By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
70 min read · 14,026 wordsStart
Andrew Roberts 0:00 I'm afraid I'm a bit of a pessimist.
Tim Ferriss 0:01 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 0:02 Um, yeah. Not so much for the United States because you're such a, still such a rich and innovative country. But I'm wondering in Britain whether or not, and history plays a, an important part of this, especially the way in which history is used politically, to wonder whether or not we still believe in ourselves, certainly in the way that we did when I was growing up. In 20-- I'm gonna try and get the statistics right. I think it's 2015, as recent as 2015, maybe it's 2010, 86% of people were proud of British history. That has now fallen down to 56%. And I'm sure that the reason for this is the sustained attack on, on, well, the British Empire that we were discussing earlier, and people forgetting the part that we played in the abolition of slavery and concentrating just on the, on the horrors and the, and the monstrous things that, uh, happened. And we are therefore-- If you're not proud of your past, you're not proud of your an-ancestors, you're not proud of the things that they produced, and Britain has produced some pretty extraordinary and wonderful things for the world, then it's difficult to see why anyone would want to be proud of the future of the country as well. And so I'm pretty pes-pessimistic. And when I feel pessimism for America, it's for things like taking Thomas Jefferson's statue down from the New York City Hall. And it's a form of cultural suicide, it strikes me, not to admire the founders of your nation. And yes, of course, he owned slaves, but he also wrote a constitution that has survived for a quarter of a millennium. And, and, and he was brave enough, and Washington and all the, the others, brave enough to stand up against the most powerful empire in the world. These things, you deserve your statue, it seems to me. [upbeat music]
Tim Ferriss 2:27 Hey, everybody. This is Tim Ferriss. Welcome to another episode of The Tim Ferriss Show. We're gonna get started very shortly. What follows is a conversation, an interview with Andrew Roberts. He is an incredible historian. He is also a prolific author, and we talk about his creative process, but also lessons learned and life lessons from the subjects of his books, which include Napoleon and Churchill. We cover a lot of ground. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. You can find his full bio, many more links in the description, and here it
Expelled from Cranleigh school.
Tim Ferriss 2:57 is. Well, pleasure to meet you. Thank you for taking the time.
Andrew Roberts 2:59 Thanks so much, Tim, for having me on this show.
Tim Ferriss 3:02 I thought we would start with Cranleigh after your A-levels.
Andrew Roberts 3:06 Did you now?
Tim Ferriss 3:07 What happened?
Andrew Roberts 3:08 [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 3:09 What on earth happened?
Andrew Roberts 3:09 Did you know that's the way, that's the way you're gonna kick off? That's the way we're gonna make friends and, uh-
Tim Ferriss 3:14 No, I-
Andrew Roberts 3:14 ... and get on with each other.
Tim Ferriss 3:15 Roll up the sleeves and just get into it.
Andrew Roberts 3:16 You're gonna, you're gonna mention the reason that I was expelled from school, or at least I'm gonna mention the reason because you don't know-
Tim Ferriss 3:22 I don't know the reason.
Andrew Roberts 3:23 Absolutely. Good. Okay. Well, I don't think I'm the first person ever as a young man to get drunk and climb up buildings. You know, that-
Tim Ferriss 3:32 Absolutely not.
Andrew Roberts 3:32 Thank you. Thank you.
Tim Ferriss 3:33 Time-honored tradition, I think.
Andrew Roberts 3:34 Hallelujah that I'm not the only person this happened to. But quite understandably, the school chucked me out before I fell off one of them, you know, and they'd-
Tim Ferriss 3:43 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 3:43 And they'd have got blamed. And it led to actually one of my wife's most brilliant witticisms. She's a very funny woman, my wife, and she said, "Yes, and all Andrew's done since in life is to get drunk and social climb." [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 3:58 [laughs]
Why MI6 considered Andrew for recruitment.
Tim Ferriss 4:00 That is clever.
Andrew Roberts 4:00 It's not bad, is it?
Tim Ferriss 4:01 All right. Well, we might come, we might come back to that.
Andrew Roberts 4:03 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 4:04 It seems like also maybe-- It's hard for me to tell given the British school system, although I did go to St. Paul's in New Hampshire where they do have the third, fourth, fifth, sixth form and so on. So that much I know.
Andrew Roberts 4:15 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 4:15 But I think in the same piece where I found the Cranleigh bit in doing the research, also found note that you were approached as a possible candidate for MI6 a bit later on?
Andrew Roberts 4:26 No, that was when I was at Cambridge.
Tim Ferriss 4:28 Cambridge.
Andrew Roberts 4:29 Yes, yes, absolutely. That's the right time to be approached for MI6 is because Cambridge and MI6 have had a, a long and, and fairly disastrous career, needless to say. [laughs] All of the worst spies in the 1930s, traitors of the 1930s went to Cambridge. But yeah, it was a fascinating thing. I was just going down from university, and somebody in my college, one of the dons there, who's still there actually, come to think of it, approached me and said, "How about it? Would you be interested in, in becoming a spy?" And so automatically, needless to say, you just think of yourself as James Bond immediately, you know. That sort of [singing] is going on.
Tim Ferriss 5:09 The soundtrack kicks off.
Andrew Roberts 5:10 The soundtrack in the back of your brain, you're automatically there with your Beretta and the beautiful women and all of that kind of thing. But I then had to actually do the, do the process of where you need to, to join, which I did get through, and it was completely hilarious. I mean, it was-- You couldn't satirize it, basically. They asked you things like, there were hundreds of questions, and you had to answer them very, very quickly. And some of them were things you'd expect, like, you know, what are the five longest rivers in the world kind of thing.
Tim Ferriss 5:41 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 5:42 Put them in order and all that. There were also things like, place in order of social precedence, prince, duke, viscount, marquess, baronet. [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 5:53 Oh, I'm out.
Andrew Roberts 5:54 Yeah, well, exactly. Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 5:54 I would have thrown in Cookie Monster. I wouldn't have got any of it.
Andrew Roberts 5:57 You're American. You're allowed to. They're not going to ask that in the CIA. But in, for some reason, in MI6 back in-- This was, I hasten to add, back in the sort of mid-1980s. That was one of the questions.
Tim Ferriss 6:08 [laughs] What did the don think made you a- Potential candidate.
Andrew Roberts 6:14 Well, that also was a little bit annoying, really, because he told me later about how he had been interviewed by MI6. And one of the things he'd been asked is, "And is Andrew a kind person?" And this person said, "No, not, not really." And he saw the person interviewing him put a tick in the, [laughs] in the margin next to the question. [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 6:38 Wonder if that made you more or less desirable.
Andrew Roberts 6:40 Much more desirable as far as they were concerned. They, they ticked the, the, the thing.
Tim Ferriss 6:44 Right.
Andrew Roberts 6:44 I know. I can understand. Well, James Bond, he's not a kind person, is he, really? [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 6:49 No. No, no. You view them as disposable pleasures. Well, perhaps. So let's see if we can take off the initial layers of the onion with respect to history.
The teacher who made history exciting to 10-year-old Andrew.
Tim Ferriss 7:02 Christopher Perry, Mr. Christopher Perry.
Andrew Roberts 7:05 Yeah, wonderful man.
Tim Ferriss 7:06 Who is that?
Andrew Roberts 7:07 He was my first history teacher-
Tim Ferriss 7:08 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 7:09 -when I was at prep school, which in the English version means when you're sort of 10 to 13.
Tim Ferriss 7:15 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 7:16 He's dead now, but he was a inspirational history master. He taught history in the way that I think it should be taught, in a narrative way of explaining really, you know, what happened next and why.
Tim Ferriss 7:30 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 7:30 Uh, he believed in the great events, the great sort of wars and battles and things like that. And he was a, he was a kind man. He wouldn't have made it into MI6. [laughs] But he was a, a sort of old school history master of the best possible kind.
Tim Ferriss 7:48 Mm-hmm. What characterized that? You said narrative, but maybe would you be able to contrast the status quo as it goes in terms of teaching history and then how his style most differed from that?
Andrew Roberts 8:03 He taught it as the most exciting story you're ever going to hear, basically, which has the extraordinary added advantage of being completely true.
Tim Ferriss 8:12 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 8:12 He'd sort of sit cross-legged on the, on the table and give you the voice of Charles I and then the voice of Oliver Cromwell, you know, he-- Elizabeth I and Mary, Queen of Scots. He would entrance you with the, with the excitement of the unfolding story, every word of which would be true. It would have loads of dates in it. At the end of the term, each of the terms, the semester, you'd be tested on 300 dates, and not a child in that class didn't get at least 298 of them right.
Tim Ferriss 8:44 That's wild.
Andrew Roberts 8:45 Extraordinary way of teaching. He did it entirely through inspiration rather than through, you know, just sort of standing there on a blackboard, ordering people to remember, you know, what happened in 1356 or 1415.
Tim Ferriss 8:57 Did he have any theater background?
Andrew Roberts 8:59 You'd have thought.
Tim Ferriss 9:00 You would think.
Andrew Roberts 9:00 You'd have thought.
Tim Ferriss 9:01 Because just sitting cross-legged on the desk is going to get a requisite minimal amount of attention from the students, which is brilliant.
Andrew Roberts 9:08 Automatically.
Tim Ferriss 9:09 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 9:09 Of course, exactly. No, I mean, [laughs] now I come to think of it, of course, he was overacting from day one.
Tim Ferriss 9:17 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 9:17 But he didn't seem to be at the time, at least as far as the, as the 10-year-old Andrew Roberts was concerned.
Tim Ferriss 9:23 Yeah, we have a sort of rental library behind us in this room that I've rented, and one of the books sitting over there, The Power Broker, does an amazing job of end-of-chapter cliffhangers. Uh, that's, I think, Robert Caro over there.
Andrew Roberts 9:35 And he managed to make, you know, um, urban development, essentially that book's about urban development, isn't it?
Tim Ferriss 9:41 100%.
Andrew Roberts 9:41 And he managed to make that interesting. But you've got a few other ones. You've got a great friend of mine there, Niall Ferguson, writing about, you know, his book, Colossus. You've got, you've got some pretty interesting people, a few people that I've-
Tim Ferriss 9:54 Oh, yeah.
Andrew Roberts 9:55 -met. You might have rented it, but it's a pretty good, um, bunch of, of books.
Tim Ferriss 9:57 It worked out.
Andrew Roberts 9:58 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 9:59 And it's also quite surreal that Niall is featured here since he, he is, I'd say, partially responsible for us meeting in the first place.
Andrew Roberts 10:08 Yeah, he told me definitely to go on your show. He said loads of people, uh, watch it, and you've got a good sense of humor. And we'll see.
Tim Ferriss 10:13 We'll see about the sense of humor.
Andrew Roberts 10:14 We'll see later. We'll see later whether or not that's, that's true.
Tim Ferriss 10:15 Yeah, the jury is out. The jury is out.
Andrew Roberts 10:17 [laughs]
Words Andrew avoids when writing about history.
Tim Ferriss 10:18 I found in writing history, and I'm paraphrasing here, but I believe you've said before that you're cautious around the words perhaps, maybe, possibly, especially probably.
Andrew Roberts 10:30 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 10:30 Could you explain why?
Andrew Roberts 10:32 Don't use them. They're cheat words. What they're saying to the reader is, "I haven't worked hard enough on this. I don't know. I'm, I'm going to just come up with some kind of theory here, and, you know, bear with me." You shouldn't do that. The, the, the person-- if the person's paid 40 dollars for your book, he or she is going to want to think you know, you know what you're talking about.
Tim Ferriss 10:54 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 10:55 So if something is a great story, and you're not sure it's true, but nonetheless, it's just, it's funny or it's, or it shines a light onto personality, or for some reason, there's a great reason why you need to put it in the book, there are loads of ways that you can, you can hint to the reader. You know, you can say, "It is said that," or, "The story is told that," or, you know, "Anecdotally, people stated that." You know, and, and that's the signal to the reader, this is probably not true at all, but nonetheless-
Tim Ferriss 11:28 Someone's hedging their bets.
Andrew Roberts 11:28 It's, yeah, but it's too good to, to leave out.
Tim Ferriss 11:31 [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 11:31 But perhaps, probably, and maybe, and so on, there you really are hedging your bets. And, and I, I think it breaks the bond of trust that you need to have with your reader.
Are steady-nerved leaders naturally born or nurtured?
Tim Ferriss 11:43 Would you mind speaking to the importance of steady nerves or self-control in crisis? It seems that that's something that recurs. And the reason I'm asking about it is, this would be, I suppose, a sub-question, how much of it do you think is nature versus nurture also? But feel free to take that in any direction you'd like.
Andrew Roberts 12:07 Both Napoleon and Churchill were educated in war. You know, they both went to military colleges. So as their level of command grew, as they grew older, the- Sense of responsibilities they had, the number of men essentially that they were controlling-
Tim Ferriss 12:25 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 12:25 -increased exponentially. So they had the intellectual background, they had the training as well, and as young men in both cases, they thought a lot about, about war, about Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great and, and so on. They had a egotism, to look at it in the negative way, but a self-confidence, to look at it in a positive way, that gave them the ability to take these, these shatteringly important decisions. And so I think it's much more nurture than, than nature.
Tim Ferriss 13:04 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 13:04 In both cases, as far as they were concerned, there was a sort of holy fire that they both had. There was a-- not holy in a, in a religious sense, obviously, because neither of them were at all religious, but in a sort of deeper spiritual sense, a belief that what they were doing was so good and right and proper and had to be done, that they were not kept up awake at night-
Tim Ferriss 13:31 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 13:31 -over even the, the death of friends.
Tim Ferriss 13:33 Hmm.
Andrew Roberts 13:34 Death of friends that they were responsible for.
Tim Ferriss 13:36 They were responsible
The thinkers who influenced Winston Churchill and his sense of noblesse oblige.
Tim Ferriss 13:37 for. In the cases of Churchill and Napoleon, we could bring up other names, or I suppose using the royal we here, you could bring up other names. Were there particular philosophers or writers that they found particularly instructive, who they leaned on in some sense, that they found solace in? Were there particular minds?
Andrew Roberts 13:57 Well, certainly Churchill. Churchill did because he was a huge reader. He was a massive autodidact. He never went to university, and so therefore, when he was a young subaltern in India in his early 20s, he, he sat down and, and read the greats, philosophers as well as writers, and he was particularly influenced by Gibbon and Macaulay, the two great 19th century historians, English historians. And that affected his, his writing style, and of course, later his oratorical style, but also his outlook on, on life, philosophical outlook on life. With regard to Napoleon, he was even more literary really, because he also wrote short stories and, and books and, and so on. And so he was very much affected by what he read again as a young man. And in both cases, it slightly-- they were reading so much that it slightly cut them off from their contemporaries. Uh, Napoleon, you know, didn't have many friends when he was in his early 20s. And Churchill, when the other people were off sleeping in the, in the midday heat of India, his colleagues and comrades, he'd be sitting there reading, you know, Chopin now and Gibbon and Macaulay and so on.
Tim Ferriss 15:25 How did Gibbon and Macaulay inform his philosophical leanings?
Andrew Roberts 15:29 They made him into what was called at the time a Whig. We don't have them today, obviously. They were sort of, in, in modern sense, I suppose, liberal conservatives who believed in noblesse oblige, in the importance of-
Tim Ferriss 15:45 What is that? I'm sorry.
Andrew Roberts 15:46 No-noblesse oblige. It's a almost a medieval concept where your duty, if you have privilege, is to work for the greater good of the community, to protect widows and orphans, to... It's sort of like the knightly chivalric-
Tim Ferriss 16:04 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 16:04 -concept that you get from the Middle Ages. And they very much believed in that, and so did, so did Churchill.
What made Napoleon Bonaparte the prime exemplar of war leadership?
Tim Ferriss 16:13 Let me ask about Napoleon. So I know shockingly little about Napoleon, I'm embarrassed to admit, and I do want to ask more about Churchill as well. But you've described him as the prime exemplar of war leadership. Why do you say that?
Andrew Roberts 16:26 There are lots of military leaders who can do a lot of things.
Tim Ferriss 16:29 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 16:30 But he was the only one that I can think of who could do all of them.
Tim Ferriss 16:35 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 16:35 Of course, it helps if you're winning. In the last three years of his military career, he was losing. But even when he had far fewer troops, when he was retreating, when he was defending Paris in the 1814 campaign, for example, he was still able to win five victories in seven days, uh, in the 1814 campaign. That's two years after the retreat from Moscow. It's quite extraordinary capacity. And he was able to win whether he was advancing or retreating, whether he was defending a town or attacking it, whether he was attacking on the right or left flank, or sometimes straight through the center, as at Austerlitz. He had a-- he had that capacity, that, that mind for military conquest, but also, of course, the greatness that was required completely to revolutionize French society. People think that the French Revolution revolutionized society, you know, the clue is in the name, as it were.
Tim Ferriss 17:32 [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 17:33 But in fact, the long-lasting things that ultim-- that actually dragged France into the 19th, um, century were things like the Code Napoleon, which were not a revolutionary concept. They were a Napoleonic concept.
Tim Ferriss 17:49 Hmm. This may seem like a lazy question, but since, since I'm operating from a deficit here with respect to knowledge of Napoleon, what do you think it was that allowed him to be a decathlete of war, as it were, being good at all of these different facets? And I think of how we might analyze different athletes and what allows them to exercise the capabilities we see.
Andrew Roberts 18:13 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 18:14 Um, sort of breaking it down into its component parts. But how would you describe what enabled him to do that where others were unable?
Andrew Roberts 18:22 It was inspiration, but also perspiration. He really did put in the time-
Tim Ferriss 18:26 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 18:26 -thinking about it. And reading about it. By it, I mean, I mean warfare.
Tim Ferriss 18:32 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 18:33 And of course, he'd been educated in it. He read the key books. There's a guy called the Comte de Guibert, who in 1772 wrote a, a book about strategy and tactics. And he, 30 years later, put these into operation. And so he was able to spot the sort of best of the best when it came to modern thinking and to, or in this case, 30-year-old thinking, in fact. That didn't matter because the weapons of war hadn't changed in, in the intervening period. And he was able to put those thoughts and ideas into, into practical use.
Tim Ferriss 19:16 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 19:16 Classic example being the corps system. And when he-
Tim Ferriss 19:20 What was it called?
Andrew Roberts 19:20 It's called the corps system. It's-
Tim Ferriss 19:22 C-O-R-E.
Andrew Roberts 19:23 C-O-R-P-S.
Tim Ferriss 19:24 Oh, there you go.
Andrew Roberts 19:25 Um, and what he did was to create mini armies essentially, which were able to march separately but converge and concentrate for the battle.
Tim Ferriss 19:36 Hmm.
Andrew Roberts 19:37 And so one of your corps would engage the enemy, and then he would use the other corps to outmaneuver and envelop the enemy, sometimes double envelop the enemy. It was a, it was a brilliant concept. And actually, the allies didn't start beating Napoleon until they had also adopted the corps system.
Tim Ferriss 19:58 Ah.
Andrew Roberts 19:58 And so he was always at the cutting edge of thinking of the new concepts. And, but at the same time, he had very old-fashioned views about how to excite the men. I mean, victory obviously is the, is the best thing when it comes to exciting-
Tim Ferriss 20:15 [laughs] Incredible.
Andrew Roberts 20:16 Exactly. No, nothing much works better than that. But as I say, he was still winning at the end of his career. But he had this, this belief that to appeal to the soul was the way to electrify the men. And so he was able to do that. And some people who he was against, the Duke of Wellington, the British general being the classic example, who won the Battle of Waterloo against him, wasn't interested in electrifying the soul of the, of the men at all. He, he rather despised his ordinary soldiers. But nonetheless-
Tim Ferriss 20:50 You're talking about Wellington or Bonaparte?
Andrew Roberts 20:51 The Duke of Wellington, he had some sort of choice negative remarks about his, uh, about his own soldiers. And he was a, a rather sort of stuffy aristocrat. But, but they loved him because he cared about how many of them died in, in battle, you know.
Tim Ferriss 21:09 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 21:09 And he never lost a battle as well, which is a very useful thing in a commander, needless to say. But he didn't try. He didn't go out. He, he would think it beneath him to go out and try to inspire the men.
Tim Ferriss 21:20 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 21:21 Whereas Napoleon, his choice of hat and his gray coat and his way of taking off medal, his own medals and giving them to soldiers on the battlefield, and his orders of the day, his proclamations. Before the Battle of the Pyramids in 1799, he said, "40 centuries look down upon you." And this is an extraordinary thing for a, for a soldier, you know, in Egypt, far away from home. He looks up at the pyramids and thinks, "Oh, yeah, I'm..." He's placing the events of that day in the long historical parabola. And Churchill did that too, by the way, of course, to a great degree. You, in about 10% of all of the speeches that Churchill gave in 1940, there's some reference to history or the past.
Tim Ferriss 22:05 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 22:05 He too would summon up the idea that, yes, Britain is on its own, Britain and the British Commonwealth are on their own. This, of course, was in the period before America and Russia are in the war. But we, we've been in terrible straits before. Look at Sir Francis Drake, look at Admiral Nelson, and so on. And, and we came through those and, and won. He also brought up the First World War a lot. And so he too drew on history. And people knew that because he'd written history books and written biographies, including the biography of his great ancestor, the first Duke of Marlborough, who was with Wellington, the best soldier that Britain ever produced, people trusted his, his view of history.
Lessons from Winston Churchill’s autobiography, My Early Life.
Tim Ferriss 22:50 Hmm. Instead of biographies, I'd like to ask about autobiography. So I, it's my impression that you recommend that young people read My Early Life.
Andrew Roberts 22:58 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 22:59 And that there are life lessons contained within it that perhaps might help young people. What, what types of good advice or life lessons can people expect to find in that book? Or is there, does anything stand out to you?
Andrew Roberts 23:18 Resilience is the, the classic one. Although he doesn't go in this book-
Tim Ferriss 23:24 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 23:24 -into criticizing his parents, even between the lines, Churchill was tremendously resilient because his father despised him and his mother ignored him, essentially. But in the actual book itself, he talks about how wonderful it is to, to be young, 20 to 25, those are the years. He says people will forgive you for mistakes you make in that period. It's not until you're 30 that, that people judge you on what you've achieved rather than your promise. And he writes about his escape from prison, for example, which, let's face it, there is no young man or woman who hasn't at some stage dreamt about the idea [laughs] of a successful prison escape. He took part in the last great cavalry charge of the British Empire, and so he, he writes about what it's like to charge in with lances. He himself had a pistol in a great cavalry charge. It's just the most exciting book, and it makes you, it draws you along with, with life lessons that are very good, I think, even for today, at a time when you're frankly unlikely to have to escape from prison or go take part in a cavalry charge. [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 24:36 Or he'll just be very unsuccessful at attempting to escape prison. [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 24:39 [laughs]
Napoleon’s relationship with risk.
Tim Ferriss 24:41 Modern lockdown. I can't let this go. It's sticking in my mind. The core strategy, I'm not sure strategy is the right modifier for that, but that Napoleon used, it seems like that was waiting to be used.
Andrew Roberts 24:52 But it took him to be in the position, of course, of Emperor of France, whereby he could impose it. But equally, there are other things like the Code Napoleon that's-
Tim Ferriss 25:01 Mm-hmm
Andrew Roberts 25:01 ... not really waiting to be used. He had to sort of work them up into a, into a body of laws that completely revolutionized, uh, France.
Tim Ferriss 25:10 Now, when he took the writing from 30 years prior and applied it, is, is it the position that enabled him to do it, or did he think about risk differently than other people, and that is part of what allowed him to implement it?
Andrew Roberts 25:28 He'd taken huge risks. He was 26 years old, and according to the, the Churchill view of life, you know, you can take risks when you're 26, uh, years old because, because people will forgive you. Actually, the French Revolution government would not have forgiven-
Tim Ferriss 25:43 Yeah
Andrew Roberts 25:43 ... Napoleon if he'd lost the Army of Italy in 1796. But nonetheless, he was, he was a, a huge risk-taker. He would attack when normal generals would have fallen back. He was very lucky in that he was fighting, he was 26, he was fighting generals who were Austrian generals who were in their 70s.
Tim Ferriss 26:03 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 26:04 And he used to hit the hinge of enemy forces. If you have, in an Austrian-Sardinian army, for example, he would hit the point between the Austrians and the Sardinians, pushing them both back along their own supply lines-
Tim Ferriss 26:19 Mm-hmm
Andrew Roberts 26:19 ... and so on. He used psychology a great deal, trying to get into the minds of the generals he was opposed to. He was a great chooser of, of, uh, lieutenants, of divisional commanders and people who he felt he could trust. Superb sense of timing as well in a, in a battle. He was, as I say, the sort of exemplar of so many of the leadership tropes.
Tim Ferriss 26:44 Do you think he would have viewed his decisions from the outside that look risky as risky? If someone takes sort of calculated risks over and over again, then you could call them reckless. But at least at face value, that's not maybe the adjective I would use. So I'm just-
Andrew Roberts 27:00 If they came off, this is the thing.
Tim Ferriss 27:01 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 27:01 In the Italian campaign, this first great campaign of his, he hardly lost a battle. He fought, fought, you know, 20, and, and sort of won 19 of them. So if you do that, even though you have taken risks, it's, it's a sort of force multiplier in a sense.
Tim Ferriss 27:19 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 27:19 You know, you wind up thinking that, that they aren't as risky. He did believe in luck, which is very important. You know, he famously said that he wanted his marshals to be lucky, and he would, and he would promote people if he thought they were lucky. And that, of course, is a, I mean, it's run, runs against everything that we 21st century rationalists can possibly believe in. But, you know, it, it worked for him.
Tim Ferriss 27:43 Yeah, seems to have worked.
Andrew Roberts 27:44 Until it didn't.
Tim Ferriss 27:45 Until it doesn't.
Andrew Roberts 27:46 The decision in 1812 to march on Moscow was hugely risky, and of course,
Andrew’s signed letter from Aldous Huxley.
Andrew Roberts 27:52 it didn't pay off.
Tim Ferriss 27:53 Is it true that you have a signed letter from Aldous Huxley?
Andrew Roberts 27:57 I do.
Tim Ferriss 27:57 All right. Now, Aldous Huxley, I believe-
Andrew Roberts 28:00 Aldous, as we English people-
Tim Ferriss 28:01 Aldous.
Andrew Roberts 28:01 [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 28:02 God, you know, I've realized the longer I spend in England, I really need to, I think I should take TOEFL classes, Test of English as a Foreign Language.
Andrew Roberts 28:08 [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 28:09 Need to brush up on the mother tongue, as it were. He died, if I'm not wrong, the year you were born. I think it was. Why do you have that letter, and what does the letter say?
Andrew Roberts 28:20 The letter actually was written from Los Angeles, where he was living in the 1950s. It was in 1959. And somebody just wrote to him asking for his autograph.
Tim Ferriss 28:32 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 28:33 And, and obviously also asked, I don't have the letter from the autograph hunter, but he obviously asked for some sort of deep, meaningful thought. The deep and meaningful thought that Huxley gave him, and I'm a huge admirer of Huxley, Eyeless in Gaza and, and obviously, uh, Brave New World and so on, are, are wonderful works, and so are his very minor, minor books as well. And he said in this letter that, "Men do not learn much from the lessons of history, is one of the most important of all the lessons that history has to teach us."
Tim Ferriss 29:09 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 29:09 And that is so true, isn't it? [laughs] There's not a book that I've written, I've written 20, 20 books, there's not a book that I've written when I haven't looked across at that framed letter in my study and thought, "Wow, that is just so perceptive."
When historical figures carry a sense of personal destiny.
Tim Ferriss 29:22 [laughs] Question about the subtitle of your biography on Churchill, which I believe is Walking with Destiny. You mentioned this holy fire, I think is the term you used earlier, but do many of the leaders you've studied have this belief, and I may not be wording this the best way, but of being chosen by destiny in some fashion?
Andrew Roberts 29:45 The phrase comes from his remark in the last chapter of, last few pages of his war memoirs, the first volume of his war memoirs, The Gathering Storm, wonderful book. And he's referring to the day that he became prime minister, the day he was appointed by the king as prime minister, which happened to be coincidentally, as it turned out, because Hitler didn't know he was going to become prime minister, on the same day that Hitler invaded in the West.
Tim Ferriss 30:16 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 30:16 Invaded Belgium and Luxembourg and Holland, shortly afterwards, of course, to invade France. And he said, "I felt as if I were walking with destiny and that all my past life had been but a preparation for this hour and for this trial." And he had a profound sense of, of personal destiny. Now, you and I might think- Again, as, as 21st rationalist, 21st century rationalists, that this is a bit sort of mad to think that you're preordained to save, in this case, Britain and civilization. If you said that to me, that that was your belief about yourself, I would think that you were clinically insane. But enough things had happened to Churchill in his life, he had had so many close brushes with death, that it's not insane to think that. But it's not by any means just... And, and Napoleon also felt that he had a star to guide him, and he had the luck that we spoke about earlier. But that luck, who was a woman in his case, was somebody he needed to woo and to try to seduce. And of course, in 1812, she turns her back on him, and, and he speaks of her in that sense.
Tim Ferriss 31:32 Really?
Andrew Roberts 31:32 Which is also a pretty, you know, insane way to look at, uh, to look at life, isn't it? But they were both, as I mentioned earlier, devotees of, of the ancients, of Caesar and Alexander the Great, both of whom also, of course, had this driving sense of personal destiny. And so it does exist in people.
The meeting Andrew wishes he could have witnessed as a fly on the wall.
Tim Ferriss 31:54 If you could, I'll give you two options, stand in, meaning take the place of one of the people you've studied in depth, or just simply witness them in a given moment or day or period in their lives, what might you choose?
Andrew Roberts 32:11 Well, first of all, I wouldn't want to stand in their place at all. I know that I don't have the intestinal fortitude of these extraordinary people. But it would be, would it be the day that I just mentioned? It would be the 10th of, of May 1940, the day that Hitler's invading. The cabinet meets and recognizes that Neville Chamberlain is not the man to continue on the, the war now that it's turned to the west. And the meetings that took place the previous day and that day that whereby, uh, Neville Chamberlain goes to the king and suggests Churchill. And the king wasn't terribly excited about Churchill either because they'd fallen out over the abdication crisis, and he thought Churchill was a bit of a loose cannon. But nonetheless, he's willing to call Churchill. Churchill then goes to Buckingham Palace and becomes prime minister and comes back and starts to organize his government as the news is coming in of, of the German success and victories in the, on the western front. I mean, this is, what a day, what a day in history that, uh, must have been. So if I could be a, a, a fly on the wall any day in history, that's the day that I would, I would choose. Can we just go back though, um, to this concept of, of a sense of destiny? Because-
Tim Ferriss 33:35 Of course.
Andrew Roberts 33:35 Of course, it isn't just great men as in good men, positive forces in history that has this. Adolf Hitler also had a sense of destiny when he... Well, and providence and luck and being watched over by bigger forces and so on. When he survived his assassination attempt on the 20th of July 1944, when you remember Stauffenberg moves the briefcase with the bomb in it to a point in the table that just shreds Hitler's trousers when it goes off and doesn't kill him. He also put it down to providence that he had been allowed to survive and therefore to stay in charge, and, and the Fuhrer was going to save the fatherland and the, and the Reich. So it's not something... I don't want your viewers and listeners to come away thinking that it's a really good thing to think that, you know, you're being watched over by a more powerful force who's saving you to become the world-saving figure.
Tim Ferriss 34:34 Yeah, it can cut a lot of different ways. [laughs] You know, think of David, David Koresh and cult leaders and-
Andrew Roberts 34:39 Well, exactly, exactly that.
Tim Ferriss 34:41 Jim Jones down in Ghana or wherever he was.
Andrew Roberts 34:43 Precisely. All of these, all of these frauds and crooks and con men use it
When historical villains carry a sense of personal destiny.
Andrew Roberts 34:47 as well.
Tim Ferriss 34:47 Are there any particular weaknesses or pathologies or failures that come to mind in, say, Churchill and Napoleon or others who helped to make them ultimately great in the ways that they were great?
Andrew Roberts 35:02 Key thing is learning from mistakes, which not all politicians do, [laughs] I need scarcely point out, but Churchill certainly did. He made mistake after mistake. He got female suffrage wrong, the abdication crisis that I mentioned earlier. He joined the gold standard at the wrong time, at the wrong level. The Black and Tans in Ireland was a disaster. Primarily, of course, the Dardanelles crisis of 1915 to early 1916, where over 100,000 Allied troops were killed, wounded, or captured. I mean, this was a series of, of, of mistakes. In every single one of them, he learns from those mistakes.
Tim Ferriss 35:44 How did he do that? There's probably, I would think, maybe some method behind the madness. Maybe it's just more self-awareness or reflection, but did he have a process for learning?
Andrew Roberts 35:53 He wasn't hubristic. That was the key thing. He had... I think it probably helps also, of course, that he was in a democratic system like Napoleon or Hitler, whereby, you know, he was criticized the entire time in the House of Commons for all of those things. He had to defend them, and therefore had to, in a logical and rational point, democracy works very well at pricking the pomposity and hubris of people if it's, if it's working properly. And Napoleon also learned from mistakes in his military career. And I don't believe that the decision to march on Moscow itself was hubristic. I'm slightly aside from a lot of military historians about this. But, um, just to explain, he'd beaten the Russians twice before. He- Had an army twice the size of the, um, of the Russians. He knew perfectly well that the winter was going to come. He stayed too long in Moscow, but if he'd gone to Moscow and then come back again immediately, he would not have had the climactic disasters that overcame him with the blizzards in the October and November of 1812. And so you have this sense that, yes, it was a appalling strategic error, but it wasn't done out of a drive to the-- because he thought he was a sort of demigod. That, I think, is a misunderstanding of his personality.
What Churchill and Napoleon learned from their mistakes.
Tim Ferriss 37:18 Hmm. So I'm going to ask [laughing] something that Niall Ferguson of, of Colossus on the Shelf put in an email. "I would ask Andrew about the diary he keeps, which is a source of intense anxiety."
Andrew Roberts 37:31 He's obsessed with this.
Tim Ferriss 37:31 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 37:32 He is-- Okay, finish the, finish the rest of it.
Tim Ferriss 37:33 Yeah. "Which is a source of intense anxiety to all of his friends and even more to his enemies. Best wishes, Niall." [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 37:40 Yeah. Well, Niall, Niall doesn't care about any of that.
Tim Ferriss 37:42 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 37:42 He only cares about what I say about him.
Tim Ferriss 37:44 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 37:44 He's the-- He is the friend, he is the friend who is obsessed with the diary. Yes, I, I keep a diary. For God's sake, is, is it such a, is it such a crime? Um, you know. [laughing] He ne-- He talk-- We went on a skiing holiday this year, and it's all he talked about.
Tim Ferriss 38:01 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 38:01 He's obsessed. Um-
Tim Ferriss 38:03 Is it the forbidden fruit? I mean, what is-
Andrew Roberts 38:05 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 38:05 What is the story here?
Andrew Roberts 38:06 I think he's kicking himself that he didn't keep one. You know, you think of all these extraordinary people he meets, you know. Every, every time I see him, he's just been talking to President Xi or Bibi, um, Netanyahu or, you know, president of America, and he doesn't write down and keep it all in the diary. So I think there's an element of envy, uh, going on here, frankly. But I find it very relaxing and calming to think that my life isn't just going to be a complete waste of time. [laughing] And one of the only ways that I can-
Tim Ferriss 38:44 I can see that.
Andrew Roberts 38:44 Thank you. Well, that's kind of you. Thank you.
Tim Ferriss 38:46 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 38:46 Um, one of the only ways that I can, uh, I can justify this concept that it's all not just a sort of nihilistic sort of male-
Tim Ferriss 38:56 Boondoggle.
Andrew Roberts 38:56 [laughing] Boondoggle, exactly, is, is by writing books, obviously, which I hope will, um, survive me, but also noting down what I've, what I've done in the day. But Niall is convinced that every time he says anything embarrassing or something, I'm going to be noting-
Tim Ferriss 39:13 You're just loading the ammo into your diary.
Andrew Roberts 39:15 [laughing] Exactly. And that when we are sort of 80, he's going to, he's going to go to the bookshop, buy the diary, flick to Ferguson comma Niall, and see sort of, um, 40 entries, each of which is going to make his face go redder than the last.
Tim Ferriss 39:30 The following charges.
Andrew Roberts 39:31 Exactly. Which it's, it's not going to be like that at all. What he's actually going to do is to, uh, is to immediately go to the diary and look up Ferguson, Niall, but see all the amusing, charming, intelligent remarks he's made, the witticisms, you know, and all that kind of thing. And not just him, obviously, everybody that I've, I've ever met over the last 40 plus years. And-
Tim Ferriss 39:53 How do you keep your diary?
Andrew Roberts 39:54 So you're on, you're on your mettle now. You're going to have to, I'm going to say-
Tim Ferriss 39:57 I know.
Andrew Roberts 39:57 Went on Tim Ferriss's show.
Tim Ferriss 39:59 To be on, to be on best behavior.
Andrew Roberts 40:00 [laughing] Exactly. What a, what an idiot.
Tim Ferriss 40:02 Note, note to self, send chocolates to Andrew.
Andrew Roberts 40:07 [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 40:07 Don't forget his birthday. [laughing]
“Dear Diary…”
Tim Ferriss 40:11 Now, there are many, many people who keep a diary. How do you keep your diary? Is it a nightly exercise? Is it typed out?
Andrew Roberts 40:18 No, you mustn't do it nightly.
Tim Ferriss 40:19 Is it pen, is it quill pen?
Andrew Roberts 40:20 You mustn't do it nightly because... Or at least you, you might be able to, but I drink.
Tim Ferriss 40:26 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 40:26 And so, uh-
Tim Ferriss 40:28 I like drinking.
Andrew Roberts 40:28 Good, yeah. And so there's nothing worse than trying to write if you've been drinking. Also, writing down the witticisms, sometimes there's a bit of a problem owing to the fact that I can't read my writing the next morning. [laughing] Um, but, but no, it has to be done pretty much the next morning. You can't leave it for two weeks or so.
Tim Ferriss 40:48 What's your frequency?
Andrew Roberts 40:49 Every day.
Tim Ferriss 40:49 Every day.
Andrew Roberts 40:50 I used to write it... Oh, no. But if nothing interesting has happened, then I won't put anything down.
Tim Ferriss 40:55 Nothing to report.
Andrew Roberts 40:56 Yeah. No. [laughing] There's... Yes. Oh, like Louis XVI on the 14th of July, 1789, the day of the fall of the Bastille, all he writes is, "Rien." Nothing. [laughing] So I hope I'm not going to be quite as moronic as that. It's not really intended for publication, which is another thing that Niall doesn't understand.
Tim Ferriss 41:14 He's going to latch onto that really part of that sentence.
Andrew Roberts 41:18 [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 41:18 He's going to be like, "You see? You see?"
Andrew Roberts 41:20 Yeah. Yeah. No, of course he is. But, um, [laughing] but nonetheless, I, I do find it... Well, you mentioned earlier about how many words I write. It's never more than about 500 words maximum, and it picks the most interesting parts of the day. And if somebody has said or done something interesting, I'll, I'll stick it in.
Tim Ferriss 41:42 Do you do that before your book writing? Let's say you're on-
Andrew Roberts 41:45 Yes, yes.
Tim Ferriss 41:46 You do.
Andrew Roberts 41:46 First thing in the morning.
Tim Ferriss 41:47 All right. And is that just like pajamas, slippers, and a cup of coffee or?
Andrew Roberts 41:50 Yeah, precisely that.
Tim Ferriss 41:51 Yeah. All right,
Maintaining creative flow during the writing process.
Tim Ferriss 41:52 great.
Andrew Roberts 41:52 Exactly.
Tim Ferriss 41:53 Seems like such a ridiculous question, but how do you think about taking breaks when you're writing? I mean, obviously you might have a bathroom break or something like that.
Andrew Roberts 42:00 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 42:00 But do you build in breaks? Do you ride the flow as long as you have it? What does it look like?
Andrew Roberts 42:04 The flow as long as you have it. Absolutely. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because it, because it might not come back-
Tim Ferriss 42:08 Mm-hmm
Andrew Roberts 42:08 ... if you deliberately have breaks. Sometimes, and I'm slightly loath to, uh, admit this in public, but, um, nonetheless, sometimes if you are really flowing, I don't... I can go without, you know, washing for three days.
Tim Ferriss 42:24 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 42:24 I can be in my dressing gown and, and slippers. My wife finds it extremely unhygienic, and I'm not allowed to sleep in the same bed. But if I'm running, you know, hard at a really difficult chapter, and I need to keep my thoughts in order, I will not waste time doing anything. I'll, I'll get some breakfast and so on, but that will just be a dash to the kitchen and back again. Because you've got to get... If something's complicated- And there are lots of occasions, another classic is when we go back to the 10th of May 1940, that in my Churchill book, you have to get it right because every minute, not just every hour, every minute something is happening. They're getting news from what, what the Luftwaffe is attacking, and he's then having to create his government. He then goes off to the House of Commons and so on. You know, it's just, it's just relentless. And unless you encapsulate in your mind successfully what is important about that day, you'll never get it over to the reader. And if you're constantly going off and going for a walk or going to the gym or showering or whatever, there's a danger that you're going to fall out of the rhythm of, of creativity.
Tim Ferriss 43:34 How do you think about that flow when you have the flow? I mean, there is-
Andrew Roberts 43:38 I hasten to add, it's never more than three days I've ever gone without a shower. [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 43:41 I wouldn't judge. I, I was just on a hiking trip.
Andrew Roberts 43:44 I promise.
Tim Ferriss 43:44 I went, I went 10 days without showering, so I don't judge. I won't throw stones in my glass house.
Andrew Roberts 43:49 And it's only when I'm writing [laughing] the book, I hasten to add that as well. God. I don't want people to come up and, you know, at parties, hold their nose and go, "Hello, Andrew." [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 44:00 How do you think about that flow with writing? So there's one reason not to interrupt the writing. If you have a hard task ahead of you, and you have 47 balls in the air, and if you drop them, you're going to have to start the juggling process all over again. The boot-up sequence takes a long time. How do you think about the, the flow of writing or that feeling that things are coming to you more easily or moving onto the page more easily?
Andrew Roberts 44:29 Sometimes it's a very bad thing. Of course, uh, Dr. Johnson did say, "When you have written your most brilliant purple paragraph, read it again and rip it up." [laughing] So, you know, you must-
Tim Ferriss 44:41 Tell me more about that.
Andrew Roberts 44:42 Oh, yeah. No. Well, if you think that you've just written something completely brilliant, there's a very good chance that it's rubbish. [laughing] And that it has to be somebody else. It has to be your publisher or so, some other person who can read it and have a completely objective eye, because there's a very good chance that you're hugging yourself with glee about something that actually you think sounds wonderful, but in fact is complete, is complete rot.
Tim Ferriss 45:05 That's going to be the name of my memoir, Hugging Yourself With Glee. Let me write that down.
Andrew Roberts 45:10 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 45:10 I'll give you your customary 5%. That's fine.
On working with brilliant publisher Stuart Proffitt (aka Professor Perfect).
Tim Ferriss 45:13 If you had to choose, uh, maybe you don't want to choose from your darlings here, but, uh, if this question has an answer, you don't even need to name them, but you keep a person in mind. If you had to choose one person to act as your proofreader for your work, to be that sanity check.
Andrew Roberts 45:28 Oh, he's called Stuart Proffitt. He's the most brilliant publisher in, in London. He's, he's known by everybody to be the most brilliant. He's also the most irritating-
Tim Ferriss 45:37 That makes sense to me
Andrew Roberts 45:37 ... pedant. Um, he... Oh my God. For my Napoleon book, he's going to listen to this, so I'm going to have to be as nice as possible. But, oh my, he's, he's Professor Perfect is my nickname for him.
Tim Ferriss 45:48 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 45:49 Because he's a total professorial figure. And for my Napoleon book, I remember a series of marginalia. Again, this is the thing where you think you've done something rather good, you know. And he writes, one of the things he wrote in the margin, "Are you sure this joke is funny?" [laughing] Nothing more crushing than, than to have that. He also wrote-
Tim Ferriss 46:12 Strikes me as very British also.
Andrew Roberts 46:13 [laughing] Exactly. Question mark, you know. And you, and you read it again, and you chortle to yourself. You go, "Yes, it is funny." And [laughing] damn it. Um, but, um, he wrote, there was, there were a whole series of them in the... Well, we were talking earlier about the 1796 campaign of Napoleon. He said, "How, how wide was the River Po in 1796?" There was another one, "Did Napoleon take Herodotus to, to Egypt?" You think, "Oh my God. Goddamn, I don't know. I'm going to have to find out." He's a genius, but also a very irritating person.
Tim Ferriss 46:51 Could you say more about what makes him so good? And I'll buy some time just by saying if I can't find a writer friend of mine, let's just say, or an editor who can proofread my work, I'll very often give, and I write particular type of thing, but I will give my chapter, let's just say, to a friend who's a really good lawyer. And part of the reason for that is that they're very good at trimming out excess.
Andrew Roberts 47:16 Mm-hmm.
Tim Ferriss 47:16 And if anything is ambiguous, they're-
Andrew Roberts 47:18 Or contradictory.
Tim Ferriss 47:19 Or contradictory.
Andrew Roberts 47:19 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 47:20 They're very good at surgically excising that. What makes this particular gentleman, what was his name again? Stuart?
Andrew Roberts 47:26 Stuart Proffitt.
Tim Ferriss 47:28 Great man. What makes Stuart so good at giving feedback? What-- How does-- Does he see things differently?
Andrew Roberts 47:35 He's a profoundly committed to history, and he, he loves history. And so he has a sort of higher purpose to try to, to flood the world with great history books, and which is, as far as I'm concerned, the greatest-
Tim Ferriss 47:52 That's beautiful
Andrew Roberts 47:53 ... purpose that you can have. I mean, it doesn't get better than that. He has a very logical brain. He's very good on syntax. So anything that doesn't sound right in a sentence, he will point out. Sometimes to a infuriating degree.
Tim Ferriss 48:09 Sound right from a poetic perspective?
Andrew Roberts 48:10 From a poetic perspective, yeah. If there's a rhythm that, that isn't right, or if something rhymes as well, sometimes you can use two words that have a rhyme in them, and he will cut that automatically because it just doesn't feel right.
Tim Ferriss 48:25 Sit well with his sensibilities.
Andrew Roberts 48:26 Precisely. And mine, I hasten to add, you know, because I, I, I very rarely actually disagree with him. I did on the joke, um, by the way. [laughing] And, and whenever anybody tells me that something, that that particular joke is funny, I, um-
Tim Ferriss 48:40 You forward it to him.
Andrew Roberts 48:40 I forward it to him. I ping the email straight on to, uh, to Stuart. Of course I do. I'd be mad not to, wouldn't I? [laughing] I mean, and he's been doing it for 40 years, so, and he's at the top of his trade, so you would expect him to be, to be really good. But boy, is he.
Tim Ferriss 48:56 So there's two examples you gave, the width of the river and Herodotus.
Andrew Roberts 48:59 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 49:00 Why did he ask those two?
Andrew Roberts 49:02 Because he is- Always trying to put himself into the mind of the reader and wondering what the reader would be thinking. And he thought, rightly or wrongly in this case, that the reader would be interested in the width of the river and, and whether or not Herodotus went with him. But I mean, there are loads more examples like that. You know, I will send him 100 pages, and he'll send me back 100 pages of, of questions and criticisms and, and, and remarks. And so I almost sometimes think that I ought to put his name on the, on the front cover of the, of the book. He phoned me up actually about the Napoleon book, and the original of Napoleon just had a huge N on it and lots of bees. And he said, he phoned me up and he said, "I'm going to... I've got this idea for the front cover of the book. Your name isn't going to be on it." [laughs] And he said, "And neither is Napoleon's." [laughs] And I thought, over the phone, I thought, "Okay, he's finally gone completely mad."
Tim Ferriss 49:59 Finally cracked.
Andrew Roberts 50:00 Yeah, exactly. [laughs] That's right. Poor man. How long can he stay in the, in his job if he's going to come up with ideas like-
Tim Ferriss 50:06 Oh, he can take it for a while.
Andrew Roberts 50:07 Yeah, that's right. Exactly. But it can't be long now, you know, before... And it turned out to be a totally brilliant concept because if you see a gigantic N with bees, you, you think of Napoleon.
Tim Ferriss 50:17 Bees as in... I'm such an idiot.
Andrew Roberts 50:20 Bees, as in-
Tim Ferriss 50:20 Bees, like honeybees.
Andrew Roberts 50:21 Honeybees, yeah. That, that was his symbol. It was Napoleon's symbol because they could sting, but they could also give honey, you know.
Tim Ferriss 50:27 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 50:27 That was the idea. And it just captured people's imagination and sold an awful lot of copies, which was really great. That sold half a million copies, that book now.
Tim Ferriss 50:35 That's incredible.
Andrew Roberts 50:35 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 50:36 That is incredible. Sounds like such a gift to have a steward. I need a steward.
Andrew Roberts 50:39 Yeah, everyone needs a steward.
Tim Ferriss 50:40 Everyone needs a steward.
Andrew Roberts 50:41 Don't take mine, but whatever you do.
Tim Ferriss 50:43 No, I don't, uh, I don't... I think, I think he might find, might spend his entire first month on just the syntax errors in my first chapter, so.
Andrew Roberts 50:53 You do want to strangle him, by the way, so. [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 50:56 It's the sign of a very good proofreader often.
Andrew Roberts 50:58 Yeah,
Why are some significant figures immortalized while others go the way of Ozymandias?
Andrew Roberts 50:59 yeah.
Tim Ferriss 50:59 Why do you think it is that some historical figures take on these mythic proportions, where some who have huge impacts seem to sort of fall into obscurity over time? Are there particular characteristics? Is it self-made in a sense, where people create that myth of themselves while they're still alive? How do you think about that?
Andrew Roberts 51:24 I haven't thought about that before. That's a really good question. There are some things that are very difficult to get over to people on the printed page. Charisma is one of them. Charm is another one. Uh, sexiness. These are things that we all know from our own lives matter enormously. If somebody's charismatic, charming, and sexy, you're going to want to be interested in them, follow them, you know, and so on, much more than somebody who isn't. And yet explaining how they are, any of those things, very famously hard to explain. And I think the same is true in, with historical characters. How can it be that this unprepossessing-looking American president who happens to, uh, with this strange beard but not mustache, who happens to be president at the time that the country is falling apart, manages to save the country through this terrible, see it through this terrible civil war, and then is assassinated right at the end of the civil war? I mean, the story is so extraordinary, isn't it?
Tim Ferriss 52:30 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 52:30 And yet to explain the charisma and charm, not sexiness, I don't think, you know, [laughs] in Lincoln's case, but I think many of your listeners-
Tim Ferriss 52:38 Who knows?
Andrew Roberts 52:38 -or readers might disagree with you nonetheless.
Tim Ferriss 52:40 Just imagining him popping up on a dating app.
Andrew Roberts 52:42 [laughs] Yeah. Like, do you swipe right or left for Abe Lincoln? Exactly.
Tim Ferriss 52:48 Might ride a fixed gear bike, make expensive cappuccinos. That's kind of the hipster look. Anyway, I digress.
Andrew Roberts 52:55 It is difficult to explain how some people just grab it, grab the headlines and others don't. I mean, of course, it does help to be a leader in a war. That's true of, of Lincoln and Churchill and Napoleon and so on. The chance of becoming a world historical figure if you are prime minister of Luxembourg in a time of peace is going to be much more difficult, of course. But yeah, there doesn't seem to be a, a hard and fast rule, does there?
Tim Ferriss 53:27 Hard and fast recipe that I can follow. [laughs] I'm just, I'm just kidding.
Andrew Roberts 53:32 Well, don't take us to war on the back of your wanting to be remembered.
Tim Ferriss 53:35 No, no. I don't think I'm capable. Certainly not eager. Makes me think of, oh, what is the title of that poem? Ozymandias. "Look upon my works and despair." Uh, I'll leave that alone.
Andrew Roberts 53:47 "I met a traveler from an antique land who said, 'Two vast and trunkless legs of stone stand in the desert. And near them, on the sand, half shrunk, a shattered visage lies, whose wrinkled lip and sneer of cold command tells that its sculptor well those passions read which yet survive. My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings. Look upon my works, ye Mighty, and despair.' Nothing besides remains. Round that eternal wreck, long and bare, the lone and level sands stretch far away."
Tim Ferriss 54:17 Hot damn. There you go, listeners. [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 54:20 Can you point out to the listeners that you didn't tell me that this was going to happen?
Tim Ferriss 54:23 I did not. I did not send a memo in advance. And I suppose the preface to that is that there are these ruins sticking out of the sands. Am I getting-
Andrew Roberts 54:35 Well, the feet.
Tim Ferriss 54:36 The feet.
Andrew Roberts 54:36 Well, the trunks of-
Tim Ferriss 54:37 That's right.
Andrew Roberts 54:37 The trunks of the legs. So there was obviously a huge, magnificent kind of pyramid-high glorious statue to Ozymandias, and now there's nothing. And it, it goes back to what I was saying earlier about not being remembered.
Tim Ferriss 54:53 Who is the author of that, of that poem?
Andrew Roberts 54:55 Percy Bysshe Shelley.
Tim Ferriss 54:57 I saw the, maybe the original or a first, certainly a first draft in Oxford, because I was going through a program at Wadham College, and there's an exhibit on right now, which is something like- Cut, paste, rewrite, and it shows the hand-edited works of Mary Shelley, Frankenstein, and all these others, and I came across that.
Andrew Roberts 55:18 If anybody wants to see a first edition of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, it's just gone on exhibition at the, I was there this morning, the Lambeth Palace Library. There's a thing called Her Book. It's about early female writers. It's a brilliant exhibition. And so if there's anyone in London who's interested in seeing that book, it's, it's there today.
Tim Ferriss 55:42 Beautiful. And if you're near Oxford, Weston Library has the exhibit that I was mentioning. A lot of gems, a lot of gems. You have some really fun old stuff in the UK-
Andrew Roberts 55:52 [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 55:53 -it turns out.
Andrew Roberts 55:54 Thank you. I'm not going to take that personally.
Tim Ferriss 55:56 No, no, no, no.
Andrew Roberts 55:56 [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 55:57 That's a compliment. Yeah, old in the US is like 1970.
Andrew Roberts 56:01 I thought you were talking about me.
Tim Ferriss 56:02 Oh, no, no.
Andrew Roberts 56:02 Oh, is it? Good. All right. [laughs]
Thoughts on personal legacy.
Tim Ferriss 56:04 [laughs] Not you. How do you think about legacy? Because I, along the lines of Anya, the Ozymandias piece, I'm like, is it just sort of hubris to believe in the first place that that's something worth aspiring to, having something last and stand the test of time? I mean, how do you, how do you personally think about this? Especially as someone who studies history.
Andrew Roberts 56:27 I obviously do want people to read my books long after I've died. Now, I'm not going to know whether they are or not. So why on earth? It just seems so illogical to even think that, doesn't it? That it should matter to me that anything happens the second after I've, you know, died. But I know that I do, and it is one of the drives for being a writer, because words always live forever, and they're virtually the only thing that does. Ozymandias' statue is just two trunkless legs of stone, whereas actually his words, you know, uh-
Tim Ferriss 57:05 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 57:05 -uh, "Look upon my works, ye mighty, and despair," that goes to the heart of the human condition. And Shelley's poetry still survives in a way that Ozymandias' statue doesn't. So there is something about words that are immortal, and we're all sort of grasping for immortality in one way or another, aren't we?
Tim Ferriss 57:25 Yeah, it is true.
Fiction favorites.
Tim Ferriss 57:27 Do you read fiction?
Andrew Roberts 57:29 Yes, I do. When I go on holiday, which is us-usually hiking actually with my, my wife. She loves going to, to places that involve mountains.
Tim Ferriss 57:41 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 57:41 And in order to get history completely out of my system for the two weeks or so that we're hiking, I do read fiction. Sometimes if I want to completely clear my brain, I'll, I'll have a detective novel. And I've chosen the most complicated of all of the detective novelists, chap called Robert Goddard. Have you ever heard of Robert Goddard?
Tim Ferriss 58:03 I have not.
Andrew Roberts 58:04 So complicated to work out who done it or what groups of people done it. You know, it's very rarely just one person and why. And I try and make notes in the, in the back of the book connecting each person to everybody else.
Tim Ferriss 58:18 [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 58:18 And it-- So by the end of it, it looks like one of those really complicated sort of management, um, uh-
Tim Ferriss 58:24 [laughs] It's like an org chart.
Andrew Roberts 58:25 Yeah, exactly, exactly.
Tim Ferriss 58:27 [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 58:27 With hundreds of people to-- connecting to, to everybody else to try and work out who done it. And he always, always beats me. [laughs]
Tim Ferriss 58:34 [laughs] That sounds fun.
Andrew Roberts 58:37 But as far as sort of high culture novels concerned, I will occasionally do that. I'm president of the Cliveden Literary Festival, and so we have lots of novelists come to that. And so if you've got William Boyd or Salman Rushdie or somebody who you know you're going to be bumping into at the festival, it's always a good idea to read their latest novel. We had Robert Harris recently, and that's always well worth doing. And then there are a few writers like Michel Houellebecq, who is just so great that you have to sort of read whatever he brings out.
Tim Ferriss 59:12 I don't recognize the name, I'm embarrassed to say.
Andrew Roberts 59:14 He's a French, uh, he's a French writer. It's, it's pronounced Houellebecq.
Tim Ferriss 59:18 Houellebecq.
Andrew Roberts 59:18 He's a genius. Very controversial and, uh, quite unpopular in, in France. And he-- [laughs] the, the latest one I'm reading is-- where it features his, his own murder.
Tim Ferriss 59:30 [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 59:33 [laughs] It's a great satire. It's very, very funny.
Tim Ferriss 59:36 Is there a book you might suggest starting with, if I were going to start with one?
Andrew Roberts 59:39 Uh, The Map and the Territory.
Tim Ferriss 59:41 The Map of the Territory?
Andrew Roberts 59:42 The Map and the Territory of Michel Houellebecq. The name starts H-E-L-L-E.
Tim Ferriss 59:48 I'll find him.
Andrew Roberts 59:48 It's a sort of satire on French intellectual customs and-
Tim Ferriss 59:52 I can see them loving that.
Andrew Roberts 59:54 It's very funny.
Tim Ferriss 59:54 [laughs]
Andrew Roberts 59:55 It's very funny.
Tim Ferriss 59:55 Why is he controversial?
Andrew Roberts 59:56 Because he's deeply politically incorrect as well. He just doesn't care.
Tim Ferriss 1:00:00 Great.
Andrew Roberts 1:00:00 He just doesn't care what he, what he writes. He's a honey badger in that sense. Do you know what I mean?
Tim Ferriss 1:00:06 I do, I do, I do.
Andrew Roberts 1:00:08 Yeah, he, he's a, he's a literary honey badger, is Houellebecq.
Tim Ferriss 1:00:11 [laughs] Literary honey badger. All right, so, so speaking of politically incorrect,
Being objective about the history of imperialism.
Tim Ferriss 1:00:17 how should we, in your mind, write about imperial history?
Andrew Roberts 1:00:24 We should try as far as possible to be genuinely objective. We, we shouldn't take the assumption that all white people, whenever they went abroad, did so solely in order to, to rape, murder, massacre, and exploit. Because certainly in the latter part, we were talking earlier actually about, um, Winston Churchill and the noblesse oblige, the concept that it was part of your duty as a privileged person to, to try to make the world a better place for other less privileged people. And that was, especially in the latter part of the British Empire, a driving force for a lot of people, especially obviously missionaries and Christians, but also other people, explorers and- People who were involved in agriculture and, and so on. You know, they actually were not driven by, by rapacity and, and greed in the way that the, essentially the Marxist analysis of imperialism has made out.
Tim Ferriss 1:01:28 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 1:01:28 So be objective. Some of those people were like that, undoubtedly, of course they were. You know, especially some of the people in Southern Africa and, uh, and elsewhere. But for a long period of the story of the British Empire, for much of that empire, it actually was a force for human good rather than evil.
Tim Ferriss 1:01:48 Mm-hmm.
The challenges of teaching and learning history today.
Tim Ferriss 1:01:50 What do you see as the challenges moving forward for the capturing of history, and/or how do you see it changing as we, as we move forward?
Andrew Roberts 1:02:03 I am quite worried about it in Britain because first of all, fewer and fewer people seem to be taking it as a subject at a university level. Secondly, we have this, uh, thing, it's nicknamed Henry to Hitler, where we jump from the Tudors to the Second World War, and we don't do the very important intervening stages of the Stuarts, the Civil War, the Hanoverians, loss of America, really anything up to the outbreak of the First World War. And there's so much of really important history in that period that we seem to jump from one to the next. There was a survey quite recently of British teenagers, quite a big survey, you know, over a thousand of them, and 20% of them thought, I think it was like 23% of them, thought that the American War of Independence was won by Denzel Washington. [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 1:02:59 You know, and the Americans get a bad rap.
Andrew Roberts 1:03:01 Yeah, I know, I know, exactly.
Tim Ferriss 1:03:02 It's not just us.
Andrew Roberts 1:03:03 No. And also there were 20%, there were 20% of these kids, these are British school kids, who also thought that Winston Churchill was a fictional character and that Sherlock Holmes and, and Eleanor Rigby were real people. So whatever's going on in, in, you know, British history teaching, I think there's, there's still a lot to be desired.
Tim Ferriss 1:03:23 If you had never been able to write any books in that alternate reality, what have you personally or what would you have gained personally from studying history?
Andrew Roberts 1:03:35 Well, it's a, it's a lot of things, isn't it, history? It's, it can be a bit of a quicksand.
Tim Ferriss 1:03:40 In what sense?
Andrew Roberts 1:03:41 Well, as soon as you think you understand a period, all it takes is, is one new set of papers or, or a new book written by somebody else, a friend especially, that can make you look again at the same period and completely change your mind about it. And that's a little unnerving at the age of 61, I have to say.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:07 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:04:07 I'm just reading Ronald Hutton's second volume of his life of Oliver Cromwell, which has just been published. And I'd always thought of Cromwell as somebody who had a set of principles that he molded his times around in order to see through. And Ronald Hutton has completely exploded that thesis for me. And I realized that he was like most politicians, just sort of grabbing the, the coattails of history and hanging on as much as he could.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:40 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:04:41 And yes, he was a good soldier and so on, but he was, in terms of his, his politics, he was constantly trying to create, um, alliances, of course, like all politicians do. But when opportunities came, he grabbed them. But he was at the mercy of events much more than creating them.
Tim Ferriss 1:04:58 Mm-hmm.
Andrew Roberts 1:04:59 Whereas I had for years had the sort of image of Oliver Cromwell, like that statue outside, outside Parliament of this, this incredibly sort of solid figure.
Why “Study history” is Andrew’s coat of arms motto.
Andrew Roberts 1:05:09 He wasn't like that at all.
Tim Ferriss 1:05:10 What are other things that attract you or attracted you to history?
Andrew Roberts 1:05:16 It wasn't just Christopher Perry. My dad read history at Oxford, and he used to take me around, uh, castles. We'd go on holiday to, you know, Wales and see the great Edward I castles. And, and he would chat to-- on journeys, we'd chat about, about history and what-ifs, you know, the counterfactuals and things like that. And so I always-- I grew up feeling very comfortable with it and, and recognizing that it's a beautiful and fascinating thing. Whereas I think sometimes some people can be, not scared of history, but, but they can be put off history because they weren't taught it very well at school, or they just thought it was a succession of dates, or they can't see any relevance to their, their daily lives and so on. And I've never been one of those people.
Tim Ferriss 1:06:06 So if you were doing a presentation, could be anywhere, on why people, aside from conflating, you know, Denzel Washington with other historical figures, why they should read history or engage with history, what would the, the thrust of the presentation be?
Andrew Roberts 1:06:27 I suppose it does come back to that Aldous Huxley quote, you know, about, about trying to learn some of the lessons. There's a marvelous moment in June 1953 at the time of the late Queen's coronation. Winston Churchill is walking across Westminster Hall, this fabulous great hall that was, when it was built in the late 13th century, the largest room in Europe, and it's fused with history. It's, of course, where Churchill himself was to lie in state, but also where the monarchs lie in state, where Warren Hastings went on trial, and, and Charles I went on trial, and people like Mandela and Zelenskyy have given speeches and things like that. It's, it's compounded this, this-- Sir Thomas More went on trial there, uh, the Earl of Stratford. I just mentioned a whole load of people who were all decapitated, actually. [laughing] William Wallace as well, he was decapitated as well. And so you've got this, this sense of all of British history, you know, summed up in a room essentially. And a young American student stops Churchill and asks essentially for a piece of life advice. And Churchill replies, "Study history, study history, for therein lies all the secrets of statecraft." And that would be one of the reasons that I would tell people, you know, that, that if you want to understand what's going on in the world, you do have to look and see what, what has happened before. And there's no person who doesn't want to have a better understanding of what's going on in the world or try to, to work out for themselves the great, uh, forces in, in our planet today. So that, I suppose, would be the answer. That's why I've chosen study history as my, as my motto of my coat of arms, for example, and why I, I've got a podcast too, and I call it Secrets of Statecraft.
Tim Ferriss 1:08:14 Hmm.
Andrew Roberts 1:08:14 I think that's a, that's a sort of, um, motivating factor.
Tim Ferriss 1:08:18 Secrets of Statecraft. That is-
Andrew Roberts 1:08:21 It's the Hoover Institution's podcast, but it's great fun to do. Must have Niall Ferguson on at some stage, and, uh, I can, I can tease him about not keeping a diary. [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 1:08:33 What is statecraft? Just so I... I think I know, but I want to-- Very often, I, I think I know something, and it is in fact not true at all, so.
Andrew Roberts 1:08:42 It's the ability to, to run a country.
Tim Ferriss 1:08:46 To run a country.
Andrew Roberts 1:08:46 Yes. So you've got to juggle the diplomatic, the military, the economic, the cultural, all of these things, religious, all of these things together to create the kind of, of country that you want it to be. And that is statecraft. And so it's been going on as long as human history has and, and
What Andrew, as a history expert, sees for the future.
Andrew Roberts 1:09:07 always will.
Tim Ferriss 1:09:08 Looking forward, let's see, you've studied many great figures from history. You've looked at these different chapters of-
Andrew Roberts 1:09:17 Including your late king, your last king, George III. I wrote a biography of him, him a few years ago, which was, which was great fun to do. Yeah, sorry, carry on.
Tim Ferriss 1:09:27 Oh, no, that's all right. I was just going to ask you, looking forward, given how much you've reflected backwards, where do you think things are going for the UK and/or for the US? Like, if, if you were a betting man, and you say, "Hmm, there's a good chance, it's not a certainty, but the dominoes continue to fall the way they're falling, A, B, or C." Do you have any-
Andrew Roberts 1:09:49 I'm afraid I'm a bit of a pessimist.
Tim Ferriss 1:09:50 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 1:09:51 Um, yeah. Not so much for the United States because you're such a, still such a rich and innovative country. But I'm wondering in Britain whether or not, and history plays an important part of this, especially the way in which history is used politically, to wonder whether or not we still believe in ourselves, certainly in the way that we did when I was growing up. In 20... I'm going to try and get the statistics right. I think it's 2015, as recent as 2015, maybe it's 2010, 86% of people were proud of British history. That has now fallen down to 56%. And I'm sure that the reason for this is the sustained attack on, on, well, the British Empire that we were discussing earlier, and people forgetting the part that we played in the abolition of slavery and concentrating just on the, on the horrors and the, and the monstrous things that, uh, happened. And we are therefore... If you're not proud of your past, you're not proud of your ancestors, you're not proud of the things that they produced, and Britain has produced some pretty extraordinary and wonderful things for the world, then it's difficult to see why anyone would want to be proud of the future of the country as well. And so I'm pretty pes-pessimistic. And when I feel pessimism for America, it's for things like taking Thomas Jefferson's statue down from the New York City Hall. And it's a form of cultural suicide, it strikes me, not to admire the founders of your nation. And yes, of course, he owned slaves, but he also wrote a constitution that has survived for a quarter of a millennium. And, and, and he was brave enough, and Washington and all the, the others, brave enough to stand up against the most powerful empire in the world. Now, these things, you deserve your statue, it seems to me. And if you go around pulling these things down, I think you're breaking a kind of living link with the past that makes you a great country. And that's certainly happening in this country as well. And I, and I, I mean, I'm a bit of a pessimist anyway because I'm a Tory, and pessimism is an essential part of Toryism. Um, but not as big a pessimist, I hasten to add, as Niall Ferguson, who, [laughing] who I like to say, it's never terribly difficult to tell the... It's a quote from P.G. Wodehouse, "Never terribly difficult to tell the difference between a ray of sunshine and a Scotsman with a grievance." And, [laughing] and Niall always tells you that it's all doom and gloom, and everything's going to be utterly disastrous. I, I wonder, I wonder whether or not he, he truly believes it because he's actually himself a very upbeat and personally, uh, sort of positive individual who does lots of things that imply that actually he does think the world's going to get better. But boy, oh boy. [laughing]
Counteracting natural pessimism.
Tim Ferriss 1:13:00 How do you personally, if you do, I mean, it seems like you examine or you have a fascination with counterfactuals, the what ifs. You read books that have the potential for upending sort of long-held theses.
Andrew Roberts 1:13:15 Mm-hmm.
Tim Ferriss 1:13:16 Which can be uncomfortable, I would imagine.
Andrew Roberts 1:13:18 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 1:13:18 Do you have people around you or who you deliberately expose yourself to who offset perhaps some of your pessimistic tendencies with forms of optimism that they can defend?
Andrew Roberts 1:13:33 Yes, my wife.
Tim Ferriss 1:13:34 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 1:13:34 Is the, is the classic example. She's, she's optimistic about the future. She's in business. She's a very successful businesswoman, so she actually sees a lot of the things that are being innovations that are taking place, the drugs that are coming online that, you know, saving lives and taking on defeating pain and so on, you know. She's great at believing in the innate capacity of capitalism to reinvent itself in a positive way for more and more people and take people out of poverty and all of those positive things. So yes, I-- it's, it's an invigorating thing to talk about the, the world with her because it makes me much less sort of Eeyore-like and-
Tim Ferriss 1:14:15 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:14:16 [laughing] And Ferg-Fergusson-esque.
Tim Ferriss 1:14:19 [laughing] I feel like, I feel like any other inside scoop that, that people should know about Neil? What are, what are-
Andrew Roberts 1:14:28 No, no. [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 1:14:29 His, his secret optimistic voice memos that he sends you?
Andrew Roberts 1:14:32 [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 1:14:34 You can annotate, add to your diary, "Please see audio reference 47." [laughing]
What to expect from Andrew’s latest book Conflict (co-authored with David Petraeus).
Tim Ferriss 1:14:41 Oh, Andrew, this has been, been great fun. You have many books that, that people can, can read certainly, and they'll all be in the show notes. But the, is it most recent Conflict?
Andrew Roberts 1:14:53 That's a book I wrote with David Petraeus. And of course, him being a general who's commanded armies of over 160,000 in both Iraq and Afghanistan has been so fascinating intellectually for me because, of course, I've-- a military historian, I've never worn a uniform for, for one minute.
Tim Ferriss 1:15:12 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:15:12 So that was great.
Tim Ferriss 1:15:14 The subtitle for folks, just so they have that, The Evolution of Warfare from 1945 to Ukraine.
Andrew Roberts 1:15:19 Well, it's now actually Gaza. The paperback-
Tim Ferriss 1:15:21 Oh, it's Gaza.
Andrew Roberts 1:15:22 -takes us up to Gaza as well, about halfway through that campaign in, uh, in Gaza. And yeah, we-- it was after the Russian invasion of Ukraine that I came up with the idea of writing the book, and I got on to David, who I knew, and said, "Why don't we write this as a military history?" There are going to be lots of political histories about this, but, but just, you know, the, the military side of it, and, and put it into the context of all the wars that have happened since 1945. So we go through, not all of them, there are 400 of them, but all the key ones, you know, the 40 or so key ones that, um, that you'll have heard of and that show how war has evolved and developed, and sometimes it leaps forward, and other times it goes into, into sort of sideshows. But we went to the publishers, and, and they quite understandably said, "Well, how are you going to divvy up the chapters?" And I said, "Well, David's going to write about all the countries he's invaded." [laughing] "And I'll, and I'll, you know, fill in the rest." And he also did the Vietnam chapter as well, actually. And then we sent hundreds, maybe thousands of emails to one another, uh, over the course of the year or so that we were writing it.
Tim Ferriss 1:16:35 That's very fast.
Andrew Roberts 1:16:36 It is fast. It is fast. But the thing was-
Tim Ferriss 1:16:37 How did you do it so quickly?
Andrew Roberts 1:16:39 Well, because the situation in Ukraine was moving so, so quickly.
Tim Ferriss 1:16:42 Ah.
Andrew Roberts 1:16:42 And then the Gaza war broke out on the day of the publication of the hardback. And so that was literally the 7th of October that we were bringing that out. So we then needed to get on with, with writing about that as well. And as you know, I tend to write quickly.
Tim Ferriss 1:16:58 Yeah.
Andrew Roberts 1:16:58 And so does he. You know, he's a soldier scholar. He went to your old university. He was at Princeton doing a postgrad, uh, on military history. So he very much able to keep sending back those emails.
Tim Ferriss 1:17:11 Yeah. I suppose he's not, not lacking discipline, would... [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:17:15 Say that again.
Tim Ferriss 1:17:16 Would be my guess.
Andrew Roberts 1:17:17 Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 1:17:17 What did you find were key ingredients to that successful collaboration? What made it work, especially with that type of pressure under deadline?
Andrew Roberts 1:17:27 Well, I think there was-- I know there was a mutual respect, which is very important. I'd never written a book with anybody before, and, and I was-
Tim Ferriss 1:17:34 I'm in the midst of doing that right now, which is part of the reason I'm asking.
Andrew Roberts 1:17:36 Yeah. No. Well, it's, it's slightly nerve-wracking, isn't it? Because one can get very sort of proprietorial about, about one's work. But that wasn't the case with, with David because the insights that he gave about what it was like to be a commander into wars at the absolute apex of command meant that he could then look back on wars like the Korean War, the Vietnam War, Iraq 1, and other wars, to the Gulf War, to sort of place himself in the position of Matthew Ridgway, you know, in Korea, for example. And that was so fascinating that I knew that there was nothing that I could add to that. I just knew that the combination of, of the soldier and the historian would produce something that was really intellectually stimulating for me. And that's, you know, in the end, life is a constant battle against boredom, isn't it?
Tim Ferriss 1:18:35 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:18:35 It's a, it's a constant rear guard action against, um, against not being stimulated.
Tim Ferriss 1:18:42 Yeah.
Upcoming book projects.
Tim Ferriss 1:18:43 Do you think you will do more collaborations? How are you thinking about your writing moving forward?
Andrew Roberts 1:18:48 No, I know-- my next two books are just going to be written by me. I've got Napoleon and his marshals, about how the emperor interacted with his marshals and how the marshals interacted with each other. They fortunately all hated each other, so that's much easier for a historian to write something interesting.
Tim Ferriss 1:19:05 [laughing] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Andrew Roberts 1:19:05 And hated each other in very imaginative ways.
Tim Ferriss 1:19:08 The greatest reality TV show ever seen.
Andrew Roberts 1:19:10 [laughing] Yes, exactly. And then after that, I'm doing Disraeli, and he's an extraordinary character who was a complete outsider, as a Jew, of course, didn't go to one of the British public schools or Oxford and Cambridge or any university, and through his own brilliance, and he's a novelist, of course, also, his own wit, he wound up becoming the most powerful man in the world.
Tim Ferriss 1:19:37 Yeah, I look forward to reading that one.
Andrew Roberts 1:19:38 Good. Thank you.
Tim Ferriss 1:19:39 I do.
Andrew Roberts 1:19:39 Let me back on the show in 2030-
Tim Ferriss 1:19:41 [laughing]
Andrew Roberts 1:19:42 -which is when it's being published.
Tim Ferriss 1:19:44 I hope, hope I'll still be around. We'll see.
Andrew Roberts 1:19:46 [laughing]
Tim Ferriss 1:19:46 I'm going to have been here for a decade.
Parting thoughts.
Tim Ferriss 1:19:48 We'll see how it goes. Andrew, this has been great. I really appreciate you taking the time. People can find you. Correct me if I get any of this wrong. Andrew-roberts.net. Would that be the main website? That's what I have here.
Andrew Roberts 1:19:58 Can't remember, but yes, I hope so.
Tim Ferriss 1:20:00 Let's just say that's right, and if it's not, I will, I will put correct version in the show notes.
Andrew Roberts 1:20:04 [laughing] Yeah.
Tim Ferriss 1:20:05 Is Twitter or X, as it stands now, a good place for people to follow you as well?
Andrew Roberts 1:20:10 Yeah, that, uh, has things like my, my podcast and so on.
Tim Ferriss 1:20:14 Perfect. So that's, as I have it here, ARoberts_Andrew.
Andrew Roberts 1:20:18 Is it good?
Tim Ferriss 1:20:19 [laughing] Perfect. We'll fact check all of that. But we do have that. Is there anything else that you would like to add? Any requests of my audience? Anything at all that you'd like to mention?
Andrew Roberts 1:20:32 Just thank you so much, Tim, for being on the show. I've really enjoyed it.
Tim Ferriss 1:20:36 Yeah. Thank you so much for taking the time. This has really been great. And for people who are listening, as always, you can find the show notes at tim.blog/podcast. We will include links to everything we discussed. And also, as always, until next time, just be a little kinder than is necessary to others, but also to yourself. Thanks for tuning in.
Episode duration: 1:21:07
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode h0aGN_rdnMQ
