By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
Peter Attia MD#15 – Paul Conti, M.D.: trauma, suicide, community, and self-compassion
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
CHAPTERS
- 0:04 – 6:36
Introduction and Meeting in Medical School
Peter Attia introduces Paul Conti and the themes of the episode, including trauma, shame, depression and suicide. The two joke about Paul's laryngitis and reminisce about their close group of friends in medical school.
- •Peter describes Paul as the best psychiatrist he has met and previews topics such as emotional trauma, shame, depression and suicide
- •Paul has laryngitis and treats it with his grandmother's remedy of hot water and aspirin
- •The pair have known each other twenty-one years, since a close group of seven formed in the first week of medical school
- •Peter recalls Paul saying on day one that he wanted to be a psychiatrist
- 6:36 – 14:02
Why Paul Chose Psychiatry: Searching for Truth
Paul explains that psychiatry represented a search for truth and a response to difficult experiences. He describes his path from political science and consulting to medicine and why he found business work unfulfilling.
- •Paul says the group came to medicine searching for something, driven by suffering and trauma
- •He rejects the split between doing things for others and doing them for oneself as a false dichotomy
- •He studied political science, history and literature and was drawn to the people behind events
- •Four years in consulting brought more authority and money but less happiness
- •He missed the intensity of human interaction and struggle
- 14:02 – 17:29
Losing a Brother and a Friend: Silent Struggle and Functional Death
Paul speaks about the deaths of his brother by suicide and a close childhood friend within about a year. They discuss how silent bravado and an inability to be vulnerable can lead to death, or to a functional death in which a person is alive but effectively dead.
- •Paul's brother died by suicide, and a close friend died with a similar desperate recklessness
- •Both had real needs that never got acknowledgement or help
- •Peter describes a functional death where someone is technically alive but effectively dead
- •Paul says society's matrices of achievement push people toward incessant striving and away from pausing to feel vulnerability
- 17:29 – 26:04
Training at Stanford and Harvard; Is Freud Still Relevant?
Paul describes splitting his residency between Stanford's neurobiology and Harvard's psychotherapy tradition. He explains the Freudian ego as the whole self rather than a defense mechanism and links this to psychedelics.
- •Paul agrees there is truth in the Stanford (neurobiology) and Harvard (psychotherapy) description of his training
- •He is critical of a field that trains too little in brain biology and too little in psychology
- •The Freudian ego is the whole self that mediates between id and superego, not the defensive ego
- •Psychedelics may dissolve ego as defense, the protective walls built from childhood insecurity
- •Therapy and psychedelics can help people reach an authentic self, including acknowledging shame and vulnerabilities
- 26:04 – 34:35
The Wounded Child, Striving, and Whether It's Getting Worse
Peter describes his experience at a trauma treatment program in Kentucky and the idea of a wounded child driving adult achievement, and asks whether this is worsening. Paul suspects modern opportunity has made it easier to run from vulnerability and says 80% of what he treats is trauma.
- •Peter says his perfectionism and achievement were a kid trying to protect him
- •Paul sees more opportunity as also offering more ways to run from what plagues us
- •He contrasts modern striving, a drive away from something, with the sense of a day being done that his shepherd ancestors may have had
- •Paul believes about 80% of what he treats is trauma, appearing as anxiety, depression, panic attacks, substance abuse, overeating, cutting or gambling
- 34:35 – 45:47
Diagnosis vs. Understanding, and Suicide Statistics
Paul criticizes psychiatry's focus on categorizing and billing rather than understanding people. Peter cites rising suicide rates, and both discuss how many deaths labeled accidents may really be suicides.
- •Paul says categorizing someone with a number is not understanding them, and criticizes the DSM and insurance-driven care
- •He extends the criticism to a society of phone trees and isolation
- •Peter cites a roughly 30% rise in suicide among 40-to-60-year-olds and notes suicide is a top ten cause of death in every decade after the first
- •Peter tells of a friend's father and then the friend dying, an experience that changed how he prioritizes
- •Paul says he keeps track of what people really died of, such as shame or unaddressed rape, versus what is on the death certificate
- 45:47 – 50:47
Trauma Beneath Disease and the Road to The Bridge
Paul argues that trauma underlies much of the morbidity and mortality doctors see. Peter recounts his resistance to attending The Bridge to Recovery, his angry intake call, and the program's five roots of trauma.
- •Paul says trauma and depression raise risk of cardiovascular disease, accidents, addiction and are linked to stress effects on immunity and cancer
- •He believes more than half of what any doctor sees rests on misery from trauma
- •Peter resisted going because he equated success with having no problem and minimized his past
- •The Bridge names five roots of trauma: abuse, neglect, abandonment, enmeshment and witnessing tragic events
- •A counselor asking how he'd feel if it happened to his son Reese broke through his defenses
- 50:47 – 56:42
How Shame Works and Why Children's Ages Trigger Trauma
Paul explains shame as an aroused affect that a child makes sense of by blaming themselves, and why it is untouched by time. He explains why a parent can be triggered when their child reaches the age at which they were hurt.
- •The intake clinician's question was like a physical exam locating where it hurts, revealing shame and fear
- •Shame is an affect created without volition, and a child often decides abuse is deserved or their fault
- •Trauma stays alive because the brain doesn't care about the clock or calendar
- •A parent can be triggered when their child reaches the age they were hurt, since they are a traumatized child supposed to protect a child
- •Internal stress contributes to suicide, cardiovascular disease, cancer and autoimmune problems
- 56:42 – 1:06:17
The Brain's Power Over the Body: A Patient Case and the Inner Voice
Peter recalls a shared patient whose metabolism improved after trauma-focused work with Paul. Paul describes how the brain can shut down limbs and metabolism and shares the story of a man who berated himself hundreds of times a day.
- •Peter's patient did everything right metabolically yet lost thirty pounds over six months of work with Paul without other changes
- •Paul cites conversion-type paralysis of limbs as evidence of the brain's power over the body
- •A highly capable patient was in a low-level job and said he told himself he was a piece of shit hundreds of times a day
- •Addressing that inner voice changed the man's life and career
- •Paul says he carries a similar critical inner voice himself
- 1:06:17 – 1:14:52
Generational Transmission of Shame and the Myth That Pain Makes Us Stronger
Peter and Paul discuss how trauma and shame come out in unexpected forms in the next generation rather than repeating directly. Paul rejects the idea that what doesn't kill us makes us stronger and says high achievement can mark defense against hurt.
- •Trauma usually emerges in an orthogonal way, not as a repeat of the same abuse
- •Peter cites Terrence Real on how many generations it takes shame to work itself out
- •Paul says shame may take practically infinite generations to resolve without understanding
- •Most human suffering happens with a fizzle, not a bang
- •Paul calls 'what doesn't kill us makes us stronger' a lie, since bad things often make us weaker and are buried
- •Very high achievement is, for him, a marker of suspicion that someone is defending against something
- 1:14:52 – 1:21:49
The Bridge Experience: Camp Misery, Roommates and 12-Step Meetings
Peter and Paul discuss the nicknames of The Bridge and why Paul recommended it despite Peter's worries about socioeconomic differences. Peter describes the roommate rule, the exhausting schedule and the vulnerability of 12-step meetings.
- •The Bridge is nicknamed Camp Misery and The Crying Factory
- •Paul told Peter the socioeconomic mix was the reason he should go
- •Peter realized he and a roommate he thought he had nothing in common with were fundamentally the same
- •Daily 13-hour group days plus nightly 12-step meetings were more draining than swimming the Catalina Channel
- •Peter found vulnerability in the meetings an antidote to shame, where nobody cared that he was in the room
- 1:21:49 – 1:30:24
Separating Ourselves, Shared Humanity and Everyone Having Been a Client
Responding to Peter's question about what listeners can do, Paul says to notice how we separate ourselves from others to escape shame, which guarantees loneliness. He tells of his clinic's mixed groups and a young woman teaching a neurosurgeon, and Peter notes that every Bridge employee had been a client.
- •Paul says the reflex to stand out is driven by a need to avoid shame and ends in isolation
- •His clinic's addiction groups deliberately did not stratify people by addiction, age or socioeconomic status
- •His proudest memory is a formerly homeless nineteen-year-old teaching a neurosurgeon
- •Peter says immersion achieved what weekly therapy might never have
- •Every staff member at The Bridge had once been a client, reinforcing that we are all the same
- 1:30:24 – 1:46:46
David Foster Wallace and the Role of Meaning
Peter brings up David Foster Wallace's "This Is Water" and plays a 1997 interview in which Wallace describes a sad, privileged generation. Prompted by Peter's question about suicide and evolution, Paul argues that we are wired to survive when we see meaning, and that its absence promotes suicide.
- •Peter describes Wallace's idea that everyone worships something, and that money, power or intellect will never be enough
- •In the interview Wallace says his generation was extraordinarily sad despite material comfort and freedom
- •Peter asks whether suicide is a symptom of civilization and whether unmet expectations make people unhappier
- •Paul says people struggle to survive when they see meaning, citing Viktor Frankl, and that struggle can give meaning
- •He says people risk their lives for others because meaning is clear in that moment, the opposite of suicide
- •Paul says struggle over unaffordable basics is hard to find meaning in, and that shared hardship used to be borne in community
- 1:46:46 – 1:59:46
Rebuilding Community, Tribe and Friendships
Peter asks whether anything can curb rising suicide. Paul proposes accessible community spaces for connection and psychoeducation and criticizes cost structures, and they discuss the fantasy of living as a tribe and why one spouse can't meet every need.
- •Paul advocates community places with facilitators, couches and coffee for connection and basic education about what happens inside people
- •He says society pays a million dollars for an ICU stay after an overdose but not a few hundred dollars for a car repair
- •Peter and Paul describe the fantasy of the med school friends living on one block as a tribe
- •Paul says we act on automatic values and rarely see old friends, and he traces this to trauma and insecurity
- •Paul says it is a human problem, not gender-based, that society expects one partner to be everything
- 1:59:46 – 2:09:24
Takeaways, Book Recommendations and Closing
Paul suggests taking stock of one's inner dialogue, connecting with people, and trying psychotherapy, and recommends Camus' The Plague and Katherine Mansfield's short stories. The episode closes with plans for a part two and mutual thanks.
- •Paul urges noticing the inner dialogue and talking with people close to us, complemented by professionals
- •He says everyone could benefit from psychotherapy and that 12-step meetings foster shared humanity
- •He recommends Camus' The Plague and Katherine Mansfield's short stories to evoke humanity and compassion
- •Compassion for self is what leads people to seek help
- •Peter says they plan a part two, covering topics like distress tolerance and pharmacology
- •Peter calls unhappiness perhaps the greatest disease of civilization
