Skip to content
PivotPivot

Can We Get Back Together With Canada? | Pivot

Live from Toronto, it's the Pivot Tour! Kara and Scott are hitting the road, and their first stop is a visit to our neighbors up north. They discuss tariffs and tourism, and how the U.S. can get back together with Canada. Plus, FAA cuts lead to flight cancellations, what the Supreme Court SNAP ruling is really all about, and the new wave of progressive mayors on both sides of the border. Timestamps: 00:00 Intro 7:15 Flight Cancellations Mount 12:05 Supreme Court SNAP Ruling 21:45 U.S.-Canada Trade War 35:21 Mamdani the Role Model 43:21 Tourism Downturn 49:47 Q&A #pivot #podcast #pivottour #karaswisher #scottgalloway #canada #toronto #faa #supremecourt #snap #mamdani #tourism Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin Corinne Ruff Video Editor: Jim Mackil Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa Subscribe to Pivot on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pivot/id1073226719 Subscribe to Pivot on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4MU3RFGELZxPT9XHVwTNPR Follow us on Instagram and Threads at: https://www.instagram.com/pivotpodcastofficial/ Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@PIVOTPODCAST Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email pivot@voxmedia.com

Kara SwisherhostScott Gallowayhost
Nov 11, 20251h 0mWatch on YouTube ↗

CHAPTERS

  1. 0:00 – 2:14

    Live in Toronto: Tour kickoff, Canada love, and Scott’s pre-show banter

    Kara and Scott open the live Toronto show, set up the “seven cities in seven days” tour, and establish a playful U.S.–Canada tone. The early banter covers travel, Toronto trivia, and Scott’s habit of outsourcing curiosity to ChatGPT.

    • Live show context: Toronto stop on a multi-city tour
    • Sponsors/recording setup for audio + YouTube
    • Comic bits about flights, Toronto facts, and Scott’s AI/ChatGPT usage
    • Framing the episode’s local focus: tariffs, tourism, local politics
  2. 2:14 – 2:42

    Flight delays and FAA dysfunction: economic fallout and safety risk

    Kara uses her delayed flight to pivot into mounting U.S. flight cancellations and concerns about FAA capacity and competence. They argue the disruption harms business, tourism, and public trust, and warn that political gamesmanship could raise safety risks.

    • Kara’s delayed travel becomes a case study for broader cancellations
    • Government shutdown/operational cuts ripple into commerce and tours
    • Critique of U.S. transportation leadership and politicization
    • Safety anxiety: near-collisions and fear of a major incident
  3. 2:42 – 10:51

    Why aviation is a civilization-level innovation (and what it teaches about AI)

    Scott zooms out to argue the biggest innovations benefit the public more than they enrich a few firms—citing vaccines, the PC, and commercial air travel. He contrasts aviation’s huge societal gains with its historically weak industry profits, then speculates AI could follow a similar “broad benefit, limited capture” path.

    • Big innovations often create widespread public value (vaccines/PCs/air travel)
    • Air travel’s net profitability vs. enormous social/economic impact
    • FAA’s role in making flying ultra-safe compared to other transport
    • AI may become a commodity-like benefit rather than a winner-take-all platform
  4. 10:51 – 14:43

    SNAP benefits and the Supreme Court: what budgets reveal about national values

    They discuss a Supreme Court procedural move that keeps SNAP benefits constrained while the case moves through lower courts. The conversation broadens into moral and political critique: the U.S. safety net, the optics of wealth concentration, and how fiscal choices expose a country’s priorities.

    • SNAP dispute and court maneuvering (emergency decision back to circuit court)
    • Juxtaposition of billionaire wealth vs. children’s food insecurity
    • Racist misinformation tropes about SNAP usage
    • Argument that budgets reflect values: kids vs. enforcement spending
  5. 14:43 – 19:24

    Trump-era imagery, cruelty politics, and public backlash signals

    Kara and Scott argue that the administration’s visuals and spectacles (gold interiors, demolition imagery, aggressive enforcement optics) shape public sentiment. They suggest some of Trump’s popularity erosion may be tied to visceral reactions to what people are seeing, not just policy details.

    • ICE raid imagery and “cruelty as leadership” framing
    • White House renovation/demolition as a powerful visual metaphor
    • Public opinion decline linked to symbolic visuals
    • Pivot to the next segment: trade tensions with Canada
  6. 19:24 – 22:48

    U.S.–Canada trade war: tariffs, ‘51st state’ talk, and alliance damage

    Back from break, they lay out tariff levels and Canada’s response under Prime Minister Mark Carney, including diversifying exports and increased spending. Scott argues the U.S. is taking Canada for granted, undermining a uniquely trusting alliance and economically harming both sides.

    • Tariff specifics and Canada’s planned counter-strategy/investment
    • Carney’s political position and Canada’s shift to new partners
    • Historic alliance context: undefended border, wartime cooperation
    • Critique of ‘51st state’ rhetoric as destabilizing and unserious
  7. 22:48 – 28:23

    Trade is asymmetric: why Canada may be the one ‘taken advantage of’

    Scott claims the U.S. often captures more shareholder value per trade dollar because it exports higher-margin goods while importing lower-margin commodities. He frames the tariff strategy as an irrational “angry divorce” move that damages the richer partner too—just to hurt the other more.

    • Export mix: Canada-to-U.S. commodities vs. U.S.-to-Canada higher-margin goods
    • Shareholder value argument: U.S. gains more per export dollar
    • Tariffs as self-harm and as a kind of geopolitical unkindness
    • Long-term cost: trust once broken is slow to rebuild
  8. 28:23 – 35:20

    Canada’s innovation challenge: BlackBerry’s rise/fall and how ecosystems scale

    Kara raises Canada’s tech potential and the missed opportunity symbolized by BlackBerry, arguing dependence on the U.S. can stunt local innovation. Scott points to risk tolerance, regulatory posture, tax incentives, and the compounding effects of repeated big winners (e.g., ‘more Shopifys’) that seed venture ecosystems.

    • BlackBerry as a cautionary tale about sustaining tech leadership
    • Why the U.S. produces more unicorns: risk, upside, and ecosystem flywheels
    • Role of founder liquidity events in creating VC density and repeat startups
    • Open question: what combination of policy/culture closes the gap for Canada
  9. 35:20 – 40:17

    NYC politics meets Toronto: Mamdani, progressive priorities, and ‘role model’ masculinity

    They connect Toronto’s progressive mayoral agenda to New York City’s new political moment and debate Zohran Mamdani’s appeal. Scott praises Mamdani’s campaign strengths and uses the moment to explain his framework for masculinity—provider, protector, procreation—arguing modern leaders often fail the “protector” role.

    • Progressive governance themes: affordability and housing vs. symbolic perks
    • Mamdani as a bold, disciplined campaigner; Democrats can learn from it
    • Scott’s masculinity triad: provider → protector → procreation
    • Cultural polarization and the ‘mating crisis’ as politics splits genders
  10. 40:17 – 42:04

    State-run stores vs. cash support: the fight over government’s role in affordability

    A quick policy sparring match uses Canada’s government-run liquor stores as a proxy for debate about public vs. private provision. Scott argues governments should fund people directly (wages/transfers) rather than run retail operations, which he says create inefficiency and poor service.

    • Government-run liquor stores as an example of public-sector retail
    • Scott’s case: privatization can increase selection, employment, competition
    • Affordability strategy: ‘give people money’ vs. state-operated distribution
    • Connecting back to SNAP cuts and the consequences of weak safety nets
  11. 42:04 – 43:54

    Tourism downturn: tariffs’ unintended damage to a bigger jobs engine

    They note a sharp drop in Canadian tourism to the U.S. and highlight the economic stakes (spending and jobs). Scott argues the U.S. has a fetish for manufacturing revival even though tourism employs more people, and that hostile policy is undercutting a higher-margin sector.

    • Canadian visits down; U.S. residents increasingly traveling north instead
    • Tourism’s employment footprint vs. manufacturing’s smaller share
    • Tariffs and political hostility as demand-destroying signals
    • Tourism as a higher-margin ‘export’ that the U.S. is harming
  12. 43:54 – 48:30

    ‘How do we get back together?’ Normalcy, apology, and rebuilding goodwill

    Asked what would bring Canadians back, Scott bluntly says leadership change and a return to normal alliance behavior. They reflect on the closeness of the two countries, the asymmetry in public sentiment, and the simplest repair strategy: stop attacking friends and acknowledge harm.

    • Core fix: stop declaring war on allies; restore predictable governance
    • Canadians’ colder view of Americans vs. Americans’ warmer view of Canada
    • Shared identity and deep cultural/economic interdependence
    • Kara’s prescription: a straightforward ‘we’re sorry’
  13. 48:30 – 1:00:30

    Audience Q&A: saving democracy, careers in advertising, and disinformation/AI guardrails

    In Q&A, they address fears about U.S. democratic backsliding and argue America has survived prior dark eras and can rebound—especially with youth engagement. They also give career advice for advertising in a shifting ad-supported economy, then end with urgent calls for AI/social media regulation to curb disinformation and youth harm.

    • Democracy question: historical resilience and the need for civic action
    • Youth turnout and local races as signals of counter-mobilization
    • Advertising careers: stay if senior; otherwise move toward small-screen/content + client relationships
    • Disinformation/AI: regulation, age limits, phone-free schools, antitrust, and accountability

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.