By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
The Curiosity Shop with Brené Brown and Adam GrantWhy Our Words are so Important | The Curiosity Shop
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
55 min read · 11,344 wordsIntroduction
Brené Brown 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone. I'm Brené Brown.
Adam Grant 0:07 And I'm Adam Grant.
Brené Brown 0:09 And today, we're here to watch Adam be really generous to me. Um, I don't wanna be wrong on this topic today. I do not, I cannot be wrong on this topic today. I am very vested in my rightness.
Adam Grant 0:26 Wow. Okay, so you're already appealing to my core values and asking me to violate other values.
Brené Brown 0:31 [laughs] You sort that shit out on your own, but I need to be right.
Adam Grant 0:36 [laughs]
Brené Brown 0:36 You, you, you sort your value hierarchy over there. I'll... You, you do that over there, but we're gonna talk about two insidious Machiavellian communication tools that people use that are my least favorite in the whole world.
Adam Grant 0:59 I can't wait.
Brené Brown 1:00 [laughs]
Adam Grant 1:00 But I should say, a wise friend once told me, "It's more important to get it right than to be right."
Brené Brown 1:08 Yeah, I call bullshit, but okay.
Adam Grant 1:09 [laughs]
Brené Brown 1:09 So
The Invisible Army
Brené Brown 1:11 let's start with... So I think we all know this first one. It is... I, I'm guilty of doing it, and I've been on the receiving end of it, and it's hard. It... I, I call it, in my work, The Invisible Army. So in a work context, uh, you're my boss, and I come up to you and I say, "Hey, Adam, we're all e- we're really exhausted. All of us are really tired of the way these priorities are shifting. We're really kind of sick of the pressure on us to do more with less, and we need a break." What's your first instinct there?
Adam Grant 1:53 I wanna hear more.
Brené Brown 1:55 Okay. W- let me, let me tell you my first instinct. Let's turn this scenario around. You come to me and say, "We're all exhausted. We're tired. We're, we're... The constant reprioritization's killing us. We need a break." I'm gonna wanna look at you and say, "You got a mouse in your pocket?" Like, who's we? I, I, I cannot... I, I... This Invisible Army, we all think, we all believe, we're all wondering. Like, come to me with the I. That's important enough. But for me, the Invisible Army of the people that are backing up your... You know, and even in, in, in personal, in the personal world. "Listen, we're all... We, we... We're all really disappointed by this," or, you know, "We all think you should talk to Dad about this."
Adam Grant 2:50 This is so fascinating. This is exactly the kind of communication I teach.
Brené Brown 2:56 You teach people to say we?
Adam Grant 2:58 Absolutely. It's, I mean, it signals that you're not selfish, that you're thinking about the good of the group.
Brené Brown 3:04 No.
Adam Grant 3:04 And that, you know, you're, you're not raising something that's idiosyncratic.
Brené Brown 3:08 No, it's-
Adam Grant 3:08 It's actually relevant to everyone
Brené Brown 3:10 ... it's chicken shit.
Adam Grant 3:12 [laughs]
Brené Brown 3:12 It... I, I, I completely disagree. Unless you're willing to say to me, "Hey, Adam, do you have a second? Um, I sat down and spoke with Sabrina, Jose, and Jack around what's going on, and we kinda came up with some ideas. They were not able to meet with you, and... But they said that I could talk to you about this." I mean, I, I think it's terrible. Like, I, I, I literally, like, unless you have a critter in your pocket-
Adam Grant 3:43 [laughs]
Brené Brown 3:44 ... I don't ever wanna hear your Invisible Army.
Adam Grant 3:47 Okay, I do. I wanna hear it all the time, but I don't, I don't want it to be invisible. So I think what you just outlined is ideal in an environment with high psychological safety. That's, that's the standard I'm aspiring to all the time. Um, and anyone should be able to s- s- speak on behalf of the group, or ideally, everyone is speaking independently for themselves. In environments that lack psychological safety, if you're in a culture of fear, if you're in a culture of blame and shame, um, it's, it's really risky to put yourself out there. And so if I'm the one to come to you and say, "Hey, I've heard a lot of people complaining about this," everyone else is afraid to tell you, that for me, that's an act of courage, right? Because I'm the messenger, and I might get shot, and it's so important that I'm willing to raise it anyway on behalf of the group.
Brené Brown 4:30 You did not say we once in your role model here. You said, "I'm coming-"
Adam Grant 4:33 No, I'm not role modeling it.
Brené Brown 4:34 No, I'm just saying-
Adam Grant 4:35 I'm, I'm explaining-
Brené Brown 4:35 I'm just saying, you said, "I'm coming to you because here's what I'm hearing, and I think other people are concerned about it, so I wanted to let you know." That is not the Invisible Army.
Adam Grant 4:46 Isn't it, though?
Brené Brown 4:47 No. I-
Adam Grant 4:47 Aren't they less visible?
Brené Brown 4:48 No, no, no. That is... No. I think that's very different than you arming yourself with we all believe, we all think. You're saying, "I'm observing this. I wanted to let you know about my observation."
Adam Grant 5:04 Oh.
Brené Brown 5:04 You're not representing. You're not a... You're not representing a delegation, a fake delegation of fake-ass people, um, because you're, you're not using the I statement. And so-
Adam Grant 5:17 That's so interesting.
Brené Brown 5:19 Yeah, I think it... I think this is really important, because literally, this Invisible Army, it... And the way it plays out in family dynamics is, you know, my sisters and I talk about this all the time. "Yeah, we all think you're being a real asshole here." Like, "We who?" "I'm not gonna say, 'cause, you know, again, because you're an asshole." No, no. Like, if you think I'm being an asshole, I wanna hear that from you. But again, unless you've got people in your pocket, and if you do, bring them out, and then de-shrink them up to human size, and let's have a real adult conversation. I think the Invisible Army, I think if you're teaching peopleTo have the courage to say, "There's something going on I think you should know about. I can't speak clearly to people's comfort levels about coming to you, but here's something I'm seeing. I think it's getting in the way of the work we're doing, and I wanted to let you know about it," that's really respectful and thoughtful. If you're coming in and leading-
Adam Grant 6:25 This is so fascinating.
Brené Brown 6:26 Yeah. If you're leading with we all think, I, I, I'm gonna wanna know who. And I'm gonna, I'm gonna tell you why this is such, why this is so important right now. The cha- the velocity and volume of change right now is so untenable that there are no way, there's no way people can keep up. We, we can't keep everybody informed every second about the changes that are happening. And in the absence of data, we make up stories. We just know that because we're a meaning-making species. It does require psychological safety and good le- and daring, really good, daring leadership to say to your team, "Listen, I'll tell you what I know when I know. If you find yourself making up stories about what's happening, I want you to check them out with me." And you c- it's as simple as saying, "Hey, the story I'm making up right now is h- this." When you start using invisible armies, you are taking small collections of fire and pouring gasoline on them. And it is s- it creates such a toxic environment. We all believe. We all think.
Adam Grant 7:50 So I have, I have a different reaction to this.
Brené Brown 7:52 Okay.
Adam Grant 7:52 I think the two versions that you think are so different for me are almost identical. And [laughs] when... So le- let me, let me actually just react to what you just said. I think when you say it creates a toxic environment to bring an invisible army, I, what I see is people are doing that because they're in a toxic environment. That is a survival strategy. I'm coming to you and I'm saying, "Hey, I've been elected by a group of people who are too afraid to even give you their names." I- I'm speaking up because I think you're gonna lose some really amazing people, and they're, they're just too nervous to even put their, you know, their thoughts out there in a way that could damage their reputation or their relationship with you. And I know that it's, it's ironic that, that this is my reaction, not yours, because you're the one of the two of us who's normally more sensitive to, to power differences, right? And I just look at this and I see... I'm not, like, when, when someone comes to you and they have the invisible army, yeah, I get, I get that in some cases, you know, it's a strategy, and they're, they're trying to bolster credibility, or they're trying to build up support for something that they know is a little self-serving, um, or, you know, kind of just a, a personal ask. But that's not, that's not how I see it unfold in most of the organizations I work with. I see people do this when they feel they have no other choice. And this is a culture in which, uh, people do not speak truth to power, and so this is the only way I can do that safely.
Brené Brown 9:23 So this, this is, this is gonna maybe get too nuanced for the podcast, where listeners and watchers are gonna be like, "What's happening here?" Again, I did not hear you, in your example, use an invisible army. I heard you-
Adam Grant 9:37 Isn't an inv- Wait, so-
Brené Brown 9:38 I heard you take, I heard you take full responsibility for what you were doing. I'm coming to you.
Adam Grant 9:49 Mm-hmm.
Brené Brown 9:50 I was elected by a group of people who are fearful about coming to you to let you know these things. That is very different than saying, "We believe, we feel, we want." That, that, tha- those are, those are, to me, even neurolinguistically, very different things.
Adam Grant 10:19 S- okay. That's, that's a helpful distinction. Now, okay, so when you said invisible army originally-
Brené Brown 10:26 Yeah
Adam Grant 10:26 ... I was thinking, "Uh, okay, you're objecting to any time I come and speak on behalf of a group, but you don't know who they are." And you're only objecting to a subset of that, when I'm claiming to proxy a bunch of people who are hidden or unknown, and I'm not willing to even take ownership over the fact that I agree with them.
Brené Brown 10:45 Right. Huge difference.
Adam Grant 10:48 Yeah, that is a big difference. I agree with that.
Brené Brown 10:50 Yeah, and I have to tell you that, like, when I think about this from an organizational perspective as a former union steward, that was my job, you know? But in, in, not until this very second sitting here did I even think about the possibility that that's where this training came from. So as a union steward, I oft- I, I had to be... I never, I was trained to never say, "We believe, we feel." Now, I was trained to believe there's a problem on the floor.
Adam Grant 11:33 Yes.
Brené Brown 11:34 This is what's generating fear. It's getting in the way of work.
Adam Grant 11:38 Yes.
Brené Brown 11:38 It's creating burnout and call-ins, call-outs. So that's different because I'm taking responsibility for coming to you with a problem that I'm observing. I'm not pretending to represent exactly how people feel and think and believe because-
Adam Grant 11:57 Yeah
Brené Brown 11:57 ... I'm scare, I'm scared that me believing and thinking and feeling it isn't enough.
Adam Grant 12:03 Yes. Yeah, that-
Brené Brown 12:04 Is that the-
Adam Grant 12:04 I've never, I've... Yes. I have never noticed this distinction until you brought it up, and I, I think it's important and rightYou know, it, it reminds me of some, some research I published years ago with Sharon Parker and Katherine Collins where we studied how often people spoke up with concerns and suggestions.
Brené Brown 12:22 Mm-hmm.
Adam Grant 12:23 And we were interested in whether supervisors valued and appreciated it [laughs] or whether they, they tended to reject it. And what our data showed was that supervisors liked it if you were doing it for pro-social reasons, if it seemed like you were trying to help the group, and, you know, you were bringing up a, a problem or a solution-
Brené Brown 12:40 Yeah
Adam Grant 12:40 ... that could benefit the whole team. But if supervisors perceived it as self-serving rather than benevolent, they tended to dismiss it or even penalize it. And I've always then assumed that the we language is a way of signaling, "Hey, this is, this is a collective problem, and I'm trying to help all of us." But I think you're right that if you do that in a way that, [laughs] that, that essentially says, "Yeah, here is, here, there's a, there's a group with a uniform opinion, and I'm gonna tell you I have read all their minds, I have captured all of their feelings and thoughts, and I'm gonna tell you everything that they want," that's not credible. That is manipulative.
Brené Brown 13:20 It's mani- Okay, so that, that's the thing that we're trying to avoid here in communication. For me, well, to be honest with you, if you come in and say, "We all believe this" or, "We all think this," I immediately don't trust you.
Adam Grant 13:36 I don't either, and it's not, it's not just you. I now have doubts about your group too, because-
Brené Brown 13:41 [laughs]
Adam Grant 13:41 ... if you're telling me the truth, best case scenario, then we're in the middle of groupthink. You got a bunch of people who are a hive mind, and they're just clones of each other. They're not thinking independently. They're not coming to their own conclusions. They're sharing all of the same assumptions, and that means their thinking is faulty and flawed. So I don't, I don't wanna listen to it, [laughs] even if you're being honest with me.
Brené Brown 14:00 Right. And so they, just, just listen for, listen for the accountability shift here. I wanted to talk to you about something I'm, uh, observing in the team, and I'm not sure whether you're hearing this from other people or not, but I felt li- I feel like it's an important thing to talk to you about. Here's what I'm seeing, and here's how it's disrupting work, and here's how it's creating a lot of anxiety and self-doubt. This is my observation. Versus I came in to tell you that we all think this, we're all feeling this, and we all believe this.
Adam Grant 14:39 Yes.
Brené Brown 14:42 And if I come back to you and say, "Well, I don't understand why..." "No, no, no, no. Don't get mad at me. No, no, no. I'm just saying that this is what everybody's thinking. This is what everybody's feeling." Um, so I think precision, especially right now when shit is so hard, precision of language as it relates to what you're representing and what you're accountable for is, I was gonna say king, but is even more important that. It's queen.
Adam Grant 15:16 Yes. Yes. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.
Brené Brown 15:19 Support for the show comes from Shopify. There's always something a little
Speaking Up and Pluribus
Brené Brown 15:23 scary about starting your own business, and listeners of this show know that when you take on any endeavor, there will be bumps along that road and a lot of what-ifs. But tools like Shopify can help settle those nerves and make things way less intimidating. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e-commerce in the US, from household names like Rare Beauty and Skims to brands just getting started. Shopify can help you build an online store that matches your brand's style with hundreds of ready-to-use templates. And whether you're uploading new products or trying to improve existing ones, Shopify can help accelerate your efficiency. Their AI tools can help you write product descriptions, page headlines, and even help enhance your product photography. Best yet, Shopify can be your commerce expert with world-class expertise in everything from managing inventory to international shipping to processing returns and beyond. It's time to turn those what-ifs into [bell dings] with Shopify today. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at shopify.com/curiosity. Go to shopify.com/curiosity. That's shopify.com/curiosity. [bell dings]
Adam Grant 16:45 Okay. I wanna, I wanna talk about, I, it, I think it sounds like we're gonna talk a lot about language today.
Brené Brown 16:50 Yeah.
Adam Grant 16:50 Which is great, because you and, you and I are both word nerds.
Brené Brown 16:53 Yeah, yeah.
Adam Grant 16:53 And I think, I don't think enough people spend enough time choosing their words carefully. Before, before we, we talk more about language, two things that jumped out at me on this. Number one, have you, have, have you been watching Pluribus?
Brené Brown 17:08 I can't. I tried. I wanted to. I just... It's so... It, I, I go to bed at night, and I can't stop thinking about it. Like, I, I can't. So, but tell me, tell me what you're seeing and watching. I'm obsessed-
Adam Grant 17:23 Well, I'm only-
Brené Brown 17:23 ... with the whole concept. [laughs]
Adam Grant 17:25 I'm only two episodes in, and I don't wanna spoil it for people who haven't seen it, but-
Brené Brown 17:29 Okay
Adam Grant 17:30 ... the, the reaction I had watching it and seeing the way that a collective communicates as one gave me the same ick that your "We all believe, and we all think, and we all want" gave me. And I think-
Brené Brown 17:43 Oh, God. That's so interesting
Adam Grant 17:46 ... I think anybody who wants to understand, like, viscerally why you're so bothered by one claiming to fully represent a whole, like, [laughs] just go watch two episodes of Pluribus. Done.
Brené Brown 17:58 Is it... I mean, I heard the acting's amazing. H- is it, it just...
Adam Grant 18:02 It's, it's been stunning so far, but-
Brené Brown 18:05 Wow, okay.
Adam Grant 18:07 More, more to watch.
Brené Brown 18:07 Maybe I'll try, maybe I'll try it again. Okay, what's the other thing you wanted to t- like, I love this. I love this pop culture reference.
Adam Grant 18:13 Okay. The, this, the other one's the opposite of pop culture, but-I was just thinking about this, you know, this how do you approach speaking up in a low versus high psychological safety climate question that we were talking about. And one of the questions I get asked a lot, uh, I get, I get tons of questions from managers and leaders about, like, should we do an anonymous survey of our people, or should we make the survey identified? And I've always been torn on this, and I'm curious to hear your take because I think an anonymous survey is an Invisible Army of sorts, but I don't think it's the kind you object to.
Brené Brown 18:51 No, because I think an anonymous survey is individuals... There's not a re- there's not a representation. There's not a royal we there. Um, so I think-
Adam Grant 19:05 Yep
Brené Brown 19:05 ... there's, there's a representation, a one-on-one representation of data to person, even if that person is de-identified or anonymous. Um, I, I, I think whenever... I of course, I get this question often as well. The thing that's, the thi- the first thing, because I work from kind of the social work ethic of do no harm first, the first thing that always comes up for me is how anonymous really is your anonymous survey? What's your sample size? How's it being reported? Is it tied to IP address? Um, I would never commit to anonymity if it's not true anonymity, which really is about team size and all kinds of technology stuff. Um, and I think for me, the answer to that question is always what is your intention? You know, what are you trying to... I have really mixed feelings about 360s as well. I, I, there's, I, I've worked with one company-
Adam Grant 20:04 Same
Brené Brown 20:04 ... out of 30 that does it well. You know?
Adam Grant 20:07 Yeah, it's hard.
Brené Brown 20:08 Um, yeah, they're hard, and they're flawed, and a flawed, a f- a, a, a 360 that has flawed design, flawed implementation, and flawed analysis can just blow up a team and a person.
Adam Grant 20:30 Yeah. Yeah. I've, I've, I've seen it happen. And, you know, the, the survey dilemma is interesting because I think on one level, I, I want, I wanna get to a point where people can say what they really think and put their names on it, but the bigger the organization, the larger the team, the harder that is. And so [laughs] one of the things I've, yeah, I've sometimes, you know, had leaders say, "But, you know, I, I create, I create an environment where, you know, everyone can tell me the truth. My door is always open. Um, you know, I'm, I'm non-threatening. I'm, I'm inclusive." And sometimes I say, "Okay, let's run the test. Ask people to give you direct feedback, and then we're gonna do an anonymous survey." And the larger the gap is between what-
Brené Brown 21:15 Uh-huh
Adam Grant 21:15 ... people say to your face and what they say under the cover of secrecy, the more of a problem you have with psychological safety. And-
Brené Brown 21:23 That's interesting
Adam Grant 21:24 ... I think, I think there's some, there's something
‘But’ or Escaping Accountability?
Adam Grant 21:26 to be said for, like, let's let people be invisible, but let's not have one person claim to be in charge of the army.
Brené Brown 21:34 I, I think that's ex- I think that's exactly right. The biggest problem with the Invisible Army is the, um, purported representation.
Adam Grant 21:43 Yeah.
Brené Brown 21:43 And so-
Adam Grant 21:44 Yeah
Brené Brown 21:45 ... yeah. And I think the other thing that is interesting to me is if... [laughs] I always ask leaders, if their door is open and they're receptive to feedback, then why are they asking me about doing an anonymous survey? I mean, so you, you would know. Um, the other thing is I, I am pro anonymity in any culture where there are not open conversations about power. So that's my litmus test. If you talk openly about power, if you talk openly about identity, if you talk about, you know, being the only anything in a room, if you, if, if those are just kind of normative cultural conversations, then I'm more open to believing that the door is really open. If any conversation about power or equity is off limits, then, you know, I'd wear gloves when I completed the anonymous survey. You know, just, yeah.
Adam Grant 22:41 That's a great point.
Brené Brown 22:44 Yeah. [laughs] Okay, do you wanna go to the next one? And this, I'm probably more loaded for bear on this one than even the first one.
Adam Grant 22:51 [laughs]
Brené Brown 22:51 Wait, why are you laughing?
Adam Grant 22:52 I, I'm ju- I'm just laughing because you were the one who said a few episodes ago, like, we, we shouldn't try to amplify tension. We should just, you know, share and then see where the tension emerges. And here you are saying, "I am loaded. I wanna be right."
Brené Brown 23:07 I, I do wanna be right here because these are, like, these are, the, this one is really tough. So I'll introduce this by saying I call these bullshit disclaimers. I know there are other terms in the, in the research for them, but they're wrong. Um, and then I wanna, I... Let me just give you the first one. Anything that starts with, "Look, I don't mean to be critical, but..." "I don't mean to be shitty, but..." "I hate to be rude, but..."
Adam Grant 23:37 That's my least favorite one. Not to be rude, but-
Brené Brown 23:39 Yeah
Adam Grant 23:40 ... you're about to say something really inappropriate and offensive.
Brené Brown 23:43 Right.
Adam Grant 23:43 Thank you for giving me a heads-up.
Brené Brown 23:44 That's it. So let me translate those for you. I'm gonna be like the translator. When someone says, "I don't mean, I don't mean to be critical, but," what they're saying is I'm getting ready to be very critical, and I do not wanna be held accountable for that behavior. When they say, "Hey, listen, I don't mean to be shitty, Adam, but," they're getting ready to be shitty, but they don't wanna be held accountable for being shitty. That, this is the translation here. Here's, here's the translation ring. Um, look, not to be rude, but translation, do, do, do, do, do, do, do, I'm fixing to be really rude. I do not wanna be held accountable for it.That's what's happening here. Thoughts? These are hedges, soft openings. They're called a lot of things. I call them bullshit, but go ahead.
Adam Grant 24:32 I love it. I love it. These, [laughs] these disclaimers, the, the kinds of disclaimers that you're talking about-
Brené Brown 24:37 Yes
Adam Grant 24:37 ... which are a different kind than the sort I wanna defend.
Brené Brown 24:40 Okay, great.
Adam Grant 24:41 [laughs] Which is, which is good news, I think. Uh, the kind that you're talking about are... I never thought about it as escaping accountability.
Brené Brown 24:50 Oh, 100%, yes.
Adam Grant 24:51 When I thought about it, it... But I, I think you're spot on. I, I had a, I had a different way of, of thinking about why those bother me, which is when somebody says, "Not to be rude, but..." I think that they're, they're trying to, they're trying to preempt what they realize is a reasonable reaction and prevent you from having it. And-
Brené Brown 25:13 I... Yes.
Adam Grant 25:14 And ironically-
Brené Brown 25:14 It-
Adam Grant 25:14 ... I think it has the opposite effect, right? [laughs] It, it puts your guard up and leaves-
Brené Brown 25:18 For sure
Adam Grant 25:18 ... you to say, "Wait a minute. Uh, you're... Why, why are you mentioning rudeness? Why are you saying not to be critical? You must have had a critical thought." And so I think it's, it's counterproductive regardless of, you know, w- regardless of what the person's intent is, right? That they're, they're trying to escape accountability. It doesn't work because it draws your attention to the very thing that they're trying to minimize.
Brené Brown 25:42 Yes, and it's, it is absolutely a... It's an accountability trapdoor, and I'm just realizing again in real time for the first time that the reason I do not like the Invisible Army or the bullshit disclaimer for, is for the same reason. It lacks accountability. They... I, I, I just don't like the lack of accountability. So what, what I teach people to... And I, I mentor a lot of women, and I mentor a lot of women who are first-time college graduates, undergrad graduates that are getting PhDs, and they're on the receiving end of these things all the time. And so I think to combat the bullshit disclaimer, I like to go to... I wanna share this with you. It's one of my favorite thing. It's, it's Alberto Ban- Brandolini's... I love this, the bullshit asymmetry principle. Do you know it?
Adam Grant 26:44 I love Brandolini's laws. Go.
Brené Brown 26:45 Okay. Brandolini's bullshit asymmetry principle: The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it. And so you have to do some work to, to, to really combat this. So let's do a role play. Are you game?
Adam Grant 27:04 I'm ready.
Brené Brown 27:04 Okay. I want you to say, "Look, I really don't wanna be critical, but..." like you're starting a sentence.
Adam Grant 27:12 Brené-
Brené Brown 27:13 Yeah
Adam Grant 27:13 ... I don't wanna be critical, but-
Brené Brown 27:15 Okay, wait, wait. Let me stop you there. I'm so glad that you don't wanna be critical. Do you wanna take a few minutes to find a more productive way to share your feedback and coaching with me? 'Cause I'm really, I'm really grateful for your commitment to not be critical.
Adam Grant 27:30 Wait, are you saying we're not allowed to be critical? I thought we wanted to have high standards and be discerning.
Brené Brown 27:36 Oh, no, we can be discerning, and we can... I love the coaching, and I love the feedback. But when you start a sentence with, "I don't mean to be critical," what I hear is, "I'm going to be critical. I don't want to be accountable for the behavior."
Adam Grant 27:49 Okay.
Brené Brown 27:49 So I'm glad you're making a commitment to not do that. Let's try it again. Like, this is one of my favorites. I actually took this, um, from a real-life experience. I'm not trying to tear you down, but...
Adam Grant 28:04 [laughs]
Brené Brown 28:06 So you try. You try the intervention here. Look, Adam, I'm not trying to tear you down, but-
Adam Grant 28:13 Oh. Oh, wait. Brené, it's really surprising to me that you would even think that I would think [laughs] that you're trying to tear me down. We, we have a strong relationship. I know we care about each other. Wh- why would tearing me down even cross your mind?
Brené Brown 28:29 [laughs] I love this, but... Okay, you get bonus points, A+.
Adam Grant 28:33 [laughs]
Brené Brown 28:33 Um, this is what I mean. Like, you have to have a little tolerance for interrupting, which I normally don't love. But I think if you want to hold people accountable, you have to stop them right there before they get to the shitty part and say, "Great, I appreciate the commitment. Either do you need more time to find a better, more productive way to give me some coaching or feedback?" Or, "Wow, what you just did was great. I'm gonna add it to my repertoire." Um, I love this.
Adam Grant 29:01 What, what did you like about it, so I can learn?
Brené Brown 29:03 Um, oh, wait. You kinda stopped me, which you have to do, and then you said, "I, I'm surprised that tearing me down even came up for you. I, I would not expect that because we care for each other, and we give each other tough feedback sometimes but in a caring way. H- how did you get to tearing me down?" Like, again, it's an accountability shift.
Adam Grant 29:31 Yeah. Yeah, it's asking you to be accountable for the phrase that you put on the table and the sentiment behind it. It's also... I mean, my... What I was, what I was trying to do there was just welcome you to The Curiosity Shop. [laughs] Like, I am-
Brené Brown 29:46 [laughs]
Adam Grant 29:48 I, I'm so curious about why you would approach me from a tearing down lens, and you should be curious about that too, I hope.
Brené Brown 29:57 That's really interesting. I'm coming from the shut the fuck up lens-
Adam Grant 30:02 [laughs]
Brené Brown 30:02 ... which is different than the welcome to The Curiosity Shop lens. [laughs] Um-
Adam Grant 30:07 Okay, and why, why is that, why is that different? I think-
Brené Brown 30:11 Why is what different?
Adam Grant 30:13 Wh- why do we approach this differently?
Brené Brown 30:21 Okay.
Adam Grant 30:21 We're trying to get to the same point. We're trying to accomplish the same thing. We have different styles.
Brené Brown 30:25 Are we?
Adam Grant 30:26 I don't know. Maybe not.
Brené Brown 30:26 Are, are we? Um-I'm trying to say, "Whoa, take accountability for what you're going to say, and don't try to squirm out of accountability before you even say it." And y- I feel like you're trying to say, "Whoa, I'm surprised to hear that language from you. I'm curious where it's coming from."
Adam Grant 30:55 Mm-hmm.
Brené Brown 30:57 I, I, I don't know that we are coming from this... You're coming from curiosity, I'm coming from accountability. I think they're different places maybe.
Adam Grant 31:09 Maybe. But do we wanna land the person at the same place? I wanna land it at the other person doing some questioning and rethinking of [laughs] what their intentions were and what kind of relationship we have and saying, "Huh, I really, I really ought to approach both my goals and my communication style a little more thoughtfully."
Brené Brown 31:32 Okay, that's really wild because let me tell you what happened when I was like, "I'm gonna add that to my repertoire." Let me tell you what immediately happened in my bo- my back processor. This is so wild that this is happening in real time. What happened in my back processor when I said, "I'm gonna add that to my, to my, my list of things to do," is the people I thought about immediately were people I care about and with whom I have a relationship with. So I think that if I care about you, what you're saying is better, curiosity and connection and care is better than if I don't really know you, and... I mean, I've had people stand up in a Q&A at an event and be like, "Listen, I don't mean to drag you in front of everybody," but I'm like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Great. I wanna hear what you have to say, but if you don't wanna drag me, then think of a different way to say it."
Adam Grant 32:33 Yeah. Yeah, okay, so our approaches are... Yeah, I was thinking about this in the context of an established relationship.
Brené Brown 32:39 Right.
Adam Grant 32:39 That's meaningful.
Brené Brown 32:39 So I think in that-
Adam Grant 32:41 Yeah
Brené Brown 32:41 ... to say, "Whoa, whoa, great. Where, where did tear me down come from?" Or, "I don't mean to be rude." "Whoa, before you even go, I don't experience feedback from you as rude. I, I'm, I mostly experience it as helpful or at least coming from a place of concern or curiosity.
Adam Grant 33:00 Mm-hmm.
Brené Brown 33:02 What about this is feeling, like, different, different for you or like it's going to be hard or rude?"
Adam Grant 33:09 Yeah. Yeah, that's really good.
Brené Brown 33:11 But that's, that means-
Adam Grant 33:12 That's really good
Brené Brown 33:12 ... let me tell you something what that is. Let me tell you what you... Let me tell you the difference between yours and mine. To me, yours telegraphs care, connection, and relationship, and mine telegraphs, "Your disclaimer will not get you out of accountability with me. I don't know you. I don't know what you're getting ready to say, but just know that that's not going to work." Two different populations.
Adam Grant 33:40 Different popu- populations, but also different speakers. I, I wonder, I, I'm just thinking about gender stereotypes here. It will n- it will surprise no one that women have to work harder to prove their competence than men, and so you asserting some degree of strength and authority, which gets taken for granted when I speak as a man much more so, is that, is that partially gendered?
Brené Brown 34:04 I was with you on the gendered part till you got to, to, uh, till you got to the why the gendered about me, m- do- me doing this as a, as a, as a show of competence or confidence even. I think the gender part that w- that started to ring true for me was permission to be rude, critical, tear people down, and tear people apart-
Adam Grant 34:29 Ooh
Brené Brown 34:29 ... without being held accountable for it. That seems very male to me today.
Adam Grant 34:35 Yeah. Yeah.
Brené Brown 34:36 And so, yeah, and, and-
Adam Grant 34:37 And t- particularly to do that to a woman.
Brené Brown 34:39 To a woman, right, with... Yeah.
Adam Grant 34:41 Yeah.
Brené Brown 34:41 And so, but other power differentials I think exist as well, and so there's other relationships where that, that plays out. I think the difference for me really comes down to, and it's quite clear in my mind to be honest, investment.
Adam Grant 34:58 Mm-hmm.
Brené Brown 35:00 When I wanna get under something and get curious about it, um, I want what, like, what in coaching Ico Pathia would call channel three communication, listening for connection.
Adam Grant 35:17 Mm.
Brené Brown 35:18 Not listening just to understand or listening to respond-
Adam Grant 35:21 Yeah
Brené Brown 35:22 ... but real channel three listening for care and connection. I'm not even on channel three if I don't know you.
Adam Grant 35:29 Right.
Brené Brown 35:29 If I know you-
Adam Grant 35:30 Right
Brené Brown 35:30 ... I might respond with, "Whoa, I don't know what's gonna come next, but the tearing down is not something we usually do together."
Adam Grant 35:40 Yeah.
Brené Brown 35:40 I think that I... 'Cause I, I wouldn't... I always imagine if one of my kids said to me, I would have a hard time imagining 'cause I don't, I don't think we talk like this to each other in our family, but if one of my kids said, "Look, Mom, I don't mean to be rude, but..." I don't imagine saying, "Hey, then do you need more time to figure out something, you know, a way to do this where it's, that's not rude?"
Adam Grant 36:00 [laughs]
Brené Brown 36:00 I would imagine saying, "Whoa, before you even go there, I don't ever experience your feedback to me as rude."
Adam Grant 36:09 Yeah.
Brené Brown 36:11 The, uh, then I think I would say-
Adam Grant 36:12 So-
Brené Brown 36:12 ... with one of my k- I, I might say, "Do you want more time to think about what we're gonna talk about or something?"
Adam Grant 36:17 Sure.
Brené Brown 36:17 But I would be on channel three communication.
Adam Grant 36:22 And if you're, if you're dealing with a stranger or somebody you don't have a meaningful relationship with, it seemed like your motivation was more to neutralize it.You were, you were gonna, you were gonna... Almost like you were almost preemptively putting the person in their place.
Brené Brown 36:37 It wasn't-
Adam Grant 36:37 Or shutting down their tactic. No?
Brené Brown 36:42 It wasn't neutralizing. It was, what's a nice way to say proceed with caution.
Adam Grant 36:50 [laughs]
Brené Brown 36:50 Like, no, really, like-
Adam Grant 36:51 Oh, so you're waving a red flag.
Brené Brown 36:53 I'm waving a flag that said, "I don't know what's coming next, but just because you started this way does not mean I'm not going to hold you accountable for the behavior. So let me just, let me g- let me issue a preemptive caution here that I recognize your disclaimer. I understand that the energy it's gonna take me to intervene right now is an order of magnitude greater than the bullshit you just created with your disclaimer."
Adam Grant 37:18 [laughs]
Brené Brown 37:19 So-
Adam Grant 37:20 Yes
Brené Brown 37:21 ... be thoughtful.
Adam Grant 37:25 Yeah. So it-
Brené Brown 37:25 I'm asking you both to be thou-
Adam Grant 37:25 ... it's a bit of a wake-up call.
Brené Brown 37:27 It, ah.
Adam Grant 37:32 You are treading on thin ice.
Brené Brown 37:35 Now wait until you get to the right one. Keep going. Like, what, what are the other ones?
Adam Grant 37:38 I'm trying, I'm trying to, I'm trying to find, I, I, I'm, I'm trying to, well, [laughs] I'm, I'm, I'm cycling through the different things I thought as you were saying that. So another one was... No, that's not quite right either. Eh, what, what... Well, let's do another one, actually, and I'm gonna, I'm gonna try to pay attention to my reaction in real time.
Brené Brown 37:59 Okay. Um.
Adam Grant 38:00 Okay, I've got one for you.
Brené Brown 38:02 Okay.
Adam Grant 38:04 Okay. Um, Brené.
Brené Brown 38:06 Yeah?
Adam Grant 38:07 I've been biting my tongue on this for a while, and just, like, no offense, but-
Brené Brown 38:13 Okay. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. When you say no offense before you even start, I get genuinely concerned that you're looking for permission to say something offensive. And our relationship really means a lot to me, so if that's what's coming next, I wonder, I'd love to slow down a little bit and get underneath what's going on before we get there because I, when I hear no offense, I usually prep for getting offended, and I don't want us to do that to each other.
Adam Grant 38:59 Okay. Okay, light bulb. Okay.
Brené Brown 39:01 No, wait, but this is-
Adam Grant 39:03 Okay, tell me if this is right
Brené Brown 39:03 ... this is my channel three care-
Adam Grant 39:05 Yes
Brené Brown 39:05 ... curiosity. Okay.
Adam Grant 39:07 Yeah, yeah. I felt, I felt that strongly, but I also, I felt something that I think is consistent across the different contexts, which is you are actually shifting the responsibility back to me. The way that I'm bringing this up-
Brené Brown 39:20 Yes. Yes.
Adam Grant 39:23 [laughs]
Brené Brown 39:23 Yes. Yes.
Adam Grant 39:23 Okay, good. Okay, we got it. So the way that I was bringing this up, no offense, but I'm acting like you are gonna unreasonably, as a, th- like you are being unreasonable in taking offense.
Brené Brown 39:34 Yes.
Adam Grant 39:35 But I kn- but I know you're the kind of person who might be delicate and sensitive, and so I'm putting it out there saying, "Hey, don't be that person. I'm not doing anything wrong. It's you."
Brené Brown 39:45 No.
Adam Grant 39:45 "And so you need to adjust to what I'm about to say."
Brené Brown 39:49 No. No. Not you are a delicate and sensitive person. I might be ready, I'm, I'm getting ready to be a dick. That's how I would see it. Like, I'm get- I, I'm giving myself permission-
Adam Grant 40:06 Yes
Brené Brown 40:06 ... not to be-
Adam Grant 40:06 No, no, no. We're... Yeah.
Brené Brown 40:07 Okay, 'cause, 'cause I'm giving myself permission to not be thoughtful by telling you to not take offense, therefore I don't have to do-
Adam Grant 40:19 Yes
Brené Brown 40:19 ... any work on my side to make sure that I'm giving you feedback or coaching in a non-offensive way.
Adam Grant 40:25 Yes. Yeah, I, I, I think we're, we're actually saying the same thing here. What-
Brené Brown 40:29 Okay, great
Adam Grant 40:29 ... what I'm, what, what I'm w- what I'm trying to drive at is I, I know that what I'm gonna say might be offensive. But instead of taking ownership over that and trying to make sure [laughs] it's not offensive or it's presented in a way that shows care or a desire-
Brené Brown 40:46 Yes
Adam Grant 40:46 ... to help-
Brené Brown 40:46 Yes
Adam Grant 40:46 ... I am offloading that responsibility to you and leaving you wondering, like, well, w- why, why would you say this? A- are you, like, do you think I'm the kind, kind of person who takes offense easily?
Responsibility Versus Accountability
Brené Brown 40:59 Yes, exactly.
Adam Grant 40:59 Do, do... And, and when, when you cut it off and say, "Hey, wait a minute. Like, [laughs] why, why don't you pause and think about this for a second?" You're putting that responsibility back in my hands where it belongs.
Brené Brown 41:12 Okay, this is exactly everything.
Adam Grant 41:16 [laughs]
Brené Brown 41:16 Okay? This is-
Adam Grant 41:17 It's something. It's definitely something.
Brené Brown 41:19 No, it, it, it's everything. It's... We, we were using the word accountability as, as what both of these communication tools have in common, um, the Invisible Army and, but it's also about responsibility. When you come into my office and say, "I'm observing something that I wanna share with you because I have concerns," then you are taking responsibility for what you're getting ready to lay out on my desk.
Adam Grant 41:51 Yes.
Brené Brown 41:51 When you, when, when someone says, "Hey, let's pause for a second then. When you say don't be, I don't want you to be offended," I'm wondering if we can, you know, if we can just get ahead of that. I am shifting... How do you think differently about responsibility and accountability? I've never thought about it really before.
Adam Grant 42:15 I think responsibility is... Well, okay, I'm just, I'm just thinking about the research on this. Responsibility is a sense that, it's a t- it's a sense of ownership-
Brené Brown 42:26 Mm-hmm
Adam Grant 42:26 ... that I take over my actions-
Brené Brown 42:29 Okay
Adam Grant 42:29 ... or over a decision, whereas accountability is me having to justify my actions to you.
Brené Brown 42:40 Okay, I'm not tracking. Say it again.
Adam Grant 42:42 So responsibility is personal-
Brené Brown 42:44 Mm-hmm
Adam Grant 42:44 ... and accountability is interpersonal.
Brené Brown 42:47 Okay, got it.
Adam Grant 42:47 Um-
Brené Brown 42:47 Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah
Adam Grant 42:48 ... so responsibility is something I can take, but you can hold me accountable.
Brené Brown 42:52 Got it. Okay, that's super helpful. Can you s-
Adam Grant 42:54 I have to, I have to justify, explain, and answer to you, as opposed to when I'm responsible, I'm answering to myself.
Brené Brown 43:02 God, then why don't we talk about radical responsibility instead of radical accountability?
Adam Grant 43:06 Because we don't trust people to uphold their commitments to themselves. We think that they need to be held accountable by others.
Brené Brown 43:16 So w-
Adam Grant 43:16 I don't think that, but a lot of people think that.
Brené Brown 43:18 Yeah, yeah. That's interesting. It's like a whole nother podcast, I think. Um-
Adam Grant 43:23 It might be.
Brené Brown 43:24 Yeah. So when... So it's interesting, because I'm gonna get really nuanced here, but I think it's really important. I mean, I'm telling you, if, if you, if you, unless you are an island, if you have a partner, if you're a parent, if you have children, if you have friends, I think this is an important conversation. Because when I stop you, when you say, "Look, I don't mean to tear you down here, Brené, but," and I stop you, I think two things are happening. And I say, "Whoa, whoa, whoa. Then let's stop before that even h- potentially could happen," there's two things happening there, Adam. One is I need you, before you start, to take responsibility for what you're going to say, and I will hold you accountable for what you say.
Adam Grant 44:14 Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding. Jackpot.
Brené Brown 44:15 Do y-
Adam Grant 44:15 Yes
Brené Brown 44:16 ... do you know what I mean?
Adam Grant 44:16 You're asking me to take responsibility, and you are making it clear upfront that if I don't, you are gonna hold me accountable. Yeah. That's exactly right.
Brené Brown 44:25 Yeah, so okay, let's, okay, let's keep that in mind.
Adam Grant 44:27 I love that.
Brené Brown 44:27 Let's, like, l- let's hold that in mind. So what, what these preemptive pauses, I like that better than interruptions, when people are using these bullshit disclaimers, what they're doing is a combination of responsibility and accountability. So let's try it again. [clears throat] And I don't really know you, and so I, I don't know that I'm gonna be on channel three communication with you, looking for care and connection. I'm just going to, I'm just gonna probably say something. So why don't you say to me, "Look, um, I don't mean to be shitty about this." So why don't you try that with me?
Adam Grant 45:07 I have to, I have to use one that I would actually-
Brené Brown 45:08 Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah
Adam Grant 45:09 ... consider saying.
Brené Brown 45:09 Use one, yeah. That's what I would say.
Adam Grant 45:13 [laughs] I, I, I don't like to think about myself as someone who would ever be shitty. So, uh, that might be wishful thinking, but here we go. Brené-
Brené Brown 45:23 Yeah
Adam Grant 45:23 ... I, I don't mean to sound like a jerk here, but it's really important to-
Brené Brown 45:26 Oh, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Okay, okay. Let me... Can I just stop you there?
Adam Grant 45:31 You already did.
Brené Brown 45:32 Yeah. It, it worries me when you say that you don't mean to sound like a jerk, 'cause I don't experience you as a jerk. I can't do the other one with you, 'cause I, I'm always on channel three communication with you 'cause we're friends. So, so I would just probably say, "I, when you say you don't mean to sound like a jerk, I immediately kinda get defensive, and I also am curious about, we don't talk to each other like that. So do you wanna take a pause and figure out another way that would be-
Adam Grant 46:04 Yeah
Brené Brown 46:04 ... jerk-proof?"
Adam Grant 46:06 [laughs] Yeah.
Brené Brown 46:07 Um, so-
Adam Grant 46:08 Yeah
Brené Brown 46:08 ... there it is. Like, I need you to take responsibility for what you're going to say.
Adam Grant 46:12 Yeah.
Brené Brown 46:12 And to say, "I don't mean to sound like a jerk," is not enough responsibility.
Adam Grant 46:18 Yes.
Brené Brown 46:19 And-
Adam Grant 46:20 Yes
Brené Brown 46:20 ... if you are indeed a jerk to me,
Judgment Based on Gender and Identity
Brené Brown 46:22 I will hold you accountable for it, and your disclaimer is not a get out of jerk f- you know, free card.
Adam Grant 46:30 This is a, this is a big aha moment for me, because this clarifies why I like another flavor of disclaimer and hedge. The kind that I like are the opposite of making excuses. They are... I love disclaimers and hedges that show interpersonal sensitivity, as opposed to showing a lack of sensitivity and a lack of concern-
Brené Brown 46:56 That's right
Adam Grant 46:56 ... and care for others. So can I, can I walk you through some examples of the ones that I find myself advising?
Brené Brown 47:02 I am on the edge of my chair with bated breath, and I'm a little nervous. Go ahead.
Adam Grant 47:09 Okay. Brené, I might be wrong, but here's a thought. Brené, I think this might be true, but I'm not 100% sure. What do you think? I love those. Do you wanna react, or do you want me to tell you why the science has taught me to love them first?
Brené Brown 47:37 Oh, you could tell me. I, I'm, I'm torn, I'm mixed, but I wanna hear about the science, and I'm, I, I wanna hear about the science, and then I'll walk through it with you. Go ahead.
Adam Grant 47:47 Okay.
Brené Brown 47:47 Tell me about the science.
Adam Grant 47:48 All right, so the-
Brené Brown 47:49 I'm curious. I'm very curious.
Adam Grant 47:51 [laughs] Good. Good. Okay, so there's, there's a solid body of evidence showing that if we are interdependent, if we're collaborating, if we're playing basketball as opposed to doing gymnastics, to, to use one of our new, our new favorite analogies, that you care as much about whether I'm interested in your opinion as you do about whether my opinions are right, and you're, you're vetting me on, on care, not just competence. And in those situations, it's really important for me to show that I'm, I'm willing to consider your view, that I'm not just locked into my view. Um, I, I have to balance assertiveness and openness. So Alison Fragale calls this the power of powerless speech, and she finds that when, when people are evaluating a potential teammate, and I imagine this is true also when they're looking at a, a possible partner on, on a first date, uh, that-They l- they look at these disclaimers and hedges and think, "Okay, this person is not gonna be a bull in a China shop. They're not gonna dominate every decision. They're actually gonna be, you know, receptive to what I have to say." And the, the research I've read on this in the workplace suggests that if your boss is easily threatened, it's better to frame your suggestion as a question. Like, "Here's an idea. What do you think of this?" As opposed to, "Here's an idea. You should adopt this." And if you wanna influence someone who has more power than you, instead of just s- telling them what you're gonna do, it's more effective to seek their advice and say, "Hey, you know, I'm, I'm kinda torn. What direction would you recommend?" And I think I find that really compelling, and there's, I think, a bunch of evidence suggesting that unfortunately we live in a world where these strategies are especially important for women, uh, because women are more likely to threaten male audiences in particular, and using so-called weak language is actually a source of surprising strength, which we can go into more, but I have said enough things.
Brené Brown 50:01 Well, what's at top of mind right now for me is fuck that.
Adam Grant 50:06 [laughs] Rightfully so. That's why I said, "Unfortunately."
Brené Brown 50:09 Um, yeah. That unfortunately doesn't cover it, but here, here is where... Here is where I get worried. Well, first of all, let me just say this, for the record, as my partner and collaborator in this podcast. I am not gonna do that. I, I, I am, I am... N- zero chance am I gonna do that-
Adam Grant 50:40 [laughs]
Brené Brown 50:42 ... if it does not accurately reflect-
Adam Grant 50:47 Yes
Brené Brown 50:47 ... my genuine sentiment.
Adam Grant 50:50 Yes.
Brené Brown 50:50 I, I-
Adam Grant 50:50 Endorse
Brené Brown 50:51 ... other- otherwise, you know, this is, like, the gauntlet of to- this is the gauntlet of bullshit masculinity, is that if I'm direct, I'm an aggressive bitch, and if-
Adam Grant 51:05 Yep
Brené Brown 51:05 ... I hedge and use disclaimers, then I'm wishy-washy and lack executive presence. Like, so I'm gonna pick the one that makes me, enables me to sleep at night. And so, a- and this, I'm like, I'm really having to stay in my skin. I'm, I'm working really hard to not lose my mind right now, but it's not, it would not be unlike me, and I think you could t- you could, you know, starting a business together with a partner like you and I have done, which a podcast is a business, is not easy, and we've had really hard talks, really hard rumbles. We've talked about having to do repair with each other. It's not gonna be unusual for me to genuinely say to you, "I'm not sure if this is a, the best idea that I've ever had or the worst thing I've ever thought, and that I'm scared. I'm not even sure what's driving it, but here's what I'm wondering if we should consider doing." That, that, I'm gonna say that to you, because it genuinely reflects where I am. Um, but the days of me contorting myself into a hedgy little disclaimer, "Well, I have an idea, and I'm wondering if you think it's a good idea, because it would be so cute if you thought it was a good idea", fuck that.
Adam Grant 52:32 [laughs]
Brené Brown 52:32 I'm not doing that. And-
Adam Grant 52:34 Hell no.
Brené Brown 52:35 Yeah. And-
Adam Grant 52:35 I don't, I don't ever wanna hear that from anyone.
Brené Brown 52:38 Yeah, no.
Adam Grant 52:38 Especially from women, but anybody.
Brené Brown 52:40 But anybody, yeah. And so I think it really does point to... It, it really almost makes me wanna cry. I'm just gonna be really honest with you. It's like I'm really having to fight back tears, because it's just not me. It's, you know, Black folks and Brown folks and disabled folks and queer folks and people who, you know, "This is the best idea you're ever gonna hear, dude, and I'm gonna make you think it's yours so I don't get in trouble, so you're not threatened by, you know, my excellence and, you know, your winning mediocrity." It, it's just, it's really hard. And so what I would say is I think it's interesting to read the comments on our podcast, 'cause some people listen to it who are not into the leadership work that we do and not even into thinking about work. They're thinking about this for their, their lives. I think I would say when I genuinely feel curious, I wanna be in relationships with people where I'm not dinged for saying, "Look, I'm not sure, but here's what I'm thinking."
Adam Grant 53:50 Yes.
Brené Brown 53:52 And I wanna be equally in relationships where I'm like, "Shit, I think I figured this out last night."
Adam Grant 54:00 Yeah.
Brené Brown 54:00 "This is what I think we should do." Then I want people to be like, "Go. Go. I love this for you. Shine the light."
Adam Grant 54:07 Yes.
Brené Brown 54:07 "I love it." And so if you can't be both in your power and in your vulnerability in your personal life with people, it's a reevaluation marker for me, and at work, I just want you to know that that's not always true for all of us. Um, I do- I mean, I think probably I take this so personally because I just think as a, you know, n- a newly minted assistant professor, this was my whole life in committees.
Adam Grant 54:38 Yeah.
Brené Brown 54:38 You know?
Adam Grant 54:39 Yeah.
Brené Brown 54:40 "I'm wondering. I mean, I'm not sure, but I'm thinking we should..." You know, you know, um, this is the reality, and this is why equity matters. This is why feminism matters. This is why representation matters. Um-And this is the problem, I think, sometimes with research. It will tell us through a scientific model what's effective-
Adam Grant 55:12 Yeah
Brené Brown 55:13 ... but not always shine a light on why we have to do shit like that to be effective.
Adam Grant 55:21 Yeah. Bea- beautifully said, with power and vulnerability. And I, I would say it tells us what's effective, but not always what's right.
Brené Brown 55:31 Oh, God, yes.
Adam Grant 55:32 It al- it also tells us what's effective in a one-shot situation, but rarely addresses the question of are we then just reinforcing the stereotype and failing to shatter it? And I think the more times you break the stereotype by saying, [laughs] "This is a really good idea," the better, right? Because you are modeling a different way of communicating-
Brené Brown 55:54 That's right
Adam Grant 55:55 ... and legitimating that.
Brené Brown 55:56 That's right.
Adam Grant 55:58 And, you know, a- as I, as I listen to your reactions on this, I think it, it strikes me that, that two things can be true simultaneously here. One is that, like, we've just gotta stop evaluating people on their styles of communication and start evaluating them on the quality of their ideas and the thought and care they put into presenting them.
Brené Brown 56:23 I, I think that's right. I think that's exactly right.
Adam Grant 56:26 Unfortunately, we're not there yet. Like, we sadly live in a world where people still get judged on the group they belong to and the, the identity they hold. And given that, I, I'm, I'm still committed to figuring out, okay, what is effective for somebody who, you know, might, might be threatening to, you know, a majority group member, or who might be in just a, a tough position. How do they communicate? And so I, I wanna get your reaction to a specific example. This is, uh, this is Hannah Riley Bowles and Linda Babcock. It's one of their experiments on relational accounts, you know, the, the work on, uh, on women negotiating salaries. So they, they tried to put together, uh, an example of something that you could say that I think shows both strength and vulnerability. And I like it. Uh, I have, I, I, I have a hunch that you have some ways to improve it. So, um, here is the line that boosted salary recommendations for women, did not matter for men, in one of their experiments. Uh, the line, I should say, the line is part of a paragraph, but this is the line that stood out for me. Uh, it, the line goes like this: "I don't know how typical it is for people at my level to negotiate, but I'm hopeful you'll see my skill at n- negotiating as something important that I bring to the job."
Brené Brown 57:48 I love it.
Adam Grant 57:49 There's a disclaimer, right? I, I'm actually not sure if this is appropriate, but this is something I'm really good at. And guess what? I'm gonna be negotiating on your behalf if you hire me or if you give me a raise, and this skill that you could otherwise perceive as, as hurting you because [laughs] I'm asking you for more money, this is actually gonna work to your benefit.
Brené Brown 58:08 Yeah, and I don't think, I'm... Did you say this or did I know this already, that, that men did not get dinged on that?
Adam Grant 58:14 Correct.
Brené Brown 58:15 Yeah, yeah. Uh, yeah. And so I, I, I don't know, because to me, what my, my, my read is I, I don't really, I don't really care if this is normative or not. I'm gonna, I'm gonna negotiate this with you because I think it's a good skill that I have and I'd like for you to see it, and I'd like more money. And so-
Adam Grant 58:40 [laughs]
Brené Brown 58:40 ... um, so I think-
Adam Grant 58:42 Oh, I like, I like, I like how candidly you did that. The, you just put it out there.
Brené Brown 58:46 Yeah, I mean, that, that's it. I think I'm worth more. And so, so I think that-
Adam Grant 58:53 Whoa, pause on that for a second
Brené Brown 58:54 ... what it is... Yeah.
Adam Grant 58:54 Pause on that.
Brené Brown 58:55 Yeah, yeah.
Adam Grant 58:56 Just, I mean, we're, we're talking about, about these micro patterns of communication.
Brené Brown 59:00 Yeah.
Adam Grant 59:02 I, I think, uh, I mean, the word that comes to mind is authenticity, but-
Brené Brown 59:05 Right
Adam Grant 59:06 ... you said it, you said it so matter of fact. "I think I'm worth it." That, there, there's something so influential about that that [laughs] that doesn't come through when somebody says, "I'm gonna make the case to you that I'm worth it. I'm worth it for the following seven reasons." Where it starts to feel over explained and over justified, and you're just saying, "I think I'm worth it," which doesn't require me to, to put up my guard and argue with you, and it also, it, it just conveys so much confidence on your part. Like, you don't have any doubt. "I'm worth it."
Brené Brown 59:41 Yeah, and I'm also, you know-
Adam Grant 59:42 That is such an effective way to communicate.
Brené Brown 59:45 Yeah, for me, I, I also think, though, it's, it's really tough, too, um, because I have... It's personality aligned for me. Like, I, I'm, I'm, I'm q- I'm not always funny, but I'm quick-witted. It might be bad, but I, you know, I, I have a personality that that suits, and so I know what style is best for me. Um, would it work for everyone? I'm not sure. Have I heard it more recently in our hiring over the last two or three years? 100%. Um, do I love it in people? 100%. And so I... Because they will be representing me in situations where I will need to see that level of grounded confidence.
Adam Grant 1:00:28 Yeah.
Brené Brown 1:00:28 So I think that... And the other thing is that in terms of the humanity up front, the humanity, the humanity and the power, the vulnerability and the confidence, those things living together, I think curiosity is the key there. I, I, I... We talked about this the other day, where we were talking about, um,Oh, I was, I was joking about the fact that I didn't know whether someone's in a car service for me for a job, and I was like, "Should I tip this person?" I, 'cause I, it came up, you know, in addition to being a union steward in my colorful past, I was a bartender and waiter for six years. And so I just said, "You know what? I know this seems really weird, but how does tipping work with y'all? Because it's important to me to get it right. And so if you've been tipped, I wanna know, but if you haven't been tipped, I wanna know." And the driver literally turned around at the light and said, "It's so thoughtful that you would ask me that. Most people are so anxious to talk about money and things like that, they, they just wouldn't even ask. So they would either... They just probably wouldn't do anything." I'm like, "Yeah, I just don't know how it works."
Adam Grant 1:01:41 Yeah.
Brené Brown 1:01:42 And he, he's like-
Adam Grant 1:01:43 Yeah. No, this, this-
Brené Brown 1:01:44 "This, this is how it works"
Adam Grant 1:01:46 This, this is almost like...
Brené Brown 1:01:48 And what I-
Adam Grant 1:01:48 Oh, sorry, go ahead.
Brené Brown 1:01:49 No, and what I learned was there is a minimal tip included,
Takeaways From Today’s Episode
Brené Brown 1:01:55 but it's not a living wage kind of tip. And, but a, a regular normal tip would be too much, 'cause there is a small percentage included. So he said, "If you're dri- if you're driving with one of our drivers in this driving service, this is really helpful." I was like, "Man, thanks. That's so helpful."
Adam Grant 1:02:13 [laughs] It would have never occurred to me to go to the source and just ask. But it's, [laughs] it's almost like asking for directions as a, as a man-
Brené Brown 1:02:20 [laughs]
Adam Grant 1:02:20 ... driving. [laughs] Like, no, no, I sh- I should just know. I, I should be able to figure it out. And what I would do instead, if I couldn't, is I ask somebody else who's taken the car service. But I don't-
Brené Brown 1:02:30 Yeah
Adam Grant 1:02:30 ... go directly to the driver, and I loved how you did that. Now, we're, we're, we're probably at time here, so maybe moving toward wrap-up.
Brené Brown 1:02:38 Yeah, yeah.
Adam Grant 1:02:40 Uh, so t- two, two high level... I don't know how high level these are, actually. Two, two reactions, just stepping back a little bit. One is, I, I think my big worry around people just objecting across the board to disclaimers is, you know, I hear a lot of people just pounce on so-called weak language, and they say, "You gotta edit all the disclaimers and hedges out of your comments in meetings, out of your speeches, out of the way that you talk to your partner." And I think that's a mistake. I don't think we should be judging language as strong or weak. I think what we should be conveying is that language should be clear, and it should be caring, ideally. And Alison Fragale's book, Likeable Badass, is such a good encapsulation of how to do that effectively, and I think you actually modeled some of what she recommends in the book [laughs] in the way that you asked-
Brené Brown 1:03:36 Mm-hmm
Adam Grant 1:03:36 ... for your raise. So that was, that was my first reaction. The other, the other thing that I'm just left thinking about is I think we... Hmm, no, maybe not.
Brené Brown 1:03:53 Oh, I love this. I love your thinking in real time. It's like down-
Adam Grant 1:03:56 [laughs]
Brené Brown 1:03:56 ... downloading, downloading learnings right now.
Adam Grant 1:03:59 Buffering. It's buffering.
Brené Brown 1:04:01 I love it.
Adam Grant 1:04:01 Uh, the little, the little wheel is spinning, and I changed my mind-
Brené Brown 1:04:03 But I love it
Adam Grant 1:04:04 ... about where I was gonna land. But no, I'm just, I'm just going back to the, to the beginning where you talked about invisible armies and bullshit disclaimers. And I think striving to make our armies as visible as possible and making sure our disla- our disclaimers are not bullshit, but they're heartfelt, is something we can check before we use them, as opposed to having this-
Brené Brown 1:04:27 Yeah
Adam Grant 1:04:27 ... like, you, you, you, you can't ever have an invisible army. You can't ever have a disclaimer. What I took, what I took out of this conversation is how nuanced that is and how there, there's a time and a place for, for each of those, and there are also ways in which they can be used manipulatively and counterproductively.
Brené Brown 1:04:45 I think that's a, I think that's a... I think that represents my takeaways. I, I really had some big takeaways from our conversation today. Um, personal takeaway for me that was hard is how easily I get hooked when people do not take responsibility for the language they use and it, the impact it has on other people. The second one is how frustrated I get when I have to do the lift of holding people accountable for not taking responsibility, [laughs] 'cause there's a theme here. Three, um, I think a hedge, a disclaimer, representation of other people's opinions, I'm not gonna call them an invisible army because I have such a negative connotation around that, but just the representation of what you're seeing in other people. I think for me, the bottom line is care, thoughtfulness, and is it aligned with how you really feel? You can never make something effective that's manipulative and not aligned with really, I think, what you're sensing or feeling. I think that's very, very difficult. Because I think above all else, no matter what we're hearing, we are doing an authenticity check on people all the time. And so... And I just think the emotional baggage from a lot of the work that women have to do about really often making people feel good about their own mediocrity while making ourselves small is, kills us, and so, literally and spiritually and morally and every other way. So I think that's, that was a big learning. I loved the conversation. I, I appreciate it. And I don't always love it when you pump the brakes, um, but I did not find myself flying through the windshield on this one. [laughs] I did, I, I-
Adam Grant 1:07:07 [laughs]
Brené Brown 1:07:07 It was more of that thing that your mom and dad did when you were little and you were riding in the front seat where they just kinda put their arm out, um, on the, on the brake pump. I, I do think my own argument would say it's not an all or nothing. It's about alignment and nuance and care. And I just wanna say, for, for people listening, don't think that this came easy to me, if I have the right words. I practice every hard conversation I'm gonna have with someone with a coach. I, you know, I've been working on this in a lot of different ways, therapy, coaching, practice, discipline, for 20 years. And so the careful use of language is, it's a practice. Would you agree?
Adam Grant 1:07:52 I didn't even realize I, I didn't even realize I pumped on the brakes.
Brené Brown 1:07:56 Yeah, because I mean, the name-
Adam Grant 1:07:58 So interesting
Brené Brown 1:07:58 ... yeah, because of the name of this, this, this sub chapter in Strong Ground is Beware of Invisible Armies and Bullshit Disclaimers. Like, it is, it's, it's pretty sweeping.
Adam Grant 1:08:11 Well, I don't think it's sweeping at all. I think that, I think the invisible modifier, we clarified what-
Brené Brown 1:08:18 Yes, that's true
Adam Grant 1:08:18 ... acceptable versus unacceptable invisibility is, right?
Brené Brown 1:08:21 Yeah.
Adam Grant 1:08:21 But you already had a modify in th- modifier in there, and then bullshit disclaimers. I'm, I'm defending non-bullshit disclaimers, [laughs] and you are too.
Brené Brown 1:08:29 That's it. Let's go. That was fun. See you next time. [upbeat music] The Curiosity Shop is produced by Brené Brown Education and Research Group and Grant Ed Productions. You can subscribe to The Curiosity Shop on YouTube or follow in your favorite podcast app.
Adam Grant 1:08:43 We're part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more award-winning shows at podcast.voxmedia.com.
Episode duration: 1:08:49
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode hVjPKKcJRH0