Skip to content

By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.

Dalton + MichaelDalton + Michael

How to Handle Co-Founder Fights

In this episode of Dalton + Michael, the two discuss one if the most important topics in the life of a startup: cofounder relationships.

Dalton Caldwellhost
Jul 13, 202622mWatch on YouTube

Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.

Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.

uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.

See how

Transcript

  1. 0:00 – 3:43

    The value of co-founders

    1. DC

      I think a lot of founders have heard horror stories about cofounder breakups, and their takeaway is like, "Oh, I'm a genius. I'm just not gonna have a cofounder. Oh, I fixed the problem." [laughs]

    2. SP

      I pre-fixed the problem. [laughs]

    3. DC

      Dalton. [laughs] That's the best sort of fix.

    4. SP

      This is Dalton + Michael, and today we're gonna talk about cofounder fights and cofounder breakups. We have a lot of experience in both of these. [laughs]

    5. DC

      [laughs] Should we start with breakups first or fights first? Where, where, where do you wanna... What's logical? Let's start at the beginning. Um, cofounders.

    6. SP

      Okay.

    7. DC

      What do we even mean by cofounders?

    8. SP

      Yes.

    9. DC

      So traditionally, when you start a tech startup-

    10. SP

      Yes

    11. DC

      ... you don't do it by yourself. And if you look to history of how a lot of the biggest companies started, um, they tended to have cofounders. I guess there's examples of families, so I'm thinking of non-tech companies-

    12. SP

      Sure

    13. DC

      ... where you started with your family.

    14. SP

      Sure.

    15. DC

      But usually there was, you know, another person, like the canonical Steve Jobs. [laughs]

    16. SP

      Yes.

    17. DC

      Steve Wozniak.

    18. SP

      Yep.

    19. DC

      It was, it was two people.

    20. SP

      Yes.

    21. DC

      Maybe to start by addressing that, I think a lot of founders have heard horror stories about cofounder breakups, which we're about to talk about in a second.

    22. SP

      Yes.

    23. DC

      And their takeaway is like, "Oh, I'm a genius. I'm just not gonna have a cofounder. Oh, I fixed the problem." [laughs]

    24. SP

      I pre-fixed the problem. [laughs]

    25. DC

      Dalton. [laughs] That's the best sort of fix. And it's like, man, you guys sure spend a lot of time talking about cofounder problems.

    26. SP

      Have you even thought of my genius solution? [laughs]

    27. DC

      You know, I'm a genius. Um, l- again, let's address that. Let's, let's steel man that argument. It is true that if you remove a cofounder-

    28. SP

      [laughs]

    29. DC

      ... the odds that you will get in a cofounder dispute dip to zero.

    30. SP

      Yes. Clever. [laughs]

  2. 3:43 – 9:19

    Navigating co-founder fights

    1. SP

      what happens when you are fighting with your cofounder? In my experience, there are two realities: You are friends with this person, or you are not friends with this person. What I have found is when you are friends with your cofounder, there will be something in the startup that happens that will frustrate the hell out of you, and you will have a particularly harsh thing that you wanna say. But because you're friends with this person, more often than not, you're not gonna say it, or you're gonna put it slightly differently, or you're gonna ask yourself, "If I were on the receiving end of this, would this motivate me or not?" Unfortunately, when you're not friends with this person, sometimes it's easier just to boom, boom, fire, fire, and then that can create problems.

    2. DC

      Yeah.

    3. SP

      That can create real problems. So that's probably the first thing that I see with a cofounder fight, is when it's initiated stupidly, right? Like, you're gonna have to fight about some stuff, but it's just like, can we avoid the dumb ones, you know? Like, "Oh, these guys raised money. Why couldn't you go raise money?" So I think that's a big one. Where else are you seeing cofounder fights?

    4. DC

      The biggest root cause is that you end up getting into the relationship for the wrong reasons. And so for better or worse, I can't help but think that all human relationships are fundamentally similar in some ways.

    5. SP

      Sure. Sure.

    6. DC

      Not always. [laughs]

    7. SP

      For sure.

    8. DC

      But, you know, if, if you end up getting thrown into a pretty intense experience with a complete stranger, and you've taken no time to understand the other person, the chances that you'll have a disagreement are pretty high. You just don't even have the same context.

    9. SP

      Yes.

    10. DC

      Um, and so the biggest issue I see is that they don't even... It's like strangers trying to navigate the beginning part of a relationship, and then it sort of dawns on them, "Oh man, this person's a stranger, and I got into this relationship for the wrong reasons."

    11. SP

      Yes.

    12. DC

      Um-

    13. SP

      "And I'm mad at myself. Let me do some lashing out."

    14. DC

      Yeah. And so what that looks like in practice is you can't even agree on really basic stuff.

    15. SP

      Yes.

    16. DC

      Such as the name of the company.

    17. SP

      Sure. Sure.

    18. DC

      Such as what idea are we working on?

    19. SP

      Yes.

    20. DC

      Such as what- ... should I be doing with my time and what should you be doing with your time?

    21. SP

      It's interesting 'cause, like, there's almost no basis for there being trust.

    22. DC

      Yeah.

    23. SP

      And if there's no trust, we can fight about everything. [laughs]

    24. DC

      Anything. [laughs] Just, just throw something out there.

    25. SP

      Forever.

    26. DC

      Yeah. [laughs]

    27. SP

      You can have endless arguments-

    28. DC

      Yeah

    29. SP

      ... about everything.

    30. DC

      Yeah. [laughs] And especially 'cause you're the boss, right? Like, everything's on the table. [laughs]

  3. 9:19 – 13:49

    Handling a breakup

    1. SP

      I think there's an interesting transition between cofounders fighting, which I think, you know, is gonna happen, and cofounders fighting that when we're talking to them we know-

    2. DC

      Yeah

    3. SP

      ... they're gonna break up before they break up. We know the trust is destroyed. I think that's a really important time in a startup because I, I always fear with startups, like, when you really know the probability of success is zero, the most important thing is to stop wasting time. And, you know, sometimes I see people living in this, like, "We haven't decided we're gonna break up yet, but obviously-

    4. DC

      But we definitely are. [laughs]

    5. SP

      Yeah. [laughs] But, like, everything is dysfunctional. It's not gonna get repaired, and it's like, can we get through that phase-

    6. DC

      Yeah

    7. SP

      ... as quickly as possible? [laughs] Like...

    8. DC

      Yeah. I mean, what this looked like to me in office hours with a, with a YC company is they would wanna meet with me without the other person.

    9. SP

      Oh my God.

    10. DC

      And they'd basically wanna present some facts.

    11. SP

      About why that person sucks or this.

    12. DC

      About why... Yeah.

    13. SP

      Yeah, yeah.

    14. DC

      And so kind of what I learned to do after many years of this is to say, "The facts don't matter. I am not the judge and jury. You don't need to present the case to me. If you don't think it's gonna work and it's bad enough such that you're trying to meet with me and present facts to me, that sounds pretty bad. I think this is pretty far gone." And so counterintuitively, I think, I'd be like, "Let's not talk about the facts. It doesn't actually matter. Let's just try to create a go-forward plan that is the most positive for all parties involved to not work together anymore-

    15. SP

      Yes

    16. DC

      ... so that everyone feels good about how they were treated, they feel good about the process.

    17. SP

      Yes.

    18. DC

      There wasn't a lot of, like, legal threats or problems. You just go your separate ways, and there's not, like, um, permanent toxic waste in the relationship. You're just like, "Cool, we're just gonna go our separate ways," and everyone is gonna be okay with it.

    19. SP

      Yes.

    20. DC

      Um, that's what I learned to do, and it works a lot if people are super professional and adult about it.

    21. SP

      I think the thing that always frustrated me when giving office hours on this topic was how unhelpful third parties can be.

    22. DC

      Yep.

    23. SP

      Um, you know, cofounder breakups extremely common with pre-product market fit early-stage companies, right? Another way of saying a pre-product farket- market early stage is, like, it has created no value. So, like, the stock that you have is worthless.

    24. DC

      Correct.

    25. SP

      You have nothing. And so in a situation where you're having a cofounder breakup and the stock is worth nothing, paying lawyers a bunch of money makes no sense.

    26. DC

      It's idiotic. Well, you're fighting over nothing. You're fighting over ego. So-

    27. SP

      You're spending money. [laughs]

    28. DC

      [laughs] Over nothing.

    29. SP

      I don't mind if you fight. Can you just also not spend-

    30. DC

      Yeah

  4. 13:49 – 22:45

    Framework for separation

    1. DC

      So again, to start with, the way it should go is sort of no fault from both sides.

    2. SP

      Yes.

    3. DC

      And so, again, unless you catch them committing a felony, okay-

    4. SP

      Yeah

    5. DC

      ... that's, that's, uh, outside the scope of this conversation.

    6. SP

      Yes.

    7. DC

      But for the most part, make it no fault.

    8. SP

      Yes.

    9. DC

      Don't try to ruin the other person. Don't try to ruin their reputation. Don't try to contact the investors and all this other crap.

    10. SP

      No, no.

    11. DC

      So make it no fault.

    12. SP

      Yes.

    13. DC

      Optimize for cleanliness for both sides-

    14. SP

      Yes

    15. DC

      ... so it requires the least amount of mental angst and anger to separate ways.

    16. SP

      Yes.

    17. DC

      Make it so that you don't say things you can't take back.

    18. SP

      Yes.

    19. DC

      Preserve the ability to interact with them in the future, any employees.

    20. SP

      Yes.

    21. DC

      You know?

    22. SP

      Yes.

    23. DC

      Keep your mouth shut, basically, both parties should.

    24. SP

      Yes.

    25. DC

      And then vesting is good. Uh, hopefully you have vesting.

    26. SP

      Yes.

    27. DC

      Um, vesting protects both parties in this case-

    28. SP

      Yes

    29. DC

      ... because it makes it cleaner to separate.

    30. SP

      Yes. I think that oftentimes what we tell founders is that if you're pre-product market fit, and the company's gonna continue operating, and you're the leaving party, you have to understand that the vast majority of the value this company could create hasn't been created yet.

Episode duration: 22:47

In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen

Transcript of episode s1YszjhzQ6U

Get more out of YouTube videos.

Read along on your phone, search it beside the video, or ask your favorite AI app what was said.