By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
David SenraWhy Founders Like Jensen Huang Are Irreplaceable | Tobi Lütke, Shopify
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
70 min read · 13,877 wordsWhy founders like Jensen are irreplaceable
David Senra 0:00 [digital effects] Give me your thoughts on the firing of Jensen.
Tobi Lütke 0:06 I mean, um, with, with your own timeline, it's, uh... I mean, he, he resigned. He resigned, I think, four days after some allegations of him having an affair, I think, in short order, evolved into an affair with a Chinese spy. And then there was, uh, like a TikTok of, um, like another person, another person. I think we are up to three or so of, of, of, of, of, uh, alleged affairs, uh, then a resignation. And so, yeah, what are my thoughts? I mean, yeah, don't have affairs is definitely sort of the first thing that comes to mind.
David Senra 0:36 This is why I just asked you the question, and I'll just read this to you real quick. These are your own words. "There's no replacing a founder like Jensen. There never has been, and there can never be a true succession for a founder like him. NVIDIA ends today, and it's replaced with a thing cosplaying NVIDIA. It will be run by custodians trying and failing to preserve the flame he ignited." So really the reason I asked you the question is just, like, your thoughts on why founders like Jensen, and I would say most founders, are irreplaceable.
Tobi Lütke 1:01 Yeah, and especially Jensen, because he's one of one. We see one video of now, right, like a, like, what is it, four-plus trillion-dollar company. NVIDIA's product is that it takes essentially rocks and makes them think. It's the closest thing to magic human, uh, humanity's ever come. It is something that is so clearly a product of his indomitable vision.
Donating blood 3 times to buy a Riva TNT
Tobi Lütke 1:22 When I was a teenager, I had, uh, made my money. I, I, I sold things to my classmates. I had a paper route and, uh, because I was trying to make money for the things that I wanted, like usually computer upgrades. Then I fell short. I went to, uh, donate blood because the hospitals were paying you in Germany for this, and, um, they didn't-- they were not integrated, so you could make rounds. And, uh, I remember, uh, donating blood in three different hospitals in a row, um, to make enough money to buy the most magical device, uh, what's, uh, called a Riva TNT, one of Jensen's products, a 3D accelerator. Like this was very, very, very long time ago. Jensen has been part of this industry and has kind of ignited the magic and the spark of this industry in a very real way, like accelerating linear algebra made for video games that we know today. But this dogged pursuit of his, just making this better and better and better, the vision of making them programmable, CUDA. For ten years, no one knew what CUDA really did. It's a sort of-- kind of people didn't get it. And yet I, I don't know how you preserve something where, where you have only naysayers. It's a huge investment. The investors were like, "Why are you doing this?" And then the dawn of, uh, um, uh, you know, AlexNet, which was I think the first, uh, um, machine learning model that was trained on these graph- graphical accelerator, GPUs, are not-- like these are graphical processing units. You can't even plug a monitor into them anymore, but they're still called GPUs. So that's all Jensen. Jensen has given us the gift of the graphical accelerator, given us the gift of a machine that does something so fast that we can use it to make synthetic intelligence now and God knows what else, and all these industrial things. It is a singular company he's built. It's a company around a vision that if you just take a thing that's really very important and make it unbelievably good in, in-- even in the presence of no competition, just dogged pursuit of absolute excellence for its own sake, that we would reap the benefits from this. And, um, on top of it, he's like, now that everyone needs this product, it's literally the most valuable product on planet Earth. He's been a, a, like a statesman of presiding over this incredible, um, responsibility and of, of, of allocating these, these things and where they go and bootstrapping industry and supporting everyone. It's like it's-- Jensen is, like, irreplaceable. It's Jensen's exoskeleton, right? And so, um, look, I, I-- extramarital affairs obviously, like, um, marital dis-indiscretions, I-- like these are not good things, but like, it's just like only Jensen can, like, run NVIDIA. It's, it's, it's a, it's a, it's a nutty thing. I mean, you can put him on administrative leave or like figure out something, but he built this company. Like the company is worth, what? Four-- again, I think I remember it's over four trillion dollars. Um, and it's like, you know, that's all v-value on planet Earth that doesn't-- didn't exist without him seeing this, without him building this. It's like we have-- like everyone is living in a... I-I-I-is a good deal richer in the West because NVIDIA exists. It creates money out of nothing and, uh, creates these products out of the potentiality of the ether, and then more value exists in the world, and then you can build products on top of them, which are even more value entering the world. And this is like trillions and trillions and trillions of dollars. And if this stops now because we are turning NVIDIA into some kind of legacy company because the knuckleheads on his board just kind of like seemingly have made a snap decision in the face of scandal or whatever, like the eye of the storm, it's crazy to lose this. And I just, I just think that there's kind of no track record of custodians truly managing to prolong something that's running as red-hot as, uh, like as NVIDIA. I think this is of societal impact, like progress on planet Earth at some point, if you can measure it, like ten years from now, twenty years from now, you might look at a chart, and you could potentially mark the moment where sort of after Jensen's-- like after the current set of decisions have played out, played themselves out, uh, in the market, there will be a de-acceleration because of this. Because like, again, it's an unbelievably hard thing to run a high-functioning large company that's doing important things, and there's really not many people who can do it, and I don't think there's really anyone who can, can do it, definitely for NVIDIA as well as him. So like, well, we need to preserve people in the, in, in this world as long as we want them, and we also should celebrate people for what they truly accomplished. And who knows what the real story is and what all the components are to it. But like the burden of proof needs to be much, much, much higher for saying that he, he's not the right person to run this company.
David Senra 5:58 Yeah, I think what we were talking about before we started recording was I, both of us, uh, like the last time, uh, we had this conversation, you're like, "Oh, we actually have the same job. Both you and I are trying to create more entrepreneurs." And maybe I'm like so, like, you know, I'm so deep in the ocean, I don't understand that like, uh, like the water is wet. [chuckles]
Tobi Lütke 6:15 Mm-hmm.
David Senra 6:15 But like the idea was like unfathomable to me that regardless-
Tobi Lütke 6:20 Yeah.
David Senra 6:20 That they would-
Tobi Lütke 6:20 Yeah.
David Senra 6:21 When people were like, "Oh, you know, Jensen's gonna lose his job," people were speculating. It's like it's impossible. Like the founder is so important 'cause I just-- we have a deep understanding of how important they are.
Tobi Lütke 6:28 Yeah, yeah.
David Senra 6:29 I just wanna read something to you because I think, um, Michael Moritz, he wrote this book on Steve Jobs called, uh, The Little Kingdom. He publishes it, Steve Jobs is still there. I think Steve Jobs is thirty years old. In two thousand and nine, Michael Moritz writes an updated, a version called The Return to the Little Kingdom, and in the forward, he has one of the best lines, 'cause when I was reading your tweets about Jensen, this is what popped to my mind, and he talks about the difference between the founder and a professional CEO. He says, "There's no greater distance known to a man than a single footfall that separates a CEO from a founder. CEOs are, for the most part, products of educational and institutional breeding. Founders, at least the very best of them, are unstoppable, irreplaceable forces of nature." And I think your perspective and what-
Tobi Lütke 7:10 Yeah.
David Senra 7:10 -you were tweeting on Jensen is like he is a force of nature.
Tobi Lütke 7:13 He's a force of nature.
David Senra 7:13 There is no repeating him.
Tobi Lütke 7:14 Yeah, one-
David Senra 7:14 There is no replacing
Tim Cook was still extending Steve's runway
David Senra 7:15 him.
Tobi Lütke 7:15 There is no such thing as a succession for a founder. You can have a succession plan, uh, as a, in a structured sense of moving a founder-run company and transitioning into a custodial-run company and a managerial company if, if you will. And there's obviously success stories in the managerial world too, right? Like as, um... I mean, uh, Tim Cook did a very, very good job extending the runway of products that were created, like keeping, like building them on the clock and so on. I think there was even one or two new products, uh, under his leadership. So something kept working. He's presumably the best in the world that's ever existed as, uh, in terms of taking over from a founder and actually keeping the direction. Now, a lot of the market cap increase was during hi-his time, and he sh-he should get the credit for it. But it's like you have to allocate the market cap, uh, to the products, and, um, the products are all developed under, under, under, under, under Steve. So it can, it can be done in this way. There's even a ca- a case to be made that it is possible to potentially give a company a refounding event. There's examples of this too, but like really, in all situations, you ha- you're, you're having a transition from one thing to another. And the thing, the company that was under the founder ends the day the founder is no longer, no longer in charge. And m-maybe if you're lucky, it's replaced with something else valuable. If you're extremely lucky, maybe it's gonna be replaced with something that might even be more valuable. But like I think your, the betting odds are just really, really low there.
David Senra 8:48 One of the things I love about Ramp is their mission is easy to understand. They wanna help your business save time and money, and that is why they have built Router. Do me a favor. While you're listening to this, go to router.com. Router was built to reduce your company's inference costs by matching every request to the most efficient AI model. Router automatically balances cost, speed, and quality of output. Router is built for CTOs and loved by CFOs. Your engineering team gets the best model for every workload, and your finance team gets lower inference spend. One customer of Router has the perfect description of why your company should be using Router: "Choosing the right model makes a meaningful difference to our AI spend. We run billions of tokens through Router and have reduced our model costs by ninety-two percent." Tokens are money. Save both, and you can do that by going to router.com. One of my all-time favorite quotes is from the book Zero to One, and it says, "The single most powerful pattern I have noticed is that successful people find value in unexpected places, and they do this by thinking about business from first principles instead of formulas." That is exactly what AppLovin has done with their advertising platform. AppLovin connects you with over a billion potential new customers in mobile games. AppLovin allows you to capture undivided attention. AppLovin ads are full-screen videos that are watched for an average of thirty-five seconds. That is retention that blows other ad platforms out of the water, and you can launch on AppLovin in minutes. You set the goal, and AppLovin achieves it. No complex setup, no expertise needed. And AppLovin scales quickly. They can put your ads in front of over a billion potential customers. Other businesses have seen immediate results scale to hundreds of thousands of dollars of spend per day and increase their revenue by millions. So you wanna get started quickly before all of your competitors are on AppLovin, and you can do that by going to applovin.com. That's applovin.com.
Only founders can reinvent their companies
David Senra 10:47 Why do you think this is so widely misunderstood, the importance of the founder? Like, let me give you an example. A friend of mine, uh, was talking to somebody, and this person said, out of all the technology companies that are still founder-led, the one that would be the least different if the founder left was Meta. And I go, "What?" I go, "Who is this person?" And they're like, "That, this person's an investor." I go, "No, that person's an idiot."
Tobi Lütke 11:07 Yeah, no, that is completely wrong. People always have it bo-both ways. Like, you know, just like a year ago or whatever, maybe a year and a half ago, or two maybe max, um, like everyone's complaining about suddenly Meta is hiring all these, uh, researchers for a lot of money, um, and that doesn't make sense. And now they're like have frontier-level, like Meta is an AI lab at a full Pareto frontier. Like, like try that. Like there's a lot of companies in the world now who have the resources of, uh, Meta, and none of them have made that decision. So like, it's like giving, like reinventing your own company as a, as an aspect of founder-run companies. And like you, you can point at basically any run-- founder-run company. Now, I can go in a bit of a, my, uh, junk science, um, uh, take on why this is, um, but like it depends on where you want to go in this conversation really, because I think it is under, like understudied, um, what, what, what is the, the operating bit that's causing, uh, founder-run companies to, to, to be so effective. But it's not a new topic. Like there's the- I think the best books on this topic are written-- b- I mean, probably the best books read on this topic I've read is written by, um, John Burnham, uh, called The Managerial Revolution. I think he wrote this before World War II. They didn't have word founders. I think he called them the bourgeois entrepreneur or something like this, you know. So, um, but, but, but, but, but it, it nails the, the, the thesis, and it's under-discussed, and I think it's causing people to, uh, make a lot of principle sort of category mistakes in a, in a, like billionaires are universally hated, and people are allowed to hate whoever they want. But, like, [sighs] it is really, really crazy to not make a difference here between builder billionaires and, uh, others. You know, again, the people who, um, build companies, uh, people who build products, or there's at least one billionaire who wrote books, they are adding value to the world in a way that, like, it, it would simply not exist otherwise. Like, someone has to start the book, and someone has to write it. Someone has
The 95% of Shopify he doesn't own
Tobi Lütke 13:14 to start a company. I started Shopify. It exists because of a couple of decisions I made in two thousand and four, and then the decision to keep at it for twenty-two years. I'm obviously not responsible for all the value of Shopify. This is a team production. We have thousands of people who work here, and I own a very small percentage of a company. It's, like, five, six percent at this point. So nine-- like ninety-five percent is owned by, you know, the public, by employees, by early people who took bets and who take- took huge risks. This is how money is created. We want great societies. We want, uh, fair societies. We want, um, people to not suffer, people to have healthcare, people to have options, people to have safety nets. And so, you know, all, all these kind of things are created from an energy in the form of money that is created by the entrepreneurial spark, mostly of taking potentiality, like potential that's out there, and converting this into products and services that we then trade for each other. And but m- money comes into the world at the moment of product creation. Jensen, uh, and his teams are taking sand and rock and making it think and be able to answer your entrepreneurial questions that you secretly harbor, um, in the quest of one day starting your own company. That is a thing that only is possible and is extremely valuable to you, and therefore you are happy to pay for the, uh, ChatGPT subscription because of all the work by the builders. I think it's hugely important to, um, have a more, um, balanced view of, uh, the importance of, uh, makers, um, in society because, again, it's a pretty [chuckles] tough job, uh, by itself, and I think most founders can deal with the sort of constant, uh, derision. Founders tend to be, uh, and entrepreneurs tend to be used to lots of naysayers along the journey. You have to overcome a lot of people telling you you shouldn't be doing this. So there's some sort of school of hard knocks there that everyone's gone through, and that's okay. The moment it becomes
Rising violence will make founders opt out
Tobi Lütke 15:16 a safety issue, right, which it increasingly becomes, that will just mean a lot of people will opt out.
David Senra 15:20 What do you mean safety issue?
Tobi Lütke 15:22 Well, I mean, [sighs] we've seen, uh, assassinations of, uh, CEOs now. We've seen, uh, um, there's a lot of violence. There's polls which say that occasional violence against, um, uh, CEOs can be justified, which I think up to sixty percent of people, uh, um, on, on one side of the political spectrum agree with.
David Senra 15:42 Come on.
Tobi Lütke 15:43 And, uh-
David Senra 15:44 That's fucking insane.
Tobi Lütke 15:45 I mean, this is also a consequence of telling everyone that all problems come from someone else being, being rich.
David Senra 15:52 I think your framing is really smart, um, about, okay, everybody's focused on the fact that you own five percent of, of Shopify, and they can do the numbers, and it seems like a big number, but you're like-
Tobi Lütke 16:03 And it is
David Senra 16:03 ... what about the other ninety-five percent? So, um-
Tobi Lütke 16:05 It's a big number because of all the value that was created.
Bezos wants a different rich list than the Forbes 400
David Senra 16:07 I get to spend time with Bezos. He's one of my favorite entrepreneurs.
Tobi Lütke 16:09 Yeah.
David Senra 16:09 Obviously, one of the greatest.
Tobi Lütke 16:10 One of the best ever.
David Senra 16:11 Fucking crazy. The complexity and the performance of the co-- uh, the company and everything else-
Tobi Lütke 16:15 Ten thousand.
David Senra 16:16 And so we were supposed to meet for thirty minutes 'cause he listens to my other podcast, Founders, and I think he's gonna do this show. But, um, we were supposed to meet for thirty minutes. We wound up talking for three hours. And one of the things I told him, which was the most insane thing ever, 'cause hi- his point was just like, uh... I was like, "Dude, you made a magic" -- He's done a lot of stuff, but I go, "You made a magic button I can press, and anything come-- anything I want in the world comes to my house in two days."
Tobi Lütke 16:39 Yeah.
David Senra 16:39 And now it's like six hours, or it's even crazier. And I go, "And they put a fucking guillotine in front of your house."
Tobi Lütke 16:46 Yes. Yeah, yeah. Right, right, right. Exactly.
David Senra 16:47 Did you make a magic button that I could press and anything... Like, that's an insane thing.
Tobi Lütke 16:50 Yeah.
David Senra 16:50 And one of the, the ideas he had was he thinks that the Forbes 400 list is actually, like, really detrimental to society.
Tobi Lütke 16:56 Yeah. Yeah.
David Senra 16:56 'Cause it's like we're like, "This person has two hundred or one hundred or fifty," and it's like makes it some kind of competition. He goes, "There should be how much-- There should be a list of how much wealth the entrepreneur has created."
Tobi Lütke 17:05 Completely created.
David Senra 17:06 He goes, he goes... I think at the time, I, I forget the markup. We'll just make this up. Amazon's worth two trillion dollars. I own two hundred billion of that two trillion, which means I created one, or I helped create one point eight trillion-
Tobi Lütke 17:18 That's the same point
David Senra 17:18 ... for others.
Tobi Lütke 17:19 Yes.
David Senra 17:19 The idea that we haven't built... Y- y- I love it, you're like, "We can just put things into existence with AI now." We should just build this together and just have a fucking list, and then we'll just put it everywhere about the wealth created by other people.
Tobi Lütke 17:29 I completely agree, and it's just like, it's, it's, it's again, like, where does the money come from? It seems a question that a lot of people just are not curious about. But it is the most important question because o- only when you understand it do you understand who are on... Like, who are people on the side of human thriving truly, right? Like, it's like, don't get me wrong, but redistribution of, uh, uh, money is also an incredibly important topic. But clearly it's a secondary topic to creating it, because, like, first you need to make something, and then you can figure out who needs help, right? And so in a lot of parts of the world, uh, in the West, we are no longer concerning ourselves so much with the creation of money and a lot more with, uh, redistribution. And the problem is, if this continues, at some point, you know, the growth stops, at which point you only have redistribution, and the only way to then get One dollar from one side where you think it shouldn't exist to a place where you think it's needed. Even if you're right about this, you have to take something away from others, and this is where things get really, really, really bad because that's basically the situation that the Middle Ages were in. That's-- There, there was no growth. The, we didn't have steam power. Um, the only way to bring more kinetic energy into the world was by someone being born or by, like a human or a beast of burden, and, um, that was very slow. So growth was basically nothing. Therefore, only thing that existed was, uh, rivalrous competition for resources, and therefore it all went to the landed gentry, or it-- you, you went on conquest for, for resources. And that's a bad world. Like this is one world we rejected and replaced with a, with a vastly better world where we allow people, uh, with a vision to create things to, to, to, to make goods, make services for each other, which then brings more money into-- onto planet Earth, into the economy. That is what GDP growth is. Then allow them to, uh, like, like-- or incentivize this kind of behavior by allowing people to own a very small fraction while sharing almost all of it with civic society, and so this is a beautiful system.
David Senra 19:27 There's something that popped in my mind. I actually think it's a problem that I didn't think of until we're, we're talking about this now. Plenty of examples of well-known entrepreneurs that are giving away money quietly and anonymously. They do not... They're, they're like, "I want to do this, but I don't want any credit back."
Tobi Lütke 19:41 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
David Senra 19:42 There's an organization I think... I, I forgot. This is like three or four days ago. Uh, I was in downtown LA. There's an organization that is helping rehabilitate gang members. A lot of them came out of prison. A lot of them are covered in tattoos. They're doing tattoo removal. They're getting them jobs. They're getting them education, and it's completely one-off donations. And a world-famous wealth creator, entrepreneur that built products donated, I forgot the amount now. It was like fifty million, but they insisted it was anonymous. The problem with that now-
Tobi Lütke 20:12 It's okay
David Senra 20:12 ... listening to you speak is just like, okay, so it's public how much your stock is worth, and at the same time, all these entrepreneurs that their wealth is public, they're doing all this great stuff for, for society and giving back, but they insist it's anonymous. We can go back to history. You and I both share, uh, a love of history, and it's like, well, what did Carnegie do? Carnegie did... Like, he spent a ton of his wealth building, I think, a couple hundred of the libraries at the time-
Tobi Lütke 20:35 Yeah, the public libraries, yeah, yeah
David Senra 20:35 ... obviously no internet, like, in communities that made a difference.
Tobi Lütke 20:38 Yeah.
David Senra 20:38 And he insisted on starting in communities where he got his resources from-
Tobi Lütke 20:41 Yeah
David Senra 20:41 ... like a lot of the, the, the natural resources you need to make steel. And as a result, like he made society better, but then he made it known that it was his. Now, you could say he did that for fucking ego and everything else, but I think that is actually important. A-the-- Doing anonymous donations to me is like the highest form of giving. But it's also like y-there-- especially when we're all connected, it's like you almost have to kind of let people know what you're doing.
Tobi Lütke 21:06 Totally.
David Senra 21:06 Think about one of the most beloved, you know, multi, multi-billionaires in the country right now, I would say, would be Michael Dell. You're not gonna find a lot of people that hate Michael Dell. He's one of my personal heroes. I, I love him. He's been so supportive of me. His books are amazing, the way he thinks. He's just an incredible person. I get to spend a ton of time with him, and I think what he's doing is one of the, the, the-
Tobi Lütke 21:26 I love it
David Senra 21:26 ... best things I've ever seen.
Tobi Lütke 21:27 Yeah, yeah.
David Senra 21:28 It's like, I'm not gonna wait till I die-
Tobi Lütke 21:30 Yeah
David Senra 21:30 ... to give the money away. I'm gonna do it now, and I'm gonna do it for the kids of America.
Tobi Lütke 21:34 Yeah, yeah. Yeah. These, um, kids accounts were, were I think one of the most important sort of breakthrough piece of infrastructure that has been built in recent times, right? Like, because there's, I think, a way to like, like do this now, give money to all the kids. I think there's some talk about, uh, depositing shares, uh, of companies, uh, into kids' accounts.
David Senra 21:55 Greg Shaw was doing this-
Tobi Lütke 21:56 Yes
David Senra 21:56 ... for shares of SpaceX, for example.
Tobi Lütke 21:58 Exactly.
David Senra 21:58 I think Elon said he did the same thing.
Tobi Lütke 21:59 Unbelievable. Yeah. This is a wonderful form of, like, like of giving, which is, I think, it's very novel. It skirts around a lot of the problems that, that otherwise exist with, uh, with giving. I agree. So like I'm, I'm conflicted on the, on an anonymous donation thing. I'm partial to it, but like it is somewhat selfish counter, counter intuitively. The largest charitable donations in Canadian history, I, I'm proud to say, was done by, uh, a family member of mine. Well, like Bruce McLean was like financed and, and-
David Senra 22:28 Really? Oh, interesting
Tobi Lütke 22:28 ... the company. My, my, my father-in-law did, um, a very, very large anonymous, uh, donation, and we convinced him o-over years to eventually own it. Like it built, um, I think CAMH, uh, like mental health, uh, research hospital in Canada. The reason why it was important to own it is because if you do it anonymously, it is incredibly... Like it, it's sort of unambiguously morally pure for sure. However, money is a form of directed energy. It comes with a lot more than just the monetary value. I think you want to make it a high-status thing to, uh, do this type of donation, like this well-researched, this is a cause that's important to me, and funnel it in your direction because you give signal to everyone else. First of all, other people can see themselves in this act of putting money into a cause that they like really, uh, uh, that's, that's really important to them. And then also you're just g-like creating an amplification effect. Like there's more money flowing into this cause now because this got owned.
David Senra 23:28 Michael Dell and Brad Gerstner started this, and now everybody's coming in.
Tobi Lütke 23:32 Exactly.
David Senra 23:32 They're like, "This is a great idea."
Tobi Lütke 23:33 Yeah.
David Senra 23:33 "I didn't think of that before. I have resources. Why don't I do that too?"
Tobi Lütke 23:36 I don't even think it's necessarily true in this way, but like mainstream understanding of a robber baron times was that there's a lot of, uh, labor exploitation.
David Senra 23:44 Mm-hmm.
Tobi Lütke 23:44 So you would basically accumulate, um, guilt along the way of creating wealth, and then you would sort of make it okay by building libraries or so. But that's, that is a template. You know, like that was sort of a compact that, um, existed, um, until I think recent times. I think the sort of last person to go for the compact was, I would say, Bill Gates is sort of infamous, right? Like, um, at least the narrative arc. Again, I don't really believe in the guilt part of this because, again, I think the real virtuous thing that you can do on planet Earth, my own philosophy is like What is more virtuous to do than create products and services for your fellow humans, right? Like, but that already is the thing that you're supposed to be doing, right? Like
Markets are the original superintelligence
Tobi Lütke 24:33 the money component is like humans make markets. Markets are the original form of superintelligence. Like we are all part of markets that are vastly more intelligent than us. They are in real-time change the prices of everything based on supply and demand. If there's demand for something, um, it'll-- like supply will exist. I can, uh, in my city, I can just call a plumber and fix everything in my house if it needs fixing. I have no idea how to do this, and I don't need to face up the reality of being completely incompetent in these matters because the superintelligence of a City of Toronto allows me to, um, uh, just like solve this problem on demand, uh, for myself. Like markets exist everywhere. The oldest writings we find, like tablets, clay tablets, are of things where a bunch of people go to the other town over with a, with a cart full of goods, and, uh, they tally who owns what and so that they can track who will make what profit. Those were entrepreneurs of their times. This is like twelve thousand years ago or something, and we are creating markets. Free humans create markets amongst each other. They make goods for each other. They make compensation for this, which then allows them to do more of it. And this is just what happens in a free society, right? I'm not a full laissez-faire, uh, capitalist. I think, uh, you need to avoid monopolies. You need to co-- ensure that every space of value has competition in it. If competition stops, it very, very, very, very rarely goes, it goes well. The examples of where it went well are usually the founder-run companies, right? Like I think-- like NVIDIA had no true competition for a very, very long time. Yet you would never notice because like clockwork, every, every year there was a new revision of the cards with new features. Suddenly, we had tensor cores, but we had no idea why anyone would want them because we used them to make, I don't know, uh, Call of Duty run better, right? Like, so why, why do we need tensor cores? But turns out tensor cores were the entire reason we needed them, like invent because, uh, that's what you need for the, for, for AI acceleration. That was not a product of fierce competition. That was product of vision. So in a market or in a space where you have people following true mission, you don't need to rely on markets and competition to get the best outcomes. In all other cases, you do. The moment the custodians take over, the motivation will be induced externally rather than being an intrinsic burning flame that needs to be fanned to glow brighter and brighter.
Jensen reserved chips for the little guys
David Senra 26:58 To tie that idea to what you referenced earlier, that you viewed Jensen as like the statesman of the entire AI industry.
Tobi Lütke 27:05 Again, getting these GPUs, without them you can't do AI training. There's no other address you can call. You need a lot of them, and you place a large order. Jensen will review every one of those orders. I mean, he makes plenty money, so like he, he's fine. But like at many times he could make a lot more money. Again, I know I have no insider information here. This is, you know, the stories I hear or what I'm being told. He always made sure that there's availability for the s- the smaller guys, the, the, the, the startups. Presumably, he wants more customers in the future, so there's some self-interest in this, but he doesn't have to do it. He made sure that these things were available to everyone. He championed open source AI, which has a very high likelihood of being involved somehow in these events because there's a lot of people who really, really, really do not want open source AI to, to take off, and NVIDIA was heavily investing in them. I should say-
David Senra 27:57 Wait, say more about that.
Tobi Lütke 27:58 I, I should say, so like again, we'll get more information. This might look dumb in retrospect, and I might be completely wrong, but this looked like an op, let's be honest. This was like surgical. Affair, Chinese spy, another affair, another affair. Now, of course, he did potentially have those affairs. Maybe there's even a Chinese spy component. This is like currently just looks extremely unlikely, uh, that that's a real thing from the information available right now. But this is an op, right? This is like choreographed. It's too, uh, organized. This is exactly how you write it in a book as a takedown story. The question is: Who's benefiting from Jensen not having this job? And there's a pretty large list, and it depends on-- there's multiple motives that could exist. So I think we're-- we need to understand the real story. But what's frightening is how quickly you can unseat someone who started a company thir- thirty-three years and turn it into the most valuable company on planet Earth, doing an incredibly good job, uh, running, running it and, uh, again, having to make enormously important decisions, you know, about allocations and a roadmap and, uh, uh, like of, of, of, you know, the currently most important product on planet Earth, really. So yeah, there's clearly more to the story.
David Senra 29:09 The best founders are relentless about saving time and only focusing on what matters most. The founder of FedEx, Fred Smith, had this great line that he would repeat. He would say, "You have to be absolutely brutal in the management of your time." That is why many of the best founders in the world are using Dot in ChatGPT. Dot is OpenAI's AI agent that works for you continuously even when you're not actively using ChatGPT. Dot works across your apps, can execute multi-step tasks, and help you stay organized. You give it a responsibility, and it starts working, giving you more time to focus on the work that matters most. One way that I use my Dot is to help me research upcoming guests. It reads my email and keeps an eye on my calendar, so it knows who my upcoming guests are. It then finds relevant information, interviews, articles, and their top posts on X. Twenty-four hours before we record, my Dot sends me a document with detailed notes and links to everything. What used to take you hours, Dot can do in minutes. Save more time and keep your business moving with Dot. Dot is included with ChatGPT Pro, Business, and Enterprise plans. Again, that is chatgpt.com/get-dot.
The computer programmer job is over
David Senra 30:16 Okay, so let's transition to what you were saying earlier. I think-- I don't even think, uh-- I think we were talking about this before we started recording. I had your close friend DHH on the show.
30:25 Uh, he's just like a bottle of energy. I think you just, like, tee him up and he just goes. [laughs] I think that's probably the, the, the episode I spoke the least in-
Tobi Lütke 30:33 Yeah
David Senra 30:33 ... 'cause I was just like-- I was also been a fan of his writing for like fifteen years, so I was like, "Shit, it's kinda cool now that, like..." You know, we had dinner the night before. We hang out at his house. Like, it's, it's really cool to get to, like, meet the people you admire and, you know, his-- a lot of his writing shaped my thinking as well about, like, how to build a business. You said something interesting where you're like, well, uh, and I watched his, his speech about him no, no longer being a programmer, and he puts, like, the-
Tobi Lütke 30:57 Yeah
David Senra 30:57 ... the date, like, two thousand and twenty-six is when-
Tobi Lütke 30:59 Yes
David Senra 30:59 ... it all ended. So you said something fascinating. You were like, "Well, you know-
Tobi Lütke 31:01 This is, uh, uh, like a talk he did at, um, Railsworld, um, conference, like, of a, again, technology started a lot of us used to build our company, Shopify included. I recommend even for non-programmers to watch at least the, these clips because I think David did an enormously good job here, like framing something that's really, really important. And the entire audience there was there to learn about how, um, what's next in this technology, and David basically said, "This is no longer a job."
David Senra 31:31 We'll link it down in the show notes, but explain how you said Web 2- Web 2.0, 'cause I love how you tie everything back. Like, you're always looking back to figure out what's going, happening forward too. So Web 2.0 as of two thousand and twenty-six is dead, that idea. Can you just explain that in totality?
Tobi Lütke 31:44 You'll hear me say a lot of, uh, similar things to what David, I think, articulated better than I will be able to. These are things we've been talking. We, we, we, we have a hobby together doing endurance racing, and these are things we've been philosophizing. I mean, we've been part of one of the greatest creative periods in human history with jobs that allowed us to be not just participants, but also make a dent into them. Like, really sort of early two thousands was called Web 2.0. Um, uh, then it's, it's not a term that's important, but, like, it's impo-- a term that's important to me. It was a lot of us basically raising our hands and saying, "Hey, we have figured out how to take this, like, academic document viewer called web browser and use it to make software." It's sort of very different from the way we're making desktop software in all these important ways because there's some restrictions in the medium and of course like a client-server architecture and so on. But, like, we figured out how to make good web applications. In fact, David's best-known product is Basecamp, and, uh, I think really could be associated with the true starting point of an, uh, c- at its release in, uh, two thousand, two thousand and four. So the browser's not good enough. We figured out some sense of mastery over the technologies, and we know how to put it together to, for, for, for making phenomenal products, and then we did. Like enormous amounts of the technology industry are companies that many use David's technology, Ruby on Rails, again, including Shopify. So we, we built these companies. Again, we made gifts for each other in the open source world, and then we took those to make gifts for our customers that we charged some money for. And then our customers, they, if we did a great job, then through the wonders of the market, they subscribed. In most cases, they could cancel at any moment. Uh, this is true for Shopify. So it's a very, very honest relationship, um, of value exchange. You know, this is this industry of Web 2.0, and we are in the AI age. And at least the jobs that we had, the computer programmer, uh, uh, which I associate with, uh, you know, typing characters into a terminal or a editor, um, to, to, to program computers, that doesn't exist anymore. I mean, there might be practitioners still, and there might be, like, some s-situations where you really, really, really want to tweak exactly everything. It-- but, like, that's, like, very fleeting now. So really there is a period where this existed. It's over now, and everyone who, who used to be a computer programmer has started a, a new job now. And, and I, I think in, in almost every way this is gonna be a better job. It, it's, it's like, it's, it's-- we are now just creators of things. We are makers. We are talking to our computers in the form of w-wishes. We are thinking much harder about the system we want instead of just the next step to getting somewhere that's, like, good enough. We are thinking about what could be. We are-- like, there's vastly more ambition. There's vastly more back and forth. I can go in all sorts of depth here on what this job now is.
David Senra 34:47 Explain what you mean by there's now more depth.
Tobi Lütke 34:50 I truly live in this world now. I have-- Since we last talked, I have realized my life's ambition of becoming a full-time technologist, creator of products at a kick-ass company. [laughs] Like, that's what I always wanted. This is-- I start a company because, uh, I couldn't find a company, uh, that w- I would call a kick-ass company. I felt I had to create it. I became the CEO partly by cleverly hiring everyone, uh, uh, under myself [laughs] and to, uh, preserve the flame of a great company because that's easy to screw up. And, um, uh, but, like, mostly I created the jobs I really, really wanted for other people. And now I can, at the same time, while doing my job, also, um, be someone who, uh, makes things. So I'm making, I think, pretty cool, [laughs] I hope everyone else agrees, at the company, um, contributions to, like, Shopify core systems. I built products. I built, uh, uh, uh, uh, tools and technologies, um, that, that thousands of people use in a company. In fact, everyone uses in a company. That is remarkable. My main advice is when people are not quite, uh, able to get all the value out of, um, this AI-driven development, it's, like, usually
Insufficiently ambitious prompting
Tobi Lütke 35:59 insufficiently ambitious prompting. It's really phenomenally interesting to sit down with people and saying-- And sometimes, funnily enough, I, I just sit down with them and instead of asking them how they prompt, I'm like, I ask them, "Hey, go through all the history of prompting." Um, like I, I literally go to the AI and we say, "Go through all the prompts and just sort of cluster them in types of prompts and, like, give us good examples of prompting and especially start beginning, mid of project, and, like, just, like, analyze it." And, and, like- You know, the AI can actually do the meta-analysis itself. And then we look through this and just saying, "Look, you had some preconceived notions about how to solve the problem, but you told it to, um, uh, like investigate, which is good, but you didn't understand the problem, so give it a chance to actually say there might be much better ways to solve it. Or maybe there's a, you know-- m-maybe this isn't the problem at all if we change something else over here." So they often sort of working with the machine is actually, [chuckles] in a way, trying to inspire it to, uh, understand, um, like the, the problem you're trying to solve. And then most of the work ends up becoming, it's not a good term, but for lack of a better one, we call it, call it, uh, verification engineering, which is like creating acceptance tests. Like, here's how you know for sure that the thing that exists, the thing that was created is good. Again, I'm not gonna bore you with the technologies with going into this, and also I think all of those are going to change because we're sort of working with what we've got right now. But this will be a huge part of our industry now, um, where we make sure that we use, um, automated systems to know that, like a system is known to be good. We, we had unit tests before. We had static typing before, which are sort of things-- at least static typing is sort of formal verification, but the field of formal verification is now by far the most, um, important field in engineering. Look, I've lived in this industry. I pride myself on knowing almost everything that's going on to the degree that, uh, that, that one human can. Formal verification was a thing I had-- I knew it existed in academia and knew mathma-math-mathematics was using things like Lean to, to formalize proofs, but I probably knew this from AI research and, like I had no idea that this was gonna be the most important part of engineering in the future, and now it is. And so this is how quickly everything's changing.
David Senra 38:21 Wait, explain why it's gonna be the most important part of engineering.
Tobi Lütke 38:24 Because you can prove that some-- a system is correct. This is-- and this is extremely important for complex systems. Like I, I just like-- Let me say something about what I've learned here in-- about agentically engineering, and this is specifically when you're rebuilding systems with agents. And tying this back to, um, David and Ruby and why David proclaimed, "Pencils are down. We are no longer hand-chisel coding. We are now, uh, working with agents." We didn't have enough engineers, um, in a, in a world or even close, probably point one percent of amount of demand-- there was demand for. Like it's just too few people went into this. Maybe it's an aptitude thing, but like it's just, I think for whatever reason, there was just like way more demand than, uh, supply of engineers because there was so much demand for writing code. Therefore, the most important thing that m-most of us could work on, and this is why you hear so much about frameworks, like Shopify is built on top of Ruby on Rails. I said this like three times already. That's a really, really important thing. What is Ruby on Rails? Ruby on Rails is a, uh, again, a framework that just sort of like constrains the possibility space and just sort of says, "Here's a known good way of building a web application." It's full of abstractions, and abstractions are sort of pretension, like you pretend that something is simpler than it is. You can just like make a-- You, you, you can talk to the database by just making a new object and telling it to find, find by name one, uh, and like it, it does all this. It does all the hard work of plumbing these things together and dealing with wire protocols and the complexities of retry logic and busy databases and like all these things are kind of pretended to not exist in an abstraction. So what are abstractions? Our entire industry was like build abstractions. Why? Because abstractions cause productivity. They actually, unfortunately, have a large negative consequences, but n-none of this mattered because we needed productivity, productivity over everything. We needed to get one engineer to be able to write ten X, a hundred X the code of, uh, an engineer who wouldn't use these, um, abstractions. So productivity was absolutely everything. And we invested, one could say wasted, almost all the advances of computers getting faster simply for productivity gains. Like we, we made higher and higher, higher stacks of abstractions. This is why when you find a really old computer and start it on, uh, like, like start it like an old Mac or so, it just boots in a no time, and you start an application, it's there. And it's like, this thing is from-- Like try this with a Macintosh. Like it's-- this thing is from eighty-four and like the word processor opens instantaneously. Why does today when I start Word have a splash screen that takes thirty seconds, right? It's because-
David Senra 41:05 JJ is doing this. I love the, the-- He's like, "I bought a new Apple computer. It took forty minutes."
Tobi Lütke 41:09 Yeah.
David Senra 41:09 And then his new, um, his new Linux machine says-
Tobi Lütke 41:12 Operates.
David Senra 41:12 Yeah. [laughs] Yes.
Tobi Lütke 41:13 Yeah, like you can install the entire thing, uh, faster than you can, uh, probably load Word, right?
David Senra 41:19 Yeah.
Tobi Lütke 41:19 Like and so why is this? Because we were extremely wasteful because we had to be because you need productivity. Okay, all this to say we don't need productivity anymore. So this is crazy, right? Like so working with agent is actually in so many ways the opposite. No engineer wants to work in a code base with insanely strict rules. These are called linter rules, right? Like rules which say, yes, you wrote valid code. It might even work, but it's not allowed around here for reasons of-- that are important to the code base. So valid code becomes errors because every company has their own way of doing things and bans certain ways and allows certain ways. Um, these things are seen as, uh, tools of oppression. You have to like not go too far, otherwise no engineer wants to work on your code base anymore because it's like oppressive. The agents love them because they give them rules. They love rules, but not abstractions because they are perfectly happy to write tens of thousands of lines of code that are correct for the thing they are doing, and they don't want to go through fifty files and read all the layers and layers and layers of, uh, uh, uh, that, that the abstract, uh, Tower of Babel has built up to understand what the actual consequences are. Okay. That's important. So we need to write code entirely different now with agents. How do we know that it's good? Because now we are producing too much code to review. Because another aspect of building abstractions is the end result of code is not that much. Therefore, we can have humans reread this in the form of a code review to make sure that it's okay. Code review is basically our human-run formal verification shitty version of it. All this, um, is changing now. So formal verification now is actually specified. You s-- you basically say, "This system has these many states, like, that can exist. Here's, like, a model of the state machine that runs the Shopify checkout or something. And now please verify that every single possible state the system can get into is actually thought through and is tested and is specified." What you will invariably find is within... If you ask your, um, AI to-- Like, and everyone can try this. Everyone who has, like, any code base, uh, can try this. Go into something like Cloud Code and just ask your AI, "Find all implicit state machines in this code base." You say, "Get me all the state machines to be, uh, that are implicit currently and sort of ad hoc in the system, and make them explicit." First of all, you will learn so much about human failings in writing code. You, you will immediately, um, realize we were not as good as writing code as we all thought because the machine will m-make everything better the moment you tell it. And then afterwards you say, "Now make, um..." It's called a TLA model. It's like it'll change fifteen minutes after this podcast is, uh, released about how we do these things. But right now you ask it, "Now make a TLA model for it to make sure that all the cases are, are specified." You will find a thousand bugs in your code base, any code that we've ever pointed it at. Then afterwards you go and say, "Okay, by the way, use some tool." Vercel made a great tool called, uh, DeepSec. "Use DeepSec to look for security vulnerabilities in my code." And then you will definitely not think that humans should be writing any code anymore after that's done. We are currently in the midst of an unbelievable awakening to, uh, of, of, of cybersecurity, which is... Like, I think most companies are in some form of code red, just, like, trying to fix everything and we probably have to replace all human code within the next probably six to twelve months, um, that are running in production on planet Earth. So a way to do it is either, uh, by improving existing code bases to be sound, uh, through prompts and, uh, things like I mentioned, or by building verification systems that make it so that you can really specify what the actual system truly should be, that you make sure that it's all considered, which is something you can collaborate with great AI on. And then against these formal verification methods, uh, maybe unit tests, maybe production traffic, whatever you have, you will rebuild a completely net new code base in a safer language than the one you might have used before, like Rust or something like this. That's-- will be the code of the future. Many, many consequences in this, uh, like, that are side effects of, um, this kind of activity.
Software is about to become nearly bug-free
Tobi Lütke 45:45 I think software will basically be near bug-free. It will be a hundred X faster in many instances. Um, we'll definitely get back to a world where things just start instantaneously, and we will be, um, amazed by how much you can, uh, do on with a run-of-the-mill or, like, even with a ten-year-old laptop all of a sudden. The quality of all software is gonna just go through the roof. Computers will do the things that their users want. If computers don't do the things that their users want, you will tell your computer that you would like it to be able to do something different, and it will rewrite the parts that, um, are involved in the thing that you didn't like before. We will live in a world of entirely-- where the-- all computers are entirely malleable in a sense that it's gonna be the computer that supports you and your job perfectly in exactly the way you want. Potentially not a computer at all, potentially just fully automated in the cloud, potentially behind an AI that you talk to. Those are options for y- for everyone and, um, all of this is gonna happen extremely fast now.
David Senra 46:47 Deel is how the best founders turn the world into their talent pool. I've been studying how history's greatest founders operate for a decade, and one thing they all have in common is they understand that recruiting and hiring the very best talent is your most important priority. A players recognize other A players, which is why top companies like Ramp, Shopify, Eleven Labs, Uber, and DoorDash all use Deel. Many of the top founders I know have personally invested in Deel after using their product, and what they discovered is that Deel is the best company in the world at building infrastructure for global hiring. Deel will help your business hire, pay, and manage any worker anywhere in the world, so you can retain the best talent anywhere and spend the rest of your time focusing on what you do best, delivering value to your customers. The founder of Eleven Labs has a great description of the value Deel can give your company. He said, "We built Eleven Labs to break down language and communication barriers. With Deel enabling us to hire and support exceptional talent anywhere, we can accelerate our innovation and bring more voices, stories, and ideas to every corner of the world." Deel is trusted by over forty thousand companies and growing fast. Learn how they can help your business by going to deel.com/senra. That is deel.com/senra. Okay, I'm trying to understand everything that you just said, and I-- it's very fast. Thank you for doing that, by the way. That was incredible. It's-- But it started from this point where you're like, well, the big issue here is you're insufficiently ambitious prompting.
Tobi Lütke 48:12 Mm-hmm.
David Senra 48:12 Right? And then the more you spoke from that starting point, I almost feel like you're describing the difference between human intelligence and artificial intelligence. And-
Tobi Lütke 48:23 Yes
David Senra 48:23 ... when we went through these prompts, you're assuming too much that you knew, you actually identified the right problem, or that you knew maybe you had an inkling how to solve it. There's a weird thing that happened in my mind when I'm listening to you speak. You-- That, that documentary they did on Demis in DeepMind, right? And they talked about like eventually they just studied every other-- uh, at the very beginning, they studied every move that humans could possibly do in Go.
Tobi Lütke 48:44 Yeah.
David Senra 48:44 And then eventually that only got them so far.
Tobi Lütke 48:46 Yeah.
David Senra 48:46 But what got them even further is the machine coming up with things that humans would never even-
Tobi Lütke 48:51 Yeah.
David Senra 48:51 -comprehend or even think of.
Tobi Lütke 48:53 Move thirty-seven. Yeah.
David Senra 48:54 Something like that. Is-- You're describing a very similar thing in programming-
Tobi Lütke 48:57 Yeah.
David Senra 48:57 Yes or
AI as an instrument
David Senra 48:58 no?
Tobi Lütke 48:58 Yes, that's exactly what I'm doing. AI certainly is an excellent current task accelerator, and I think this is how it's usually used. I think AI is best thought of as an instrument. If you first pick up an guit- uh, pick up a guitar, maybe on one string, you can maybe even figure out how to play a melody or something like this, but, like, you don't really know how to produce music. It takes a while, right? Like, and of course-- But there's no difference between truly the guitar you can pick up just like this and what, like, I don't know, Hendrix plays. At some point, you understa-- Like you can play an instrument truly because you understand it at a, at a, at a, at a level. It's a small group of people, but there are people in the world who, who, who can play AI at this level, um, who are really understanding the tools, even though it's a very fast-moving base. And I think I'm reporting back a little bit from what the l- what the world looks like from that perspective, in that instead of accelerating your tasks, learn the instrument. Learn how to, um, work with AI in such a way that it-- like you, you provide it with the problems you want to solve. Show up with an openness for a wide variety of solutions because it turns out there often are things that you might never have thought. With the tools becoming more sophisticated, it's not just the AI is turning sophisticated, it's also what's called the harnesses that are using the AI is becoming more sophisticated. Almost all engineering at Shopify now is happening through these things called factories, which, uh, are like constellations of AI agents with different jobs, kind of loosely mirroring what organizations, um, were like, who collaborate with each other through chat or through message boards to accomplish much more long horizon tasks. It's much better to be more ambitious with AI and have it do reps on solving the problem than it is to, uh, accomplish tasks, because I think accomplishing just the tasks keeps you in a sort of smaller frame of reference, which I think will be very hard to get to the right places, at least i-in the engineering world, fast enough. Again, because, and this is the other part, between cybersecurity, number one, and then also, um, a resource crunch that's probably gonna happen with compute in, in the next year. There's really good reason why a lot of software probably has to be rewritten. We need it to run faster, to use fewer resources, because, like, if you want a laptop right next year, buy it now. Like it's just everything is getting very, very tight in the supply chains. And also that, uh, uh, it's just human software is just not secure enough.
David Senra 51:28 How do you make your own self maximally ambitious? Like are there other people that you're going to to learn? Like, okay, so I guess we'll back up because we talked about, um, you're, you're like, "Dude, I love the Sam Altman episode you did, but I had to skip over the first five minutes." But this is not something I'm prompting. So DHH comes on the show, and he's like, "Tobi nerd-sniped me. I didn't know anything about AI. I was dismissive, and now I'm like envious that I can't think about AI the way he does." I hear this from a million different founders, by the way, on and off the show. And then Sam Altman, I'm just fucking sitting with him before we start recording, he started bringing up Tobi, and the fact that he gets this insane-- Like he learns more about how CEOs and founders are using his product from you than anybody else, and you give him this crazy feedback. So like you're obviously-- people are looking to you, but like who are you learning this stuff from? Are there resources, specific people, companies, and like how are you making sure that the same advice you're giving to other people, don't-- like be maximally ambitious. How are you doing that for yourself?
Tobi Lütke 52:23 I-I'm extremely fortunate in that I think if you can create self-sustaining small groups like, uh, along those alliance. Like within Shopify, I just have, uh, groups of people where everyone is kind of at the same level, and it's like maybe there's the implicit, you're part of this particular club because you can keep up, and to keep up, you also have to contribute. So like there hasn't been a weekend this year that I basically didn't work throughout the entire weekend because like I-I just like-- I have zero ability at this point to stay away from progress, computers, and stuff like this. I don't know. I-I-I'm made for this moment. I-I think I, I didn't know this, but I-- like every decision I've made in my life pointed at this moment, uh, to be maximally prepared and useful. Um, but like I certainly think about it this way. Again, if you want to be successful in life, it's very simple. You just have to be too good to ignore, and there's opportunities. You got to be like amongst the first people to, that are being called when something interesting happens, or you need to be the obvious choice when a promotion, when, when a position-- Like it's be too good to ignore. That's, that's all. Like figure out your own way there. Um, that's up to you. That's a beautiful thing. There's millions of ways to do it, but be too good to ignore. Inside Shopify, I have like groups of people that I can talk to who are like way ahead, uh, of me on many, many things, and I can learn from them, and so on. So it becomes self-sustaining. These groups exist in many companies. A lot of people share what they know on X or in podcasts. Like, I mean, I-I-I unspooled close to the edge of my understanding, uh, earlier here, like the, the, the talk track of, um, insufficiently ambitious prompting, the underscore around implicit state machines, the, the, the fact that we have to move from productivity towards much more constrained systems through linting and through formal verification that circumscribe this problem space and which you want solved by the AI. You do all those kind of things, and you can outcompete everyone who doesn't understand them right now, right? So like there's a lot of sharing.
David Senra 54:22 Can you say more about the gap between the productivity of the people that do understand what you're saying and the people that do not?
Tobi Lütke 54:27 I think it's the biggest gap of productivity that's ever existed in any industry, even in variant time, probably. It's incomparable. It's a modern factory versus a- Medieval blacksmith kind of territory. There's so many zeros in terms of difference. Time has almost stopped being a concern. The variable is just how much are you willing to invest in terms of cost?
A weekend rewrite that used to take years
David Senra 54:51 Wait, I don't understand why time would stop being a concern.
Tobi Lütke 54:53 Again, it's called building factories. It's a dumb term, and it will be renamed. If you're having like an agentic factory that like really works well in the problem domain you're trying to solve problems in, you can make a decision on Friday, and you show up on, uh, like on, on, on Monday with production code. I'm not making this up. I literally just did this. Like I completely rewrote our entire-- like I mean, not entire thing, but like I-- and I rewrote, like it's a figurative like-
David Senra 55:21 [laughs]
Tobi Lütke 55:21 ... a term at this point, not to be taken literally.
David Senra 55:24 What was it?
Tobi Lütke 55:24 System of our, um, internal source repository system, um, that, uh, hosts all the code in Shopify called Better, um, sort of loosely based on a tool I shared called Wargate a while ago. Yeah, that's in production. Thousands and thousands of engineers, plus the rest of the company, everyone commits into this thing. It's like I had to update it because we are now, uh, merging pull requests at a rate which is like, I don't know, ten to a hundred times higher than it has been at any other point in history in the company because of the acceleration, so it needed to be faster. So it, now it's, now it's faster, and, uh, that was a weekend project, not a multi-year rewrite.
David Senra 56:00 Okay, so that was a weekend project. Five years ago, it would've been taking how long?
Tobi Lütke 56:05 I don't even know if you would do it because it's like, it's kind of why, like you, you would use GitHub. And, and the reason why you would use GitHub is because GitHub was perfectly good enough for the pace at which humans wrote code, which is like you work for weeks, and then you make a pull request. Maybe there's multiple pull requests at the same time, but it's like, it, it's bounded by the amount of engineers you have, and so the-- it, it never gets like that crazy. But now if you decide, I need to rewrite our entire database layer, the like, uh, system because I have this beautiful idea that can cause millions of lines of simplification in the systems that we then have to rewrite in Rust [chuckles] which is so like doing pre-work basically to make the next task cheaper and more solvable, then you can build all of that in a day. You would never, ever have done this because it's too hard. It's like it's a too hard thing because you, you'd have to find people with specialized skills to staff it. You would then have to keep them being a really, really jiving team for a year, um, and at the end, you get something that you then can check to figure out if your assumptions were right. It's like in a company that makes software for entrepreneurs and commerce and, and so on, that's too much of a side quest. But now it's like it's worth $2,000 of tokens, right? So.
David Senra 57:24 You just mentioned your mission. So DHH, uh, he said when he was on the show, so he's on the board of Shopify, and he says, "You should see some of these internal tools that they're building. It's like better than anything that I could buy," is what he, in his words.
Tobi Lütke 57:38 Yeah.
David Senra 57:38 And he was like begging for you to give the or sell them to him, right? How do you decide what of these tools you're gonna open source? What are you gonna keep for yourself? What could you sell as, you know, additional services to your customers?
Tobi Lütke 57:53 So Shopify's always been a internal tooling company, which makes sense because we are a tooling company, right? We make tools. We're toolmakers in Shopify. We make tools for entrepreneurs, therefore, we make tools for making tools for entrepreneurs. It's like very, very native to us. I think we talked about this before in an episode already. This culture of internal tools, it's a bit of a two-sided coin sometimes maybe because like we do put a lot of effort. It's, it's a very high-status thing in, in Shopify to work on internal tools. In every other company, as I understand it, it's not the best people on those. It's the hardship assignment inside of a company. It's usually maybe you get some interns, you put them on the internal tools.
David Senra 58:29 Oh, interns. Okay.
Tobi Lütke 58:29 Yes, yes, yes.
David Senra 58:30 And you're saying in Shopify-
Tobi Lütke 58:31 Yeah, in Shopify it's the opposite. So like, uh, maybe not quite the opposite, but like it's, it's some of the best, uh, engineers work on internal tools. We found this to be correct for us and easily worth it. So guess how prepared we were for the AI age because of this. Now we already have a culture of internal tools. We have all this infrastructure for internal toolmaking. AIs can now autocomplete basically every internal tool. Internal tools are wonderful to work on because you can just deploy them, and your colleagues say if it's any good, and if it isn't, you make changes, and if you need some downtime, who cares? Like, like production software is like, I mean, you need like four nines of uptime and whatnot and, uh, you know. I'll show you some stuff after the episode. I can easily blow your mind. It's like, it, it's again, the way Shopify feels internally right now, and I really, really hope this is true for everyone else who's so lucky to work in tech companies. It is magic. It is absolute magic. Like we are all kind of wizards conjuring up beautiful new things from almost from spells we cast into factories and agents and AIs, and like, it, it just, it is like I've never seen anything like this. I mean, I really hope that Florence, uh, Florence might have felt like this during the Renaissance, but I kind of don't even think so, right? Because it's just crazy. I think people have not fully priced in and understood how amazing things are going to get now. There's such a limiting factor that existed around software. There's so many creatives. Like we're gonna have a billion people easily who will make things with, uh, like on computers, and man, there is a lot of incredible brains and incredible minds that just cannot make things right now because they just don't have, they didn't have the skills until recently. But learning how to work with these systems is getting easier every day, and it involves using of language as, as main tool, and it will support any language. So it's not even like that you have to learn English first. It's such a positive thing for my mind, and we definitely have very much arrived in this sort of world. I think we are tracking very early, but my God, is it nice. Like we-- what we wanna do is we wanna like get our customers to be like the part of industry that's sort of experiencing this, uh, first, um, as well. So this is the, the products we are- Creating is like then first we create products for us because we need to understand the new tools that exist s- to a degree that we can play them like an instrument. And only after we've, like, figured out what works, what doesn't, does it make sense to productize it into our core products. Because otherwise it doesn't come from a point of fantastical insight. And I think software that doesn't come from a point of f- uh, fantastic depth of insight is transient, and there's too much of it. Like, it, it maybe worth a little bit for a moment, but it will always be replaced by once the sort of a beautiful hidden harmony behind all the tools that people have created has been spotted and then is taken as a core foundation on which then entirely new products are being built, and that moment is now, uh, rapidly arriving. Like I said, like, software will become fantastical, malleable, essentially bug-free, incredibly fast, just delightful in every way it can. People don't have to care about software. For people, it just has to work. But, like, the makers of the software should love it, uh, and be proud of what they built because otherwise there's no chance that people will like them, uh, like it, and it's not worthy of, uh, creating true fans, which is, I think, what great, great software does.
David Senra 1:02:07 Say more about the fact that you don't think how great things are gonna be is priced in.
Tobi Lütke 1:02:11 First of all, because the shape is going to change. Initially, I thought what would happen is first the quality of all existing software is just going to g- go up, again, bug-free, fast, no splash screens anymore, this kind of stuff. Again, this doesn't sound like much,
Why computers shouldn't make you feel bad
Tobi Lütke 1:02:23 but people love their computers when they're-- everything happens instantly, and they really, really dislike computers and usually feel it's their own fault somehow when everything's sluggish and they kind of can't accomplish things. When software is, like, too verbose and too complex, or you can't find where the feature is that you want. Like, if you ever been in, like, I don't know, Word, and you just sort of try to get the line, the page breaks right, and there's, like, some things that just, like, go to the next page, you don't quite know why. And, like, it's like people oddly never end up being mad at Word for that. People end up being-- thinking they are bad at computers, right? They, they internalize this. But then also that's a negative feeling, and then they don't want to use computers to solve problems, which I also understand because it made them feel bad. And, like, I don't think a computer should ever make anyone feel bad about themselves. If you want to throw a computer across the room or in a garbage bin or so, that is not your fault. That is the computer's fault. Now we can fix this and make things just that work, um, the way people want, and at worst you ask it the question, and it will help you. That is by itself will cause more people to accomplish their tasks at work and then potentially, due to much, much better, uh, experiences, be more ambitious, maybe in the off hours with their own projects, and that will also work. And then that might, um, lead to times where people might reach for, you know, the, the, the institution of entrepreneurship to, to, to make products that you can sell and that you can share with others. And I think, again, these are the things I want to see. That's my, like, entire philosophy and bias, so, um, I, I, I, I state those as the most important things to accomplish because they are the most important things for me.
David Senra 1:04:02 I'm gonna interrupt you 'cause what I love about you and why I like our conversations is because you're an evangelist for entrepreneurship, and the greatest definition of a business I ever heard actually came from Richard Branson, and he says, "All businesses is an idea that makes somebody else's life better."
Tobi Lütke 1:04:14 Mm-hmm.
David Senra 1:04:14 And so what you've just beautifully described for us is the fact that these tools, this new technology, uh, if you embrace it, it just allows you to make products that make other people's lives better.
Tobi Lütke 1:04:24 Yeah. I completely agree with what, um, uh, Richard said. The entrepreneurship part of it is essentially just saying, "Hey, I got something that I think is good enough to join the market with it," making it available through the wonders of the market to, um, the system that, A, shares it with everyone. Now, now once it's on the market, people can access it. They can exchange money for it to get, to gain, gain it, and of course, that money is a form of energy directed backwards at the person who created it, which then causes more of these products to be created, more iteration, better products, maybe a next version of it later. I just feel the need to appreciate the system more. I always, like, cringe when I see people talking about capitalism and stuff like this. Capitalism. The capitalism is not the point of it. Like, it's, it's free markets are the point, right? Like, it's-- capitalism is just sort of like a term that, like, usually is offered in by, by talking about the sort of small bits and pieces around the margins that, uh, the markets stop being free, usually in the form of monopoly or often regulations, frankly. Patents are monopolistic, right? Like, and, and, and disable the free markets. They might be worth it societally, especially for drugs, but nowhere else are they beneficial, and we still do them. Capitalism can go either way. Free humans are entrepreneurial in the form of putting things into a market. The quality of our lives is determined by how vibrant this market is and how many ideas and how many products and how many services are shared through it. And so it is our project on planet Earth as part of any nation, I believe, to cause the market to become more vibrant, right? Like, to make more products, to put them there, to create value, to take it out of the potentiality of, of a, of planet Earth and, uh, make it actually realizable. Then the market grows. We call this GDP growth, but really it's, it's energy growth. Because of all of it expanding, it means there's more opportunity, there's more story, there are more successful people that might speak to you as, uh, models, and you think you can potentially do the same thing as that person that you're, uh, observing. And as long as all these pieces fit together, man, are we in a good shape here. And I believe that almost anything that makes this flywheel go slower leads to less human thriving. Obviously, I'm very far now with my explanation out of the Overton window here of, like, how people tend to think about these markets. But am I wrong? And if I'm not, at least broadly- Why is the current narrative in media outside of your wonderful podcast and very few other places so different about this? Why are the people who are building and creating companies so maligned to the point of drumming up-
David Senra 1:07:17 Violence
Tobi Lütke 1:07:18 ... violence? Now, everyone has a different tolerance for these kind of things, and again, the economy is our collaborative multiplayer game, and, uh, the market is the thing that we're all trying to, uh, make go faster because it leads to more thriving, a more vibrant, uh, society. If the destination of this, like p- of participation, again, this moment of entrepreneurship, the moment where you declare, "I've got something that I'm going to try in the market," if that is starting to come just with too many downsides, especially in terms of bodily harm, man, like when we are gonna go into the time of maximally most distributed participatory potential, uh, and opportunities, uh, that probably planet Earth will ever see. More people could make companies and create products than at any... ever before, and so many people will opt out because, "Fuck, that's not worth it." I think that's dangerous, and I think benefits no one. The good news is I, I just looked at the Labor Bureau numbers. New business formation is at an all-time high. It is actually increasing, so right now things are looking good, but, like, I think there's a very, very, very, very troubling trends here that are just, like, very, very need to be reversed. Otherwise, this is gonna get... go poorly. It is so unbelievably important to just, like, spend a moment, like, celebrating the good parts of what's happening when anyone starts a company, small and, and, and big, and it's so important to tell the stories in a way that, like, I think they become relatable. Like, they're, like, they're all just like... All the entrepreneurs are just... They're just people. They decided to pick up a lot of skills along the way and putting this out there. They're just trying to make goods and services [laughs] for each other at the end of the day.
David Senra 1:09:02 That, that's my definition of entrepreneur: has idea, does them. As the first person on the receiving end of what you just said, and the main takeaway I hope that I took away and that I hope the people listening take away is that all you need to do is just use technology to build tools or products that make other people's lives better. As always, man, thanks for making the time.
Tobi Lütke 1:09:19 Thank you.
David Senra 1:09:20 I hope you enjoyed this episode. Please remember to subscribe wherever you're listening and leave a review, and make sure you listen to my other podcast, Founders. For almost a decade, I've obsessively read over 400 biographies of history's greatest entrepreneurs, searching for ideas that you can use in your work. Most of the guests you hear on this show first found me through Founders. [electronic buzzing] [camera shutter]
Episode duration: 1:09:42
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode w0oOxs0WKNk