Skip to content

By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.

The Joe Rogan ExperienceThe Joe Rogan Experience

Joe Rogan Experience #2500 - Scott Horton

Scott Horton is the director of the Libertarian Institute, host of “The Scott Horton Show,” co-host of “Provoked” with Darryl Cooper, and author of several books, the most recent of which is “Provoked: How Washington Started the New Cold…

Joe RoganhostScott Hortonguest
May 15, 20262h 35mWatch on YouTube

Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.

Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.

uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.

See how

Partial transcript

0:00 – 0:02

Intro

Joe Rogan 0:00 [upbeat music]

0:02 – 3:50

Studio warm-up: audio setup, gifts, and media nostalgia

Joe Rogan 0:02 Joe Rogan Podcast, check it out. The Joe Rogan Experience. Train by day, Joe Rogan Podcast by night. All day. [upbeat music]

Scott Horton 0:13 Do I sound okay? Check, check, check.

Joe Rogan 0:15 You sound great.

Scott Horton 0:15 This is my normal complaint volume right out of-

Joe Rogan 0:17 Are you one of those one ear on-

Scott Horton 0:18 Yeah

Joe Rogan 0:18 ... one ear off guys?

Scott Horton 0:19 Yeah, my right ear hurts a lot from-

Joe Rogan 0:21 Ah

Scott Horton 0:21 ... years of this.

Joe Rogan 0:22 There's a volume-

Scott Horton 0:22 And so I usually just leave it off.

Joe Rogan 0:24 There's a volume adjuster thing too, so if, if it's too loud-

Scott Horton 0:26 Oh, that's nice

Joe Rogan 0:26 ... you can turn it up or turn it down.

Scott Horton 0:28 You sound good.

Joe Rogan 0:29 What's, uh-

Scott Horton 0:29 But no, it's just, I have a pain in my right ear, so I try not to antagonize it.

Joe Rogan 0:32 And thank you very much for the gift, ladies and gentlemen. Scott Horton gave me a professorial pipe. And, uh, like I was saying-

Scott Horton 0:39 Awesome

Joe Rogan 0:39 ... Metzger uses a pipe now because of you.

Scott Horton 0:42 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 0:42 Like, he, he-

Scott Horton 0:42 I love that guy.

Joe Rogan 0:43 He's the best. [laughs]

Scott Horton 0:44 He's so funny, dude.

Joe Rogan 0:45 He's such a nut. When he corners you-

Scott Horton 0:46 He comes into the room, he just blows the room away.

Joe Rogan 0:49 Yeah.

Scott Horton 0:50 He, he's just a force in there. It's incredible.

Joe Rogan 0:52 And he's a giant dude, so he like-

Scott Horton 0:53 Yeah

Joe Rogan 0:53 ... lu- hovers over you, like, "Oh, you didn't know? You don't know about this?"

Scott Horton 0:56 Yeah. [laughs]

Joe Rogan 0:57 And then he just hits you with 15 conspiracies in a row, rapid fire, with-

Scott Horton 1:00 So good

Joe Rogan 1:01 ... yeah, with no breaks in between them. So, uh, thanks for doing this, man. Um-

Scott Horton 1:05 Yeah, thanks for having me. Good to be here

Joe Rogan 1:06 ... we have a great mutual friend in Dave Smith. He recommends you highly.

Scott Horton 1:10 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:10 So I'm glad we could finally do this. I wish there was more going on in the world right now we could talk about, though.

Scott Horton 1:15 I know.

Joe Rogan 1:15 Just seems like everything's so calm-

Scott Horton 1:16 We'll just have to go back over-

Joe Rogan 1:17 ... and peaceful

Scott Horton 1:17 ... Vietnam or something, you know?

Joe Rogan 1:18 Yeah, yeah, some, the old stuff, back when we didn't know any better. [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:23 It's, uh, kind of a mess.

Joe Rogan 1:24 Yeah. Um, I've seen you argue on television, like, 1,000 times. Do you enjoy, like, that Piers Morgan-type chaos?

Scott Horton 1:34 No, no.

Joe Rogan 1:34 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:35 Um, in fact, I just got back from England. I got invited to do the Oxford debate, which I lost, on Ukraine. Um-

Joe Rogan 1:43 Oh

Scott Horton 1:43 ... but then I invited myself on Piers Morgan Live as long as I was in town. And I-

Joe Rogan 1:48 When you say you lost the debate, is that because the people voted that were in the audience?

Scott Horton 1:52 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:52 All those people with Ukraine flags? [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:55 Well, they didn't have Ukraine flags that ti- I think someone showed a old picture or something.

Joe Rogan 1:58 Oh, well, that doesn't surprise-

Scott Horton 1:59 But yeah, same crowd. So what happened was, yeah, when they leave, they either leave through the yes door or the no door, and the yeses had it, which was unbelievable to me, but, uh-

Joe Rogan 2:08 Yeah

Scott Horton 2:08 ... not that I did my very best job.

Joe Rogan 2:10 Well, so-

Scott Horton 2:10 But on, on Piers Morgan, I was trying to get myself just a interview so I could just talk to him about some things, and instead, they just prefer that format where you gotta mix it up with a guy, which I can do that, too, you know?

Joe Rogan 2:22 Yeah. The interview thing is way better. The, the thing that he does, though, is really good for engagement. He's very smart.

Scott Horton 2:30 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:30 Like, Piers has done ... He's mastered it. He's taken, like, the Jerry Springer-type format and thrown it into the world of politics and, and any other social issue that's going on.

Scott Horton 2:41 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:41 But-

Scott Horton 2:41 But it is, too, like, um, years ago, the guy from antiwar.com can't be on TV.

Joe Rogan 2:47 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 2:47 But we can be on his show. He doesn't care. He's cool with it. I mean, I guess same thing here-

Joe Rogan 2:51 Yeah

Scott Horton 2:51 ... where it's, that's, is a big change from how things used to be. We just had this whole separate conversation going on below the higher one, where he has reach, you know, up and down the chain, I guess, is a way to put it.

Joe Rogan 3:03 Is he on TV-TV, or is it just YouTube?

Scott Horton 3:05 No, but he just has massive-

Joe Rogan 3:06 Yeah, massive

Scott Horton 3:06 ... viewership, so it counts, I guess.

Joe Rogan 3:08 TV-TV is actually a hindrance now, 'cause the only p- way people watch TV-TV is clips that someone takes and puts on X-

Scott Horton 3:15 Right

Joe Rogan 3:15 ... or YouTube. That's it.

Scott Horton 3:16 Or, or they just see it accidentally. It's just on. It happens to be on when they're in the room or whatever, but.

Joe Rogan 3:21 What a fucking dying market. Like, imagine if you're in broadcast television right now, and you're just thinking, like, "Where am I ... What am I doing?"

Scott Horton 3:29 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 3:30 Like, this is a bad format. You have to break for commercials every seven minutes.

Scott Horton 3:34 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 3:35 No conversation could ever get into depth. There's executives in your ear telling you what to say and what not to say. They'll edit out anything that they think is, like, controversial that's gonna m- fuck with their sponsors or fuck with the government or fuck with-

Scott Horton 3:48 Yeah

Joe Rogan 3:48 ... whatever their narrative is.

3:50 – 6:41

From radio legitimacy to podcast reach: Scott’s career scale

Scott Horton 3:50 It's just everything's changed. When I first started doing podcasting, it was the archives of the interviews from my radio show, and it was so important to me that I'm on the radio, 'cause that's real legitimacy. That means somebody hired you, somebody thought you were good enough to be there. Whereas podcasting, any jerk can do from his basement, and it just doesn't count. And then that just became not true, and I kind of clung on to my radio show. I actually gave up my last radio show on KPFK in Los Angeles last year.

Joe Rogan 4:15 [laughs]

Scott Horton 4:16 After, I mean, where it didn't matter anymore anyway, and podcasting has completely changed the entire market, you know?

Joe Rogan 4:22 Do you know how many people were listening to you actually on the radio before you quit?

Scott Horton 4:27 I think it's, like, probably high thousands, but not 10,000. You know?

Joe Rogan 4:32 [laughs]

Scott Horton 4:32 KPFK in LA.

Joe Rogan 4:34 Isn't that crazy?

Scott Horton 4:34 It's the most, it's the most powerful FM transmitter west of the Mississippi River.

Joe Rogan 4:38 [laughs]

Scott Horton 4:38 It's grandfathered in at 115,000 watts, but it's ... But the thing is about it, too, and it's always been like this, the, the programming on there is so inconsistent that you're listening to Latina lesbians one hour, and then you're listening to crystal worship, and then you're listening to hard-hitting news, and then you're listening to, like, leftist union organizing, or then, just whatever. You know what I mean? But it's just, there's no, like, real rhyme or reason to it, so it's hard to follow, you know?

Joe Rogan 5:03 What kind of a channel is it?

Scott Horton 5:05 Oh, it's, um, you know, left of the dial, um, at 90.7 FM, so it's, you know, comparable to, like, KUT-type. It's not actual public radio, but it's no commercials, all donations. And-

Joe Rogan 5:17 Oh, wow

Scott Horton 5:18 ... yeah, I mean, they were good to me-

Joe Rogan 5:19 A regular radio show that's no commercials, and it's not public?

Scott Horton 5:22 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 5:23 That's interesting.

Scott Horton 5:24 Yeah, it's like, um, I don't know if the co-op still exists here in Austin, um, uh, cooperative-

Joe Rogan 5:30 You must have made a lot of money from that. You must be so rich from doing that.

Scott Horton 5:34 Yeah, not as much.

Joe Rogan 5:35 Like, a leftist radio with no, no ads at all, just donations.

Scott Horton 5:40 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 5:40 Boy, you must be raking it in.

Scott Horton 5:42 No, they never did pay me. But-

Joe Rogan 5:43 [laughs]

Scott Horton 5:43 ... I looked at it like they let me be on there for 14, 15 years or something. And, um, you know, like, even when I was, uh, writing my book about the Russia-Ukraine stuff, I would do my radio show once a week, and I was able to still cover what was going on in Palestine, and in a way that I felt like-... you know, you know, you know, something meaningful that I can do even though my attention was completely diverted elsewhere. I still got all my guys from the Libertarian Institute and antiwar.com and I can interview them once a week. And, and then when I left KPFK, I got some response. They're like, "Oh, no, where are you going?" kinda thing. So I mean, some people were caring for it at the time. I don't know.

Joe Rogan 6:22 Did you let them know, "Hey, I have a podcast. You could see 'em all, all these episodes will be archived"?

Scott Horton 6:27 Yeah, I kinda always let them know that. You know, I've done 6,200 something interviews since 2003-

Joe Rogan 6:34 Good Lord

Scott Horton 6:34 ... on my various shows. So I always try to remind people to go check the archives if they want for the full dose of that stuff.

6:41 – 8:57

Scott’s early 'New World Order' phase—and why he abandoned it

Joe Rogan 6:41 Before we get into any of these subjects, like how did you get into this?

Scott Horton 6:45 Um, well, you know, in the '90s I was, you know, when I was younger, I was much more of like a New World Order, uh, truther type. And, um, but then I basically dropped all that. I grew out of that basically.

Joe Rogan 6:57 How do you, how do you define New World Order truther type?

Scott Horton 7:00 Well-

Joe Rogan 7:00 Like, I mean-

Scott Horton 7:01 Okay, well, I mean, the New World Order conspiracy was that American foreign policy ultimately is about building a one world federal government under the United Nations that would ultimately dominate the United States, the John Birch Society-

Joe Rogan 7:13 Right

Scott Horton 7:13 ... sort of idea of how... And, and I, uh, I really like those guys. Um, and I believed that for a long time, really through Clinton, and even the, into the beginning of W. Bush. But then I could... I finally realized with the way that the Iraq War was prosecuted, that this is not about building up the UN Security Council. We got the National Security Council, and Cheney and his neocons, and they have their own separate policy that just disproves the, that sort of New World Order theory. And the American... And, and in fact, so what H.W. Bush meant by that was just the era of the American Empire with no one to stop us this time-

Joe Rogan 7:48 Mm

Scott Horton 7:48 ... was all. It was never to build up the UN as the world government. It was to build up Washington, D.C. as the world government. And of course, they've been failing and flailing at trying to establish that ever since.

Joe Rogan 8:00 Yeah. Um, so the conspiracy was that the United Nation would, would be the government of the entire Earth-

Scott Horton 8:10 Right

Joe Rogan 8:10 ... and that all other governments would somehow or another give up their power to the United Nations. For what reason?

Scott Horton 8:17 Um, 'cause they're all in on it together in secret, whatever.

Joe Rogan 8:20 Well, but, but-

Scott Horton 8:21 And that's the point, is it ain't right. It's not true

Joe Rogan 8:23 ... well, the, my-

Scott Horton 8:23 There's no-

Joe Rogan 8:24 ... my question would be like-

Scott Horton 8:24 Too many people would have to... Exactly. Too many people have to sacrifice the power they do have-

Joe Rogan 8:28 Exactly

Scott Horton 8:28 ... to somebody else-

Joe Rogan 8:30 And-

Scott Horton 8:30 ... when they don't have to

Joe Rogan 8:31 ... money.

Scott Horton 8:32 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 8:32 That's the other thing. I mean, as soon as you lose power, then you lose access to-

Scott Horton 8:35 Yeah

Joe Rogan 8:35 ... insane amounts of wealth.

Scott Horton 8:37 Yeah. So we don't want... You know, uh, obviously it's the ultimate nightmare would be that you would have some kind of one world government and then some kind of totalitarian regime take power-

Joe Rogan 8:48 Do you think-

Scott Horton 8:48 ... with a monopoly on nukes and a monopoly on police power and, you know... But that's just a nightmare for centuries from now. I mean, that's just not gonna happen anytime soon at all.

Joe Rogan 8:56 You-

Scott Horton 8:56 That's not what it's about

8:57 – 12:22

Rules-based order as empire: Wolfowitz Doctrine and permanent dominance

Joe Rogan 8:57 ... you don't think there's any push towards centralizing things in that regard? Like, wasn't the World Health Organization trying to push for-

Scott Horton 9:05 Oh, sure

Joe Rogan 9:05 ... something where the entire world would have to respond to their pandemic rules?

Scott Horton 9:11 Well, look, uh, so yes, there, there's always, you know, the widening and deepening of the international law as much as they can.

Joe Rogan 9:18 Right.

Scott Horton 9:18 At the end of the day, there is no actual world state to enforce that law other than just the United States of America, but there is no one world army, one world police force to enforce these things. It's all about coercing and cajoling governments to go along. And-

Joe Rogan 9:34 Right

Scott Horton 9:35 ... which goes to show, I mean, this is the whole thing about when they talk about... You know, what, what H.W. Bush meant when he talked about the New World Order is the same thing that Joe Biden meant when he would say the liberal rules-based international order of just doing what America says.

Joe Rogan 9:48 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 9:48 Right? That's what it is. You know, it's a pseudo empire. It's not exactly the ex- the same kind of empires and, you know, colonialism that we've had in the past, but it's sort of a neocolonialism where if we can overthrow your government with some money, then we'll do that. A little bit of CIA help, we'll do that. And if we have to-

Joe Rogan 10:06 Bomb the rebels

Scott Horton 10:07 ... if we have to bomb your capital city, we'll go for that if we think so.

Joe Rogan 10:10 Yeah.

Scott Horton 10:11 And it does go back really to the Wolfowitz doctrine, you know, of various degrees, but this is of reference to right after the First Gulf War, Paul Wolfowitz at that time was the Deputy Secretary of Defense for Policy. And him and a couple other neocons, Scooter Libby and Zalmay Khalilzad, they wrote up this document called the Defense Planning Guidance, and it was saying this is going to be, you know, the posture for the post-Cold War era and the post-First Iraq War, Gulf War era. Um, and what it said was, "We're going to be the most dominant power on every continent anywhere in the world, and we're not even gonna tolerate any other nation or alliance or group of nations anywhere to try to join together to balance against us. We will be dominant everywhere, and we'll never let anyone get that far ahead, or at least we're gonna try to construct an order where our power is essentially permanent and they don't even try it." And so that's what they've been trying to do with expanding our footprint in the Middle East, expanding our footprint into Eastern Europe, and of course, you know, working hard at least on building their alliances and, or tightening them and arming their alliances in Eastern Asia. And it's, you know, it, under the theory that if it's not us, it'll be somebody else and it'll be so much worse, so we have to stay and dominate everything forever. But of course, you can look at the debt and just see, well, we can't afford it, so I don't know how anybody else can, but we certainly cannot afford to keep doing this.

Joe Rogan 11:33 Right. And if you look at Wolfowitz, if you see POPA image of Paul Wolfowitz, he looks exactly like the kind of guy you would expect to make something like the Wolfowitz doctrine.

Scott Horton 11:45 Right. And by the way, they did rewrite it 'cause it was a scandal. It was leaked to The New York Times, and so they went back and rewrote it, and they just said, "Well, we'll bring our friends, you know, from the international institutions along too."

Joe Rogan 11:57 That picture right there where your cursor is, right below, right there. No, to the right of that.

Scott Horton 12:01 That.

Joe Rogan 12:01 That one.

Scott Horton 12:01 Yeah, there you go.

Joe Rogan 12:02 Look at that. That looks like [laughs] That completely looks like the type-

Scott Horton 12:05 Yeah

Joe Rogan 12:06 ... of guy that would do something like this.

Scott Horton 12:06 So listen, there's a, there's a book about the neoconservatives by Jacob Heilbrunn called They Knew They Were Right.Which is of course-

Joe Rogan 12:14 That's hilarious

Scott Horton 12:14 ... right? Like, the, yeah, these guys who have no idea what they're doing.

Joe Rogan 12:16 [laughs] Really, you know. That's hilarious.

Scott Horton 12:19 Let me try this.

Joe Rogan 12:20 Yeah.

Scott Horton 12:20 Does it fit right on my little head?

12:22 – 17:38

The 'seven countries' plan and the neocon network behind Iraq

Joe Rogan 12:22 Like I said, you can fuck with the volume on that little knob and turn it up and down. So, um, this was a, the, this, one of the things that, um, when Coleman Hughes and, um, our buddy Dave Smith got into it with was about whether... And when, you remember when, um, they brought up this seven countries thing.

Scott Horton 12:43 Mm-hmm.

Joe Rogan 12:44 That, you know, and he was saying that there was no real proof that that exists, that he didn't actually read it. He was told that we were gonna go into seven countries. But, you know, uh, I was talking to Dave about this the other day, it's like I, y- if y- you just look a- at the fact that we did everything on that list except Iran. Every single one of them-

Scott Horton 13:07 Yeah

Joe Rogan 13:07 ... took place, except Iran. Like, he's like, "I really wanna go and do that debate again, and I can't get Coleman to sit down with me." [laughs]

Scott Horton 13:13 Yeah. You know, yes.

Joe Rogan 13:15 [laughs]

Scott Horton 13:15 For people who are interested in this subject, you know-

Joe Rogan 13:18 Yeah

Scott Horton 13:18 ... long-term, uh, there's no mystery about the connection between the neoconservatives' doctrines and then the activities that the W administration engaged in-

Joe Rogan 13:28 Yeah

Scott Horton 13:28 ... you know, subsequent. I mean, what happened was y- you have, you know, Andrew Cockburn, the great journalist, Andrew Cockburn, says that the neoconservatives are a cross between the Israel lobby and the military industrial complex. The fighter bomber salesman needed eggheads to justify their policies, and the neoconservatives wanted to support Israel, wanted to support American hegemony, and so took all the military industrial complex money to build their think tanks, to create their consensus, to build their policy. S- you know, their own kinda thousand little Council on Foreign Relations to get what they want. And then when, you know, the seven countries thing is-

Joe Rogan 14:05 So what we're talking about, just to clarify-

Scott Horton 14:07 Yeah, sure

Joe Rogan 14:07 ... is Wesley Clark was given, well, was-

Scott Horton 14:09 Yeah

Joe Rogan 14:09 ... he was on some television show. I forget what the show was. Do you remember him?

Scott Horton 14:14 There's, there's two different statements. One of them I know was with Amy Goodman from Democracy Now!

Joe Rogan 14:18 That's right, that's right, Democracy Now!

Scott Horton 14:19 Yeah. And basically what he's talking about is, um, you know, he says that a general, or, I'm sorry, a military officer of some rank told then retired but still with access former General Wesley Clark, who had been the Supreme Allied Commander of NATO forces in Europe under Bill Clinton, did the Kosovo War, so a very prominent four-star general, and he said, the way he told the story was he told him, "Hey, you know, we're g- they're planning for a war with Iraq." And he said, "Iraq? Why?" And the guy said, "I don't know." And then the second part of the story was he came back a week later or something, and the same guy said, "There's this memo that has this seven countries, and they say they wanna take them all in five years." So they meaning the Office of the Secretary of Defense, so that's Donald Rumsfeld, who's not a neoconservative. He's his own separate thing here. He's the Secretary of Defense, but all of his guys, all of his most important guys are neoconservatives. So the Deputy Secretary of Defense is Paul Wolfowitz. The Deputy Secretary of Defense for Intelligence is Stephen Cambone. The Deputy Secretary of Defense for Policy is Douglas Feith, and then under him is Abram Shulsky and Bill Luti, and all of these guys, uh, Michael Rubin and others, who were all working on this project to get us into Iraq. And this is the neoconservative network of power. You got Scooter Libby and, um, David Wurmser would travel around from state to defense to the vice president's office. But you got Scooter Libby and John Hannah in the vice president's office. You got Zalmay Khalilzad and Elliot Abrams on the National Security Council, Robert Joseph and, and, uh, Stephen Hadley and, and, uh, Eric Edelman. All of these guys were already the network of guys who agreed with this policy going back through the 1990s. It was what they had founded the Project for a New American Century on. And so what they're saying is, "We should not tolerate any..." And remember the time. In, in the d- they, this was the stated doctrine. We will not tolerate the existence of any Middle Eastern regime that supports terrorism, and supports terrorism can mean anything, right? Like Abu Nidal died in Iraq before the war even started and was a washed up old terrorist from a previous day, but, like, that's good enough. You got Mujahideen, he called commie terrorists who've worked for us ever since, but at that time was a good enough excuse to invade Iraq. They would invoke that. And so they made up that doctrine of-

Joe Rogan 16:33 The Mujahideen were in Iraq as well as Afghanistan?

Scott Horton 16:36 Well, this is a particular sect of Mujahideen kooks that, who were Iranian communist cultists who were, had left Iran and gone to work for Saddam Hussein, and then were, you know... He supported them. They had nothing to do with anti-American terrorism at that time except, you know, uh, I guess committing it when they, uh, had worked for Iran previously during the Iranian Revolution. But by, I mean, by the time we invaded Iraq, Donald Rumsfeld inherited them, and they've worked for America and Israel ever since then. They have a base in Albania now. But they w- in other words, though, this wasn't Al-Qaeda. This was not any real excuse. They would just invoke the, a doctrine of fighting terrorism in order to check off this list of all of these governments that they didn't like. And coincidentally and incidentally and very importantly, of course, is this was really, in many cases, Israel's list of enemies, where if it was, say, Colin Powell, which is what people thought they were voting for in the year 2000, by the way, "Well, I don't know about this W Bush, but at least Colin Powell will be up there. We can trust him," they all said.

Joe Rogan 17:38 Right.

17:38 – 23:29

Clean Break strategy: Iraq as a lever for Israel’s regional goals—and the blowback

Scott Horton 17:38 If it had been up to him, we would've done a two-state solution in Palestine and solved that issue, and then we would've had probably the most limited of wars against Al-Qaeda in Afghanistan, and that would've been it. The rest of it would've been police and/or special forces action. There would've been no invasion of Iraq, which he did lie us into that war, and he's responsible for that. But that was not his policy. That was the policy that came out of the vice president's office and this neoconservative setAnd it's really as Dave Smith correctly says, it's all based on the clean break doctrine, which David Wurmser and Richard Perle... Oh, I've, I neglected to mention Richard Perle and his friends on the Defense Policy Board. But, um, Perle and David Wurmser had written up this policy paper called A Clean Break in 1996, and they wrote it for Netanyahu when he was first prime minister the first time back then. And what it said was, instead of going along with the Oslo peace process and making a deal with the Palestinians, we should just forget all that and just we'll have peace through a position of strength and total dominance over our neighbors. And so, but the problem of course is we, and, and of course meaning continue to devour Palestine, what's left, the 22% of what's left of historic Palestine in the West Bank and Gaza. But the problem is we have Hezbollah on our northern border, and Hezbollah is backed by Iran by way of Syria. So if you just picture the Middle East, you know, um, if you want, you can throw up a map, uh, and just kind of show there's this arc of power from Tehran in Iran through Syria and to Hezbollah, this Shiite militia in southern Lebanon. Now, Saddam Hussein was the Sunni roadblock in that arc of power. But these guys are stupid, the neoconservatives. Uh, they're as stupid as they are arrogant, you know, and certain in their policy. And they believed in this harebrained scheme essentially, that the Jordanians and the Turks would be dominant in the new Saddam Hussein-less Iraq, and that even though it's a super majority Shiite Arab country, those Shiites, they just love being told what to do by either, their original plan was the Hashemite king, the cousin of the King of Jordan, and then they threw that out, and it was the guy who sold them this line that this was possible in the first place, an Iraqi exile you might remember from that time, Ahmed Chalabi, the head of the Iraqi National Congress. They said, "Well, we'll just make him the guy instead," which ended up not happening. But that was their plan, and they said the new Shiite-dominated Iraq will then, the religious leaders in Iraq will then force Hezbollah to stop being friends with Iran and start being friends with Israel instead.

Joe Rogan 20:18 [laughs]

Scott Horton 20:18 And they'll even build an oil pipeline to Haifa or reopen the old British oil pipeline to Haifa, Israel. And they were sold this bill of goods, and they really believed it. And so, and you can find this on my website, scotthorton.org. I have A Clean Break: A New Strategy for Securing the Realm, and then the companion piece is called Coping with Crumbling States: A Balance of Power Strategy for the Levant. They're both by David Wurmser, signed off on by Richard Perle. And then they wrote a book where Wurmser wrote the book and Richard Perle wrote the forward. It's called Tyranny's Ally: America's Failure to Remove Saddam Hussein. Get that? America's the ally of Saddam just 'cause we won't launch a war to regime change him there, right in the title, and then based on the same harebrained scheme. And what's funny about this is this guy David Wurmser now tries to defend himself, and he did a interview on a podcast not too long ago with this, uh, born again Christian about September 11th and stuff. And, but he talked about this, and he's like, "Yeah, no, that's still right. They'll do whatever the Hashemites tell them to do, those Shiites. They just worship and revere anyone who claims to have the blood of the prophet." But if that was true, as Dave Smith pointed out, well, then how come you can't just call the King of Jordan right now and ask him to ask the Ayatollah to knock it off? Call him and ask, have him ask Hezbollah to stop being friends with Iran. Why couldn't they have just done that this whole time? Why do you have to have a regime change in Baghdad before you can make this magic wish come true? And the whole thing is completely stupid. And the Shiites do revere some of the lineage of the family of the Prophet Muhammad and, but one, it's not a magic spell of hypnosis and total control over them, and two, that has nothing to do with the Hashemites, who are Sunnis in a whole separate line and are the British sock puppet kings of Jordan-

Joe Rogan 22:02 So-

Scott Horton 22:02 ... who used to rule Iraq back 70 years ago or something but have no purchase there whatsoever. And of course, what happened, just real quick, what happened then in the war was they just empowered Iran. They didn't empo- empower Jordan and Turkey and America and Israel over the Iraqis. They just gave Iran even more power than they ever had before. When it was all meant to screw them over, it blew up in the Americans' face.

Joe Rogan 22:28 This episode is brought to you by ZipRecruiter. It's good to be passionate about something. Exploring what interests you adds more color to your life. It makes it more fulfilling in a way. And that's not just limited to your personal life. If you run a business, you know how much of a difference it can make when the people on your team are excited about what they're doing. And if you don't, well, it's time to find out with ZipRecruiter. Try it for free at ziprecruiter.com/rogan. It's been rated the number one hiring site based on G2, and that's because ZipRecruiter is always looking for ways to improve the hiring process, including its newest feature that lets you see the most qualified and, more importantly, most interested people for your role to make sure they're some of the first you start talking to. Find candidates who really want your job on ZipRecruiter. Four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. Try it for free at ziprecruiter.com/rogan.

23:29 – 29:02

Was Iraq incompetence or a profit engine? The incentives of forever war

Joe Rogan 23:29 That's ziprecruiter.com/rogan. Meet your match at ZipRecruiter. Do you think that that is because of total incompetence and stupidity, or do you think that it was a scam, and that they were, they kind of knew this was gonna happen in the first place, but what they really wanted to do was sell a lot of weapons, sell a lot of war, make a ton of money? I mean, the amount of money that was generated... How much money did we spend on the Iraq War?

Scott Horton 23:58 Oh, I meanOn Iraq alone, at least five or seven trillion. I think it was probably 10 trillion for the whole terror war.

Joe Rogan 24:06 So let's stop and think about that.

Scott Horton 24:07 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 24:08 Five or 10 trillion. Let's just say five. Let's be nice.

Scott Horton 24:11 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 24:11 Where's that money going? How many defense contractors were deeply enriched by that? How many defense contractors are involved in, you know, lobbyists, policy, influencing change-

Scott Horton 24:23 Yeah

Joe Rogan 24:23 ... influencing certain actions? And why would they do that? Why would they do that? Why would they push a harebrained scheme? Is it because of stupidity, or is it because they, they don't give a fuck what the excuse is-

Scott Horton 24:33 Both

Joe Rogan 24:33 ... let's get the party started.

Scott Horton 24:36 I think-

Joe Rogan 24:36 Let's get some missiles. Let's get some new planes.

Scott Horton 24:38 Yeah. Okay, so-

Joe Rogan 24:40 Sh-boom boom.

Scott Horton 24:41 But, okay, so we can see right in front of us right here where Netanyahu convinced Trump this would be easy, and then it wasn't, and I think that's the same thing here. Iraq was supposed to be easy, and it was easy after all, right? You send the Marines to take Baghdad, they can take it. The, the, the 3rd Infantry Division and the Marines were done regime changing the place in what, five weeks? But then it was a matter of occupying the place and the whole thing devolving into civil war and all that, and I think... Well, I'll put it to you like this. In The Clean Break, we might be in Coping with Crumbling States, but it might even... Yeah, I think it's in Coping with Crumbling States, which is the same thing as-

Joe Rogan 25:17 Are we back?

Speaker 25:18 Yeah, yeah.

Joe Rogan 25:18 Okay.

Scott Horton 25:18 It'll be that too.

Joe Rogan 25:19 Sorry about that. We had that-

Scott Horton 25:19 So

Joe Rogan 25:20 ... stupid glitch again.

Scott Horton 25:21 Yeah, this is my-

Joe Rogan 25:21 Did we, did we get a new computer?

Speaker 25:23 I did... I've done everything, even, yeah, I've, I've talked to the company. They don't know what's going on.

Joe Rogan 25:28 Motherfuckers.

Scott Horton 25:29 Hey, burner.

Joe Rogan 25:31 Um, yeah. Anyway, um-

Scott Horton 25:31 I'm sorry. Let me, uh-

Joe Rogan 25:33 Can I, can I ask you this?

Scott Horton 25:34 Yeah, yeah, sure.

Joe Rogan 25:34 So what-

Scott Horton 25:35 Well, on the stupidity or the plan.

Joe Rogan 25:37 Yeah.

Scott Horton 25:37 I think, look, plan A is, "It'll be fine," and then plan B is, "Well, at least we can make some money and, and push this thing on and-

Joe Rogan 25:45 Right

Scott Horton 25:45 ... let both sides fight and weaken each other," and these kinds of attitudes for sure.

Joe Rogan 25:49 But that's the point. Like, did they genuinely think that this plan would work, or was this plan just a feasible excuse to talk them into-

Scott Horton 25:59 Maybe. Well-

Joe Rogan 25:59 ... getting the party started?

Scott Horton 26:00 I, I have one good, uh, argument in your favor there for sure, which would be Senator Joe Biden at the time insisted that we break Iraq into three and create-

Joe Rogan 26:09 Our greatest president?

Scott Horton 26:10 [laughs] Yeah, right there with the worst. That, that, that we draw these lines and essentially enforce ethnic cleansing or sectarian cleansing and create three sort of mini states within Iraq, and, you know, Antony Blinken was his right-hand man then, and, I mean, that's who these guys are, is, you know, very, very much Amer- I mean, uh, Israel first, Israel instead types.

Joe Rogan 26:35 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 26:36 Um, there is something before The Clean Break called the Oded Yinon Plan, uh, from, I believe, 1981, which is a real riot to read. It's, uh, this Israeli strategist, and the premise of the thing is that the Soviet Union is certain to conquer the entire planet. Talk about one world government, we're about to have one world communism run out of Moscow, and poor little Israel's gonna be all alone out here, so we have no choice but to smash every near Arab state into as many warring tribal pieces as we possibly can to weaken all of them relative to us as this-

Joe Rogan 27:08 Hmm

Scott Horton 27:08 ... desperate strategy. And of course, the Soviet Union didn't exist anymore at all by the end of the decade, but that was the premise for the thing. And there's... Oh, and here's what I was gonna say before the glitch, was there is a statement in, I think it's in Coping with Crumbling States, where he kind of says, "Yeah, you know, these states are pretty artificial, and without, you know, the Ba'athist construct in Iraq and Syria, you would have these smaller tribal based type units." So then, you know, in other words, if you can't have a completely compliant sock puppet there, might as well make them fight and, and destroy their countries, and that certainly happened in the case of Iraq, certainly happened in the case of Syria under Obama as well, where they just said, "Look, if we can't get the Al-Qaeda guys to sack Damascus and get rid of Assad, at least we can just destroy the place," which they did.

Joe Rogan 27:56 Do you think there's a parallel in, um, when we first went into Iraq, like Desert Storm, it was very easy, right? Relatively.

Scott Horton 28:04 Mm.

Joe Rogan 28:05 It was minimum loss of American lives, and I think everybody got a little cocky.

Scott Horton 28:12 Oh, yeah. That absolutely was part of that.

Joe Rogan 28:13 Yeah.

Scott Horton 28:13 Just like what we just saw with Venezuela.

Joe Rogan 28:15 That's what I was gonna say.

Scott Horton 28:15 It was so easy, and-

Joe Rogan 28:17 That's exactly what I was gonna say

Scott Horton 28:17 ... yep. I mean, people ask me right after Venezuela, "So what do you think this means for Iran?" And I was like, "Bad news." Right? Like, nobody thinks we're gonna go in there and kidnap the Ayatollah, but if you can put eyeballs on him, you can put a bomb on his head.

Joe Rogan 28:28 Well, they killed him.

Scott Horton 28:29 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 28:29 You know?

Scott Horton 28:29 And that's all you gotta do. That's the thing right here.

Joe Rogan 28:30 And that didn't even help.

Scott Horton 28:32 Of course not.

Joe Rogan 28:32 It's like, and whenever-

Scott Horton 28:33 Yeah, but you... Yeah

Joe Rogan 28:34 ... is it true that whenever they've been negotiating with someone, Israel kills them? [laughs]

Scott Horton 28:39 I think that happened at least a couple of times early in the war. Yeah. I mean, that was what they said. And in fact, was it... I forget if it was-

Joe Rogan 28:45 Oh

Scott Horton 28:45 ... Vance or Trump who said, "Well, we, we can't say..." I think it was Trump said, "We can't say who we're negotiating with, 'cause they'll get killed."

Joe Rogan 28:51 [laughs]

Scott Horton 28:51 And, like, you're supposed to think that, what, like, hardliners in Iran will kill them for trying to negotiate, but no, it's, this is the Israelis will kill them, you know?

Joe Rogan 29:00 That is wild.

Scott Horton 29:01 Yeah.

29:02 – 33:51

Ukraine: why it vanished from focus—and how the conflict was 'set up'

Joe Rogan 29:02 That's wild. It's wild that it's true. Um, one of the things that's not talked about at all since Iran, it, it, I mean, rarely talked about, i- is Ukraine.

Scott Horton 29:14 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 29:14 It's so strange how that kind of just left people's consciousness. It's like they now are just concentrating entirely on this Iran thing.

Scott Horton 29:23 Mm-hmm.

Joe Rogan 29:24 And the, uh, Ukraine thing is fascinating, too, because it was one of the few wars that I saw leftists support. It was very interesting. It was, like, kind of right after they put the masks and the syringes down from their profiles, then it was Ukraine flags.

Scott Horton 29:40 Right. Metzger had a joke about that.

Joe Rogan 29:42 Did he?

Scott Horton 29:42 Where he, like... Yeah, he starts out like, "Hey, invading Ukraine is bad. Can't we all agree on that?" Like, he really gives a, like, he, like, leans on, "Can't, can't we all agree that it's bad?" And he's like, "But it was a cure for COVID, you gotta admit."

Joe Rogan 29:58 [laughs]

Scott Horton 29:58 You know? Um, and it was. They just switched from night to day on that, and then, yeah, the other thing... And, uh, look, a big part of that is Putin... is a great stand-in for Trump. If you're a angry liberal something, you gotta be angry at something, and he represents... Now we're the-

Joe Rogan 30:13 Right

Scott Horton 30:13 ... common turn, and the Russians are the more conservative Christian force. And so like if, not that Trump's a Christian, but you know what I mean, and they're anti-right everything, that the Russians are the right. Not the, the Ukrainians are the left, but whatever. And Russia is obviously the, uh, the much larger country, and the one that invaded, that crossed the border first here, and, and, and they are the aggressor in the war. So it's, as far as the narrative goes, it's easy to justify sticking up for those, you know, plucky defenders, which is, you know, I was actually surprised, but I shouldn't have been, right, when I went to Oxford and lost that debate, was that was who was... It wasn't, not that they were leftists, but they're liberals, you know, or progressive-type-

Joe Rogan 30:58 Mm

Scott Horton 30:58 ... you know, college kids, and they're just totally on the side of Ukraine. And in fact, the question of the debate was, this house would rather go to war with Russia than lose Ukraine. And I thought that was just the most ludicrous thing in the whole world. That's not even debatable. They've got H bombs, 7,000 of them, and we're not having a war with Russia. I don't even know what you're talking about. This... And then w- I should have made my case better, because they did not like me or my case at all. They were so just staunchly for Ukraine that they were willing to support that, that they think that Britain should get into a war with Russia over the Donbas, which is just absurd. But I take responsibility for not framing my argument well enough. I just thought the question was so ridiculous in the first place, I would barely have to make my case. I just thought I'll just make a H bomb joke, and that'll be the end of that, you know? I said, "Haven't you ever seen Threads?" Have you ever seen Threads? It's like the British version of The Day After, where Margaret Thatcher gets them nuked in a-

Joe Rogan 31:53 No

Scott Horton 31:54 ... in a war.

Joe Rogan 31:54 It's a movie?

Scott Horton 31:55 In... Yeah. Remember The Day After from 1983-

Joe Rogan 31:56 Yeah

Scott Horton 31:57 ... with Steve Guttenberg in it?

Joe Rogan 31:58 Yeah.

Scott Horton 31:58 So this is the Russians' version from the same timeframe.

Joe Rogan 32:00 Oh.

Scott Horton 32:01 And, um, and I was like, "Haven't y'all seen Threads?" Which of course they haven't. They're a bunch of little kids.

Joe Rogan 32:06 Well, they probably think it's that social media app.

Scott Horton 32:08 Yeah, right. [laughs]

Joe Rogan 32:09 The Instagram one.

Scott Horton 32:10 Yeah, exactly.

Joe Rogan 32:11 Um, we should talk about, like, how this whole thing got started in Ukraine-

Scott Horton 32:17 Okay

Joe Rogan 32:17 ... 'cause most Americans don't even realize that the United States kind of overthrew the government there.

Scott Horton 32:23 Yeah, absolutely, twice in 10 years.

Joe Rogan 32:25 Yeah.

Scott Horton 32:26 In, in, in the Orange Revolution of 2004 and in, uh, 2014. And in fact, you know, George Soros bragged that he had really influenced the vote toward the pro-Russian candidate in 1994, um, the, you know, back 10 years before that. Uh, he's, he bragged about that in a interview with, um, The New Yorker, Connie Bruck in The New Yorker magazine. Uh, he said, "Like real estate investment trusts, I make it happen with my investments," you know? Um, and so-

Joe Rogan 32:56 Funny guy.

Scott Horton 32:56 Yeah. And look, I mean, Russia and Ukraine have a long and difficult history, but the long and the short of it for our purposes is that they wanted out at the end of the Soviet Union. And in fact, even embarrassingly for the Republicans, George Bush Senior and his government even intended the USSR to stay together. They wanted, not communism, but they wanted Russia to be able to hang on to Belarus and Ukraine and at least some of the Stans. And but what happened was really the Russians under Boris Yeltsin overthrew the Soviet Union. The most powerful member of the Soviet Union overthrew what was left of it, and it was actually in the aftermath of a hardline commie coup in August of 1991, which failed. And so it was Boris Yeltsin who saved the day, but then ended up doing his own coup, basically, and just destroying what was left of the USSR and, and kicking Mikhail Gorbachev out. So-

33:51 – 44:06

NATO expansion and the broken promises: the long fuse to the New Cold War

Joe Rogan 33:51 So why did the United States, um, get involved in Ukraine, and why did they stage a coup?

Scott Horton 33:57 Yeah. Well, so it's been a contest for dominance there ever since, right? And so back to the Wolfowitz Doctrine, the, and, and they talked about this in Rebuilding America's Defenses, the, uh, PNAC strategy document from the 1990s, 1998, I guess. Um, and I believe in, in the defense planning guidance of, that he wrote in 1992, uh, Wolfowitz, um, that we gotta expand NATO into Eastern Europe, and this is... The debate at the time was whether to include Russia or not. But n- but... And in fact, in the '90s, there were some people expo- who opposed expansion altogether. But then there was another school of thought that just said, "Well, we'll expand, but we'll bring the Russians in," but then they never did. And so they ended up expanding the military alliance up to Russia's border in a threatening manner and in a way that did not include them at all. And they had alternatives, like the Partnership for Peace, and before that, what we still have, the OSCE, the Organization for Security, or yeah, Security and Cooperation in Europe, where those had been brought up as alternatives to NATO, where NATO would be more political. This is what James Baker and, uh, under H.W. Bush and Warren Christopher under Bill Clinton had promised the Russians, is that we're gonna make NATO a political organization, and we're gonna have, as a security organization, it'll be the OSCE or the PFP, which will include you guys, and which was not true. They're basically, you know, never really meant to live up to those promises. So, um, it's not a perfect analogy, but imagine if America had lost the Cold War from all the spending in the 1980s, and then the Soviets had come to dominate Western Europe, and then they started moving into the Caribbean, and then they started overthrowing the government in Canada when they-

Joe Rogan 35:39 Right

Scott Horton 35:39 ... voted wrong.

Joe Rogan 35:40 Right.

Scott Horton 35:41 And this is, Ukraine is Russia's Canada, right? Kazakhstan's their Mexico. Ukraine's their Canada. It's their most important neighboring state, other than maybe Belarus, but it's same difference here. And so, um-

Joe Rogan 35:53 That narrative gets lost here.

Scott Horton 35:55 Yes, it does. And look, I'm not-

Joe Rogan 35:56 But it's, it's weird because it's so obvious. When you lay it out like that and when you look at the agreement that was made at the fall of the Soviet Union, that they wouldn't push arms closer to the border of Russia-

Scott Horton 36:05 Right

Joe Rogan 36:05 ... and yet they consistently did that.

Scott Horton 36:07 Absolutely. And by the way, so let's talk about that for just a second, 'cause people dispute that and say it's not true, but it is true. And in fact, H.W. Bush gave the first promise to Gorbachev in Malta in December of 1989, that if you let the Eastern EuropeanWarsaw Pact states go, not the Soviet republics, but the Warsaw Pact states, "If you let them go, we promise not to take advantage," like full stop. That's it, 100%. And then from there, and, and I cover all this in my book, Provoked, um, and I, I... It's even overkill on the research, 'cause I wasn't sure where to stop, so it's all there for you, where it wasn't just on February the 9th. It was all of these meetings over the course of months where the Americans, the British, and especially the Germans, but with the Americans standing right there in many cases to affirm to the Russians, the Soviets and then the Russians over and over again that, "We're not coming. We are not going to integrate Poland. We're not gonna integrate Hungary," at then Czechoslovakia, which hadn't split apart yet. Um, and, "We have no intention of doing that." And that was, you know, came from Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the foreign minister of Great Britain, as well as Helmut Kohl, the chancellor, uh, Margaret Thatcher and John Major, the prime ministers of England, and, um, Douglas Hurd, their foreign minister, and, um, even Francois Mitterrand, the president of France, and along with George Bush's government, over and over again promised them that, "We're not going to do this." And then they just went ahead anyway, and the Clintons, uh, you know, went along with it, too. And in fact, in the, in the Clinton years, one of the major proponents of NATO expansion was a guy named Strobe Talbott, who originally opposed it. And by the way, so when all of the... Anybody in that era, whenever they... On, um, on America's side or on the West's side, whenever they opposed this, it was always for one reason. There was no, like, variety of reasons. It was always one reason. This is an unnecessary provocation against the Russians. These are our friends who just overthrew the communists for us, so why would we pick a fight with them? Why would we disrespect them? We should be doing everything we can to integrate them into the West, into Europe, into everything, and this is totally unnecessarily antagonistic. That was the one and only reason, and it was brought up by a lot of people, including famously George Kennan, who had coined the containment policy against the Soviet Union in the 1940s and, you know, uh, was... Had been ambassador to Moscow, and he was the one who said, "We gotta contain communism." Well, now he's saying, "We should not be trying to contain Russia when they didn't do anything." And he said, in fact, in an interview in The New York Times in 1998, Kennan said... And he was the most highly respected Russia expert out of all of the old so-called foreign policy great bears. And he told Thomas Friedman of The New York Times, he goes, "I'll tell you exactly what's gonna happen here, okay? We're gonna expand NATO right up close to Russia, and we're gonna get a negative reaction from the Russians. And then as soon as we do, all of the people who are now telling us, 'That'll never happen. Don't worry about it,' will then say, 'Aha. See? That's how the Russians are. That's why we have to do this.'" Which is exactly what they say now. "See? The Russians are coming. That's why we need NATO more than ever before," when it was building up NATO more than ever before was what created this antagonistic relationship in the first place. And then, you know, and I should specify, I am from Austin, Texas. I don't have any connection to Russia whatsoever. I don't give a damn about Russia whatsoever. This has nothing to do with favoring their side of the story or whatever. This is, like, whatever. I... What can I say? I reluctantly admit that... And I'm not saying this is a good enough reason for war, but I'm saying that this is true, essentially. Uh, in his declaration of war, when Putin said that basically, "We tried independence. We tried letting Ukraine be an independent country, but it turns out that no, it just became a colony of the United States of America. It's c- totally controlled by America. So w- we're... But we're just not gonna stand for that, you know? So we're gonna intervene. We're gonna do what we have to do at least to mitigate that. If America's still gonna control Kiev, then at the very least, we're gonna control the Donbas and the south, uh, southeastern coast here." And so I'm not saying that's a good enough reason to do what he did, but I'm saying that was essentially true, that America had, you know, almost like it was a, a British colony, just had total sock puppets in charge of that country. In fact, there's a, a clip that I quote extensively. It's one of the only block quotes in my book, 'cause I got rid of almost all of them for space. But I ha- I think I have the block quote of Victoria Nuland testifying. That's Robert Kagan's wife, um, very important neoconservative, worked in Dick Cheney's office in the W. Bush years and everything, um, helped, you know, cause all of this problem. And she goes on and on describing the level of what can you call the infiltration, essentially, of the Ukrainian government by the United States, that she says, "We have our people, State Department people and whoever, working at every level of the Ukrainian government, throughout their police services, throughout their military, throughout their judicial branch, throughout, you know, and, and out in the provinces and everywhere. We're doing everything we can to control everything that's going on in that country." And, you know, the, the WikiLeaks are very, uh, beneficial on this story, 'cause they show where the Americans understand clearly... By the Americans, I mean Washington, the State Department, whatever, these guys, that, um, they know good and well that Ukraine is deeply divided p- especially politically on questions like whether they should join the NATO alliance or whether they'd rather be closer to Russia or try to split the difference and stay out of it or anything like that. And so they say, "Well, so we just have to push then. We'll just have to spend tens of millions of dollars on massive propaganda campaigns, and we'll just have to make sure to support the candidates that support us and our wishes." And essentially, it's America. You know, the, the book is called... Sorry, I keep mentioning the book. But it's how Washington... Provoked: How Washington Started the New Cold War with Russia and the Catastrophe in Ukraine. I'm not blaming it on Kiev. I'm blaming it on essentially Bush Senior through Joe Biden, that they, all of them, had such a ham-handed Russia policy that it led to this

Joe Rogan 42:14 It's just fascinating that this perspective is not being discussed or wasn't being discussed when it was in the news every day. When people were talking about Russia and Ukraine, it was always that Russia had done this horrible thing-

Scott Horton 42:26 Mm-hmm

Joe Rogan 42:26 ... and attacked Ukraine, which was horrible.

Scott Horton 42:28 Of course.

Joe Rogan 42:28 But no one gave any background.

Scott Horton 42:31 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 42:31 No, no one really talked about-

Scott Horton 42:33 Or-

Joe Rogan 42:33 ... and make, made the comparison to imagine if the Soviet Union or Russia rather, took over Canada.

Scott Horton 42:38 Right.

Joe Rogan 42:39 You know, or was proxying Canada.

Scott Horton 42:41 Yeah, exactly. Or if they went back at all, they would go, "Well, you know, this all started when Russia seized Crimea."

Joe Rogan 42:47 Right.

Scott Horton 42:47 But of course, they seized Crimea as a direct reaction to America overthrowing the government in the so-called Revolution of Dignity in February of 2014, and, uh, so then it's a complicated mess, but Crimea happened after that. But they just wanna start history at places where it's the most convenient for them.

Joe Rogan 43:06 And there's a- also, the control of Ukraine is a- also connected to resources, right? I mean, there's-

Scott Horton 43:14 Yes

Joe Rogan 43:14 ... immense amounts of minerals, natural gas. There's trillions of dollars of that stuff there that, and this also connects Burisma to the Biden administration, right?

Scott Horton 43:26 Yes. So like, I would not buy anyone arguing that these minerals or these resources are somehow crucial for the United States of America, for the American people, for our betterment or anything like that. Only as Ross Perot called them, the special interests, right? Chevron wants that oil, and Cargill, and Archer-Daniels-Midland, and Monsanto have investments in those grains, and so this is about them, but that isn't necessarily us.

Joe Rogan 43:57 Right.

Scott Horton 43:58 You look at, you know, whatever benefit they have to our GNP or GDP is negligible, certainly not worth starting a war or anything like that.

Joe Rogan 44:06 Of course.

44:06 – 58:23

Cost-imposing strategy: RAND 'Extending Russia,' Nord Stream, and shadow-fronts

Scott Horton 44:06 These are all the free riders. These are, you know, the excuse makers for this kind of policy. But essentially, I think what it really is, is just trying to keep Russia weak and off balance as much as possible. And, you know, like, there's this, um, uh, really important Rand corporation study that was published in 2019. So the Rand Corporation is a Pentagon-sponsored think tank, but it's out in Santa Barbara. They put it in California, so it would be somehow a little bit less political, a little insulated from East Coast stuff, and be able to come up with their thing. But that's, that's basically who they are. So of all the think tanks, they're, like, the most directly connected to the Pentagon itself. And they came up with this thing, it's called Extending Russia, and by extending Russia, they mean overextending them, mean, in other words, how to provoke them into overextending themselves, right?

Joe Rogan 44:53 Like during the Cold War.

Scott Horton 44:54 Right. Exactly. So w- w- cause small trouble for them in as many places as we can just to bog them down with expenses and commitments. So we wanna, at that time, the, the pipeline wasn't complete yet, so we want to intervene with sanctions, whatever we can to disrupt the Nord Stream pipeline. They said maybe we could try to overthrow the government of Belarus again, which they actually did in 2020. Um, they had done it before in 2005 and 2001, failed all three times. Um, which if they did that, boy, that might lead right to a nuclear war right there. I mean, you don't wanna succeed in a, a, especially a bloody, if it turned bloody, a coup in Belarus. My God. Um, but anyway, uh, then they said, "We could increase, uh, weapons to the jihadists in Syria. We could try to overthrow the government of Kazakhstan. We could increase support for the, uh, Ukrainian military." And what's interesting about this, so in other words, see how they're saying, "Do all these things to essentially agitate the Russians, to keep them off balance, to keep them bogged down, to keep them spending money they can't afford to spend," right? But then all throughout it, they have all these disclaimers where they say, "Don't listen to us. If you do this, it'd be terrible. Like, if you overthrow the government of Belarus, the Russians might just invade it immediately and station nuclear weapons there," [laughs] to make the point, right? "If we support the jihadists in Syria, they could break out of the Idlib province and sack Damascus, and then we'd have an Al-Qaeda government in Damascus," which is of course exactly what happened at the end of '24. They said, "We could increase support for the," what was then the ongoing civil war that had broken out after the revolution in 2014, "and we could increase support for the Ukrainian side of that or the Kiev side of that war, but then that could provoke the Russians into a full-scale invasion of the country, which would of course be terrible for Belarus... I mean, for Ukraine, and terrible for the United States, at a massive expense for us, a humiliation for as far as our international standing and prestige, and of course untold chaos for the people of Ukraine. And so we better be real careful about pursuing these policies." And then I swear, you look at how Biden ran things, and it was like he got that memo just without any of the disclaimers.

Joe Rogan 47:13 Hmm.

Scott Horton 47:13 And they just went ahead and did all of these things. And in fact, they were doing, they were messing around... It, it was actually the last year of Trump that they, uh, tried to overthrow Belarus. Uh, so that was independent of, of Biden's wishes. That was already going on. And then they were messing around in Kazakhstan in January of '22, right on the eve of war, right when you might hope that the entire, you know, pressure in Washington was to try to figure out a way to avoid war, to prevent this from breaking out. What kind of deal might we have to make with Putin to try to prevent him from invading Ukraine, as they're threatening to do, and had, were building up their forces in preparation for it? And then what do they do? They support an armed insurrection in Kazakhstan, which is, that's the big one, right on Russia's southern border there. Out of all the 'stans, it's the most important one, which is just madness. B- And it goes to show that that's essentially what they're up to when it comes to that, is just, you know, "If we can't overthrow Putin, we're gonna still weaken him, hem him in, surround him, agitate him, and force him to make commitments." And of course, this is what, this is why the war's been going on for four years. America could tellKiev, under Biden or under Trump, that, "Look, you guys are just gonna have to compromise here, obviously. You've lost, you know, all of Luhansk and most of Donetsk and, you know, at least half of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson, and so just make a deal, figure it out, and, and we're not supporting you anymore." Instead, what'd they say? Remember they said over and over again, "We want to inflict a strategic defeat on Russia. Russia might win the war, or... But no, we promise they won't. But yeah, but if it takes a long time, good." And in fact, I have a collection of quotes in the book where politicians and pundits and all these people would say, uh, and maybe they still say this, "We're getting such a good bang for our buck in Ukraine, 'cause just think about it. Russian soldiers are dying, but American soldiers are not. So all we gotta do is we just give them money, and then they go fight." And then sometimes they wouldn't even make any reference to the Ukrainian soldiers at all, hundreds of thousands of whom have been killed, hundreds of thousands who, of whom have been horri- uh, you know, horrifically maimed. Uh, the, uh, a major part of this country completely destroyed. Huge segments of their population fleeing the country as refugees, many of whom to never come home again, right? A total destabilization of their culture and society in every way. And then, but you can tune into Fox News or, hell, the Democrats too, talking about, or maybe worse, that, "Oh, but we're getting such a good bang for our buck, 'cause we're killing Russians. We're sending them home in body bags. We're sending them home in coffins. We're even killing their generals in the field." But-

Joe Rogan 49:56 None of our guys are dying. Heh, heh, heh

Scott Horton 49:58 ... as though the Ukrainians don't matter at all, and that's the way they think of it. This is inflicting costs on the Russians. Joe Biden would say that over and over again. It's almost like the Underpants Gnomes thing with the first you steal the underpants, then question mark, question mark, question mark, and then profit. Not really sure.

Joe Rogan 50:13 I don't know what that is. What are you talking about?

Scott Horton 50:14 Oh, on South Park, the poor... I think it's Butters. The Underpants Gnomes are stealing his underwear, and they're trying to explain how this is supposed to work, and they don't really have it worked out what they're gonna do with the underpants, but they're sure they're gonna make a lot of money in the end. And that's the same kind of thing here, where they skip the step about, well, is this really weakening Ru- uh, Vladimir Putin's regime, or maybe it's strengthening his regime? Is it, you know, increasing American power and influence in the region? Or in fact, we're shown as sort of a paper tiger ourselves, and we've done more than, uh, you know, you could have imagined to push Russia towards China and toward the rest of Eurasia. Um, you know, Joe Biden is essentially deliberately trying to prevent them from being part of European civilization to, and to emphasize their turn to the East. That seems to me to be a terrible mistake, you know? And I think part of it is part of the longer term Cold War with China too, and, and they're... You, you hear them talk about this, Joe. They'll say, you know, essentially, "Russia's friends with China, so there's two things we can do there." And this is what I think Trump would prefer to do, would be just make friends with Russia and pull them away from China. Maybe he's already decided it's too late for that or he doesn't know how. Um, and then the other side was, "No, lure Russia into Eastern Europe. Bog them down so they're no use to China. Um, you know, weaken their power. Give, inflict them, uh, on them this strategic defeat in Ukraine so that then they won't be as useful to China in our Cold War with them, or worse." And which I think is stupid and didn't work. I think that was the, the choice that Joe Biden made, and I think it was totally wrong, 'cause it just strengthened the relationship between Russia and China. And the Russians have a huge new pipeline that they opened, well, not that new, about 12 years ago, that they opened to China, and they keep adding to it. So they're able to sell all the hydrocarbons they want, and the Chinese will burn every hydrocarbon you got. So, you know, they really don't need Europe. Uh, you know, Joe Biden kicked them out and basically solidified their economic break with Europe, uh, totally unnecessarily, but in a way that didn't really hurt Russia.

Joe Rogan 52:25 And the blowing up of the Nord Stream pipeline was a part of this?

Scott Horton 52:28 W-

Joe Rogan 52:28 This was the d- to disconnect their oil supply or the natural gas supply to Europe?

Scott Horton 52:33 Yeah, in fact, more specifically, right, it was to, to make this break between, to solidify the break between Germany and Russia. So the previous German chancellor, Angela Merkel, she had this project she called Eurasian Home, and, uh, and what she was trying to do was balance American and Russian interests in Europe. And then they were closing down all their nuclear stuff, all the green movement, you know, environmental stuff.

Joe Rogan 52:59 Yeah.

Scott Horton 52:59 They closed down all their nuclear in Germany, and then the idea was, "Don't worry, we're gonna import all this clean burning, uh, CH4 from the, uh, Russians." And then, but to the Americans, this is the worst thing that could happen, would be an alliance or this strengthening, any, any part of a, any strengthening relationship or, or budding relationship between the Germans and the Russians. Because with, um, uh, you know, German manufacturing power and Russian raw materials and both of their at least potential military strength, that if they have an alliance and dominate Eastern Europe, they can keep everybody else out. And so I think that has always been the British and the American fear there. And, you know, there's, um, here in Austin, there's that sort of, uh, corporate CIA, Stratfor, run by this guy George Friedman.

Joe Rogan 53:46 What is it?

Scott Horton 53:47 Stratfor, it stands for Strategic Forecasting. They do dirty tricks-

Joe Rogan 53:51 That's here?

Scott Horton 53:51 Yeah, it's here in Austin.

Joe Rogan 53:52 Oh, no.

Scott Horton 53:52 They, they do some dirty tricks, but I think-

Joe Rogan 53:55 [laughs]

Scott Horton 53:55 ... they mostly, like, do, like, you know, pseudo CIA briefings for corporations and stuff, let them know what's going on in the world, that kind of thing mostly. Their emails got leaked on, uh, wikileaks.org, uh, years ago, and, you know, they're involved... They're, they're close with some of these color-coded revolutionaries. And anyway, I don't know them or anything, but their leader is a guy named George Friedman. And I'll give him credit, I know he opposed Iraq War II in 2003, 'cause I heard him on the radio back then. But, um, I mean, I'm not vouching for the guys like, uh-a good guy or whatever, but just to say he's sort of like a realist school foreign policy analyst type.

Joe Rogan 54:31 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 54:32 Um, not too ideological or anything like that. And he gave a speech years ago where he says, and this is the key words, "primordial fear." This is the primordial fear of American, you know, imperial policy planners, is that you would have an alliance between the Germans and the Russians, and so anything that we can do to prevent that, we'll do. Now, I don't know exactly who blew up that pipeline, but I'm sure they had at least the support of the United States. Seymour Hersh has it that it was American military guys who did it, um, which I think... I don't know. And then there's a whole cover story about this yacht, and then there's six different versions of who rented this yacht and whether it was used, and whether it was robots or whether it was divers or whatever, and it's all meant to confuse and... But-

Joe Rogan 55:16 This episode is brought to you by Visible. Ah, spring is in the air, which means time for some spring cleaning. We're cleaning out the garage and finally tossing those mystery cords. But while you're cleaning out your junk drawer, take a look at your wireless bill. Don't fall for wireless traps, tacked on fees, confusing bills, and empty promises. Join Visible and cut out the nonsense. With Visible, you get unlimited 5G data and hotspot on Verizon's network for one flat cost. Just $25 a month, taxes and fees included. It's everything you need and nothing you don't. Plus, for a limited time, new members can get the Visible plan for just $20 a month for one year using code FRESHSTART. Refresh your wireless with Visible. Head to visible.com to get started. Terms apply. Limited time offer. Subject to change. See visible.com for plan features and network management details.

Scott Horton 56:25 So what it had Seymour Hersh-

Joe Rogan 56:25 The bottom line is nobody wants to know, right? Seymour Hersh, what did he say happened?

Scott Horton 56:30 He said that it was, um, miners based out of Pensacola, Florida, meaning not pickaxe miners or children-

Joe Rogan 56:39 Right

Scott Horton 56:39 ... but meaning divers that go down and disable sea mines, that that was their expertise. Those were the guys that they sent to do it, and that was in... I think he did that in the London Review of Books or something like that.

Joe Rogan 56:51 Is, is that disputed?

Scott Horton 56:52 Yeah, and, and including by people who blame the Ukrainians and people who blame, um, I don't know, like Polish or, I guess Polish, uh, groups or whatever. They had all these different investigations that all led different directions. I know Jeremy S- I think Jeremy Scahill had one version of it, and then James Bamford, who I really respect, he's the guy that wrote all the books about the National Security Agency over the years, um, and he had it that it was the Ukrainians, and they used robots to do it. And he's, you know, sussed that out through documents and stuff and decided that that must've been what had happened. And, you know, there... So I don't know. There's, there's six different versions of it, and I have... I'm not choosing which is the favorite here, but I think it's, clearly was in America's interest. And, and of course, Joe Biden and Victoria Nuland have both sort of cheekily said, "We're not going to let this proceed, and if they do, we'll, we will do whatever it takes to stop it." And so evidently they did.

Joe Rogan 57:48 Hmm.

Scott Horton 57:49 And you could see how they would consider that to be, you know, what they would be trying to prevent would be this strengthened relationship between Germany and Russia.

Joe Rogan 57:57 Where's all that natural gas going now? Is it just pouring right into the ocean?

Scott Horton 58:00 Well, eventually they capped it, but it, I think it was the biggest release of methane into the atmosphere ever. It was a huge thing. It was a massive... If you were a liberal progressive Democrat environmentalist type, that ought to be, like the most offensive thing you ever heard of.

Joe Rogan 58:15 Yeah, it's way worse than cow burps.

Scott Horton 58:17 It was a huge... Oh, yeah. There's-

Joe Rogan 58:18 Remember they're worried about cow burps?

Scott Horton 58:19 Yeah, it's centuries' worth of cow burps, man.

Joe Rogan 58:21 [laughs]

Scott Horton 58:21 Centuries' worth.

58:23 – 1:06:07

Kazakhstan unrest as a pressure point—and the broader 'always hit them' doctrine

Joe Rogan 58:23 Jesus. So the Kazakhstan, Kazakhstan thing I'd never heard of. I'd, I'd, I hadn't heard a peep about that. I had no idea that we were meddling in Kaz- Kazakhstan.

Scott Horton 58:32 Yeah, it was one of those where, much like what just happened in Iran in January, where there's a protest over some economic policy. I think in that case they had cut the gas ration or something like that, and, and it's, you know, it's a country that's divided by ethnicity. Those borders are in all the wrong places and whatever, so you have sort of the ruling caste and the people on the outs and whatever. So you had a big protest movement, and then all of a sudden there's armed gangs of guys killing cops, seizing police stations, trying to seize airports, and-

Joe Rogan 59:03 Mm

Scott Horton 59:03 ... and this kind of thing. And, um, and then what happened was the Russians invaded. They sent regular troops across. They were asked by the government there to come and intervene. They sent troops. They crushed the insurrection. And then it was funny 'cause Antony Blinken said, "Oh, there's a lesson. When the Russians come, they don't ever wanna leave." And then the next day they turned around and left, and then they invaded Ukraine. They haven't left there since, but, um-

Joe Rogan 59:27 So-

Scott Horton 59:28 Yeah

Joe Rogan 59:28 ... who were these insurrectionists?

Scott Horton 59:30 I don't know. I mean, I think presumably they worked for the CIA and probably the Turks or something. You know? I don't know.

Joe Rogan 59:38 Just mercs.

Scott Horton 59:40 Yeah, them too.

Joe Rogan 59:41 Yeah. And so this whole thing was just what you were saying earlier, just to try to get Russia to be spread as thin as possible, spend as much money as possible, cause as many problems in as many places as possible.

Scott Horton 59:53 Yeah. And in fact, the same George Friedman from Stratfor, I think it's in that same speech or maybe a different, uh, one where he says, "Yeah, when, when Iran is doing a little bit better, you hit them. When Russia's doing better, you hit them. When China's achieving a thing or two, you hit them. You do whatever you can to always be effing with everybody all the time in order to... You know, that's how to press your advantage," which I think is totally just shortsighted. It's high time preference, you know, sorta government thinking, right? That, like, "Well, if we can get away with this now, we should," without really thinking about the long-term consequence. In fact, that was one of the, um, the things that failed to impress at Oxford that I brought up that, that I thought was crucial that is in my book, is, uh, Strobe Talbott, Bill Clinton's guy who-... or- originally opposed NATO expansion and then later championed it in 2018 when it was the middle of the war, uh, the, the civil war, so-called, with America supporting Kiev and the Russians supporting the so-called rebels on the other side. Um, a New York Times reporter named Keith Gessen went and interviewed Strobe Talbott, and it just kinda went without saying that, like, clearly what is going on here is the project of NATO expansion has sorta blown up and caused all these problems. You know, "What are we gonna do, and, and what do you think now, pal?" I forgot exactly the way he phrased it, but it was sort of, you know, "What do you have to say for yourself, Strobe?" And so Strobe Talbott says, "Well, listen." He goes, "When you're in power, you have one job, and that is to pursue your nation's national interests. And if you don't do that, well, then you won't be in power very long. So that was what we had to do." But then he says, "Now, maybe should we have had a higher, wiser conception of our national interest? Maybe." In other words, at the time, what they were thinking is, "We want Lockheed dollars and we want Polish votes for 1996." Illinois is a crucial swing state, right? So... Or was. I don't know if it still is. Uh, so that's why we gotta do this, 'cause it's in America's national interest that Bill Clinton get reelected and we all get to keep our jobs. So we're gonna, we're gonna make these promises to these people and pursue this policy for our narrow interests as rulers of the empire. But then if he had had a higher, wiser conception of America's national interests, he might have thought, "Wow, are we scheduling a military conflict with Russia for the next century? Maybe we shouldn't do that. Maybe we should look at it like actually nothing in the world is more important than America continuing to get along with the Russians." And again, when the communists are long gone, so whatever problem you have with these guys, it ain't Stalinism and it ain't evangelical Marxism at the point of a rifle, right? I mean, this is just, whatever it is, we can deal with it. And, um, and so no, they chose the lower, dumber conception of America's national interest instead of the higher, wiser one, and they blew it, you know?

Joe Rogan 1:02:55 Is there, uh, anyone that's ever made the argument to you l- like, where you've had these debates, where you have a utopian perspective on international relations, and that this libertarian ideology of, like, staying out of people's business, staying out of the... W- what you'll do if you don't fuck with the Russians, you don't keep them spending, you don't keep them stretched out, they'll just amass more and more power, and then they'll start to try to take over what was traditionally the Soviet Union, what was or- originally the Soviet Union?

Scott Horton 1:03:27 Yeah, you know, it, it just so happens, right, that America never leaves anybody alone, so we just don't have a controlled experiment, right?

Joe Rogan 1:03:35 Right.

Scott Horton 1:03:35 We're constantly provoking, and everything that we see them do is clearly a reaction.

Joe Rogan 1:03:41 I understand, but-

Scott Horton 1:03:41 And it's just like when we talk about terrorism, again, I'm not in any way justifying it, but I'm just saying you have so much intervention preceding the terrorism, you have to be able to attribute that.

Joe Rogan 1:03:51 Yes.

Scott Horton 1:03:51 But now, so how would things be otherwise? For example, if H.W. Bush had just said, "Okay, well, we won the Cold War. Pat Buchanan's right. Let's just come home," and had brought the empire home from Europe, then what would happen is the Germans would've reunified, and then they would've joined into a new European Union army with the British and the French and probably the Poles, and then it would've been on them to keep the peace between each other, to police the smaller countries in their region, and hopefully strike a long-term security partnership with the new red, white, and blue Republican Russians. And, you know, if people wanna say, but... And, and in fact, the other side in that debate at Oxford, Daniel Fried, said, "Yeah, but it was Poland wanted to join our alliance. It's not like we made them. They wanted to." But the thing is, yeah, they might have reason to fear Russia based on old things, but the question is, why are we obligated to be the guarantor of their independence?

Joe Rogan 1:04:48 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:04:48 It's, it's too far from here, and it's something that we're no good at, we only cause problems, and something that the other European states, who are all Western Christian capitalist democracies and friends of ours, that they can all work together and solve on their own. I mean, when Germany reunified, it's not like the commies were taking over. It was the West that was dominant in the new Germany, right? These are our pals. There's no reason in the world Am- that America should've had to have... Well, for example, like, a, a big part, part of the horrible war in the Balkans was because of a contest for power between America and Germany over who's gonna be dominant in the former Yugoslavia. We should've just let the Germans have it. Or I mean, not have it and kill everybody or whatever, but God, it could hardly have been worse than what America helped to cause there by trying to compete with the Germans for dominance in a land that's quite literally 6,000 miles from here.

Joe Rogan 1:05:41 But is the fear, uh, from the American side that if you let other countries consolidate power, if you let them grow in influence without fucking with them and keeping them spread out like we're doing with Russia-

Scott Horton 1:05:52 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:05:53 ... that they'll eventually get stronger, and then they'll become a real problem?

Scott Horton 1:05:57 I mean, maybe.

Joe Rogan 1:05:57 And they keep them weak, keep them distracted, keep them engaged in this Ukraine conflict and Kazakhstan and anything else you can cook up-

Scott Horton 1:06:05 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:06:05 ... and that keeps them down.

1:06:07 – 1:16:14

China, Taiwan, and chips: industrial reality vs war logic

Scott Horton 1:06:07 Well, it's like this. When it was the Cold War against the commie Soviet Union, I was a kid, and it's... I'm not a expert on all of that history. I think there were real questions about the dangers of world communism at that time, where at least I'd be willing to hear you out. But since the end of the Cold War, no, there's just no justification for it, because as Bill Hicks would say, right, like, "Just spin the globe, man. There's no countries out there," right? Every power in Europe is our friend and no threat to us and mean us no harm whatsoever. There are no powers in-In Egypt, or I mean, pardon me, in Africa that count at all except for Egypt, which is our friend. India will be a power in 100 years from now. Uh, China is a rising power, but we've been their friends for 50 years, even when they were still communists. Nixon went and made friends with them in the early 1970s.

Joe Rogan 1:06:57 Friends.

Scott Horton 1:06:57 And then the Soviet Union, yeah. And then the-

Joe Rogan 1:06:58 But aren't they constantly infiltrating our d- different universities and people who-

Scott Horton 1:07:05 Wow. I ain't endorsing that. You can keep them out. But-

Joe Rogan 1:07:08 Well-

Scott Horton 1:07:08 But it's nothing-

Joe Rogan 1:07:08 But Chinese infiltration is kind of crazy, like what they're, what they're doing in America. It's like if you're saying they're our friends, you know, the mayor of Arcadia just got busted.

Scott Horton 1:07:16 [laughs] I saw that. Yeah, that was funny.

Joe Rogan 1:07:17 She was a communist spy. She's a fucking mayor of a city in-

Scott Horton 1:07:20 Okay

Joe Rogan 1:07:20 ... California.

Scott Horton 1:07:21 I'm putting that on the FBI Counterintelligence division. That should have never been allowed to happen in the first place. Um, and no, I don't mean that they're totally benign. But look, uh, worst case scenario, China invades or just surrounds and forcibly reintegrates Taiwan. That doesn't mean they're gonna invade Korea, and it doesn't mean they're gonna invade Japan or Australia or, or have the appetite to want to do that. I think China's already a pretty overextended empire, and it's very poor in many parts of it. And they have something, is it 14 or 15 neighbors that they gotta deal with already. You know, their, their greatest ambition is to build this, um, a, you know what, a highway and, and, and fiber optics and whatever from Shanghai to Lisbon, right? This, what do they call it? The... Why am I forgetting the name of the damn thing? The, the great, uh, the, the great new highway they're trying to build all the way across Eurasia.

Joe Rogan 1:08:20 Mm.

Scott Horton 1:08:20 Um, they can't do that by intimidating everyone and lording it over everyone. They gotta cut through Tajikistan. You know, these are wild lands. They gotta make deals the whole way across if they're gonna do that. If, you know, they're... And, and if you look at the way they're building their empire so far, it's all just briefcases, you know?

Joe Rogan 1:08:41 Right.

Scott Horton 1:08:42 Government-backed businesses making deals and buying up resources and stuff. But I, I, I really don't think that Xi Jinping is looking at George W. Bush and Barack Obama and Donald Trump and Joe Biden and going, "Yeah, that's what I wanna do for my country is blow my own brains out trying to take over the whole rest of the planet Earth."

Joe Rogan 1:09:04 Well, and-

Scott Horton 1:09:04 You know?

Joe Rogan 1:09:05 ... you know, just to point to what you're saying is like China's not invading anybody. They're-

Scott Horton 1:09:09 They're not

Joe Rogan 1:09:10 ... they're not doing what we're doing.

Scott Horton 1:09:11 And I'm not saying they're nice guys or whatever.

Joe Rogan 1:09:13 No.

Scott Horton 1:09:13 But they don't rule us, and they're no threat to North America. They have no need to pick a fight with us. People say, "Oh, you got all your microchip factories on Taiwan." Well, then move them to Austin. We've had advanced micro devices here for 30 years or whatever, 35 years, maybe more than that. They can build that stuff here.

Joe Rogan 1:09:30 Right, but it's... They can, but they tried. It's very difficult. The thing about what they've got going on in Taiwan, the reason why Taiwan is the head of it is that they're far more advanced than anybody else in the world at doing it.

Scott Horton 1:09:41 Bring them.

Joe Rogan 1:09:42 Yeah, you would have to... You- the- it- that's a lot. You see-

Scott Horton 1:09:45 I thought you were gonna say it was something special about the saltwater over there or something. [laughs]

Joe Rogan 1:09:48 No. No, no, no, no. They're just way ahead of everybody else. I mean, in fact, didn't Samsung try to do a, a chip manufacturing plant in Texas? And I think their yields were so poor, uh, I don't know what the actual story with that is. So I'm speaking way over my pay scale here, but I think what it is, is you have to have, like, certain tolerances when you're creating these chips, and they weren't achieving what they were trying to achieve with- despite spending an enormous amount of money. So it's not as simple as build a plant, the schematics are there, you just crank out chips.

Scott Horton 1:10:26 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:10:26 Like, apparently these chips are super complicated to make.

Scott Horton 1:10:30 Sure. Not worth having a war over.

Joe Rogan 1:10:32 You're, you're dismissing it. No, not worth har-

Scott Horton 1:10:33 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:10:33 ... I'm not saying it's worth having a war.

Scott Horton 1:10:34 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:10:34 But I'm just saying that this-

Scott Horton 1:10:35 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:10:36 ... idea, just move them to Austin, I don't think it's that easy. I think chip manufacturing is one of the most complex technological challenges-

Scott Horton 1:10:46 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:10:47 ... in 2026.

Scott Horton 1:10:48 Yeah. I don't know. I mean, we've had, um... I don't, I don't know what all-

Joe Rogan 1:10:53 What is, uh-

Scott Horton 1:10:54 ... AMD does here, but I'm pretty sure that, that, um, them and Samsung and others have, you know, all the facilities they need here to-

Joe Rogan 1:11:02 I don't-

Scott Horton 1:11:02 ... do whatever they want

Joe Rogan 1:11:03 ... I don't think-

Scott Horton 1:11:04 They should be able to

Joe Rogan 1:11:04 ... that's quite true

Scott Horton 1:11:05 Or they should be able to.

Joe Rogan 1:11:06 They sh- they maybe could with enough resources and time, and maybe if you stole all the fucking eggheads from-

Scott Horton 1:11:13 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:11:13 ... Taiwan and bring them over here, all the geniuses that have figured out how to make these chips.

Scott Horton 1:11:17 Just pay them.

Joe Rogan 1:11:17 Maybe. Maybe they wouldn't let them. But what did, what happened with the Samsung chip factory?

Speaker 1:11:24 It's not, it has... It's never been fully open, and it's not done yet for like a-

Scott Horton 1:11:28 Oh, okay.

Joe Rogan 1:11:29 But what was... There was some-

Scott Horton 1:11:30 I used to be a rent-a-cop at some pretty fancy factories here, you know, back 25 years ago.

Joe Rogan 1:11:37 Oh, yeah? What kind of factories?

Scott Horton 1:11:39 Uh, I think it would've been AMD or, and/or Samsung. Some pretty fancy, like, uh, chip fabrication and stuff like that.

Joe Rogan 1:11:48 Well, let's ask Perplexity. Let, let's ask-

Scott Horton 1:11:51 And I did have a job being a rent-a-cop 'cause you skate parking garages at work and do my homework at work. It was great.

Joe Rogan 1:11:57 [laughs] Yeah, easy job for the most part, right?

Scott Horton 1:12:00 Absolutely.

Joe Rogan 1:12:00 Just free time. Um, let's ask Perplexity why are all the... why are so many chip manufacturers in Taiwan? 'Cause I'm pretty sure there's something about the advancements they've made in chip manufacturing that no one's been able to replicate. Otherwise, it doesn't make sense that China wouldn't just make their own.

Scott Horton 1:12:19 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:12:20 Like-

Scott Horton 1:12:20 You know-

Joe Rogan 1:12:20 ... they're right there

Scott Horton 1:12:21 ... I read this thing not long ago about how, like, with the China's AI stuff, they figured out how to write their program where they need much less computing power to do the same kinda effort in the way that they did it.

Joe Rogan 1:12:33 Yes.

Scott Horton 1:12:33 So they just found their own workaround.

Joe Rogan 1:12:35 Yes.

Scott Horton 1:12:35 You know what I mean? So-

Joe Rogan 1:12:35 Well, they also... There's a lot of espionage going on, too.

Scott Horton 1:12:38 Yeah, probably.

Joe Rogan 1:12:39 Um, a lot of the world's chip manufacturers is in Taiwan because the island deliberately built a specialized ecosystem around con- contract chip fabrication foundries, then compounded that early lead with huge investment, dense clustering of suppro- suppliers and talent, and strong government support over several decadesSo early strategic bet on manufacturing. Starting in the 1980s, Taiwan chose to focus on precision manufacturing, fabricating chips for others, instead of trying to build its own big consumer tech brands. And then their dominance and scale-

Speaker 1:13:14 That's an interesting stat

Joe Rogan 1:13:14 ... yeah, founded in '87, now the world's leading contract, TSMC, the leading contract chip manufacturer, produces over half of the world's advanced semiconductors and more than 90% of the most cutting-edge nodes. Because of advanced fabs, uh, because advanced fabs cost tens of billions of dollars and must run near full capacity to be profitable, only a few players can keep up, and Taiwan's leader kept pulling ahead as others dropped out. See, that's what I'm talking about.

Speaker 1:13:42 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:13:42 Like, the, it, I don't think it's easy.

Speaker 1:13:44 The biggest issue-

Scott Horton 1:13:45 I don't, I thought-

Speaker 1:13:45 ... I was seeing was that the, uh, no customers is what kept popping up here.

Joe Rogan 1:13:49 What is that?

Speaker 1:13:49 No, there are no customers.

Scott Horton 1:13:52 I mean, the thing is, at the same time-

Speaker 1:13:53 Factory has huge problem delays 'cause there's no one to buy them.

Joe Rogan 1:13:56 Well, why not?

Speaker 1:13:57 I don't know. I mean-

Joe Rogan 1:13:58 Huh.

Scott Horton 1:13:58 Yeah, I mean, when it comes to capital-

Speaker 1:14:00 I mean, I guess they have to run full capacity, then it's a lot probably, but-

Scott Horton 1:14:02 We got Samsung and Dell and AMD and IBM here. I mean-

Joe Rogan 1:14:06 Right, but they're-

Scott Horton 1:14:06 ... seems like they can invest their own money and build their own whatever they need to, right?

Joe Rogan 1:14:10 Right, but they-

Scott Horton 1:14:10 They should be able to

Joe Rogan 1:14:11 ... just read what they said there-

Scott Horton 1:14:12 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:14:12 ... about the amount of money that's involved in keeping it running. Like, I think they're so... I think the idea about Taiwan, and again, this is not really my area of expertise, not that I have any, but that they're so far ahead that this process that they bet on early on, that they've got their manufacturing to this point where-

Scott Horton 1:14:32 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:14:33 ... they've already invested this enormous amount of money, and the money, it, and they have to keep them running constantly. I don't, I don't, I don't think it's simple. I don't think it's like car manufacturing.

Scott Horton 1:14:42 And then the no, by no customers, you mean that essentially everybody who needs these chips is already getting them from Taiwan. There's not much more demand than that, right? But-

Joe Rogan 1:14:49 Well, not necessarily. It could just mean that they already have contracts, that they don't need them-

Scott Horton 1:14:54 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:14:54 ... 'cause they've already, you know, made commitments to Taiwan chip manufacturers or whatever.

Scott Horton 1:14:58 On the other hand, if, if Beijing is a military threat to Taiwan, and these people would rather not be under the rule of Beijing and the Communist Party, then there's a pretty big incentive for them to move to Texas.

Joe Rogan 1:15:13 There is, but again-

Scott Horton 1:15:14 Pack it up

Joe Rogan 1:15:14 ... what I'm saying is I don't think it's a simple step. I think, I don't think it's just like move here.

Scott Horton 1:15:19 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:15:19 I think it's an enormous investment in capital, like beyond normal things, and then I think to keep them running is an insane commitment, and it's very difficult. And again-

Scott Horton 1:15:28 Hmm

Joe Rogan 1:15:29 ... if Samsung doesn't have any, if right now they don't have any customers, didn't they have an issue with yields, though? Wasn't there an issue with, uh, chips being made to standard? I think there was something else on top of that.

Speaker 1:15:45 I tried typing that in and out. I didn't see anything, but they're trying to get to two nanometer production. They started on trials, and then there's rumors about why they have not moved into mass production, and that's, it's all these articles are saying.

Joe Rogan 1:16:01 Hmm.

Scott Horton 1:16:01 Hmm. Well, the Pentagon-

Joe Rogan 1:16:03 I think-

Scott Horton 1:16:03 ... budget is a trillion and a half this year. Let's just cut all that. Then we'll have plenty of capital freed up to-

Joe Rogan 1:16:10 Well, that's-

Scott Horton 1:16:10 ... produce your microchips

Joe Rogan 1:16:10 ... cute. [laughs] They're not gonna do that.

Scott Horton 1:16:12 Who needs a world empire?

Joe Rogan 1:16:13 [laughs]

1:16:14 – 1:25:29

Iran war reality check: base vulnerability, escalation dominance, and missile saturation

Scott Horton 1:16:14 Hey, look, uh, one of the lessons of the war in Iran is the empire's good for nothing anyway, right? We have H-bombs that are enough to deter anyone from attacking us, but America's military empire in the Middle East is completely bankrupt, right? That whole thing was a hollow bluff, and the Iranians just called it, and we lost. I mean, our bases have been evacuated. They keep coming out, y- you, I know you, I think you talked about this on your show, right? How they were covering up the satellite photos.

Joe Rogan 1:16:39 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 1:16:39 They weren't letting Americans have access to the satellite photos when you could get them online, whatever other countries had them. And then you've had The New York Times, and I hate to cite CNN, but it was a well-sourced story, where they got all these great satellite photos and went and showed how the Iranians reached out and touched 18 bases from Erbil in northern Iraq all the way down to Muscat in Oman and, and took out all radar stations and pitted our runways, hit refueling tankers and AWACS radar planes and took out the entire, not the entire, but a huge percentage of the, uh, overlapping radars for the missile defense systems over there.

Joe Rogan 1:17:17 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:17:17 Left our allies in Saudi, Qatar, UAE, Bahrain wide open. Uh, you know, our, our naval's, uh, Fifth Fleet station at Bahrain is destroyed and offline. I read this thing, said the Qataris, our, our main air base in the Middle East, the headquarters of Central Command and our main air base at Qatar, the Qataris made a deal with Iran. "Please stop hitting us," and they promised to not allow America to fly any sorties out of Qatar, our main air base during that war. And so as Justin Logan from the Cato Institute said, "Well, what good is a military base that you can't fight a war from?" You know, it's just like that, um, I know you've seen this, right? That, um, that old meme that says, "Well, if Iran doesn't want trouble with us, how come they put their country so close to all our military bases?" And it has all the-

Joe Rogan 1:18:04 [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:18:04 ... the map of all our bases in the region. But the thing is, what Donald Trump I guess didn't understand was that those were a tripwire that were essentially, we were making our own guys hostages of Iran to prevent war. Those bases were preventing war because it should have been out of the question that we would attack Iran 'cause all those bases would be up for grabs against them.

Joe Rogan 1:18:25 So how do, how are they so-

Scott Horton 1:18:26 They were by then

Joe Rogan 1:18:27 ... poorly defended? That's what I don't understand. Like, how is it so easy for Iran to attack these bases? And did they have any foreknowledge of this? Did they understand?

Scott Horton 1:18:37 Oh, yeah. So why they were so poorly defended, that's gotta be political decision-making among the brass, right? About like, "Well, we don't want to admit that we need these fortifications in the first place," maybe, or just the other general said, "Don't," so we don't wanna fight with him about it for office politics reasons or what. Like, I don't know.

Joe Rogan 1:18:55 So it's not-

Scott Horton 1:18:55 No good excuse

Joe Rogan 1:18:56 ... gross underestimation? It's not a gross underestimation of-

Scott Horton 1:18:58 Well, it can't be because listen, I'll tell you, man, um, in January of 2007The chiefs took W. Bush down to the tank in the basement of the Pentagon and they told him, "Look, we'll do your Iraq surge where we increase the war in Iraq, but we really don't want to go to Iran." And they told him, "The reason why not is because the Iranians have escalation dominance, or at least we won't have it." That, I, I shouldn't have said that. That was overstating it. We will not have escalation dominance there, and that means that, you know, it's a Pentagon term for if we're gonna get into a fight, we don't want to fight at all unless we know we're going to control every stage of that conflict. And in the case of, say, invading Iraq, there's nothing Saddam Hussein can do about it, right? As Paul Wolfowitz said, "Iraq is doable." In the case of Iran, they have, most importantly of all, a short and medium-range missile force that we cannot defend from. Now, we can defend from it some. We have our Patriot missiles and our other type of interceptors, but they can pour on volume that there is no magic Star Wars shield that can protect from. And we had, at that time, a hu- more than 100,000 guys in Iraq, 50,000 in Afghanistan, and then plus still, as we still do, um, tens of thousands Air Force and Army in Kuwait, Air Force and Army in Saudi Arabia, Air Force in Qatar, Navy at Bahrain, uh, I guess Air Force and Army in, in UAE, and I didn't know in Oman, but yeah, of course, in Oman they had, you know, some naval presence there as well. So, and they knew then that all of that stuff will be up for grabs, and then the Strait of Hormuz will also be at risk. And in fact, it's true, um, in, at antiwar.com, you can find in the archives there, I wrote an article in August of 2005 called Who's Behind the Coming War with Iran? And I say in there they can close the strait, and they can inflict economic damage, drive the cost of a barrel of oil up t- above $200 a barrel, and all of that. So there were people a lot smarter than me who were writing about that at the time that I was interviewing on my show at the time who were just saying, "Look, we can start a war with Iran, but we don't really have a good way to finish one."

Joe Rogan 1:21:18 Mm.

Scott Horton 1:21:18 And so, and we can talk about the nuclear program and how unnecessary all this was in a sec too, but point being that you want to do a regime change, as you just said, you kill the ayatollah, it doesn't do any good. They have a new ayatollah. You can kill the whole ruling council that appoints the ayatollah, but then they'll just appoint a new ruling council. So then you can dump in the 80, uh, Second Airborne Division, but they can't occupy and control Tehran. There's no good land route to invade the country. They have two massive mountain ranges.

Joe Rogan 1:21:45 And one of the most preposterous narratives was, like, getting the people to rise.

Scott Horton 1:21:49 Oh, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:21:49 Getting the-

Scott Horton 1:21:49 We're gonna arm up some Kurds.

Joe Rogan 1:21:51 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:21:51 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:21:51 Well, not just the Kurds. They were trying to get the, just the Iranian civilians.

Scott Horton 1:21:55 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:21:56 With no arms.

Scott Horton 1:21:57 Yep, and they'll talk about, you know, arming the Kurds and arming the Baluchis, which I don't know if there are other factions, but that seems to be a direct reference to groups like Jundallah, who the Obama and, the Obama administration and the Israelis both backed about 15 years ago, who were Bin Ladenite head chopper suicide bomber guys. They were, you know, no different from Al-Qaeda or ISIS, and they, you know, John Bolton on Piers Morgan, uh, that, the same show that I was on, was saying, "Yeah, we could arm up the Baluchis." And this stuff is crazy. I actually wrote in that article at that time, the neocons daydreamed that if we just start the war, then the people will rise up and create a new pro-American government there, but that's crazy to bet on that. There's no reason to believe that. And so, and there's video of me in 2010 warning the same thing, and I'm not claiming any great insight. I didn't go to college, man. I just, you know, I'm interested in this stuff, and I, I, you know, have a show where I was interviewing all these experts about it at the time, and it was just complete consensus. Everybody knew they can reach out and, and boy, over 20 years, I must have said this 1,000 times. They can not only hit all of our, uh, military stuff in Iraq, in Kuwait, in Bahrain, in Qatar, et cetera, Saudi, et cetera, but a trillion dollars of economic targets all up and down that gulf, which is exactly what they did. They hit refineries. They hit chemical plants. They hit, not just at the Strait of Hormuz, they hit American oil tankers up near Kuwait just to show that, like, we pwn this entire thing now. So back to my original point when I got on this tangent was that America's conventional military empire is bankrupt, that Donald Trump just blew his big bluff that we're the big player in the region. We're actually not in the region. We're here. The region is over there, and the entire, you know, threat of our dominance over there is basically called. I mean, obviously we still have aircraft carriers and planes and bombs and even nukes and all that, but can the leaders in Bahrain, in Qatar, in UAE, and Saudi rely on America to defend them?

Joe Rogan 1:23:56 Right. And haven't we-

Scott Horton 1:23:56 Or are they gonna come up with their own different policy now?

Joe Rogan 1:24:00 Haven't we also used up, like, two-thirds of our Patriot missile supply?

Scott Horton 1:24:04 Oh, yes. I don't know the exact percentages, but a lot.

Joe Rogan 1:24:07 And which is crazy.

Scott Horton 1:24:07 And they, they're admitting now that the Iranians still have 70, 75% of all their missiles and launchers. All that stuff about we decimated everything they had was all just buster.

Joe Rogan 1:24:16 They're admitting that? Who's admitting that?

Scott Horton 1:24:18 Government officials talking to The New York Times and The Washington Post-

Joe Rogan 1:24:21 Really?

Scott Horton 1:24:21 ... in the last three days. Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:24:22 Oh, I hadn't, I hadn't heard that.

Scott Horton 1:24:23 Three, four days. Yeah. 70, 75%. They got all their launchers, all their missiles. They, they dug out missiles that had been buried. They refurbished some and finished some that were on the assembly line. That was what they told The Post. They were finishing some that had been on the assembly line that they went ahead and restarted up again.

Joe Rogan 1:24:40 And don't they have some crazy, like, missile elevator system where they're, they're buried deep underground, and they-

Scott Horton 1:24:46 I don't know how it works exactly, but yeah, they, and, and even they have apparently, like, the factories are buried deep underground as well and just dispersed throughout the country. And so-

Joe Rogan 1:24:54 They've been preparing for something like this-

Scott Horton 1:24:56 Of course

Joe Rogan 1:24:56 ... for a long time.

Scott Horton 1:24:57 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:24:57 And so these bases that we had, are all of them non-functional, all the ones that have been hit?

Scott Horton 1:25:02 I don't think so. Uh, I don't know the exact extent of that, but as far as their usefulnessOver the long term, they might as well have just been abandoned at this point

Joe Rogan 1:25:12 Let's, let's, uh, see like what the conventional news says.

Scott Horton 1:25:15 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:25:15 Like-

Scott Horton 1:25:15 New York Times and CNN-

Joe Rogan 1:25:16 How many-

Scott Horton 1:25:16 ... have two big profiles on this. I don't know off the top of my head better stuff than that. The CNN one... Oh, and NBC also had, had one within... The, the CNN and the NBC are within the last couple of weeks. The New York Times is about six weeks old maybe.

1:25:29 – 1:28:45

Apocalypse theology in the ranks: Armageddon narratives and war justification

Joe Rogan 1:25:29 One of the things that-

Scott Horton 1:25:30 Five

Joe Rogan 1:25:30 ... disturbed me to no end, and we talked about this a couple times at the podcast, was, um, there was, uh, one of the guys who was over there who, uh, attended a, uh, a briefing, and they were told that this is bringing about Armageddon, and that Trump was anointed by Jesus Christ, and that this war in Iran was going to cause Jesus to return, and that this was actually being told to a bunch of military people that were having a war debriefing.

Scott Horton 1:26:04 Man. So-

Joe Rogan 1:26:04 And then, and then the guy had a... Whoever this officer was that was tell- s- talking about this said that the guy had a giant smile on his face-

Scott Horton 1:26:12 [laughs]

Joe Rogan 1:26:12 ... when he was telling this, which made it all the more creepy.

Scott Horton 1:26:15 Oh, good, the end of the world. We g- nobody wants to die alone, right, Joe? But they were saying there that-

Joe Rogan 1:26:19 It's all about to go down

Scott Horton 1:26:20 ... they, that there's a faction in the military that is these religious fundamentalists-

Joe Rogan 1:26:26 Yeah

Scott Horton 1:26:26 ... that actually believe that it's bringing about Jesus's return.

Joe Rogan 1:26:30 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:26:30 So look, there's a guy named, um-

Joe Rogan 1:26:32 "Commander claimed Trump was anointed by Jesus to cause Armageddon to justify Iran strikes."

Scott Horton 1:26:38 So there's a guy named Mikey Weinstein.

Joe Rogan 1:26:40 This is... But look, look at this.

Scott Horton 1:26:41 Who is-

Joe Rogan 1:26:41 Let's just go over this real quick-

Scott Horton 1:26:42 Yeah, yeah

Joe Rogan 1:26:42 ... 'cause this is so crazy. 'Cause this... Go up to the top, please. Right there. So, no, but at the ti- So it's where it says who it was. So it's a military commander, uh, told a group of non-commissioned officers that President Donald Trump, anointed by Jesus to light the signal fire in Iran to cause Armageddon and mark his return to Earth. Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:27:02 Uh, and then that's, that's Mikey Weinstein right there, the Military Religious Freedom Foundation. He was, I believe he was an Air Force officer. Maybe he was a Army officer, and then he created this group to advocate against this kind of stuff in the military. And I, it's been a long time since I spoke to him, but he was saying to me years ago that it's especially in the highest ranks of the Air Force, the highest ranks of the Air Force, they really believe this stuff. "It is time to bring on the apocalypse, and it's a good thing that they are the ones in charge of the nukes so that they can use them according to the divine plan" and this kind of thing.

Joe Rogan 1:27:35 [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:27:36 It is scary stuff, dude.

Joe Rogan 1:27:36 People need to know this. Uh, go back to that please, 'cause there's one quote that, that's below that. This is, uh, this is so fascinating. "He urged us to tell our troops that this was all part of God's divine plan, and he specifically referenced numerous citations out of the Book of Revelations, referring to Armageddon and the imminent return of Jesus Christ." Can you imagine if you're over there, you already think the war is sketchy, like, "Why the fuck are we doing this?" And then this guy comes down, you're like, "Oh my God, we're cooked."

Scott Horton 1:28:04 This is a big part of how they justified Iraq. I mean, there's so many Protestant ministers out there who told their people that this is the Bible. Get it? Middle East, year 2000 sorta-ish.

Joe Rogan 1:28:14 Man. God.

Scott Horton 1:28:14 Um, this is how you're gonna get raptured up to heaven in your body-

Joe Rogan 1:28:18 [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:28:18 ... and all you have to do is support this aggressive war, and all this magic stuff is gonna come true. And in fact, this is why there's such a massive crash in evangelical support for Israel and these kind of foreign policies now, is 'cause people just don't believe that anymore because that's what the Left Behind series at Walmart said 25 years ago-

Joe Rogan 1:28:34 Yeah

Scott Horton 1:28:34 ... and then it never happened.

Joe Rogan 1:28:36 Exactly.

Scott Horton 1:28:36 It didn't come true, speaking of the one world government and all this stuff. Where's Satan? Where's the deal?

Joe Rogan 1:28:41 Right.

Scott Horton 1:28:41 Instead, it's just Obama and Trump, you know? [laughs]

1:28:45 – 2:04:15

How Trump got pulled in: Netanyahu influence, flattery, and the nuclear misunderstanding

Joe Rogan 1:28:45 So how do you think we got talked into this Iran thing? 'Cause JD Vance, very against it. A lot of people, Tulsi Gabbard, very against it. So what the fuck happened?

Scott Horton 1:28:57 I think that Netanyahu essentially... You know all this talk about, um, four-dimensional chess and whatever, I think what it is is it's just checkers, right? Is Netanyahu goes, "Listen, for Iran, for Iran to have a civilian nuclear program, come on, that's just cover for really a weapons program. That's just a stage in a weapons program. We know eventually they're gonna make nukes, and then they're gonna attack Israel with them. And we also know that, um... "And, and you already said that you're not gonna let them have nukes. Well, having a nuclear program at all is having nukes. Same difference, and you already agreed to that, right? Right. Okay. Well, and they won't give up enrichment. So what do we do? W- we gotta attack." It's just like Obama's red line on the fake chemical weapons scare in Syria there, that once you agree to this thing, now it's written in stone, and now, like, we got you on this technicality. Double jump. Y- you already agreed with the stupid things I said, and so now you have to do the thing that I said. And then Trump goes, "Okay." And then plus on top of that, just the flattery. And like, you know, honestly, this is the most obvious thing. Back when he was on Twitter in his first term, I used to tweet at him and I would say, "Wealth, strength, gold, get out of Afghanistan, height, power." And w- like, just tell him, like, things that he likes, right? With get out of Afghanistan in the middle.

Joe Rogan 1:30:20 Right.

Scott Horton 1:30:20 And so this is what Netanyahu does, is he goes, "Listen, you're greater than Abraham Lincoln. You're greater than George Washington. You're a world historical figure. You're sure to go to heaven now. You're like if FDR had done the right thing and invaded Germany in 1935 and prevented that whole thing from ever happening," right?

Joe Rogan 1:30:39 But you're just guessing that this is how he talked to him, right?

Scott Horton 1:30:41 Well, kinda, but-

Joe Rogan 1:30:43 Wouldn't it be awesome to be a fly on the wall?

Scott Horton 1:30:44 'Cause he repeats a lot of it. Oh, it would. It would be great. But he repeats so much of it back-

Joe Rogan 1:30:49 Right

Scott Horton 1:30:49 ... that I think that, like, yeah, you could pretty much tell.

Joe Rogan 1:30:51 Okay.

Scott Horton 1:30:51 This is what they're saying to him, and then this is what he's responding is, "Obama wasn't man enough to do it. George Bush wasn't man enough to do it. He knows what has to be done. He's willing to do it." And he's ill-informed enough to believe-That it makes any sense. That if you just bomb their nuclear program, that somehow it'll go away. If you just hit 'em hard enough, then eventually they'll just do what you say. It doesn't work like that. It oftentimes does not work like that, and with these guys, they've made it clear that we're not making bombs, but we absolutely reserve our right to enrich uranium for peaceful purposes, and we will suffer your airstrikes. We will not give up that right. And so that's it, and, and they've been completely clear about the, that this entire time. But Netanyahu convinced him, right? This is why he also believed that the Strait of Hormuz was not at risk, 'cause Netanyahu convinced him, "Once we hit 'em, once he killed Ayatollah, the whole thing's gonna fall apart. There'll be no one to close the Strait of Hormuz 'cause we'll have already won by then."

Joe Rogan 1:31:50 But what do you think happens if Iran does get nuclear weapons?

Scott Horton 1:31:54 Hmm. Probably, um, the other s- states in the region will. You know Darryl Cooper, who's my partner on our show Provoked, and I know a good, uh, friend of yours.

Joe Rogan 1:32:05 I love Darryl.

Scott Horton 1:32:06 He, he is so great, and, um-

Joe Rogan 1:32:07 He's awesome

Scott Horton 1:32:08 ... and he was pointing out that-

Joe Rogan 1:32:09 That guy gets... Boy, does he get fucking misrepresented online.

Scott Horton 1:32:12 Oh, he does. It's-

Joe Rogan 1:32:13 Oh my God.

Scott Horton 1:32:14 He does.

Joe Rogan 1:32:14 Oh my God.

Scott Horton 1:32:15 Heroic guy, man. Um-

Joe Rogan 1:32:16 Very fucking smart, and if you listen to Fear and Loathing in the New Jerusalem, anybody who listens to that and thinks that guy's antisemitic is fucking crazy.

Scott Horton 1:32:26 Yeah, no.

Joe Rogan 1:32:26 You're crazy.

Scott Horton 1:32:28 He's-

Joe Rogan 1:32:28 All that stuff is so balanced

Scott Horton 1:32:29 ... just a smooth... Out of context stuff. Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:32:30 It's, it's so balanced and so o- objective and, you know, his perspective on it. And just people take that one thing that he said, uh, about, um, [lips smack] uh, fuck. Uh, Churchill. The thing that he said about Churchill being the real villain. He's being provocative, right?

Scott Horton 1:32:48 Right.

Joe Rogan 1:32:49 And what he's trying to say is that Churchill, by imposing those embargoes, essentially was starving them and was, was keeping resources from getting to Germany, and he forced Hitler's hand to do what he did. It's not excusing him. It's not like saying Hitler wasn't a fucking evil cunt. It's not, it's not like saying-

Scott Horton 1:33:11 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:33:11 ... he, he... Hitler's the good guy, but Winston Churchill's the bad guy. That's not what he was saying at all. But he was saying Winston Churchill, also a bad guy.

Scott Horton 1:33:19 Right.

Joe Rogan 1:33:19 Also wanted-

Scott Horton 1:33:20 He-

Joe Rogan 1:33:20 ... to attack Soviet Union right after they were done with the war.

Scott Horton 1:33:24 And he was actually... He even introduced the subject by saying to Tucker that, "You know, I like to pick on my friend Jocko, who's very WASPy, and I like to-

Joe Rogan 1:33:35 Yeah

Scott Horton 1:33:35 ... pick on him and joke with him that, you know, Churchill was the real bad guy," whatever-

Joe Rogan 1:33:39 Exactly

Scott Horton 1:33:40 ... 'cause, 'cause he wouldn't accept, you know, peace for an answer. He had to finish the regime change no matter what, even if it took America doing it for him and whatever. And then his point about... He never even finished the point about the people starving in the camps. He was totally taken out of context to mean that the only people who died in the Holocaust, all that happened was the Germans didn't care enough to feed them well enough or something. But that was not what he was saying at all. He was essentially arguing that even if you were some kind of German apologist, even you would have to admit that every single soul they took possession of, they took responsibility for. And if people are starving to death by the millions in their camps, then nobody could deny that, right? And then he didn't even discuss the rest of the Holocaust. His point had nothing to do with, like, trying to diminish the rest of it or discount the rest of it or anything like that. He was just saying, you know, arguing even the devil's advocate would have to admit so much of the case on the face of it. And then there, he was segueing right into a point about Gaza and how the Israelis... Gaza's not a country. Gaza is an Indian reservation. They were already whooped and conquered and besieged. And so you take control of people like that, then you're responsible to make sure that they're fed and that they're not starving to death in this, you know, under your captivity, which was the point that he was making. So it ended up being, you know, half, half of a thing in jest ab- and, and, and half explained about Churchill, and then a point about the war in the East that was totally, and I think in some cases, honestly misinterpreted. But, but what's dishonest is people pretending like he didn't explain himself on the record over and over and over, clarifying-

Joe Rogan 1:35:28 Agreed

Scott Horton 1:35:28 ... what he meant by all that stuff

Joe Rogan 1:35:29 Agreed. And that's the problem-

Scott Horton 1:35:30 Completely ridiculous

Joe Rogan 1:35:30 ... with video clips.

Scott Horton 1:35:32 Yeah, yeah. Totally.

Joe Rogan 1:35:32 You know, clips are a real problem-

Scott Horton 1:35:34 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:35:34 ... because you lose the context of the entire conversation. You get one person's point where they might be steel manning something else, or they might be, like, trying to be provocative or-

Scott Horton 1:35:42 Right

Joe Rogan 1:35:43 ... or whatever it is. But to me, it's always very fascinating that this one war is beyond debate. Like, there's no room for any discussions of what might be true, what might not be true. I don't think there's a single fucking moment in human history where we have gotten a completely objective, 100% accurate representation of why the war started, what were the factors, what were the motivations. We could go all the way back to Smedley Butler and Smedley Butler's War Is a Racket, which I always point out-

Scott Horton 1:36:17 Right

Joe Rogan 1:36:17 ... because here's a guy in 1933 that was realizing... He was a major general realizing at the end of his tenure, like, "Holy shit, what did I do?"

Scott Horton 1:36:27 Right.

Joe Rogan 1:36:27 "I thought that I was doing this to s- to make the world safer, and really I was making it better for bankers, better for all these interests to go in and control resources or do whatever the fuck they were actually doing."

Scott Horton 1:36:39 Mm-hmm.

Joe Rogan 1:36:40 And d- you can talk about that, but if you get into discussions about World War II and anything involving the Nazis, anything involving the Holocaust-

Scott Horton 1:36:49 Mm-hmm

Joe Rogan 1:36:49 ... anything, all of a sudden, antisemitic gets thrown around.

Scott Horton 1:36:52 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:36:52 All of a sudden, you're a, you're a bad person.

Scott Horton 1:36:54 Yeah. As he says, it's, you know, a huge part of our civic religion basically, um, you know, where, like, George Washington and even Abraham Lincoln and all that stuff is too long ago, where it's really Franklin Roosevelt and Harry Truman and Dwight Eisenhower are the founding fathers of the American empire, and their great project, the greatest generation and all of those things. That was... You know, that's-That's how we know that that's who we are. I mean, my grandfather was in that war, and my great-uncle was, you know, death marched by the Japanese in that war and stuff. Like, every- a lot of people have, uh, connections to that. It's, well, uh, as Bill Kristol and his friends would say, this is how you build national greatness. You need big projects that we can all do together, and World War II is the biggest project of all.

Joe Rogan 1:37:38 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:37:38 So it's the kinda thing that, that people don't really wanna question. And-

Joe Rogan 1:37:41 It's also, we should point out that they were bankrolling Smedley Butler, trying to get him-

Scott Horton 1:37:46 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:37:46 ... to overthrow the fucking government. They were trying to get-

Scott Horton 1:37:48 And he refused to do it.

Joe Rogan 1:37:49 Yeah.

Scott Horton 1:37:49 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:37:49 They were trying-

Scott Horton 1:37:49 He marched up Capitol Hill with the documents and-

Joe Rogan 1:37:52 Yeah

Scott Horton 1:37:52 ... and showed 'em, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:37:53 They were trying to get him to th- throw a military coup on the United States government and take it over.

Scott Horton 1:37:58 Yep. I mean, you thought FDR was bad, and these guys [laughs] wanted to overthrow him. He wasn't, you know-

Joe Rogan 1:38:03 Isn't that crazy?

Scott Horton 1:38:03 ... wrong faction, I guess. Um, but um, look, I'm not a expert on... And I, I've only read a few books about the Second World War, and you'd have to read hundreds to really know what you're talking about on that one. But I can tell you that-

Joe Rogan 1:38:15 Agreed

Scott Horton 1:38:15 ... Pat Buchanan's great book, Churchill, Hitler, and the Unnecessary War, that Pat knew that everybody was gonna try to smear him, and everyone was gonna attack him, and nobody wanted to hear his version of how this all happened. So he only quotes the highest level, most credentialed English historians from Cambridge and Oxford. And so he's not relying on the German point of view whatsoever. He's quoting only these English historians saying, "Here's how the idiot Neville Chamberlain and Winston Churchill essentially fumbled into this war, screwed up, and got us into this war that w- way worse than we ever could've hoped." And they ended up turning Poland over to the commies at the end anyway, and all of that. And it's really, honestly is, what I think it is, is a decent take on World War II without all that religiosity that you're referring to there, and just take a cold look at it. You know, like they say that W. Bush, he's the Winston Churchill of the 21st century, and I'm like, "You know what? Maybe that's right." [laughs]

Joe Rogan 1:39:16 [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:39:16 And maybe Winston Churchill was really just the George W. Bush of the 20th century. It's just you're supposed to never admit that or talk about that.

Joe Rogan 1:39:21 Who's Winston Churchill's Dick Cheney?

Scott Horton 1:39:24 Oh, yeah, that's a good question.

Joe Rogan 1:39:26 'Cause Dick Cheney-

Scott Horton 1:39:26 I don't know enough. But-

Joe Rogan 1:39:27 That was... Boy, that guy, he had no pulse for a while.

Scott Horton 1:39:31 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:39:32 You know, k-

Scott Horton 1:39:32 But he-

Joe Rogan 1:39:32 Is that not in the Bible or something? [laughs] Like, this guy-

Scott Horton 1:39:34 No, it, yeah, it should be

Joe Rogan 1:39:35 ... a fucking guy who wants war, who, uh, is giving no bid contrat- contracts to the company that he was the fucking CEO of-

Scott Horton 1:39:44 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:39:44 ... where they're going over there and fixing, for billions of dollars, shit that we blew up, and this guy doesn't even have a pulse.

Scott Horton 1:39:50 I know. That's really weird.

Joe Rogan 1:39:52 He had a fake heart.

Scott Horton 1:39:53 He lived so long too.

Joe Rogan 1:39:54 Woo, crazy.

Scott Horton 1:39:54 Like, only the good die young kinda thing, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:39:57 I mean, how many people dropped dead after COVID of heart attacks that were young and healthy?

Scott Horton 1:40:01 I know.

Joe Rogan 1:40:01 And this fucking guy-

Scott Horton 1:40:02 No

Joe Rogan 1:40:02 ... keep on trucking.

Scott Horton 1:40:04 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:40:04 Remember when he shot his friend in the face and his friend apologized?

Scott Horton 1:40:07 [laughs] Yeah. Yep.

Joe Rogan 1:40:10 He fucking... They were, they were doing, which is one of the most, uh, very... Uh, I'd say it's one of the hardest to, uh, argue in support of type of hunts. It's called a canned hunt.

Scott Horton 1:40:25 Uh-huh.

Joe Rogan 1:40:25 Do you know what it is?

Scott Horton 1:40:25 Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:40:26 Okay, so what it is is they just release these-

Scott Horton 1:40:28 Like in Gaza

Joe Rogan 1:40:29 ... ah, very similar. They just... Well, this is, you know, birds. They just release these birds from a cage, literally, and they fly, and then they shoot 'em out of the sky. And even then, he blasts his friend. And then he w- wouldn't do-

Scott Horton 1:40:42 Drinking and hunting

Joe Rogan 1:40:43 ... well-

Scott Horton 1:40:44 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:40:44 ... allegedly. So he wouldn't do any interviews or anything. He wouldn't talk to anybody for, like, 24 hours. And so he had to sober up or, you know, allegedly, or whatever, and then his friend was like, "Oh, it was a m- minor, minor misunderstanding."

Scott Horton 1:40:56 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:40:56 "You got a few pellets in my face. What the fuck?"

Scott Horton 1:40:58 "I'm very sorry if this reflected negatively on the vice president."

Joe Rogan 1:41:02 That's how gangster-

Scott Horton 1:41:02 "And my fault for putting my face there. I don't know." [laughs]

Joe Rogan 1:41:04 Isn't that amazing? No lawsuit, no nothing.

Scott Horton 1:41:07 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:41:07 Your friend shoots you in the face, no worries.

Scott Horton 1:41:09 And what angle exactly did he get shot that he was okay after that?

Joe Rogan 1:41:14 Well, you c- the thing about it is it's birdshot.

Scott Horton 1:41:16 It was just birdshot, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:41:17 And, um, if you... Birdshot spreads, right? And, uh, depending upon the distance and how far he was away from him-

Scott Horton 1:41:23 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:41:23 ... he could've just got clipped-

Scott Horton 1:41:24 Yeah, a few pellets, yeah

Joe Rogan 1:41:25 ... with a couple. It's most likely that's what happened-

Scott Horton 1:41:27 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:41:27 ... 'cause I think he was 70. You know, if you're 70, you get shot in the face with a shotgun, usually that's a wrap.

Scott Horton 1:41:32 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:41:32 So I, I think he just got clipped with a couple of pellets and the, you know...

Scott Horton 1:41:35 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:41:36 He probably should've just shut the fuck up and not reported it.

Scott Horton 1:41:39 Right.

Joe Rogan 1:41:39 I don't know how it even got out.

Scott Horton 1:41:41 He, he must've had to go to the hospital.

Joe Rogan 1:41:43 Yeah, he'd say, "I fucked up. I dropped my gun and it went off."

Scott Horton 1:41:46 Oh, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:41:46 Yeah, you don't-

Scott Horton 1:41:47 Vice-

Joe Rogan 1:41:48 Yeah

Scott Horton 1:41:48 ... the vice president shot me.

Joe Rogan 1:41:49 I mean-

Scott Horton 1:41:49 Don't tell the newspaper I said that

Joe Rogan 1:41:51 ... if that was my friend-

Scott Horton 1:41:53 [laughs]

Joe Rogan 1:41:53 ... you know, I would probably say, "Let's let it go."

Scott Horton 1:41:56 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:41:56 "Let's, let's figure this out."

Scott Horton 1:41:57 Man.

Joe Rogan 1:41:58 "You don't have to go to the fucking press."

Scott Horton 1:42:00 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:42:00 "Come on, bro."

Scott Horton 1:42:01 There's a guy who's-

Joe Rogan 1:42:01 "We're both hammered"

Scott Horton 1:42:02 ... killed and wounded a lot of people, that's for sure.

Joe Rogan 1:42:05 I know.

Scott Horton 1:42:05 Mostly vicariously, but not always.

Joe Rogan 1:42:07 Yes. Well, I mean, there's a special place in hell. It's just-

Scott Horton 1:42:10 He's there already

Joe Rogan 1:42:11 ... it's just w- it was so weird that that worked, you know?

Scott Horton 1:42:15 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:42:15 Just all of it, the no bid contracts, the, the fact that he was essentially running... And he, remember when he was in a bunker and Bush was running around like, "Where's Dick Cheney?"

Scott Horton 1:42:24 Yeah, he's out at Mount Weather. Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:42:24 He's in a bunker somewhere. Like, why is he in a bunker? Like, what do, what the fuck? That whole war was so weird.

Scott Horton 1:42:31 It was to pretend that there's a threat-

Joe Rogan 1:42:33 Yeah

Scott Horton 1:42:33 ... that there's a ongoing threat when there wasn't. So-

Joe Rogan 1:42:35 I had a bit about it in my act is, like, that the elites really have no idea how dumb people are, and the only way to find out how dumb people are is make a dumb guy president, and that that's what they did.

Scott Horton 1:42:45 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:42:45 And then when we went into a war, uh, with Iran, or with Iraq rather, like, how did, how did we, how did we justify that? And they bought that? How, what the fuck? And then the bit was like, "He won again?"

Scott Horton 1:42:59 Right, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:42:59 He won again.

Scott Horton 1:42:59 He got reelected on that, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:43:01 And then I go, there's someone sitting in the back of the room going, "I think we can go dumber." [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:43:06 [laughs] Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:43:08 That was, that was the idea of the bit is that this is the only way to find out how dumb we are.

Scott Horton 1:43:12 Right.

Joe Rogan 1:43:12 And, uh-

Scott Horton 1:43:12 Like that, um, Kurt Vonnegut story, uh, Harrison Bergeron, where there's, like, the ruling elite, but the president, I think it was the president, in the movie of it is Tim Curry or something, and he's just a total, like, buffoon, and it, they justThe, the real power's all behind the throne running things, you know

Joe Rogan 1:43:29 Well, my-

Scott Horton 1:43:30 The fourth branch

Joe Rogan 1:43:30 ... the, my favorite movie about that is Dr. Strangelove, 'cause it's like... 'Cause it's kind of humorous and, you know, it's... But the whole thing is like, oh my God, I think... When you see this Pete Hegseth thing-

Scott Horton 1:43:42 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:43:42 ... where these guys are talking about this, and this commander is saying that it's all to bring about Armageddon, it's, this is right out of-

Scott Horton 1:43:50 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:43:50 ... Dr. Strangelove.

Scott Horton 1:43:50 Yeah. No, you can tell, and this is one of the most dispiriting things, right, is when you can tell a lot of times when these people are talking that, wow, they're, he's really not lying. He really thinks that that stupid lie is true, and he's telling us what he thinks is true. Like, it's, you know, depending on their tone and the way they explain it, you can sometimes, like even with Donald Trump, like, it's possible he's even talked himself or allowed himself to be talked into believing that they really were making nuclear weapons, and that then they were gonna use them on us. I mean, that might just be the dumbest lie and he knows it, but-

Joe Rogan 1:44:20 Right, but if they did-

Scott Horton 1:44:21 ... certainly not true

Joe Rogan 1:44:22 ... have nuclear weapons, it would be a giant problem, 'cause the Iranian-

Scott Horton 1:44:24 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:44:24 ... government, just look what they've done to their people. Executed protesters. They, they've done some wild-

Scott Horton 1:44:29 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:44:29 ... shit.

Scott Horton 1:44:30 Nah, I don't know.

Joe Rogan 1:44:31 You don't think that's a big deal, what they've done to their protesters?

Scott Horton 1:44:33 No. In fact, that's what we got off on, uh, on, uh, Martyr Made there a minute ago, was because on our show he was saying right now, through their conventional power, and especially because W Bush gave their best friends Baghdad, Iran is by far the dominant power in the region, conventionally speaking, other than us. If they rush to an atom bomb, say to somehow deter us, which I don't think that would work, I think we'd just attack them if they really did it, we'd just attack them again. Um, but if they did somehow get an atomic bomb, well, then that would then incentivize all of the other powers, I mean, or other states on the GCC there, Saudi and Qatar and Bahrain and UAE, to get their own nukes. And at that point, Iran's entire strategic advantage is canceled, 'cause now they got nukes too, and so now nobody has a strategic advantage.

Joe Rogan 1:45:22 Right, but then, but no one can do to them what happened to them now if they had nukes.

Scott Horton 1:45:26 Maybe.

Joe Rogan 1:45:27 Like, this was the argument for Ukraine not-

Scott Horton 1:45:29 But that would include them ha-

Joe Rogan 1:45:30 ... disarming

Scott Horton 1:45:30 ... that would include them being able to deliver them to the United States as well. And I think... See, it's like this. Here's how it worked, okay? The Iranians, they're members of the Non-Proliferation Treaty going way back, and they had a safeguarded civilian nuclear program where the IAEA could verify they're not diverting their nuclear material.

Joe Rogan 1:45:47 How could they have verified this?

Scott Horton 1:45:48 Oh, it's just, it was-

Joe Rogan 1:45:49 If they have their bases all underground, I mean, are they-

Scott Horton 1:45:51 No, no, no, because all that stuff was open and declared and, and safeguarded by the IAEA. So they're enriching at two major facilities, at Fordow and Natanz, and then they follow the uranium from womb to tomb, from the mine through the conversion process-

Joe Rogan 1:46:05 Right, but how much oversight-

Scott Horton 1:46:06 ... through the enrichment

Joe Rogan 1:46:06 ... do they have of this? I mean, how-

Scott Horton 1:46:07 It-

Joe Rogan 1:46:07 ... how much of it could be done in secrecy?

Scott Horton 1:46:09 It, it was very robust, uh, up until, you know, last June.

Joe Rogan 1:46:13 Can I pause you there?

Scott Horton 1:46:13 Essentially, they were pro- proving the negative there.

Joe Rogan 1:46:16 Can I pause you there?

Scott Horton 1:46:16 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:46:16 Because they didn't know that the Iranians had the capacity to f- to... They, they sent one 4,000 kilometers, right? The Diego Garcia attack.

Scott Horton 1:46:26 Oh, the, yeah, the missile. Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:46:28 So those missiles had a far greater range than anything that they had declared.

Scott Horton 1:46:33 Actually, not quite, because, well, first of all, that's s- The missile stuff is totally separate from their safeguards agreement with the IAEA. They have nothing to do with that. But as far as the missiles, the only limit on their missile range previously was a political limit, and it was in-

Joe Rogan 1:46:48 Oh, it wasn't a capability?

Scott Horton 1:46:50 That's right. So they had-

Joe Rogan 1:46:50 So it wasn't that they stated that all we have is this?

Scott Horton 1:46:55 They, only previously, but then in October of, I'm pretty sure it was last October, in the aftermath of the June war, in, so then in October of '25, the ayatollah announced we're lifting our limit on the range of our missiles.

Joe Rogan 1:47:10 Oh.

Scott Horton 1:47:10 And they said that publicly, that they were doing that. And so-

Joe Rogan 1:47:13 So-

Scott Horton 1:47:14 And that was as a result, again, of this provocation of the war last June.

Joe Rogan 1:47:18 So it wasn't-

Scott Horton 1:47:18 And that's still separate from the nuclear stuff, though, but go ahead.

Joe Rogan 1:47:20 It wa- I'm sorry. So it wasn't-

Scott Horton 1:47:22 No, no, no

Joe Rogan 1:47:22 ... a capability thing.

Scott Horton 1:47:23 No, it was-

Joe Rogan 1:47:23 It was just a-

Scott Horton 1:47:24 Right

Joe Rogan 1:47:24 ... an agreement.

Scott Horton 1:47:25 Although they don't have the capability to launch a three-stage intercontinental ballistic missile to the United States of America. They can hit Israel, but they can do that with an intermediate-range missile.

Joe Rogan 1:47:34 But if they're cooperating with China, and China has that capability.

Scott Horton 1:47:38 Because Bill Clinton gave it to them, yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:47:40 Yikes.

Scott Horton 1:47:41 [laughs] Geez.

Joe Rogan 1:47:42 Jesus, why'd he do that?

Scott Horton 1:47:43 Oh, I love this story. For the money.

Joe Rogan 1:47:46 Oh.

Scott Horton 1:47:46 Um, if, if you remember the scandal-

Joe Rogan 1:47:48 Hey, hey

Scott Horton 1:47:49 ... of '96 and all the Chinese money in his campaign in '96, they spent all their money hyping, or, or all the media attention hyping up Charlie Trie and Johnny Chung, who were, like, low-level fundraisers who didn't have anything to do with anything, and then they framed an entirely innocent Taiwanese scientist named Wen Ho Lee, and the evil FBI persecuted poor Wen Ho Lee, and it was this huge distraction from what really happened, which was this Chinese Indonesian, um, billionaire named Riady, who was directly tied to Chinese intelligence. He got his guy, John Wong, appointed to the Commerce Department, where he was put in charge of licensing missile technology transfers to China, and they took that authority away from State and Defense and gave it to Commerce, and then John Wong was the guy who got to rubber-stamp those missile tran- uh, technology transfers. So then Hughes Aircraft and Loral Corporation then sent their very best three-stage rocket technology to China.

Joe Rogan 1:48:46 Oh, Jesus.

Scott Horton 1:48:46 'Cause it's cheaper to have them launch the satellites, you know. So th- they were not, I don't think, able to deliver hydrogen bombs to the United States before that.

Joe Rogan 1:48:55 Oh.

Scott Horton 1:48:55 And they were able to, 'cause, I mean, and for a few hundred thousand dollars or maybe a couple of million dollars or whatever they were able to buy this from Bill Clinton.

Joe Rogan 1:49:02 Jesus Christ.

Scott Horton 1:49:03 I know, crazy. But no, you're right, that, look, could China, could, could Iran, with Chinese help or whatever, someday be able to deliver a warhead here? Yes. However, uh, the much better solution to that certainly would have been, we, I know we can't go back, but certainly would have been just normalizing relations with Iran and just dealing with them. The reality was Iran's position was not that they were racing to a nuke. Their position was they had this safeguarded program where, again, the IAEA is essentially proving the negative. We know where all their uranium is. It's right where it's supposed to be, and they haven't taken it and diverted it yet, and we know how much they're enriching, and we know where it all goes. And soThere, so then Israel would say, "America, they're making nukes. If they have a nuclear program at all," this is the same during W. Bush, during Obama, this is true under Olmert as well as under Netanyahu, um, who's been in charge almost the entire time since Obama. Um, and the policy was, from the Israelis, "America, bomb them. They got a civilian program and you know that's just cover for they're gonna make nukes someday and they're gonna use them on us, so just go ahead and let's get them now." Then America would say, "No, we're not doing that." This is under W. Bush, again under Obama, um, under Trump one and under Biden. "No, we're not gonna just start a war. But we will warn the Iranians, don't you break out and try to make a nuke now, because if you do, then we will attack you, and we'll bomb your Manhattan Project before you can complete it and before you can get an atom bomb. We'll see you then."

Joe Rogan 1:50:39 But here's-

Scott Horton 1:50:39 And then the Iranians would say, "We're not making nukes, so don't attack us." And then the heavy implication was, "If you attack us, then we might make nukes." So they had a latent deterrent, right? A half-ass nuclear weapons deterrent. They proved that they had mastered the fuel cycle, that they could enrich uranium if they wanted to up to weapons grade. They never did. But they said, they were essentially saying, "We have a revolver in one pocket and bullets in the other. Let's not escalate this." And that could have and should have stood, except this is what, this is the answer to your question about how did they get us into this? 'Cause Netanyahu convinced Trump to change that line and to adopt the Israeli line, that for them to have a civilian nuclear program at all is equivalent to the exact same thing as them making nuclear weapons, and we're just not gonna allow that.

Joe Rogan 1:51:28 So how much understanding do we have of their capabilities, and how do we have that understanding? Like, how much do we know about their enrichment program? How much do we know about whether or not they're capable of making a weapon? 'Cause haven't they stated recently that they are capable of making a nuclear weapon?

Scott Horton 1:51:48 Well-

Joe Rogan 1:51:49 Do you think that's bluster?

Scott Horton 1:51:50 I think that was not a threat. I think what, in fact, if I, if I know the statement that you're talking about, they were saying, "Look, we're not making nukes, and the proof that we're not is the fact that we know how to, we could, and we're still not, and you can see all this time." They mastered the fuel cycle back in 2006.

Joe Rogan 1:52:04 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 1:52:05 Once you... Okay, so it's like this, and, and they have been set back on this. They got their facility, uh, blown up last June. But essentially you have, remember yellowcake? "Don't drop that shit."

Joe Rogan 1:52:18 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 1:52:18 Um, you have that refined yellowcake is refined uranium ore, then you convert that to uranium hexafluoride gas, and that's the stuff that you inject into the centrifuges. Then you have what's called a cascade of centrifuges, a whole bunch of them all connected together with tubes, and then you spin the, the uranium hexafluoride gas in the centrifuges, and you spin the U-238, which is heavier, out and away from the 235, which is the sweet stuff. And the more you enrich it, then, um, the more capable it is of being used for nukes. Well, is one way to put it, but so they would, they need, like, 3.6% U-235 for their electricity program. They need 20% U-235 for targets for their medical isotope reactors, for, like, cancer treatment radiation or, like, that radioactive dye that they put in people for, to see your circulatory system and stuff. But then to make weapons-grade uranium, you need typically above 90% pure uranium-235. In any case, once you spin it through the centrifuges to whatever stage of purity, then you gotta convert it back into a metal again, whether you're gonna make fuel rods or whether you're gonna try to make a bomb warhead out of it. So under the Obama deal of 2015, the JCPOA, it was really just a extra layer on top of the Non-Proliferation Treaty and on top of the safeguards agreement that we already had. But the way that was worked out was, a big part of it was that they would scale back their capability to enrich by shutting down, I think it was two-thirds of their centrifuges at Natanz, and then at Fordow, they would change it from a f- a production facility to just a research facility. And then whatever stockpile of uranium they came up with would be transferred out of the country to Russia, and they would turn it into fuel rods and send it back. That way, they had no stockpile that they could just quickly reintroduce into the centrifuges and enrich to a higher grade. They'd have to basically start at nothing again. And so under the theory and the way the scientists worked it out, that if they withdrew from the treaty, kicked the inspectors out of the country, and said, "We are now making atom bombs," it would take them a year to enrich enough uranium at weapons grade to make one bomb out of it. Then on top of that, you have to have the actual experts who know how to machine it into the exact, uh, specifications as, and how to detonate it and everything else. And the, the simpler the nuke, the harder it is to deliver. So typically, like, the Hiroshima bomb was a gun-type nuke where you just shoot, uh, one uranium pit into the other one, and which they didn't even test. The Trinity test was the Nagasaki bomb, basically. They knew it would work, but it was essentially a very heavy bomb and very difficult to deliver. And virtually all miniaturized, um, implosion bombs in the world that can ever be married to a missile, they're virtually all made out of plutonium. And they don't have a plutonium route to the bomb because under the Obama deal, they poured concrete into the Arak, that's A-R-A-K, which was supposed to be a heavy water reactor, which can produce weapons-grade plutonium as waste. But they poured concrete into that thing and shut it down completely before it was even open. Their reactor that they do have operating is at Bushehr, and it's a light water reactor, which means that it is possible for it to produce weapons-grade plutonium as waste, but it's much more difficult. They would have to shut it off all the time to harvest the stuff out of there and all of that. Under inspections, they can't do that.

Joe Rogan 1:55:43 So this is all monitored, we-

Scott Horton 1:55:44 This is all monitored. It's like if you had a gun shop and you have a ATF cop sitting at the bar stool. Well, unless he was fast and furious smuggling your guns to cartels.

Joe Rogan 1:55:52 [laughs]

Scott Horton 1:55:52 But as- assuming not that, but, like, assuming he was just a regular copLike, you can't accuse me of selling illegal laser rifles from my gun shop when I've got a cop sitting right here, and that's the deal here is they've got inspectors throughout the place. And then what happened was, so we had that perfect Mexican standoff, right? Where is- Israel's saying, "Bomb them, they're making nukes." We say, "No, we won't bomb them, but we will if they do." And them saying, "Don't bomb us 'cause we're not." Then Trump called their bluff last June. Really, Netanyahu did, and then Trump jumped in the thing, and they really did set their nuclear program back quite a bit. Now, I don't think there's any proof that they destroyed the centrifuges at Natanz and Fordow. They're deep underground, under granite, and very hard to get at. But they got the elevator shafts and they got the air shafts, and they, if anybody was working down there, they were buried alive. The Iranians were incentivized to move giant boulders in front of the doors to protect them from missiles and attack and stuff like that. But so, um, all the reporting is that the Natanz and Fordow facilities are essentially just frozen right now. There's nothing going on there. There's open source reporting from last November, and then there was a report of a, in the newspapers just two weeks ago or maybe three, um, based on classified information, that there's nothing going on there. They, um-

Joe Rogan 1:57:07 You know what my deep concern is?

Scott Horton 1:57:08 Okay.

Joe Rogan 1:57:09 No one said what you said to the president.

Scott Horton 1:57:13 Yeah. See? That's right.

Joe Rogan 1:57:15 Not, not only that-

Scott Horton 1:57:15 You're right

Joe Rogan 1:57:16 ... that the people, these elected officials and these appointed officials that get into positions around him, they don't know this.

Scott Horton 1:57:23 Right.

Joe Rogan 1:57:24 Which is crazy.

Scott Horton 1:57:25 Dude, I'll tell you what, that New York Times article, did you read that one where Netanyahu came and they sat across from each other at the table like this instead of Trump sitting at the head of the table, and Netanyahu gave him the whole presentation about how easy the war would be? Um, so as soon as he left, then they said everyone else at the table said, "Don't listen to him, boss. He's, he's blowing smoke, man, that this is gonna be so easy." Now, they didn't really tell him, "Don't do it," but they told him, "Don't trust Netanyahu and that it'll be a snap the way that he promises" and all that. But then, and look, it's Maggie Haberman and them at The New York Times. I mean, it seemed like a very well-reported story from, you know, the principals are talking to her about this stuff. Um, and-

Joe Rogan 1:58:04 Well, this is what Joe Kansas said as well, right?

Scott Horton 1:58:06 Yeah, so they, they go around the table and Rubio has his say, the vice president has his say, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and whoever, but none, as you just said, none of them say what I just said.

Joe Rogan 1:58:20 Right.

Scott Horton 1:58:20 And it really is, it's like a, it's like f- four or five dudes in a room who may or may not know very much about this really and, and, and talking about it, and none of them man enough to say like, "Mr. President, permission to speak freely here, sir. Don't make this mistake, buddy." You know what I mean?

Joe Rogan 1:58:40 But my fear is that they don't know as much as you know about it.

Scott Horton 1:58:42 I think they probably don't. I mean-

Joe Rogan 1:58:44 Which is wild

Scott Horton 1:58:45 ... I've been at this for a long time.

Joe Rogan 1:58:47 But that is wild.

Scott Horton 1:58:48 You know? Yeah.

Joe Rogan 1:58:48 That is really crazy that you'd be in a position of making these decisions without having this understanding of the fact that they're not even really capable right now of making nuclear weapons.

Scott Horton 1:58:58 If any of them were capable of really knowing about it like this, it would be Rubio or Vance, or hell, Cain too, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. He, all of these guys should have been able to say to the president, "This is an illusory threat, sir."

Joe Rogan 1:59:13 Wasn't Vance not there?

Scott Horton 1:59:13 Like, "This is really not right."

Joe Rogan 1:59:15 Wasn't Vance not there wh- while this was going on?

Scott Horton 1:59:17 Well, he, he was not there for the Netanyahu part, but then he came in later.

Joe Rogan 1:59:20 Right.

Scott Horton 1:59:20 Which, or what, he was in Azerbaijan preparing for the war, [laughs] right? Was, where he was is why he was late.

Joe Rogan 1:59:26 Well, wasn't, wasn't Azerbaijan, didn't they have some sort of a peace agreement with Armenia-

Scott Horton 1:59:31 Um

Joe Rogan 1:59:32 ... at the time?

Scott Horton 1:59:33 Oh, I don't know.

Joe Rogan 1:59:33 And he visited both of them?

Scott Horton 1:59:34 Oh, I don't know. I had missed that then. You're right then.

Joe Rogan 1:59:36 I think-

Scott Horton 1:59:36 I, I didn't know that

Joe Rogan 1:59:37 ... he visited both of them-

Scott Horton 1:59:38 Okay

Joe Rogan 1:59:39 ... and that's one of the reasons why he couldn't come back.

Scott Horton 1:59:41 Okay.

Joe Rogan 1:59:41 'Cause like if you visit Azerbaijan-

Scott Horton 1:59:41 I, I assumed he was in Azerbaijan as preparation for the war with Iran, but I guess not.

Joe Rogan 1:59:44 If you visit Azerbaijan-

Scott Horton 1:59:46 Yeah

Joe Rogan 1:59:46 ... you also have to visit Armenia, otherwise it would cause some sort of an international conflict, right?

Scott Horton 1:59:49 Sure. Yeah, because we support the hereditary dictatorship in Azerbaijan because they help us run the oil pipelines west instead of north through Russia.

Joe Rogan 1:59:57 But w- it was also because they had made some sort of a peace agreement, correct? Didn't Azerbaijan-

Scott Horton 2:00:02 I don't know

Joe Rogan 2:00:02 ... and Armenia make a-

Scott Horton 2:00:03 I mean, they're, possibly. I mean, they're, they're, they're fighting over, or the, the, the contest was over whether Armenia is going to open this corridor across Armenia to an Azerbaijani or-

Joe Rogan 2:00:15 Could you look that up, Jamie?

Scott Horton 2:00:15 ... yeah, an Azeri enclave on the Turkish border.

Joe Rogan 2:00:19 Okay. France, uh, met in Baku. [clears throat] JD Vance and, uh, how do you say his name? Aliyev, uh, met in Baku to descri- discuss the implementation of historic August 8 White House Peace Summit, and reaffirmed their shared commitment to regional peace, security, and prosperity. Leaders signed the US-Azerbaijan Strategic Partnership Charter, which will strengthen bilateral relations between our countries. The United States remains committed to working with Azerbaijan to unlock the great potential of the South Caucus region. So it was a peace summit, and so he met with Azerbaijan, and he also had to meet with Armenia as well. This was February 10th, so this is right before the war.

Scott Horton 2:01:02 Okay.

Joe Rogan 2:01:03 So yeah.

Scott Horton 2:01:04 I guess I thought he was, like, just tipping them off.

Joe Rogan 2:01:06 No.

Scott Horton 2:01:06 War on your southern border in a week or two.

Joe Rogan 2:01:08 I'm pretty sure-

Scott Horton 2:01:10 You know?

Joe Rogan 2:01:10 ... that the reason for this was that he had to meet with both of them, so he could not be there. So if I was JD Vance and I knew, or rather if I was Netanyahu and I knew that JD Vance was really not into this war and didn't wanna be a part of it at all-

Scott Horton 2:01:24 Right

Joe Rogan 2:01:24 ... I would probably try to-

Scott Horton 2:01:25 Time it for then, yeah

Joe Rogan 2:01:26 ... yeah. What a good time.

Scott Horton 2:01:27 That makes sense, yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:01:27 He can't even come back.

Scott Horton 2:01:28 Yeah, that makes sense.

Speaker 2:01:29 Read the top of the article here.

Joe Rogan 2:01:30 What does it say?

Speaker 2:01:31 That he was not there.

Joe Rogan 2:01:32 Ah, the gathering had been deliberately small to guard against leaks. Other top cabinet secretaries had no idea th- it was happening. Also absent was Vice President JD Vance, who was in Azerbaijan, and the meeting had been scheduled on such short notice that he was unable to make it back in time. Now, if I was Netanyahu and I knew that JD Vance is gonna be in Azerbaijan.

Scott Horton 2:01:55 You know, I don't really, you know, try to spend too much time on the symbolism of things, you know? Leave that to the symbol-minded, right? As Carlin would say.

Joe Rogan 2:02:03 Symbol-minded? [laughs]

Scott Horton 2:02:04 Yeah. But, like-Isn't it meaningful that this is the Situation Room? The president's supposed to sit at the head of the table. Instead, Netanyahu sat there and Trump sat here-

Joe Rogan 2:02:14 Hmm

Scott Horton 2:02:15 ... opposite him and let him run the thing as an equal instead of-

Joe Rogan 2:02:20 Why do you think that is? Why do you think they have-

Scott Horton 2:02:22 I don't know

Joe Rogan 2:02:22 ... that kind of influence?

Scott Horton 2:02:23 I really don't know.

Joe Rogan 2:02:24 Do you have a-

Scott Horton 2:02:24 I mean, they've been friends for a very long time. All the-

Joe Rogan 2:02:26 Reb-

Scott Horton 2:02:26 ... speculation about him being compromised, I mean, is very possible, but unknowable really, right? Netanyahu would do that. I mean, he, he brought up Monica Lewinsky to, to Bill Clinton.

Joe Rogan 2:02:37 Did he?

Scott Horton 2:02:37 Oh, yeah. You know we're tapping your phone, homeboy. We got you on tape. You better let Jonathan Pollard out of prison. And then Bill Clinton refused to do it because George Tenet and the whole top tier of the CIA were gonna resign over it if he did it, so he didn't do it. It was Trump that let Pollard out, and now Pollard is running to the right of Netanyahu. He's now announced that he's running for the Knesset over there.

Joe Rogan 2:02:58 So the reason why the Monica Lewinsky scandal went public?

Scott Horton 2:03:02 No, 'cause... No, no, no.

Joe Rogan 2:03:04 That was Linda Tripp-

Scott Horton 2:03:04 I don't think so

Joe Rogan 2:03:04 ... right?

Scott Horton 2:03:05 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:03:05 Netanyahu's said to have offered Lewinsky tapes for Pollard. Oh, they had tapes?

Scott Horton 2:03:12 What do you mean? They had the, like, recordings?

Joe Rogan 2:03:13 Saying, "Well, you were..."

Scott Horton 2:03:15 It may have been, it may have been after the scandal had broken, but they had him on tape with her, 'cause the only tapes were her on the phone with Linda Tripp, that Linda Tripp had recorded.

Joe Rogan 2:03:22 Right.

Scott Horton 2:03:23 But they had him-

Joe Rogan 2:03:24 Linda Tripp

Scott Horton 2:03:24 ... on the phone with her.

Joe Rogan 2:03:26 That's right. I forgot her name.

Scott Horton 2:03:27 You know, the story is, um, the first time Bill Clinton met Netanyahu in 1996, they were in the room for half an hour or something, and when they came out, Clinton was just completely exasperated and says, "Who the F does this guy think he is? Who's the superpower and who's the client state?" Because Netanyahu had just told him, like, "Look here, butler, here's your orders," for half an hour, just barked commands at Bill Clinton in a way that he was just like, "I can't believe this guy."

Joe Rogan 2:03:56 Wow.

Scott Horton 2:03:56 It's hard to feel sorry for him. In fact, here's one, too. Barack Obama was caught on a hot mic. This is the only time I've ever been sympathetic with Barack Obama. He was caught on a hot mic talking to the president of France, and he goes, "Oh, man, you think you hate him? I gotta deal with him every day."

Joe Rogan 2:04:13 And that was about Netanyahu?

Scott Horton 2:04:14 Yeah, about Netanyahu.

2:04:15 – 2:13:09

Israel’s undeclared nukes, JFK tensions, and the politics of taboo topics

Joe Rogan 2:04:15 Well, wasn't there an issue with JFK and Israel over their ability to acquire nuclear weapons?

Scott Horton 2:04:22 Yes.

Joe Rogan 2:04:23 So to this day-

Scott Horton 2:04:23 He was demanding inspections of Dimona, their nuclear facility there

Joe Rogan 2:04:27 ... s- to this day, they don't officially have nuclear weapons.

Scott Horton 2:04:31 Correct, and the reason for that is because it's illegal for America to give aid to a nuclear weapons state that refuses to sign the Non-Proliferation Treaty. And so... And they don't wanna do that. In fact, they did proliferate nuclear weapons to South Africa, who gave them up before the change after apartheid. Um, but if, if they're, if they openly possess nuclear weapons, then, I mean, hell, it should already be illegal 'cause everybody already knows. But the Glenn Symington law says that you can't give aid, military aid, to a nuclear weapons state that won't sign the NPT. That's America's treaty that we forced the whole world to accept, and which, by the way, is in terrible jeopardy now. Right? Because, you know, um, Saddam Hussein goes, "Look, my hands are up. I got nothing." They invaded him anyway. The North Koreans armed up with nukes. The Libyans said, "Well, look, we have some centrifuge material, but we have no operational program, but you can have our junk." They killed him. And then the Iranians said, "Look, we can make nukes, but we're not making nukes, so leave us alone already," and then we kill them. So America is the great destroyer of America's Non-Proliferation Treaty that we foisted on the world, by which the non-nuclear weapons state promised, the non-nuclear weapons states promised never to get them, and the nuclear weapons states promised never to share them.

Joe Rogan 2:05:56 So-

Scott Horton 2:05:57 And that's all in jeopardy now. That may not even exist anymore. The Poles are talking about getting their own nukes now because of Trump's pivot away from Europe in the middle of a war that America helped cause over there.

Joe Rogan 2:06:09 Jesus. So Israel officially doesn't have nukes?

Scott Horton 2:06:13 Officially they don't, but everybody knows that they have at least 200. And in fact, I have that personally from Mordechai Vanunu, who is the Israeli whistleblower who went to prison. They kidnapped him in a honey trap plot, I think in, in England or in Italy.

Joe Rogan 2:06:27 With chicks? Was it a honey trap?

Scott Horton 2:06:28 With chicks, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:06:29 It's always chicks. [laughs]

Scott Horton 2:06:29 They, they went to get him laid, and they kidnapped him-

Joe Rogan 2:06:31 [laughs]

Scott Horton 2:06:31 ... and they held him in solitary confinement for like 25 years or something.

Joe Rogan 2:06:35 Wow.

Scott Horton 2:06:35 But he gave the whole story to The Sunday Times, The London Times, and they published it back in, I'm gonna say '86. And then, um, what happened was he was on Twitter. He may still be on Twitter. Um, but, um, I had an anecdote from Daniel Ellsberg, the great, uh, whistleblower of the Pentagon Papers, and who was a friend of mine for a long time. He died a couple years ago now. But, um, he had an anecdote about Vanunu that turned out was incorrect, but I asked Vanunu, "Is this correct?" And then he said, "No, it's just like I told The Sunday Times back then," and that was that they had 200 atom bombs by the time that he squealed on them. And we know from Grant F. Smith's research, he got this through some FOIA documents. Um, he's from the Institute for Research: Middle Eastern Policy. Really great researcher on this. And he showed that they had at least been researching hydrogen bombs, the big ones, although there's no proof that they ever actually made H-bombs. And I don't think it's been reported that they've made them, but they at least were looking into how to.

Joe Rogan 2:07:36 Jeez. And this was part of the conflict that JFK had with Israel, right?

Scott Horton 2:07:42 Yes, in trying to register what was then, I think, the American Jewish Council, I believe is what it was called, the, the predecessor to AIPAC, as a foreign, as foreign agents, and then they dissolved it and created AIPAC instead, I guess, is the long and the short of that, how they got around that.

Joe Rogan 2:07:59 And they got whacked.

Scott Horton 2:07:59 And there are people... You know, and it was... You know, I don't know, man. Honestly, like I told you, I was more of a conspiracy theorist in the '90s, but I never did all read into JFK because there's just 100 books about it and 100 different theories, and I'm just not sure if LBJ hired French hitmen to do it, or if the Israelis got James Jesus Angleton to do it, or if Allen Dulles got some Cubans to do it, or what the hell, right? Like, I don't know. And so it's, um, I really get-You know, I'm, uh... I don't, I don't think I ever really could figure it out, so-

Joe Rogan 2:08:31 Well, no one really has

Scott Horton 2:08:32 ... I just kinda-

Joe Rogan 2:08:32 There's a bunch of speculation

Scott Horton 2:08:32 ... leave that one alone.

Joe Rogan 2:08:34 But Oliver Stone is the-

Scott Horton 2:08:35 There are a lot of people-

Joe Rogan 2:08:35 ... best guy to talk to

Scott Horton 2:08:35 ... with motive. Yeah. You know what's funny about that? And I think he even admitted this at one point, man. You watch the whole movie JFK. Oh, God. You watch the whole movie JFK, and... I'm sorry, man.

Joe Rogan 2:08:46 No worries. It's just Dr. Pepper. I like the little stains on this table.

Scott Horton 2:08:49 There you go. In the-

Joe Rogan 2:08:50 Makes it live.

Scott Horton 2:08:51 In the edit later, we'll just clip-

Joe Rogan 2:08:53 No

Scott Horton 2:08:53 ... to Joe and back, and then we'll clip-

Joe Rogan 2:08:54 No, we'll just show the Dr. Pepper.

Scott Horton 2:08:56 [laughs]

Joe Rogan 2:08:56 Why Dr. Pepper? Why are you so into Dr. Pepper?

Scott Horton 2:08:58 Oh, it's so good.

Joe Rogan 2:08:58 You br- he... I should tell everybody, he brought a whole cooler filled with Dr. Pepper.

Scott Horton 2:09:02 I gotta have Dr. Pepper, man, for my-

Joe Rogan 2:09:04 [laughs]

Scott Horton 2:09:05 ... just gotta work here. Um, no, the, um, the, uh... You watch the whole movie JFK, right?

Joe Rogan 2:09:11 Mm-hmm.

Scott Horton 2:09:11 It's got every theory under the sun in there, and then as soon as it's over, it says, "Produced by Arnon Milchan," who is an Israeli spy, and who helped Benjamin Netanyahu steal krytrons, which are an essential part of these nuclear triggers-

Joe Rogan 2:09:26 That's who produced the movie?

Scott Horton 2:09:26 ... for their weapons. That's who produced the movie.

Joe Rogan 2:09:29 [laughs]

Scott Horton 2:09:29 And so then someone asked Oliver Stone, like, "Hey, man, an Israeli spy produced your movie where you point the finger at everyone except maybe the Israelis. What's about that?" And he's like, "Wow, you're right." And I, I forgot exactly how he says it, but he acknowledges that, "You know what? Like, it could've been even that my own film was part of... uh, put on there."

Joe Rogan 2:09:49 Well, especially when you consider-

Scott Horton 2:09:50 You know, that's funny

Joe Rogan 2:09:50 ... the fact that his own film was made in, what? The '90s?

Scott Horton 2:09:54 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:09:54 Yeah.

Scott Horton 2:09:54 It came out in, like, '91, I think.

Joe Rogan 2:09:55 Right.

Scott Horton 2:09:56 '90, '91.

Joe Rogan 2:09:56 So back then, he probably didn't know as much as he knows now.

Scott Horton 2:10:00 Right. Yeah, probably never even heard the angle that-

Joe Rogan 2:10:02 Right

Scott Horton 2:10:03 ... it would've been the Israelis.

Joe Rogan 2:10:04 Right.

Scott Horton 2:10:04 But of course, you know, uh, LBJ was very close to the Zionists, and even had a Mossad agent for a girlfriend. I'm sorry, I forget her name, but one of his mistresses was a Mossad agent, and then-

Joe Rogan 2:10:14 Holo-

Scott Horton 2:10:14 ... he, he completely reversed all those policies as soon as he-

Joe Rogan 2:10:18 Wow

Scott Horton 2:10:18 ... was in power. But of course, same thing with Vietnam. He reversed, well, or at least released any skepticism about Vietnam and said, "Let's go ahead and escalate there," and all that. So like I say, that one's... it's too muddy for me to try to wade through and, and figure out exactly who-

Joe Rogan 2:10:32 God, it's all so-

Scott Horton 2:10:33 ... pulled the trigger on that one

Joe Rogan 2:10:34 ... crazy. The not so secret life of, uh, Matilda? Is that how you say her name? Matilda Krim?

Scott Horton 2:10:43 Think so.

Joe Rogan 2:10:43 That was his Israeli spy girlfriend?

Scott Horton 2:10:46 Uh, yeah, I believe that's her.

Joe Rogan 2:10:48 She looks like a dirty girl.

Scott Horton 2:10:48 Good old Phil Weiss. I love that guy. He's a great guy. That's, uh-

Joe Rogan 2:10:51 Interesting

Scott Horton 2:10:51 ... mondoweiss.net is a great website for anti-Zionist, uh-

Joe Rogan 2:10:55 The no daylight policy-

Scott Horton 2:10:56 ... activities

Joe Rogan 2:10:57 ... the US alignment with the Israeli government. So obviously today, in J- in Trump's deference to Netanyahu, was born under Matilda Krim's dear friend Lyndon Johnson. In the feverish weeks surrounding the 1967 war, Krim, who had once emigrated to Israel, and her husband Arthur, a leading fundraiser, were continually at Johnson's side and advised him on what to say publicly. I mean, you gotta give it up to a country the size of Rhode Island that has that kind of fucking pull all over the world.

Scott Horton 2:11:26 They got their priorities straight, that's for sure.

Joe Rogan 2:11:28 Kind of amazing-

Scott Horton 2:11:29 You know? Yeah

Joe Rogan 2:11:29 ... that they've been doing this since the '60s and before.

Scott Horton 2:11:33 Yep.

Joe Rogan 2:11:33 I mean-

Scott Horton 2:11:34 I mean, they threatened Harry Truman. They bribed him, and they also threatened him. They sent... His, his daughter's memoir said the Zionists sent letter bombs to the White House, and they'd stop at nothing to get their state.

Joe Rogan 2:11:45 Truman?

Scott Horton 2:11:46 Yeah.

Joe Rogan 2:11:46 Wow.

Scott Horton 2:11:47 And, and they paid-

Joe Rogan 2:11:48 I had never heard that

Scott Horton 2:11:48 ... for his re-election, too. In fact, um, there's a great scholar named, um, John B. Judis, uh, J-U-D-I-S, and he wrote a book about this.

Joe Rogan 2:11:58 What an unfortunate name.

Scott Horton 2:11:59 Uh, yeah, kinda.

Joe Rogan 2:12:01 [laughs]

Scott Horton 2:12:01 If you mispronounce it, you know. He actually also wrote, uh, as long as I'm talking about him, he wrote a great article for Foreign Affairs in 1995 about the neoconservatives called From Trotskyism to Anachronism, and it was about how now that the Cold War's over, who needs these crazy hawks anymore, right? And then these are the guys who took us, who launched the Iraq War, you know, a few years later, uh, seven years later or whatever. He was, he was saying, "They're a spent force. They should be by now," 'cause they had been Trotskyite communists, and then had moved to the right for the militarism and stuff. But he wrote a book about how Truman did this, and, and I think that was part of it, was this intimidation campaign, and it was his own daughter that, in her book, in her memoir, said that they sent, uh, letter bombs to the White House to intimidate.

Joe Rogan 2:12:45 Good Lord.

Scott Horton 2:12:45 And, and they also paid for his election, so it was, you know, carrot and stick kind of a thing. And then, yeah, look, if you ran the Israeli Foreign Ministry, you only have one priority in the world that outranks every other priority by a million billion-

Joe Rogan 2:12:58 Right

Scott Horton 2:12:58 ... and that is your relationship with the United States of America. How friendly is the president? How friendly is the Senate? What do we gotta do to make sure that everything stays in line? It's everything to them.

2:13:09 – 2:28:27

What comes next for Iran: deterrence, proliferation risk, and the 'just come home' argument

Joe Rogan 2:13:09 So let me ask you this. How... What do you think happens with Iran now? Like, how does this-

Scott Horton 2:13:13 Oh, man

Joe Rogan 2:13:13 ... play out, if you had to speculate?

Scott Horton 2:13:17 Well, I'll tell you that, first of all, they're more likely to go ahead and try to break out and make an atom bomb now than ever before, although I'm not necessarily predicting that. I think, you know, Trump has proven by calling their bluff on their latent deterrent, he has proven he's willing to bomb them, and if they really break out and try to make a nuclear weapon, it's almost impossible that they could do that without us knowing. And then this president, and I think the next one, too, would be willing to go back to war over it, as Barack Obama promised he would absolutely launch a war against Iran if they broke out and tried to make an atom bomb. And, you know, he did an interview with Jeffrey Goldberg in The Atlantic called As President, I Don't Bluff, where he's essentially begging Jeffrey Goldberg to tell Netanyahu and them, "I really, really mean it. If they try to make a nuke, I will bomb them, but just let me try to solve this another way." So I think that promise stands. This is the same as W. Bush, same as Obama, same as Biden, and I think that will continue to last into the next presidency. And if the Iranians are smart, what they'll do is they'll hold the same posture they've had, which is, "We're not giving up enrichment, and we're not giving up our capability to make a bomb one day, but we're never gonna call it that, and just don't do this to us anymore," and try to bet on the fact that Trump's only got three years left, and the next presidents won't be so belligerent, and they won't call the bluff or, and, and go ahead and launch another war unless they break out and try to make a nuke. And as Darryl was sayingThey're so much more powerful than all their neighbors conventionally, they really have no need to make a nuclear bomb. And they can, I think, successfully deter Israel even with their conventional missile force, and we saw them just- Yeah ... absolutely blast the crap out of Tel Aviv. Yeah. So I- Very un- underreported, right? Yeah. And, and I think, you know, they should not have killed the conservative old ayatollah, right? And they kill him, and apparently, like, the, the new ayatollah, his son, they killed his mother and sister and... or mother and wife and baby. I mean, that's the new ayatollah over there, is, you know, he's got to be more radical than his father. He's got to be angrier at us than his father ever was. And- So what is the pathway- So- ... to resolution? Well, this is... It's so unfortunate because honestly, um, you know, whatever, maybe some genius at some think tank has a better idea, but I really think that the thing to do is just quit. The thing to do is for America to just come home, for Trump to say, "Look- Cut their losses ... I won." Yeah. But we don't really need these bases over there. The American people don't need to dominate the Middle East. We're not worried about the Soviet Union invading Iran and dominating the Gulf anymore, so forget the Carter Doctrine. Let's just come home. And I think if we do that, we s- we bring all of our ships home, all of our planes, all of our bases, just close them all up and come home, then that shifts the entire burden onto Iran, that they still have to deal with the rest of Eurasia. We're not the one dependent on their hydrocarbon exports. Everybody else is. So are they going to now levy a tax to get through the Strait of Hormuz? Absolutely, but too bad. Shouldn't have started this war then. Nothing we can do about that now, Willie Nelson said, you know? So, like, the way going forward is... And by the way, like, in, in Panama, they tax, um, ships going through the isthmus there, through the Panama Canal. The Indonesians, I believe it is, uh, tax people going through some of the bottlenecks in the Indies. And so it's not entirely unheard of that, you know, the, the dominant power there is going to, uh, levy a fee on people coming in and out of there. But again, too late. Too bad. I mean, America already, we had the... Exactly what Marco Rubio says he wants now, we had on February the 27th, and then they launched this war on the 28th, which by the way, was the anniversary of the Waco raid. This is a pretty ugly time to start an aggressive war. And in fact, as long as I'm on that, and I know you know this, but it's really worth dwelling on, that they killed not just one but two girls' schools in their initial assault. They killed, in one building, they killed 100 and, I think, 73 or 74, uh, almost all little girls. And then in the other one was 20 more. And with, and with that was an experimental new Lockheed missile that fires tungsten pellets out the front before it detonates, uh, or as it detonates, uh, in a creative new way to cut people to shreds. And the thing is about that is as, um, there's this great media critic, um, named Adam Johnson who pointed out this is equivalent to the Oklahoma City bombing, which, you know, for young people, uh, Oklahoma was 9/11 before 9/11, right? It was massive. And never mind, it was a bunch of FBI informants who did it and got away with it. That's another interview, Joe. But, but it was 100- That is another interview, and that's a deep one. Yeah, it is, and- Just the- I'm here for you, buddy. Yeah. But yeah. But, but they killed 167 people, were killed in that thing, and it was just the ugliest damn thing, and it included, like, 20 kids in the daycare there, right? That was the cover of Newsweek, was a firefighter hol- holding a dead baby. It's the worst thing. This is the most traumatic thing for this country, and in the heartland of Oklahoma City and all that. Well, that's what America did to Iran, only the entire building full of kids, all 167 of them, a, a few teachers, but virtually all of them little girls. And another school down the street, too, or relatively nearby, where they... at the volleyball game, where they killed even more. So now think about the Pearl Harbor attack, which Donald Trump himself compared it to Pearl Harbor, out of context, but still, it was a sneak surprise attack in the middle of negotiations on behalf of a foreign country over a lie, and then they killed a bunch of kids. It's like imagine if at Pearl Harbor, if our story of Pearl Harbor was that they sank all our heroes and drowned them down in their ships, in the hulls, stuck in their hulls down there, but also they wiped out schools full of 180 little girls, the children of those sailors who drown at Pearl Harbor. Oh, and also they killed FDR that same day, too. Oh, and also it was a Catholic country, and he's also the pope. Imagine how we would react to that. Imagine what our story of Pearl Harbor to this day would be. I'll tell you what our story of, of World War II would be. It would be that we kept nuking them till they were all dead, is what our story of World War II would be if that's how they had done us at Pearl Harbor. It's just somehow we just don't really think of it in that context, but we should. If that had happened to us, again, just like we, you know, uh, we did a little on Ukraine there and the way America just absolutely pushes their luck. If Russia overthrew the government of Canada twice in 10 years 'cause they kept voting wrong, we would invade Canada and nuke Moscow. And in fact, when you bring up the analogy, it's completely absurd, right? How ridiculous is it that the Russians would dare try to overthrow the regime in Ottawa, that they would dare threaten to try to kick us out of our bases in Alaska or any of these kinds of things, that they would go to war with the people of Vancouver who refuse to accept the new coup junta. It's comic book crazy. They wouldn't dare. But we do that to them, you know? And we act like, as, as Dr. Paul said, if we go around the world killing people like this, bombing people like this, and we think that we can just get away with it and not have to suffer the blowback, then we do that at our own peril. And he was speaking for the government as a member of Congress at the time, that we're putting the American people in danger.By acting this way. It's completely crazy. You know, the... Remember the, the f- um, the Shiite fatwa that the old ayatollah, the ayatollah before last, last, uh, Khomeini put on Salman Rushdie, the author of the book The Satanic Verses, where people in s- people have tried to kill him numerous times, including got his eyeball in, in one case. Um, we've had a real problem with bin Ladenite jihadi terrorism over the time. We have not had the Shiites, we have not had the Ayatollah Sistani in Iraq or the Ayatollah Khamenei declare that all good believers should attack the West now. They could do that. And that's the kind of fire that we're playing with. It's extremely dangerous. I mean, bin Laden didn't even really have a religious rank. He was just a rich guy who, he had earned respect 'cause he was wounded in battle and stuff. He had money and, and influence. But if the Ayatollah Sistani put out a full jihad, which I'm not saying he would do that. I don't, I don't have any real reason to believe that he would go that far. But he's been willing to stand up to the United States numerous times, especially during the war, um, in, you know, the last couple of wars over there. And so, and remember what happened. The night that they started this war, on the February the 28th, the next day, on Saturday the 29th... Or was it, I think it was Friday was the 28th, and it was, like, late in the night they started the war, and then Saturday, I believe, was the 29th, and a, uh, an American, uh, immigrant from Sierra Leone here in Austin took an AR-15, put on a shirt with the ayatollah and an Iranian flag on it. I didn't even know they had Shiites in Sierra Leone, Joe, but I guess they do. And he went down to 6th Street and, and he shot 18 people. He killed three and wounded 15 people in an immediate blowback terrorist attack called backdraft. I, I coined the phrase in my book that, and if blowback means long-term consequences from secret foreign policies that the American people then don't understand and are left up to false explanations or left susceptible to false ex- explanations, well, then backdraft terrorism is when the consequences of your overt foreign policies just blow up right in your face. And, you know, frankly, like, those three people were crucified for Israel, for their sins, for, for... And 15 more wounded, and I don't know how terribly wounded. For all I know, people are still in the hospital over that thing. And that was a immediate blowback terrorist attack from this war, just right away. And, and it's the kind of danger that our government is, continues to put us in through these interventions over there. At some point, you know, all the sort of, um, hypotheticals about, "Yeah, but what if Russia took over the world?" or, "What if China did if it wasn't us?" or whatever, those have got to just kinda fall away, you know, by the wayside. There's no real reason to fear that in the first place, but also, who in the hell are we to stop it at this point, right? Another South Park reference. When Cartman is so scared by the Chinese display at the Olympics ceremony, he gets all paranoid that China's coming for us, so he recruits Butters to come with him to fight and keep all the Chinese away. And then over and over again throughout the episode, Butters keeps, like, closing his eyes and shooting some guy accidentally in the dick, just over and over again. And then by the end of the episode, Cartman says, "You know what? Just forget it, okay? If that's the best you can do, Butters, let's just stop." We're just going around... We're... This is not working, our intervention. It's just not.

Joe Rogan 2:24:31 What do you predict is gonna happen with Iran?

Scott Horton 2:24:35 I don't know. I'm really worried. I mean, I try not to take Trump too seriously when he's... You know, or too literally when he's being hyperbolic. But he has threatened to nuke them over and over again, including just the other day. He said, "The country's gonna have a glow around it, you know, when I'm done with them," or whatever, something very close to that.

Joe Rogan 2:24:52 Do you really think he would do that?

Scott Horton 2:24:54 I mean, I've... No. No, I don't. I'm not predicting that. But I think it's a s- it's symbolic, right, of his frustration. He absolutely just should not have done this, and now he has no good way out of it, right? He could just declare victory and it would be fine by me. In fact, there was this story in the Jerusalem Post, um, the end of April, I think, I think it was, like, April 28th, about how Trump ordered the intelligence agencies to do an estimate about what would happen if I just walked away, right? And then they're looking into it. Well, just how bad will Iran exploit the new vacuum that we've created and the power and influence that we're handing to them? How bad will it really be? Because he has no options to fix it. He just doesn't. You want a regime change in Tehran, you can drop a hydrogen bomb on the capital city and kill 10 million people and then claim the desolation is peace, or you can just forget it. And, like, man, you know what? W- we're all tough and badass enough to kill all these people. W- we should be tough enough to admit when we screwed up then. Look at Afghanistan. We stayed for 20 years because Washington couldn't admit that we can't win this war. There's only one way to tame the Pashtuns, and that is kill them all, and we're not willing to do that. So what are we doing? W- we're just losing slowly. And then what do they do? They finally admitted it. They finally just said, "Fine, I guess we lost," and left. That's what we gotta do here, but sooner is better.

Joe Rogan 2:26:22 Do you think that it's possible that this war will go on to the end of his regime and then whoever comes into power in 2028 then gets out?

Scott Horton 2:26:31 God, I hope not. I, I can't imagine what's gonna happen if this c- thing keeps on for three years, you know? This is a real flaw in our system, quite frankly, is, like, if we had a parliament, we could just vote no confidence in this guy and put a new guy in there whose fault this isn't and try to get him to resolve it. Instead, all we can do is wait three years, wait for him to f- keel over of a heart attack, or wait for his own cabinet to overthrow him in the name of him being, you know, too demented to continue, which is not going to happen. Um, you know, that 25th Amendment, they always invoke that like they could do a coup against him for being a Russian agent or whatever back in his first term. But you can't do that-

Joe Rogan 2:27:08 Look, if they didn't do it with Biden-

Scott Horton 2:27:09 Yeah, if they didn't do it with Biden-

Joe Rogan 2:27:10 Yeah

Scott Horton 2:27:10 ... he would have to be completely off his rocker and, and to, to a degree where his own cabinet is going to agree to overthrow him, which I just think is virtually impossible. SoThe good news is, right, is that he's, he, he could just flip-flop on anything, right? He can just change his mind about anything. In fact, when he announced the ceasefire, he said, "We're gonna n- we're going to negotiate based on Iran's 11-point proposal." [laughs] Like, okay, man, fine, right? Go from unconditional surrender to surrendering unconditionally. Like, call it whatever you want, and, and he, he is good at that. You could call that a gift if you want to politically-

Joe Rogan 2:27:45 Spinning it

Scott Horton 2:27:45 ... that he can just pretend like, "Yeah, no, I meant to do that."

Joe Rogan 2:27:48 So what is the hold up? Like, what are, what are they disagreeing on?

Scott Horton 2:27:51 Well, he's gotta deal with Netanyahu, right? The Master Blaster thing, you know, from Thunderdome on his back shouting in his ear what he's gotta do and what he's gotta not do. In the 60 Minutes interview, uh, he tells the, the, um, Major Garrett that, you know, uh, "We're not done. The war's not over until we get that uranium." And Garrett says, "Well, how are we gonna get it?" He says, "Trump promised me. He wants to get it. He's going to get it." And, and of course, they have this, it... Ever since they announced the ceasefire, the Israelis immediately escalated their bombing campaign in Lebanon just to destroy the ceasefire.

The published transcript ends here. Continue watching on YouTube

Episode duration: 2:35:24

In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen

Transcript of episode KBNfvk5Ali0

Get more out of YouTube videos.

Read along on your phone, search it beside the video, or ask your favorite AI app what was said.