By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
Hard ForkWhy GTA VI Is a Monumental Human Feat | Hard Fork
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
70 min read · 13,595 words- 0:00 – 34:54
What to know about G.T.A. VI
- MRMax Read
Grand Theft Auto VI is a cathedral. Look, I know it's been a busy week in tech news. Anthropic just went public. Jensen Huang wants to return to Nvidia. The technological infrastructure our entire country runs on seems to be crumbling in front of our eyes. I promise we'll get to all that stuff in this episode. But first, I wanna talk about GTA. Grand Theft Auto VI was released on Thursday to rapturous reviews and about one and a half billion dollars in pre-sales. It's being called a masterpiece and an astonishing American epic. Grown adults around the world stayed up till midnight to download it and cleared their schedules to play, all but weeping with praise over a game that's fairly described as a crime simulator with a South Park sense of humor. And you know what? I get it. It's been 13 years since the last Grand Theft Auto game. We've had three presidents in that time. There was a pandemic. They made computers that can talk to you. Throughout that time, nearly 5,000 people have been toiling at Rockstar Studios. Those countless hours of labor have now crystallized into 212 gigabytes of code, downloaded to PlayStations and Xboxes across the globe over the past week, that describe an enormous digital simulacrum of Miami. If a large language model is a statistical model of the world, GTA VI is a qualitative one. You can still steal cars, rob old ladies, and jump off buildings, but you can also adopt dogs, put up drywall, fall in love, buy your partner flowers, hold their hand. It's mesmerizing, strange, funny, and astonishing. All of this has been done, Rockstar says, without any AI assistance. This is what I mean when I call it a medieval cathedral, a generational project built by hand, stone by stone, asset by asset, rocket launcher by rocket launcher. I can't believe I'm saying this about an entertainment product with an in-game porn site called Booty Bang, but this is a monumental human achievement. And given the direction the video game industry and really all entertainment is headed, that probably makes GTA VI the last game of this scale made this way. Times reporter Joe Bernstein has had access to the game for three weeks now. I wanted to ask him, how did a game like this get made? Why does it have such a hold on our imaginations? And can I come over to play it on his PS5? I'm Max Read. This is Hard Fork. Welcome to Hard Fork. I am here, as usual, with Times tech reporter Erin Griffith.
- EGErin Griffith
Hello.
- MRMax Read
And today we're joined by journalist Mike Isaac, who is soon to start at The Atlantic, but is currently extremely unemployed. Hi, Mike.
- MIMike Isaac
Hello. [laughs]
- MRMax Read
And we're extremely excited to welcome Times reporter Joe Bernstein. Joe has spent the past several weeks living out a fantasy shared by millions of people around the world. He is one of a small handful of people with early access to the latest game in the Grand Theft Auto series. He's written a really smart and funny piece about it for The Times Magazine, and I wanna talk about this both because I am one of these insanely jealous people, but also because this game is a huge deal. It is, [laughs] frankly, a really monumental achievement. It's been 13 years since the last game, which was a huge, iconic blockbuster that people still play all the time. Some huge number of people, uh, helped to make it. It cost a, a small nation's GDP or so-
- EGErin Griffith
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
... we sort of suppose. Um, Joe, since you're one of the few people who has gotten to spend time with this game, and you also went to visit the headquarters of Rockstar, the company that makes GTA, in Edinburgh, could you tell me a little bit about the scale here, both in terms of the resources that went into it, but also the actual game itself?
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Sure, yeah. I mean, sometimes we think of video games as having, like, annual editions, like the new Madden or the new FIFA, the new Call of Duty. This is something, uh, rare. I mean, three presidential administrations since the last one, right?
- EGErin Griffith
[laughs]
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Uh, which came out in 2013. These Grand Theft Auto games are giant open worlds, meaning it's like a huge virtual environment that will be modeled after an American metro region. Uh, so the first one took place in Liberty City, which is New York City. Uh, some take place in Vice City, which is Miami, and the new one takes place in Vice City. Uh, several take place in a sort of satirical version of California.
- MRMax Read
Hmm.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
And the game they've made is astoundingly huge. So Rockstar... And a lot of this reporting, uh, comes from a great, uh, Bloomberg Businessweek piece by the games reporter Jason Schreier. Um, Rockstar staffed up, like doubled in size, something like that, to 5,000... nearly 5,000 employees to make this game.
- MRMax Read
Wow.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
And they're working on a scale that's enormous. Uh, this is in a huge open world that sort of encapsulates not just Miami... not just South Beach, but all of metro Miami, and then sort of like the South Florida of the mind.
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Uh, so, you know, everything from Parrot Head Keys life to, like, Florida Project, like greasy motels and oxycodone.
- MRMax Read
Yeah. [laughs]
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Um, it's just a really all-encompassing thing. Mike is nodding, like, uh, impressed.
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs] Sounds like my unemployment status.
- MRMax Read
So it's huge. It's, like, physically huge. You can run from one end of Miami to the o-
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Yeah
- MRMax Read
... and not just Miami, you can run from one end of Miami-Dade County to the other. But it's also, like, every single step along the way-
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Yeah
- MRMax Read
... there's a shop you can enter, there's a car you can steal, there's a dog you can pet. There's 60 different species of bird in this game.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Right, and not only that, like, you c- you're free to ignore a lot of that filigree. So, like, yeah, there's birds all over the place, and I haven't... Like, you just told me before we started the show that you can own a dog in the game, and I didn't even know that, and I've been playing it for, like, 50 hours.
- MRMax Read
I should say, not only can you own a dog in this game, this came up in the context of seeing a clip where a dog was riding a jet ski with the game's main character sitting behind him.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Amazing.
- MRMax Read
So it's not just that you can own a dog in the game.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
Mm-hmm.
- MRMax Read
The dog can be your friend. The dog can drive a jet ski.
- 34:54 – 49:32
The ongoing Nvidia scandal
- MRMax Read
Erin Griffith and soon-to-be Atlantic writer Mike Isaac, who is joining us from his unemployed headquarters where he's been playing through Elden Ring. We're not only going to talk about video games on this episode. We will be talking about the network outages that plagued the entire world this week, uh, and of course, uh, Nvidia and the ongoing saga of Jensen Huang. I wanna note here, I said we're not only talking about video games, but Nvidia, of course, is a graphics card company, and it furnished the guts of many, many gaming PCs, Xboxes, PlayStation 3s, Nintendo Switches. Mike, as a gamer, did you always expect Nvidia to be one of the richest and most powerful companies-
- JBJoseph Bernstein
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
... in the world?
- JBJoseph Bernstein
I feel vindicated for my lifelong obsession with this company because I used to have to save up all of my money to buy these graphics cards, which have inadvertently become the most valuable things [laughs] in the entire world. But it, they have been around for such a long time because of how important they were to the gaming industry.
- MRMax Read
I know. It's, it's funny that many people know what a, what a chip-making company even is, but it's because they were... That was the, the best possible cards you could get for your gaming PCs. Anyway, we're not really gonna talk about, uh, a- Nvidia GPUs from 20- 2007, though I'm sure Mike would be happy to do it at length.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
That's right.
- MRMax Read
Instead, we're gonna talk about, uh, the open C.E.O. position.
- EGErin Griffith
Yeah.
- MRMax Read
Uh, they have an interim C.E.O., and they've got, uh, presumably some internal candidates. There is one external candidate. That would be the businessman Jensen Huang, uh-
- EGErin Griffith
Oh, yeah
- MRMax Read
... who has-
- EGErin Griffith
He, he filled out an application on LinkedIn.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
Well, he, he, he, he put his name forward on Twitter. I'm gonna read what he said.
- JBJoseph Bernstein
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
Uh, "Since my departure, I've seen an outpouring of calls from Nvidia's employees, investors, business partners, and customers for me to return as C.E.O. If the board of directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as C.E.O."
- EGErin Griffith
Wow, bringing America into it.
- MRMax Read
[laughs] Yeah. Erin- Is this a real possibility? I mean, Sam Altman left and then ca- was forced out by the board and then came back at OpenAI.
- EGErin Griffith
I mean, I never wanna rule it out because, I mean, just a week ago, I think most commentators were saying, "Oh, Jensen will never be [laughs] fired," and then it happened, uh, very quickly that he resigned. Um, but you know, the, the comparisons to the Sam Altman blip have been kind of interesting because it is a very, very different situation. I mean, first of all, Sam was fired for what we later found out to be no reason, really-
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
... or no, no good reason.
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
And-
- MRMax Read
I think the official reason was that they... He was sort of a weird liar-
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
... and they didn't like that very much.
- EGErin Griffith
Right, not, not consistently candid. Um-
- MIMike Isaac
Bad vibes
- EGErin Griffith
... and, um, and, and Jensen, I think, went beyond, uh, being not consistently candid. You know, we've seen from reporting that he lied to the board, and-
- MRMax Read
Though to be fair, he was also not consistently candid.
- 49:32 – 56:25
What's up with all the network outages?
- MRMax Read
So while a bunch of investors and executives are arguing over who gets to run Nvidia, the rest of us have been stuck in airports, locked out of our email, unable to [laughs] use our banks. Uh, I'm just gonna run down a list of the companies and institutions that have faced major network issues over the past 10 days. On Thursday, Microsoft Outlook went down. On Friday, the FAA grounded every plane in the US over a communications outage. On Monday, Trace transactions were disrupted. That same day, United flights were stopped after a widespread system outage. On Tuesday, Apple Pay and iCloud went down. On, uh, later that day, a classified NSA network went down, which I don't believe affected me, but who could possibly say?
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
Did you guys get grounded? Were you stuck at airports or anything? Or were you, were you mostly unaffected?
- EGErin Griffith
Uh, I was, I was not. Um, maybe I just live too much of an analog life-
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
... or I'm just, like, a hermit, but-
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
... no, I personally wasn't. But-
- MIMike Isaac
I've been a cocoon of video games and unemployment, so I have-
- MRMax Read
Mm-hmm
- MIMike Isaac
... no idea what's going on.
- EGErin Griffith
What I have been doing, though, is I've been reading all these prepper guides that have been circulating.
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
Like how to prepare for, you know, if the grid goes down and what you should do. And I, I feel like half of them are AI-generated, but like-
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
... are you guys getting these in your feeds? 'Cause I'm like reading it like, "Oh, we gotta get more water," and like, "I gotta," you know? [laughs]
- MIMike Isaac
That is not my feed, actually. [laughs]
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
Well, I have been thinking about, like, one of the things is like, "You should get a landline." And I'm like, yeah, it would be great to have a landline for when all the, all the, you know, cellphone towers are down, but like, who would I call? There's no one-
- MRMax Read
[laughs]
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs]
- EGErin Griffith
... left to call. [laughs]
- MRMax Read
Let's the three of us get landlines and talk more often.
- MIMike Isaac
I was gonna say, let's just call each other.
- EGErin Griffith
I think I can.
- MRMax Read
I think that would be really nice. Whether or not everything goes down, I think it would just be, it would be nice of us to have a w-
- MIMike Isaac
[laughs]
- MRMax Read
... a couple weekly conversations on a landline.
- EGErin Griffith
I agree.
- 56:25 – 1:03:59
Anthropic's astounding I.P.O.
- MRMax Read
We're back with Aaron Griffith. We're recording this on Thursday, the day of Anthropic's IPO, just moments after stock began trading at, uh, 111.50 per share for a fully diluted valuation of more than $2 trillion. Aaron, my first question: Is that a lot of money?
- EGErin Griffith
[laughs] Well, you know, in the, in the grand context of how much has been dumped into the AI boom over the last four years, maybe not, but for a five-year-old startup going public, yes, that is an absurd, obscene amount of money, and it is going to be, you know, raining cash, um, all around San Francisco and Silicon Valley and, uh, maybe, you know, a data center near you. [laughs]
- MRMax Read
Um, w- what are your big takeaways from this IPO, from this figure and, and, and what you're seeing out there?
- EGErin Griffith
For one thing, they're defying all of the macroeconomic and geopolitical and kind of market jittery fears that have been swirling in the market and kind of, like, building on one another throughout the year. I mean, we had the fears of the AI, AI bubble and the infrastructure build-out. We had the midterms where, you know, the country basically said, "We don't like AI [laughs] or any of the people building it, and we especially hate data centers and the infrastructure that you need." And then we have this Nvidia scandal and Jensen Huang, uh, uh, getting ousted and, you know, a lot of questions around the, quote-unquote, "Fed chair" of the, um, of the AI boom. And so amid all of that, it seems a little bit insane that a five-year-old startup that, you know, came out of nowhere basically is now worth roughly $2 trillion and was able to raise m- uh, more than $200 billion from public market investors and is now trading on the stock market. So that piece of it is kind of what I'm marveling at this morning. [laughs]
- MRMax Read
Right. So it seems fair to say if there is an AI bubble, this IPO is not the thing that's going to pop it.
- EGErin Griffith
That is the open question. I'm kind of wondering if a lot of these public market investors who are just scrambling to get into this IPO, they are so excited to have the chance to invest in a pure-play IPO, like a, an LLM company that's the frontier lab at the cutting edge of this tech, um, if they're selling off all their other AI investments in order to pile into Anthropic. That's one thing I've kind of heard and wondered about. Unclear if that's the case or not, or if Anthropic is going to be kind of the, the rising tide that lifts all the other boats. Um, I don't really know. I, uh, I... Right now, investors are, you know, just kind of taking a victory lap and talking about how smart they were to get in on this company even though many of them, most of them passed on early opportunities to invest in Anthropic and then only piled in later when the company was obviously a, quote-unquote, "consensus bet," like it was an obvious winner. And, and now they're all, like, very excited and patting themselves on the back, and I think that's gonna continue, and a lot of them have, you know, invested even more in the IPO.
- MRMax Read
Mm-hmm.
- EGErin Griffith
So just from an investment perspective, it does seem like investors think the AI trade has a lot more room to go.
- MRMax Read
And what kinds of people are, are, and institutions are buying the stock today? Is the demand institutional? Is it retail? What are we seeing?
- EGErin Griffith
I mean, this is a very interesting piece of these mega IPOs that we're starting to see now. I mean, we saw this with SpaceX, and it's been kind of a continuing trend for a little while, but, you know, when a really big IPO that has a lot of name recognition, a lot of brand behind it- Obviously, Elon Musk is the prime example of this, but Anthropic and probably next year OpenAI as well will be. They are now trying to find ways to get retail investors bought in because they're the ones that are kind of promoting and talking about the stock on Reddit and kind of making it into, like, maybe a meme stock, maybe kind of borderline. But anyway, retail is an increasingly important component of any I.P.O. and any kind of public [laughs] market investment composition strategy, and so Anthropic did that as well. They've talked about how it's kind of part of their mission. They wanna bring everyone along because this is the age of miracles, and maybe we might all be out of jobs because of AI soon, so why not buy our stock?
- MRMax Read
[laughs] Um, you mentioned OpenAI. Uh, what do we think this tells us about the, their expectations and, uh, schedule for them to go public?
- EGErin Griffith
OpenAI is supposed to go public next year. Obviously, this shows there's a ton of demand for a pure play LLM frontier lab. Um, they're Anthropic's biggest competitor. I don't think the businesses are apples to apples. OpenAI has spent a lot of time and probably gone down some kind of dead ends with consumer-facing products, and Anthropic has focused on enterprise from the very beginning. And so they have a very strong business, and they're also, you know, maybe a little bit more efficient with their use of compute and their use of capital. So investors probably have a stronger case for why they're more excited about Anthropic, but, you know, OpenAI could also play into that retail and consumer piece of it as well. So yeah, they're, they're planning to go next year as far as I'm aware. Um, we'll see how the market shakes out.
- MRMax Read
I should mention by way of disclosure that The New York Times is suing OpenAI and Microsoft over alleged copyright violations related to the training of large language models. Okay, Erin, I think I have just one more question, which is looking at this I.P.O., $2 trillion, it's huge, does this feel like the machine god is coming, or [laughs] does this feel like a normal I.P.O.?
- EGErin Griffith
Th- this has actually been kind of a disorienting experience this morning. I've been talking to all these investors. I've been, you know, watching Dario's, uh, speech. He gave this speech, uh, before ringing the opening bell on NASDAQ this morning, and all of the conversation around it feels like, oh, this is a normal I.P.O. This is a normal tech company. I mean, at one point, Daniela did, uh, Daniela Amodei, the president, Dario's sister, did say something like, "We started this company because we care about safety. That's our main concern, and we don't believe... We believe this technology is different than other technology." But all the other conversations I'm seeing, you know, it's not about, uh, the machine god. It's all about A.R.R. and credit ratings and cash reserves and all of the normal stuff that you'd think about when you're talking about an enterprise tech company. So it has been a little bit disorienting that way because we also know that this mo- this morning, Jacob Coxon, the former Anthropic employee, is staging a protest in front of the Anthropic office in San Francisco, calling on the company to ban R.S.I. And there's this whole, you know, conversation basically started by Anthropic swirling around about how recursive self-improvement is potentially going to be the end of us all, and we're going to hand over our control of humanity. So it is extremely disorienting. Um, I, I am very much wondering how these earnings calls are going to go. Every time the founders have been asked about this kind of doomer and safety question, they have a very pat answer that I feel like has probably, you know, been coached by the, the bankers to say, like, "Yes, we, we care about safety, but back to our revenue and our growth." [laughs]
- MRMax Read
[laughs] Uh, all right, Erin, thank you so much for joining us to talk about, uh, a $2 trillion company that may or may not end the world. Um, this has been Hard Fork for this week. Uh, thank you for listening, uh, and we'll see you next week. [upbeat music]
Episode duration: 1:03:59
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode CaAKSCQiIrE