By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
Lewis HowesMillions Say 'The Chosen' Changed Their Lives & I Still Ask Why Me | Jonathan Roumie
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howCHAPTERS
Jump to publisher timestampsChapter summaries
Rock bottom in 2018: broke, overdrawn, and ready to surrender
Jonathan describes waking up in May 2018 with no money, no work prospects, and a sense of total collapse. He recounts surrendering his life and career to God and feeling an immediate internal lightness afterward.
- •He woke up $80 overdrawn with $20 left and no prospects for work
- •He wept and offered a full surrender to God
- •He describes feeling “100 pounds lighter” right after surrendering
- •Lewis frames him as the actor who plays Jesus in The Chosen and introduces his story arc
Two decades in the making: moving to LA and committing to the long game
Jonathan and Lewis outline how long Jonathan pursued acting before The Chosen, including the decision to move to LA and go “all in.” Jonathan emphasizes that the path was closer to 20 years from his first booked work to the breakthrough call.
- •Jonathan clarifies he was in LA about eight years, though it felt longer
- •He traces the journey back to nearly 20 years since his first paid voice acting job
- •He describes moving to LA as committing to give the dream everything he had
- •Lewis highlights how close he was to quitting before the turning point
Quitting vs. surrendering: holding the dream differently
Lewis asks what made Jonathan’s moment a surrender rather than giving up. Jonathan explains surrender as keeping the possibility alive while releasing control over how it must happen, and explicitly entrusting the dream to God.
- •Surrender means the goal may still be possible, just not in the way you imagined
- •Jonathan didn’t abandon acting; he “gave it to God”
- •He asked God to change his desires if acting wasn’t the path
- •He reflects on people who love their work and the joy of genuine vocation
Faith at a distance: realizing he kept God out of his career
Jonathan explains that while he practiced his faith, it didn’t fully inform every part of his life. He describes relying on himself, staying anxious and control-driven, and not asking whether acting was what God wanted for him.
- •He describes being a faithful Catholic but “not converted here” in a deeper way
- •He admits he prayed for roles but still relied primarily on himself
- •He connects anxiety and control to leaving God out of the career process
- •He realizes he never truly asked, “Is this what you want from me?”
The day everything shifted: knees on the floor and a total offering
Jonathan gives the detailed story of the surrender morning: side jobs drying up, credit cards maxed, food running out, and panic setting in. He recounts dropping to his knees before a crucifix and offering God his entire life, career, and future direction.
- •He lists the survival jobs he worked to stay afloat (rideshare, deliveries, painting, coaching, catering, stand-in work)
- •Work abruptly dried up, intensifying fear and uncertainty
- •He prayed directly and asked God to show him a different path if needed
- •He describes trusting God and experiencing immediate relief after surrender
Four checks in the mailbox: timing, tears, and a new perspective
Jonathan recounts spending his last money on breakfast, returning home calm, and then finding four checks in his mailbox. He records himself opening them, watches the amounts increase, and ends with $1,100—an event he experiences as a clear response tied to his internal change.
- •He describes feeling unusually carefree after surrendering
- •He finds four checks and documents the moment with photos and video
- •One check was a small church reimbursement; others were unexpected
- •He ends up with $1,100 and describes it as life-changing at that moment
- •He interprets it as confirmation that he needed to live for God, not himself
Coincidence or sign: answering skeptics and redefining who he serves
Lewis raises the skeptical interpretation that the checks would have arrived anyway. Jonathan responds that it was a unique event and, more importantly, it triggered a lasting perspective shift: his life is not his own, and he is here to serve God.
- •Lewis challenges how to distinguish divine timing from coincidence
- •Jonathan says nothing like it had happened before or since
- •He describes a “fundamental change” that shaped everything afterward
- •He states: his life is not his own; he’s here to serve God
- •He notes he previously kept faith and career separate and private
Cast three months later: why surrender had to come first
Jonathan says that three months after the surrender and checks, he was called and cast in The Chosen. He tells Lewis he believes he would not have gotten the role without the spiritual change, because playing Christ requires real humility rather than self-rule.
- •He connects the casting call to the earlier surrender as “irrefutable evidence”
- •He believes the role would not have come without inner change
- •He frames humility as essential to portraying Christ authentically
- •He contrasts being broke with being humble, arguing control can still be pride
- •Lewis asks about ego after fame; Jonathan emphasizes the role is “about Him”
When fans see Jesus, not Jonathan: staying grounded in public encounters
Jonathan discusses what it’s like when fans address him as “Jesus” and project spiritual expectations onto him. He explains how he gently reorients people to his humanity, reminding them he is flawed and not the person he plays.
- •Lewis describes emotional fan reactions and the tendency to call him “Jesus”
- •Jonathan names it as projection and tries to “gently sever” the ambiguity
- •He introduces himself out loud as “Jonathan” to ground the interaction
- •He emphasizes he is human, weak, and not Jesus
- •He reiterates his focus: it must be about Christ, not himself
If he could ask Jesus three questions: impact, responsibility, and “Why me?”
Jonathan shares what he would ask Jesus, including whether his portrayal was close to reality and why he was chosen to play the role. He also reflects on messages he’s received from viewers who say the show influenced major life decisions, which leaves him wrestling with the weight of being the face associated with the character.
- •He says he’d ask: “Was I close?” and “Why me?”
- •He adds a personal question: what Jesus’ favorite food was
- •He references messages claiming the show helped stop some people from taking their own lives
- •He mentions people rethinking atheism and becoming curious about the Bible and Jesus
- •He struggles with what to do with the responsibility of being associated with Jesus’ image
Early echoes of the role: passion plays, a childhood reenactment, and bullying
Jonathan describes portraying Jesus in church passion plays before The Chosen and recalls a striking childhood memory of reenacting the cross-carrying at age 12. He connects his early identification with Jesus’ innocence to his experience of being harassed and bullied as a kid.
- •He had played Jesus multiple times in passion plays before The Chosen
- •While rehearsing carrying the cross, he remembered doing it at age 12
- •He reenacted it in his backyard after seeing a TV depiction of Jesus
- •He suggests childhood bullying may have shaped his identification with Jesus’ innocence
- •Asked what he’d tell his 12-year-old self, he says he might say nothing to avoid “messing it up”
Trusting a long timeline: why you’re doing it, and Harold Ramis’ “20 years” line
Jonathan responds to Lewis’s question about when to keep chasing a dream by focusing on purpose: why you’re doing it and who it’s for. He shares advice he received early in his career from Harold Ramis about how long it can take to become an “overnight success,” then describes the financial realities of grinding for years in the arts.
- •He says the key questions are: “Why are you doing it?” and “Who are you doing it for?”
- •He argues money, fame, and prestige won’t fill inner emptiness without deeper purpose
- •He describes wanting to tell stories that positively impact lives and point people toward God
- •He recounts Harold Ramis telling him it takes 15–20 years to become an overnight success
- •He challenges aspiring actors to prepare realistically for 10–20 years of struggle and low income
Prayer as preparation: authenticity in the role and work with the Hallow app
Jonathan says he couldn’t portray Jesus authentically without an active prayer life, calling Jesus’ life “a living prayer.” He and Lewis discuss Hallow, Jonathan’s involvement narrating content, and stories of people saying the app—and faith content—helped change or save their lives.
- •Jonathan says without prayer he’d be “guessing” and the performance would feel inauthentic
- •He describes prayer as integral to Jesus’ life and to his own preparation
- •Lewis shares how daily prayer with his wife has become a stabilizing ritual
- •Jonathan describes joining Hallow early and narrating a Gospel of Matthew sleep story
- •He mentions messages about people being pulled back from suicide and experiencing spiritual change through the app
Crucifixion filming and final reflections: suffering, love, Three Truths, and greatness
Near the end, Jonathan identifies filming the crucifixion as the moment he felt most connected to God, describing injuries and the emotional and spiritual intensity of the season. He shares the biggest lesson—Christ’s love—and closes with his “Three Truths” and definition of greatness as embracing one’s mission with excellence worthy of God.
- •He says the crucifixion scenes brought a “divine intimacy” and were the hardest thing he’s done
- •He describes praying to experience a fraction of what Jesus endured and then sustaining injuries during the shoot
- •He says the greatest lesson was the enormity of Christ’s love and the willingness to suffer innocently
- •His Three Truths include: suffering can teach love, we are loved more than we know, and the only real truth is Christ
- •He defines greatness as embracing your mission fully with excellence worthy of God
Publisher timestamps
- 0:00Intro
- 1:23Broke in LA before The Chosen
- 3:01Quitting vs. surrendering
- 6:04Keeping God out of his career
- 8:45The day he surrendered everything
- 13:43Four checks in the mailbox
- 16:53Coincidence or a sign?
- 18:46Cast as Jesus 3 months later
- 22:16Why surrender came before the role
- 24:16Did fame ever go to his head?
- 25:24When fans see Jesus, not Jonathan
- 26:52What he'd ask Jesus
- 30:22Playing Jesus years before The Chosen
- 31:56Advice to his 12-year-old self
- 34:44When to keep chasing your dream
- 38:59How he keeps his ego in check
- 41:10Faith & the mystery of God
- 42:39Why prayer made the role possible
- 44:35Praying with Hallow
- 49:38Trusting the process at 44
- 50:14Harold Ramis' 20-year advice
- 55:00Filming the crucifixion
- 57:33The biggest lesson from Season 6
- 58:27The 3 truths
- 1:00:49What is greatness?