By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
The Jefferson Fisher PodcastFriendship Expert: Stop Asking People What They Do
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
EVERY SPOKEN WORD
95 min read · 19,496 words- 0:00 – 1:16
Asymmetric friendships and why adulthood makes friendship feel risky
- AGAdam Grant
Sociologists have found repeatedly that about half the people you name as friends do not see you as a friend back.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Really?
- AGAdam Grant
I thought this was depressing at first.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs] Yeah, that would crush me.
- AGAdam Grant
But what I've realized is we have different ideas of what friendship means. Um-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Tell me more about that.
- AGAdam Grant
Well, let's break down pals, allies, and companions.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
So allies are people you are pursuing goals with. Pals are people you have fun with. And then companions are the people you go deep with.
- JFJefferson Fisher
But-
- AGAdam Grant
I wouldn't want all your relationships to be companions. There's now a growing body of research showing that if you go to different friends for different things, some as allies, others as pals, others as companions, you actually are happier on average. What's interesting is the kinds of questions we ask people are gonna look different depending on what kind of bond we're trying to form. So if you wanna make an ally, one of the first things you could do is ask them, "What's one of the biggest goals you're trying to achieve this year?" If you're trying to make a pal, the first thing most people do is they ask, "What do you do?" Instead, try asking people, "What do you love to do?" And watch them light up. But what tends to be much more powerful is to skip the small talk and go right to deep talk. There's a whole series of questions that have been studied that actually help with accelerating deep talk.
- JFJefferson Fisher
How important is friction in friendships? Is constant contact good for a relationship? Should you make friends at work? How do you reconnect with a friendship you feel has gone stale?
- AGAdam Grant
I have three go-to habits for reconnecting. Number one is-
- 1:16 – 6:25
Why it’s harder to make friends now—and how success and envy complicate it
- JFJefferson Fisher
Is it harder to make friends than when we were kids?
- AGAdam Grant
I think it is.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
What do you think?
- JFJefferson Fisher
I think it's so much harder, man. Like, it is hard at this age to make friends period.
- AGAdam Grant
You don't seem like someone who would be lacking friends though, Jefferson.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Well, it's ... I think there's a big difference between acquaintances and friends. That's, to me, is the, the hard one. I have a lot of acquaintances. I don't know if I'd say I have a lot of, like, friends that are going to be there in those hard moments.
- AGAdam Grant
I'm sorry to hear that.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
I'm here, I'm here to help if I can.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right. Thank you. [laughs] Yeah. Okay. All right. Exactly.
- AGAdam Grant
Do I extend the offer of friendship now?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Can I, can I get your number now?
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
That's right. But I think it was, um ... Who did ... I, I overheard this the other day of, m- maybe it was Simon, of, of, of how you celebrate friends, right? The, the question is not, you know, the people you'd reach out when you're having a hard time, the peach- people you'd reach out to when you're having a, when you have a good win. You know? Who, who you're gonna give your good news to.
- AGAdam Grant
Hmm.
- JFJefferson Fisher
And I'd say I have very f- very few.
- AGAdam Grant
Why is that?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Um, oh, am I ... I think I'm on your podcast now. [laughs]
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
I'm on this podcast now already. Uh, because there is a sense of all these wonderful things that have happened in my life really quickly, uh, I'm talking like three years, and I feel like I'm ... I do know based on experience that I've, I've gotten judgmental reactions, and either jealousy or resentment, or I'm either traveling more, or I have this other good thing and this other person doesn't, and it just becomes you don't wanna share the good. And that, that's hard.
- AGAdam Grant
That is hard. I'm sorry to hear it. So I think there are two layers to this. One is, hey, for most people, particularly men, it becomes harder to make friends as we move from childhood to adulthood. And a lot of that is just about no longer being part of a big cohort of shared experiences.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
So you go through school with classmates, you sit through the same classes, you're on the same teams and the same clubs, and there's just a foundation of [laughs] like events that are gonna happen that, that bring you closer together.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And then as you get older, your cohort gets, it gets smaller and smaller, right? For you, it was probably much bigger at UT for college-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm
- AGAdam Grant
... than it was in law school.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And then you start your career, and the cohort is even smaller, and now you're kind of doing a, like an N equals one thing.
- 6:25 – 10:39
Defining friend vs acquaintance—and a tendency to rush into depth
- JFJefferson Fisher
Do you... Is there, um, I'm curious, is there a definition for you of, like, what's an acquaintance and who is a... Let me ask it differently. Is there a definition for you of who is an acquaintance versus who is a friend?
- AGAdam Grant
For me, a friend is somebody that it doesn't matter how much time has passed.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
We can pick up right where we left off.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
Could be months, could be years. Nobody puts, we don't put pressure on each other.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
To, like, "But I haven't heard from you in a whole week. Where are you?"
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
It's like, no, we, we know that this, this bond is solid, and we're there for each other if we need each other.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah. I had this thing, um, uh, at least that I've kept in my head for a while that I try to apply, is, like, if I can't go deep with you in conversation, we can be friendly, but we cannot be friends. Of, uh, if I can't really say the hard stuff of what's really happening outside of the, you know, uh, you're picking up kids from school and you see another dad, and all the other dads are in quarter zips and-
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
... you know, and they're, you know, "Well, how's it going?" "Oh, yeah," and all you talk about is kids or the weather, and then life goes on. And I know that's the same way for Sierra, and it's like, if I can't tell you what's really happening, we can be... I'll be friendly to you, but that doesn't necessarily mean we're gonna be friends.
- AGAdam Grant
I'm really glad I didn't wear a quarter zip today.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, [laughs] exactly. I wouldn't-
- AGAdam Grant
It would, it would've been disqualifying immediately.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs] Right. Exactly.
- AGAdam Grant
So that's interesting. So tell me if this is accurate.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Uh-huh.
- AGAdam Grant
It sounds to me like in, at least in my worldview, you've got, like you go really quickly to wanting to see if somebody could be a real companion.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And you're less oriented toward allies and pals.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Ooh, yeah. Um, I think I've changed in the last two years in particular, and through this whole experience, I've changed because, uh, it once thought was, if I know your name and w- we can smile when we see each other, then hey, we're, we're, we're pals.
- AGAdam Grant
Got it.
- JFJefferson Fisher
We're good, you know? And I feel like now I'll still have that, but I may not consider you one of my, like, my top five or my three of, like... Not like the MySpace top five, but, like, the-
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
You know, if something is really happening in my life, then, then I want to, or make sure I'm, I'm good with you. You know? How, how can I, I check that. You have this thing in your book. Uh, your book is Vibe: The Secrets of Strong Connections in a Lonely World, which is, uh, I really liked it.
- AGAdam Grant
Uh-
- JFJefferson Fisher
One thing I love about your writing is that it keeps it fresh like every other... One, you have the sections out, laid out really well, but then I feel like you hit just enough, like deep enough on each little topic that makes you feel like, like you're not droning on one area. It's like you're a professor who's done this for a long time.
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- 10:39 – 13:16
A three-part framework: allies, pals, and companions
- JFJefferson Fisher
And, uh, now I feel like that's such a big, uh, big difference in, in, uh, our life. Are there different types of friendships that we need to... Let me ask it differently. Should we consider everybody as either your acquaintance or a friendship, or is it really more nuanced than that?
- AGAdam Grant
Well, let's break down pals, allies, and companions.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, let's do that.
- AGAdam Grant
I, I think, I think a lot of people run into trouble because they mistake one for another. I found these are the three important roles that people can play in your life, and they're, they're not all the same.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
So allies are people that you basically are pursuing goals with. Um, so a great ally is a reliable collaborator. It's somebody who has complementary skills to yours.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
You would love to start a company together or volunteer together or basically say, "Yeah, I wanna be on a team with you."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
Pals are people you have fun with.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
These are the people who share your interests and hobbies.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Uh, you might play pickleball with them, go to karaoke with them, might, might even invite them on vacation-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... 'cause you think it would just be a blast to, to do whatever they decide would be exciting to do together.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And then companions are the people who you confide in. These are the people that you go deep with.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
These are the people that you'd seek emotional support from, that you might celebrate your big wins, but also would console you if you had a major loss.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And I think that, like kids actually learn about these early on. They don't necessarily have the language for them. But [laughs] you make allies when you do a group project together.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
You make pals at recess together. You find companions when you confess that you have a crush on a classmate to somebody-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... right?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And I think, to your point, the bar has just gone higher and higher for, okay, wait, but I really have to put myself out there if I want an ally and, and actually propose that we commit to something together-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm
- AGAdam Grant
... as opposed to the group project in school, which was over in a week.
- 13:16 – 17:17
Don’t make one person your everything—and handle mismatched expectations
- JFJefferson Fisher
Do you recommend of, like, how many people should be in what category? Like, would, would it be a bad sign if everybody was a companion kind of thing?
- AGAdam Grant
I don't know if it would be a bad sign. It might be exhausting.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
'Cause companion, companion relationships tend to be a little bit more emotionally taxing. Uh, you, you know, sometimes you're taking on the other person's burden-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... as your own. And so I wouldn't want all your relationships to be companions. And in fact, uh, there's, there's now a growing body of research showing that if you go to different friends for different things, some as allies, others as pals, others as companions, you actually are happier on average than if you put all your eggs in one basket.
- JFJefferson Fisher
In one friend.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah, exactly, 'cause then you are putting a lot of pressure on that friend to be everything to you all the time.
- JFJefferson Fisher
What's the downfall of if you make one friend everything to you?
- AGAdam Grant
Well, one, they may not be there when you need them. [laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Because you just need too much from them.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, y- uh, too idealistic.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah, or they move, and then you lost your best friend.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And then, well, what do, what do I do now?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Um, I think the other thing is, though, that sometimes it's, it's really hard to know what you want from each other. So psychologists find over and over again that a recipe for disappointment and even betrayal in a relationship is I think we're allies, pals, and companions, but you think we're only one or two. And then all of a sudden... This, this happened to me not too long ago. We had some, uh, some difficult health news in my family.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
And I shared it with somebody that I thought I was pretty close with, and his response was, "Oh, I'm really sorry. That sucks." And then he never mentioned it again. And-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... I, at first I felt like immediate unfriend. [laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right. Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
You, you are not friendship material.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
I'm gonna ghost you.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And now with the benefit of hindsight and, you know, having done all this research on the different kinds of connections we can have, I realize he was not good companion material for me. But it turns out he's a great pal. We have a blast playing tennis together. He's also been a really good ally. We've hosted a few events together, and he's extremely dependable.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
And I, like, I didn't have to ghost him. I didn't have to cut him out of my life.
- 17:17 – 19:09
The “next level” myth: great interactions don’t require ongoing bonds
- JFJefferson Fisher
You know what I don't like is when... It's usually some kind of school event or maybe some kind of, uh, public g- like, I don't know. You could call it a gala reception conference or something, and you're talking to somebody and they go, "Oh yeah, we should totally get the kids together, and we should totally-"
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
"... Oh yeah, let's, we should definitely do this." And you know there's no int- like, that's not gonna happen. They just say that knowing that you're probably never gonna see each other [laughs] again or never get together for, for that thing. Um-
- AGAdam Grant
It feels disingenuous.
- JFJefferson Fisher
It feels so disingenuous.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah.
- JFJefferson Fisher
And I'd rather you just say, "Hey man, it was so good to see you."
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah.
- JFJefferson Fisher
"Uh, hope, uh, have a great rest of the night." You know, I would rather that.
- AGAdam Grant
Well, I think people, they believe that it's, one, it's polite. [laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And they would be violating some kind of norm of decency if they didn't offer.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
But two, they think that there needs to be a natural ladder of connection that they climb up.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
Most people believe this, right? We, we think, "Okay, I met somebody. I had a pleasant conversation. Now how do we take this to the next level?" There doesn't need to be a next level.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs]
- AGAdam Grant
A great interaction does not mean-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... you need to have an ongoing relationship.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And some of those people, I think what's awkward about it is they're more than acquaintances now, because you're gonna see them again. If they're-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm
- AGAdam Grant
... you're h- h- like, if they, if they have kids at the same school that you do, or if their kids play the same sport you do, right? You're gonna run into them repeatedly.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
They think, "Well, that means we need to be allies, pals, or companions." I would say no, some of those people can just be associates.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
That's okay if it's a transactional relationship.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
You can enjoy each other's company. You can have pal-like interactions. You can feel like allies if you're, like if, if your kids are teammates and you're rooting for the team together.
- 19:09 – 21:06
Better questions for better bonds: stop asking ‘What do you do?’
- JFJefferson Fisher
If you wanna go kinda to the next level of a friendship of, you know, this is... I, I think I want to, uh, see them or talk more often or be better buddies, pals, whatever, is it on you or should you wait for them?
- AGAdam Grant
I think it, it depends on how much courage you have, right?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
What I, what I like a lot is to recognize that the kinds of questions we ask people are gonna look different depending on what kind of bond we're trying to form.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
So if you wanna make an ally, one of the first things you could do is ask them, "What's one of the biggest goals you're trying to achieve this year?" Or, "What's a problem you're trying to solve right now?" And then you'll immediately gain an understanding of what they're trying to accomplish, and you can look for ways to help them, and that's, that's a step toward allyship, right?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
We don't have to commit to doing something together. Um, I'm now trying to, to help you get where you're trying to go, and that's a little bit of a test of-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... are we compatible as allies? If you're trying to make a pal, like the first thing most people do when they meet a stranger is they ask, "What do you do?" What an alienating question.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs] Yeah. Yeah, yeah. What do you do?
- AGAdam Grant
Do you wanna talk about work outside of work?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
You better love your job.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
No. Instead of what do you do, try asking people, "What do you love to do?"
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And watch them light up. They'll tell you about their passions.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
You might hear about their favorite movie or book or, um, or a musician.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And then you've got an immediate opportunity to find common ground.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And then if you wanna become companions with someone, I think it's much easier to, to actually make yourself vulnerable than to impose on them. And so you might... [laughs] The, the research on this shows that if you tell somebody a mildly embarrassing story-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm
- AGAdam Grant
... uh, they feel trusted, and then they tend to reciprocate with one of their own.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, okay.
- AGAdam Grant
So that, that tends to work pretty well. I think another thing that, that people really naturally become companions around is favorite childhood memories or what was a, what was a family tradition that you loved.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Uh, you end up getting pretty real when you do that, and comparing notes on traditions, you think, "Oh, wow, like I'm, I'm now getting a window into your values, and I can see whether you're somebody that I, I might wanna have a deeper interaction with."
- 21:06 – 25:13
Frequency vs depth: ‘burstiness,’ space, and why constant contact can backfire
- JFJefferson Fisher
Do you have to see, do you have to see a friend all the time for there to be a close friendship?
- AGAdam Grant
No.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
No. We should kill... I think it's time to kill the myth that the frequency of interaction is what tells us how strong a connection is.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
Like closeness is not about how often we see each other, talk to each other, or text each other. It's not about the frequency of interaction. It's about the depth of connection.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
Those are two different things.
- JFJefferson Fisher
You talk, uh, in your book, The Vibe, on the burstiness of, of friendship. What is burstiness?
- AGAdam Grant
I-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Which I, I love, I love that word
- AGAdam Grant
... it's such a great image. So burstiness is a term that Anita Woolley and her colleagues coined, and it's... What it captures is that feeling that we, we have when we're in a... Well, actually, let me, let me back up a step and say-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... you will know burstiness as the feeling of energy and connection you have when you're on a great first date or when you're in a, an electric brainstorming session, and it just literally feels like the interaction is bursting with energy and ideas.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
So [laughs] what better term than burstiness for it?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
What I think people overlook is when you study how bursty people's interactions are, burstiness does not happen in continuous streams. It happens in sporadic interaction.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
So the burstiest software teams, for example, and sales teams, um, they're not in contact every single hour.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
They will have a great meeting or a great exchange, and then they might go several days or weeks without communicating at all. Because what's happening is they're going off and they're learning new things, they're solving problems, they're getting focused on deep work. And then when they come back needing their teammate's help or when they have an idea, they're, they're recharged and they're ready to go, and they're focusing their shared attention in one direction. And this is not limited to work teams. Friendship, um, I think friendship works the same way, right? I think that there's actually such a thing as catching up too often. It becomes mundane.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Catching up too often?
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
I mean, do-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... think about the people you see every day.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
Like, well, what, what are your highlights of yesterday? Well, since I last saw you, I walked the dog-
- 25:13 – 29:24
Long-distance closeness, weekly rituals, and a detour into gratitude vs contribution lists
- JFJefferson Fisher
I'm with you. So when... And is that... Let me ask this question. Is that just frequency, or is it also, like, location? If you live, like, is there hope for long distance relationships?
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah. There have been multiple studies of long distance relationships showing that on average, people in long distance relationships tend to feel a little bit closer emotionally-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Really?
- AGAdam Grant
... than people who live together.
- JFJefferson Fisher
No way.
- AGAdam Grant
And there's a little bit of selection bias there.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
Right? Because if your, if your relationship is on thin ice, you're probably not gonna, it's not gonna last long distance.
- JFJefferson Fisher
And you're not gonna do a survey on it. Yeah. [laughs]
- AGAdam Grant
No. You definitely wouldn't fill it out.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Uh, but you know, what happens is when people are, are living apart, they do miss each other more, and they also feel like our time together is precious. And so they tend to have deeper conversations.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
They tend to actually exchange, they tend to show more emotional intimacy, uh, because it feels a little bit fragile, and they wanna make the most of their time together. Now-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm
- AGAdam Grant
... this is not to say, like, if you live together, you should, like, you should just go a week without seeing each other.
- JFJefferson Fisher
See you.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah. [laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Then you're on a path to having a decreasingly significant other.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right, right, right.
- AGAdam Grant
But I think there, there is something to be said for time and space to maintain healthy relationships, and I think this is just, this is part of the fundamental wiring of human psychology. Uh, there, there are actually some great experiments that, that speak to this in a slightly different way, which is, so Jefferson, you were talking about going from, like, you and Sierra have a check-in every day-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... to every few days. Now it's every week.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
Um, something very similar holds for gratitude lists.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
There, there have been experiments now showing that if people are randomly assigned to write down the things they're grateful for every day, they get less of a happiness boost than if they just do the gratitude exercise once a week.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, okay.
- AGAdam Grant
It's a similar dynamic. You do the daily gratitude, and you're, you're kinda, you're grasping at straws. You're like, "All right. I'm grateful for my socks."
- 29:24 – 35:45
How to ‘vibe’: match the bond, add emotional intensity, and skip small talk
- JFJefferson Fisher
Let's go. Let's do it. Let's do it. Ab- absolutely. What, uh, does the science say in your research that makes people click or not click, when you vibe, so to speak?
- AGAdam Grant
Well, I think that a big part of vibing is being on the same wavelength, and so you and I have the same idea about what kind of connection we have or what kind of bond we're trying to form. And so if I'm trying to be your ally and you wanna be my pal, we're gonna be like ships passing in the night.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And I think a big part of being able to vibe with other people is we get on the same wavelength, and then we need to be in situations with emotional intensity. Uh-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Tell me more about that.
- AGAdam Grant
So a lot of people get together and they're like, "Okay, we wanna get to know each other better. Let's sit down for lunch or dinner." And that is not a high energy experience for most people to have.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
What we should be doing instead is something a little more active, something that makes us a little bit more vulnerable, but also gets our hearts racing together in unison. So in the research on this, it might be we go for a workout together. Uh-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, cool
- AGAdam Grant
... like, I wanna get to know you. Let's go for a run.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, yeah. Right, right.
- AGAdam Grant
Or let's go to the gym and lift. And what's great about that is if we don't hit it off, at least we still got a workout in.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs] Yeah. Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
It's very efficient, right?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right, right.
- AGAdam Grant
Uh, we might wanna go to a haunted house together. There's a, a hilarious experiment where, where people are just getting to know each other and they go to a haunted house, and afterward they feel closer, as long as they debrief the experience because they're comparing notes on the jump scares. They're like, "Yeah."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
"You know what?"
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
"I really felt that."
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs]
- AGAdam Grant
And now we feel like we have shared a unique experience together.
- JFJefferson Fisher
For anybody who says, "Let's go to a haunted house," that's how I know they're not going to be my friend.
- AGAdam Grant
You're out.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs] Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Done.
- JFJefferson Fisher
If they recommend a haunted house to me, I'm like, "Well, it's great to meet you." [laughs]
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs] You will ne- you will not be going back.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, yeah. So is it, uh, what I hear you saying is- Well, let me, uh, I wanna get some context to it. So there was somebody who connected me with somebody else. He was like, "Oh, hey, you need to meet this guy." Uh, immediately put us in a group chat. I go and have... He's, he's, uh, he and I text. He's like, "Let's do lunch." We do lunch, and we haven't talked since.
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- 35:45 – 42:16
Playful pal-bonding: hot dog debates, niche interests, and better icebreakers
- AGAdam Grant
My favorite question is, do you think a hot dog is a sandwich?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Ooh, that's a good one.
- AGAdam Grant
I mean, people, people have strong views on this. Where do you stand on it?
- JFJefferson Fisher
I'm... No, it's not. A hot dog is its own category.
- AGAdam Grant
Why? Is it, is it the wrong shape, or is it the fact that the, the bun is still attached?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Uh, to me, it's just, I'm just gonna put respect on its name. I just... It's a, it's a hot dog.
- AGAdam Grant
Oh.
- JFJefferson Fisher
It's not a, it's not a hamburger or a sandwich.
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
I don't know.
- AGAdam Grant
Wait, you think a hamburger is a sandwich?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Uh, no, I don't think it is. To me, a sandwich is two slices of bread that are separate that has some kinda something in between.
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs] Okay, wait, so-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Whereas a bun, it's not a bun, it's, you know.
- AGAdam Grant
Okay, so let me, let me, let me, let me take that one step further. So if I, if I cut off the connector in the hot dog, and now the, the, the top and bottom bun are separate-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... does it meet your sandwich definition?
- JFJefferson Fisher
What's a hoagie? Do we know what a hoagie is? I know that-
- AGAdam Grant
I think it's a kind of sandwich.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right. But now, now it's a-
- AGAdam Grant
But in a different sphere
- JFJefferson Fisher
... it's sort of a sub, right?
- AGAdam Grant
And what's a sub?
- JFJefferson Fisher
You know, I think like, uh-
- AGAdam Grant
I don't know
- JFJefferson Fisher
... I don't know either.
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
But I do know that you have a, a sub or, I love, I'm a fan of Jersey Mike's, you know, and they have, I don't know, a hoagie sub, cheese steak. I don't know. You're from Philly.
- AGAdam Grant
Those are subcategories of sandwich.
- JFJefferson Fisher
There we go. Are you a cheese steak fan, by the way?
- 42:16 – 51:58
Friction is underrated: conflict strengthens relationships when framed with care
- JFJefferson Fisher
It is. Um, friendships. Do you need... Let me ask this. How important is friction? I just hit my mic, so I'm gonna do it again. [laughs] I'm not gonna do that again. How important is friction in friendships?
- AGAdam Grant
Friction is underrated in friendships.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Underrated.
- AGAdam Grant
Most people avoid it. Yeah.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
I mean, this is, uh, this is how I, I think I first discovered your work actually, is-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, cool
- AGAdam Grant
... my wife sent me a reel you did on Instagram about how to have a difficult conversation with somebody.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, cool.
- AGAdam Grant
And she said, "This guy is brilliant."
- JFJefferson Fisher
That's cool.
- AGAdam Grant
"And he talks about, like, he, he has figured out through experience what takes you years to learn through research."
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs] Amazing.
- AGAdam Grant
And I was like, "Wait, wait. What are you saying here?"
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
But, um, but I think that it's so interesting. Most people see conflict as harmful to relationships.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
They think that if we fight, it's going to damage our connection.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And so we're gonna walk on eggshells. We're gonna keep the peace. We're gonna avoid doing anything that might, might even involve some disagreement.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And that is a huge mistake because a relationship in which you can't have any friction stops being a relationship. It's a charade.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, that's true. I feel like in every area of our life, but just as a general statement, like, your life has to have resistance. Like, you need resistance to, uh, to work out the, the way you handle things, and friendships is one of those that you have to have resistance.
- AGAdam Grant
Friendships, romantic relationships, collaborations at work too, if you never disagree with someone, best case scenario is you're stuck in group think.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
You're in such a deep filter bubble or echo chamber that you're not even thinking for yourself anymore.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And I think, you know, people, people talk a lot about wanting to have chemistry, and they forget that, [laughs] like... Well, actually, a better metaphor probably is harmony. Like, people, people think, "I wanna have harmony with others, and that means we're gonna get along all the time." No. Harmony is not you and me playing the exact same note on the exact same instrument. It is the pleasing arrangement of different tunes, different sounds.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
And it's not easy to have friction and keep it pleasing, right? [laughs]
- 51:58 – 1:02:44
Turning disagreement into resilience: ‘tensility,’ modeling conflict for kids, and conflict rituals
- JFJefferson Fisher
I get to be with. What, what, i- is there a science behind that feeling of we've done something hard together?
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah. I think Jane Dutton has called it the... She uses... Well, she has a couple terms for it, but Jane Dutton talks about the tensility of a relationship.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Tensility? Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
Tensility.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
Uh, I, I think resilience might be an easier-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right
- AGAdam Grant
... way to capture it.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Like a pencil, yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah. That, like, when a relationship has been stretched, and you've seen people under stress, when you have gone through a challenge together and overcome it, you believe in your carrying capacity to face other hard things and become closer through them.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And, you know, a lot of people don't do this. Like, they, they think they're gonna pick their battles, and they think they need to pick their battles, and so they avoid little conflicts until they blow up as big conflicts, and then those are, those are just disastrous to the relationship. They never practice having little disagreements. They never have the hot d- is the hot dog a sandwich fight?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Which is actually a great rehearsal for, how do we disagree but still enjoy each other's company as pals?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And how do we make sure we're still allies at the end of the day? Because we want to align on what our definition is.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And I think, I think that, like, we are, in some ways, we're a conflict il- illiterate society. We are... [clears throat] Like, I was... I, I mean, I grew up believing that, like, the more, the more your parents fight, the more likely they are to get divorced. That's empirically false.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Really?
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah. It's just not true.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
If you wanna predict the longevity of a marriage, it is not how often people argue, it's how constructively they argue that matters. And in fact, having frequent friendly disagreements is actually a recipe not only for a healthy marriage, but also for raising creative kids-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... it turns out. Uh, psychologists have studied what they call wobble, uh, which is when a, a family is, is kind of, like, seeming like it's teetering on, on an edge because people, like, you know, you sit down at dinner, and there's a big debate-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm
- AGAdam Grant
... about the news of the day. But what's happening is kids are learning to think for themselves, and they can't just assume that their parents always agree because their parents don't have all their fights behind closed doors. Their, their parents... Sorry. Yeah. Like, a lot of parents say, "We're gonna fight behind closed doors because we don't wanna stress the kids out." Guess what? You are teaching your kids then that arguing is bad for relationships. What parents should be doing is having constructive disagreements in front of their children and role modeling how to, how to say, "Look-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... like, we are two different human beings."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
"We are not on the same page all the time, and that is okay."
- 1:02:44 – 1:06:47
Motivational interviewing at home: acknowledging emotions and letting others persuade themselves
- JFJefferson Fisher
Um, and let's do this in a way that is, is going to smooth things and not escalate things. You know, one thing that's, uh, helped me with... So my kids, if they are complaining [laughs] or, uh, if my daughter's upset and, or like she's mad about something and she's pouting, of course, she does the, like one of these, and I'll be like, "Hey, can you, can you pout just a little bit more for me?"
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
That's what I'll say every time, and it always gets a laugh. Or-
- AGAdam Grant
That's hilarious
- JFJefferson Fisher
... or my son, he'll, you know, he's disappointed about something. I'm, I'm like, "Hey, I need you to be more disappointed. Can you look more disappointed, please?" And always it turns into a smile if I ask for more of how they're behaving. "Can you be uglier to me, please?"
- AGAdam Grant
[laughs]
- JFJefferson Fisher
And they, and every time it kinda shakes them out of it.
- AGAdam Grant
That is so clever. That is the best application I've ever seen of what psychologists call emotional acknowledgement.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh, tell me.
- AGAdam Grant
Well, normally when you, especially with your kids, but with anybody that you're in a relationship with, if you like them, if you care about them, and you see them show an unpleasant emotion, the first thing you wanna do is fix it or change it.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
But that usually, [laughs] that's an immediate way to, to piss them off-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right
- AGAdam Grant
... or to, yeah, to invite a lot of resistance.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And so emotional acknowledgement tends to work better. It's where I say, "Hey, Jefferson, um, you look a, a little bit frustrated right now."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
"Tell me more."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Okay.
- AGAdam Grant
Or like, "I noticed, [laughs] like I noticed a scowl."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, affirming those feelings.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah, exactly.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And, and validating that-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... which says, "Look, you know, it's okay to feel and even express those emotions. Now, let's talk about a more constructive way to deal with them."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
But you're, you're acknowledging the emotion at the same time that you're neutralizing it.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
That's very clever.
- 1:06:47 – 1:17:10
Work relationships: don’t force friendship—build allyship, mission, and real values
- JFJefferson Fisher
I wanna, um, switch gears for a little bit and talk about work and vibe. Make sure... Yeah, we're good on time. Should you, should you make friends at work?
- AGAdam Grant
Should you make friends at work? It depends.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah, I mean, I'm gonna answer this like any self-respecting social scientist would answer any question.
- JFJefferson Fisher
[laughs]
- AGAdam Grant
The answer is it depends.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, like any, any attorney.
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah. Uh, I think I would say that leaders shouldn't pressure people to be friends at work. I think this is a, a mistake that a lot of bosses make. They say like, "We're all friends here," or, "This company is a family." No, a company is not a family.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
You would not furlough your kids. You wouldn't fire your kids. When you call a workplace a family or when you say we're all gonna be friends, it creates an unrealistic expectation of unconditional love.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
It's not sustainable, right? A workplace-- I, I think I know what, what managers are trying to do when they deliver that message. They are trying to convey that we're gonna respect each other and care about each other. We are going to be a community.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
You're gonna belong here. But the family and friend metaphors are the wrong ones because with family and with friendships, the relationship is the only priority.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Ah, so we're not family, we're a community, and you, and you are welcome here.
- AGAdam Grant
Yes, and we're a community that cares deeply about strong relationships. We also care deeply about great results. And if you are building relationships but not getting results, you're not gonna be welcome to stay in this community, right? That's-- We have performance standards here.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
And so I think we need to be clear about that, and what that means for me is you do not need to be friends or family. You do not need to be pals or companions at work. You need to be allies first and foremost. That is-- That's the, the basis of the bond-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah
- AGAdam Grant
... is you and I are committed to a shared mission, and we've aligned on what are our core values that are necessary to subscribe to in order to advance that mission, which means we know exactly what behaviors are acceptable around here, what values uphold-- Excuse me. We know exactly what behaviors uphold our principles.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm-hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
We know exactly what actions would violate those principles. And once we're clear on that, then we can say, "Look, this is a, this is a collaboration where we are trying to bring out the best in each other." And if we like each other enough that we wanna hang out as pals, that's potentially okay. If we are in a situation where we care about each other enough that we wanna build a companion bond outside of work, that's okay too, but it's optional.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
It's not required.
- JFJefferson Fisher
So there are, um, I know there are people who are managers of people, bosses, supervisors listening and going, "Hey, I want the people that work for me to be friends," bec- That's the mindset they have. I, well, I want everybody to be friendly and, and get along. Should everybody at work get along?
- AGAdam Grant
The research on this, I think, is a little surprising. So if you look at the data, this is research on over twelve thousand work teams and also sports teams. What you see is that what's called task cohesion is more important than social cohesion.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Hmm.
- AGAdam Grant
So social cohesion is what most people think of when they think about cohesion. That's do we like each other? Do we have-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Going to a happy hour-
- AGAdam Grant
Yeah
- 1:17:10 – 1:34:12
Low-maintenance friendship, voice-based connection, and reconnecting dormant ties
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm. Should, should your friendships be high maintenance or low maintenance?
- AGAdam Grant
Depends on the friendship, I, I suppose. Uh, I-
- JFJefferson Fisher
If you had to pick
- AGAdam Grant
... I... Look, I think we all want more low maintenance friendships.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And I think that we walk around with a lot of guilt, feeling like if we don't spend enough time together, if we don't interact often enough-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right
- AGAdam Grant
... then we're, we're not being good friends, and we're letting others down, and I just think we need to relax our expectations. It's not always feasible to be the perfect friend to everybody in your life, and in fact, I think great friends are the people who understand that we're just going through a hard thing right now.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Mm.
- AGAdam Grant
Or we're really busy with family and work, and it's just a season where we don't have a lot of time for, you know, our pals or our companions, and when the seasons change, we'll be there for each other. I think some of my best, some of my closest friends, I actually have a, a tradition with, uh, with one of my best friends from college, Palmer. He started it. Uh, when we graduated, he said, "Okay, we're, we're going off to live in different states, eventually different countries, and we're just, like, you can't just walk over to each other's place anymore."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right.
- AGAdam Grant
"What are we gonna do about that?" [laughs] Like, "We don't live in the same dorm anymore. We don't, we're not roommates anymore."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah, yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
"How are we gonna manage that?" And he said, "Let's put a once a year or twice a year catch-up on our calendar, and you can reschedule it as many times as you want, but you have to reschedule it. You can't cancel it."
- JFJefferson Fisher
Oh. I like that.
- AGAdam Grant
"And we're just gonna agree it's always okay to reschedule, but we always have a future interaction that we've committed to." That, I think, has kept us close-
- JFJefferson Fisher
That's awesome
- AGAdam Grant
... for literally a quarter century. I haven't seen Palmer since before the pandemic.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And I know I can call him, text him, or even drop in at his house-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Right
- AGAdam Grant
... and he'll be happy to see me, and vice versa.
- JFJefferson Fisher
How important is it that our friends hear our voice rather than just sending the, the short text?
- AGAdam Grant
Oh, I love the research on this. So are you familiar with oxytocin?
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yes.
- AGAdam Grant
Okay, so-
- JFJefferson Fisher
Sort of like the caring, you know, portion.
- AGAdam Grant
Exactly. So I think neuroscientists call oxytocin the, sometimes it's called the love hormone or the care chemical.
- JFJefferson Fisher
Yeah.
- AGAdam Grant
And it turns out that oxytocin is released when we hear other people's voices-
Episode duration: 1:34:12
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode u5qH8AZCo2A