Skip to content
The Joe Rogan ExperienceThe Joe Rogan Experience

Joe Rogan Experience #1423 - Andrew Doyle

Andrew Doyle is a British comedian, playwright, journalist, political satirist and is creator of the fictitious character Titania McGrath. The new book "Woke: A Guide to Social Justice" by Titania McGrath is now available: https://amzn.to/36X2GoG

Joe RoganhostAndrew DoyleguestGuestguest
Feb 5, 20202h 33mWatch on YouTube ↗

EVERY SPOKEN WORD

  1. 0:000:52

    Titania McGrath revealed: the persona behind the viral satire

    1. JR

      Three, two, one. This is your unveiling-

    2. AD

      Okay.

    3. JR

      ... because now people know.

    4. AD

      That people know, yep. That's it.

    5. JR

      That, first of all, Titiana.

    6. AD

      So, this is the- I should've chosen a, an easier name. Like, uh, no one can get... it's Titania.

    7. JR

      Titania?

    8. AD

      Because she's named after the queen of the fairies in Midsummer Night's Dream.

    9. JR

      Oh.

    10. AD

      But-

    11. JR

      Tell everybody your real name.

    12. AD

      ... my real name's Andrew Doyle.

    13. JR

      Do you have an issue with people now knowing-

    14. AD

      (laughs)

    15. JR

      ... that, uh, Tatiana or Tit- Titania? Titania? Doesn't-

    16. AD

      Titania's... yeah, she totally eclipsed me. I don't, like, I don't have-

    17. JR

      (laughs)

    18. AD

      I'm basically not alive anymore. It's all about her, you know?

    19. JR

      Oh! Well-

    20. AD

      It-

    21. JR

      ... I, I can't remember how I found out about you on Twitter, but just laughing really hard at something that you wrote. That was so close. You, you do such a good job of, like, blurring the line between outrageously woke and satire.

    22. AD

      Yeah, it's that thing of trying to-

    23. JR

      There you are.

    24. AD

      ... try... (sighs)

  2. 0:523:31

    How the satire works—and why people still fall for it

    1. JR

      Who's the girl?

    2. AD

      Trying to tr- oh, there! Okay. Yeah, so the girl is a composite of four different women-

    3. JR

      Well, that's good.

    4. AD

      ... put together, because I was worried about, you know, I don't wanna get sued or anything like that.

    5. JR

      Oh, for sure, yeah. So it's not-

    6. AD

      Um-

    7. JR

      ... a real human.

    8. AD

      But, you know-

    9. JR

      "Radical intersectionalist poet."

    10. AD

      That's it.

    11. JR

      (laughs) "Selfless and brave." Buy my book. (laughs)

    12. AD

      (laughs) But-

    13. JR

      "Activist healer." (laughs)

    14. AD

      (laughs) But also, I love that she's deadpan, 'cause it means that she sort of look- every time I post something, it's like there's this po-faced woman staring at you, daring you.

    15. JR

      Yes.

    16. AD

      "Don't you dare," sort of-

    17. JR

      (laughs)

    18. AD

      "... challenge me," or she could be mean in a way that I'm not. Uh, and so-

    19. JR

      Wow.

    20. AD

      ... that's kind of funny. You end up inhabiting this character who just isn't like you, and I do, I do end up thinking like her and, and, and, and-

    21. JR

      (laughs)

    22. AD

      ... and I even, I've even dreamt as her, and that sounds like a lie, but I have.

    23. JR

      Wow.

    24. AD

      So that's pretty scare- I, I ha- you know. Uh, she'll have to go eventually, 'cause I can't, like, I can't deal with that kind of... th- it's a psychosis, isn't it? It, it-

    25. JR

      Well, she's so big now. You have 420,000 followers.

    26. AD

      It's weird, 'cause it happened really quickly. I, I, I guess it's because there's a whole cohort of people out there who are just sick of this stuff, and they-

    27. JR

      Oh, yes.

    28. AD

      ... you know, and I d- well, it's partly that, but also partly 'cause people still fall for her all the time. People constantly think it's real, you know?

    29. JR

      Oh! All the time.

    30. AD

      All the time.

  3. 3:316:24

    Wokeness as pseudo-religion: purity tests, cancel culture, and no redemption

    1. AD

      Like, like, f- frighteningly so, to, to a point that it's, it's a cult-like behavior. It's like, it's, it's, it's... like, I think the, the basic principles of, you know, standing up against racism, sexism, homophobia, all that stuff, is great.

    2. JR

      Yes.

    3. AD

      Uh, I think the, the, the woke movement isn't that. It's a kind of weird cultish, uh, pseudo-religious thing that is beyond that. So that you're no longer allowed to make mistakes. You can't be redeemed. There's no-

    4. JR

      Right.

    5. AD

      ... there's no r- it's a, it's, it's, it's got all those hallmarks.

    6. JR

      Yes.

    7. AD

      You know? It's like when the early Christians used to burn people out of love, you know? It's that-

    8. JR

      (laughs)

    9. AD

      It's that thing. And that's why we get this kind of cancel culture stuff. And I guess that's why I wanna... (sighs) And maybe that's why it's popular, 'cause people are sick of, uh, treading around on eggshells, worried about being misinterpreted or even worried about fucking up and making a mistake. I mean, what's wrong with saying something that's... every now and then, maybe you do say the wrong thing, and-

    10. JR

      Well-

    11. AD

      ... um-

    12. JR

      ... it should be fine if you're a human being, but part of it is also that things are written down, right?

    13. AD

      Right.

    14. JR

      And then when things are written down, you can see them over and over again. If you made a mistake and just said something-

    15. AD

      Right.

    16. JR

      ... in normal human conversation, which is how we're supposed to communicate and how we normally communicate-

    17. AD

      Yeah.

    18. JR

      ... it just comes and goes.

    19. AD

      Yeah.

    20. JR

      You know? But when it's written down, then it becomes something different.

    21. AD

      But it's more than that, isn't it? Because it's, it... I'll give you an example. So there was a guy who was the editor of a, uh, cookery magazine in the UK. And a vegan freelance journalist emailed him saying, "I'd love to do a thing about vegans." And he replied and made some joke about, "Yeah, you can do something about how we all force-feed them meat and we'll make them eat each other and all..." Stupid, flippant thing.

    22. JR

      Right.

    23. AD

      Rather than saying, "I was really offended by that. Can we talk about it? I don't think that's appropriate for you to email a freelance journalist," she screenshot the thing, put it on Twitter, made a thing of it, and he had to step down. So I think-

    24. JR

      Wow.

    25. AD

      ... that's the difference, is w- whereas, like, saying to someone, "Look..." Calling out a mistake or calling someone out for something they've done that you perceive to be bad, that's, uh, that's all well and good. But when you're using it to advertise how virtuous you are-

    26. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    27. AD

      ... and, and how you, you're able to take someone down for the mistake that they made, that troubles me. 'Cause then it's no longer about, really about the issue.

    28. JR

      Well, I think what we're dealing with when it, when, when you're talking about woke culture, and I love that you made this comparison to radical religion, 'cause I think they're the same patterns.

    29. AD

      Right.

    30. JR

      I think human beings have patterns that they follow, and you could say that you're not religious, but you follow these extremely rigid ideologies that don't allow for any variation whatsoever. You-

  4. 6:2411:56

    Art under ideological enforcement: Rowling, Tarantino, and representation metrics

    1. AD

      Oh, yeah. And well, it happened with JK Rowling, didn't it?

    2. JR

      Yes.

    3. AD

      It happened with JK Rowling because she defended... It was a British case, it was the woman who, um, was fired from her job because she posted some tweets saying that she didn't believe that sex was a mutable characteristic. She said there are men and women and you can't change... Now, that's her opinion and she's entitled to have it. Uh, but the, the judge in the UK ruled that no, it's, that's not a legitimate opinion to hold and you can be fired for that. Right?

    4. JR

      (sighs)

    5. AD

      So JK Rowling simply said, "No, that's not fair. That's, it's her opinion." And they went for her.

    6. JR

      Yeah.

    7. AD

      Even though she's like, she's so woke, 'cause she keeps retrospectively deciding that her characters are gay and-

    8. JR

      (laughs)

    9. AD

      ... all sort of stuff like that.

    10. JR

      Yes.

    11. AD

      And, you know, D-Dumbledore's gay.

    12. JR

      Yes.

    13. AD

      And d- and she got, she got-

    14. JR

      They gone after her.

    15. AD

      They went after her before that as well, 'cause in the Fantastic Beasts sequel with Dumbledore as a young man, uh, there's not much overt homosexuality. And so the LGBTQ community was saying, "Why isn't it more..." I mean, what do they want? Like, double penetration? What do they want with that?

    16. JR

      Yes.

    17. AD

      Like, they, they want a full-on wizard gay sex scene.

    18. JR

      Uh-huh.

    19. AD

      And she got, she got the brunt of that.

    20. JR

      (laughs)

    21. AD

      You know? It's like, this doesn't... And I hate that sort of, I don't think, you don't need validation by seeing wizards making out. (laughs)

    22. JR

      Well, unless that's your vision. I mean, if her vision was, I mean, if she wanted some radical sexual aspect to her story.

    23. AD

      I don't think it was. (laughs)

    24. JR

      But if she wanted it... No, it wasn't.

    25. AD

      Yeah, if she wants to write wizard porn, that's fine. Yeah.

    26. JR

      I wouldn't... Yeah. I mean, if that's what you... Look. I mean, it doesn't even necessarily have to be porn. But, um, look, I don't think you should ever try to alter someone's artistic vision-

    27. AD

      Yeah.

    28. JR

      ... when someone is a genius like JK Rowling. I mean, think about the stuff that she's created.

    29. AD

      Yeah.

    30. JR

      Harry Po- look, the Harry Potter series speaks for itself-

  5. 11:5616:37

    Identity politics escalations: corporate fandom purity tests and superhero casting demands

    1. JR

      There was a, a crazy one that I, I'll send it to you, Jamie, 'cause I was sending it to a bunch of people, about them calling for, uh, Captain Marvel to step down. (laughs)

    2. AD

      Right. Okay. Why?

    3. JR

      Because, uh, let me find it for you. Hold on a second.

    4. AD

      (laughs)

    5. JR

      'Cause it's, it's so fucking ridiculous. They want Captain Marvel to step down and be replaced by a gay woman of color.

    6. AD

      Right.Yeah.

    7. JR

      Because, I don't, I mean, is that how the comic book was originally?

    8. AD

      Uh-

    9. JR

      Was the original comic book a gay woman?

    10. AD

      Well, so, no, I, I'm not a comic book fan, but I know that this is something that's particularly affected comic books, in terms of Thor-

    11. JR

      Here it is.

    12. AD

      ... and Iron Man. Oh, okay, yeah.

    13. JR

      "We need Brie Larson to step down from her role to prove she's an ally of social justice and ensure a gay woman of color plays the role. Let Monica, the original female and," all caps, "BLACK Captain Marvel instead of whitewashing characters for the benefit of the straight white men running Disney." First of all, Disney is run by a woman.

    14. AD

      Right, okay.

    15. JR

      This, this should be clarified. I'm almost positive the CEO of entertainment at Disney is a woman.

    16. AD

      Is that right?

    17. JR

      Find out the... Pretty sure that's true. Yeah.

    18. AD

      They've still got Walt on ice though, haven't they? He's still-

    19. JR

      Yeah, they haven't had-

    20. AD

      ... there in the cabinet. Right, okay.

    21. JR

      ... released-

    22. AD

      (laughs)

    23. JR

      Is that-

    24. GU

      Bob Iger.

    25. JR

      No, but the, the entertainment CEO of, uh, there's someone who runs the film division. Whitney Cummings is explaining it to me about how ridiculous it is.

    26. AD

      But isn't Brie Larson-

    27. JR

      Who makes, whoever makes the decisions.

    28. AD

      Isn't Brie Larson super woke? Like, she's got a reputation of being incredibly woke.

    29. JR

      Not woke enough if you're white.

    30. AD

      But she was the one who said that she wanted to ban male journalists from her press junkets and from her-

  6. 16:3721:32

    Comedy, censorship, and the ‘punching down’ debate

    1. AD

      But then, yeah, so you can't argue with them. I thought maybe satire would be a good approach that, you know, because if they're not prepared to listen to reason, you can mock them.

    2. JR

      Right.

    3. AD

      Right? I thought that would be a good... But it just makes them really angry. Uh, you know, I've get... I've had so much venom for mocking this, this... But, but of course when you mock the priests, they, they, they get angry.

    4. JR

      Yes.

    5. AD

      Yeah, that- that- that's the point.

    6. JR

      Yes. And they don't feel like you have any right to make fun. Which is, for me as a comedian, one of the most offensive things a person could say.

    7. AD

      Right. It also makes you wanna do it more, right?

    8. JR

      Of course. (laughs)

    9. AD

      (laughs) Yeah.

    10. JR

      Yeah. It's, that's what it's about.

    11. AD

      Yeah.

    12. JR

      We're, we're the, the mockery police.

    13. AD

      Yeah.

    14. JR

      We come in and mock when things are fucked up.

    15. AD

      But then because they believe in the power structures, what they're saying is you're punching down.

    16. JR

      Down.

    17. AD

      Right, you're punching down. But-

    18. JR

      But arguably with woke people, you're not punching down.

    19. AD

      You're not.

    20. JR

      No.

    21. AD

      That's always been my argument, you see.

    22. JR

      Yeah.

    23. AD

      'Cause for one thing, I think you can punch down if you want.

    24. JR

      Sure.

    25. AD

      You know, who's, who gets to say? But I think the, the, the woke people have incredible power.

    26. JR

      And they're bullies.

    27. AD

      And they're bullies.

    28. JR

      They, they pile-

    29. AD

      They are.

    30. JR

      ... up together.

  7. 21:3227:59

    UK vs US speech climates: ‘unsafe’ jokes, self-censorship, and career risk

    1. AD

      You know, it's those, it's those younger comics, right? Who, who are coming up and they self-censor because they're worried about what they're gonna say. You know, that's-

    2. JR

      Right.

    3. AD

      ... that's basically what it is. I mean, I had an argument with a young comic and, uh, and she said to me, "You know, you don't understand because I go up to comics... I have to go up to comics every night after they're set and explain to them why they shouldn't tell these jokes and why they, they..." You know, this was a serious conversation. And I thought, "This isn't for you."

    4. JR

      And she was a comic?

    5. AD

      Yeah. Standup, yeah.

    6. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    7. AD

      This was a... This was a comic in a group. So I, I used to run this like, uh, workshop for young, young standups, and I can't do it anymore-

    8. JR

      (laughs)

    9. AD

      ... because one of them complained... This is serious, right? So like, one of them complained to the boss, the b- the b... It's a very famous theater in London. And, and one of them complained and said that the, one of the jokes I'd tweeted as Titania made her feel unsafe. And then therefore, I was told I couldn't, I couldn't do this course anymore because I'd developed an unsafe environment.

    10. JR

      Oh, you made them feel unsafe?

    11. AD

      Yeah.

    12. JR

      Hm.

    13. AD

      By a joke.

    14. JR

      Dangerous.

    15. AD

      That wasn't even mine, it was Titania, it was a character.

    16. JR

      Must've been a great joke. You're really-

    17. AD

      It was probably a fucking great joke, yeah.

    18. JR

      So good you made someone feel unsafe?

    19. AD

      Yeah.

    20. JR

      Like, they were laughing so hard?

    21. AD

      Yeah.

    22. JR

      They're like, "I could die."

    23. AD

      Yeah. (laughs)

    24. JR

      "I could die from laughter."

    25. AD

      But that's that conflation of words and violence, isn't it? This idea that, that, that-

    26. JR

      That is a problem.

    27. AD

      I- and I think... What really scares me about that is I think they believe it.

    28. JR

      It's disingenuous. Yeah.

    29. AD

      Do you think it's disingenuous?

    30. JR

      It's clearly disingenuous, but it's the, the orthodoxy, right? Like, this is, this is what they're pushing.

  8. 27:5941:43

    Politics and the culture war: why ‘woke’ messaging shifts elections

    1. JR

      Well, it's a shift over the last few years, and it's the reason why Trump is in office.

    2. AD

      Yeah. 100% it is. This is, this is why when people tell me, "Oh, the culture war is like a sideshow, it doesn't matter," I'm like, "It wins and loses elections, this stuff." You know? Like-

    3. JR

      It's not a sideshow.

    4. AD

      It really isn't.

    5. JR

      No.

    6. AD

      Like, you know, when, what was it the other day, it was Eliza- Elizabeth Warren saying that she's gonna get a trans stu- pupil, like a 15-year-old to, to veto her, one of her, um, uh, appointees, right?

    7. JR

      Was it Secretary of Education?

    8. AD

      Some- yeah, something like that, something like that.

    9. JR

      Something like that.

    10. AD

      But it-

    11. JR

      But it was a nine-year-old.

    12. AD

      Oh, was it a nine-year-old? I thought it was like a 15-year-old.

    13. JR

      Uh, I'll go pull, pull that up, see we can find-

    14. AD

      I mean, either way, that's not good, right?

    15. JR

      No, either way it's not good. It's madness.

    16. AD

      It's, and most people think that's madness, and most people think it's weird. Like, in the UK, Jeremy Corbyn started announcing his pronouns.

    17. JR

      Yes, I saw. (laughs)

    18. AD

      Let me tell you, I don't know if you know what Jeremy Corbyn looks like. No one's confused about his pronouns.

    19. JR

      I know.

    20. AD

      No one has ever been confused about it.

    21. JR

      He's got a fucking beard.

    22. AD

      (laughs) He's g- women can have beards? What are you saying?

    23. JR

      Oh, I didn't know.

    24. AD

      They get-

    25. JR

      They also, uh, can have penises and men can have their period.

    26. AD

      Yeah, but Jeremy Corbyn's never identified as a woman as far as I'm aware. (laughs)

    27. JR

      It's so dumb.

    28. AD

      You know, it doesn't fit with also that old school socialist, 'cause he's proper old school lefty socialist.

    29. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    30. AD

      The woke stuff doesn't fit well with those people.

  9. 41:431:00:23

    LGBT acronym politics and internal contradictions

    1. JR

      And this is what the woke people are doing. Every, no one can be woke enough. I mean, Martina Navratilova-

    2. AD

      Yeah, I know.

    3. JR

      ... they went after her.

    4. AD

      Yeah.

    5. JR

      F- she's a lesbian.

    6. AD

      No, but she-

    7. JR

      But she's not woke enough-

    8. AD

      Wh-

    9. JR

      ... because she doesn't want trans women to compete in sports and dominate and win world records.

    10. AD

      So she shouldn't be part of that community anymore. You see, I've got a real problem with the, the whole acronym thing, the L-

    11. JR

      Yes.

    12. AD

      ... the LGBTQIA+ or whatever it is at the moment, because it keeps getting longer-

    13. JR

      It keeps going. It's, it's, but I love it.

    14. AD

      I, I-

    15. JR

      I want it to get longer.

    16. AD

      What is it now? It's lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersexual, asexual.

    17. JR

      Yeah. And what's the plus?

    18. AD

      And then- the plus is whatever fucker we've forgotten, basically.

    19. JR

      Aliens. (laughs)

    20. AD

      Uh, like, whatever- whatever isn't there, yeah. Um, who the fuck knows? I mean, I- I- I- see that as... For a start, there's massive internal contradictions within that.

    21. JR

      Yes.

    22. AD

      Like, we're seeing this at the moment with sort of lesbian- lesbians versus trans people-

    23. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    24. AD

      ... and gay rights versus trans rights, women's rights versus-

    25. JR

      Mm-hmm.

    26. AD

      You know, that's not a coherent... It's not like those people are all the same.

    27. JR

      It's a weird gang.

    28. AD

      It's- it's a gang that doesn't get on with itself.

    29. JR

      Right. Exactly. Yeah.

    30. AD

      They also, that's why Dave Chappelle's bit about that was really good-

  10. 1:00:231:06:12

    Surveillance and reputational scoring: hiring software and ‘liked tweet’ audits

    1. GU

      There's a ... While you guys are talking about this, I found a story that happened last week, um-This was a tweet that I, I've kinda gone through it to verify it a little bit. I don't wanna say it's a 100% accurate.

    2. AD

      Okay.

    3. GU

      But this guy got a job interview and I guess he signed up and they found this on his, on their own. He said he did not give them his information. They sent him 351 pages of every tweet he ever liked that had the word "fuck" in it.

    4. AD

      Wow.

    5. JR

      He said, "I had to get a background check for my job and it turns out the report is a 300 plus page PDF of every single tweet I've ever liked, liked, with the word 'fuck' in it. Enjoy your dystopian BS."

    6. GU

      It's like there's a bunch of tweets showing up.

    7. JR

      Waves.

    8. GU

      But I, I looked up the company that does this.

    9. JR

      Hold on, go back.

    10. GU

      Sorry.

    11. JR

      What does it say? "Update: I came home to a package containing a printout of all 351 pages of it. Obviously, the dystopia cares about wasting paper."

    12. GU

      Here's like a for instance of what it looked like.

    13. AD

      And have they used this to justify not giving him the job? Is that the idea?

    14. JR

      I don't know.

    15. GU

      I don't know what happened after that.

    16. AD

      Right. Okay. Okay.

    17. JR

      He, he liked this tweet, "Merry Christmas to the toddler I saw running across Trader Joe's with a giant bottle of peppermint vodka and Mom running after him like, 'No, no, no, no, no, no, no.' Only."

    18. AD

      So flagged type, bad. Flagged reason, alcohol.

    19. JR

      Yeah.

    20. AD

      Post type, liked.

    21. JR

      Yeah. So they, they changed what he was saying.

    22. AD

      Right.

    23. JR

      He's, he's making a joke about a toddler that he saw running across Trader Joe's with a giant bottle of peppermint vodka that it had taken from its mom, and the mom was like, "No, no, no, no. Give me that, give me that, give me that." So they flagged it because the- there was alcohol in it. The baby had a bottle of alcohol. There's nothing offensive about that whatsoever.

    24. AD

      I don't-

    25. JR

      It's-

    26. AD

      I actually don't understand why that would be an issue.

    27. JR

      Because they want you to be scared as fuck. They wanna be able to control your thinking and they don't want you to ever do anything that could c- come back to hurt the company in any way and, and, and mess with their bottom line. I mean, that is crazy.

    28. AD

      But even liking a tweet-

    29. JR

      Yeah, like-

    30. AD

      Not, not just writing the tweet, but liking.

Episode duration: 2:33:01

Install uListen for AI-powered chat & search across the full episode — Get Full Transcript

Transcript of episode NIxhH85cQMY

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.