Skip to content

By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.

Dalton + MichaelDalton + Michael

Why Your Startup Shouldn’t Hire Like Google

Dalton Caldwell and Michael Seibel talk about how to hire elite talent for your startup.

Dalton CaldwellhostMichael Seibelhost
Nov 16, 202624mWatch on YouTube

Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.

Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.

uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.

See how

Transcript

  1. 0:00 – 0:40

    What a short résumé can tell you about a first hire

    1. DC

      The mistake you might make is to put résumés side by side, and someone with a résumé with nothing on it is bad. And I'm saying, "No, I'm- I think they're just young." Like, it might just be that you're ... The reason their résumé's blank is because they're young. Like, it's not 'cause they're bad. [upbeat music]

    2. MS

      This is Dalton + Michael. Today, we're gonna talk about how startups hire great teams. And I think that this is an interesting topic because I would argue that, like, what we're gonna say is it shouldn't be counterintuitive, but it is.

    3. DC

      [laughs]

    4. MS

      Right? Like, it's like when we say it's gonna make a lot of sense, but I think a lot of people don't do this. So I'll kind of put up the- the- the straw man here.

  2. 0:40 – 1:33

    Do you need someone who can manage 50 people yet?

    1. MS

      I think too many founders try to hire like Google does.

    2. DC

      Yep.

    3. MS

      I think too many founders are like, "I want a résumé that looks like this. I want a sure thing. I am not predicting that these early employees will grow at all. I want them to come with all of the skills we will need to make the company great." And, like, the number of times I've had these hilarious conversations where someone was like, "Well, I need to hire this person, but, like, I need them to have the ability to manage, like, 50 people." And I'm like, "Do you have 50 people?" [laughs]

    4. DC

      [laughs]

    5. MS

      And they're like, "No, but, like, when we do." And I'm like, "Well, what's the problem you have now?" [laughs] And then I, I often kind of break into this idea of, like, if we expect you to grow, if you know you-

    6. DC

      Yes

    7. MS

      ... don't have all the skills you have right now, but you're gonna grow, maybe your early employees will be on the same curve. Wouldn't that be

  3. 1:33 – 2:45

    Someone took a chance on you. Who will you take a chance on?

    1. MS

      cool? [laughs]

    2. DC

      Yeah, that's the ultimate irony to me sometimes, um, working with YC companies, where it's like the core kernel of the idea of YC itself-

    3. MS

      [laughs] Yeah. Yeah

    4. DC

      ... is let's take people-

    5. MS

      Yes

    6. DC

      ... that are, like, young and unproven-

    7. MS

      Yeah

    8. DC

      ... and believe in them more than anyone else did.

    9. MS

      Yes.

    10. DC

      And then we give those people money. They're like, "We only want proven people."

    11. MS

      Yeah. [laughs]

    12. DC

      Like, it was ... [laughs] 'cause it's like, I don't think you get this whole thing. Like, you're missing the point here.

    13. MS

      You're missing the point.

    14. DC

      We're making a bet on you-

    15. MS

      Yes

    16. DC

      ... that no other people wouldn't-

    17. MS

      Maybe

    18. DC

      ... because we think some percentage of the time you're gonna way surprise us.

    19. MS

      Yes.

    20. DC

      Why aren't you doing that?

    21. MS

      Yes.

    22. DC

      You should do that.

    23. MS

      You should do that.

    24. DC

      [laughs]

    25. MS

      You should do that. We almost, uh, kinda laid out the path. I think it's tricky for people 'cause I think, one, if I were to kind of steal man the other side, there's this weird conservatism that happens to a founder that's raised a little bit of money. It's like they revert into IBM mode. Like, it's almost like they forget that this is all a long shot, and there might have to be a series of long shots that all go right for their company to work. Whereas, "Oh, well, someone gave us money. That was the only long shot. Let's stack a bunch of sure things." [laughs]

  4. 2:45 – 3:44

    Why would a great candidate choose your startup?

    1. DC

      Well, and the other uncomfortable thing I have to always tell folks that are saying this is you can only hire out of the pool of people that would wanna work at your startup. And if someone is a sure thing with a gold-plated résumé-

    2. MS

      Wow

    3. DC

      ... please explain why they would wanna join your random startup. And they're ... it's like that never occurred to them. They're like, "Oh, I never thought about it that way." It's like, well, how, what way did you think about it?

    4. MS

      Exactly, yeah. [laughs]

    5. DC

      [laughs]

    6. MS

      Explain to us the alternative way. [laughs] Give us any theory.

    7. DC

      Like, you think, you think these, like, gold-plated folks are like, "I'm gonna apply to a job at Anthropic, OpenAI, you know, Google, Meta, and-

    8. MS

      Shitshow

    9. DC

      ... XYZ-

    10. MS

      Yeah. Yeah. [laughs]

    11. DC

      ... XYZ YC startup that was just in the last batch.

    12. MS

      Yeah.

    13. DC

      Like-

    14. MS

      And then I'm gonna take the, the YC startup job. [laughs]

    15. DC

      And that that's the de- Like-

    16. MS

      No

    17. DC

      ... like, just walk ... And it's like, again, I just don't think they've explored this. So again, I'm, I'm inviting you, audience, to explore.

    18. MS

      Yeah.

    19. DC

      Put yourself in the shoes of the, of the applicant. Why on earth would you be the right bet for their career based on what their résumé says?

    20. MS

      So let's make this

  5. 3:44 – 5:06

    The early Twitch engineers Google passed on

    1. MS

      real. Two of the best hires that we made, um, at Justin.tv/Twitch early, um, one was a guy named Aman, who, uh, I went on to start a company with. He started more companies. Another one was a name Guillaume, same thing. Neither of them got hired at Google. Shocker, shocker. Even more, Google almost bought us when we were very, very small, for a small amount of money, and they interviewed our team, and they decided our team wasn't worth working at Google.

    2. DC

      [laughs]

    3. MS

      So, like, Google rejected the key people, like, two of the, like, four or five key engineers, [laughs] um, and they rejected our whole team. [laughs] And one would argue that's what you're a- that's the goal. Like, what you, you wanna find the people who are great-

    4. DC

      Yeah

    5. MS

      ... that Google doesn't think is great. That's where you have leverage. [laughs]

    6. DC

      And another quick aside, many people, uh, probably know this, but the founder of WhatsApp famously got rejected-

    7. MS

      [laughs]

    8. DC

      ... in the technical screen for a job at Facebook.

    9. MS

      [laughs]

    10. DC

      And then Facebook bought his company for billions of dollars.

    11. MS

      Yeah.

    12. DC

      But, like, literally, he couldn't just get, like, a regular engineering job.

    13. MS

      Nope.

    14. DC

      They were like, "Nope, this guy's not good enough to work at Facebook"-

    15. MS

      Nope

    16. DC

      ... before they bought WhatsApp for billions of dollars.

  6. 5:06 – 10:52

    How to spot someone who’s ready for their first shot

    1. MS

      There you go. So to me, I think what's tricky for a lot of founders is they tend to have a network of friends who are not founders and who are going after these kind of normie, kinda Google-y style jobs, or whatever the equivalent is now. And they kind of acclimatize to those people instead of trying to find people who are more high-risk, more risk-seeking, more ambitious, people who want to work very hard and grow very fast, wanna tackle really hard challenges, um, and people who want to be given a shot.

    2. DC

      Yeah.

    3. MS

      Who wanna be given a shot. And, like, you'd be surprised at how many big company employees-

    4. DC

      You just described the opposite-

    5. MS

      Yeah. [laughs]

    6. DC

      ... of ... 'Cause think about it. The way you become a big company employee is you make a series of life decisions-

    7. MS

      Yeah

    8. DC

      ... including probably when you were in college, you did internships at big companies. You probably accepted an offer before you even graduated.

    9. MS

      Yep.

    10. DC

      Like, you've basically been on this career path which is extremely-

    11. MS

      Safe bets

    12. DC

      ... the opposite- ... of who you would probably wanna hire at your startup-

    13. MS

      Yes

    14. DC

      ... at least when you're a small startup.

    15. MS

      Yes. Well, and either you didn't really want the opportunity to have a lot of responsibility, or you believe the lie that Google gives 23-year-olds lots of responsibility. Either way, you wanted something different from your job.

    16. DC

      Yep.

    17. MS

      The tricky thing, though, is how do you recognize these people? Where do you find these people?

    18. DC

      I th- the way I like to think about that is that you have to be fishing out of the pond of people that might actually want to work at your startup. And this means someone that probably wouldn't get hire- would neither wanna work at Google maybe, or Google would not hire them.

    19. MS

      Yes.

    20. DC

      And so there's gonna be some kind of trade-offs-

    21. MS

      Yes

    22. DC

      ... that makes them a little bit less shiny in other ways.

    23. MS

      Yes. Basically, like, a, a really talented person has a higher chance of getting a great opportunity the longer they've had been in their career.

    24. DC

      That's right.

    25. MS

      So, like, the longer they've been in the career and the less success they've had-

    26. DC

      Yep

    27. MS

      ... it's m- it's more demonstrating their actual potential.

    28. DC

      Yeah.

    29. MS

      Whereas the earlier they are, like they have less opportunity-

    30. DC

      And again, the-

  7. 10:52 – 11:58

    Why hiring your first VP of sales is so hard

    1. MS

      of a founder hiring executives for the first time?

    2. DC

      It depends on the role. Um, but for, like, sales and things like that-

    3. MS

      Damn VP sales

    4. DC

      ... single digits.

    5. MS

      Yeah. I, I'd argue-

    6. DC

      Right? Less than 20%. I think single digits.

    7. MS

      Especially if they're stranger, like true strangers.

    8. DC

      Yeah.

    9. MS

      Oh, God.

    10. DC

      Yeah, it's pretty bad.

    11. MS

      It's 20% or less. It's way lower-

    12. DC

      Like marketing executives-

    13. MS

      Oh, yeah

    14. DC

      ... sales executives, yeah.

    15. MS

      It's, it's counterintuitively it's way lower than the success rate of hiring engineers.

    16. DC

      Yep.

    17. MS

      And I think, like, if only we put that expectation in founders' minds, like, a, a 50% success rate on engineers is actually great.

    18. DC

      Yeah.

    19. MS

      And so then the question is, like, when should you start that journey? 'Cause man, we talk to founders where suddenly hiring, managing, firing, pipping executives seems like it went from 0% of their time to, like, 60% of their time.

    20. DC

      Well, it becomes, like, all-encompassing. [laughs]

    21. MS

      Yeah.

    22. DC

      'Cause if you're a founder and you're dealing with an executive team and it's not working out-

    23. MS

      Oof

    24. DC

      ... that's-

    25. MS

      Yeah

    26. DC

      ... you know, 'cause the executive, they bring in their own pe- like, it's, it's just a big mess. We could spend the whole video on this.

    27. MS

      Oh, boy.

    28. DC

      I don't know if we need to, but again, the, the actual surprising

  8. 11:58 – 15:28

    When to promote someone already on your team

    1. DC

      insight, I think, is that you know what works a lot better than 20% of the time? Promoting your best homegrown people.

    2. MS

      Yes. Yes.

    3. DC

      It's not 100%, like you're not gonna have 100% success rate.

    4. MS

      Yeah, there are no 100 percents.

    5. DC

      But I think a lot, looks a lot more like 80% success rate-

    6. MS

      Yes

    7. DC

      ... than 20.

    8. MS

      Well-

    9. DC

      Because you already know them. They already hired them. They're in your culture. Like, like-

    10. MS

      Yes

    11. DC

      ... all these things that could go bad hiring a stranger-

    12. MS

      They're not a stranger.

    13. DC

      They're not a stranger. [laughs]

    14. MS

      I also think that delaying this executive hiring ... point, right? When you, when you promote from within, you get to delay this like, oh, this person's gonna come in and wanna hire a whole bunch of people and do a bunch of stuff and da, da, da. And I think delaying that point is actually often better than doing it earlier, regardless of what investors are saying.

    15. DC

      And, and you should think about what kind of company do you wanna build.

    16. MS

      Yes.

    17. DC

      I would advise you to be like, "I wanna build a company that can bring in raw talent-

    18. MS

      Yeah

    19. DC

      ... and they can work here for a long time-

    20. MS

      Yeah

    21. DC

      ... and just, like, keep getting promoted if they're good, and we can be the place for them to be as ambitious as possible."

    22. MS

      Yeah.

    23. DC

      And that if that is your culture, and it is understood within your culture that the top performers get promoted, you're gonna have a much better time than if your, if your employees perceive your culture as-

    24. MS

      Layering

    25. DC

      ... this is just a job. I'm gonna work here for 18 months.

    26. MS

      Yeah.

    27. DC

      I'm gonna vest.

    28. MS

      Yeah.

    29. DC

      And then I'm gonna go somewhere else.

    30. MS

      Yes.

  9. 15:28 – 19:15

    Will AI change how many people your startup needs?

    1. MS

      of employees, and these big departments, and these people who have to manage, hire, fire, build processes for hundreds if not thousands of employees. And I wonder with AI, is this changing?

    2. DC

      Hmm.

    3. MS

      I wonder, should a startup founder today have a different expectation of the number of people they will need in order to be access- successful? And, like, in a world where your company can be generating a billion dollars and you have 100 employees or 200 employees, one would argue there's a whole set of people-

    4. DC

      Yeah

    5. MS

      ... I guess-

    6. DC

      Who-

    7. MS

      ... do you need them in your company ever?

    8. DC

      I think there's an implicit culture in big tech that the more headcount that reports to you-

    9. MS

      Yes

    10. DC

      ... the more legit you are.

    11. MS

      You think-

    12. DC

      And the same-

    13. MS

      That is the compensation path.

    14. DC

      Yeah, and the same-

    15. MS

      You make more money if more people report to you. [laughs]

    16. DC

      For founders, where the more employees you can brag about having, the better.

    17. MS

      Yeah.

    18. DC

      And again, we don't subscribe to the theory of, like, have zero employees-

    19. MS

      Yeah

    20. DC

      ... the zero person startup. But to the extent you can measure impact on revenue per employee-

    21. MS

      Yeah

    22. DC

      ... or things like that, that seems better than just total headcount being the metric you wanna optimize for.

    23. MS

      Well, and-

    24. DC

      Right?

    25. MS

      ... if we are in a sea change of company organization, right? If it turns out the rules that worked in the past to generate a billion dollars or the way a company looked to generate a billion dollars of revenue is gonna look different in the future, bringing a whole bunch of people from the old model into your company might not let you f- live in the future. And I can't tell you how many founders we talk to who started their companies in the pre-AI world, who are, like, looking around at their hundreds or thousand or 2,000 employees and being like, "I suspect this needs to be unraveled, but I have no idea how." And, like, it's tricky, but if we're in this new age with AI where each employee can be 10, 20, 100X more capable, maybe you should explore the boundaries of what that might mean. Maybe you shouldn't be too quick to say, "I'm gonna need to have 10,000 employees one day."

    26. DC

      Yeah.

    27. MS

      And I think, I think that if you start experimenting with that, you might see that kind of shining exec is just not as interesting, you know? It's like maybe-

    28. DC

      Well, they, their experience is in a world that may not a- actually exist anymore.

    29. MS

      Yeah. [laughs] Yeah. Like-

    30. DC

      Like, maybe, maybe that's actually working against you than some homegrown talent that helps make your company successful to begin with.

  10. 19:15 – 22:43

    Why founders put off firing someone they know isn’t working out

    1. MS

      And then I'm like, "Whoa, so what are you gonna do?" And I think you and I both experienced this, but, like, the burden of having weak performers on the team-

    2. DC

      Yeah

    3. MS

      ... is not covered up by adding more people. So how would you advise a company who's basically like, "Hey, I wanna have a great team, but that means I also have to learn how to let people go"?

    4. DC

      Everyone wants to feel like the hero in their own story, and they wanna feel like they're good.

    5. MS

      Yeah.

    6. DC

      And-

    7. MS

      Yeah

    8. DC

      ... they want people to like them.

    9. MS

      Yeah.

    10. DC

      And they never wanna hurt someone's feelings or have someone not like them.

    11. MS

      Yes.

    12. DC

      Right? Like, that's just-

    13. MS

      Yes

    14. DC

      ... that's human nature.

    15. MS

      Yes.

    16. DC

      And if you are willing to hire someone-

    17. MS

      Mm-hmm

    18. DC

      ... you h- you're signing up-

    19. MS

      Mm

    20. DC

      ... for-

    21. MS

      A strong possibility. [laughs]

    22. DC

      Yeah. Like, it's, it's actually, you're taking-

    23. MS

      Yeah

    24. DC

      ... that responsibility. It's like if you, you know-

    25. MS

      If you have a kid-

    26. DC

      If you have a kid-

    27. MS

      ... you gotta raise 'em

    28. DC

      ... you know, you're kinda like-

    29. MS

      Yeah, yeah, yeah

    30. DC

      ... oh yeah, there's, there's an understanding here-

  11. 22:43 – 24:16

    The 90-day question to ask yourself about every hire

    1. MS

      people in terms of hiring, and this is very crude, is I basically, I say to them, "90 days after the person's first day at work, put a meeting invite on your own calendar that's private." And it basically says, "If this person told you that it would be their last day at work today, they're gonna go work at Google or whatever the, you know, OpenAI, how would you feel?" And if your first feeling isn't, like, just this horrible, in the pit of your stomach, like, "We are screwed," that's a signal.

    2. DC

      Yeah.

    3. MS

      God forbid the feeling's like, "Oof." [laughs]

    4. DC

      [laughs] Right. Like, God forbid the feeling is like, "Yeah."

    5. MS

      Release.

    6. DC

      God forbid. Like-

    7. MS

      You know what you have to do. And, like, 90 days is enough time-

    8. DC

      Yeah

    9. MS

      ... to make the judgment about whether someone feels invaluable. And, like, trust that feeling, because the longer you keep them around, the more you're gonna feel this weird attachment to them and the harder it's gonna be. And so it's hard, but man, I like your point, right? Like, don't bring babies into the world if you don't wanna be a parent, right?

    10. DC

      Right. [laughs]

    11. MS

      Like, don't hire employees if you don't ... Like, that's part of the game. And don't pretend like you're doing someone a favor keeping them in the job that they suck at.

    12. DC

      Yep.

    13. MS

      That's kinda screwing you and them. All right. Good chat.

    14. DC

      All right. Sounds good. Thanks, Michael. [upbeat music]

Episode duration: 24:16

In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen

Transcript of episode Is7EsoDgDDY

Get more out of YouTube videos.

Read along on your phone, search it beside the video, or ask your favorite AI app what was said.