The Mel Robbins PodcastThis One Study Will Change How You Think About Your Entire Life: The Cornell Legacy Project
EVERY SPOKEN WORD
145 min read · 28,846 words- 0:00 – 1:28
Meet the Guest
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Life is incredibly short. It passes by faster than you think it will. When you come to the end of your life, you are going to value people and experiences over things. Not one person, not a single person said, "I wish I'd spent more time accumulating more things."
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm. Today on the Mel Robbins Podcast, we have life lessons from 90-year-olds with Professor Karl Pillemer from Cornell. Once you hear these lessons, your life will never be the same.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Unless you have a compelling reason to say no, always say yes. If you're offered a new responsibility, offered a new opportunity, in general, have your principle be, that may take me out of my comfort zone, but I'm going to say yes. And I'm telling you that thousands of people told me this. You absolutely are much more likely to regret things that you didn't do than things you did. I would encourage you folks to say yes rather than no. This was one of the most profound regrets. Over and over, people said, "I wish I had expressed love more. I wish I had asked for forgiveness," because that is a truly time-limited possibility.
- MRMel Robbins
Say what you need to say. Take the backpack off. Free yourself of the emotional weight of waiting for the right time, and that freedom is available to you literally right now.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
You can't assume that people understand how much you love them, how much you care about them, how proud you are of them.
- MRMel Robbins
Say it now.
- 1:28 – 4:06
Life Lessons That We Learn Too Late
- MRMel Robbins
Please help me welcome Dr. Karl Pillemer to the Mel Robbins Podcast.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
It is such a pleasure to be here, Mel. I just can't wait for our discussion.
- MRMel Robbins
I have been waiting nine years-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
(laughs)
- MRMel Robbins
... to meet you in person, so I'm thrilled that you're here, and here's where I wanna start. Could you speak directly to the person who's with us right now and share with them what could change about their life or the life of somebody that they care about who they share this episode with if they take everything that you're about to share with us and teach to us today and they apply it to their own life?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I wanna share with you a lesson that many people learn too late. One of the things older people have told me over and over is that life is incredibly short. It passes by faster than you think it will. Uh, there's a corollary to that, which is even more important, and that's that happiness, and fulfillment, and purpose are not a destination that you will arrive at when conditions are somehow perfect. Instead, happiness, and fulfillment, and purpose are the product of choices you make amidst the kind of circumstances in which you find yourself. Uh, so it's a question of discerning what you can control and what you can't. And what would you do if that was, uh, the wisdom you were gonna base your life on? Well, there are some things you really would do. One of those is you would stop waiting for things like, uh, um, to travel, or express love, or find a more meaningful job. You would make more conscious choices to be happy and to optimize your current situation. You would focus on what's working rather than what's not. You would savor small things throughout the course of a day, and the elders told me all kinds of things, a colored bird on the lawn, a phone call from a friend, the silly antics of the dog. You would treat moments, and conversations, and days, uh, with people you love as precious rather than routine that you're just walking through. Those are all part of what you can do if you embrace this elder wisdom about life being extremely short and that life can't be deferred. And so, that's kind of where, I mean, I think, uh, that's really the essence of it. Uh, you know, these are sailors on the sea of time who've gotten to the end of this journey.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
And one of the things they really know about is how to use this extremely limited lifetime that we have.
- 4:06 – 12:38
With Age Comes Happiness
- MRMel Robbins
Dr. Pillemer, you've spent over 20 years at Cornell researching the biggest life lessons, the biggest regrets, the tactical advice that people in their 80s or 90s, even 100 and beyond have. You call it The Legacy Project. Could you tell the person that is listening right now a little bit about The Legacy Project and what it's about?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Sure. I was... Um, I'd been a gerontologist for around 25 years. I was in my early 50s, and I had a powerful revelation that all I was studying was the problems of older people and older people's problems. So, I really had the idea, what do older people know that younger people don't, and could I find that information and distill it in a usable form? Um, uh, the one thing people don't realize, and one thing that we've lost in our age-segregated society, which is one of the most age-segregated now that's ever existed, is that it's only been in about the last 150 years or so that people have gone to anyone other than the oldest person they knew-
- MRMel Robbins
Hm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... for advice about life. So, that... And we know from anthropological studies that older people were absolutely critical to human survival. If you were in your 50s and, uh, and everybody else was dying in their 20s and 30s, and you knew what to do in a drought, or what to do in a famine, or where better land was, people have found that older individuals were key to human survival. We're at the risk of losing what is honestly an extremely natural human process, which is not asking older people for their stories or their anecdotes, but asking them for their practical advice for living. Um, if I can tell one story, I can say that what... uh, there was a moment i- in which this revelation occurred. I was starting to think about, you know, that I was on the wrong track. That... You know, because also, we scientists get funding-... for solving human problems. So, y- you don't get so much money for trying to figure out why people are happy, so I had that problem focus, uh, and I was doing research in a nursing home, and, uh, the nurses knew I liked interesting older people and they introduced me to somebody who I called June Driscoll in the book. And I went in and it was like a typical nursing home room, this was a very frail woman, you know? She couldn't get out of bed, uh, you know, I imagine only had a few more months to live. And I asked her how she was doing, and in this strong voice she said, "Just great, you know? I've had my bath, I'm watching my programs, you know? It's a nice day outside." And I was so surprised that I asked her, "How could this be?" And she said, "Look, I grew up in terrible poverty. I didn't have three square meals a day. Now, I'm being taken care of. I have a place to live. I have people who are caring for me. Why would I be unhappy?" And that's when she said the thing that got me to write the book. First of all, she said, "Young man," and in my mid-50s that was nice, but she said, "Young man, you will realize, though, when you get to be my age that happiness is a choice and not a condition, um, and that you learn to be happy in spite of things." So, I thought then, "Hmm." I mean, it just sent me on this quest, you know? I'm sure you've had this every once in a while something happens when you realize you're about to go on a journey that for me led to, you know, talking to these hundreds of people over many years, but where I just had to understand how can there be this paradox of happiness and aging where many older people, despite all the problems they have, have solved some of life's individual problems and are very happy? How could we find that out and not waste that resource?
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm. You know, I'm actually reading from your blockbuster, uh, best-selling book, 30 Lessons for Living. This is page 232. "What's different about aging is that you don't have 50 more years-"
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah.
- MRMel Robbins
"... when you're 80." And if you really take that into consideration, there's something about limited time that focuses the aperture that you have, the lens that you have on life about what matters. Because if you really... Let's say that you're listening right now and you're in your teens or 20s or 30s or 40s or heck, like me in my 50s. If you knew you only had one year or a week to live, notice how quickly you would only focus on the things that actually were important. And so much of the crap that occupies your mind and your energy would just drift to the side because you would suddenly know you have limited time, so you focus on what matters. And what I love about your work is the practical advice that you're about to hear, and the specific things to really think about and focus on and change now come from a group of thousands of people who had they, uh, that exact experience. "I have limited time, so by God I'm gonna wake up and spend that time on the things that actually matter because I'm learning from the things that I regret that I didn't do earlier," and I think that's the opportunity of this conversation. What is the biggest takeaway from your research about how to live a happy, successful, and healthy life?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Uh, there are some runners up.
- MRMel Robbins
Okay.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, like, a runner up is that even though a lot of these people grew up in the Great Depression, they think you should find work you love and not work just for money. They have many other kinds of, uh, you know, specific advice, uh, that we can come to, but I would sum up... And this is one piece where I see a real interaction with Let Them Theory as well. If I were to sum up maybe that core piece of advice or, or really one of the big ones is, um, that the secret to a fulfilling life is to be able to distinguish and act on the difference between what you can control and what you can't.
- MRMel Robbins
Hm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, it's a difference between controlling your own actions while acknowledging that you can't always control outcomes. So, what you can do is you can make a decision to value people and experiences over things, but what you can do is very carefully devote time and attention to personal relationships. What you can do is make a daily decision to put mindless worry aside, and by the way, about worry I know that we'll come back to it, but imagine 2,000 grandparents yelling at you, "Stop worrying so much." You're gonna regret wasting the time on it. Um, you would act as much as you can with honesty and integrity, uh, because you know you're gonna regret it the later on. You would stop worrying so much about things that you can't control. You can't control exactly how your children turn out. You can't control exactly how your older parents treat you. You can't control how long you're gonna live no matter how much you believe in body hacking. You have to focus on these aspects of your life that are controllable and understand what the difference is, and really take action on those things. So, I think it's this difference. People get paralyzed by this kind of a despair about things, uh, that are going on, be it the political situation or something else. The elders want you to believe that these things that you do in life to become happy and fulfilled and purposeful are the result much more of choices you can make than they are of some abstract force, uh, governing outcomes. One of the ways that you can look at it, if I can use a little more social science-
- MRMel Robbins
Please.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... terminology is that there's something called, and it's another big one, optimization with compensation, especially as you grow-
- MRMel Robbins
Optimization with compensation?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Optimization with compensation, and it-
- MRMel Robbins
Like, I'm getting paid for something?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Well, uh, (laughs) almost, but it... As you grow older-... people who age successfully learn to optimize what they have left and compensate, um, for what they may have lost.
- MRMel Robbins
Okay.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So rather than being upset as one of my interviewees, "I can't climb this mountain anymore, but I can still go hiking-"
- MRMel Robbins
Ah.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
"... I'm gonna optimize what I have left." Instead of reflecting and ruminating about all the losses, they argue that you take action on what you can
- 12:38 – 27:43
How to Avoid the #1 Regret People Have When They Die
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
control.
- MRMel Robbins
You know, one of the biggest takeaways from the Legacy Project Research, because I've been a fan of your work for almost 10 years, (clears throat) is this sense that I wish I didn't waste so much of my life worrying about things that never happened or worrying about what people thought. Are there a couple key things that you should focus on? You know, when you talk about living intentionally and what's in your control, what are, like, the top two things to really focus on from the study that a- are within your control?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Can we touch on worry?
- MRMel Robbins
Of course.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Because, well, I asked these very, very old people what their major regrets in life were. Well, I actually asked it differently. I asked them, "What can a young person do to avoid getting to your age and, and having regrets? So, um, how can they avoid it?" First of all, almost everybody said, "If you get to 90 or 100 with no regrets, you haven't lived a very interesting life, and it means you haven't taken any risks." So, so that we can come back to that, but that's not an aspiration to completely avoid regrets. But in general, I asked them about this, and I was ready to hear people talk about big ticket items like a shady business deal or an affair. I was not ready to hear, and it was so surprising, "I wish I hadn't worried so much."
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
"I wish..." And people gave many examples. One of the w- here are just a couple I can think of. One woman said, "There were gonna be layoffs in my company, and we were gonna learn in three months. I could do nothing about it. There was nothing I could do. I worried constantly." And she paused and looked a little wistful and said, "I wish I had those three months back."
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Um, um, somebody else said, "I wasn't able to get pregnant, and I just worried and worried and ruined my life about it, and then I got pregnant." C- and people used the same phrase, "I wish I had that portion of my life back." So, when you get into mindless ruminating worry, here's one action step. Know for a fact that when you reach the end of your life and you look back on it, you will say, "A lot of the things I worried about didn't happen, things happened I didn't even think to worry about, and I wish I had that time back that I had spent mindlessly worrying and ruminating." So, one technique I use is I imagine this auditorium full of old people, 'cause it was a universal part of elder wisdom, yelling at me, you know, "Stop worrying about x." Now, I'm such a worrier, uh, that I could actually have a calendar scheduling in worries, you know, daughter one, daughter two, grandchildren, job, y- you know, climate change. I mean, so that this, for me, was, though it was immensely helpful. Uh, the second thing that they argue, and, and, and I think it's very actionable, is they really believe in planning. So, they aren't saying, "Don't not plan. Don't live through rose-colored glasses," but they really urge, f- for whatever it is now that you're worried about, conscious planning. So that's the sense of what... Take advantage of what you can control, rather than what you can't. I think they would also argue because this particular insight, even though they didn't know it, is so consistent with principles of cognitive behavioral therapy, that if you are an incessant worrier, there are therapies that can help you. And taking that time to work through the el- the elimination of these negative ruminating thoughts, putting in the effort, really can pay off for an entire lifetime.
- MRMel Robbins
Well, if I take everything that you just said, from the I wish I didn't waste periods of my life worrying about things that either didn't happen, or things that happened and they weren't so bad, or that happened and they were bad and I survived anyway, I wish I could get that time back. And if we also take the advice of you should just plan because it's something in your control, and then I take the example from one person in your study who remembers a three-month period where they knew layoffs were coming, they felt like a sitting duck and worried about it, which in the study is they're now reflecting, "I wish I could get those three months back." And how many of us can look backward and go, "Wow, I really allowed six months in that relationship to just go right down the toilet 'cause I was worrying. I allowed three months of my life, a year of my life..." The advice is in there, because if you take the example of you think layoffs are coming, well, that's not in your control, but what is? You can plan. So if you think it's happening, start looking for another job.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yup.
- MRMel Robbins
Start brushing up on other skills. Start asking yourself, "Am I really happy here anyway?" And if you lean into that tactical piece of advice, you've now learned two things. When you're worrying, you can take control. And by taking control, the worrying (laughs) disappears, and you don't poison the time. So, the biggest regret, "I wish I wouldn't have wasted so much of my time worrying about things." What are some of the other big regrets that people near the end of their life make?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Like, if I were talking to your, you know, listeners, I would say one thing that you are likely to regret is not investing enough time and energy in people you love or like and making sure that they are aware of it.So, I would say that that's one key thing is when I analyze all the regrets, uh, that people have, they are much more about people than they are about career, and they are much more about not engaging with, attending to, as I said at the beginning, being present and intentional about relationships. So for example, not investing time in relationships. In the studies I did, th- we learned that what children really want is your time. They really aren't interested in anything else you can give them. They want time spent with you, as does your partner. One example of this, uh, that I talk about in the books is something I called the middle-age blur, but maybe be better called the activity blur.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
People in their 30s to 50s... Often, people would say, "I almost don't remember that time. I, you know... It was so filled with work, and building a career, and getting my education done, and housing, and then have kids thrown in, it passed by like a nanosecond." It, it, it occurred in this blur. And people very often in that blur lose track of relationships. And the odd thing is, or the ironic thing is, is that older people would tell me either directly or indirectly that they spent these enormous amounts of time pursuing happiness in other ways, and happiness was essentially already there if they had invested in these, you know... Had acted in compassionate ways in rewarding relationships. So, I would say the one thing you're gonna believe as an older person, there's no question that when you come to the end of your life, you are going to value, uh, people and experiences over things. I'll say again, and this is one of the things that's been quoted very heavily from the book, if you want data... So, so out of the 1,200 people for 30 Lessons for Living who we surveyed, not one person... A- a- and it's gonna sound a little absurd, but not one person, not a single person said, "I wish I'd spent more time accumulating more things."
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
But not one person said, "I really should have just tried to make more money. Really, that's the thing I just did wrong. If only I'd invested a lot more time trying to make more money so I could buy more stuff." Now, that does sound absurd when worded that way, but I deal with a lot of young people in my job, and that is a very present motivation for a lot of people. No older person towards the end of their life is going to endorse that. So that you can think about that, you know, that you are gonna value experiences and people way more. And let me say one other thing about that. They don't... The older Americans don't want you to be starving artists. I mean, a lot of them... I'm sorry. Apologies to starving artists. That's fine. But, but they wanna make sure that you prioritize that what you do is enjoyable and fulfilling. One of my favorite interviewees, who was a very successful entrepreneur, summed it up. He said, "I loved what I did, and I made money doing it." So, it was in that order. So, I do think this notion that, uh... I would say a principal regret is failing to, uh, be present, failing to be intentional, and failing to be active towards people who we love and like in our life-
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... and end up being distracted about, um, so many other things. A- a- and I can guarantee almost everybody, that's what you're gonna think about at the end of life.
- MRMel Robbins
You know, another, um... You know, when I think about your work, the regrets that really stuck with me were, first of all, wasting too much time worrying about things in the future that never ended up happening. The second one was not spending time with the people that mattered while they were still here. And the third one that had a really big impact on me personally was worrying so much about what other people thought that I didn't let myself be or do the things I actually wanted to do. Can you talk a little bit about that one?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
If I could sum up their advice, I think they would be fairly radical, looking back over their own lives, and would endorse a statement like, "Don't do anything because you think it would impress somebody else." That is, don't make a purchase. Don't make a choice. As much as you can, don't do something because you think it would increase other people's opinions of you. Now, it's not bad to want people to like you. It's not bad sometimes to try to fulfill other people's expectations. But as a major motivation, to give something concrete, if you're buying a car, extract from your mind what other people will think of that car. Um, you know, so I think, uh, th- the, uh, that, uh... The insight you've said is really, really key to them, that you waste an extraordinary amount of time-
- MRMel Robbins
And money.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... and money, um, uh, focusing on, uh, what other people think. Now, let me qualify that.
- MRMel Robbins
Okay.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
There are some times where they really want you to consult other people and really want you to be concerned about what other people think. Um, well, one of the examples I really like... One of their strongest pieces of advice about finding a mate is really listen if nobody else likes your prospective partner. Um, that is, if none of your f-
- MRMel Robbins
Wait, hold on. So, like, if none of your fr-... Like, really listen-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I-
- MRMel Robbins
... to your friends and your family if they don't like the person you're with?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
If they... They said... Over and over, they said, "If only I'd listened..." If it's just one person, but if everybody you know is saying, "This guy is not right for you," and they're repeatedly saying it, and your impulse-... is to say, "You're all wrong. You, uh, you don't understand him," over and over, that was a major life regret, because very often, your friends and family have your best interests at heart. So, they do want you to listen to other people around those kinds of decisions, but that's very different from doing something just because you want them to think better of you.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- 27:43 – 34:50
Why You Anticipate Regret
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
- MRMel Robbins
So, for the person who's listening or watching who finds themselves saying that to their, "Well, I never hear from them," and you're starting to get that edge, "Well, I never hear from them," what is your advice to that person who is noticing that they say that, "I never hear from them"?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
As we talk about distance and estrangement-
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... I think, uh, that we have to remind ourselves that there are some family relationships where there's been a history of abuse, either physical or sexual, where the per- person is currently a damaging or dangerous person-
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... or where the relationship can be so emotionally stressful that there are some people who are right, at least temporarily, to break off contact, and if they decide that they wanna resume or stay in contact, doing so with the help of a psychological or counseling professional is a good thing. So, we have to acknowledge that. But our studies have found that's really the minority of cases. And so, with many of the people who were estranged, in permanent estrangements, I said, "What could've, you know, what can you do to find help?" They would say, "I need a time machine. I mean, I would go back and stop this s- before it occurred."
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, that, and so what you, so, so what you can think about is anticipatory regret, which is something psychologists talk about. Uh, we don't just regret those things, uh, that we did, but we think about things that we might regret. A- and I think, uh, that's a key message here. So f- so for one example, you and your brother are having a horrible conflict, and you decide never to speak to one another. Well, that's gonna have ripple effects down to all the next generations. Uh, the cousins aren't gonna speak together. There won't be family reunions. There won't be family gatherings. So, the idea is to use anticipatory regret. "If I let this happen, will I regret it?" I think that's a very powerful way to think about th- these things in your family. You grew up with your sibling. You have strong attachment to them. You have biologically based attachment to the people you grew up with that you can't overcome rationally. So, do you really want those, uh, to deteriorate to a point, even if it seems right in this very moment?
- MRMel Robbins
I, I love that you're breaking this down, because I think you can intellectually know that at the end of your life, you wanna be surrounded by your family. You want to have made amends. You want your friends to be there.... and it's easy to let the small little cuts build up and resentment to take hold. And as a parent myself of three adult kids, what's interesting to me is that I believe that my relationship with them is 100% my responsibility. So, if you could take these very emotional interviews and reflections from the 80 and 90 and 100-year-olds that wish they could go back in time and make one change, what would be the one change that you would want... that you would tell them... tell the person listening tactically that they should make? Because I think that this is a, a conversation that both people will reflect on for themselves-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Mm-hmm.
- MRMel Robbins
... personally as a parent, but a lot of adult kids or kids in their teens might share back to their parents in the hopes that you will be able to have somebody have an epiphany about a small shift that actually creates a major positive ripple throughout an entire family and generations.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
You know, I am... Uh, let me answer it, you know, um, in one way, and I'm not saying this because I'm on this podcast. I'm saying this because it fits with all of our work. The general principle with your older parents or your adult children of something along the lines of, "Let them,"
- MRMel Robbins
(laughs)
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... is the actual advice, uh, that they would give. So, that... And it works both ways.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, I have tremendous d- Uh, if I can confess to the world, I think that my children would agree, I have lots of ideas about how my children should have different health habits and, uh, you know, actually, fortunately, uh, they're great at raising their children. I can't complain about that. But I have lots of ideas of what they should do, and it's a daily process of not saying them. Uh, and so, I- I think, uh, what I had said to them both eventually is, "Look, I'm gonna work on this." The only exception I'll make if I think something is actually dangerous.
- MRMel Robbins
Yeah.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Like, if there's something that I think is gonna be life-threatening to somebody, which hasn't occurred. Uh, but otherwise, I'm going to try to withhold my advice. Very similarly, like, um, um, for adult children. You don't need to go home at Thanksgiving and try to convince your parent that it's time for them to sell the house and move into assisted living. I mean, you know, y- uh, in that situation, you let them make their own mistakes and accept natural consequences. It doesn't mean that you can't give advice. I would say one of the strongest things is don't give unsolicited advice. I mean, just get out of the habit. There's, there are 30 or 40 years of research showing that unsolicited advice about a problem you're having is stressful, especially if it's somebody who hasn't been through the same issue. I will give another strong principle for this. These relationships need, to some extent, if they're successful, to, to translate into something a little more like friendship.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, that you wanna think about shared interests, for example, uh, things you can do together. There are those kinds of things. Many people who overcame an estrangement didn't do it by having a huge conversation about the past. They started to go to a bingo parlor together, or they went to a weaving workshop together.
- MRMel Robbins
Or played golf together.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Played golf together. They did. So, so this idea, uh... So, I would say there, you know... A real key piece for making these intergenerational relationships work is, in these family relationships, lighten up. Lighten up about them. I mean, you know, if somebody, you know, makes goofy jokes or whatever, I mean, everything is not something that has to be that w- So, over and over, like, uh, th- this is a message of older people, again and again and again in all these relationships, lighten up about some of these things. Everything doesn't have to be, you know, darkly serious. And especially in marriage, that was a strong one. Everything doesn't have to be this battle of the worlds. You can lighten up.
- MRMel Robbins
Yeah, my doc-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, that was a discursive answer to your question.
- MRMel Robbins
No, I, I, I actually love it. It helps me apply, because I do think the vast majority of people that have strained relationships with family members, whether it's siblings or parents or kids or whatever, kids' partners or in-laws, is the slow burn.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Mm-hmm.
- MRMel Robbins
And the fact that all this stuff just builds up, and then everybody gets together, and you're so tense that it's stressful to be together, and it just becomes easier to avoid
- 34:50 – 35:29
5 Lessons From Our Elders For Living a Good Life
- MRMel Robbins
it. You know, one of the things that I wanna talk about, because you summarize this on page 193 of your-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Mm-hmm.
- MRMel Robbins
... best-selling book, Thirty Lessons for Living, there are five lessons from people in their 80s, 90s, and even their 100s for living a really good life, and those lessons are, "Always be honest, say yes to opportunities, travel more, choose a mate with extreme care, say it now." I wanna take these one by one. Let's start with the first one.
- 35:29 – 42:49
Lesson #1: Be Honest
- MRMel Robbins
"Always be honest. Most people suffer from serious regret later in life if they have been less than, quote, 'fair and square.'"
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah, 'cause, of course, uh, the people I interviewed, that term fair and square was something they often would've used in the '50s-
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... and so, ye- and- a- and, uh, that was the idea, that you offer people a square deal. You offer something that's really fair. Yeah, that was another surprise for me. And I will say to listeners, I know you may have in your mind a little sign going off for cliche alert, because who wouldn't want to be honest? But for them, it meant something deeper and more profound 'cause it was such a source of regret. People who had deceived someo- Well, actually, let me say, if you were on the receiving end...... of some kind of major dishonesty or betrayal. You know, that was a major regret in your own life, s- so people of course had been on the receiving end of that kind of thing, of infidelity, and it was often... So, it really would shake their faith, you know, in the grounds of human relationships.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
But I would say one of the strongest regrets was a person's own dishonesty. So I had many cases, one man t- told me about his marital infidelity, and he wasn't able to overcome his feelings of guilt about it, how he had never been able to be faithful even though he tried, his wife had put up with it. I talked to other people who had been involved in questionable business deals, uh, so that, eh, you know, eh, and they had those same kinds of regrets. So, honestly, integrity, having your life narrative at the end of your life.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Because, by the way, narratives towards the end of life are extremely important. You do really wanna be able to sum up your life in some kind of a meaningful narrative, and we could come back to that, but that's an important way of feeling like you're ready for whatever's next. Having acted with integrity turns out to be a major thing that people value when they're summing up their life narrative. So, when you're thinking now, eh, like, if you're doing something, uh, that is less than honest, if you're doing things that e- you know, are deceitful or deceptive in some way, you can be pretty sure it's something that's gonna interfere with your understanding of the value of your own life. So-
- MRMel Robbins
Well, I think it's a question you could ask yourself, Dr. Pillemer, like, "Where am I not being honest-"
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah.
- MRMel Robbins
"... with myself? Or wh- where am I not being honest with other people?"
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Exactly. It's a way you can use right now, so it's something that, for people, it's extremely actionable. Ask yourself right now, "Is there something I'm doing that is on the borderline of honesty, even, th- that I will later regret?" Now, p- I say in the book, uh, we aren't talking about, you know, the answer to the question, "Do these pants make me look fat?" I mean, th- we aren't talking about some kind of radical honesty in which you can never be strategic, but it's more honesty and integrity in actions.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Um, and yeah, pe- you know, like, it might, I would say, you know, like, it might feel good now, and it's not gonna feel good as you review your life.
- MRMel Robbins
Well, I think that there's an even deeper way to apply this, because, you know, most people that are doing something really dishonest, until they either get caught or they just can't bear it anymore, they're not gonna come clean.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah.
- MRMel Robbins
But there is a level of self-betrayal and lying to self where I d- do believe there's an opportunity as you're listening or watching right now, to truly ask yourself, "Am I being honest with myself about whether or not I'm enjoying what I do for a living?" I love the quote that you said that, you know, somebody summed it up best, "I loved what I did, and I made money doing it."
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Mm-hmm.
- MRMel Robbins
That loving what I did first was the priority, because I spent so much time in my life at work. And so, maybe the honest thing for you is to admit to yourself that you're not enjoying where you are right now, kinda gaslighting yourself about your current habits, that you're not actually taking care of yourself, like that, "I need to be honest now, because if I'm honest with myself that I'm not happy or honest with myself that 'I don't wanna live another decade doing life the way I'm doing it, I need to make some changes,'" that that right there is wisdom from an 80 or 90-year-old that you can apply if you're eightee- you hate your major, you're 20.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
You know, that's so-
- MRMel Robbins
Be honest.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
It's absolutely true, and it's being honest with yourself, too, as you're thinking about a partner. "Am I deceiving myself in this? You know, d- do I not really have that powerful in-love feeling, but I'm simply, just feel it's time?" Though one of the strongest arguments they would make is what Mel just said, "If you are in a job right now that is unfulfilling, and you're doing it mostly for the money, really be honest with yourself." I've learned after these studies to cringe every time one of my students says, "I wanna be a chef, but I'm gonna go work in the financial services industry, and then I'll do that later." They argue that it is always too late to make that kind of change, that if you are in a job that is unfulfilling, really, really think about changing it. Uh, their rule was, "If you don't feel good to get up in the morning and go to your job, and you're staying in it," exactly like Mel said, "you're not being honest with yourself." And I- I, and I would say that is t- is to me one of the most impactful things. They really argue that you need to choose work for its intrinsic value, not for the extrinsic rewards. As I said, the one thing older people know about is time, and they're amazed at how younger people use time. It's like a desert tribesperson would look at our profligate use of water. Like, they just can't understand it. So the idea of taking five years slogging in a job that is really unfulfilling rather than taking a risk for something else, uh, you know, obviously, you have to plan out your own life and what's feasible, but to the extent it is possible for you, to honestly assess if you really hate this job, and make a change if, you know, as soon as you can, um, um, they would say it's urgent.
- MRMel Robbins
This is coming from a generation of people whose life experience was you stay in a job, and you actually do that for your whole lifetime, whereas we now live in a reality where the average person is probably gonna have, I don't know, 19 different jobs by the time that, you know, your career is over, at least. And the wisdom is still, "Be honest with yourself. Do not waste your life toiling away at something you don't enjoy doing. Figure out how to make a change."
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
It was one of the biggest surprises of the study. People from the Depression-era generation, who I figured would say, "Oh, find a stable job, make as much money as you can," not a single person said that. And, and, you know what? It was especially powerful from older women who had not had opportunities, uh, that younger women have today. Over and over they said, "I would give anything for your opportunities. Make use of them. You know, don't languish in a bad job." So anyway, I- but I think that's
- 42:49 – 44:41
Lesson #2: Say Yes to Opportunities
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
absolutely right.
- MRMel Robbins
Well, that brings us to the second thing that people say that you need to do in order to live a good life, which is say yes to opportunities. When offered a new opportunity or challenge, you are much less likely to regret saying yes and more likely to regret turning it down.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah, I got that in- that first insight first came from a successful entrepreneur who just said, "Look, here's my lesson. Unless you have a compelling reason to say no, always say yes." If you're offered a new responsibility, offered a new opportunity, in general, have your principle be, "That may take me out of my comfort zone, but I'm going to say yes." M- you know, this may also sound like a cliché, but I'm telling you that thousands of people told me this. You absolutely are much more likely to regret things that you didn't do thing- uh, than things you did. You are more likely t- to look back on a missed opportunity that you could have done. So, I mean, one thing they would also argue, you can be a little more cautious about decisions that are irreversible.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Uh, but in many cases, uh, um, they would say, "You can experiment with a change, uh, that isn't so extreme." So, so say yes to the initial steps in a new career. Say yes to exploring something. I think they say, and I'm sure you see it in your work, people become inert. That, that they become stuck. One day blends into the next, and that's where this being honest with yourself, being in- being, uh, you know, present and intentional-
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... as you look at your life. And absolutely, they want you to say yes rather than say no if you can. So, if you're wondering about, um, some decision, some new opportunity, I would encourage you folks to say yes rather than no.
- 44:41 – 47:31
Lesson #3: Travel More
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
- MRMel Robbins
Another thing that 80, 90, 100-year-olds say is the secret to a good life: travel more, travel while you can, sacrificing other things if necessary to do so. Most people look back on their travel adventures, both big and small, as highlights of their lives, and they regret not having traveled more.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, uh, there are times when what sounds like a very specific piece of wisdom sheds light on bigger issues. So, the most interesting thing is a lot of very old people hadn't traveled very much when they were younger.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I interviewed a 93-year-old nun in Rochester, New York whose idea of adventure was her family would leave the Polish enclave and go to the German enclave for dinner. Or I interviewed people in East Texas who until the World War II or Korea had never been outside of their own county, so they knew what it was like not to go anywhere, and they valued travel incredibly.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I had one woman say to me, uh, "You know, if you've got a choice between a kitchen remodel or a trip, I say take the trip." I would say that was something we had to resolve in my own marriage, but I think we now do take the trip, r- um, rather than the kitchen remodel. But the idea there is it didn't have to be adventure travel. It could be anything, but something that takes you out of your normal daily route. So, people who were unable to travel much when they were young think that this is a critical thing for young people, in part because it symbolizes an attitude of openness and receptivity and adventure. We think of older people as being more conservative than younger people, but in terms of what you should do with your life, they're generally radical. It was over and over, "Don't waste your life." Uh, you know, uh, the one woman told me, you know, "You have only a few years here on Earth. You have to cram as much into it as you can. You know, don't take for granted these things." And travel is that symbol. Um, it's a symbol for doing things that they were unable to do and discovered later in life and felt that it was too late. So, so as- I would think of it that way. I thought it was an interesting insight.
- MRMel Robbins
Well, I also love that you're saying big and small, 'cause these are the things you can remember. And I, as a kid, remember m- l- like actually the, the one summer I remember was the summer that we rented a motor home and went on a tour of a bunch of the US national parks as a family. I remember that as clear as day, one of the highlights of my childhood. It was probably a two-week period. It wasn't some big, fancy trip. I also remember the fishing trips that we would take that were just an hour from the house. And so, I love that reminder. Cram it
- 47:31 – 58:07
Lesson #4: Choose a Mate with Care
- MRMel Robbins
in. Uh, another thing that 80, 90, and 100-year-olds say is the key to a good life: choose a mate with extreme care. The key is not to rush the decision, taking all the time needed to get to know the prospective partner and to determine your compatibility over the long term. I've heard that choosing your life partner is the single most important decision you will make.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I- at least ag- uh, I believe it is, and it- you know, because most people, we have to remember, uh, despite our times right now, one thing that hasn't changed in 20 years and since Jane Austen's time, still if you look at surveys, most young people wanna get married, most young people plan to get married, and most young people have as a value in that marriage being married for a lifetime.So, those values, even though people are doing it later, uh, they're living together first, uh, the core desire to have a life partner is still there. So, I wanna clarify that, 'cause it's not like nobody cares about this anymore.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I mean, this really is, uh, you know, the most important decision that a lot of people make, b- because you can change your career. So yeah, they believe that younger people aren't careful enough. They, you know, like, they observe their own children. People get to a certain age and it's time to get married, um, and that sort of thing, and they have certain rules for choosing a mate that I think are useful. One I have mentioned already, that it's okay to listen to the impressions of people who love you about your future mate. You should absolutely choose carefully. They argue that you should make sure that you have... It's very interesting. They all talk about a gut feeling, so that people who violated that gut feeling that this was the right thing regretted it. But one thing that may sound a little controversial, but was their strongest piece of advice and it's choosing a mate carefully, um, is we may like to think, uh, that opposites attract, but they really go with birds of a feather flock together. They argue that you should marry somebody or, but like, you know what? I'll say marry, even though, uh, we know that this could mean a long-term partnership, but just to make it so I don't have to say that every time I'll say marry. Marry someone who's a lot like you, who is fundamentally very similar to you. S- so the idea is this is, uh, a fact, one of the strongest facts from research on social relationships of all kinds. Unfortunately or fortunately, we like people who are similar to us. For example, you'll notice that when you first have a child, pretty soon your social network consists only of other people who have children because you gravitate towards them, and so your friendship network consists of people who also have children and your other folks drop out. Uh, you know, th- that's just one example. We like to be around people who are fundamentally similar to us more than we like to be around people who are very different, and most, most important is people who share similar values. So, I think that's one of the things they mean about choose carefully. You have to go beyond attraction. Another feature of choose carefully is that nobody wants to lose passion, but your relationship, they say, you, you have to nurture qualities of friendship. A- a- and I'm gonna give one very specific piece of advice. People who are in long marriages, offer this piece of advice, and I wanna offer it, you know, directly to your listeners. Embrace your partner's interests. So, rather than being angry, uh, that she's playing golf on Sunday, learn to play golf. Rather than learning, and I can use my own daughter as, um, as an example, that, uh, one of the things your husband loves is fantasy football. Rather than being angry about that, join the Fantasy Football League. I had many older people say, you know, p- people I call in the book tough old guys, "Opera? I never thought I'd go to opera, but I just decided my wife likes that and I'm gonna do it." People started to do... The, the, the, uh, the practical step in so many relationships of the anger that mounts-
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... because a person has a specific interest and the partner thinks it's ridiculous. So, here's one of the things that people, but, because I interview older people across the racial and ethnic spectrum, and one piece of advice that came through from many of them is when you're choosing a mate, watch how your prospective partner plays games. So I interviewed-
- MRMel Robbins
What do you mean by that? Like cards or-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Right, yes.
- MRMel Robbins
... basketball or all of it?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
When you're actually playing a game, like when they're doing, uh, like a leisure activity, like-
- MRMel Robbins
Okay.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... playing a game, and so to make it concrete, one of my interviewees who was Dominican-
- MRMel Robbins
Yeah.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... um, from the Dominican Republic. If you go to many social clubs or anywhere like where there are lots of Dominicans, you will see people playing dominoes.
- MRMel Robbins
Yeah.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
And they play very cutthroat dominoes. And she said, "I observed my... The guy I was interested in. I saw he was competitive, but he was a gracious loser. Uh, I saw..." There was someone else who said, in a, um, in a Chinese senior center, "I watched my future wife play mahjong and I could see how she related to, to the other people." And somebody else said, "I tried to play something like a tribute, you know, some game w- with my guy I was interested in and he threw the board up in the air and stormed out of the room."
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So, watching how your partner operates, again, being the researcher. So, that was one concrete thing. Uh, the other piece of advice I took to heart is if you're having a lot of serious arguments, you find there's a pattern to arguments, rather than therapy, the cure might be a sandwich. Uh, because my wife and I though we'd be traveling and we'd forget to eat, and our argument, like who chose the bad hotel or why we got there after the museum closed, would be unbelievably intense until we realized th- that we were hungry, and there's good research on this, Mel, showing that you should not argue when you're hungry. Um, and so one of the things the elders said, like one of their little lessons is, uh, eat... If you're having an intractable argument, get something to eat and see what happens.
- MRMel Robbins
I love that advice. And here's what I'm realizing. My mouth is kind of open 'cause I'm now-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah.
- MRMel Robbins
... processing what you're saying. My husband and my kids do that with me 'cause I will get so lost in what I'm doing and then next thing you know I'm bickering about something just so stupid and I'm the, I'm the jerk, right?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yep.
- MRMel Robbins
And somebody in my family will go, "When's the last time you ate?"And sure enough, five or six hours ago.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Try it out, a cup of tea and a biscuit if you're having a terrible argument. So that was one of their key points.
- MRMel Robbins
Wow.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Um, but yeah-
- MRMel Robbins
I love that.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah, I think it's a good one. You know?
- MRMel Robbins
I think it's a really good one.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Well, you know, they, uh, yeh- wh- l- m- like another p- piece of... There's one piece of advice, I think, that really sums up a little bit too of this whole area, if I could share it. So, so sometimes a cliché is way more than a cliché. So, so sometimes a saying or an expression has this real power-
- 58:07 – 1:01:56
Lesson #5: Say it Now
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
True.
- MRMel Robbins
And another thing that people in their 80, 90s, and 100 say is the secret to a good life. Say it now. People wind up saying the sad words, "It might have been," by failing to express themselves before it's too late. Don't believe the ghost whispers. The only time you can share your deepest feelings is while people are still alive.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
This was one of the most profound regrets. Over and over, people said, "I wish I had expressed love more. I wish I had asked for forgiveness." Because that is a truly time-limited possibility. Unless you believe in seances, it's gonna be too late, uh, eventually to ask forgiveness, to offer an explanation, to offer an apology. You know, l- like, you know what else it's too late for sometimes? Asking for information.
- MRMel Robbins
Hm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
You may desperately wanna know what, you know, your f- your, uh, y- y- your father did in Vietnam or something like that, and it will be too late even to find out things. So I would argue that that is an ex- very actionable thing for listeners. If you are pondering saying something now, if you have something on your mind, if you're wondering about whether to do any of those things, um, you know, use the five-second rule.
- MRMel Robbins
(laughs)
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I mean, sort of. I mean, if I can bring that in, I mean, I would say-
- MRMel Robbins
Can.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... just do it. I mean, really, really just do it. One of the things I found in the estrangement work is how often people who had been waiting and waiting and waiting, they were gonna call the brother, they hadn't talked for 10 years, more than one person, uh, you know, described it as a backpack they'd been wearing, this very heavy backpack. One man said, "Hey, you know, I woke up the next morning and realized I don't have to think about why I don't talk to my brother Ed anymore." So that saying things now is beneficial for you, but I would say that cropped up.
- MRMel Robbins
Meaning when you're waiting for the right time to say something, you are wearing a weighted backpack-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah.
- MRMel Robbins
... and you're carrying it around, and the second that you, five, four, three, two, one, pick up the phone, or drive over to their house, or write the letter, say what you need to say, you take the backpack off, and you free yourself of the emotional weight of waiting for the right time. And that freedom is available to you literally right now.When you're done listening to this, you could pick up the phone-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Listen.
- MRMel Robbins
... or write the letter. Like, it's available right now.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
No, I wouldn't even, even suggest that people think, "Is there something I should be saying that I'm not?" So for example, I know parents don't want their kids, because, well, because parents think, uh, uh, their kids know it. Don't look their kid in the eye and say, "You know, I'm just really proud of how you've turned out."
- MRMel Robbins
Mm. Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
"You know? Look, I just want you to know that, uh, we've had our issues, but what you've done is really remarkable." Um, you know, I did a thing, even like I, uh... I had a beloved college professor who was nearing the end of her life, and I didn't think about it, but I sort of five-seconded find, I said, "I'm just nearby, I'm gonna go see her." And the feeling before the end of her life of expressing the gratitude for advancing my career, I think it's an excellent exercise. What am I not saying right now that, if it were too late, I would really regret? Uh, you can't assume that people understand how much you love them, how much you care about them, how proud you are of them. It doesn't have to be negative things or forgiveness, but we often don't in... You know, it's what I said early on, you treat these moments as precious rather than routine, 'cause our relationships get routine.
- MRMel Robbins
Hm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I think that's an excellent piece of advice, is what might you not be saying,
- 1:01:56 – 1:06:09
How to Let Go of the Past and Embrace Your Future
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
uh, that needs to be said now?
- MRMel Robbins
One of the other things that you write about, this is on page 194, is another piece of advice, which is go easy on yourself regarding mistakes and bad choices you have made. And there is this lesson around self-acceptance that so many people in their 80s, 90s, their 100s wish they had learned when they were way younger, and this is what one person in your study said. "What I've learned from the mistakes that I've made is that you can't change what's happened in the past. You have to accept yourself, warts and all. That was hard for me, because I came out of a background that was telling me if you just keep trying harder, you really could do it all right and be perfect. It took me some time to accept the fact that it's not gonna work out that way, and it's okay that it doesn't work out that way. Once a decision is made or a direction is started, you don't get anywhere by looking back and second-guessing. And as somebody taught me years ago, if you've bought a pair of shoes, don't look at the shoes in the next door window." Did these 80, 90, and 100-year-olds have any tactical or practical advice on how to start learning how to be more self-accepting and kinder of yourself for the mistakes you've made or the decisions that you wish you could change?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Uh, yes, and I love that shoes in the store window metaphor.
- MRMel Robbins
Okay.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I mean, I think, uh, that that really is the concept that if, if we're constantly comparing ourselves, like, to what we could've done, uh, it is a really dangerous and damaging possible thing. I would say, w- um, uh, one thing you could do, if you're listening to here, um, is you could reflect on this. Am I making certain kinds of decisions, or do I tend to second-guess myself? Is there something I'm second-guessing right now that would be better just to let go or just to leave alone? So you can analyze yourself. Where are you doing this kind of emphasizing your own regrets? So one thing is just awareness, and you can definitely look at what's going on, and you can let it go. Another thing you can do is become aware that you're being pushed towards a kind of perfectionism by our culture, and, uh, the more you are watching so-called influencers showing you their perfect refrigerator, their perfect bedroom, their perfect body, their perfect face, you are going to be pushed towards perfectionism. So you can inoculate yourself against that. But finally, you need to practice self-compassion. You need to actually begin to understand that you're n- not gonna express perfection and have this kind of a self-pa- compassion and self-forgiveness. So I think a number one thing is definitely being aware of it. I will give one piece of elder wisdom, I think, which is really critical about this. It applies to other things, but I would sum it up, as you're criticizing yourself, worrying about things you might have done, kind of thinking about, you know, this pair of shoes you bought, is really taking the long view.
- MRMel Robbins
Hm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Uh, there is a certain logic to asking, "Will I really care about this when I'm 80? But this particular thing I'm worrying about myself..." You know, taking that view as if you were one of the elders looking back on your life. Like, so people tend to torture themselves about, in the moment, about the missed opportunities or mistakes, but by taking the long view, will this really matter over the longest period of time, I think that you can get a certain amount of peace with it. So I would say those are, uh, you know, kind of the essence of elder wisdom on that. Uh, you know, the other thing about these, about this kind of regret is r- is, one thing is to focus on what you learned from it, rather than on how bad it was-
- MRMel Robbins
Hm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... or what, that whatever you did or failed about it, so you can reframe it. Uh, you can shift it to, to here's what I learned from it, rather than here's how I messed things up.
- 1:06:09 – 1:11:51
Is Happiness as Simple as Choosing to be Happy?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
- MRMel Robbins
One of the big things that I learned from your work is this concept that you call learning how to be unhappy... Learning how to be happy in spite of, and I wanna read to you from page 208. "Lots of unpleasant things are gonna happen to you in life, and when they do, you have two choices. You can mope and sulk, and you can feel sorry for yourself, or you can put on a brave face and get on with your life."I have come to call this attitude "happy in spite of." This viewpoint contrasts with that of many people, which I'd call "happy if only." The dominant perspective among young people is, "I'll be happy if only I... If only I lose the weight, if only I find a partner, if only I get divorced, if only I find a different mate, if only I get healthy, get rich," and on and on. The experts believe, meaning people in their 80s, 90s, and even 100, that "happy if only" attitude is futile and leads to disappointment. And one of the reasons why this is something that has been a huge change in my life is that it's occurred to me that it's so easy to be waiting around for happiness, it's so easy to be disappointed with where you are, it's so easy to wake up and be in a bad mood for no reason at all, that it's a skill that you can learn, that I practice now, to be happy in spite of everything that's going on, to be happy for no reason at all. And I'd love to have you unpack-
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Mm-hmm.
- MRMel Robbins
... this choice that you have, that if you could embrace this attitude, that you can choose how to have a good attitude and be in a good mood and not dwell on your expectations, or disappointment, or make it a habit to be unhappy, how important this is and how much it changes your life.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah. And here's, here's where you get to a core of wisdom that is in some ways unique to older people. So in some ways, that insight, to me, justified the project. Because you can say, "Choose to be happy," and someone can very reasonably say back to you, "Well, that's just a platitude. What about that..." But when you get to be 70 and beyond, just about everybody, and no, body hacking is not gonna fix this, just about everybody bears some burden of chronic disease and sometimes crippling chronic disease, and just about everybody has experienced loss. You've certainly lost your parents. You may have lost siblings, you may have lost your partner. So you have, you have a whole group of people who have experienced many of the things, uh, that young people worry about.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Second, we have a fascinating finding from hundreds of studies, that on average, older people are happier than younger people. So if you ask a survey item like, "How happy are you on a scale of one to 10? Have the past five years been some of the best of your life?" people over 60, or especially over 65, are happier than younger people. So, so you've got those two things. How can people who are experiencing an accumulation of loss and negative life events still be happier than younger people are? How would that occur? And that's whe- And one of the things, uh, that we found, and it's supported by other research, is this conscious choice to be happy, not because of all circumstances aligning perfectly, but choosing to be happy given the current circumstances in which you now exist.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
And there are, there are various techniques they employ, wh- which do map onto other ones, you know, that people do use in psychology, but these are their own indigenous ones. They would argue that it involves things like waking up and saying, "I'm going to make this as good a day as it can be." It's waking up and saying, as one of my interviewees did, you know, basically, "This can be a good day. How can I make this count?" And it does involve trying to ta- trying to consciously avoid negative emotions about your situation, to look for, "What's working in my life, rather than what isn't working in my life."
- MRMel Robbins
Mm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So they would argue again and again, "We're a group of people, if I could speak as one, we're a group of people that a lot of crap is happening to." I mean, if you're gonna be an old person, unless you can choose to be happy in spite of your circumstances, you're not never gonna be happy. Every single old person would be miserable, because if you at 30 got, uh, the level of arthritis, and your friends are dying off, and all these things are happening, you would just hate it and be miserable. They are obliged to find a way to get around this.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So that's why I think, again, this notion of 2,000 older people yelling at you this one insight is one way to get yourself moving in that direction.
- MRMel Robbins
Mm. And just think of how much it would change your life.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Yeah.
- MRMel Robbins
And the, the, the, "It's not the year..." What, I love that saying that it's not the years in your, it's the, "It's not the years in your life, it's the life in your years."
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Right.
- MRMel Robbins
And if you could teach yourself to default toward choosing intentionally to look at what you do have, choosing intentionally to look at what is working, choosing intentionally to wake up and make today a good day simply because you woke up, what a difference that would make in your life.
- 1:11:51 – 1:14:55
Healthy Habits Linked to a Longer, Happier Life
- MRMel Robbins
You know, one other thing I wanted to ask you is that, um, you likely aren't gonna make it to be very old if you're not taking care of yourself.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Mm-hmm.
- MRMel Robbins
So what do 80-, 90-, and 100-year-olds say is the secret to staying healthy through life? Like, what do they wish they had done earlier?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Uh, the o- Um, this is one of the insights that, th- when I give talks on this, that people wanna hear the least. So, uh, the one thing I...
- MRMel Robbins
(laughs)
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Th- when I tell them elder wisdom about your health, I get this feeling of fingers in ears and, "I'm not listening." But they had, I think, a profound insight, uh, that I wish people trying to do public h- health messaging would embrace, and I've tried to argue that in different venues. Young people, when they think about their health, and I imagine some of you out there have said this or know people who've said it...... "I like smoking, I like eating junk food, I like not exercising, and I don't care how long I live. I really don't. If I enjoy these things so much, if I die at 69 rather than 78, who cares?" What America's elders know is, you will not just die at 69. Medical science is gonna keep you alive in a state of incredibly burdensome chronic disease for one or two decades. So your worry isn't dying, they say. Don't worry about dying, worry about chronic illness.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
And we know now from increasingly powerful research, what you do in your 30s and 40s and 50s can be more important than what you do in your 60s and 70s.
- MRMel Robbins
Hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
So these sort of heart-healthy, chronic disease prevention lifestyles in midlife are really critical. So one of the main messages that they wanna say is anytime you hear yourself saying, "You know, I don't really care about this unhealthy habit. You know, I don't really need to live that long," that's not your worry. You know, you, um, you- your worry, y- y- you aren't going to live unhealthily and then drop dead. You're going to be burdened with chronic disease. And when you see it in lots and lots of older people and hear them talk about it, many of them are so regretful that they couldn't stop their spouse from smoking, they couldn't, you know, get someone to become more healthy. And it sort of ruined not just one year, but a de- you know, a decade or two of life, because you will be kept alive in a state of very burdensome chronic disease. So I ho- I've tried to argue over and over, that should be your motivation, that you want to do everything you can right now to avoid this.
- MRMel Robbins
The, um ... One of the main takeaways from people in their 80s, 90s, and 100s in your research is that as you near the end of your life and realize you don't have 50 more years, you have a handful, that knowledge creates gratitude. The grateful knowledge that
- 1:14:55 – 1:17:20
The Power of Gratitude
- MRMel Robbins
today is another day. Every day, one of your respond- one of the people in your research study said, "Every day, I say, 'Yes, I'm alive,' and every night, I say, 'Thank you.' I always pick the most simple, most mundane thing to be thankful for, because that's where the meaning of your life is at." What did you learn about the power of being just grateful for another day and thankful for the mundane thing that actually matters in life?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Uh, I'm not sure if you've ever had anybody on who's sort of a gratitude, you know, the kind of gratitude, happiness researcher. So, this sense of gratitude for small things is a key part of this ... Well, uh, this sense of gratefulness for small positive things is a key part of this broader concept of, of that happiness is a choice rather than a condition. So, it is a shift in focus to, again, gratitude for those things in your life that are working, rather than focusing on those that aren't. Um, I'm gonna metaphorically pound my fist on the table-
- MRMel Robbins
(laughs)
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... and say that if, uh, that this is something that your listeners should really absorb and take to heart, because it's practical wisdom that is so evidence-based, that if you are in a very bad time-
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... things are extremely stressful, if you can infuse a positive emotion into that, your negativity will drop. So let- so one thing that has been extensively studied is people who are caring, say, for a person very debilitated with Alzheimer's disease. Those people who are unbelievably stressed, you know, constantly up all night, the person is wondering, but who are encouraged to think, "I'm doing something great here."
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
You know, "I'm fulfilling my filial or marital responsibility," um, "I am showing that I am a competent person because I can do this," simply in, you know, in infusing or, or, "I'm grateful I still have this person," you can infuse positive emotions. It's not like you have to get rid of the negative ones, but you, there's pure scientific evidence if you bring in positive emotions into a very negative and stressful experience, uh, the negativity drops.
- 1:17:20 – 1:22:37
Live Like Your Life is Short
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
- MRMel Robbins
So, uh, Professor Pillemer, after immersing yourself in all this research and really extracting the wisdom from 80, 90, and 100-year-olds on how you can improve your life, what is the big takeaway that's changed your life the most?
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
Um, I want to s- I have a big one, and then I have a smaller piece of advice-
- MRMel Robbins
Great.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... um, for your listeners. But I would say, for all of it, of all the things I learned can be summed up in an expression which also reflects some earlier things we've talked about, but I'm gonna take the risk of re-emphasizing it, and that is, live like your life is short. That is, u- u- understand that every older person I talk to, and the older they were, the- the more likely they were to say, "Life is short," or, "Life is really short," or, "Life is really, really, really short," or as one retired engineer said, "It seems like it passed by in a nanosecond."
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
I had a 99-year-old, actually one of my favorite quotes in the book is a 99-year-old, uh, like, l- l- like, looked at me and said, "I don't know what happened 'cause the next thing you know, you're 100." Um, that, you know, kinda that was a, you- you w- I can guarantee to every person listening to this, uh, that when you get in your 80s, 90s behind, you will say, "I cannot believe how quickly this passed. It seemed like my life passed by almost in an instant."Now, the thing about older people is they're telling you, "Don't let that depress you. Use that as a superpower." I mean, you know, use it as an understanding to both take the long view, whether my colleague has a nicer office than me isn't gonna make any difference to me in, i- in 60 years, and in the short term. Life is gonna seem so short that I cannot waste it in things-
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
... you know, that aren't ultimately fulfilling. So, I would say the one message that came in all the books I've done, all the research is this overpowering sense of how, how short life really is, and over and over people said, "There's not enough time to cram everything you want to in it. Don't waste your life." So, I would say, you know, like, it didn't the... uh, I think in the Hebrew scriptures, you know, "Teach us, you know, to number our days so that we may get ourselves a heart of wisdom."
- MRMel Robbins
Mm-hmm.
- KPDr. Karl Pillemer
It's very hard to do 'cause it's so depressing for people. But if you live like your life is short, uh, you will make very different decisions about how long you stay in a crappy job, about how long you stay in a bad relationship, a- about how long you wait to express love to people you love, about, you know, how long, you know, how much time you spend with your children when they're growing up. Th- that's what older people have to tell you, that you're gonna come to my age and you're gonna say, "Wow, this was a short time I had." And you're gonna w- a- and you're gonna reflect very seriously on how you spent your time. And I think if you live like your life is short, you have a, a pretty strong chance of a better life.
- MRMel Robbins
I am so grateful that you're here. I feel so inspired by everything that you shared with us because it is true. I don't care how old you are, whether you just finished high school or you are in your 80s. When you look back, it feels like it went in the blink of an eye. And what you shared today, you gave us the practical tools, and the powerful insights, and the life-changing wisdom that we need in order to start living more intentionally, choosing happiness, making amends, and doing the things that are well within our power starting today to change the course of our lives. And so, I just wanna say thank you. Thank you, Professor Pillemer, for being here. Thank you for the research that you're doing. Thank you for showing up and sharing all of this with a sense of urgency that this is not only something to pay attention to, and to share, and to be inspired by, but it is a gift and an opportunity for you to start changing your life right now. And thank you. Thank you for choosing to listen to something that could change your life. Thank you for caring about the wisdom of people in their 80s, 90s, and 100s. And I, I guarantee you, if you could get in a time machine and you could go and time travel and see yourself at the age of 90 or 100, you would tell yourself right now exactly what you just learned today. So, don't just listen, go do something about it. And in case no one else tells you, I wanted to be sure to tell you as your friend, because remember he said one of the five big things that you need to do is to say it, so I'm gonna say it. I love you and I believe in you, and I believe in your ability to create a better life. And now you have a roadmap, wisdom from people in their 80s, 90s, and 100s that you can use to create a better life starting right now. All righty, I'll see you in the very next episode. I'll be there to welcome you in the moment you hit play.
Episode duration: 1:22:37
Install uListen for AI-powered chat & search across the full episode — Get Full Transcript
Transcript of episode IF0QIfwYQnw
Get more out of YouTube videos.
High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.
Add to Chrome