By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
Modern WisdomThe Perfect Storm Reshaping The Global Economy - Steve Keen (4K)
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
80 min read · 16,207 wordsThe Biggest Forces Disrupting the Global Economy
Chris Williamson 0:00 A quick note. The year is coming to an end, and you'll probably want to learn some lessons from it and maybe plan to make next year even better. I have put together the single best annual review process that I've ever found from all of my favorite thinkers, the best bits, and it is in a document that you can just copy and paste into your notes app and fill it into your heart's content. Make sure that you start off next year right by going to chriswillx.com/review. That's chriswillx.com/review. Everything about the global economic environment feels pretty chaotic at the moment. What are the big driving forces causing the disruption that we're seeing today?
Dr. Steve Keen 0:34 [laughs] That's a life, the universe, and everything question. I mean, obviously, wars that are taking place right now are disrupting the global economy. We're in the aftermath of the global financial crisis. We still haven't recovered from what caused the crisis, which was excessive levels of private debt, not government debt. Um, we have a dramatic change in the distribution of manufacturing on the planet. I think it's, uh, it's literally an epochal change, the rise of China and the decline of America and the West in general.
Chris Williamson 1:06 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:07 Uh, and at the same time, global warming. And, uh, I, I think you couldn't get more of a perfect storm than what's coming our way right now, including El Niño, of course, being the next major storm.
Chris Williamson 1:19 What's that?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20 El Niño? Uh, it's a regular event of the climate, so it happens a, a regular process where warm water rises from the depths of the Pacific to the surface, therefore transfers heat from the ocean to the atmosphere. And this has been something which has been part of the planetary system for millennia.
Chris Williamson 1:42 Just cyclical.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:43 Okay. But we are now turbocharging it because the bubble of water that's coming up, uh, I mean, and coming to the surface now, uh, is gonna increase global temperatures by the order between 0.2 and 0.4 of degree, uh, very, very rapidly. And so, uh, w- every time an El Niño oc- occurs, it's like having... being in a bath. And, you know, a bath has got varying temperatures of water, and a bit of warm water comes to the surface. Well, that water gets put into the bathroom's air pocket. The same thing happens with the planet. But 90% of the heat that's been absorbed by the planet by global warming has gone into the ocean. So this is a bubble of that heat coming to the surface, and it will increase the average temperature of the planet by, uh, at the moment, we're about 15 and a half degrees global average temperature across the... That's the average temperature of the planet over an entire year. It might rise to 15.7 or 15.9, and that's a one and a half to 1.7 to 1.9 degrees above the temperature that the planet was at before we discovered fossil fuels, and that's the real issue that's going to... That's the dominant issue. Of course, economists don't know that because they produce absolute bullshit on climate change, and that's what I'm trying to expose.
Are Young People Facing an Unprecedented Economic Crisis?
Chris Williamson 3:00 Hmm. When it comes to the sort of economic environment, I think most of the headlines that I'm seeing at the moment, a lot of them are around young people, the challenges that young people face.
Dr. Steve Keen 3:11 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 3:11 Uh, housing prices, being able to get onto the property ladder, being able to feel like they can provide for themselves and potentially be safe and secure enough to be able to build a family. Is this right now a unique era for young people financially, economically?
Dr. Steve Keen 3:26 Oh, yeah. I mean, um, if, if you went back 150 years, the situation of young people was far worse than it is today. They were working, you know, down the mines. They were ch- You know, child labor was what we had in the West. So in, in that sense, we're better now than at any time in history. But I think the difference is for terms like my generation versus the generation coming through now. If I go back to when I was a 20-year-old, um, the unemployment rate in Australia, because I was Australian, uh, at the time I, I was 18 at university, was 1.5%, and you felt absolutely guaranteed you'd get a job. Uh, you had no fear, and I'm speaking from personal experience, about anything you did jeopardizing your possibility of having employment, okay? And then in the 1970s, we had a shift in the management of the economy from focusing upon keeping em- unemployment down, which was the attitude after World War II, to keeping the inflation rate down, which has been the attitude since the 1970s. And the promise of that time, the, the promise of n- what we call neoliberal policies, was that the economy will grow so much faster if we get rid of all these terrible government regulations-
Chris Williamson 4:43 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 4:43 ... and all those controls. Get rid of them, and the economy will grow so much faster, and your wages will rise so quickly that you won't need to have social security because you can save money for yourself. You won't need public health because you can pay for private hospitals. You won't need public education because you can buy... Your wage will be so much better than it would've been. Well, that's all complete crap. What has actually happened is the rate of growth with- in the previous period before the '70s, uh, the rate of growth of per capita incomes roughly... I haven't got the figures in front of me, so I, I could make some mistakes of numbers, but not of scale. The rate of economic growth was about, say, 3% per annum under the in, in per capita income increases between 1945 and 1975. Since 1975, the belief of Reagan and Thatcher and all the economists that supported them was that we'd get a higher rate of growth. Well, it's actually fallen from 3% to 1% per annum. So that promised increase in income hasn't occurred for the, for the, uh, for the youth these days. We've also been de-unionized, so they don't have any capacity to bargain anymore. They're working in gig economy jobs. All this is massive insecurity and angst coming out of that, and I think that's what we're seeing erupting in Europe right now. So the promise was that by privatizing and by deregulating and getting rid of government intervention, yada, yada, yada, we ended up in a better world. We've ended up in a worse one. So I think that's the specifically economic failures that modern youth are coping with. And they've got every right to be angry about it because the promises versus the outcome are completely different.
Chris Williamson 6:25 Yeah. I think for a lot of people it feels like millennials and Gen Z are playing an economic game that they can no longer win.
Dr. Steve Keen 6:31 Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, uh, if I go back like my... As a, as a... I'm 73 now, okay? So go back 50 years, 23. 55 years, I'm 18 years old. And I raised in a middle-class family in Australia. My mother and father were both bank clerks. Um, and, but, and because of the sexist rules at the time, when they got married, mom had to leave the bank. So dad's the sole income earner, uh, five children, and he... With a, an advantageous interest rate, I must concede-
Chris Williamson 7:03 Mm
Dr. Steve Keen 7:03 ... being a bank employee. But on one salary, he could raise, support seven people and buy a house, okay? And then retire at 55. He was forced to retire through ill health. That was all feasible. Completely non-feasible today. You've gotta have two income earners. Uh, you can't afford to have kids, okay? Um, you- everything has to be based on how much debt you've accumulated because you've gotta borrow money to pay for education. You borrow money to buy the house, et cetera, et cetera. Uh, they're excluded from the, uh, the gravy train that the baby boomers were on.
Chris Williamson 7:39 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 7:40 And so they've got every right to be angry.
Why Economic Growth No Longer Means a Better Life
Chris Williamson 7:42 Have we accidentally created an economy where it's more profitable to own a house than it is to become a doctor?
Dr. Steve Keen 7:48 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, but, but that's, that's, that process is failing right now. It's because you can only keep on doing that so long as the person who buys a house off you borrows more money than you did to buy the house.
Chris Williamson 8:02 Okay.
Dr. Steve Keen 8:02 So the only way that works indefinitely is the level of leverage, the ratio of household debt to income continues rising.
Chris Williamson 8:11 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 8:11 And also you've gotta have a cohort that can afford to buy in. Now, again, back when I was... I mean, I f- I'm sorry I didn't do it. Um, I haven't speculated on assets at all in my whole life. But I remember with the, the house we were renting as a share house, uh, in, in my early 20s, uh, we could have bought it for, I think, $12,500. Now, that was about a year's income for me at the time. So it'd be feasible to buy a house with... If I'd saved up a, a whole year's income, I could have bought the house we're in. Now, you have to save for 10, 10 years' worth of income to buy that house. So the, the proportion of population that can do it is shrinking, and the number of people who are, uh, the age at which people can actually s- consider taking on a mortgage is rising-
Chris Williamson 8:57 Mm
Dr. Steve Keen 8:57 ... all the time. So we're exhausting it. It, it ultimately had to be exhausted. And w- we've lived in this fiction that you can have rising house prices indefinitely. Now we're getting to the point where that no longer is feasible, and we're seeing house prices falling. But the vast majority of people can't afford to get on that ladder at all.
Chris Williamson 9:14 Why is it the case that economic growth stopped translating into a better quality of life for ordinary people?
Dr. Steve Keen 9:22 Mainly because workers lost bargaining power. If you, uh, the, the, the argument that economists will make, and it's all based on garbage economics. I'm happy to trash conventional economics as much as you would, would like to hear during our conversation. But the conventional argument is that people, um, everybody shares and the, you know, the, a rising tide lifts all boats, okay? The reality is if you don't have the bargaining power, you don't get to bargain, that your boat goes up while the others go down.
Chris Williamson 9:50 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 9:50 So the distribution of income, there was some capacity of workers to bargain when we had trade unions on mass, mass level trade unions. So workers could bargain for a share in the increase in GDP. Now, unions have been almost destroyed. They're remnants in America. They're pretty much remnants in the UK and in, and, and, and, and most of Europe as well. So workers don't have organization to mean they can bargain. They're bargaining against massive employe- employers. Um, they simply don't have the bargaining power. So the distribution of income has shifted from the workers to the bankers, and this is something which, um, my research establishes, which was a complete surprise to me, that the rising level of private debt actually causes a fall in the share of income going to workers.
Chris Williamson 10:44 Why?
Dr. Steve Keen 10:45 That is a very good question. When I... I did not expect it. This, uh, w- I got into economics originally by critiquing Marx, but also by modeling, um, financial instability. That was the, the thing which gave me my prominence.
Chris Williamson 10:59 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 10:59 Okay. Uh, and to build a model of, of, um, of financial instability, I took a model of the cyclical economy, which didn't have banks in it, and I then put the banks in the cyclical economy. And in the, in the model, I had capitalists borrowing money from banks specifically to build factories, okay? So the capitalists are borrowing money, and they're building factories. They're not building yachts and stuff like that. They're actually producing physical productive capacity, which is what you want them to do. And what I thought was that I'd, I'd get a model which gave me increasing cycles over time leading to a debt-induced breakdown. That was what I was trying to model. And I thought that as the rising amount of... If this level of private debt rose, so all the borrowing was then done by the corporate sector, okay? It was all being to build factories, and the factories had increased the capacity to produce output. But I thought the rising amount of money going to bankers would cause a falling amount going to capitalists. When I simulated the model, what I got was the capitalists fluctuated around until the crisis occurred. The amount going to bankers rose as the level of private debt rose, and the social group that got less income was workers.
Chris Williamson 12:08 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 12:09 Okay? Now, ultimately, and ironically, it turns out Marx was right about the causal dynamics here. He said that the determining factor is the level of investment. So the rate of investment is what determines income distribution and the total income as well. So now when you have-- when, when you include bankers in the system, the workers are the ones who, who don't have the bargaining power. So the capitalists will invest at their desired rate, okay? And it doesn't-- If, if their desired rate of profit is, say, twenty percent of GDP, they couldn't care who gets the other eighty percent. Okay? So what you get over time is the level of debt rises. You've got to pay more interest for the higher level of debt. That means of the eighty percent, more of it goes to the bankers, less goes to the workers.
Chris Williamson 13:01 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 13:01 So the rising level of private debt has actually caused the decline in workers' share of GDP. And the real class enemies of workers in that sense is not capitalists, it's bankers.
Chris Williamson 13:13 Hmm. Much less of a sexy argument, though, at least at
Why Raising a Family Has Become So Expensive
Chris Williamson 13:18 the moment. Yeah, it's interesting thinking about the, the cost of sort of raising a family. I don't know where I fall on this. I-I've had a couple of conversations this year that have been quite, uh, enlightening to me, and one of them was discussing how a lot of people want to maintain the level of lifestyle that they have when perhaps they're single or when they're living with a partner, and then they bring kids into the mix.
Dr. Steve Keen 13:43 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 13:43 But they still want to have the same level of lifestyle that they had before the kids were there.
Dr. Steve Keen 13:47 Hmm.
Chris Williamson 13:47 And if you have a pie and a big chunk of that pie now needs to be spent on food and diapers and assistance with care and, uh, redoing the third cupboard to become-
Dr. Steve Keen 13:57 Yeah
Chris Williamson 13:57 ... a, a nursery or whatever, you can't do that.
Dr. Steve Keen 14:00 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 14:01 You can't go away on holiday as much. You can't update the car as frequently. And I think that, um, there are sort of real economic limitations, but I wonder how much of it is because conceding a lifestyle recession or, uh, accepting a, a pullback in terms of the more publicly lauded, uh, good parts, fun parts of having a life-
Dr. Steve Keen 14:29 Hmm
Chris Williamson 14:29 ... going on holiday rec- uh, frequently, uh, being able to update your wardrobe, being able to go out for dinner as much, being able to, uh, y- get your car. I get the sense that one of the big driving forces behind that is that people aren't prepared to take a step back in terms of their sort of public wealth in order to fund their familial wealth. I think that contributes to it, at least in part.
Dr. Steve Keen 14:50 It's part of it, but I think it's also because, again, if you look back on the fifties and sixties, uh, the education was largely, certainly in the UK, paid for by the state. Health was paid for by the state, et cetera, et cetera. When we privatized those services, we haven't completely privatized health, but education has been massively privatized, and now you've got the, the debt there as well. What you didn't have to pay for in the past is now coming out of your wage.
Chris Williamson 15:14 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 15:14 Okay? So a lot of this isn't just because individuals wanna hang on to their pre-child lifestyle.
Chris Williamson 15:21 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 15:21 That's the same thing in the fifties and sixties. But you are forced into, you know, you've got to cut back. You don't go to restaurants, you eat, eat at home. Uh, but you didn't have to pay for your education, your health, all these things which used to be covered by state payments-
Chris Williamson 15:37 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 15:37 ... are now expected to come out of your salary. And so that would only have worked if the salaries continued rising, and you'd know that graph that shows that in nineteen seventy-four, basically the workers, you know, rising GDP and riking- rising wages, real wages over time, and then they diverge from that point on. So if we'd followed the line where GDP continued rising and wages did the same thing, then a lot of what the fantasy about paying for your own education and paying for health and so on would be feasible, but it hasn't. So in many ways, workers have been stuck, not quite. They've gained a bit, but on average, working-class people are no better off in real terms now than they were fifty years ago. So most of that increase in wealth has gone partly to capitalists, but mainly to bankers, mainly to what Marx used to call rentiers, and so did Adam Smith, for that matter. So we've let the rentiers taken over the economy, and that's what's causing most of the misery for the working class.
Does the UK Have the Worst Quality of Life Economically?
Chris Williamson 16:35 Which are the countries in the Western Hemisphere that you think have done the worst job of giving working people their quality of life in line with their wages?
Dr. Steve Keen 16:49 [laughs] I think the UK stands out pretty prominently there, unfortunately. Um, I mean, I... Just as my own personal anecdote, when I got offered the position at Kingston University back in two thousand and fourteen, I was a professor in Sydney, it was University of Western Sydney, and my salary then was a hundred and seventy thousand Australian dollars. Right? And I had no administrative responsibilities whatsoever. And they said, "What do you want for the position?" I said, "Well, I don't want to get less than I'm getting in Australia." And they said, "Well, then match it." So I get eighty-eight thousand pounds.
Chris Williamson 17:20 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 17:21 Okay? Which when I-- um, on the, on the Kingston salary range, I was the top. Every time they did a salary range for the staff, bang. I knew that was to the cent. That was my salary at the top of the range. I ended up with four thousand pounds a month after all deductions came out. So down to, you know, from eighty-eight to forty-eight thousand. So forty thousand went in all the various deductions that are taken. I then had to pay the rent, and I had to pay s- a lot of the costs that are covered in Australia by the landlord are imposed upon council rates and stuff-
Chris Williamson 17:51 Yep, yep, yep
Dr. Steve Keen 17:51 ... imposed upon the tenant here.
Chris Williamson 17:53 Yep.
Dr. Steve Keen 17:53 Ended up with about two grand a month to live on. And I said I had to live on Sainsbury takeaways. I couldn't afford to go to restaurants anymore. And so I worked out-
Chris Williamson 18:01 As the highest paid-
Dr. Steve Keen 18:03 Yeah, the highest paid academic-
Chris Williamson 18:04 Professor
Dr. Steve Keen 18:04 ... at Kingston University, and I, I could go to a restaurant maybe once or twice a month. I used to go every day in Sydney, pretty much. And I bumped into a couple of friends who are other economists, not different politics to me, and I, I, and I said, "How are you finding London?" This is a male and female couple. Paul Fritters is the guy. I can't remember his wife's name. And they both had this crestfallen look on them. And they then said, "We've worked out we're about forty percent worse off than we were in Australia." And I said, "Spot on. That's my calculation as well." So if I had to say any country in Europe is headed towards third world status, it's the UK.
Chris Williamson 18:40 For fuck's sake. [laughs] Oh. Yeah, I... Look, I, I, I left the UK four years ago, and, and there is definitely a trend for people who have done to sort of turn around and be flippant or dismissive or callous about the situation-
Dr. Steve Keen 18:55 Yeah
Chris Williamson 18:55 ... that, that they're no longer a part of.
Dr. Steve Keen 18:57 And that's... The callousness is what I find particularly confronting because you're feeling a callousness from people about the rest of the world, and you... every five minutes you're walking past a homeless person-
Chris Williamson 19:08 Yeah
Dr. Steve Keen 19:08 ... in the heart of the city.
Chris Williamson 19:09 Yeah. Yeah. Uh, but the UK is not showering itself in glory at the moment. I saw a, a video the other day of a guy that owns a pie shop in, I want to say maybe Manchester, and he was explaining about what the changes in the minimum wage, because recently Andy Burnham has said that there's gonna be a minimum wage increase in the UK, and I think it takes a full-time job for someone who's over 21 to about £27,000.
Dr. Steve Keen 19:39 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 19:40 I mean, yeah, inflation, whatever, like when I would've been looking at that around about university, it would've been 15 years ago for me.
Dr. Steve Keen 19:47 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 19:47 But like nearly 30 grand, especially in pounds, right?
Dr. Steve Keen 19:51 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 19:51 Which is closer to $40. 40, 40 grand in dollars. That's not a bad wage, or it didn't used to be a bad wage.
Dr. Steve Keen 19:58 No.
Chris Williamson 19:59 And, and this guy that was explaining in the pie shop, he said, "Well, because what's happening to my staff, that's £700 a week of an increase in that, and then there's going to be additional costs that are going to be pulled in from my suppliers because they're gonna have to pay more, which means they're gonna have to put their prices up, which means I'm gonna have to put my prices up, which means that I'm gonna get fewer customers coming in, and they're gonna get annoyed at me." And it works out he needs to sell, it's like tens of thousands of additional pies just in order to be able to keep his head above water at where it was previously. And yeah, there's this squeezing of what would've been a previous entrepreneurial or entrepreneurial adjacent middle class. And, um, it doesn't surprise me that... The UK has kind of always had somewhat of a, a low-key cynicism, skepticism, uh, sort of stiff-upper-lip approach to things. It does not surprise me that that is becoming more and more prevalent. Where would your rosy disposition economically come from?
Dr. Steve Keen 21:01 Look, I, I go back to the fact that U- UK has deindustrialized itself in the last 40 or 50 years. That's, I think, really the source of the angst that we're going through, and we've gone over to being a financialized economy rather than a manufacturing economy.
Chris Williamson 21:15 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 21:15 Uh, if you had the manufacturing economy, you could support those rising wages. Uh, the fact that it's been deindustrialized, uh, and, and all the money is being made in the services sector, and the service sector really means the City of London, and services means creating private debt. Okay? That was the, the real growth engine for what's happened between 1970 and, and now. But that is in no way that services make up for the decline in manufacturing.
Chris Williamson 21:44 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 21:45 And the, the myth that Maggie Thatcher fell for, and Bill Clinton the same, is that, uh, you know, services are the future. Manufacturing is old hat. We'll, uh, get the manufacturing done in a Third World country. We'll still do the design over here. Um, and, and then we can get the, you know, the services. They see design as services and, and they saw financial services as something which you could expand indefinitely. Uh, all crap. The industrial, uh, might has moved to China. The design is being done there, not here. We don't have the engineers anymore that can do that level of design in the West, and certainly in the UK. So it has been a failed economic strategy for 50 years, and that's why it's so hard to support the population today because you simply don't have the productivity that the country had comparatively that it had back 50 years ago. Like as a kid, I used to watch a show, uh, called The Plane Makers. Do you ever see that? Okay. It was an Eng- a, a movie, a, a drama about an English aircraft manufacturer. Does that sound like a sensible thing to do today?
Chris Williamson 22:53 [laughs]
Dr. Steve Keen 22:54 Okay? It made... It was obvious there'd be plane manufacturing in the UK 50 years ago. But now you make components for the Airbus and that's it. Uh, so the decline in manufacturing and the deliberate run- running down of manufacturing and belief services could take over, I think that's one of the major sources of the, of the malaise, not the behavior of individual people, but the framework we've set up for them, which has always been a fallacy.
Chris Williamson 23:22 Most people have no idea where their testosterone levels sit. They'll talk about it. They'll insult their friends about it, but they don't actually know what theirs are. What if I told you there was a solution, something that identifies low T faster than a high school bully, and it won't cost you all of your lunch money? That is where Function comes in. It gives you access to over 160 advanced lab tests, including a deep dive into your full hormone panel. Every result is reviewed by clinicians, and anything out of range is flagged. You get clear explanations and a personalized protocol with next steps so that if something is off, you know exactly what to do about it. Normally, this level of testing would usually cost thousands, but with Function, it is only $365 a year, $1 a day to stop guessing with your health and start actually knowing what's going on. And you can get an additional $25 off, bringing it down to 340 bucks. Get the exact same blood panels that I get and save $25 by going to the link in the description below or heading to functionhealth.com/modernwisdom and using the code MODERNWISDOM at checkout. That's functionhealth.com/modernwisdom and MODERNWISDOM at checkout.
Will AI Destroy the Global Economy?
Chris Williamson 24:20 What's AI going to do to the economy?
Dr. Steve Keen 24:23 Um, AI could be... I mean, it is a epochal technology. Um, the fact that you can now get a machine which can, you know, do research, relatively speaking, uh, which can take over mundane clerical positions, uh, which if robotics ever gets past the, the very many, many problems in getting robotics to work properly and replace human labor. But it would be feasible to replace an entire social class because the one reason workers get jobs right now is workers do things that machines can't do. Now, we're nowhere near this, and I'm just certainly looking at the robotics. There are issues just about the joints, uh, and the wearing out and, uh, you know, uh, the ma- maneuverability and of hands and so on, uh, on, on robots that we haven't cracked that yet. We will one of these days. But if we did crack it, and we did have the copper that's necessary and all the physical scale, you wouldn't need human labor in manufacturing, and you wouldn't need human labor in clerical processes inside corporations and government. And that means that the one reason that workers got employment in the past history of capitalism would cease being how they got employment, and that means you have to do one of two things. You either have to do what Elon Musk is talking about, when he talks about universal high income.
Chris Williamson 25:48 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 25:49 Okay? But that means how are you gonna give people money to spend when they don't have a job? Which means you've gotta have a universal government provision of money so people can go shopping. Or we end up in The Hunger Games, where you ig- ignore the vast majority of the people, you entertain them by letting them kill each other, and the, an elite lives on the largesse of having a robotic soci- um, system that manufactures everything they consume.
Chris Williamson 26:15 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 26:16 So again, this is one of the many sort of sliding doors that I can see us facing, and almost certain we're gonna choose the wrong door.
Chris Williamson 26:24 You've predicted that the AI investment bubble's got less than a year left.
Dr. Steve Keen 26:28 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 26:28 Why?
Dr. Steve Keen 26:29 Oh, fun- fundamentally because it, the, one of the natural things in a capitalist economy, uh, is that when a new technology comes in, it initially causes a boom in the economy because, uh, an entrepreneur, n- not all of them, but entrepreneurs can be people with good ideas and no money. Okay? Uh, and the best person to look at this is Joseph Schumpeter with a, uh, his PhD thesis he wrote back in 1907, I think it was, which is titled The Theory of, uh, Economic Development. And what he argues is that he, he takes the position, ignores the, you know, established businesses that already have money, and says an entrepreneur is somebody with a good idea and no money, yeah. So to put their good idea into practice, they've gotta borrow money, and when they borrow money from the banking system, that creates money. It's not redistributing existing money. It creates new money. That then is spent into the economy, and it causes a boom 'cause you're, you, you know, you're building a new... In the 1890s, 1800s, it was railways, okay? You gotta, you, you borrow the money, you're building railways everywhere, you're employing people, you're buying steel, et cetera, et cetera. For data centers now, you're buying GPUs, you're buying, you know, copper wiring everywhere. You cause a boom, okay? But then once the technology comes online, you cause a slump-
Chris Williamson 27:46 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 27:46 ... because you undermine the previous industry. So if you look at railways, railways, when they were de- developed, everybody was building railways. Everybody thought they were gonna be the only entrepreneur left who made railways.
Chris Williamson 27:58 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 27:58 So of course you get over-investment.
Chris Williamson 28:00 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 28:00 Too much being created.
Chris Williamson 28:01 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 28:02 Then when the product comes online, it doesn't get the sales that are expected. It's still a transform- transformative industry-
Chris Williamson 28:09 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 28:09 ... but your sales slump, and you also undercut the previous industries. So in the case of the railways, canals got slaughtered, carriages got slaughtered, et cetera, et cetera. So boom and bust cycle is a natural part of bringing in a major transformative technology.
Chris Williamson 28:26 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 28:26 Now, so that's what I'm saying. The, the level of over-investment seems ridiculous. I mean, I don't keep close track of the numbers, but it's some- it looks like something of the order that costs five times the income. Okay? Something like that, which means you're accumulating debt. You're bor- you're getting... So all these companies that had large amounts of money, the Microsofts and the Googles with enormous cash reserves, they started this. It wasn't borrowing from banks initially.
Chris Williamson 28:53 Yep.
Dr. Steve Keen 28:53 But now they'd be running down their reserves and borrowing from banks-
Chris Williamson 28:56 Yep, yep, yep, yep
Dr. Steve Keen 28:56 ... et cetera, et cetera. So we're setting ourselves up for a slump. When, when you get to the other stage and these companies start folding, you know, maybe, maybe 10% of them will survive. God knows how many will actually survive the boom and bust cycle. But when that decline happens, then all these pr- people, companies people have overvalued by buying into the shares on the belief this trajectory's gonna be maintained will fail, and those prices will fall.
Chris Williamson 29:20 How much of the current Western economy is predicated on this sector?
Dr. Steve Keen 29:28 Oh, like, I've seen... Again, I don't follow this d- this stage. I've got the numbers on the top of my head, but I've seen it's estimates of 2 or 3% of GDP being the scale of investment that's going into data centers and so on.
Chris Williamson 29:42 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 29:43 It's a substantial level of investment. Now, if you go from 2% to half a percent, okay, then you've got a fairly strong decline in demand in the economy, and I do expect that the, a cl- a slump, a, a classic stock market boom and bust, like happened in 2000. 'Cause the last time this happened on scale was when you had all the telecommunications, uh, the bubble in the 1990s, people laying op- you know, optical cable everywhere, and they actually laid 10 times as much optical cable as was necessary. So you would've heard about dark fiber. You know-
Chris Williamson 30:17 No, what's that?
Dr. Steve Keen 30:18 Okay. Well, when you, when you lay optical cable, you've gotta have lasers to send the signal down the cable, and you've gotta have booster se- stations along the cables as well. So because virtually 10 times as much cable was laid, it was actually necessary in the 1990s. 90% of that cable didn't have lasers attached, so it was called dark fiber. Okay? But then in the aftermath of the slump, you could buy this stuff really cheaply.
Chris Williamson 30:46 [laughs]
Dr. Steve Keen 30:47 Okay? And then people would buy it, and then they'd attach lasers to make the dark fiber work. So it, it transforms soci- the, the technology transforms society-
Chris Williamson 30:58 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 30:58 ... when the slump is going on that the technology actually caused. And this was an argument that I read in Schumpeter, uh, when I was using him for one of my courses at, um, Western Sydney, and I th- when I first read this argument, that the technology permeates society during the slump- Not during the boom, but during the slump. I thought that's can't be right.
Chris Williamson 31:17 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 31:17 And then I saw it happen in front of me. So that, that boom and bust cycle, it's, this is a, a natural cycle of a capitalist economy, which mainstream economics completely fails to understand.
Chris Williamson 31:28 Why is there always an overestimation of what the market's desire for a new technology will be?
Dr. Steve Keen 31:36 Oh, because we don't coordinate. And one of the strengths of capitalism, people always talk it up, you know, individual entrepreneurs make your own decisions, et cetera, et cetera. No central planning. What that means is 10 entrepreneurs go into an industry which is gonna support one.
Chris Williamson 31:52 And they all assume, "Yeah, but I'm best."
Dr. Steve Keen 31:53 They all think, "I'm gonna be the survivor."
Chris Williamson 31:55 Right. Okay. And obviously you're incentivized to do that. It's, it's-
Dr. Steve Keen 31:58 Yeah
Chris Williamson 31:58 ... in your interests to do that.
Dr. Steve Keen 32:00 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 32:00 But when you look at it at a more a- macro scale, you end up with these people pumping up the price.
Dr. Steve Keen 32:04 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 32:05 Because there's so much excitement, it's, it's a, a hot, bubbly market at the time.
Dr. Steve Keen 32:10 Yeah. And like, and Hyman Minsky spoke about this brilliantly as well, 'cause he, uh, there's a conventional economics has this mythical belief the economy reaches equilibrium.
Chris Williamson 32:19 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 32:19 Complete and absolute myth. It's what makes them useless and frankly dangerous for managing a capitalist economy. But Hyman Minsky was somebody who really understood the system, and he said that capitalism is inherently flawed because it necessarily is enables signals to be generated that inspire additional investment, and then provides finance that enables that to happen. So you, you get a boom and bust cycle coming out of capitalism, and you will always have overinvestment when a new technology comes in.
How AI Could Revolutionise the Economy
Chris Williamson 32:50 Is AI genuinely going to be revolutionary from an economic perspective, or have investors convinced themselves it's more valuable than it actually is?
Dr. Steve Keen 32:58 Uh, I think it's a bit of the latter, definitely. Um, but like I have, you know, I, I, I work with a computer programmer to design software, so he- I'm seeing his own feedback of what he's now enabled, enabled to do by having an AI agents searching out problems with how his software integrates with other software systems that it relies upon. Uh, and now he said it's actually coming up with decent code, so I can see that people are using it and replacing what would otherwise be jobs. Okay? So that is hugely transformative. So I think ultimately the promise is there. It will transform how we produce and how we manage our economies. But the danger is that at the same time, it undermines the d- demand side of the economy. 'Cause we, we live in a mass market economy still. Uh, you know, we have Woolworths and Sa- Sainsbury's and all these shops because working class people can afford to buy goods and services to stay alive. If we eliminate them, then we're undermining part of the mass consumption society.
Chris Williamson 34:06 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 34:06 So I think the main da- the main challenges with AI don't relate so much to how it alters production as how it alters distribution of income, and it's going to amplify what's been happening for the last 50 years, reducing the power, the bargaining power of anybody who doesn't own capital.
Chris Williamson 34:24 So if AI eliminates half of all jobs, does that mean that universal basic income is inevitable?
Dr. Steve Keen 34:31 Yeah. And this is why I think I've... When I see Musk talking about it, I've got to laugh in many ways because he spent his time trying to slash government spending at the DOGE farce, okay? But fundamentally, the only way that you can actually generate an income for people who don't work is the government has to create the money. And so he's, he, he played a role in undermining the capacity of the government to do what is necessary for his vision of AI to work.
Chris Williamson 34:58 Was the goal of DOGE not to improve efficiency-
Dr. Steve Keen 35:02 Yeah
Chris Williamson 35:02 ... rather than-
Dr. Steve Keen 35:03 If you're going to improve efficiency, you put engineers in charge. You don't put 18-year-old testosterone charged libertarian idiots in charge, which is what he did. And they, they falsely believe the government... This, this is one of the big issues that I'm trying to communicate to people today is people think the government borrows money. It doesn't. It creates money. So the whole idea the government is doing excessive spending and excessive debt, yada, yada, yada, that's based on making an analogy between what households and firms are like to what the government is like. So the, the slashing, trying to get efficiency, um, there's plenty of waste in the government. I've, I worked in the government on occasions and I called the Department of Trade that I worked in for a while, a bit of a, um, uh, uh, a retirement village. You know, so I saw the level of work being done. I wasn't impressed. Um, but the idea that government of inefficiency is the problem is wrong. Okay? It's government, well, running wars rather than building infrastructure, not seeing what the government should do, which is building the long-term, relatively boring stuff that every society needs.
Chris Williamson 36:14 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 36:14 We've tried to privatize everything, and that's been destructive of us creating those resources. Like, we're in the UK right now. You're normally based in US. You know how, you, you know how many dams have been built in the last 40 years in the UK since privatization of water?
Chris Williamson 36:31 No.
Dr. Steve Keen 36:31 Minus one.
Chris Williamson 36:33 How do you build minus one?
Dr. Steve Keen 36:34 They just, one of the mines, one of the ba- one of the existing dams has been shut down. Okay? So you had 40 or 50 years of privatized water. The argument was the private sector will do everything better than we do, and that's wrong when you look at long-lasting infrastructure because the, the people say the incentives that the private sector responds to incentives, the government doesn't, doesn't do that, therefore the private sector's always gonna be better than the government at doing anything. That's the blanket attitude that you get out of Maggie Thatcher and neoliberalism and Milton Friedman and so on. But that leaves out the issue of time. Now, if you're a manager of a corporation and you're, you know, you make five years tenure, that sort of thing for CEOs, you want to get a return while you're CEO. And if you look at the cost of long-term maintenance, which you've got to put aside money for, and it might be 20 or 30 years before you get a return, you're better off not doing the long-term maintenance and getting as much profit as you can now, getting a great b- bonus from the shareholders, and getting out before, quite literally, the shit hits the fan. Now, what's actually happened consequent of privatization of water in the UK, there's one less dam in the country than used to exist when the country had 12 million less people today. So we're seeing the potentials of that right now. And if you want to get sick, the best way to get sick is to go for a swim in a British river because they're all polluted with sewage. So they haven't done the long-term maintenance. That's the sort of thing you want to hand to a, a government bureaucrat because governments do respond to incentives, and the incentive a government official is under is to hand over something functional to the person who replaces them.
Chris Williamson 38:13 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 38:14 Okay? Now, that incentive works for long-lasting infrastructure. That's what you want the government to be providing rather than saying the private sector does everything better. So that ideology has ruined the West.
Chris Williamson 38:26 This episode is brought to you by Gymshark. Gymshark makes the best gym wear on the planet, and on November 15th, they're doing their biggest sale of the year. You can save up to 50% site-wide, plus an extra 10% when you use the code MODERNWISDOM10 at checkout. If you need some recommendations, their Hybrid Shorts in Onyx Grey and Navy are an absolute staple for me. Their Crest Hoodie is what I'm flying in whenever I'm traveling, and their sleeveless T-shirts are what you've seen me train in for nearly every vlog that I've ever put up. All of their kit are unbelievably lightweight, sweat-wicking, easy to wash and dry. The fit and the quality of the fabrics are phenomenal, and the sale doesn't last for long. So if you want to save up to 60% off the best gym wear on the planet, go to the link in the description below or head to gym.sh/modernwisdom and use the code MODERNWISDOM10 at checkout. That's gym.sh/modernwisdom and MODERNWISDOM10 at checkout.
Is Universal Basic Income a Good Idea?
Chris Williamson 39:15 What do you think about UBI as a, an idea, as a-
Dr. Steve Keen 39:19 Okay. Um, at... I, I'd, I would prefer to c- uh, in terms of what I'd bring in at the moment, I wouldn't call it universal. I'd call it guaranteed basic income, so a, you know, a GBI rather than UBI. 'Cause a Universal Basic Income means everybody gets the same amount of money as a base. Okay? So I get a, you know, I get £1,000 a month, and so does Rupert Murdoch, that sort of thing. Okay? Um, if you did that in general, then you would simply rise, increase the price level over time. Okay? But if you say that if you lose your job, then you have a benefit, which means you can still afford to stay alive, that's what I call a guaranteed basic income. That's what I'd bring in at the moment. But in terms of a universal basic income, that only makes sense if most people can't get a job.
Chris Williamson 40:06 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 40:07 And now if we, if we do go down the AI track, and I don't think we will, other things are gonna stop us. But if we go down the AI track, and therefore 80% of the population cannot get employment, then you've got to s- create, uh, money that they can spend on the shops that ex- owned by the 20% who do have it.
Chris Williamson 40:27 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 40:27 Uh, owned and staffed by the 20% who do have jobs. So universal basic income is absolutely required if we get to the point where technology takes over the vast majority of work, and that's what AI promises. It hasn't delivered, but that's what it promises.
Chris Williamson 40:43 Why do you think we won't go down that track?
Dr. Steve Keen 40:45 I think global warming's gonna wipe us out before we get there.
Chris Williamson 40:48 Okay. How so?
Dr. Steve Keen 40:52 Uh, this is a long, deep dive. Okay. We have a- trusted economists on the impact of global warming on the economy, and they know... Can I use French in this show?
Chris Williamson 41:03 As much as you'd like.
Dr. Steve Keen 41:04 They, you know, fuck all about the climate. So they have fooled themselves to believe that what happens ac- across space happens through time, and that's, that's literally a quote from a couple of academic papers by economists. But they assume they, they don't know what global warming is gonna do to the e- economy over time, but they can measure the relationship between temperature and income now across the planet. So they've done very careful measurements of the relationship between temperature and income now, and it's a fairly trivial relationship. You know, you, um, you can have, like, a 10-degree higher temperature than somewhere else, and you'll have a 5% lower income, that sort of thing. So they've used those figures to tell politicians what's gonna be the impact of global warming, and they've literally said this in published academic papers. They assume that what happens between temperature and income over space will happen through time as well. Now, that is the stupidest, most dangerous, negligent piece of idiotic assumptions in the history of humanity, and because politicians don't know that that's what economists have done, they... when they get their s- staff to check and see what the IPCC says is gonna happen, they read the economics chapters.
Chris Williamson 42:24 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 42:25 And the economists say, for example, this is the 2022 IPCC report, said that four degrees of global warming by 2100 will reduce income in 2100 by between 10 and 23%. Sounds like a large number, doesn't it? Okay. Let's say income in tw- 2100 is 100. They're saying it's gonna... because of global warming, rather than being 100, it's gonna be between, s- uh, you know, 70, well, it says, you know, s- 80, 87, 77 and 90. Let's say 90, so 10% fall. They're comparing back to 2022, so you've got 80 years of growth to get to that figure. So if you're gonna start here or you'll start at, say, you start at 10 and you're heading towards either 100 or 90, th- there's a trivial difference in the rate of economic growth.
Chris Williamson 43:15 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 43:15 So they're saying four degrees of global warming will reduce the annual rate of economic growth by about 0.05%. Which you can't even measure. Okay? And that's what politicians have accepted as the scientific estimate of what's gonna happen with global warming. Now, at the same time, and I work with climate scientists, they've been screaming into the void saying that, and this is a quote from an academic paper, "One and a half degrees of warming is dangerous." Okay? "Three degrees is catastrophic, and five degrees and above is beyond catastrophic, including existential risks." In other words, we might cease to exist as a species because of that. Now, climate economists who just talk to each other, they don't read what climate scientists write, and if they do, they completely distort what the scientists say. But the climate economists were surveyed in 2021, two and a half thousand of them, and 380 asked answered a question about, "What do you think is gonna be GDP in two centuries' time if we hit seven degrees of warming by 2220?" And the answer was they gave was, uh, it'll be 25% smaller. Okay? Now that translates to go like a 0.1% fall in the rate of economic growth. So saying seven degrees warmer, we'll, uh, have a GDP which is, you know, 25% smaller than it would've been if there's no global warming at all. Climate scientists say five degrees we're extinct. Now, the climate scientists know what they're talking about. The economists haven't got a fucking clue. But politicians don't know that. They trust the economists. Those are the advisors they turn to.
Chris Williamson 44:53 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 44:53 And they've been fooled by this to believe that global warming is a distant problem for a future generation. Therefore, we'll make, uh, we'll make, you know, nice sounds about it. We'll, we'll say we care. We'll do little things, but we'll still open up that oil mi- you know, oil field in the North Sea, and, uh, and we'll, we'll, we'll make the right noises and do the wrong things. And that's what they're doing because they believe there are no consequences for one or two centuries.
What Economists Get Wrong About Climate Change
Chris Williamson 45:20 I've had Richard Betts on from-
Dr. Steve Keen 45:22 Richard-
Chris Williamson 45:22 Richard Betts, the guy behind the IPCC, the, the, the lead for-
Dr. Steve Keen 45:26 Yeah
Chris Williamson 45:26 ... who was putting together most of the reports. And, um, he... It was a little while ago that we spoke, but he didn't seem to have a definitive answer about what was going to happen with the future of temperature increases or CO2 PPMS or whatever.
Dr. Steve Keen 45:41 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 45:42 Has that changed?
Dr. Steve Keen 45:44 Uh, scientists have... They're building on their own research over time. They've been getting more and more precise. They're the ones who are terrified. The economists really don't have, don't... They know bugger all about climate because they believe that they can map from what happens acr- across the planet at the current times-
Chris Williamson 46:05 Mm
Dr. Steve Keen 46:05 ... where there's a fairly trivial relationship between temperature and GDP, and they simply extrapolate that forward. They're completely brain-dead about this. So it's the economists and the politicians who are saying nothing much matters. The scientists I know are screaming, truly screaming-
Chris Williamson 46:27 Mm
Dr. Steve Keen 46:27 ... about what we face. And, um, and they're talking about it in the next 10 to 25 years, not, um, two centuries away.
Chris Williamson 46:37 What ways might you be wrong about this?
Dr. Steve Keen 46:38 Might I be wrong? If the climate scientists don't understand the climate, but they do. We've still got to... You know, we, we, we can't... This has never happened in the history of the planet before, let alone the history of our species, that we've increased global temperatures this much. So we've got to have a measure of what's actually going to happen to the global circulation system. Uh, so this research has all been done in the last 20 or 30 years, and it's in panic mode in many ways because what happened was, uh, in the 1960s, scientists worked out how to model the weather as a nonlinear feedback system. And before the 1960s, uh, the way we used to do weather was by pattern matching. So if there were seven days, you know, this sequence of temperature and rainfall 50 years ago, then six days we predict it's gonna be the seventh day from 50 years ago, that sort of thing. So a guy called Edward Lorenz, uh, who was a mathematical, um, meteorologist, he said, "Look, we know the main dynamics in the weather are nonlinear." So an increase in temperature causes an increase in moisture, which causes an increase in this, which causes a, a feedback process. And to model it, he built an incredibly simple model. You would've heard of the Navier-Stokes equations?
Chris Williamson 47:51 Yes. Yeah.
Dr. Steve Keen 47:52 Like-
Chris Williamson 47:52 That, wasn't that recently... That's fluid dynamics, right?
Dr. Steve Keen 47:55 Allegedly. It, the, the, it's a singularity that's been potentially solved by an LLM. Okay, but they are equations that describe the, what happens when fluid flows-
Chris Williamson 48:05 Mm-hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 48:05 ... okay, under different conditions of pressure and, and so on. And, uh, he took those equations, which are, I think they're 11-dimensional partial differential equations. He didn't actually do the reduction, but he reduced it to a three equations pa- uh, ordinary differential equations system. So in the analogy to what the, his model has was like, uh, having a drop of water on a hot plate. Okay? And you want to say, how does it move in terms of the, the, the X, Y location of the hot plate and the temperature range from the hot plate to above the hot plate? And what he expected was, you know, he expected some sort of complicated pattern. But what he got was what we've referred the first visual eye, visual identification of what we now call chaos or complex systems, chaotic behavior. And it was a complete surprise to him that it happened. He presented it to the meteorologists, and then they realized they could use this approach to build nonlinear models of the climate, which are what you watch when you take a look at a weather report on TV.
Chris Williamson 49:08 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 49:08 So the same models that give us the weather forecasts, which you've got to, you know, precise calculations, and you want to give hourly results, they're fundamentally the same thing that's used to make the climate predictions-
Chris Williamson 49:19 Okay
Dr. Steve Keen 49:20 ... when you're talking over, over decades. So these models have been really dramatically refined by climate scientists over time. They've done historical work as well, looking at the paleontological record, you know. And, and what they find is there are things like the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. You know of the AMOC?
Chris Williamson 49:39 No
Dr. Steve Keen 49:39 ... is one of the world's best acronyms, okay?
Chris Williamson 49:41 Okay.
Dr. Steve Keen 49:41 Atla- Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, otherwise known as AMOC.
Chris Williamson 49:46 Okay.
Dr. Steve Keen 49:47 Okay? People think of the Gulf Stream. That's the surface phenomenon.
Chris Williamson 49:50 Okay.
Dr. Steve Keen 49:50 The AMOC is below the surface. That is a, a channel of, a, a, a flow of water in the oceans which is equivalent to something of the order of, I've seen between 10 and 17 times the flow of all the rivers on the planet. That amount, a huge amount of water. And there's a top part of it. It, it covers all the oceans on the planet, but the northern part of it is, is called the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. And what happens is you've got hot water from the southern, uh, Atlantic and the, um, Gulf of America, okay? Okay. Which moves north and goes around the coast of Europe, and then as it goes up there, it's getting... It's hot water, so it's transferring heat to the atmosphere, and it, as it does that, it gets saltier, okay? So because it's evaporating.
Chris Williamson 50:43 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 50:43 Okay?
Chris Williamson 50:44 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 50:44 So when you then get to the northern reaches of the planet, it's got- it's cooled down, okay? And it's got denser, so it then falls, and then it comes back under and then circulates around. At various times in the paleontological record, that has stopped because of temperature effects of the, the natural cycles of the planet. And the most recent research, which you don't find in the IPCC papers, you have to read the, the scientific literature. Uh, the most recent research argues that that will shut down sometime between 2025, i.e. last year, and 2095, with their best estimates being it'll shut down in 2050. Now, if that does, the temperature of Europe will fall by 10 degrees Celsius over three decades.
Chris Williamson 51:30 Wow.
Dr. Steve Keen 51:30 Okay? And you... The range, the, the average range for London will be between minus 20 and plus 25 degrees. That's the average, let alone the extremes. Now, London will be uninhabitable with that range happening. Europe will become uninhabitable. The... If the, if the, uh... Again, this is research by Tim Lenton, in this particular case, Tim Lenton being a scientist at, um, Exeter, whom you should also interview, okay? Uh, Tim, Tim did work for the O- OECD, and they asked him what would happen with a combination of the AMOC turning off and two and a half degrees of warming. Bear in mind, we're at one and a half degrees of warming now. Yeah. His estimate was that, this is again using a climate model, a 70% fall in the area of the planet that can support grain. Now, you have a 70% fall in grain output, you have a global famine, and that's what we're playing with. And the scientists are aware of this. They talk about it themselves all the time. They can't understand why the politicians aren't listening to them. It's because the politicians are listening to the economists who knows SFA about how the climate actually functions.
Chris Williamson 52:41 And then we roll on top of that a geopolitical climate that's very-
Dr. Steve Keen 52:46 Yeah
Chris Williamson 52:46 ... kinetic, highly, uh, dangerous, uh, massively unpredictable.
Dr. Steve Keen 52:55 I know.
Chris Williamson 52:56 Next 50 years don't look great.
Dr. Steve Keen 52:58 Not at all. And like the cra- the only thing I can say in favor of Donald Trump is he's an advanced version of what the climate is gonna do because the damage he's doing to, uh, energy production systems in this, in the, you know, in the Saudi, in, in the Arabian Peninsula, um, the damage to fertilizer supplies, all these things are gonna give us a foretaste of what global warming itself will do at some point.
Chris Williamson 53:21 Well, can-
Dr. Steve Keen 53:21 So the only thing I can say in favor of him, it's like a wake the fuck up call. Uh, and I hope that we people do because the next six months to a year could be terrifying, let alone what's gonna happen in a decade.
Chris Williamson 53:32 A quick aside, most people don't realize how much dehydration actually impacts their performance, which is why for the last five years I've started every single morning with LMNT. LMNT is a tasty electrolyte drink mixed with everything that you need and nothing that you don't. It's a science-backed ratio of sodium, potassium, and magnesium with no sugar, no coloring, no artificial ingredients or any other junk, just the stuff that your body actually needs to function. It plays a critical role in reducing muscle cramps and fatigue while optimizing brain health and regulating your appetite. I can genuinely feel the difference when I take it versus when I don't, and that's why I keep talking about it. Best of all, they have a no questions asked refund policy, so you can buy it for as long as you want and if you don't like it for any reason, they'll just give you your money back. Plus, they offer free shipping in the US. Right now, you can get a free sample pack of LMNT's most popular flavors with your first purchase by going to the link in the description below or heading to drinklmnt.com/modernwisdom. That's drinklmnt.com/modernwisdom.
How Damaging Has the Iran War Been?
Chris Williamson 54:29 How big of an own goal has the Iran war been, do you think?
Dr. Steve Keen 54:33 Oh, it's a huge own goal. I mean, I d- I didn't, you know, know much about Iran before the war started. Obviously, I've been looking more at its history since then. And for a start, uh, people think about the, the, the mental attitude the people in the West have to the Arabian region of the planet is that it's all flat desert. Well, Persia is incredibly mountainous and multiple, uh, you know, structures that make... You, you c- you can, you can invade Iraq, no problem at all. Land on the shore, get to the capital, wipe out Saddam Hussein, not a problem. No way, no, can you do that with Iran. So the geography alone is a huge mistake to take on a, a country that is that mountainous and think you can actually invade and wipe them out when the guerrillas can be shooting at you from mountainsides and so on. Uh, they've had 45 years pretty much of a, of, of isolation from the West, and we have this caricatured attitude that they've got, you know, totally sexist, uh, women can't educate. That's what happens with the Taliban, which was a creation of the Americans in the first instance to fight the Russians in Afghanistan. In, in, in Iran, women make up the m- almost a majority of STEM graduates, apparently. So the level of, of, uh, manufacturing capability and, uh- I- i- in, in industrial intelligence is extremely high in that country. It's, it's got 90 million people. It's much, much larger than, uh, than Iraq was. So to think you can go in and take that on is a huge mistake to begin with, let alone the preparations they've made. And like the very first thing America did was decapitate the leadership. We killed the supreme leader. We killed his wife. We killed, uh, children. Uh, and that's... Th- that was the same thing for Saddam Hussein. Take out the leadership. It's like a head of a snake. They were prepared for that, so they divided their military into 31 divisions based on the 31 regions of the country, and basically said, "If the leaderships get decapitated, attack." So rather than getting, you know, getting rid of one snake, you've created 31 snakes. It's an insanely bad decision to take on that country. It should never have happened.
Chris Williamson 56:44 Why do you think he did it?
Dr. Steve Keen 56:46 I th- Oh, Epstein, for starters.
Chris Williamson 56:49 Do you mean to distract from the files?
Dr. Steve Keen 56:51 I think... I mean, there's gotta be dirt on that guy. The, the, the-
Chris Williamson 56:54 You mean on Trump?
Dr. Steve Keen 56:55 Yes, on Trump, and a huge number of people in the p- political leadership globally as well.
Chris Williamson 57:00 And how would invading Iran help that?
Dr. Steve Keen 57:02 Uh, because Israel's always wanted to wipe out its major rival. Where is, is... I'm think- You know, I mean, I've, uh... To me, Zionism and, and Mossad are the only explanations I can give for the decisions that some of the people in the West make. They make no sense strategically or in their own interests what they're doing. I just... I can just see there's gotta be blackmail everywhere.
Chris Williamson 57:28 I was gonna say, what do you think is the mechanism of pressure? You think it's blackmail?
Dr. Steve Keen 57:33 Well, I'm not rich enough to find out. I mean, the usual things that are used to bribe people, um, money, uh, power, all these things. So there, there's... Uh, you simply can't make sense of the decisions being made by Western leaders-
Chris Williamson 57:49 Mm
Dr. Steve Keen 57:49 ... and the gap between what the leaders are saying and what the populace are thinking. If you go back f- you know, to the 1970s with the, the '67 war and the '73 war and so on, there was a large amount of public sympathy for Israel being attacked by the Arabs, and the general attitude was, after the Holocaust, we can't allow this to happen again. So there's huge sympathies for the West in the population in general for Israel. Now we've gone 40 years down the track and, uh, and we're, and we're seeing the expansionist nature of Israel. I think so many people have seen that expansionism. We've seen what's happened to Gaza. There's... That's gotta be the world's most inaccurate army. If that's how you try to take out a guerrilla campaign against you, and you flatten the en- virtually the entire region, the entire, um, city, fundamentally, which Gaza is not much larger than a city, you've gotta be the world's most inaccurate army. So it's, it's blatantly a genocide, and people in public are reacting because they can see it on their phones, and the politicians are coming across and criticizing anybody who supports Palestine.
Chris Williamson 58:56 Why would Israel have a problem with Iran? Why, why would they want Iran to be invaded, wiped out, decapitated?
Dr. Steve Keen 59:05 If they weren't expansionist, then they wouldn't have a problem. Israel wants to expand, and people say Israel's g- "Do you believe Israel's got a right to exist?" It's got a right to exist within its borders, okay? But it's been extending its borders and invading other countries all the, all the way through. So it's the expansionism of Israel that is the problem. If they were willing, ev- even with everything that's happened with the Palestinians, if they're willing to stay contained inside the borders that they had, then we wouldn't be having necessarily those conflicts. Um, there's a desire for Israel to dominate that region, and it's, it's, it, it's, it's a f- political philosophy that's responsible.
Is the Iran War Threatening Global Fertiliser Supplies?
Chris Williamson 59:43 What are some of the second and third order effects of the war in the Middle East continuing-
Dr. Steve Keen 59:50 Oh, well-
Chris Williamson 59:51 ... that people don't fully realize?
Dr. Steve Keen 59:52 The big- the biggest one is fertilizer, decline in fertilizer globally.
Chris Williamson 59:56 Why?
Dr. Steve Keen 59:56 Because a large part of the fertilizer is produced in the Middle East because with the... To make the fertilizer, we use oil, okay? The, the superphosphate and nitro- nitrogenous fertilizers, they all need oil as a feedstock, okay? You also need sulfur as part of the process as well. So the raw materials are a by-product of mining oil, okay? And then when you produce that fertilizer, you export it particularly to Southeast Asia. Now, with the blockage, that fuel, that, that fertilizer isn't going out. We've got... There's, it's more expensive and there's less of it, and there's a very direct link between fertilizer consumption and food production. And again, this is something you, you, uh, you have to be aware of, of chemistry to some extent to know how significant this is. But ag- again, I'm not an expert in agronomy, but I have colleagues who tell me these things, and they say that if it wasn't for artificial fertilizers, the carrying capacity of the planet with standard pre-fertilizer, uh, pre-artificial fertilizer agriculture is one or two billion people. Now, we've got eight billion, okay? So we're dependent upon fertilizer to sustain the population we've got, and the war has cut off something of the order of 20% to 30% of the world's fertilizer production. Now, that means a global famine, and that is likely to arrive, of course, patchily across the planet is where the famines occur, but we're gonna start seeing famines certainly in 2027, and they were completely unnecessary.
Chris Williamson 1:01:37 Where do you think they'll start first?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:01:39 Because you have growing seasons. So you've already planted the crop, you know, three... We have, you know, between two and four growing seasons for most crops around the world. So if you have a, a crop which has a six-month growing period, then the fertilizer's laid at the early stage and, you know, as much as you need to maintain, to maintain crop growth. But after a, a while, the fertil- you've got the harvesting and so on and so forth. Uh, so there's a time lag. All these things take time, and what fools us is if we don't see an immediate effect, we don't think anything is happening. But these things, the time delays, the time lags that exist mean that the disruption that we did back in March will potentially start hitting har- uh, you know, planting practices in September and further on. And then the next harvest is gonna be inadequate. And then when it's inadequate, what do you do?
Chris Williamson 1:02:30 What's happening with semiconductors?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:02:32 Semiconductors are also hit by helium availability. So again, helium is a by-product of mining oil because helium is the second lightest element. It's inert, so it doesn't bond with anything else. Um, if it, it gets, can get trapped in the same, uh, geographic, geological structures that trap oil. So when you bring the o- oil to the surface, you bring up the helium as well. It's an incredibly expensive and difficult pass process to separate the helium out, and helium didn't particularly matter 50 or 60 years ago as a, as a manufacturing input. But helium is essential to cool down the devices that make semiconductors-
Chris Williamson 1:03:11 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 1:03:11 ... to two or three degrees above absolute zero, which is what they've got to operate at to get the precision with which we cut the channels into semiconductors these days. So there are stocks of helium. You, you really, if you have helium, you try to hang onto it because you know it's, when it evaporates, it's gone. It just goes straight into outer space. Um, so we do have stocks of it, and people have companies that have that are trying to maintain it, but we've now cut off 20 or 30% of the supply. So at some point, this means you can't produce as many chips anymore.
Chris Williamson 1:03:41 What is the supply cutoff primarily coming from? Is this from transport through the Strait? Is this because of, uh, uncertainty in the region and damage leading to less, uh, mining?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:03:55 Oh, well, a, a couple of... I mean, again, this is where I've got to rely upon colleagues who are specialists in the area. The, the machines that extract the helium, some of those have been damaged by some of the attacks in the war.
Chris Williamson 1:04:07 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:04:07 The helium's not coming through the Straits. The, it's one of the many products that can come through the Straits that the blockade is stopping. So consequently, you're not getting restocking the helium which has been lost through the usual inevitable leak- leakage processes in manufacturing. So at some stage, you won't have enough helium to produce the number of chips that are being demanded. Now, that comes back and hits AI because artificial intelligence relies upon GPUs, graphical processing units, to do the mathematics. To produce the GPUs, you've got to have machines that cut the semiconductors to those machines rely upon helium to w- to operate.
Chris Williamson 1:04:46 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:04:46 So we're, we're cutting across the supply chain for producing so many essential elements. And the other major one is sulfuric acid because that is used in all sorts of manufacturing processes. You can't refine the copper without sulfuric acid. That's also a by-product of mining oil. So we're cutting that supply off as well. And equally, a lot of the, uh, lubrication oils happen to be produced in the, around the Gulf of, Gulf of Persia, and they're not getting through. So, you know, so long as you have stocks of lubricating oil, you can keep the machines working. But if you run out of those stocks, you can't turn the machines anymore. So all these consequences are coming our way.
Why Fuel Prices Are Becoming a Global Problem
Chris Williamson 1:05:29 What about the cost of fuel?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:05:31 Well, that's vi- that's obviously being hit right now. So there's less fuel. Again, people have this, the, a mindset that comes out of conventional economics. Uh, you know, treats everything as homogenous. You know, oil from here is the same as oil from there. That is nonsense. Uh, oil is, again, something which is vastly different types of oil in different regions. So Venezuelan oil is virtually like tar, and the same for the tar sands in Canada. Um, the oil coming out of fracking is very light. It's almost, you know, uh, has almost no sulfur in it. The, the combination coming out of the Middle East, and again, I'm not an expert on this, but again, working, relying on friends who are, uh, it has a moderate sulfur content. They talk about s- sour oil and sweet oil and all these sorts of expressions. Uh, but that comes out of that particular type of oil. You can't use it. You can't get the same oil from fracking. You can't get the same oil from Venezuela or, or Canada. So if you cut that out, an essential input to production isn't turning up. There's less oil. The price of oil will rise, obviously, but it's also the availability. If you don't have diesel in particular, then you can't ship goods from one location to another. You can't run the farm machinery. So we are gonna get... Th- this is a pretty much a unique crisis in peacetime for humans, uh, in that in the wartime, of course, a whole lot of things get cut off, production gets cut off.
Chris Williamson 1:07:01 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:07:01 This is the first time it's happened in what we're calling peacetime, that suddenly there might be a 20 or 30% fall in the availability of foo- fuel. And if you don't have the diesel, then you can't ship the food, you can't grow the food. These are serious destructions of our productive capabilities.
Chris Williamson 1:07:20 Is it fair to call this peacetime?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:07:24 No. I think this is the, the... You know, if you look back to see... Do you know who term- who coined the term the military industrial complex? General Dwight D. Eisenhower. Okay, in his resignation speech, uh, there's a particular economist, a non-orthodox economist, who wrote this part of the speech for him. But he warned about the military industrial complex. And he's, and this is a general. And he said, he says, "They distort everything so that they make a fortune." So they actually want wars because, um, working class people die in wars, rich people make money in wars. And so there's a bias. The, the military industrial complex wants us to have wars. It wants to have these weapons being produced. It wants us to live in fear because with that, a large amount of government money creation goes to arm- arms manufacturers. And I think we're seeing that massively right now.
Chris Williamson 1:08:17 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:08:18 So they're benefiting out of it. And like Donald Trump will even brag, "We're making a fortune because oil's more expensive."
Chris Williamson 1:08:24 Before we continue, most non-alcoholic drinks feel like you're settling. They're flat, forgettable, and you end up wishing that you ordered something else. That's why I'm such a huge fan of Athletic Brewing Co. Their non-alcoholic brews taste just as good as the real thing. They've got IPAs, hazies, goldens. They're so good that you'll forget there's no alcohol in them until you wake up the next day feeling fantastic, and that means that you can enjoy the ritual without the wreckage. No hangover, no 3:00 AM panic, no wasted Sundays, and that is why I partnered with them. You can find Athletic Brewing Co.'s best-selling lineup at grocery or liquor stores near you, or best option, get a full variety pack of four flavors shipped direct to your door. Right now, get 15% off your first online order by going to the link in the description below or heading to athleticbrewing.com/modernwisdom and using the code MODERNWISDOM at checkout. That's athleticbrewing.com/modernwisdom and MODERNWISDOM at checkout. Near beer terms and conditions apply. Athletic Brewing Company, fit for all times.
Does War Make Inequality Worse?
Chris Williamson 1:09:18 Does inequality get worse during wartime?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:09:21 Often not, strangely enough. And this is, like, one thing about what happened in World War II, uh, is that, like in the, the Great Depression was the biggest downturn in the history of capitalism, okay? Um, you had 25% of the workforce out of a job. And that, that we... You started 1929. In October of 1929, the recorded level of unemployment in the United States as a percentage of the population was zero. There weren't zero un- unemployed people. But when you divided the number of people who'd registered as unemployed by the population to the first decimal place, it was 0.0%, October 1929. This is in the National Bureau of Economic Research database. It then rose from zero to 25% by 1932. Then with the New Deal and all the spending that Roosevelt did at that time, um, you had a de- a decline. It went from 25% to 11% by 1936. At that stage, the conventional economists who were completely flummoxed by the Great Depression, they persuaded Roosevelt, "You gotta get the budget fixed, mate. The budget's looking really bad," you know? So they reduced the deficit from 5% of GDP to 0.1% of GDP, and unemployment rose from 11% to 20%. Okay? Then the Second World War began, and with the Second World War, it fell back to zero again. So all the working class people were either, they're either in the Army being paid a wage, or their wives, who were, you know, unemployed as well as the husbands during the Great Depression, they're working in the factories, Rosie the Riveter, all this sort of stuff. So there was, first of all, the, the, the income was being provided to fight the war for everybody. Secondly, the government controlled, uh, rate of inflation by deliberate price controls, and so you had a low rate of inflation, higher wages coming through. And then when the working class came out of World War II, the attitude was, "We can never allow this to happen again." So the post-war period, the focus, and I'll, I'll quote the Australian White Paper on Employment, which, which written in 1944. Uh, and that, that's, that's the, the... It described the objective of government policy as being, and this is a direct quote, "To maintain such pressure upon employment as to guarantee a shortage of jo- of m- of, of men rather than a shortage of jobs."
Chris Williamson 1:11:48 Hmm. Hmm. Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:11:49 That was the mentality, okay? Now we've flipped over completely. But that, during that war period, you went from the same massive inequality in the 1920s to the consequences of that during the Great Depression, World War II following as a direct consequence of that depression, and then the attitude was, "We can't allow the majority of the population to be screwed as they were in the '20s and '30s," and that became the mentality of the '50s and '60s, and now we're back with the same stupid mentality that gave us the 1920s.
Chris Williamson 1:12:17 Mm-hmm. I wonder whether UBI would be or G- GBI would be a better situation. I'm kind of fascinated, you know, sort of the psychology of what that does. I wonder whether a society where nobody needed to work would be a utopia or a psychological disaster.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:12:36 Well, look, it's a psychological disaster right now because we've set up a society in which if you don't work, you don't do anything.
Chris Williamson 1:12:43 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:12:43 Okay? So if, like, if you look at us as a species and say, what were we like before we had to go to work 9:00 to 5:00, okay? We were hunter-gatherers, okay? And we lived in small communities. Have you heard of what's called the Dunbar number?
Chris Williamson 1:12:56 Of course. Friend of the show.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:12:58 Yeah, there you go. Okay. Well, the Dunbar number, it was calculated by a mathematical biologist before, um, anthropologists confirmed the numbers that roughly speaking, the size of Cro-Magnon societies was about 150 people in a village and about 7,000 in a tribe. That's that sort of scale. And in that world, you got status for what you did. Okay? You... It was a gift-based society fundamentally. There's all sorts of variations in the nature of those, uh, tribes. But fundamentally, you, if you were just a layabout who did nothing at all, you would get kicked out. Okay? So you would do stuff, and you'd do it as this form of generosity, internal generosity. Uh, you know, you were the best flint maker, so you'd make flints for people who were the best fishermen, and they'd give you the fish and so on and so forth. So fundamentally gift-based societies. That's, uh, when we first did s- uh, research into, uh, tribal societies in the 1800s when the, uh, you know, when we, the Iroquois were being researched and so on, goods were allocated by women's council. There was no barter and, and work and labor and stuff like that. So people did things because it gave them status and respect. In the community they're in, and you were very tightly bonded with the people you related to. We live in such dis- you know, dis- discombobulated societies these days. People don't even know who their neighbors are, you know? Uh, so if you look at what the tribal societies were like, we work collectively. We had some specialization within each of those societies, but we'd work collectively, and we did it for respect of the community. And depending upon the region you're in, uh, you might work two days and have one day of relaxation.
Chris Williamson 1:14:41 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:14:41 That sort of pattern.
Chris Williamson 1:14:42 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:14:43 That's the, what- that's what's our original nature, and if we really wanna have a decent civilization, that's what we should try to recreate. But instead, we're dispersed, we're- we only work because it's necessary to get a job and, and get paid. Uh, people don't have any idea of what to do if they're not working. All these things, I think, are products of the nature of society we've created. They're not our own innate human nature.
Can We Separate Economic Value From Personal Worth?
Chris Williamson 1:15:10 Can we separate people's economic value from their sense of personal worth?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:14 I think we have to, and we don't at the moment. It's your... It, it, it's, I mean, I think I've saw one of your interviewers saying the worst question you can ask is, "What do you do for a living?" Okay?
Chris Williamson 1:15:25 Yes.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:25 But that's the standard question we ask, you know? We define ourselves by our job.
Chris Williamson 1:15:29 Yep.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:30 Okay? Not by, what are your passions? You know? What are your interests? What-
Chris Williamson 1:15:33 A much better question, my favorite question as an alternative to that at a cocktail party is, "What keeps you busy?"
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:38 [laughs]
Chris Williamson 1:15:39 "What keeps you busy?" I think is wonderful, like really lovely question, and it allows you to go down, "Well, yeah, okay, like I do, I'm a, I, I, a finance director or whatever for this, this-"
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:49 Yeah, yeah
Chris Williamson 1:15:49 ... "this startup or whatever. I'm a CFO" or whatever I do.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:51 I spend most of my time painting.
Chris Williamson 1:15:52 But what I actually am into is-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:54 Or I go to the gym. I'm a gym junk-
Chris Williamson 1:15:55 Bingo. Bingo, bingo, bingo, bingo
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:56 ... that sort of stuff, yeah.
Chris Williamson 1:15:57 What keeps you busy?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:58 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 1:15:58 Great question.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:15:59 Yeah, and that's, that's what we should be focusing upon. That's what our humanity should be about. So I, like I, I, I can envisage a, like Star Trek future, you know, where we get to the point where we've produced m- machines that can do all the manual labor that's necessary, and therefore we, the, what we have to do, we become philosopher kings, kings and artists, and that's, if you look-
Chris Williamson 1:16:22 Do you think that every human or most humans are-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:16:27 No
Chris Williamson 1:16:28 ... constructed in a manner where that is what they would go to?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:16:32 Um, I, I think if you... I mean, a lot of, like the n- the right-wing Austrian stuff will basically think everybody can be an entrepreneur. Well, that's not true.
Chris Williamson 1:16:43 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:16:43 A lot of people don't wanna be. I, I do, you do.
Chris Williamson 1:16:46 Yep.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:16:46 Okay, but a lot of people don't.
Chris Williamson 1:16:48 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:16:48 Okay? And, and therefore you wouldn't have them going out and, you know, if we didn't have work, they wouldn't become artists or painters, but they, they might watch sports. Okay? They'd be spectators in that sense. And, you know, you- football crowds, teams need spectators.
Chris Williamson 1:17:04 Mm-hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:05 So it's, it's not all negative-
Chris Williamson 1:17:07 Yeah
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:07 ... uh, to say that some people would be unproductive in that situation.
What Happens to Ambition When Work Becomes Optional?
Chris Williamson 1:17:12 What happens to our ambition when hard work is no longer needed for survival? If we're in a abundance, abundance adjacent-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:23 This is one reason why-
Chris Williamson 1:17:24 ... post scarcity thing
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:25 ... I, I th- I think if we leave it to our own devices, we'd end up in bedlam in that situation. So, like if you... I think you've seen the draft of my, the, the manuscript of my next book, and the thing that I surprised myself by at the end was saying we need a new religion.
Chris Williamson 1:17:42 What was it? Ra- Ra- Ragn- What was the name of it? Not Ragnism.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:47 Saganism.
Chris Williamson 1:17:47 Saganism, that's it.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:48 Saganism.
Chris Williamson 1:17:49 Yeah.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:17:49 Because we have been dominated by religious thinking really for the last, yeah, our, our entire existence, until we developed science 500 years ago-
Chris Williamson 1:18:02 Hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 1:18:02 ... with the scientific revolution. But science is a nerd's activity these days, that nobody... If you, if you're gonna learn science, you've gotta be ignoring your sexuality and ignoring sports. You've gotta be a, a Sheldon to go do decent science these days. Um, I think we need a world in which science becomes our religion, and therefore people get... We train people. We g- get them to recognize the importance of, of science and research and knowledge as what they learn now in terms of learning the importance of religion.
Chris Williamson 1:18:34 So-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:18:34 That would give a different culture, to respond to your question.
Chris Williamson 1:18:38 I agree. I wonder whether or not talking about science as a religion makes it far too sterile to get the buy-in that you would need from people. Because at least in the past, one of the reasons that religion has been so alluring is that there's story and narrative and personification and myth and archetype, and there's-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:18:59 And they're all bullshit.
Chris Williamson 1:19:00 That's true in... But I mean, it depends who you are.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:19:03 You see, look, th- this, this is like I d- d- b- because I've dived in with that particular comment here, um, looking at the fact that we are ig- ignoring and denigrating the scientists is part of the arguments to trivialize global warming.
Chris Williamson 1:19:17 Hmm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:19:17 Part that got to me saying, "What is the difference between religion and science, and why has religion dominated science?" And-
Chris Williamson 1:19:26 I- If, if I was to make the, the sort of bold case for why religion is good at being religion and science is bad at being religion-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:19:34 Yeah
Chris Williamson 1:19:34 ... it would be that humans are built much more around story and archetype and personification.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:19:42 Yeah.
Chris Williamson 1:19:42 And as soon as you strip out the personification from that, which is why does the sun rise? Well, it's because we're on a rotating planet, and because of the speed that we move at, it means that we see the sun, and it looks like it's moving across. Like, the, the story-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:19:56 And that's boring
Chris Williamson 1:19:57 ... the story behind it doesn't get the necessary buy-in.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:00 And that's because we haven't thought about science in the same way we do about a religion. Because you have... I mean, the religions have their miracles. Okay? Scientists have their experiments.
Chris Williamson 1:20:10 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:11 Okay? You can't reproduce a miracle. You can reproduce an experiment.
Chris Williamson 1:20:14 You need to make it more sexy.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:15 Yeah, Steve.
Chris Williamson 1:20:16 You need the sex of science.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:18 It has, it has to be a deep passion of people. And like when you think about scientists, uh, you have, you know... To be a scientist who actually goes against the mainstream, and the people like Max Planck and Galileo and so on-
Chris Williamson 1:20:28 Mm-hmm
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:29 ... you've gotta have balls. Okay? You've gotta really be able to handle being ridiculed and abused by your peers.
Chris Williamson 1:20:36 Rachel Carson-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:37 Yep
Chris Williamson 1:20:37 ... Ignaz Semmelweis.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:38 Yep. I copped a lo- load of this shit myself. I know, you know, I know what it's like to be on the receiving end of being abused by the conventional wisdom. So you've gotta have balls to do it. That makes you somebody who should be a saint.
Chris Williamson 1:20:49 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:20:49 Okay? Um, the discoveries you make, like I think it was, again, I don't know as, as well. If, if I was fully trained in science, I'd know. It was, it was Benjamin Franklin, I think, who first realized static electricity. Okay? The, those experiments. That would be, he would become one of the saints. That experiment would be reproduced in the churches of religion, and so on. So we can map with, with like, we can do in terms of a, a, a God figure, uh, we can take Carl Sagan.
Chris Williamson 1:21:17 [laughs]
Dr. Steve Keen 1:21:18 Not the only God, but he's a, a good personality to choose. In place of the cross or the other metaphors that religions have, we take this, this little blue dot, that photograph that he got deliberately. He was the person who made, who s- persuaded the NASA engineers to turn Voyager around as it went past Saturn to take a photograph of the Earth in the background, and it didn't even make up one pixel in the camera. But that little dot could be the replacement for the cross. And rather than talking about, you know, Jesus being s- uh, you know, persecuted by the Romans, and it's one bunch of humans against another bunch of humans, that little dot does two things. It says everything you've ever experienced, everybody you've loved, everybody you've fought with, they're all on that single dot, and then you've got this vast universe around you, which as far as we know at the moment, has no other forms of intelligent life.
Chris Williamson 1:22:12 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:22:12 Or life at all. We still haven't found life, exoplanetary life. So there's one spot in the entire universe that we know has life. The rest of it is a vast, so far as we know, open and empty element. You want to preserve life and explore the rest. That should be our, the focus of our religion. So if we have a religion of Saganism, and like I, I think it's wonderful that his name is one letter removed from paganism, okay? So that would be my religion, turn science into religion, because if we don't do it, when we go through, and I don't think it's a question of if anymore, when we go through what people will call an Armageddon, when the climate really starts to change-
Chris Williamson 1:22:53 Mm
Dr. Steve Keen 1:22:53 ... then in that situation, people are gonna blame the scientists and the engineers for the situation we're in, when the real people responsible for it are the politicians and the fossil fuel companies and the economists.
What's Next for Bitcoin?
Chris Williamson 1:23:06 What do you think is gonna happen with Bitcoin? I've heard that you-
Dr. Steve Keen 1:23:09 Yeah, I mean, I, I-
Chris Williamson 1:23:10 ... think it's gonna go to zero
Dr. Steve Keen 1:23:11 ... I wish I'd gambled. I mean, I mean, I could have bought Bitcoin when it was about a, a quid each, but that's when Max and Max Keiser and Stacy Herbert tried to persuade me about it. They made me the mistake of telling me its security mechanism, which is 10 minutes of computing time to generate the nonce string that enables you to make an entry on the, on the ledger, and I just thought that's just ridiculous in terms of energy. And at some point I knew the energy issues were gonna strike anyway, so I, I didn't get involved. I wish I had, okay? Obviously. Um, but to me, the failure with B- Bitcoin, there's m- multiple reasons why, but the energy issue is one. So it's apparently at the moment, again, I'm not up with the actual figures, but apparently the energy consumption for Bitcoin is about equivalent to Switzerland, something of that scale. Okay? Um, the number of people who hold Bitcoin is about 2% of the population, roughly speaking. Okay? Now, people have this fantasy that you can have Bitcoin completely replacing fiat currencies. That's a huge part of the pro-Bitcoin argument. But for it to replace fiat currencies, everybody has to have the money, or 98% of the population is gonna starve, which they won't, you know? There won't be a peaceful process. Uh, and the, if, one, now when we find we have to drastically cut back on energy consumption, the easiest things to knock off, to say like, uh, the, humans will have a knee-jerk reaction to realizing we're literally in an, an extinction event, unless we stop what we're doing, we're gonna go extinct. When that mindset gets imposed upon people by reality, then the easiest knee-jerk reaction is to ban international travel and Bitcoin.
Chris Williamson 1:24:56 Mm.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:24:56 And that cuts energy consumption by about 6 or 7%.
Chris Williamson 1:24:59 [laughs]
Dr. Steve Keen 1:25:00 You know? So that's why, uh, in the long term, even if I'd gambled on Bitcoin, I would've still had that attitude.
What Will the Economy Look Like in 10 Years?
Chris Williamson 1:25:06 What do you think the next five to 10 years look like? What should people prepare for? What should they expect?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:25:14 Well, this, this is again, how suddenly the climate effects hit our productive capabilities. Certainly given what Trump has done with the war against Iran, then we're gonna see some of those effects in the next year. Famines, uh, inability to produce large numbers of goods.
Chris Williamson 1:25:32 Where will the famines hit first?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:25:34 Oh, again, that depends on who can afford to buy the fertilizer. But so if-
Chris Williamson 1:25:38 Country-wise.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:25:39 Sorry?
Chris Williamson 1:25:39 Country-wise, you mean.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:25:41 Well, lo- large parts of Southeast Asia will be unable to buy the fertilizer sufficient for their countries. But equally, countries like the UK could find themselves hitting potential famines because first of all, you had the driest, um, period in the UK's history up until about now. Apparently, and I'm not sure of this, but apparently when El Niño hits, then there's gonna be m- massive rainfall for the UK instead.
Chris Williamson 1:26:09 We also didn't have, I think in the UK, there wasn't a single day in 2026 until March where it didn't rain. So it rained every single day until March
Dr. Steve Keen 1:26:20 And then it was dry after that. So this climate volatility is going to mean you can't produce food in the way. So the food output is going to fall independent of what's happening with the fertilizer. You put these together and there could be famines or food restrictions in the UK. And you would have seen just recently the government's been saying, make sure you've got a few days food on hand. What the hell? Okay. The whole, the governments themselves are now talking about the possibility of food shortages. So this is something which we're going to see in the next year. And in some countries it will lead to mass famines. In others it'll mean restrictions on food consumption. Now that's something we haven't experienced except during periods of world war in the past. And that's, I think that's the future we face. Simply coming out of the war in Iran. Now equally what's going to happen with El Nino will amplify that. And then the big question is what's going to happen with global climatic features like the AMOC. If that does flip, then that to me is the end of Western civilization.
Chris Williamson 1:27:30 You're primarily talking about these and not talking about the contribution of AI.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:27:34 Yeah. AI, I mean, again, this is one of those weird things that are being a bit of a Star Trek fan and very sorry to see Patrick Stewart depart the mortal coil a couple of days ago. You know, every Star Trek episode gets resolved in the final 30 seconds, which I always thought was a joke, you know. Now I'm living it. We have these tiny turning points. So we could have gone the AI direction and we have a bountiful future where the machines do the work and we're all philosopher kings. We could go the other way where we end up having to hunt and gather to stay alive and the system falls apart around us because of climatic damage. It really, we really are at that juxtaposition of a desirable and a disastrous future.
Chris Williamson 1:28:26 We are living through history.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:28:28 Unfortunately.
Chris Williamson 1:28:29 Yeah.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:28:29 Far too much of it for my liking.
Chris Williamson 1:28:31 Well, it's going to be interesting. It's certainly interesting times.
Where to Find Steve
Chris Williamson 1:28:35 Steve Keen, ladies and gentlemen. Steve, you're great. Where should people go to check out everything that you've got going on?
Dr. Steve Keen 1:28:41 Okay. Well, I've got a YouTube channel. So everything has Prof Steve Keen pretty much with me. So YouTube at Prof Steve Keen, Patreon and Substack also Prof Steve Keen. And I'm now giving an online course. Some of the marketing which annoys me, I'm about it. Okay. I've got to try to control it more, but I have an online course on school, S-K-O-O-L. And that just has Steve Keen. So school Steve Keen. So YouTube, Patreon, Substack and school.
Chris Williamson 1:29:06 Beautiful. Appreciate you, mate. Until next time.
Dr. Steve Keen 1:29:09 Thank you.
Chris Williamson 1:29:09 All right. Goodbye, my beauties. Hey, a quick note. One thing that we've been told by a lot of our subscribers is that on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube, they've been unsubscribed or unfollowed even though they pressed it. So just do me a favor and check below if that has happened. It's happening to a lot of people. Means that you get to find out about episodes before anybody else and it supports the show and makes me very happy indeed. Just give it a little check. Give it a little tap. All will be well. I thank you
Episode duration: 1:29:34
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode zoGoRBYKQrg