Skip to content
The Jefferson Fisher PodcastThe Jefferson Fisher Podcast

How to Handle Nervousness Before a Big Conversation

Let’s talk about nerves. I say this all the time—it is totally normal to feel nervous before a conversation. In fact, it's a good thing. It means you care. But what you do with that nervousness can completely change how the conversation goes. In this episode, I’m sharing three techniques I use myself and teach often—especially when people ask me how to stay calm, confident, and connected when it matters most. Whether you’ve got a big conversation coming up or just want to communicate with more ease, this one’s for you. This episode is sponsored by Cozy Earth. Upgrade Your Every Day. Get 40% off at cozyearth.com/jefferson or use code JEFFERSON at check out. https://cozyearth.com/pages/jefferson Relationships come with questions. Therapy comes with answers. Use my BetterHelp link for a discount on your first month of therapy. https://www.betterhelp.com/jeffersonfisher (Sponsored by BetterHelp) Order my new book, The Next Conversation, today! https://www.jeffersonfisher.com/book Suggest a topic or ask a question for me to answer on the show! https://www.jeffersonfisher.com/topic Want a FREE communication tip each week? Click here to join my newsletter. https://www.jeffersonfisher.com/newsletter Join my School of Communication. https://www.jeffersonfisher.com/membership Follow me on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/jefferson_fisher Follow me on TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justaskjefferson?lang=en Follow me on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/jeffersonfisher/

Jefferson Fisherhost
Apr 8, 202518mWatch on YouTube ↗

CHAPTERS

  1. 0:00 – 0:30

    Why pre-conversation nervousness is normal—and what this episode will solve

    Jefferson frames nervousness as a natural response before important conversations and tees up practical ways to handle it. He also sets the context for an early-morning recording during his book tour.

    • Nervousness before a big talk is normal and natural
    • Goal: reduce nerves and help the conversation go smoothly
    • Episode promises concrete, usable ideas
    • Context: early-morning recording while on book tour
  2. 0:30 – 1:30

    Quick housekeeping: subscribing, ratings, and why they matter

    He asks listeners to follow/subscribe and leave reviews, explaining how those signals help platforms recommend the show. He emphasizes that feedback helps him refine the content he delivers.

    • Many listeners don’t subscribe or review—he asks them to
    • Subscriptions signal “good content” to the platform
    • Ratings/reviews directly affect reach and growth
    • He reads reviews and uses them to improve the podcast
  3. 1:30 – 2:31

    Sponsor moment: Cozy Earth story from a book signing

    Jefferson shares an anecdote about a fan recognizing the Cozy Earth clothing he was wearing at a signing. He then gives the sponsor plug and discount code.

    • Listener recognized the sponsor brand in real life
    • He endorses Cozy Earth for comfort, especially when traveling
    • Provides URL and discount code for 40% off
    • Brief comedic beat: the whispered question at the event
  4. 2:31 – 3:01

    Community and coaching: his membership, calls, masterclass, and newsletter

    He explains his online membership and how it’s been growing organically. The episode’s topic comes directly from a question asked inside that community.

    • Membership includes two coaching calls and a monthly masterclass
    • He’s intentionally not “blasting” promotion; prefers organic growth
    • Newsletter delivers weekly conversation tools
    • Member question prompts today’s topic: handling nervousness
  5. 3:01 – 5:03

    Core premise: stop hiding emotions—‘tell them’ what you’re feeling

    Jefferson introduces the main guiding principle: verbalize the emotion you’re experiencing instead of concealing it. He argues that “keeping your cards close” breeds frustration, contempt, and poor relationships.

    • Nervousness is part of fight-or-flight
    • Hiding emotions increases frustration and victim mindset
    • Good communication requires naming feelings in the moment
    • Sharing emotions invites the other person to share theirs
  6. 5:03 – 5:33

    Share emotions without oversharing: ‘not a waterfall, be a well’

    He clarifies that openness doesn’t mean dumping everything at once. Instead, reveal what you feel in manageable pieces, one at a time, to keep the conversation steady and productive.

    • You don’t need to divulge secrets to be honest
    • Avoid overexplaining or flooding the other person
    • Offer feelings one at a time to keep control
    • Measured disclosure builds trust while maintaining boundaries
  7. 5:33 – 7:35

    Technique #1: ‘I can tell I’m feeling…’—claim it to control it

    He teaches a specific starter phrase for nervous conversations: “I can tell I’m feeling ___.” Naming the emotion reduces the chance you’ll act it out and increases your sense of control.

    • Use: “I can tell I’m nervous/upset/anxious…”
    • Naming emotions prevents reactive behavior (e.g., defensiveness)
    • ‘If you claim it out loud, you control it’
    • Puts the emotion ‘on the table’ as a shared reference point
  8. 7:35 – 9:07

    Why it works: co-regulation and reciprocity lower defenses

    Jefferson explains the interpersonal dynamic behind the phrase: people naturally soften and mirror calm when you show vulnerability. He uses a parenting analogy to illustrate how we instinctively help regulate others’ distress.

    • People tend to reciprocate openness with openness
    • Vulnerability often lowers the other person’s guard
    • Parenting analogy: you respond with care, not attack
    • Result: smoother, more collaborative conversation
  9. 9:07 – 10:38

    Story: the nervous attorney who wins the room by admitting it

    He describes an attorney who appears shy and nervous in court but becomes more persuasive by stating it openly. The admission makes others root for him, leveraging a common human tendency to support the underdog.

    • Admitting nervousness can increase credibility and support
    • Audiences instinctively root for someone who’s struggling honestly
    • Contrast: grandiose opponent vs. humble, vulnerable speaker
    • Lesson: the tactic works in everyday conversations too
  10. 10:38 – 11:08

    Real-life application: using ‘I can tell…’ with a teacher call

    Jefferson shares how a close friend used the technique during a sensitive call with her child’s teacher. The teacher responded reassuringly, immediately shifting the tone to problem-solving.

    • Friend opened with: “I can tell I’m nervous/uneasy…”
    • Other party responded with reassurance and willingness to talk
    • Demonstrates the technique’s practical reliability
    • Shows how it diffuses defensiveness quickly
  11. 11:08 – 14:40

    Technique #2: avoid ‘Don’t take this the wrong way, but…’—flip it

    He warns that telling someone not to take something the wrong way almost guarantees they will. Instead, he recommends a counterintuitive reframe: predict they might take it wrong, which triggers their desire to prove you wrong.

    • “Don’t take this the wrong way, but…” primes defensiveness
    • The word “but” often erases what came before it
    • Try: “You’re probably going to take this the wrong way…”
    • Leverages natural human contrarian/correcting instincts
  12. 14:40 – 17:11

    Technique #3: breathe, and lead with your ‘because’ (why you care)

    Jefferson ties nervousness to insufficient breathing and emphasizes breath as part of communication (including pauses and sighs). He reframes nervousness as evidence you care, then offers a simple lead-in: “I’m telling you this because…,” followed by the relationship or value at stake.

    • Breath and pauses are communication, not separate from it
    • Nervousness signals you care about the outcome/relationship
    • Use: “I’m telling you this because I care…”
    • Stating your motive helps lower defenses and invites reciprocity
  13. 17:11 – 18:45

    Wrap-up: the 3-part plan for calmer, smoother hard conversations

    He summarizes the three tools: name your feeling with “I can tell…,” avoid the “don’t take this wrong” phrasing by flipping it, and use breath plus a clear ‘because’ statement. He closes by reinforcing that nervousness is normal and the goal is mutual openness.

    • 1) “I can tell I’m feeling nervous…” to claim/control emotion
    • 2) Flip framing to reduce offended reactions
    • 3) Breathe and explain your motive: “I’m telling you this because…”
    • Outcome: fewer defenses, more shared ‘cards on the table,’ better talk

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.