 52:57 When you get founder reads wrong, what do you not see that you wish you'd seen?
Mike Mignano 53:02 I often see communication as a, as a big hurdle for, for founders. I think one of the hardest things you can do as a leader is communicate effectively, because I think communication touches every part of company building. Uh, it's part of recruiting, which as we know, is one of the most important things you could do. You have to be able to communicate your mission, your values, why you exist, what you're trying to accomplish. Um, you have to communicate to investors, right? If you're not a great communicator, you're not gonna be able to raise capital. You're not gonna be able to put venture dollars into the business. You need to be able to communicate your product vision to your team, right? How can you align the team around building the perfect product if you can't communicate it? And you have to be able to tell your story to the market. When I think about some of the, the, the mistakes I've made in evaluation, it's, it's, it's maybe been on communication. That's probably been one of the biggest.
Harry Stebbings 53:55 What do you think the single biggest mistake in venture is you've made in terms of miss? I would say mine probably is one that you gave me, which is... Well, two of yours. I, I, I turned down Suno when David Frank at Founder Collective introduced me at the seed. Um, you know what the lesson was there? Really interesting. And I hope Mikey's okay with me saying this. I'm sure he is. Um, it, uh, it was a 250K check or a 200K check.
Mike Mignano 54:18 Mm.
Harry Stebbings 54:18 And so the ownership was, you know, 1%.
Mike Mignano 54:21 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 54:21 And I was like, "No, I need to be high ownership."
Mike Mignano 54:23 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 54:23 "My LPs tell me high ownership." And Granola honestly was a lack of imagination. Chris, I saw, was great, but, like, it was a very unformed idea.
Mike Mignano 54:32 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 54:33 And I was like, I can't just-
Mike Mignano 54:34 Founder
Harry Stebbings 54:34 ... I can't-
Mike Mignano 54:35 Founder first
Harry Stebbings 54:35 ... W- Founder only thing.
Mike Mignano 54:37 Yeah. Yeah. [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 54:37 When founders, the, the other two don't exist.
Mike Mignano 54:39 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 54:40 Terrible mistakes there for both. Ironically, both were f- You know, you did very well on, so congrats.
Suno: Thesis-Driven Bet vs Granola
Harry Stebbings 54:45 What do you-
Mike Mignano 54:45 Two different motions, by the way.
Harry Stebbings 54:46 Sure.
Mike Mignano 54:47 Granola for me was a pure founder bet. Pure founder bet. I knew Chris. I've known Chris now for 15-plus years.
Harry Stebbings 54:54 He's also not an amazing seller. I'm just gonna give it, uh, and be blunt. He-
Mike Mignano 54:58 But I knew Chris up close.
Harry Stebbings 55:00 That's the-
Mike Mignano 55:01 Um, you know, I, I... So when I was building Anchor, the, the Socratic office, Socratic was his previous startup, was right behind ours. And we did a few meetups together. You know, we've gotten our, we got our teams together for a few happy hours, and I, and I t- you know, we, I, I would talk to him as another founder, and we would share our struggles and, you know, get advice from each other. And I w- I just, I was like, "This guy, I know he can do it. I, I've seen him. I've seen him do it." Pure founder bet. Suno was something very different. Suno was a pure thesis-driven bet. For me, the thesis came from actually the days of Anchor and seeing what it meant for a product to democratize a creative medium, and music had never really been fully democratized before AI. So I went out and I met with every team Building AI for music. I went out and I hunted down every team [chuckles] and then, and then of course, I met Mikey and the team and I was like, "Wow, this is an incredible team." And, and then the founder-- n- then the founder lens came on and I was like, "This is an incredible team."
Harry Stebbings 56:02 How obvious is it when you meet a founder that you want to invest?
Mike Mignano 56:06 Um, with Mikey and the Suno founders, it was immediate. I, I met Mikey-
Harry Stebbings 56:10 Is it normally immediate?
Mike Mignano 56:12 Um, not always. Not always. With Suno it was. Uh, Mikey and I sat down, uh, at a restaurant in, uh, n- near my home in, in Hoboken, New Jersey. He-- His, his family's in Jersey, so we met up, uh, in Hoboken and, um, we just immediately hit it off. Like just instant, instant connection and, you know, I immediately recognized how, not only how smart he and the team were about the models they were building, about their vision for the world, but also how passionate they were about the problem. Mikey is a former musician, and so I felt like he could deeply, deeply connect to this idea of how do you make music creation, expressing yourself, creativity, how do you make it easier? And so, um-
Harry Stebbings 57:00 When you're doing Suno at $5B, what are you underwriting that to?
Mike Mignano 57:04 So we believe that Suno has, you know, I'm, I'm using this term loosely, but unlimited upside potential. Um, you know, if you look back at the history of media on the internet and you think about the generational platforms that truly democratized a medium, right? YouTube, TikTok, um, you know, Twitter, Facebook to some extent with writing and publishing. I mean, these are insanely valuable platforms-
Harry Stebbings 57:31 Does, does Suno not-
Mike Mignano 57:32 And you don't, and you don't really think about the upside of them.
Harry Stebbings 57:34 Does Suno not have to move from a tool to a platform then?
Suno at $5B
Mike Mignano 57:37 So I probably would've said yes when I invested. First of all, I, I, I do think it is a platform, but I think you're asking about something different. You're asking-
Harry Stebbings 57:46 A consumption platform.
Mike Mignano 57:46 Yeah, you're talking about do you need a creator side and a consumer side, similar to what we saw play out on, on, uh, Spotify as an example. I think when I originally invested, we thought that it did. Now I'm not so sure that we understood what Suno could be back then. What is happening now in Suno is what, what, what Mikey and the team have been saying for a while and what I now believe, uh, it's that it's literally a new behavior. The team calls it creative entertainment. People are coming into Suno, they're making music for the pure joy and entertainment value of making music. You know, previously, like let's say on Anchor, you would make a podcast for the purpose of getting distribution and eventually monetizing it, right? Now AI has made music creation so much fun that you're making music to make music, and I think it's actually not too dissimilar to what we see with Claude Code or Midjourney, right? Or some platforms that are making it easy to make games with AI. You have no greater aspiration for this content, right? You're not trying to become a hit game developer. You're just having a lot of fun making games on your computer, and we see that a lot in Suno.
Harry Stebbings 59:03 What myths... Uh, brilliant, but you should be a politician.
Mike Mignano 59:07 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 59:08 I ask you what myths. I'll tell you about my two greatest hits. [laughs]
Mike Mignano 59:12 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 59:12 Thanks, dude. [laughs]
Mike Mignano 59:14 So one company that I would've loved to invest in a long time ago, which we didn't at Lightspeed. We, we met them a few times, um, and I think we could never really wrap our head around, um, kinda price. Also at the time, where they fit in the market. Now I think with the, the benefit of hindsight, um, I really regret not ever having the, having had the opportunity to invest in Substack. I really believe in Substack. I realize it's not your traditional sort of AI company, but I think, you know, over the past eight years, and I think the trend is continuing, I think we're moving more and more and more towards a world of self-publishing and people, um, controlling their own destiny in terms of media and what they create and what they publish and how they monetize it. And I think no company, maybe other than X, has done a better job of that than Substack. And so, uh, that's a company where I, you know, I love the founders. I love the purpose behind the company. I love the product and the platform. Uh, unfortunately never got a chance to invest.
Is Traditional Media Dead?
Harry Stebbings 1:00:15 Is traditional media dead?
Mike Mignano 1:00:17 I think traditional media in many respects is dead. I think, you know, one of the-
Harry Stebbings 1:00:24 I, like I go to these large-
Mike Mignano 1:00:26 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 1:00:26 ... houses, your, your Times' of the world-
Mike Mignano 1:00:28 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 1:00:28 ... your Skies, and dude, they have these insane production-
Mike Mignano 1:00:32 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 1:00:32 ... places for pods that I know no one listens to, and the teams are ridiculous and, and it's all like, "Guys, you don't get where this game has gone."
Mike Mignano 1:00:41 I probably underestimated just how big independent media could become. When we built Anchor, you know, we had this vision of democratizing audio and giving everyone a voice, and I would say by the time I left Spotify in 2022, I, I'll admit I kinda thought the opportunity was baked. I was like, "Okay, it's, it's done. It's done. You know, we've got YouTube, we've got Spotify, we've got, you know, whatever, we've got X." Um, it's gotten so much bigger since then, and that was only four years ago. So much bigger. I mean, every traditional, um, TV show or, you know, media personality, e- everything has made the leap over to self-publishing or independent media. I mean, I think you're a model example. [laughs] You've been doing this forever. But also just like huge names that were on some of these large, uh, media organizations that just made the leap and now they just have a YouTube show or they just have a show on Spotify. And so like I don't even think we've reached the peak yet. I think, I think television is still in the process of being massively unbundled.
Harry Stebbings 1:01:48 When TechCrunch Europe shut down and now Wired Europe shut down, I... coalesce the best writers in Europe, and I had 10 million bucks from very rich billionaires to bring together the next generation. And then I sat down with my investing team, and they're like, "Why the fuck are we doing this? We have no editorial control on them, just like OpenAI don't on TBPN, and we can't influence it."
Mike Mignano 1:02:11 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:02:11 "What's the point?"
Mike Mignano 1:02:12 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:02:12 And to your point, editorial freedom is everything.
Mike Mignano 1:02:14 It's, it's amazing. It's incredible. Again, which is why I love Substack and why I like X and why I like YouTube and Spotify. I think these platforms are amazing.
Quick Fire Round
Harry Stebbings 1:02:23 Are you ready for a quick fire round?
Mike Mignano 1:02:24 Sure.
Harry Stebbings 1:02:25 Single best first founder meeting you've ever had and why?
Mike Mignano 1:02:28 Brynn Putnam, CEO of Board. Have you seen Board? Tabletop gaming console. Just announced, uh, Series A a few weeks ago from, from USV. Um, when I met Board, when I met Brynn, I was blown away. Uh, force of nature founder, such clear vision, such deep domain expertise. So prior to Board, which is a beautiful tabletop display, uh, Brynn was the founder and CEO of Mirror, the, the mirror, uh, workout device-
Harry Stebbings 1:02:58 Oh, wow
Mike Mignano 1:02:58 ... which she sold to Lululemon. She took that domain expertise and said, "I know how to build a tabletop gaming console now with the same hardware and the same supply chains," and just crushed it. When I met her, I walked out of that meeting and I thought to myself, "I have to invest in this company."
Harry Stebbings 1:03:13 One of the single greatest exits also.
Mike Mignano 1:03:15 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:03:15 You have to give her credit.
Mike Mignano 1:03:16 She's, she's brilliant.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:17 Yeah.
Mike Mignano 1:03:17 She's brilliant.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:18 Um, you can invest in one seed fund. Which seed fund do you invest in?
Mike Mignano 1:03:22 I'm a big fan of what Matt Hartman is doing with Factorial. Uh, Factorial is a fund... Do, do you know Matt, and do you know Factorial?
Harry Stebbings 1:03:31 Dude, I met Matt years ago when he was at BetaWorks-
Mike Mignano 1:03:32 Yeah, of course
Harry Stebbings 1:03:33 ... with John.
Mike Mignano 1:03:33 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:34 And I went to BetaWorks.
Mike Mignano 1:03:35 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:35 And I remember they had a company called Poncho. Do you remember Poncho?
Mike Mignano 1:03:37 Yeah, of course I know Poncho.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:38 Yeah.
Mike Mignano 1:03:38 Weather. You, you mentioned weather- chief weather officer earlier.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:41 Yeah, dude. I'm like, "Oh."
Mike Mignano 1:03:42 Poncho's the original chief weather officer.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:44 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Mike Mignano 1:03:44 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:03:44 And so I remember them doing BetaWorks together.
Mike Mignano 1:03:46 Yeah. Matt's brilliant. So Matt has innovated on a completely new model of venture where he arms angel investors. These are not scouts. These are angel investors. He arms them with additional funds on top of their own capital, which, uh, then Factorial obviously then, you know, monetizes through carry and whatnot. But the brilliant thing about that model is now he's got all these great angel investors part of the Factorial network. You know, these are people like Clem from Hugging Face, like real angel investors. So I think that's brilliant. Uh, second answer I would say, tied for, you know, my favorite seed fund, has gotta be Haystack. I'm just a huge fan of Samil and, uh, Divya and the work they do. It's an, an incredible fund. Obviously, they've produced some generational outcomes.
Harry Stebbings 1:04:28 Who, when they send you a deal, is the highest signal of quality?
Mike Mignano 1:04:32 [exhales] Um, I was really fortunate at Lightspeed to, uh, collaborate closely with, uh, Nat Friedman and Daniel Gross before they, they went over to Meta. And yeah, when Nat would send me a deal, which he did on multiple occasions... And I, and, and by the way, that's actually how I met Mikey from Suno. Um, you know, I always knew to pay attention. You know, if Nat's sending me a deal, uh, I gotta pay attention to that.
Harry Stebbings 1:04:54 That is the greatest shame in venture about them not investing, which is so good. [laughs]
Mike Mignano 1:04:58 So good. Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:04:59 So good.
Mike Mignano 1:05:00 Love those guys.
Harry Stebbings 1:05:00 I mean, oh my God.
Mike Mignano 1:05:01 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:05:02 What is your favorite growth fund, if you were to invest in one?
Mike Mignano 1:05:05 I think the Lightspeed growth fund is phenomenal. I mean, again, they've done Anthropic, they've done xAI, they've done SpaceX. They've done amazing, amazing, uh, investments over the past, you know, uh, I mean, over the history of the firm, but really over the past four years of AI, they've been phenomenal.
Harry Stebbings 1:05:22 What is your biggest lesson from working with Fred for the short time you have done?
Mike Mignano 1:05:26 I would say one of the biggest lessons I've learned from Fred is that there is really nothing more important than your relationship with the founders. A, because that's probably the, the, the best thing you can do to help a founder, is just to be there for them, right? Like, that's what founders need. Founders are lonely. I, I, you know, I can tell you as a former CEO, it's a lonely, punishing job, and so just having somebody you can actually trust and actually feel you're aligned with, um, is, is very, very important. But, but secondly, you know, selfishly, um, I think reputation is everything in this business. You need a great reputation, and the only way you're gonna have a good reputation is if you have great relationships with founders.
Harry Stebbings 1:06:10 What's your biggest parenting advice? I heard that you are an incredible papa. You're also a great-
Mike Mignano 1:06:16 Wow
Harry Stebbings 1:06:16 ... investor. What's the biggest parenting advice?
Mike Mignano 1:06:19 I feel I was extremely fortunate growing up in that I had parents that were extremely supportive of me and my interests, but who also did not pressure me in any one direction. You know, I, I, I grew up, um... I'll give you an example. I grew up in a home where, um, baseball, an American sport, I don't think it's very popular here, was a very big deal. Baseball's a very big deal. And I played some baseball growing up, but I didn't continue with it. And you know, I think there are a lot of homes like that in the United States where, you know, if you're not playing the sport or going to the university or pursuing the career in the thing that the family really cares about, you know, you're a failure, or you get pressured into sticking with it. And you know, my parents, my dad, who, you know, a former coach and baseball player, just like, "Great. What do you wanna do next?" And I think that that is so important, and it's definitely something that I really try to remember and try to instill, uh, in the values of my family with my kids. You know, I really want my kids to do what interests them, but I never wanna pressure them to do it. I wanna support them. You know, I wanna be there for them. I wanna drive them to practice. I wanna do everything I can to empower them, but I never wanna pressure them too much.
Harry Stebbings 1:07:34 I remember calling my mom and telling her I was dropping out of law school-
Mike Mignano 1:07:37 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 1:07:37 ... to do this podcast that made no money.
Mike Mignano 1:07:39 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:07:40 Having worked so hard for years-
Mike Mignano 1:07:41 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 1:07:41 ... to go to law school. She was like, "Cool, if that's what you think is best."
Mike Mignano 1:07:44 Yeah. She might pressure test you, right? "Hey, are you sure?" Like, "T- talk me through it. Talk me through it." But once you... W- I'm sure once you... Or no, not even? Okay.
Harry Stebbings 1:07:53 I said, "Listen, I fell asleep-
Mike Mignano 1:07:54 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:07:54 "... in the first law lecture and I skipped the next few," and she was like-
Mike Mignano 1:07:57 All right. Fuck it
Harry Stebbings 1:07:57 ... "I think law is not for you."
Mike Mignano 1:07:59 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:07:59 Yeah. Um, uh, but penultimate one for you. What have you changed your mind on most in the last 12 months?
Mike Mignano 1:08:05 I do think that there was a moment not that long ago where I, where I And I know I said the opposite a few minutes ago, but where I thought the model providers could do everything. I did. You know, I, I, I thought that we were headed towards this world where there would be one company or five companies that would just do everything, and I think fortunately what I've been reminded of over the past year or so, or two years, is that companies can't do everything. They can't do everything. Even the biggest companies can't do everything. And I re- and I remember, oh man, 10 years ago, 15 years ago, we thought the same thing about Google. We thought the same thing about Apple. We thought these companies are gonna just take everything, and the reality is they can't, and they don't. And so I've been reminded of that recently, and it's, and it's been a surprise, and, um, I'm glad for it.
Harry Stebbings 1:08:53 You work with Fred, who's obviously been around the block a few times. I don't work with him, but he's my papa as Roy Ojo at School From Scale-
Mike Mignano 1:09:00 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:09:00 ... who likewise has been around the block a few times.
Mike Mignano 1:09:02 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:09:02 He got into venture the same year I was born, and he reminds me that Microsoft at one point were looking at becoming a bank. That is how-
Mike Mignano 1:09:11 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 1:09:11 ... like the incumbents just looked at everyone.
Mike Mignano 1:09:13 Totally. It works sometimes, right? AWS, great example. Um, but they can't do everything.
Harry Stebbings 1:09:19 Final one for you. When you look forward to the next five to 10 years, what are you most excited for? I like optimism.
Mike Mignano 1:09:26 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:09:26 What do you like, "This is gonna be amazing"?
Mike Mignano 1:09:28 I... So my partners the other day, uh, Rebecca and Nick, we, we asked each other actually like what are, you know, what do you want? What do, you know, what do you want to do at USV? And I said three things. First thing is I wanna show up to work each day and collaborate with people who I love being around, people who I enjoy collaborating with, people who I just have fun with. That's actually number one for me. Number two is I wanna partner with some incredible founders, and again, like similarly, I want it to be about that relationship and that dynamic, you know, and I want these founders obviously, uh, who are gonna change the world. And number three is I wanna produce generational returns in terms of funds. In that order. Number one for me is show up to work, have fun with the people I work with. Number two is partner with founders who w- who I love and who I believe can produce generational companies. And then number three is produce generational returns as a fund, in that order. And I think that's a good recipe. I think if you optimize for fun and like enjoying your day-to-day, good things will happen.
Harry Stebbings 1:10:33 Mike, I so appreciate you taking the time out on the London trip. I so appreciate you putting up with my bold stances-
Mike Mignano 1:10:38 I love it
Harry Stebbings 1:10:39 ... as you recoil back and go-
Mike Mignano 1:10:40 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:10:41 ... "Don't, uh, don't at- don't attribute it to me."
Mike Mignano 1:10:42 Cut this. Cut this.
Harry Stebbings 1:10:43 "Don't, don't attribute it to me." Uh, I, I really appreciate the, the decade-long friendship now. You-
Mike Mignano 1:10:48 Unbelievable
Harry Stebbings 1:10:49 ... you are a star, dude. Thank you so much.
Mike Mignano 1:10:50 Mojitos
Episode duration: 1:11:01
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode Gjjnb8j69C0