By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
a16zWhat Tesla and SpaceX Teach Founders About Building Hardware | a16z
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
60 min read · 11,750 wordsIntroduction
Chandler Luzsicza 0:00 I entered SpaceX four times. I couldn't leave. Like, it was the dream.
Turner Caldwell 0:03 I spent about a decade at Tesla and got to run around the battery supply chain.
Erin Price-Wright 0:07 Chandler Luzsicza is the CEO of Galadyne, next-generation missile propulsion. Turner Caldwell is the CEO of Mariana Minerals, critical mineral supply chains.
Turner Caldwell 0:15 When Elon sets, like, super aggressive targets, the goal is actually to get the team to think really deliberately. There's a thousand things that have to happen, but a hundred of them cannot be done in six months, so we have to go attack those hundred things.
Chandler Luzsicza 0:25 Being somewhat foreign to the missile industry, I realized we don't have enough, they cost too much, and we can't make them fast enough. With my background being purely in liquid propulsion across SpaceX and even at UCLA launching liquid rockets, there's a very real way to apply this technology to missile systems, and we're gonna go do it.
Erin Price-Wright 0:38 What is the single most important thing that you learned at SpaceX or Tesla that you now apply every single day at your companies? As you know, I spend a lot of my time with founders building in the physical world, and one thing that keeps coming up, uh, is how many of them trained at Tesla and SpaceX. People talk about the mythology, the all-nighters, the flat org, the impossible deadlines, the best part is no part. Um, but beyond the myths are repeatable practices that change how teams build and ship complex hardware. Uh, Chandler Luzsicza is the CEO of Galadyne, next-generation missile propulsion, and Turner Caldwell is the CEO of Mariana Minerals, critical mineral supply chains. Uh, Chandler was the lead propulsion engineer on Starship. Turner led battery and minel- battery, minerals, and metals at Tesla. So it's really great to have you guys here to talk about your experiences in the school of Elon Musk. Uh, maybe to just kick off, um, maybe start at the beginning. Briefly tell us the origin story of your companies, uh, the problems you saw, the first prototype or pilot you built, the moment you realized that this could be a real business. Chandler, let's start with you.
Chandler Luzsicza 1:45 Yeah, I think being somewhat foreign to the missile industry until the summer of last year, right as I jumped into it, I realized we don't have enough, they cost too much, and we can't make them fast enough. Um, it seemed like everyone in the industry is kinda doing it the same old way, um, and I think, you know, in order to get drastically different results, you have to do things drastically differently. So with my background being purely in liquid propulsion across SpaceX and even at UCLA launching liquid rockets, uh, there's a very real way to apply this technology to missile systems, and we're gonna go do it, so.
Erin Price-Wright 2:12 Awesome. And what about you, Turner?
Turner Caldwell 2:13 Yeah. So, you know, I spent, uh, about a decade at, at Tesla and got to, uh, run around the battery supply chain, uh, most recently was spending a lot of time on the minerals and metals, uh, side of things. Um, and, you know, a lot of our focus was trying to identify how do we debottleneck that part of the supply chain and make sure that the minerals that batteries need, um, could, could keep up with, with battery production. And similar to what Chandler was saying, um, you know, this is an industry that the, the major players are fifty to a hundred years old.
Erin Price-Wright 2:42 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 2:42 Um, and that way of doing things, um, you know, companies like that, they're large, uh, and conservative, really gets set in that, in that way of doing things. Um, and so as we were engaging or as I was engaging with those, with those companies and as we were building infrastructure in that space, um, at Tesla, what became very apparent, um, is that the industry is massively software deficient, and a lot of the challenges that come out of or come up when you're trying to build this infrastructure is, uh, the coordination layer, the orchestration layer.
Erin Price-Wright 3:10 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 3:10 How do you manage a large complex refinery with a talent pool that is shrinking? Um, how do you, how do you manage large complex mining operations, again, with a talent pool that's shrinking? Um, and what we've landed on is that, uh, you have to go full bore, kind of like leveraging the advances in autonomy, um, in automotive and humanoid robots to go and apply that to refineries and to, to mining operations.
The Single Most Important Thing Learned at Tesla and SpaceX
Erin Price-Wright 3:32 So there's so much mythology around Tesla and SpaceX culture. Maybe forgetting the buzzwords, what is the single most important thing that you learned at SpaceX or Tesla, uh, that you now apply every single day at your companies?
Turner Caldwell 3:47 Um, yeah. I think the f- flat orgs is, is hypercritical, right? You need information to flow, um, as quickly as possible. You need to democratize access to information, and that's really the purpose of flat organizations. It's not... 'Cause, like, if you do flat organizations wrong, it, it can get chaotic.
Erin Price-Wright 4:04 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 4:04 Right? Uh, like the purpose of flat organizations is really about information flow and collaboration. Um, and so any junior engineer should be able to go to any senior, uh, member of, of any executive team, uh, at any point in time and talk directly to folks that are making decisions, uh, as well as collaborate with teams that are within the company, kind of without having to funnel information through managers and then back down into their teams.
Erin Price-Wright 4:26 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 4:26 Um, so that's hypercritical, um, and is a, is a big piece of how we've been building the company. Um, I don't know if you wanna jump in.
Chandler Luzsicza 4:33 Yeah, I'll jump in. I think an- another part of that, maybe a part of making that successful, or at least in my, from, from my experience, is you need leaders across that flat org that are able to make decisions really quickly.
Erin Price-Wright 4:44 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 4:44 Um, I think Decision Velocity, without using a buzzword [laughs] is, is very, very important. With high-conviction leadership who can make strong decisions, um, you, you increase the pace of development, you increase the pace of production cycles. Everything goes faster. Even from a, like, flying people to space perspective, you know, there's, there's a lot of risk, right? And, and by having, you know, high-conviction leaders who can go make really fast decisions in that space too, it helps absolve a lot of risk from the lower level, more junior engineers, and it really just lets them go fast. Like, I think if, if you have a junior engineer who's just now starting out at SpaceX or a Tesla, and they're, they're, like, worrying themself, "Oh, I'm making this crazy big decision. It's gonna cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, millions of dollars. Like, what if I mess up?" If you, if, if a leader can come in and, and remove that concern from the junior engineer's mind by just making a decision and saying, "Go," then you go way, way faster.
Turner Caldwell 5:27 Like, you can't wait to have all of the information available-
Erin Price-Wright 5:30 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 5:30 ... uh, to make decisions, right? And oftentimes you won't find out if a decision is correct or not until you've made it-
Chandler Luzsicza 5:35 Yep
Turner Caldwell 5:36 ... tried it-
Erin Price-Wright 5:36 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 5:36 ... and then iterated really quickly on... You know, you're not always gonna make the right decision-
Erin Price-Wright 5:39 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 5:40 ... but you're always just trying to maximize your percentage that you did make the right decision. Um-
Chandler Luzsicza 5:44 It's all bets.
Turner Caldwell 5:45 It is.
Chandler Luzsicza 5:45 It's all making bets. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 5:45 It is. That's right. Um, but speed, speed is... Speed and, like, exec- uh, uh, excellence in execution, like, those are the two things that, that you're going for.
Erin Price-Wright 5:52 I mean, I guess, and you need that information in order to be able to make decisions.
Turner Caldwell 5:56 You need, you need to accumulate as much information as you can, uh, within the time that you kind of like constrain-
Erin Price-Wright 6:01 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 6:01 ... yourself to, and then make the decision and, and then learn from that decision.
Erin Price-Wright 6:03 Yeah. And in- incorporate that new information, I guess.Um, [clears throat] you're both pretty deep in the technical weeds. You're both engineers, um, now CEOs of companies. What lesson or experiences did you have, uh, in your previous roles, um, at S- Tesla and SpaceX that maybe directly changed an outcome or how you thought about things at Galadyne and Mariana?
Turner Caldwell 6:25 The... Solving like the discrete technical problems-
Erin Price-Wright 6:28 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 6:28 ... um, that is hard. You're ha- you're so- you're solving kind of first-of-a-kind problems in many cases. Um, but then getting large groups of people to work together towards solving those first-of-a-kind problems actually starts to like... That's where the churn starts to appear-
Erin Price-Wright 6:41 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 6:41 ... uh, between teams. And, and even if you try to have fast, uh, to, you know, uh, accelerated decision-making, even if you have everyone talking to each other, you need to make sure that the vectors are aligned-
Erin Price-Wright 6:50 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 6:51 ... um, and everyone is kind of working in the same direction towards the same thing. And that's a big part of why, you know, as we've been building Mariana, we've been focusing on, like, how do you democratize access to information, uh, between teams so that you avoid kind of data silos that form between entities. And that doesn't really happen in teams of like 10, 20, 30 people, but it does start to happen once you get into teams that are 100 people or more. Um, and seeing that, like, growth of teams that are trying to build large scale infrastructure, those, those pockets of information, those data silos really do form naturally even if, like, the executive teams are saying like-
Erin Price-Wright 7:24 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 7:24 ... "There should be no pockets of information. There should be no data silos." Um, and so we've tried to, like, embed that into, like, the core operating systems.
Erin Price-Wright 7:30 Yeah. So how, how do you... Like, how have you built kind of your product and systems around that challenge?
Turner Caldwell 7:35 Yeah. So everything is, like, web app hosted. Uh, their access controls are basically gone, um, at least internal to the company. Um, when it comes to being able to see, like, the core engineering information, it does not live on a hard drive somewhere. It does not live in an email that gets sent to a specific group of people, and that then needs to be forwarded for it to get to everyone. We've really focused on, like, building that integrated data frame, um, that enables anyone to access and see the context of, like, why a decision was made or what decision was made.
Erin Price-Wright 8:01 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 8:01 Um, because as the teams get larger, the, like, number of connections between people is what actually makes, uh, building, building, like, executing projects hard.
Erin Price-Wright 8:10 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 8:10 And so you have to democratize access to that information. And so, you know, EPC, like engineering, procurement, construction, like large scale capital project, uh, execution, there are insane data silos between the engineering groups and the procurement teams and the construction teams. Um, and so you have to build, like, a net new operating system, uh, that ensures that, like, the history of every individual decision is tracked, and everyone can see that history. Um, and now with LLMs, you can kind of, like, let them run-
Erin Price-Wright 8:35 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 8:35 ... wild on top of your data repository-
Erin Price-Wright 8:38 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 8:38 ... um, and ensure that if someone doesn't understand the folder structure, they can just query the LLM and, like, quickly navigate to, to where they need to go. And then this, you know, mining is basically one long construction project that ideally never ends. Um, and so it has a lot of the same challenges between, like, geology and mine planning and maintenance, uh, and mine operations and the processing facility. Um, and again, like, if, if you don't give people the context of an entire operation, the entire pur- like the, a- all the decisions that are being made across an operation or a project, um, they are gonna make information, like, within the data that they have available to them. Um, so you're trying to enable, like, everyone to make, like, globally optimal decisions-
Erin Price-Wright 9:15 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 9:15 ... without, again, while accelerating, uh, decision-making.
Critical Path Focus
Erin Price-Wright 9:19 What about you, Chandler?
Chandler Luzsicza 9:20 Yeah. I think, I think my, my answer here is, is really focused on critical path. Um, I think, I think chasing critical path and being a firefighter is something that SpaceX and I would assume Tesla engineers do very well.
Erin Price-Wright 9:29 Can you, can you-
Chandler Luzsicza 9:30 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 9:30 ... explain what that is?
Chandler Luzsicza 9:32 Of course. Yeah. [laughs] Totally can. Uh, so critical path just being, you know, the, the, the thing that's driving schedule.
Erin Price-Wright 9:37 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 9:37 So really the schedule driving task or, or procurement activity that needs to happen i- in order to unlock the, either the next phase or, um, or get you to the, to the end goal. Um, although we are very young at Galadyne, there's a lot of chasing critical path and playing this constant game of Whac-A-Mole to, to really, you know, get yourself to that next phase or get yourself to that next milestone.
Erin Price-Wright 9:55 And h-how do you align a team against critical path without making the next decision that comes after the current critical path take longer?
Turner Caldwell 10:05 Yeah.
Erin Price-Wright 10:05 Does that make sense?
Turner Caldwell 10:06 I've, I've got one if you-
Chandler Luzsicza 10:07 Go for it.
Erin Price-Wright 10:07 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 10:08 The, um, you, you can't play like second grade soccer. Um-
Erin Price-Wright 10:12 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 10:12 Like, that, that is the... That's like sometimes how it feels if you, like, are narrowly, narrowly focused on the critical path side of things, right? Um, and, you know, second grade soccer basically means that everyone, like, swarms to the ball-
Erin Price-Wright 10:23 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 10:23 ... on the field.
Chandler Luzsicza 10:23 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 10:24 Um, and so you have to, you have to, like, set up, you know, uh, systems that enable you to mobilize, like, core groups of teams to go after critical paths while also not letting the next decision kind of fall behind. Um, and a lot of that is around having, you know, little SWAT teams that are able to, like, independently attack things that are in parallel-
Erin Price-Wright 10:41 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 10:42 ... um, or attack things in parallel that enable you to kind of keep the thing that is not on critical path right now still moving without, like, diverting all resources over. Um, that's how we think about it.
Chandler Luzsicza 10:52 It's easy, right? It's easy for folks who, who aren't getting constantly aligned to, to kind of fall into the hype because it, it is... It, it, it will seem like the hottest thing in town whenever that's happening 'cause it's like, oh, wow, you know, this is literally blocking a rocket launch. This is literally b- blocking a production line. And people are like, "Oh, I wanna help. I wanna help." It's like w- we gotta focus resources so that, you're right, the next thing doesn't actually become that critical path sooner rathe- rather than, you know, never, I suppose.
Erin Price-Wright 11:13 I guess though as, like as a, especially y- y- you, Chandler, I mean, Galadyne's still very early.
Chandler Luzsicza 11:17 Yeah.
Erin Price-Wright 11:17 So how do you, you know, h- how, how do you manage that internally, or are you still at the point where there really is just one critical path?
Chandler Luzsicza 11:23 I think the latter for sure. Like, we, we have, right now our team is six people, so it's, it's relatively easy to, to control that game. Um, but, but it's still very important. Like, you know, how, how we've structured a lot of the initial team is, is disciplinary based or, or, uh, sort of domain based. So it may not make the most sense for a avionics engineer to go troubleshoot a engine design problem that's literally blocking the production-
Erin Price-Wright 11:45 Yeah
Chandler Luzsicza 11:45 ... of, of said
Erin Price-Wright 11:45 That probably doesn't help with the critical path.
Chandler Luzsicza 11:47 It doesn't help. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 11:48 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 11:48 So for us, it's a little bit easier, but definitely top of mind as we, as we grow the team really quickly to, to not let it get out of control 'cause it, you just waste a bunch of resources.
Erin Price-Wright 11:56 Maybe in terms of, like, practical or tactical advice, like, what are, what is a specific process or rhythm that you've brought from Tesla and SpaceX into your companies?
Chandler Luzsicza 12:06 I can, I can hop on this one first. I think the, the thing that I really like, and may sound counterintuitive potentially, is, is email dates. Um, I think-High signal, low noise email updates on, particularly with things related to critical path, um, are, are extremely important. To do, one, you know, give the information to a, a broader set of folks, even-
Erin Price-Wright 12:28 And these are email updates from you to the team or from the team out?
Chandler Luzsicza 12:31 Team out, anyone.
Erin Price-Wright 12:31 Got it.
Chandler Luzsicza 12:31 So anyone, really to the point of the, the, the fire teams, there's usually gonna be one extreme owner who is-
Erin Price-Wright 12:36 Yeah
Chandler Luzsicza 12:37 ... driving that problem or driving that, you know, specific task to get it completed. And for that person to take ownership and send, you know, high, high cadence email updates to get through the not so good parts-
Erin Price-Wright 12:47 Mm-hmm
Chandler Luzsicza 12:47 ... [laughs] of the said problem, uh, is, is extremely important, not only for the team to see and, and hear, but I think it's actually wildly important for the individual who's working that project to recall what they ... what happened that day.
Erin Price-Wright 12:56 Write it down.
Chandler Luzsicza 12:57 And make su- Write it down, exactly. Writing down things is freaking massive. I have a notebook in my pocket at all times. [laughs] And I think in order to get that out and for them to write it down, see it, and be like, "I don't think I've made the most direct progress towards the goal in, in, in this particular day. Let's fix it for the next day."
Turner Caldwell 13:11 Yeah. Second.
Chandler Luzsicza 13:12 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 13:13 Um, I, I think that, you know, there's a, the- there's like this natural thing that happens when you're very busy, is that, you know, you don't have time to write things down and write reports. What, what we've tried to do is, you know, the ... when you're running a manufacturing process, right, and then you have like, uh, just a day-to-day operation, you have a passdown that happens between shifts that gets emailed-
Erin Price-Wright 13:31 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 13:31 ... out every day. Um, and if you wanna drive, uh, like process development and R&D towards thinking about it as a manufacturing type process, the, the best forcing function is at the end of the day, you have like the equivalent of a shift passdown. Which is you say, "Here's what we did. Here's what we were supposed to do. Here's why we didn't-
Erin Price-Wright 13:46 That's fascinating, yeah
Turner Caldwell 13:47 ... do the things we were supposed to do." And, you know, because that does become burdensome from like a, as like the team starts to grow and as there's a lot of stuff happening. Um, we've done our best to try to like if everything is going into the same like aggregated kind of like data backbone, you can actually auto-populate the bulk of those passdowns, um, and it puts humans in the position where they're really like reviewing a passdown before they send it out.
Erin Price-Wright 14:06 Editing, maybe adding, adding commentary-
Turner Caldwell 14:08 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 14:08 ... versus having to write something from scratch.
Turner Caldwell 14:10 And the, what we've found even in like large scale operations, like the passdowns are very manual. Um, so but all that data is being collected. And so instead of someone having to sit down and carve out an hour of their day to write down exactly what happened, we've, we've put a ton of focus into like how do we auto-generate all of those. Um, but you still want people to look at it. You still want them to click send, because like they should have ownership and accountability of like what is in it. The other big thing that we've, we've tried to do, um, it's like a balance here of like you need to set like a drum beat for the company.
Erin Price-Wright 14:38 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 14:38 Um, and if you don't set a drum beat for the company, people don't really know what they are moving towards necessarily. It, it's how you kind of take flat organizations and enable, like give them some structure. And everyone knows that decisions are gonna roll up on some cadence, and you obviously have to be flexible because there's gonna be super critical decisions that have to happen the day of. Um, but you also want to like give some structure and like a cadence to the company that enables everyone to kind of be moving in the same rhythm effectively. Um-
Erin Price-Wright 15:04 Like a sprint.
Turner Caldwell 15:05 Sprints we try to reserve for like truly critical to the company type things. And the software engineering organization obviously runs in two-week sprints. But if we're gonna ... If we have like a major milestone that we're trying to hit, like drive towards, then we'll, we'll coin that a sprint and say like, "Look, the company, like as a whole is sprinting towards this thing." But the, the drum beat is a little bit different. It's like-
Erin Price-Wright 15:24 Got it
Turner Caldwell 15:24 ... you're, 'cause you're building ... If you're, if you're, if you're building large scale infrastructure, the ... Like it is a 12-month project or an 18-month project. And if you're sprinting for 18 months-
Erin Price-Wright 15:32 Yeah, this isn't the same thing as, you know, sh- shipping software to the cloud where, you know-
Turner Caldwell 15:37 That's correct
Erin Price-Wright 15:37 ... you can do a release cadence every day if you want.
Turner Caldwell 15:39 Yep. Yeah.
Erin Price-Wright 15:40 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 15:40 Um, but-
Erin Price-Wright 15:40 I think that's what a, a lot of folks in ... It's, it ... Who, who have spent their whole careers working in just software, sort of it's hard to mentally imagine what it means to work on something over a 12 to 18-month period.
Turner Caldwell 15:52 It, it is a long cycle.
Erin Price-Wright 15:53 Yeah. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 15:54 Um, but like the, also the goal of kind of the cadence-
Erin Price-Wright 15:56 [clears throat]
Turner Caldwell 15:56 ... is like give yourself time to celebrate those like intermediate wins.
Erin Price-Wright 15:59 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 16:00 Um, because it's easy to like lose track of the fact that you're making a ton of progress over an 18-month period. Like you look back and you're like, "Oh, well, we built this thing. It's awesome." Um, but you have to like ... That cadence is also like a, the, it's the reward function for the team, that they are saying like, "Look, okay, I'm doing the right thing. I'm driving towards the right thing." Um, and you, and you get that calibration on some regular basis.
Erin Price-Wright 16:20 Yeah. How, how do you think about setting milestones, Chandler?
Chandler Luzsicza 16:22 [laughs] As fast as humanly possible. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 16:25 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 16:26 Um, I, I, I don't know. There's ... I'm sure Turner has some impact to this, but there's, there's Elon time always-
Erin Price-Wright 16:33 Yeah
Chandler Luzsicza 16:33 ... and, and that's a, that's a hard one to battle with usually. I think ... I'd definitely say I lean towards that i- in setting these very-
Erin Price-Wright 16:39 I mean, I can attest
Chandler Luzsicza 16:40 ... focused milestones.
Erin Price-Wright 16:40 Know, knowing you pretty well by now. [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 16:42 Yeah. Um, I, I really try to think about it from ... Fortunately, I've been able to, to touch a lot of different parts of, of rockets over my short but jam-packed career so far. [laughs] And, and I have a decent gauge on, on how long things should take. Um, and I think sort of to the, to the, to the effect of this drum beat thing, but doing something sort of upfront to align the team to like, hey, this is what I ... This is how long I think these things are gonna take. You as the person who's gonna go execute on it directly, like does this sound reasonable? And then battle it there early. And then set that schedule from the get-go, uh, which is what we did. We all sat down and we set this very ambitious schedule to go get a rocket in the air by June. And like we, we broke down the things we need to do to get there, and they're very reasonable. And if we start straying from that path, then you start to be like, "What, what's, what's wrong?" Um-
Erin Price-Wright 17:27 I mean, I guess this is where having quite technical folks in leadership really matters.
Turner Caldwell 17:32 Yeah, you have to have like an-
Erin Price-Wright 17:33 You're, you're credible.
Turner Caldwell 17:34 You, you have to have like a core ... You have to have a sense of like what is actually challenging but achievable.
Chandler Luzsicza 17:38 Yeah.
Erin Price-Wright 17:38 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 17:38 Um, and like the purpose of setting super aggressive milestones, which I think everyone should do-
Chandler Luzsicza 17:43 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 17:43 ... um, is it's meant to weed out like what the actual critical paths are, going back to the critical path comment.
Erin Price-Wright 17:47 Yeah.
Chandler Luzsicza 17:47 Yep.
Turner Caldwell 17:48 Of like instead of saying, "Okay, I, I've done this before, it should take 36 months." Um, like when, when Elon sets like super aggressive targets, the goal is actually to get the team to think really deliberately and very deeply-
Erin Price-Wright 17:58 About what doesn't matter
Turner Caldwell 17:59 ... about what doesn't work in that ti-
Erin Price-Wright 18:01 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 18:01 ... like what actually doesn't solve for-
Erin Price-Wright 18:02 I see. Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 18:02 ... the aggressive timeframe.
Chandler Luzsicza 18:03 Yep.
Turner Caldwell 18:03 Um, and then it's gives you your priority list. It's like, okay, there's 1,000 things that have to happen. If we wanna do it in six months, 900 of those things can be done in six months, but 100 of them cannot be done in six months, and so we have to go attack those 100 things. Um, it's like a forcing function-
Chandler Luzsicza 18:16 And attack, attack can mean delete them too. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 18:18 Exactly. I, I ideally-
Chandler Luzsicza 18:19 Like bring, float those things to the top and then cut them
Turner Caldwell 18:21 ... ideally delete, I ideally delete.
Chandler Luzsicza 18:22 Yeah. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 18:22 Um, that's right.
Chandler Luzsicza 18:23 Yeah.
All-Nighters and the Intense Work Culture
Erin Price-Wright 18:24 Both Tesla and, and SpaceX are famous for, you know, all-nighters, like a very intense work culture, long working hours, like really... these really hard deadlines where, you know, you're trying to do something in six months, which n- normally might take 36 months. How do you avoid kind of team burnout in those situations?
Chandler Luzsicza 18:44 A lot of this comes back to the, to how mission-aligned the company is or, or how strong the mission of the company is. It's [laughs] ... it doesn't feel like working if it's fun. Um, and, and particularly for folks who are, are so aligned with the mission of the company, um, obviously in SpaceX's case, making life multi-planetary, that's a fantastic mission to go stand behind and work your butt off to, to achieve. So it makes, it makes the long hours, the, the overnight- the all-nighters, it, it makes it so that they don't really impact you that much. Um, and I think a, a large, like a [laughs] very high amount of thought on my end right now is going into, you know, how, how do I really convince a lot of folks who haven't thought about defense before to be passionate about defense? Um, because the reality is, is in, in, in my case, there's so much talent that's living at SpaceX, there's so much talent living at Rocklab, Firefly, and Relativity that need to come work this problem set too. You know, it's, it's how do you, how do you build that same fiery mission alignment that, that SpaceX has been able to achieve and other companies have been able to achieve with their workforce now in these, in these, you know, new American dynamism-focused problem sets that people just haven't been working on in a while.
Erin Price-Wright 19:43 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 19:43 Um, and then makes, makes it all feel like fun and not like pain. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 19:47 Yeah. The mi- the mission alignment is definitely kind of like the core piece. I think the thing that actually causes burnout is churn, um, and like a lack of feeling like you're making progress towards-
Erin Price-Wright 19:56 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 19:56 ... a goal. And so if people are working towards something and they feel like they're actually, like progressing towards it, and you know, if you're mission-aligned, solving hard problems, um, can be fun because you're... as long as you are, like making progress towards that goal. And so there's a handful of things that can make, like work not fun, which is churn can come from like, you know, erratic decision-making that kind of like moves teams in different dir- dir-
Erin Price-Wright 20:18 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 20:19 ... and there's always gonna be a little bit of that, especially in startup companies that are moving quick and are being very nimble. Um, but the second is like p- politics in companies creates an insane amount of churn, data silos, and kind of hoarding your Legos-
Erin Price-Wright 20:33 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 20:33 ... is what we call it, can create an insane amount of churn, and when people have to deal with that and aren't able to focus on like, okay, I have a problem that I have to solve, the pathway is clear, the decision is clear, the priorities are clear, they'll, you know, they'll work-
Erin Price-Wright 20:45 'Cause it zaps energy
Turner Caldwell 20:45 ... their butts off to go do it.
Erin Price-Wright 20:46 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 20:47 Yeah.
Erin Price-Wright 20:47 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 20:47 But it, but it definitely, it, it destroys kind of like the excitement-
Erin Price-Wright 20:50 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 20:50 ... um, if you have things that are around the team that, um, are taking away from like the core mission.
Erin Price-Wright 20:55 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 20:56 Um, so the... People can get excited about like impossible goals, um, because-
Erin Price-Wright 21:00 In fact, it's-
Turner Caldwell 21:01 ... we're gonna go prove it.
Erin Price-Wright 21:02 Yeah. It's like-
Turner Caldwell 21:02 That it can be done
Erin Price-Wright 21:02 ... the only thing that people do really get excited about-
Turner Caldwell 21:05 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 21:05 ... if it feels impossible.
Turner Caldwell 21:06 Um, but that's the other thing that Chandler mentioned, which is like if a- as long as you're setting goals that are, um, aggressive but are possible, like that has to be, like, it has to be in the realm of possibility-
Chandler Luzsicza 21:16 Within reach. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 21:17 ... um, then you know, it doesn't... Like if you go super, super aggressive on targets, um, that have no actual technical path-
Erin Price-Wright 21:23 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 21:24 ... towards, towards achieving it, the... like that can be demoralizing also.
Erin Price-Wright 21:27 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 21:27 Um, so it's a mix of like making sure the churn is gone, uh, to the extent that you can and, and making sure that you're setting goals that are motivating, not demoralizing.
Erin Price-Wright 21:34 Yeah. So m- maybe flipping it, what principle from, uh, Tesla or SpaceX has not worked for you in your new companies or patterns that you maybe needed to unlearn that didn't apply either because of the domain or because of the size of the company or something else?
Chandler Luzsicza 21:52 I think a fun one that's... It's, it's not choosing not to do it, it's kind of delaying the implementation of, but, um, the one thing that, that I definitely employed working Starship, um, a little bit on Dragon as well, is with, with the fantastic resource that SpaceX has behind it, you can do a lot of fantastic things. And you know, in order to fight critical path, there are ways to do that that maybe are less ef- efficient, I suppose, but ways that w- will go achieve the goal. Parallel pathing a lot of things can be pretty resource intensive, both on a time space, but also, uh, on-
Erin Price-Wright 22:24 Mm-hmm
Chandler Luzsicza 22:24 ... a cost. And I think that's, that's one thing that we are not able to do right now given our size. But I think it's something that as we grow, like in order to hit s- speed, you need to do everything possible and, and you know, what, what possible looks like right now for us is, is growing very quickly, but, but is a different set of possibilities than maybe what SpaceX has right now. So I think kind of, uh, really keeping an eye on, on when that point is so that we can crank up the velocity even more, um, has been in my mind.
Turner Caldwell 22:51 Yeah. I wouldn't actually say that there's any like one pinpointed thing that like, that at least at, at Tesla, at Tesla was, you know, a core principle that we wouldn't mimic. I would say that it's more like kind of massaging the implementation of those-
Erin Price-Wright 23:04 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 23:04 ... um, that is to address some of the things like churn and turnover and burnout.
Erin Price-Wright 23:08 Well, I mean, at-
Turner Caldwell 23:09 Um-
Erin Price-Wright 23:09 ... at Tesla, you, you were there w- as the company grew in order of magnitude.
Turner Caldwell 23:13 Mm-hmm.
Erin Price-Wright 23:13 So you saw two very different versions-
Turner Caldwell 23:16 Yep
Erin Price-Wright 23:16 ... of the company. Um, so I imagine, you know, so s- some lessons from when Tesla, you know, crossed 100,000 people are less relevant to you.
Turner Caldwell 23:24 In, in the early days, the... like it, it was, it was flatter obviously, as you would expect, 'cause once you get to like 130, 140,000 people, um, you know, you have to start to layer in some structure. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 23:37 I mean, you have massive, you know, groups of people who are working on flac- factory floors who are less involved in-
Turner Caldwell 23:42 Yep
Erin Price-Wright 23:43 ... design decisions.
Turner Caldwell 23:44 Yeah. And so those-
Erin Price-Wright 23:45 Or-
Turner Caldwell 23:45 ... organizations like stayed flat and nimble, uh, and still are to this day. Um, but I, I, I... you know, I, I don't think there's any... 'Cause like I, I actually believe in a lot of, in, in most of kind of how Tesla was running. Um, I think that the... it's just there's like little tweaks that you can make along the way that, uh, that enable you to make it like more sustainable for the, for the teams.
Approaching Every Problem With a Factory Mindset
Erin Price-Wright 24:05 So, um, maybe switching gears a little bit, both Tes- Tesla and SpaceX are famous for approaching every problem with this kind of factory mindset. Um, you know, everything is a factory, everything... You, you touched on it earlier, Turner, everything kind of boils down to a manufacturing problem. Um, so I wanna talk a, a little bit about what that means in practice. Um, Ch- Chandler, maybe starting with you, can we talk about iteration on Starship? So from V1 to V2 to V3, how did you balance system complexity and production rate?
Chandler Luzsicza 24:34 Yeah. [clears throat] I, I, whene- just to give some context, I, whenever I started in the Starship program, it was around Flight 3 timeframe, um, so a little bit of V1 play i, i- in terms of full stack, um, and then pushed all the way through the VT development cycle and then started s- to touch V3 and, and kind of lay that out be- before, before I left the company. Um, [clears throat] I think really what it, what, what this trade for us came down to is, is, a- and what enabled kind of the speed and thinking with, um, this, this factory mindset is and, and really just production focus in general, is requirements. Like from, from the design side, if you can boil up all of the requirements that sound stupid as fast as possible and then give yourself a chance to whack them out of the equation, you, you now leave yourself-
Erin Price-Wright 25:14 Like what? Give me an example.
Chandler Luzsicza 25:16 Uh. [clears throat]
Erin Price-Wright 25:16 If you can.
Chandler Luzsicza 25:17 Yeah, there is, there is one that's kind of interesting. It's kind of getting into the weeds, but, um, we, we had the opportunity to pull some hardware from, from Booster. So Booster was a little bit ahead of, uh, Ship, the Ship team in terms of, uh, their V3 design. They kind of skipped V2 for, for Booster. They went from V1 to V3. Um, and they had some hardware design for, for the V3, um, vehicle that actually could've been plugged into Ship very easily. And then we had so many... We had very limited engineers to go design a ton of prop systems hardware, and we identified that, oh, we can maybe use this. And we kind of brought it over early, which would've been an earlier imple- earlier implementation than Booster. And one of the things that popped up that, that sounds kind of silly is it was essentially a circle that lives inside the fuel tank, and you could condense liquid inside that circle. And [laughs] the valves that, that were, you know, effectively venting the tank there, um, don't like liquid. Uh, [laughs] so when we were, like, trying to go super fast, like, "Oh, sweet, we got free hardware, we can skip a whole design cycle. Let's go fast, then we can, you know, just jump into production sooner rather than later," we were like, "Oh, we're gonna get liquid [laughs] in this thing, too. I don't know if the valves are gonna like that." And what we did is we just spooled up the, the necessary resources to go prove that that's gonna be okay, and what that, what that did was not only allow us to go roll in this whole hardware, uh, design into production sooner, but it also enabled Booster once they got there to go use the same hardware.
Erin Price-Wright 26:28 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 26:28 So from a company goal perspective, it was fantastic, and it was, like, the, the perfect direction, I think. I won't even take... I won't take credit for all of that i, i- ideation. Uh, actually another guy on the team who's still there, uh, kind of brought it to my plate, and I'm like, "Oh, man, that's freaking great. Let's do it. Let's go fast." Um, but that, that's one thing, and it's really just, you know, staying super clear on, on this intention to question every requirement because what that does is it enables your requirement set whenever, you know, an engineer steps in to go actually design the hardware to be, you know, enabled to design a very simple solution. And simple is fast. Simple is cheap. Um, so really, I, I think that whole part of the SpaceX mantra is very real. Uh, and, and it is happening across Starship. It's even happening on, on fixes on Dragon and Falcon as some sort of-
Erin Price-Wright 27:06 Like, if you hadn't been focused... If you, if you hadn't been thinking of two steps ahead about production, you would've just designed-
Chandler Luzsicza 27:12 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 27:12 ... something from scratch-
Chandler Luzsicza 27:14 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 27:14 ... that was perfectly bespoke to the set of requirements that you got.
Chandler Luzsicza 27:16 Exactly. It's like we... Yeah, exactly. Bespoke requirements, and I think, you know, we, we literally had a whole design for all this hardware before realizing, "Oh, crap, we should just go use that," 'cause then we can go start figuring how to build these-
Erin Price-Wright 27:26 Yeah
Chandler Luzsicza 27:27 ... you know, somewhat complex weldments sooner rather than later and then build the production of those very quickly.
Erin Price-Wright 27:31 That's where information access really matters.
Chandler Luzsicza 27:33 Yeah, absolutely.
Erin Price-Wright 27:34 Yeah. What about you, Turner? Um, you know, you helped build Tesla's billion-dollar lithium refinery in Corpus Christi, which is, you know, up and running. Um, what, what were some of the hardest challenges you overcame? How did you, how did you approach them with this kind of factory and production mindset?
Turner Caldwell 27:52 Yeah, I think that, so des- design for, uh, manufacturing is kinda like how you do product design and ensure that you can kind of scale that into something that can be produced at scale with, you know, very, uh, short tack times and all that. Um, but-
Erin Price-Wright 28:03 Yeah, but I mean, people don't really think about a refinery-
Turner Caldwell 28:05 Exactly
Erin Price-Wright 28:06 ... as a product. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 28:07 So, ex- exactly. And so the, the... What we spent a good amount of time thinking about, uh, and then obviously we thought about, uh, when I was at Tesla, was, um, when you're in, when you're in, like, construction, basically, um, the, the environment is you're building a custom thing, right?
Erin Price-Wright 28:22 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 28:22 And so you have to break that down into, like, modular subsets that can be manufactured offsite and brought to site. The, um... And then you have to think, like, everything should have a tack time analysis associated with it, right? Like a very-
Erin Price-Wright 28:35 A what analysis?
Turner Caldwell 28:36 A tack time analysis, which is basically, um, breaking down all of the discrete steps required to go... to, to build something effectively. Um, and that needs to happen in-
Erin Price-Wright 28:46 Is that a Tesla, a SpaceX term-
Turner Caldwell 28:47 No, no
Erin Price-Wright 28:48 ... or is that an industry term?
Turner Caldwell 28:48 That's, uh, that, that's an industry term.
Erin Price-Wright 28:49 Okay.
Turner Caldwell 28:50 Um, yeah, can't take credit for inventing tack time analysis.
Erin Price-Wright 28:52 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 28:53 The, the key there is that, like, through the whole value chain, from, like, R&D, uh, and, like, how your analytical labs run, you should be thinking about, okay, what are the individual steps that go from a sample comes into a lab to a result comes out.
Erin Price-Wright 29:05 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 29:06 Um, and so you need to run analytical labs like little manufacturing processes. On construction, you need to boil it down into specific subsets of tasks that are, you know, actually torquing bolts and actually, like, welding out seams to build that up into, like, what does the schedule actually need to be instead of doing, like, top-down assessments of kind of how long something is gonna take to build. And then when you're in mining operations, you also need to do, like, super discrete tack time analyses of all of the discrete, like, discrete tasks that happen around a mining operation. Um, and I think that the construction industry does not... They, some folks do this, but because of the, like, custom nature of each individual project-
Erin Price-Wright 29:41 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 29:41 ... um, it's, it, you, it takes time and effort, and you have to allocate resources to be able to, like, build, build from the ground up of, like, how long it actually takes to do something. Um, and as we start to think about, like, how do you run construction like manufacturing operations, um, you know, a, the way a construction site runs typically is a superintendent, you know, has been given their target for the month. Um, on a daily basis they'll go out to the field, they'll stand in a circle with the trades. They'll say, "What are you doing today? What are you doing today? What are you doing today?" At the end of the day, they come back, they say, "What did you do today? What did you do today?" And there isn't a lot of, like, quantification that happens-
Erin Price-Wright 30:16 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 30:16 ... um, on a regular basis. Like, there isn't a lot of short-interval control of construction operations that is actually quantified. Um, and so what we, you know-What we have started doing at Mariana, um, is breaking that down and, and this ends up being like a data management thing, right, and a resource allocation optimization that you have to do where you have, uh, a subset of materials and equipment that are on site, you have a subset of people that are on site, and you have a set of tasks that need to be done. And, um, today that is, like, humans trying to, like, sit between those three databases and decide, like, what is the task that's going to happen at the site. Um, and we see a ton of opportunity there to do that algorithmically, um, that enables you, if you have all that data available, you can actually set daily, hourly goals. Um, and then if you can automate the data capture that is happening at the site, like Boston Dynamics has the Spot dog, uh, that works great. It can kind of roam around the site, take 3D scans. You have to do a lot of work on the software side to be able to reconcile the 3D scans that have come in-
Erin Price-Wright 31:13 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 31:13 ... to the model. Um, and then you can actually do short interval control on construction, which is effectively what manufacturing is, which is, like, short, super short interval control. Everyone has a dashboard that tells you, okay, how many parts are we trying to make today, uh, at this station, and they know whether they're trending towards their goal or they're trending behind their goal, uh, or, or exceeding their goal. Um, and, like, measuring the things that matter in construction, in mining, in refining, like that is actually the, the, like, cultural thing that needs to shift.
Erin Price-Wright 31:40 Yeah. Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 31:41 Um, and that we did a good amount of, um, tried, tried to do a good amount of at Tesla, but there's the... Uh, ultimately you have to invest in, like, the software backbone that enables that.
Erin Price-Wright 31:49 From, you know, few, few founders I've heard as often we are ahead of schedule and under budget than, uh, than you, Turner [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 31:55 Well, we're trying. [laughs] Yeah, we're trying. It's about measuring and quantifying. Like, I think a lot of manufacturing, like you go really deep on-
Erin Price-Wright 32:03 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 32:03 ... understanding, like be- because you're ma- making thousands of parts, you know, an hour, um, depending on the scale of manufacturing process. Um, and that level of like measuring and measuring against goals and setting targets just doesn't happen in this like large scale infrastructure-
Erin Price-Wright 32:17 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 32:17 ... um, ecosystem.
Vertical Integration: Really Expensive, Really Hard
Erin Price-Wright 32:18 Um, maybe talking a little bit about vertical integration. It's, um, one of the most obvious and talked about Tesla and SpaceX principles. Uh, it's also really expensive, really hard. There's been, you know, various debates. TVPN had a good session on this-
Turner Caldwell 32:32 [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 32:32 ... uh, recently. Um, you know, should all tech har- hard tech startups vertically integrate? Where and when do you vertically integrate? How do you guys think about it? You know, how do you balance speed with capital intensity and operational risk? I'd love to hear your, your, your thoughts on, on vertical integration. Maybe, uh, Ch-Chandler, why don't you-
Chandler Luzsicza 32:52 Yeah, I can jump in.
Erin Price-Wright 32:53 Why don't you jump in?
Chandler Luzsicza 32:54 I was talking with Mike Vinciati about this directly [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 32:56 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 32:57 Uh, after the-
Erin Price-Wright 32:57 It caused quite a stir.
Chandler Luzsicza 32:59 It sure did.
Erin Price-Wright 32:59 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 32:59 Uh, I was... Yeah, we had a good back and forth. It was funny. I, I'm largely in support of the take that was on there. Um, I think... [clears throat]
Erin Price-Wright 33:05 Maybe for the people who didn't see it, what, what was-
Chandler Luzsicza 33:07 Of course, yes
Erin Price-Wright 33:08 ... the take?
Chandler Luzsicza 33:08 The, the, the take, at least h- my read back on it was it needs to be strategic. Like this, this blank slate, idealistic, we're gonna vertically integrate is like, I think, almost naive in a way. Like vertical, vertical integration is not easy. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 33:23 Certainly not, yeah.
Chandler Luzsicza 33:23 It's, it's very much not easy. Uh, and I think there's f- we, we've, we're coming from places that have made it look easy, for sure. Uh, but it's-
Erin Price-Wright 33:32 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 33:32 ... it's not. [laughs] It's really not easy.
Turner Caldwell 33:34 From the outside. From the outside.
Chandler Luzsicza 33:35 From the outside it looks super easy. Um-
Erin Price-Wright 33:36 Yeah, it's a very romantic dream.
Chandler Luzsicza 33:38 Absolutely. And, and I think you have a lot of people who maybe haven't lived that pain to understand the, like, the, the trade associated with, with going for that strategically. So I think how, how I think about it is we have to bring in the assemblies in-house that, that are going to bottleneck our supply chain as fast or bottleneck our production line as fast as possible. So I think what that looks like for us is, is some of the bigger weldments. Like starting, starting with that sort of thing, bringing it in-house sooner rather than later is something that's relatively easy to do but is a very complex thing that has multiple steps that, that if we can bring that in-house, we, we, we whack one mole on the table, um, of, of getting to this, you know, 10,000 missiles per year number. Um, I think there's of course many more challenges or you, you kind of just... Whenever you're looking at your end state product, you need to go and see what are the things that are, are really hitting me on schedule.
Erin Price-Wright 34:23 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 34:23 And for us, there's probably five of those right now that are, are like screaming at us, like, "Please help. Please help." [laughs] So those things are obviously gonna be top of mind to like how could we do this? Like, what is, what is the way we would do this? And, and then you can actually start to analyze the, the how intense the capital is to, to make it happen, how, how extensive the time is required to actually go and achieve on that. Um, but it's [laughs] it has to be strategic, and I think a lot- the, a lot of the takes that are, uh, we're fully vertically integrated this, we're fully vertically integrated that, is just, uh, it's, it's, it's going to spend a lot of money, that's for sure. [clears throat]
Turner Caldwell 34:56 Yeah, I don't think, uh, vertically integrating for the point of vertically integrating, to kind of echo what Chandler was saying-
Chandler Luzsicza 35:00 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 35:01 ... uh, is makes any sense. Um, I think every vertical integration decision, which there, there are thousands of them, um, need to boil down to like one question, especially in like the early days of companies, is does the company exist or not if you make the decision to ver- if you don't make the decision to vertically integrate. And so like if you boil it down to like a subset of problems that are binary and like does Mariana exist or does Mariana not exist, the, that makes the decision easy where... And, and that could be a number of drivers. So either the part doesn't exist, the technology doesn't exist, or the cost is like so insanely high that the company can't exist by not vertically integrating into the thing. And so if the... And I call it the thing because there's many, many things, uh, and, and like subcomponents or s- parts of the software stack-
Erin Price-Wright 35:43 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 35:43 ... that, you know, if you don't go and do it yourself, like the company just won't exist. And so when you br- boil it down to that, like it ties into like that is the ultimate strategic decision driver. Um, so you should not be vertically integrating just because you can save 5% or 10% or 20, even 50%, um, on a subcomponent that does not kind of check the box of like does the company exist or not if we don't-
Erin Price-Wright 36:05 So it's not primarily a cost thing
Turner Caldwell 36:06 ... it, it shouldn't be in the early days. Like in the early days when you have resources that are, that are slim and you have to decide like where, where do I allocate this, this team that, you know, needs to continue to grow, like all startups or like many startups, um-The, so when you're in that, like, resource-constrained mode, you should only be vertically integrating into the things that are, that have, like, a binary outcome of, like, the company exists or the company doesn't exist. Then eventually once you, like, start to, like, have a large team that can, like, go and you're, and you're driving down unit cost, that's where the, like, cost-driven vertical integration starts to become, like, an interesting and, and much longer decision-
Erin Price-Wright 36:39 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 36:39 ... I would say, because now you're, now it's like on paper it can look great, but the risk transfer from a supplier to yourself, um, is, like, the main thing that you have to be thinking about, right? The, like, folks that do, do anything in your supply chain, th-they are carrying risk in those activities, right? And so whether it is a... You're not eliminating a supply chain point. You're actually expanding your supply chain interactions because the, if you vertically integrate into something that's upstream, they have their own supply chain that you now have to absorb. We made the decision to go and be, you know, a software company that builds and operates minerals infrastructure mainly because software companies that sell to mining companies have a very, very hard time penetrating the sector-
Erin Price-Wright 37:18 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 37:18 ... because the issue is the, like, the rate of uptake of software and of technology is actually gated by what would be the customers if you were a pure play SaaS company.
Erin Price-Wright 37:25 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 37:25 Um, and so the question for us in that regard was always, like, does Mariana exist or not if we're not both a software company and a mining company? The answer to that was no, the company would not exist. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 37:35 Yes. [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 37:36 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 37:36 Um, and so we had to do that. Um-
Erin Price-Wright 37:37 Yeah
Turner Caldwell 37:38 ... but then once you, like, sign up for that, there's a question of, like, how much of your, like, part, like, where do you do partnerships and, and where is there a rich enough ecosystem where there's enough competition to be able to have confidence that, like, the cost will come down on some subcomponent or the cost will come down on some, some part of the software
The Caliber of Talent Tesla and SpaceX Are Famous For
Turner Caldwell 37:53 stack.
Erin Price-Wright 37:54 So something that both Tesla and SpaceX are, you know, pr- pretty famous for is the caliber of talent that they're able to hire, and p- you know, part of it comes back to this mission, this mission problem, this mission alignment that you guys talked about before. Part of it comes down to, you know, people who, pe- people wanna work with other smart people and learn from other smart people. Um, but it's, you know, it's pretty remarkable how many excellent engineers and founders have come out of these companies. So how does hiring work at these companies? Like, how do they get such excellent talent and excellent engineers in the door, and how do you bring that, the, some of those lessons into the companies that you're building today?
Turner Caldwell 38:36 Yeah, I think the, like, the, the key part of the hiring process at, at, at, you know, Tesla at least, and I'm sure at SpaceX, um, is the, the, like, technical, um, evaluation, it goes quite deep.
Erin Price-Wright 38:48 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 38:49 Um, and so they're, you know, you're going to talk to six engine- if you're applying for an engineering role, you're probably talking to six engineers before you're getting an offer. You're almost certainly doing a technical test that kind of shows how you think through problems, and are you able to solve the problems that your resume says you're able to solve.
Erin Price-Wright 39:03 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 39:03 And so that level of, like, technical rigor that goes into assessing folks that are coming into the company is pretty extensive. You- you're gonna have eight to 10 conversations before you get an offer, and we've-
Erin Price-Wright 39:14 And that's a feature, like-
Turner Caldwell 39:15 100%.
Erin Price-Wright 39:16 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 39:16 And, like, it does, does it make the, like, hiring process a little bit slower? Yes. Um, but it is really important to do your darnedest- [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 39:26 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 39:26 ... to make sure that the folks that are coming to the company are gonna come in and be autonomous and able to, like, balance authority and accountability, um, which means that they have to really, really have the deep technical understanding of the field that they're going into. We've mirrored that effectively, um, and ensured that, uh... And it's ha- it's harder when you don't have the brand that, uh, Tesla or SpaceX have, right? Of, you know, the folks who are trying to get a job at those companies, they're like, "Yes, I'll do a tech test. Yes, I will talk to as many people-
Erin Price-Wright 39:53 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 39:53 ... as you want me to talk to." And so you, you know, you, you do have to manage that a little bit with candidates. Um, but for the folks who are really excited about the mission and the folks who are really excited about the company, um, who are the folks that you wanna bring in anyways, um, they will go through that process. Um, and we typically pitch it in both directions. It's like, "Look, if you're gonna join, you're joining a startup that has, you know, inherently has high risk. Um, and so you should also get to know the team that we have."
Erin Price-Wright 40:17 Mm-hmm.
Turner Caldwell 40:17 And so it goes in both directions.
Erin Price-Wright 40:19 I've always found that extremely rigorous and ha- actually hard interviewing processes positively filter for people who are motivated by the really hard interview process.
Turner Caldwell 40:30 Yep.
Erin Price-Wright 40:30 Like, if you're a cracked engineer, you wanna work with other cracked engineers, and you wanna know that other engineers have gone through the same process that you have. And, like, a really hard interview process is pretty fun, but they're very hard to design. Um-
Turner Caldwell 40:42 Yep
Erin Price-Wright 40:42 ... it's not for the faint of heart on the interviewer side.
Chandler Luzsicza 40:45 I, I think to not just repeat what he said-
Erin Price-Wright 40:47 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 40:47 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 40:47 ... just to answer the question-
Erin Price-Wright 40:48 Sorry. [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 40:48 No, no, that's good. Uh, it, it is very similar, uh, but the distinction I'll make, and I think the value I can add here is, um, I, very true on the full-time, like, say, multi-year experienced person who's coming to a SpaceX. Like, they're going through four, five, six screens, right? A panel interview to finish it off. Um, I think the, the, the value that I can add here is particularly related to the internship funnel.
Erin Price-Wright 41:10 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 41:10 I think given the brand with Tesla and SpaceX, like, literally it's been quantified. These are, like, the most applied-to programs ever. [laughs] And they've got this insane interest from the public, which obviously is a double-edged sword, right? It's like you, you get very good, but you also get very bad. It's a, it's a broad spread. Um, however, I think looking at the, the impact of, of these, of these internsh- internship programs on the eventual full-time candidates or the full-time, um, uh, employees, it, it gives, it gives a three-month trial period to these people.
Erin Price-Wright 41:38 Yeah.
Chandler Luzsicza 41:39 And the people that crush stay [laughs] all the time, and, and y- I find that, myself included, I was a, I, I interned at SpaceX four times. [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 41:47 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 41:47 I couldn't leave. Like, it was, it was the dream. I, I started sophomore year-
Erin Price-Wright 41:50 You were like, "Oh, maybe I'll try something, try a different-
Chandler Luzsicza 41:52 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 41:52 ... internship one summer."
Chandler Luzsicza 41:53 I almost dropped out of school to stay-
Erin Price-Wright 41:54 No
Chandler Luzsicza 41:54 ... but they, but they said we couldn't do that anymore. It's not the old days. So-
Erin Price-Wright 41:57 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 41:57 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 41:57 [laughs] Uh, but they're-I, I think the, the overwhelming population of folks that are doing so much of the critical work on Starship, Dragon, Falcon even, um, are intern conversions.
Erin Price-Wright 42:09 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 42:09 And, and I think that program is so freaking crucial to, like, the eventual engineering population because it, it gives people a real chance to go and demonstrate that, yes, I am, I am, I am a killer, right? I am, I am badass. I can do this thing.
Erin Price-Wright 42:23 So at Galadyne-
Chandler Luzsicza 42:23 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 42:23 ... like, you're a small team still.
Chandler Luzsicza 42:25 Yeah.
Erin Price-Wright 42:25 You're growing your team.
Chandler Luzsicza 42:26 We just launched an internship program. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 42:27 [laughs] I was just gonna say.
Chandler Luzsicza 42:28 We just did-
Erin Price-Wright 42:29 How, how-
Chandler Luzsicza 42:29 ... for this reason
Erin Price-Wright 42:29 ... yeah, how are you thinking about that, um, and, and, and designing your both internship program, but-
Chandler Luzsicza 42:34 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 42:34 ... like broader interview process-
Chandler Luzsicza 42:35 Yeah
Erin Price-Wright 42:36 ... to get the best quality people in the door?
Chandler Luzsicza 42:38 Yep. So a- we're still very small, so it's, it's not really saying much, but I'm of course talking to every person. I, I don't know if you still are. I'm, I'm sure you are.
Erin Price-Wright 42:44 Multiple times.
Chandler Luzsicza 42:45 Um, yeah, exactly. Yeah, multiple times, uh, coercing them over the phone, convincing them that-
Erin Price-Wright 42:49 Are you doing-
Chandler Luzsicza 42:50 ... working for us
Erin Price-Wright 42:50 ... both kind of the, the, the, the, uh, behavioral interviews and-
Chandler Luzsicza 42:54 Oh, yeah
Erin Price-Wright 42:54 ... the, like, deep dive technical interviews?
Chandler Luzsicza 42:55 Yeah. I find that I get a lot out of, like... I, I, I, I always start with one sort of broad question, then dig into a lot of things, but I, I, I really open it up to, to allow myself a playground to, like, punch and jab and, and go around their problem set. But I, I effectively ask, "Walk me through a problem that you solved." And whenever they walk through that problem, over 20 minutes or 15 minutes, I, I know very quickly whether or not they're good or not good. Um, and usually I'm, I'm okay enough to, no matter what the discipline is, to kinda jab and punch around that problem set a little bit to, to feel it out. Um, but I, I find that's pretty hard to, to, uh, get past my s- my screen there, um, with people who are, who are not, not true. But for the full-time process, we're, we're doing, you know, two, three screens and then a panel interview. And, and w- a large part of my framing, too, is, is very much, "I wanna introduce you to the team."
Erin Price-Wright 43:37 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 43:37 Like, we have a very small team that you're gonna need to live with [laughs] effectively, and we wanna make sure that we're happy with you and, and you're happy with us, and this gives you the perfect forum to do it. Um, so tha- that's usually how we finish our, our, our full-time process. But, but for interns, we're figuring out right now. It's a shorter process, admittedly, but what I, what I'm really looking for for this first wave of, of, uh, of [laughs] missile engineers is, is, is passion. Like, I need people who are gonna come in and crush. And fortunately-
Erin Price-Wright 44:00 And, like, what, what-
Chandler Luzsicza 44:01 ... Elon gives me a lot of them
Erin Price-Wright 44:01 ... backgrounds of interns are you, are you hiring for?
Chandler Luzsicza 44:04 Uh, project teams, doesn't matter which.
Erin Price-Wright 44:06 Got it.
Chandler Luzsicza 44:06 Uh, so the Formula SAEs, the, the, um, the whatever drone UAS stuff, the rocket teams, too. Um, I actually found, uh, [laughs] a specific rocket team in the country that, that works on ro- uh, rockets with the same propellants that we're using, which I did not know existed, 'cause it, it's a little bit m- m- more rare, but I'm targeting that school. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 44:24 Ge- get them all out.
Chandler Luzsicza 44:25 Yeah. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 44:25 Get them all out to Austin.
Chandler Luzsicza 44:25 Get the whole team. [laughs] Get them on a bus and bring them over here.
Erin Price-Wright 44:29 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 44:29 Uh, but, but, yeah.
Advice for Young Engineers Starting Their Careers
Erin Price-Wright 44:30 Uh, maybe wrapping up, um, gi- given we're talking about hiring interns and, and young talent, both of you started your careers at Tesla and SpaceX, you know, relatively young, um, what advice would you give to a young SpaceX or Tesla engineer, or in fact just a young engineer overall, who's thinking about maybe one day leaving to start a company? How should they be thinking about that journey?
Turner Caldwell 44:53 Yeah. I would, I would say, um, you know, if you, if you're at a company that has, you know, really, really high talent density, um, and you're in a position where you feel like you're constantly learning and every day is kind of like a growth opportunity, um, and you get to see projects from, like, the messy phase, the, the, the early messy phases through the middle messy phases through the kind of deployment messy phases, um, like, that experience is, is incredibly valuable. And getting to do that-
Erin Price-Wright 45:21 Seeing something through end to end
Turner Caldwell 45:23 ... end to end. So I would say that I wouldn't go and start something, uh, until you have, like, been able to sit around a project that you have seen go end to end and then done that multiple times. That enables you to see how, like, how much better can you get with each iteration of, um, of, of, like, from concept through to deployment. And getting that to, getting to do that with, like, the most awesome people in the world, um, is, is, like, a very unique experience that positions you to be able to go and start something eventually. But I wouldn't, like, rush to leave and go start something because, one, your credibility, um, to bu- really your credibility to attract talent-
Erin Price-Wright 45:59 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 45:59 ... 'cause, like, the, like, the companies are, are ultimately, like, this assembly of, like, awesome people who are driven towards a, a mission that everyone's excited about. Um, and so convincing people to join you on that mission, that's going to be painful. It's going to be risky. Um, you have a lot more credibility if you have, like, been through the execution cycle multiple times-
Erin Price-Wright 46:17 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 46:17 ... know, have, like, the kind of embedded understanding of, like, how long does some part of that process take or how long does that whole process have to take so that you can credibly set targets that the team can then rally behind and go build, uh, build to. And so, um, I would say that getting... Like, having done that, you take, take full advantage of, like, ecosystems and companies where you have the ability to do that, um, and, and where, you know, they're insulating you a little bit from the risk that you have to be able com- like, be comfortable taking. Um, and as long as you're getting authority and accountability in, like, the scopes that you're getting within the company, and then you're getting, like, more and more of that, that is gonna be invaluable experience that, uh, that will enable to s- set you up to be successful.
Erin Price-Wright 46:57 I see you nodding, Chandler.
Chandler Luzsicza 46:59 Yeah. I'm, I'm trying to think about... Again-
Erin Price-Wright 47:00 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 47:01 ... I think Turner and I live the same life. [laughs] Just he's a little bit, a couple years ahead. Um, I started at SpaceX when I was 18 years old. Like, that was when I first entered the doors into the fun candy land that was SpaceX, and it was the dream.
Erin Price-Wright 47:11 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 47:11 Right? And I told myself from day one that I'm gonna be a sponge. Like, I, I want to be the biggest sponge I possibly can to absorb as much freaking information from all these amazing people as I can. Um, that's not, not an internship-limited thing. That's a forever thing. I'm still doing it today. But I think, yeah, a lot of, a lot of how I approached it and how I think people should approach it generally, not, not just if they're going to a SpaceX or a Tesla, but they should, they should really approach, you know, this from a how can I surround myself with the best people in the world, um, and work on a project from start to finish and, and do those reps, like what Turner was saying. I will s- I will caveat that, though, with it, it's, it's hard, right? If, if you're, if you're fresh coming out of school, you may not know what that looks like. So maybe, maybe some actionable recommendation is, you know, lean on, lean on your network. Lean on people you know, both in school, peers who may have interned elsewhere and seen other environments. Or, um, if there's professors, other people in your life that you can have meaningful conversations with about perspective on, on certain companies, just missions, products, that sort of thing, like, go do that thing, because it, it can be hard. Like, it, it can be kind of scary. You don't know because you haven't already done it. You don't know if-
Erin Price-Wright 48:11 What good looks like
Chandler Luzsicza 48:12 ... what g- what good looks like, exactly. So it... I, I will, yeah, caveat it with, with it's hard, but once you find that, that sweet spot of, of place to be, then just go be a sponge.
Erin Price-Wright 48:21 Yeah. I think knowing what good looks like and being able to develop an understanding and intuition for how exceptional teams build is, like, pretty invaluable.
Chandler Luzsicza 48:32 Yep. Yeah, I, I don't think I could start Galadyne with- without having spent, you know, a handful of years doing the things I did at SpaceX, so.
Turner Caldwell 48:40 Yeah, I think that m- maybe the last thing I'll say is that you're, you'll never actually be, like, fully trained to go and start a company.
Chandler Luzsicza 48:46 Totally.
Erin Price-Wright 48:47 [laughs]
Turner Caldwell 48:47 Like, the [laughs] like, it's not like you stay there for... It's, it's, there's no recipe. It's not like you stay somewhere for 10 years, and then you go and you work on... You go and start a company. The... And so there's always gonna be an, like a, a, a, when, when do you feel yourself confident to go and take a risk, and different people are gonna have different perspectives on, like, when do they feel ready to go and do it. But I generally think that you want to have as strong of a technical basis before you go and have to learn all of the company-building-
Erin Price-Wright 49:12 Mm-hmm
Turner Caldwell 49:12 ... uh, side of, of things. And so making sure that you're kind of, like, over-indexing on the technical side before you go and, uh, kind of sign up for figuring out how to hire and figuring out how to fundraise and figuring out how to build all the eco- the ecosystem around a company that, and the infrastructure around a company that has to be built, um, 'cause you are gonna keep learning as, once you go and start something. But, you know, being hyper-focused on building that strong technical basis is the, is the key.
Chandler Luzsicza 49:35 Yeah, I can imagine [laughs] like this, already having the technical basis and going and growing into the fundraising, all of this other stuff that I didn't know how to do, like, this is already hard. I could not imagine the inverse.
Erin Price-Wright 49:44 Mm-hmm.
Chandler Luzsicza 49:45 Like, going in, and, and being, uh, going and needing to figure out all of the technical chops that I have up till this point, or at least enough to, to be successful in what we're trying to do, uh, would be very, very difficult. [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 49:57 [laughs]
Chandler Luzsicza 49:58 So I'd much rather have-
Erin Price-Wright 49:58 Don't, don't, don't, don't try to learn how to build rockets on the job-
Chandler Luzsicza 50:01 Yeah [laughs]
Erin Price-Wright 50:01 ... as a founder. That's good advice.
Chandler Luzsicza 50:02 Yep.
Erin Price-Wright 50:03 Cool. All right. This was awesome. Thanks, guys.
Chandler Luzsicza 50:04 Yeah.
Turner Caldwell 50:04 Great. Thanks.
Episode duration: 50:25
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode YAyYCdCkwo4