Skip to content
PivotPivot

Kara Swisher Is Opting Out of Meta's New AI Tool (And You Should Too) | Pivot

Kara is joined by Puck’s Matt Belloni to unpack states’ upcoming antitrust challenge to the Paramount–Warner Bros. Discovery merger, Disney’s fight with the FCC over "The View," and Netflix’s growing YouTube ambitions. Then, they discuss Meta’s controversial AI image generator, the Sam Altman movie finding a new home after Amazon walked away, and the blockbuster hype surrounding Christopher Nolan’s "The Odyssey." 00:00 Intro 5:16 States Finalize Paramount Antitrust Suit 18:18 Disney Hits Back at FCC 27:28 Netflix’s New Deals 39:56 Meta AI Generator 43:50 Hollywood Buzz 56:18 Predictions #pivot #podcast #karaswisher #mattbelloni #paramount #warnerbros #disney #fcc #netflix #youtube #meta #metaai #theodyssey #taylorswift #madonna Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin Todd Wiseman Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa Subscribe to Pivot on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pivot/id1073226719 Subscribe to Pivot on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4MU3RFGELZxPT9XHVwTNPR Follow us on Instagram and Threads at: https://www.instagram.com/pivotpodcastofficial/ Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@PIVOTPODCAST Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email pivot@voxmedia.com

Kara SwisherhostMatt Belloniguest
Jul 10, 20261h 5mWatch on YouTube ↗

EVERY SPOKEN WORD

  1. 0:005:16

    Intro

    1. KS

      Any adult with a public Instagram account was automatically opted in. Kara Swisher is opted out now, just so you know. These people, are they just constant information thieves? [upbeat music] Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott is off again. Who knows where he is? He's floating around on some yacht in some Italian area, I think. Uh, and, but I have brought in someone who is much smarter than him, Matt Belloni.

    2. MB

      [laughs]

    3. KS

      Journalist, founding partner of Puck and host of The Town podcast. Welcome, Matt.

    4. MB

      Thanks for having me. I don't know about that comparison to Scott, but I'll take it.

    5. KS

      No, he's really smart. But, uh, the, in the topics that we're gonna be talking about, and there's so many of them. You are, you are just do an amazing job and an amazing reporter on Hollywood and more, and, and broader. You talk about AI and a manner, all manner of things. And I just wanna put a, also, a shout-out to Eric Gardner, who writes with you sometimes on the legal stuff.

    6. MB

      Yep.

    7. KS

      Riveting.

    8. MB

      He's great.

    9. KS

      Rivi- riveting.

    10. MB

      Yeah, once a week at Puck, he's great.

    11. KS

      I gotta tell you, and important, actually. It's stuff I didn't know about and I, you know, you understand how, especially around copyright and things like that. Anyway, it's really good. I've been having... One of the things, the reason I wanna have you on, 'cause, um, it, it, it, you, you really have written some of the smartest stuff around a lot of these mergers with, and more to come. And so I wanna sort of get a preview of where you think s- they're going. But I wanna... You recently... I wanna bring something up. You recently said Cannes Lions is a, quote, "tacky business conference." How'd that go over?

    12. MB

      Uh, okay. So-

    13. KS

      It's not tacky. Tacky, I would... The wine is lovely, but it's tacky-ish.

    14. MB

      Well, I did say enjoy the rosé.

    15. KS

      Right. Okay.

    16. MB

      So listen, this, I did an intro my newsletter a couple weeks ago during Cannes Lions, which I called it a soulless corporate boondoggle, and that I would not be attending that year. Uh, it seems to have triggered everybody who was there, 'cause I kept hearing from people that it was coming up at different panels. Ben Smith asked, um, Alex Cooper about it on [laughs] his panel. And listen, I, I think it was a little misunderstood. I don't mind a boondoggle.

    17. KS

      Right. Right.

    18. MB

      Like, I love a good boon- boondoggle. The problem with Cannes Lions is that they call it a festival of creativity.

    19. KS

      Creativity. You're right. Correct. Yes, but-

    20. MB

      And it is not. It is-

    21. KS

      Yeah. Yeah

    22. MB

      ... it is about platforms for selling advertising.

    23. KS

      That's correct.

    24. MB

      And-

    25. KS

      That is correct, yeah

    26. MB

      ... I, you know, through my career covering entertainment, I go to the Cannes Film Festival, which happens a month earlier. That to me is Cannes. Because, yes, it's a market, but it's ultimately about the art and displaying the art. And, you know, even, like, my joke is that Cannes Lions makes the TV upfronts look like the Oscars.

    27. KS

      [laughs]

    28. MB

      Because at least at the upfronts, they're talking about the, the, the-

    29. KS

      The shows

    30. MB

      ... product. The shows-

  2. 5:1618:18

    States Finalize Paramount Antitrust Suit

    1. KS

      states are finalizing an antitrust lawsuit challenging Paramount's acquisition of Warner Brothers. It is gonna be filed. I know-

    2. MB

      Oh, yeah

    3. KS

      ... a lot about this. They have been in touch. The suit-

    4. MB

      It's politically untenable to not file at this point.

    5. KS

      Correct. That's correct. The suit could, let me just put it out, the suit could interfere with Paramount's plan to complete the deal in the coming weeks. The D- DOJ cleared the acquisition rather quickly last month. Talk about, uh, this, the, the lawsuit. Obvious, it's Rob Bonta from California, but there are other states. There's several states involved. Um, and, and of course, there's the, the ongoing British, uh, the, the person who's head of, essentially, competition in Britain is saying she's, she's sort of Adjacent curious of slowing this thing down-

    6. MB

      You bet

    7. KS

      ... at the very least. Uh, which was unusual for her to say. Several British people are like, "Uh, that's not great for them." Uh, it could be a leverage thing. Talk about the, the entire thing and where you see it going.

    8. MB

      It's an interesting one because first of all, the, the antitrust case here is not as strong as-

    9. KS

      No

    10. MB

      ... some other ones recently that-

    11. KS

      Absolutely not. You're right

    12. MB

      ... Live Nation, et cetera. Like, this one, you know, Paramount and Warners are not leaders in the industry, and they're battling these big tech players like Netflix, Amazon, Apple. So it's, it's, you know, y- when they say this merger is pro competition, it's sort of their buzzword they always say in their press releases. Like, they're not totally wrong. If this works and they can create a legitimate competitor to a Netflix, to an Amazon, like that, that is pro competition. Now, obviously the wreckage within Hollywood to do this is going to be thousands of jobs lost-

    13. KS

      Correct. Mm-hmm

    14. MB

      ... and a legacy studio vanishing, and that's what's g- gotten everybody up in arms. The, the, the state action, I, it's gonna be tough, but they need to clear a injunction to actually stop this. They need to go to a court, and a court needs to say, "Okay, not only do you have a likelihood of winning here, I'm going to enjoin this merger from closing." That's the real leverage. If they can get that, then they're gonna be in a best position to extract significant concessions because I think that's what this is all about.

    15. KS

      E- explain what's happening behind the scenes. Obviously, Makan Delrahim, who is their general counsel, is in the middle of this. He's been in the middle of the British thing. They're fighting it on two fronts, and I think the British group essentially just wants stuff-

    16. MB

      Yeah

    17. KS

      ... like promises around the Harry Potter.

    18. MB

      I actually think the states want stuff, too.

    19. KS

      Yes, they do want stuff. So explain what, l- fir- first start with the British. They're, just for people to know, there's a big Harry Potter, uh, studio out there. There may be some people visiting it, the tourism stuff. They want jobs, some children's programming stuff. T- explain what they want in Britain versus the US.

    20. MB

      Yeah. So, eh, first of all, there's, there's varying reports as to what they actually want because they haven't actually said. The, the, the children's programming thing doesn't seem to be that big of a problem. Paramount has a joint venture in the UK to distribute movies, and it's with Comcast, with NBC Universal, for the Universal movies. And there's a scenario where they exit that. Now, they may actually want to do that on their own because the Ellisons may want to just not have a partner there, but that's one area where they are, they are together with a competitor that they may have to divest there. There's also some television interests there that they have. The, the, the real goal is to get them to concede to certain things, and if it's a divestment of certain television interests, if it's a, an exit from this joint venture, that's something where they can claim victory and then they can move on.

    21. KS

      Or jobs. Job retention. Something like that.

    22. MB

      Uh, well, I don't know, actually.

    23. KS

      Yeah.

    24. MB

      That has been the, the, something that the European regulators have gone ma- gone after in the past.

    25. KS

      They have. Mm-hmm.

    26. MB

      Uh, so that could be... Now, I think that is something that is gonna be much more relevant for the state cases. Rob Bonta in California, he's interested in preserving jobs and getting a commitment from the Ellisons to continue to operate Warner Bros. and Paramount separately. You know, David Ellison has committed to releasing 30 movies per year from the two studios in theaters, 15 a year, which is a pretty robust slate. And-

    27. KS

      Right, he's committed. He has no, he doesn't have to.

    28. MB

      No, that's the, that's my point-

    29. KS

      He said, he said so

    30. MB

      ... is that maybe they get that in writing.

  3. 18:1827:28

    Disney Hits Back at FCC

    1. KS

      has told the FCC, uh, that ABC's, uh, The View should continue to qualify as a bona fide news program, making exempt from federal equal time rules for political candidates. The filing comes as the FCC has been probing whether The View violates those equal time rules. A notable line from the filing, "The First Amendment does not permit the government to sit in an editor's chair, yet that is the seat the commission now proposes to take." ABC launched a campaign, a very aggressive campaign, to encourage their viewers to make their thoughts known to the FCC in June, and the commission received over 76,000 comments about the case. Uh, y- as you know, I think Brendan Carr is a moron, and he's way, way overstepped here for reasons unknown. Um-

    2. MB

      Well, re- reasons unknown?

    3. KS

      Well, he wants, he has, he wants a big political career. He-

    4. MB

      Yeah

    5. KS

      ... and he's backing Trump. Yeah

    6. MB

      He wants Donald Trump to love him.

    7. KS

      Yes, exactly. It's, it's pathetic in so many ways. But, um, I bet Donald Trump doesn't love him, by the way. Um, so talk about the con- the consequences here for both sides, because I think Brendan Carr has overstepped, especially in his statements, 'cause his statements go way over the line of any FCC chairman I've heard i- in the many years I've covered them.

    8. MB

      Yeah, it's interesting here because the, this is all happening with the backdrop of Trump not necessarily being as powerful in the media sphere as he was even a year ago. We're, you know, we're heading into lame duck status. The polling is where it is. And it's, it's not, it, you know, I think that Brendan Carr was a little bit surprised that Disney came back so aggressively.

    9. KS

      Yes, he was. Yeah.

    10. MB

      A- and, and, and he's now on Twitter, like, trying to counter this, this pretty normal strategy. I mean-

    11. KS

      Right

    12. MB

      ... when there's ever a-

    13. KS

      Right

    14. MB

      ... carriage fight amongst distributor and, and content provider-

    15. KS

      Disney's good at it

    16. MB

      ... or any of the ... But-

    17. KS

      Disney's always good at it

    18. MB

      ... yeah, they, they go after their fans.

    19. KS

      The New York one, I loved watching the New York one. That was a real fun one.

    20. MB

      And, and shocker, people who watch The View are interested in The View having the freedom to have on any guests that they want. And if Disney communicates to them to stand up to the government to keep your show that you like as your show, they're gonna respond. So I think this was totally predictable. What's the most interesting angle to me-

    21. KS

      Mm-hmm

    22. MB

      ... is through the lens of the new CEO of Disney, Josh D'Amaro.

    23. KS

      Mm-hmm. Yes, exactly.

    24. MB

      He is being aggressive here, and he's pushing-

    25. KS

      Right

    26. MB

      ... back on this one. He's pushing back on the dumb Kimmel thing, Jimmy Kimmel thing-

    27. KS

      Mm-hmm

    28. MB

      ... where they-

    29. KS

      Mm

    30. MB

      ... claim that, you know, they're going after Disney because of their DEI policies.

  4. 27:2839:56

    Netflix’s New Deals

    1. KS

      Matt, we're back. Netflix is getting into the short form content business. The m- the company announced this week it's partnered with BuzzFeed, Condé Nast, Hearst, People, and various Penske media brands to bring the digital videos to the platform. These videos will range from three-minute shorts to 20-minute episodes focusing on travel, cooking, fashion, as well as celebrity content profiles and viral content. All these people have been making these extra what I call shoulder content that you see. You know, maybe-

    2. MB

      Oh, I used to do it. When I-

    3. KS

      Yeah

    4. MB

      ... ran Hollywood Reporter, we had to do-

    5. KS

      Yeah

    6. MB

      ... the video version. It's all-

    7. KS

      The video version.

    8. MB

      Yeah.

    9. KS

      Condé Nast does actually a pretty good job. Uh, they all do a pretty good job at it. This announcement comes in the wake of a new report that Netflix is struggling to retain fans between the first and second seasons of top shows, with some shows shedding 50% of their audience. Engagement is slowing, too. The amount of time customers spent watching Netflix last year grew by less than 2%. Um, talk about why they're doing this, and just for pe- I, I last, yesterday went on Brian Williams' new show, which is ... They're also, they've also bought a bunch of podcasters. I think the one that's doing really well is The Breakfast Club. Um-

    10. MB

      That's the one they're talking about. We'll know next week-

    11. KS

      Yeah

    12. MB

      ... when their engagement report comes out for-

    13. KS

      Yeah

    14. MB

      ... the first half of the year. But-

    15. KS

      Yeah, but I don't think they're high. I don't f- I feel like they're not-

    16. MB

      I, I have heard internally the numbers are not high, but it's early days. That's what they're saying.

    17. KS

      Yes. Yes.

    18. MB

      They're encouraged by the, the trends.

    19. KS

      Yeah. But The Breakfast Club, from what I understand, is the real standout. That's what I heard from them. So, um, uh, talk about this whole thing and include what ... It's not really podcasting. They're, they're t- ... It was a TV show that I ... It was an interview. It was like, you know, Charlie Rose with 100% less creepy. It was just [laughs] ... I don't know. You know what I mean? It was like that's what it, that's what the set looked like.

    20. MB

      Well, they're calling them video podcasts. I mean, there's a-

    21. KS

      Right

    22. MB

      ... a distinction there. I think the guilds, uh, would love for them to call them talk shows 'cause they have to pay more for them. But-

    23. KS

      Fine. It was a talk show

    24. MB

      ... okay. This is all just about Netflix having YouTube envy. Th- they, they look at the engagement report every month from Nielsen. They're getting their butts kicked by YouTube. They know why. You know, so much of the viewing on YouTube is this lower quality, um, you know, user generated. It's just, it's, it's, it's, it's a different product than Netflix. It's free. Netflix is not free. And they're saying, "How can we boost our engagement numbers without going full on user generated and becoming-

    25. KS

      Right

    26. MB

      ... YouTube?"

    27. KS

      Right.

    28. MB

      But having enough on the platform where people start to consider it u- the everyday.

    29. KS

      Right.

    30. MB

      You just go there to watch video.

  5. 39:5643:50

    Meta AI Generator

    1. KS

      to. Meta has released an AI image generator called Muse Image, which the company's calling the creative partner that knows your world. I can't b- I can't believe these people write these things. The generator comes, uh, with a feature that lets users create AI images based on people's Instagram photos, and any adult with a public Instagram account was automatically opted in. Kara Swisher is opted out now, just so you know. [laughs] The company-

    2. MB

      You know, I saw your post on Threads, and I tried-

    3. KS

      Yeah

    4. MB

      ... to do that last night, and I couldn't-

    5. KS

      Yeah

    6. MB

      ... find the button to do that.

    7. KS

      I will show you.

    8. MB

      Okay.

    9. KS

      I will send you a step by step. Uh, the company also previewed an AI video generator, which will be coming available in the next month. Uh, w- d- what is these people? Are they just constant information thieves?

    10. MB

      [laughs]

    11. KS

      They just continually do this?

    12. MB

      Listen, it's a, a ask forgiveness, not permission strategy.

    13. KS

      Right, yep.

    14. MB

      It's been the case from the-

    15. KS

      Yep

    16. MB

      ... very beginning in Silicon Valley, and it takes the Hollywood people to step up. The talent agency CAA put out a pretty good statement last night. No one, they said, "No one's image, name and likeness, voice, or creative work should be used by a third party, including AI models, without clear documented consent." They're telling them essentially what the industry said about Sora when OpenAI launched it. It's like, "Don't make this opt-out. Make it opt-in."

    17. KS

      Right, exactly. They hate opt-in.

    18. MB

      I know, because nobody does it.

    19. KS

      They ha- they've hated opt-in since AOL. They hate opt-in.

    20. MB

      Yeah.

    21. KS

      They hate it.

    22. MB

      I get it.

    23. KS

      And it's such a ri-

    24. MB

      I, it, listen, it's a much, it's a much less convenient business-

    25. KS

      Yeah

    26. MB

      ... to have to ask permission.

    27. KS

      That's correct.

    28. MB

      But that's kinda how it works when you have rights-

    29. KS

      Again

    30. MB

      ... like copyright and name, image-

  6. 43:5056:18

    Hollywood Buzz

    1. KS

      Matt, we're back with more headlines. The Sam Altman-focused movie, Artificial, has found a new home at an indie studio, Neon, after Amazon gave it the boot. Amazon walked away from the project after striking a major partnership with OpenAI. The $40 million, uh, film stars Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman and recounts the chaotic weekend in 2023 when he was fired and was reinstated as OpenAI's CEO. Neon plans to release the film later this year, and is expected to position it as an awards contender. Uh, you know, w- very well-regarded, uh, filmmaker made it. Um, uh, talk about, talk about that, and then just, uh, secondly, a big movie's obviously coming out or w- well, you mentioned Chris Nolan. His latest film, The Odyssey, which could be the biggest movie of the summer, maybe the year. Tickets went on sale, crashing AMC's app. People are desperate to see this.

    2. MB

      [laughs]

    3. KS

      Fandango says first day sales were 10 times higher than Nolan's last film, Oppenheimer. Early reactions have been raves, despite a backlash online. It's a fake backlash online d-

    4. MB

      Oh, ridiculous

    5. KS

      ... downloading the movie's trailers and calling the casting of some of the actors. It's ridiculous. It's a right-wing lunacy. One of the biggest critics, of course, is Elon Musk, who's been attacking the movie and director Nolan for months. Uh, I haven't seen the movie. I'm gonna see it Monday, I think. Um-

    6. MB

      Yeah, I'm going Monday as well

    7. KS

      ... uh, it looks, uh, it looks, uh, astonishing, you know. Um, uh, talk about... I mean, I think they've beat the backlash back. I don't think anybody is, is-

    8. MB

      That doesn't matter. That's just noise

    9. KS

      Yeah, it doesn't matter. So talk about these two movies, the Sam Altman-focused movie and the, um, and the, and this, uh, this other one. I think it'll do just fine. I think Neon is a good place for it to go. I-

    10. MB

      Listen, thi- this one, I don't know if you and Scott give a Wuss of the Year award.

    11. KS

      Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

    12. MB

      But Mike Hopkins at Amazon-

    13. KS

      Yeah

    14. MB

      ... is an early contender. They-

    15. KS

      All right. Well, you can have one. You have your own podcast.

    16. MB

      I know. I do.

    17. KS

      You make a list.

    18. MB

      Trust me, we've, I've gone on and on about this one.

    19. KS

      Wuss of the Year. We stick with Brandon Carr as a moron.

    20. MB

      [laughs]

    21. KS

      That's the people we focus on. But you can go for Mike Hopkins, but go ahead.

    22. MB

      So listen, Amazon developed this movie, hired Luca Guadagnino, who did Call Me By Your Name and Challengers, a well-regarded filmmaker, to direct this movie. They went through all the motions. The only thing that has changed from when they greenlit this movie last year until now is that they now have a $50 billion relationship with OpenAI.

    23. KS

      Mm-hmm. Right.

    24. MB

      And it's so obvious that they're not even denying it. [laughs] They-

    25. KS

      Well, no, but when you go around, like I've, I've, you know, when you go around to these comp- they're just like, "We're not touching that," you know, if it's an Elon Musk property. They do this all the time, right? They do it.

    26. MB

      They do, but this, the difference here is that Amazon committed to this major-

    27. KS

      To making it

    28. MB

      ... filmmaker and all-

    29. KS

      Yeah

    30. MB

      ... of this talent, and Amazon wants to be both. They wanna serve the masters in Seattle and be a tech platform that is looking at the, you know, the future of AI and all the bets they're making there. But they also want to be able to do real Hollywood movies like Project Hail Mary that requires relationships with talent. The first call that Mike Hopkins had to make on this was to Brian Lourd, the head of CAA, the most powerful talent agency that has a lot of talent in this movie, and tell him, "This movie by your prominent filmmaker is getting dumped by the studio." What do you think Brian Lourd is gonna do the next time they have a hot piece of material?

  7. 56:181:05:24

    Predictions

    1. KS

      Okay. Uh, Matt, let's hear a prediction.

    2. MB

      All right, so I have a fun one and a serious one.

    3. KS

      Okay. Go for it.

    4. MB

      I'll do the serious one first.

    5. KS

      Okay.

    6. MB

      I think Netflix will launch a free tier within a year.

    7. KS

      Oh. Hmm.

    8. MB

      This is where it's going. All of this low value podcast, social video, YouTube style-

    9. KS

      Free

    10. MB

      ... content, they are going to separate it or have it available on the paid tier as well, but-

    11. KS

      Right. Yeah

    12. MB

      ... they're gonna put it into this free tier that will serve as a top of funnel for the regular Netflix-

    13. KS

      Advertising?

    14. MB

      ... and hopefully juice their advertising business-

    15. KS

      Advertising. Yeah

    16. MB

      ... via engagement.

    17. KS

      Right. Okay. Little bit of Tubi. Go ahead, yeah.

    18. MB

      A little bit of Tubi.

    19. KS

      All right.

    20. MB

      And to compete with those.

    21. KS

      Yeah. Yeah.

    22. MB

      And, and I, and I, you know, query whether it will harm the brand or cause people that pay for Netflix to switch to a non-paying situation, but it's getting to the point where Netflix is showing us their cards. They are so obsessed with YouTube. They will launch a real YouTube competitor in a free service, and they can put some of this old show content that they haven't licensed out anywhere and is not doing much on the platform. They can put that on the free tier and have it be like a Tubi or a Pluto TV where it serves as a funnel-

    23. KS

      Yep

    24. MB

      ... for the other services.

    25. KS

      Yep. That's a great idea. They could do deals. Yeah, that's an interesting, that's an interest- You know, it's interesting, I saw pictures of Neil Mohan from YouTube and Ted walking into the Sun Valley thing, uh, which was interesting. I was like, ooh, I'd like to see them chitty-chat. Like, I'd like to be in front of them, seeing them. Uh, by the way, that thing also looks bad this year for some reason. Like, I never liked it. Never get invited 'cause I'm a pain in the ass, but, um, but they, uh, it, it looks particularly tone deaf this year for some reason, but maybe you don't think so.

    26. MB

      I'm interested in the fashion.

    27. KS

      Oh, okay. The outfits. Lauren.

    28. MB

      Yeah, the vest.

    29. KS

      Lauren Sanchez.

    30. MB

      And the David Zaslav-

Episode duration: 1:05:26

Install uListen for AI-powered chat & search across the full episode — Get Full Transcript

Transcript of episode 02LVlaXdn8U

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.