Skip to content

By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.

Uncapped with Jack AltmanUncapped with Jack Altman

David George on Growth Investing, AI, and Why the Power Law Is Stronger Than Ever | Ep. 58

David George is a General Partner at Andreessen Horowitz, where he leads the firm's growth fund. Before a16z, David was a General Partner at General Atlantic.

David GeorgeguestJack Altmanhost
Oct 1, 202653mWatch on YouTube

Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.

Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.

uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.

See how

Transcript

0:00 – 0:23

Intro

David George 0:00 If the premise of your question is, is this gonna be successful or that thing gonna be successful? The answer in AI is probably and.

Jack Altman 0:06 Yeah.

David George 0:06 Like, it's just the most exciting time, you know, to ever be an investor and in the technology markets. Mm.

Jack Altman 0:11 And keeping up with it is gonna be hard.

David George 0:12 Keeping up with it is gonna be hard. [upbeat music]

Jack Altman 0:17 All right, David, I'm really excited to do this. I've been, I've been really looking forward to this. So thanks for, thanks for coming by.

David George 0:22 Yeah. Great to hang with

0:23 – 1:27

The answer to every AI question is "and"

David George 0:23 you.

Jack Altman 0:23 So th- uh, one of the topics that's been on my mind a lot, um, that I think you've got really good thoughts on is something that my partner Eric Vischer said recently on, um, the Invest Like The Best podcast. And it was basically, he was like, "It's all gonna work." And it was in the context of, you know, people question, is it gonna be open source or frontier? And he's like, "The open source is gonna work. The frontier is gonna work." Is it gonna be Nvidia or is it gonna be new chips companies? And he's like, "There's gonna be both." And you can kinda like go on and on through, you know, the stack in AI. And Eric's point was basically, like, people are asking the wrong question of just like, is it this or it's that? He's like, "It's both." And I'm curious how you think about this at Andreessen and sort of in your seat.

David George 1:04 Yeah. Of course. So I am very, very closely aligned with Eric on this point that it's all gonna work. I, I actually like the way that he framed it up. I framed it up slightly differently, which is just like the answer to all this is and. And so, like, if you're answering-- if your, if your question, if the premise of your question is, you know, is this gonna be successful or that thing gonna be successful? The answer in AI is probably and. Um, I think it's helpful to start

1:27 – 4:55

Where we are in the AI buildout

David George 1:27 just like, where are we? So, um, right now, from an infrastructure buildout standpoint, we just surpassed the railroads.

Jack Altman 1:34 Right.

David George 1:34 As, as a percentage of GDP, which has been well covered.

Jack Altman 1:36 It's like 3% now or something like that.

David George 1:37 Yeah. Exactly.

Jack Altman 1:38 Yeah.

David George 1:38 And, um, you know, look, it's probably gonna get harder and harder to build data centers, which we could talk about later. But I think that's gonna 10X. So right now, like what's happening is basically-

Jack Altman 1:47 As a percentage of GDP, you think?

David George 1:48 I think it will t- no, I think hopefully that will drive GDP growth.

Jack Altman 1:51 In dollars.

David George 1:51 And this is gonna take many years. So it won't 10X in one year.

Jack Altman 1:53 Yeah, yeah.

David George 1:53 So it will be, you know, whatever, 30%.

Jack Altman 1:53 But we'll be spending many trillions.

David George 1:55 But we will spend many trillions, right? So like all of this success, which is the greatest, fastest success we've ever seen in business, which is basically OpenAI, Anthropic together, and then if you add in SpaceX AI. Now with Cursor, they're call it like 120 billion of revenue, and they add more revenue per month than all the hyperscalers, except for Amazon.

Jack Altman 2:13 That's crazy.

David George 2:13 Now, all of that is on the back of just actually a small amount of people paying for stuff. So it's like 30 million coders in the world who are the vast majority of the revenue. There's 1.5 billion knowledge workers.

Jack Altman 2:25 Yeah.

David George 2:25 But like basically all of this, which is like adding more-

Jack Altman 2:28 Yeah

David George 2:28 ... more revenue than the best businesses that have ever been created-

Jack Altman 2:31 Yeah, yeah, yeah

David George 2:31 ... is on the back of a small group of people.

Jack Altman 2:32 That's actually a really interesting point, that it's over a billion users of these things, and we think about it that way. But it's actually, you're saying it's 30 million are spending basically all the money.

David George 2:39 It's 30 million. So there's a billion consumer users. And by the way, we should talk about consumer because we're like nowhere in consumer right now.

Jack Altman 2:44 Yeah.

David George 2:44 Even though there's a billion users. But in the enterprise, basically the, the vast majority of the revenue is coming from just a small amount of coders.

Jack Altman 2:50 Yeah.

David George 2:50 And this is like in power law-

Jack Altman 2:51 How many are within that 30 million? I'm sure it's a power law.

David George 2:53 It's a massive power law.

Jack Altman 2:54 Yeah.

David George 2:54 Like we... I'm sure you've talked to your companies and, and, you know, a lot of this stuff.

Jack Altman 2:58 Yeah. The top million of the 30 are spending the biggest.

David George 2:58 The top, the top million of the 30 are spending just a massive amount. And so if you take an optimistic view of what that means, like the potential is so much greater than what has actually diffused into like everything beyond those million people.

Jack Altman 3:10 Yeah.

David George 3:10 And so again, there's one and a half billion knowledge workers, and we're just talking about B2B. And so, um, so it's just a massive amount that is gonna happen-

Jack Altman 3:18 Yeah

David George 3:18 ... in what I think is gonna be like the next five years.

Jack Altman 3:20 Yes.

David George 3:21 Um, right now, demand is totally insatiable, right? You know, in, in the enterprise, basically what's working, it's like coding, writing stuff. You're starting to see early signs in some, you know, functions beyond that.

Jack Altman 3:34 Yeah.

David George 3:34 Like legal is one where we've kind of seen this take off. I think it's like 12 months behind. But for broad knowledge work, for the one and a half billion knowledge workers in the world, we're like nowhere.

Jack Altman 3:42 Yeah.

David George 3:42 So if you just start with that as the premise, which is, um, you know, we're, we're already seeing like scale that's never been seen before and, you know, we're like scratching the surface in diffusion. It's like less, less than 5% diffused into the B2B economy. That means we're gonna get really, really big-

Jack Altman 3:58 Yeah

David George 3:59 ... if we're right about this sort of diffusing and, and being applicable broadly. So that's, so that's one piece. On the supply side, we are massively, massively constrained.

Jack Altman 4:08 Massively. Yeah.

David George 4:08 Like basically in everything in the supply chain.

Jack Altman 4:10 Yep.

David George 4:10 So basically, you know, you can't get data center capacity until 2028 because basically there's bottlenecks in every step of the supply chain. So that is where we are in the supply and demand. And I think it's important to lay that groundwork because it is like the crux of why I think everything is gonna work.

Jack Altman 4:25 Yes.

David George 4:25 Right? Like all of, all of the sta- all, all of the sort of like steps in the ladder are gonna work.

Jack Altman 4:30 Talking about the supply side for a second, so it's four gigawatts right now. Is your... Is, is sort of like your kinda view at the moment that if we had eight gigawatts live and online, it would all get used well?

David George 4:39 Yeah, it would get used. Yeah, I think it would all get used.

Jack Altman 4:40 It would all get used.

David George 4:41 Yeah, yeah, yeah. And look, maybe like it would be d- at different prices or something. Like we could talk about pricing of what's happening for tokens.

Jack Altman 4:46 Yes.

David George 4:47 Um, but yeah, I think, you know, if you, if you get like more OpenAI and Anthropic or SpaceX AI capacity live-

Jack Altman 4:54 Yeah. Yes

David George 4:54 ...

4:55 – 7:16

What would stop the token buildout

David George 4:55 it generally gets used.

Jack Altman 4:56 So I... So ju- just to sort of like check the premises along the way, and obviously, as you know, I fully agree with what you're saying.

David George 5:01 [chuckles]

Jack Altman 5:02 But, um, just to check it along the way, what would have to happen for it not to be the case that as gigawatts come online, all the tokens keep getting consumed? Is there any world where... Is there anything that could update our priors, you know, that four gigawatts becomes 20 and they don't all get used at the same or even higher prices?

David George 5:20 I think there's two forms where this could take hold. One is, um, like what happened with coding is anomalous relative to everything else in B2B or knowledge work. And because of the difficulty of injecting commerce from knowledge work from companies, like the rest of white collar work just doesn't really like have major impact. Like I think that is extremely unlikely. Um, I think it's sort of like a data collection problem-

Jack Altman 5:47 Yeah, it's too hard to do

David George 5:48 ... and like an application of the models problem. The other would be, you know, we do have teams that we've backed that are working on like algorithmic breakthroughs, right? And so, you know, perhaps you would get an algorithmic breakthrough where, you know, rather than having to consume-

Jack Altman 6:03 Oh, just efficiency goes way up

David George 6:03 ... you know, massive... Yeah, like efficiency goes way up-

Jack Altman 6:05 Yeah

David George 6:05 ... both in training and in, and in inference.

Jack Altman 6:07 Yeah.

David George 6:08 Um, I think that's unlikely. I think it's possible we could get breakthroughs in training. Like I don't know, you've probably seen the stats on what it took you and I to like build our knowledge base.

Jack Altman 6:17 Yeah.

David George 6:17 Like it's like, you know, whatever, two or three orders of magnitude less than what the models actually train on. Um, so there seems to be an opportunity there. You still will then have inference, which is an absolutely massive market that's gonna be much bigger than training anyways.

Jack Altman 6:29 Yeah.

David George 6:29 And so, you know, yeah, we could get efficiency gains in inference, but I think what we've learned so far is the more you reason at the model-

Jack Altman 6:36 Yeah

David George 6:36 ... like w- at the time of inference, the better the results get.

Jack Altman 6:39 Yeah.

David George 6:39 And so I think that'll continue to hold, um, in knowledge work broadly. So I, I struggle to find a way-

Jack Altman 6:45 Yeah

David George 6:45 ... for this, like, not to work. Now, if we went to, you know, from 5 to 100 in a quick amount of time-

Jack Altman 6:51 Sure

David George 6:52 ... and the products aren't built to actually, like, take that on, you know. Sure. But, like, we don't-- we're not gonna have that problem, because it's gonna be really hard to get this stuff online.

Jack Altman 6:59 I'm curious what you think about this. I mean, the, uh... So I also can't easily see it, but the best vector that I've heard was a conversation I had with a friend where we were basically saying, you know, all this stuff come, has come online. And so at first, you know, a few years ago, there was, like, the big build-out, and you saw, like, you know, s- we're putting hundreds of billions

7:16 – 10:39

Sellers vs. buyers of tokens

Jack Altman 7:16 in at the time. And then you get, you know, the models get a little bit better, and you start deploying them, and you kinda like keep moving through the pipeline. And now you see revenues growing like crazy on the back of AI. But the point in this conversation was most of the revenues that are, that we're talking about are sellers of tokens, not buyers of tokens. And so the next thing we kind of need to see is data around the buyers of tokens actually getting these huge efficiency gains. In other words, you know, a hyperscaler or-

David George 7:42 Yeah, like what's the ROI at the en- enterprise level?

Jack Altman 7:45 Yes.

David George 7:45 Like, you know, users, like, w- of writing all this more code.

Jack Altman 7:47 Yes.

David George 7:47 Like, is your bus- is, is your business getting better by writing all this more code?

Jack Altman 7:50 Yeah. Or said another way, it would be a bad outcome if the sellers of tokens were making lots of revenue and the buyers of tokens were not making lots of revenue-

David George 7:56 Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah

Jack Altman 7:56 ... but they were just buying lots of tokens.

David George 7:57 Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Look, I, I, I'm very optimistic about this point. Like, I think that whole argument is predicated on the fact that there won't actually be tangible, tangible productive use of, like, writing more code-

Jack Altman 8:06 Yeah

David George 8:06 ... far more efficiently that is better.

Jack Altman 8:09 Right.

David George 8:09 Like, I just think that's, like, fundamentally wrong. Um.

Jack Altman 8:11 Yeah, and I haven't, I haven't looked. I know like a year ago, there was a study, or it might even been a little more, but it's some- something like a year ago. There was a study that, like, in AI coding, it was, you know, actually you got 20% less effective by using AI code. But this was like before-

David George 8:24 This was before the big four five-

Jack Altman 8:25 Yeah

David George 8:26 ... AI breakthrough, right?

Jack Altman 8:26 And my, my guess is if you reran that study, you would not see that anymore.

David George 8:29 Yeah, and like the best coders in the world have, like, fully flipped over on this.

Jack Altman 8:32 Yeah.

David George 8:32 And, um, you know, if you talk to, like, the CEOs of the cutting edge companies, I think they would tell you that they feel much more productive.

Jack Altman 8:38 Yeah.

David George 8:38 Like, I, you know, spending time with Stripe, like, they feel like there's very high returns-

Jack Altman 8:42 Yeah

David George 8:42 ... to them being able to be a lot more efficient in writing code. Um, you know, like, is, like, Procter & Gamble getting big efficiency gains from what they're spending on AI today? Like, probably not yet.

Jack Altman 8:54 Yeah.

David George 8:54 But I think they will.

Jack Altman 8:55 Yeah.

David George 8:55 They probably need a lot of hand-holding. That's probably the answer.

Jack Altman 8:58 Yeah.

David George 8:58 Is, you know, I think the labs and, you know, Databricks and Palantir, companies like that are probably thinking about it the right way, where you have to do a lot of hand-holding to produce value, but you will produce a lot of value for those companies. Um, you know, and then there's companies like Stripe. Like I, I don't know, one of the things that we're thinking a lot about right now is, like, where is that effort actually going to? Is it going to, like, front-end building more products, or is it going to, like, back-end trying to make your business more efficient?

Jack Altman 9:23 Yeah.

David George 9:23 Um, and like the best companies in the world right now are-

Jack Altman 9:26 Front end

David George 9:26 ... singularly focused on front end.

Jack Altman 9:28 100%.

David George 9:28 Like, you can produce, um, you know, a 10X, 100X more revenue potentially if you nail the next product.

Jack Altman 9:35 Yes.

David George 9:35 Right? Whereas, like, on the cost side, like you can only get so much more efficient.

Jack Altman 9:39 Yeah.

David George 9:39 And that opportunity will kind of always be there. It's like latent.

Jack Altman 9:42 Yes.

David George 9:42 So it's like shorting your own future if you are just focused on the cost side.

Jack Altman 9:46 Yeah.

David George 9:46 Whereas, like, you're taking an expansive view of what you can become-

Jack Altman 9:49 Totally

David George 9:49 ... if you're focused on the front end side.

Jack Altman 9:50 By the way, the OpenRoad idea was very good there too. Just to be like, "We're gonna own this at the AI layer as well."

David George 9:54 Yeah.

Jack Altman 9:54 That's very smart.

David George 9:55 Yeah, yeah. Look, and like, y- I think they're right that the economy is going to, like, oscillate between using dollars and tokens-

Jack Altman 10:01 Yeah

David George 10:01 ... and, like, it's gonna be a new form of currency.

Jack Altman 10:03 Totally.

David George 10:03 Um, you know, so, uh, so yeah, we're obviously, you know, we're big fans of those guys and I think it's good.

Jack Altman 10:07 Also to the point of, like, it's all gonna work. You know, it's, you know, we talk about open source a lot in relation to the Frontier labs, and I guess the point there is if the, if the total token, you know, usage just goes up by 100X, it's just like these things are all gonna get so big.

David George 10:23 They're all gonna get so big. And so, you know, I, I wanted to like lay the groundwork first before making the case for like which of the individual layers of the stack are gonna be successful because, like, I think it paints a picture where we're gonna like 20X or 50X over the next 10 years in just how much work is being

10:39 – 13:18

Frontier labs vs. open source

David George 10:39 done with this stuff. And by the way, we're just talking about enterprise right now.

Jack Altman 10:42 Right.

David George 10:42 Like, we talk, we should talk about consumer, but just in enterprise. So, you know, if you look at the Frontier labs, like today, you know, the Frontier labs are like 95% plus of dollars.

Jack Altman 10:51 Yeah.

David George 10:51 Like the 125 billion or so across the three of them. Um, you know, it's like they're consuming all of the revenue in the market, basically. Everything else is surrounding error. They have raised more than, like, the entire downstream ecosystem. Like just OpenAI and Anthropic have raised like $350 billion. So, like they, they do have scale.

Jack Altman 11:09 Wow.

David George 11:09 Like they have massive scale benefits.

Jack Altman 11:11 Yeah, yeah.

David George 11:11 Um, and right now, what's revealed in the preferences of users is, um, users are opting to use Frontier models, and I think there's a bunch of reasons why that's the case. Um, right now people are willing to pay, you know, 10X more for Frontier, for Frontier tokens. Um, you know, I think in coding that's, that's definitely gonna persist for some period of time. Um, you know, there's, there's reasons why you could see a case that people will like cost optimize and-

Jack Altman 11:38 Yeah

David George 11:38 ... and use like below the Frontier over time. Um, but right now like-

Jack Altman 11:41 Yeah, but too early to have to assume that the... Yeah

David George 11:42 ... the revealed, the reve- revealed preference is like everyone-

Jack Altman 11:45 Yeah

David George 11:46 ... everyone who is a heavy user of this stuff wants to use the Frontier. I think there's-

Jack Altman 11:49 Well, and also it seems to me like if that happens, the Frontier should be at even more valuable tasks that are worth even more. You know, like if coding-

David George 11:55 Even more so, like, yeah, curing cancer. Yeah, like if-

Jack Altman 11:57 If coding was worth X, like what's curing cancer worth?

David George 11:59 Curing cancer is worth, you know-

Jack Altman 12:00 More than X

David George 12:00 ... some, some astronomical. Yes, of course. And so right now, like I think there's a couple reasons why people are using the Frontier stuff. Like one is just there's so much user or consumer surplus to having this work done for you that you're willing to pay s- so much more, like you're willing to pay-

Jack Altman 12:16 Yes

David George 12:16 ... the, the incremental amount for that Frontier.

Jack Altman 12:18 Yeah.

David George 12:18 Does that make sense?

Jack Altman 12:18 Yes.

David George 12:19 Um, secondly, like they've done a pretty good job with first party products. So, you know- People really like using Codex and Claude Code and Cursor and, you know, I think increasingly we'll use stuff like GroqBot. Like, it's gonna be really valuable to use the first party stuff. There's a bunch of reasons why that's the case. They've done a good job with product. I also think they have very tightly coupled their harnesses with the models.

Jack Altman 12:39 Yeah.

David George 12:40 So that, um, the experience you have with those products is actually very, very good. And so subbing out some other model where you don't have the harness and you don't have the product and don't have the interface, like, no one's doing that today.

Jack Altman 12:51 I'm curious your thoughts on what you... H- how do you... And obviously it's very hard to know, but how, how do you sort of, um, mentally picture what their incentive should be on making more first party products? And I'm asking this in relation to as you think about investing in applications at the growth stage and you think like what's gonna be worth it for them to build a first party app in and will that matter or again does it all win? Like how do you think about their incentives and how if at all it relates to

13:18 – 14:01

Application investing and the coding blast radius

Jack Altman 13:18 your application investing?

David George 13:19 Yeah. So we've done a lot of application investing. So again, this is like in the theme of and.

Jack Altman 13:24 Mm-hmm.

David George 13:24 Right? Like, um, we th- we think, we think a lot of things are gonna work. Um, on the application side, my framework is the big labs are going to be very focused on first party products that are obviously in coding and within the blast radius of coding. And so you can interpret the blast radius of coding however you'd like.

Jack Altman 13:41 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah.

David George 13:41 But it's, it's probably some things around it. Um, you know, uh, that's, that's one piece. And then secondly, they're gonna be focused on first party products that appeal horizontally to all 1.5 billion knowledge workers. So think like Microsoft Office and Google Apps, and they would like to have those as first party products. We know from their work that they're doing, like the,

14:01 – 20:46

Harvey and legal as a category

David George 14:01 the work that they do with data vendors, like they are very focused in those areas, right? So think like, you know, all the Microsoft Office products. Um, and so, you know, outside of that, there's a question of like what number priority is it for them? So, you know, we're large investors in Harvey.

Jack Altman 14:19 Yeah.

David George 14:19 And so, you know, Harvey, I feel like, you know, legal is, uh, I don't know, it's very interesting to people on X. Um, but um, but it's a market that's like absolutely in takeoff.

Jack Altman 14:28 Yeah.

David George 14:28 Right? So if you take an optimistic view of it, there's many differences which we could talk about, but it's probably like 12 months behind coding.

Jack Altman 14:36 Yeah.

David George 14:36 Just in terms of like diffusion into the workforce.

Jack Altman 14:38 Yeah.

David George 14:38 And it's now gotten to the point where end clients are demanding that their law firms use Harvey.

Jack Altman 14:42 Yeah.

David George 14:42 So like we care about it for product and we care about it for cost. Um, and so you must use it. So it used to be this thing where people would talk about like hallucinations and then now it's just like, no, everyone has it. And so, um, you know, it's probably like somewhere between number six through 15 on the priority list.

Jack Altman 15:00 Yeah. By the way, that, that one, it, it really is funny how much it gets people on X and you know, we know this too obviously from-

David George 15:05 Yeah, from Agora. Yeah

Jack Altman 15:06 ... yeah. And, and it's like, um, I think people, A, were surprised that these companies can grow this fast in legal, which you would not have thought would be an early adopter and then you have a, you know, then you've got a lot of doubt, you know, 'cause they're like, "Oh, well wasn't it hallucinating and stuff?" It's like, yeah, like 18 months ago.

David George 15:21 Yeah, 18 months ago.

Jack Altman 15:22 But like it's-

David George 15:22 And like they made a smart bet, which is like what happens when models get 100X better?

Jack Altman 15:26 Yeah.

David George 15:27 And like, and you know-

Jack Altman 15:28 And it's gonna work. Yeah

David George 15:28 ... and it's gonna work.

Jack Altman 15:29 Yeah.

David George 15:29 Like and so the big break-

Jack Altman 15:30 And legal's actually just like a perfect thing too because it's language but it's like kinda mathematical. Like it's extremely logical.

David George 15:34 Yes, exactly. Like they're...

Jack Altman 15:35 Yeah.

David George 15:35 Yeah, it's extremely logical. It's extremely well documented.

Jack Altman 15:38 Yeah.

David George 15:38 Like in terms of case law.

Jack Altman 15:39 Yeah.

David George 15:39 Right? Um, and um, you know, the big breakthrough that we saw, which I'm, I'm sure is the same case with Agora, is um, you know, reasoning models.

Jack Altman 15:48 Totally.

David George 15:48 Like, and so like lawyering is reasoning.

Jack Altman 15:50 Yeah.

David George 15:50 And so like yes, it makes sense.

Jack Altman 15:51 But no, I agree that, that, that doesn't seem like the next... 'Cause there, there's a trade-off too, I think, where if they start picking off random companies, then you lose the trust and you have to ask for X.

David George 16:00 Yeah, then the ecosystem. Yeah, of course. And so-

Jack Altman 16:01 You have to-

David George 16:02 Yeah.

Jack Altman 16:02 I mean, I think all the big platforms, I'm sure Microsoft had this and-

David George 16:04 Salesforce had it. Yeah

Jack Altman 16:05 ... like they all had to decide like is it worth pissing everybody off to go like eat some random thing?

David George 16:11 Yeah. The old Microsoft thing, like, you know, a platform is only a platform if all of the things built on top of it generate more revenue than it.

Jack Altman 16:17 That's right.

David George 16:17 Right?

Jack Altman 16:18 That's right.

David George 16:18 And so I, I don't think that the, that that's totally lost in the labs. Um, now like it might still be priority number six.

Jack Altman 16:25 Yes.

David George 16:25 And, and like there was a major validation event.

Jack Altman 16:27 Yes.

David George 16:27 Which was when Kirkland came out and said they're gonna spend 500 million bucks to-

Jack Altman 16:30 Yeah

David George 16:30 ... build their own technology stack.

Jack Altman 16:31 Yes.

David George 16:32 Like people were like, "Oh man. What's that mean for Harvey?" You know?

Jack Altman 16:35 Yes. And so then you've got these bubble ones where they're, they're-

David George 16:37 But it's great

Jack Altman 16:37 ... it's not a niche, but it is not, you know, the, it is not the path to AGI.

David George 16:41 Those applications. Yeah, exactly.

Jack Altman 16:42 But it is gonna be worth many, many billions.

David George 16:44 And there's two things that are really important about it. One, like the last details of the product really matter to the users, and then two, it requires like real go to market and on the ground efforts.

Jack Altman 16:55 Yes.

David George 16:55 And so, um, you know, those two things everyone talks about like what are now the moats of software or applications. Like-

Jack Altman 17:03 FDs.

David George 17:03 Yeah. Those things like in the ground ma-

Jack Altman 17:05 Yeah

David George 17:05 ... like making sure they work.

Jack Altman 17:06 Yeah.

David George 17:06 Like is a big thing.

Jack Altman 17:07 Yes.

David George 17:07 And so, uh, you know, will the labs like go do that in a verticalized way? At law, like probably not. Like, you know, whatever, there's a Claude Legal product.

Jack Altman 17:15 Yeah. You j- they just can't be everywhere all the time.

David George 17:16 No one really uses it. They can't do all of the things.

Jack Altman 17:18 Yes.

David George 17:18 Right? And so, you know, our investments are informed by that. Like, you know, um, it's not to say that we won't do things in that blast radius or in that, you know, sort of knowledge worker horizontal-

Jack Altman 17:29 Yeah

David George 17:29 ... category. Um, but we do ask the question, you know, a lot more about like what is the product roadmap? What's the right to win?

Jack Altman 17:35 Yeah.

David George 17:35 Um, in the applications beyond those, like I think there's gonna be, you know, hundreds of flowers that bloom.

Jack Altman 17:41 Yeah.

David George 17:42 Like this is gonna be a massive, a massive unlock. And so-

Jack Altman 17:45 Yeah. But, you know, back to the point of it's all gonna work, I think even the stuff in the blast radius-

David George 17:49 It's probably gonna work

Jack Altman 17:50 ... it's probably gonna work.

David George 17:50 Yeah. Like we're large investors.

Jack Altman 17:52 It's probably gonna work.

David George 17:52 We're the biggest investors in Replit. Like it's working very, very well.

Jack Altman 17:55 Yeah.

David George 17:55 And-

Jack Altman 17:55 Replit and Lovable and you wouldn't, you wouldn't think that these thing... You would think that tho- you're like, well isn't, you know, aren't Codex and Claude Code gonna be able to make a website? And the answer is yeah, they can, and also these things are unbelievable.

David George 18:06 They're very good.

Jack Altman 18:07 And, you know, and-

David George 18:08 Like Cursor also and that is like dead in the center of the blast radius.

Jack Altman 18:11 Totally.

David George 18:11 And you know, there's a huge market of people who use it.

Jack Altman 18:13 Yeah.

David George 18:13 And so, um, yeah, it's all gonna work. I, I think, um, you know, with the model there, like the f- the appetite for frontier technology, I, I just think it's like undisputed.

Jack Altman 18:23 Yeah.

David George 18:23 It's just going to, to be there. Um- The appetite for N-1 or open source technology is also gonna be huge.

Jack Altman 18:30 Yeah.

David George 18:30 Like, it's gonna be massive because if you 50X the usage that happens, like people will care about cost. And like maybe there will be a point where if cost is 100X higher for Frontier-

Jack Altman 18:40 Yeah

David George 18:40 ... like people really start paying attention to it.

Jack Altman 18:41 Well, and N-1 is gonna be really good soon. You know, like N-

David George 18:44 It's gonna be very good

Jack Altman 18:45 ... N-1 will be better than 5.6 Sol.

David George 18:47 Like, yeah, take, uh-

Jack Altman 18:48 By the end of... You know, I don't know when, but by soon.

David George 18:51 Yeah, and so you can see it actually at the cutting edge of the application companies, right? Who care about their own cost because that's their gross margin. And so, you know, how long has it been since most customer support tickets required the highest end model?

Jack Altman 19:04 Yeah.

David George 19:05 Like three years-

Jack Altman 19:06 Yeah

David George 19:06 ... or something, right? And so you can see a path to the sort of abstraction layer following how much-

Jack Altman 19:12 Yes

David George 19:12 ... value is required, and there's gonna be a lot of people vying for the abstraction layer, like the application companies, obviously the labs with their first party products, companies like Databricks or Palantir or Snowflake, like they're gonna vie for it. But I think people are gonna use like every variation of that.

Jack Altman 19:27 Yeah.

David George 19:27 And it's all gonna work. And-

Jack Altman 19:28 By the way, the customer support example is such a good one to me of how long diffusion's gonna take because the technology has been more than good enough for a little while and we still... I don't know what percent penetration it has-

David George 19:41 Tiny

Jack Altman 19:41 ... but tiny. And it, that's like the clearest example to me of the technology is fully there, it's just gonna take many years to get there.

David George 19:48 Yeah, the old enterprise thing of better, faster, cheaper.

Jack Altman 19:51 Yeah.

David George 19:51 Like it's been better, faster, and cheaper-

Jack Altman 19:53 It's one on everything

David George 19:53 ... for two years.

Jack Altman 19:54 Yeah.

David George 19:55 And like-

Jack Altman 19:55 And the companies are doing great

David George 19:56 ... the companies are growing faster than any other application companies before them.

Jack Altman 20:00 There's, there, there's still some laws of physics here.

David George 20:01 But, uh, but yeah, I mean, you know, you gotta sell it and you gotta implement it.

Jack Altman 20:04 Yeah.

David George 20:04 And it's like there's a, there's a lot of messy integrations-

Jack Altman 20:06 Yes

David George 20:06 ... you have to do and rules that you have to follow, brand guidelines. Again, like the labs aren't gonna build that motion.

Jack Altman 20:13 Yeah.

David George 20:14 Like there, there will be companies built on top of them. So I... That's like a classic and.

Jack Altman 20:17 So this is all enterprise. What about consumer? So, you know, like I think, um, I mean, obviously ChatGPT was sort of like the first consumer moment and, you know, it was also the, the whole AI moment, but the first AI moment was a consumer moment and like that's what caught everybody's attention was for the first time people were using this thing and they had been hearing about AI for, I don't know, 10 years, and then all of a sudden you have this thing. And even the first version of ChatGPT, we were like, "Ooh, I've never seen that before." But, you know, now talk to me, you know, four years later or whatever it is, like what's the progress

20:46 – 22:14

Consumer AI and where we are

Jack Altman 20:46 of consumer and how do you see it?

David George 20:47 Yeah. I mean, there's a billion people using it, right? Um, and there's more than a billion people using it, you know?

Jack Altman 20:53 Obsessively.

David George 20:53 Obsessive- obsessively. Um, but like the instantiation of the product and the use case is like very basic, right? We're in like skeuomorphic mode for the vast majority of consumers, which is they are doing what they used to do on a search engine inside ChatGPT.

Jack Altman 21:10 Yeah.

David George 21:11 And like that's the extent of the use case of the vast majority of the-

Jack Altman 21:14 Except for the kids. The kids use it better than that.

David George 21:16 My... Yeah. My son, uh, I, I mean, total aside, a 10-year-old is like writing full-on rap songs-

Jack Altman 21:22 Yeah

David George 21:22 ... and creating music.

Jack Altman 21:24 Yeah.

David George 21:24 And, you know-

Jack Altman 21:24 No, it's not an aside. This is the future.

David George 21:26 This is the future.

Jack Altman 21:26 But this is-

David George 21:27 And it's like incredible

Jack Altman 21:27 ... it tells you the difference where it's like there's a, there's a, a, a large cohort of people who, you know, are gonna probably always Google, you know, use this as a Google replacement.

David George 21:36 Yeah.

Jack Altman 21:36 But that's not how the kids are gonna use it.

David George 21:38 The kids are gonna be, the kids are gonna be totally native.

Jack Altman 21:40 Yes.

David George 21:40 Like, and, and, you know, you can see it with the kids now. Like they didn't, they, they never were like trained, my kids were never trained on like search engines-

Jack Altman 21:46 Yeah

David George 21:46 ... and now they just, it's a whole new thing where they get it to, you know, to give them answers to anything and give them, you know, work product of anything. Y- the big shift is gonna be like when it goes from being reactive to proactive and, you know, we're like just scratching the surface on that.

Jack Altman 22:00 Yeah.

David George 22:01 Um, it's gonna be multimodal, so it's not gonna be just like sitting doing this. Like the voice stuff actually is very, very good now. Um, you know, there was a bit of a head fake because the OpenAI voice stuff was not very good for a period of time, and it had to

22:14 – 25:52

From reactive to proactive AI

David George 22:14 rely on a dumber model. And now it doesn't and it can handle interruptions and things like that. So like a natural human interaction form now exists.

Jack Altman 22:21 Yeah.

David George 22:21 Um, and capabilities for doing proactive work on your behalf and like action taking is like, we're just now there, right?

Jack Altman 22:29 Yeah.

David George 22:29 Like OpenClaw was the first moment. I think GrokBock is a, GrokBot is a moment now. Um, and I think that'll be kinda the future of consumer use. It's so funny to me that no one talks about consumer right now.

Jack Altman 22:41 Yeah.

David George 22:42 Like everyone is obsessed with coding, rightfully so-

Jack Altman 22:44 Yeah

David George 22:44 ... given what's happened with the revenue ramps of the companies. But if like historical technology markets are any guide-

Jack Altman 22:50 Yes

David George 22:50 ... like the big prize is gonna be the killer consumer products 'cause you can, you can address billions of people with them. So I think those are gonna get a lot better. I'm very optimistic. Um, and those are gonna come with like the world's best business models too. There's gonna be like a lot of value generated. There's gonna be a ton of consumer surplus.

Jack Altman 23:05 Like what would that look like?

David George 23:07 I think it'll be advertising or some greater form of advertising. Like i- i- if you tried to describe... The thing I always say is like if you tried to describe the form factor of the feed to people, like during classifieds in newspapers, like it would make no sense.

Jack Altman 23:20 Yeah.

David George 23:20 So we have yet to figure out like what the native consumption model is gonna be and then what the native ad format is gonna be that follows that.

Jack Altman 23:27 Yeah.

David George 23:27 Um-

Jack Altman 23:28 Do you think it's ads and subscriptions?

David George 23:29 Yeah, definitely.

Jack Altman 23:30 Yeah.

David George 23:30 Yeah. I think it's both.

Jack Altman 23:31 Like you think that it'll be a situation where hundreds of millions of people might be willing to pay today surprising amounts for this thing?

David George 23:38 Yes, absolutely.

Jack Altman 23:39 Yeah.

David George 23:39 And again, I think-

Jack Altman 23:40 And that's when it's like a personal assistant for everybody.

David George 23:41 That's when a person, it's a personal assistant for everybody.

Jack Altman 23:43 Yeah.

David George 23:43 And so like I, again, I think my framework is like 10X more value will just accrete to the surplus of the users.

Jack Altman 23:49 Oh, wow.

David George 23:49 But like there's gonna be a lot of value created for that-

Jack Altman 23:52 Yes

David George 23:52 ... for that 10%.

Jack Altman 23:53 Yeah.

David George 23:53 And so that, that accretes to the companies. And so it'll be subscriptions, um, you know, it'll be, um, it'll be ads or some form, new form that isn't quite what we think of today as ads, um, that hasn't probably yet been invented. Um, and it's gonna be a new form of like consumption.

Jack Altman 24:09 Yes.

David George 24:10 And so I, I'm very, I'm very optimistic about that.

Jack Altman 24:12 But the thing that you're most excited about in consumer is something that gets to an assistant for everybody.

David George 24:16 Yes.

Jack Altman 24:16 Yeah.

David George 24:17 Yeah. And like take action on your behalf in a trustworthy way. Um, you know, like, I don't know. I've started building all these automations for myself and like, I'd say I, I'm, I'm aggressively trying to make myself more native.

Jack Altman 24:29 Yeah.

David George 24:30 Um, and I get like real value out of like- Two out of 10 of them. Um, but like there's a lot more-

Jack Altman 24:35 Yeah

David George 24:36 ... that I think will be done. Um, and you know, the models will get 10X to 100X better over the next five to 10 years.

Jack Altman 24:42 Yeah.

David George 24:42 And so think about what that's gonna result in. Um-

Jack Altman 24:44 One of the, one of the other big consu- so I fully agree with this obviously. One, one of the other big personal consumer, you know, autonomy, AI things I think about a lot is just self, self-driving cars and autonomy is, I just feel like... I mean, you know, I just got a Tesla for the first time and like-

David George 24:59 [laughs]

Jack Altman 25:00 ... I gotta, you know. I, it is insane. It is like the best pro- because you get in the car, you type in where you wanna go, and it takes you there. You don't have to think about anything-

David George 25:08 Yeah

Jack Altman 25:08 ... else.

David George 25:09 Yeah.

Jack Altman 25:10 The whole ri- it gets you out of any weird thing. It can park anywhere. And I don't think most people have realized how good self-driving is yet, unless you have a self-driving Tesla.

David George 25:20 Yeah.

Jack Altman 25:20 Or-

David George 25:20 Maybe if you, or if you live in a place where you can get a Waymo. Like basically that's-

Jack Altman 25:23 Or, or, or, yeah

David George 25:23 ... like it's a small thing.

Jack Altman 25:24 Of course.

David George 25:24 For people.

Jack Altman 25:25 Yeah.

David George 25:25 Yeah.

Jack Altman 25:25 So, uh, you know, and so it's like you've got these companies that can do it now.

David George 25:28 Yeah.

Jack Altman 25:28 Waymo and Tesla, and but it has not diffused yet. And so, A, I don't think people realize, I don't think, you know, the people who have done it realize, but I don't think everybody realizes how good autonomy is right now. But then the other most important thing is I don't think that it has turned into the business model that it needs to turn into yet.

David George 25:45 Yeah.

Jack Altman 25:45 So I'm curious your take on this is I know you're, you know, an investor and you have thought a lot about this, but like-

David George 25:51 Yeah

Jack Altman 25:51 ... where are we on

25:52 – 27:49

AI, autonomy, robotics, bio health

Jack Altman 25:52 the autonomy curve with that?

David George 25:53 Yeah.

Jack Altman 25:53 Yeah.

David George 25:54 It's so funny to think about these other major technological tailwinds that are happening because like AI just, you know, like supersedes everything-

Jack Altman 26:01 Yeah

David George 26:01 ... in our minds right now.

Jack Altman 26:02 Totally.

David George 26:03 Um, like I always find it helpful to just take a step back and just say like, okay, what are like the wa- like product cycles drive our business. And so like what are the big waves that we're catching right now? Like autonomous driving is one. But the previous generation of these was like mobile phones plus social, e-commerce, SaaS, cloud, kind of all coinciding.

Jack Altman 26:19 Yep.

David George 26:19 And that produced like $25 trillion of market cap.

Jack Altman 26:22 That's a lot, yeah.

David George 26:23 And like it's like a ton of, that's like a lot, right?

Jack Altman 26:25 Yeah.

David George 26:25 Um, and you know, like what do we have staring at us in the face right now? Like we've got AI, we've got autonomy, we've got robotics, we've got AI's application to health.

Jack Altman 26:36 Yeah, I was gonna say bio.

David George 26:37 Like we have the American dynamism category, which is like-

Jack Altman 26:41 Yeah

David George 26:41 ... you know, modernization of defense.

Jack Altman 26:43 Yep.

David George 26:43 Like the combination of all of those, I'm very confident-

Jack Altman 26:46 Gotta be more than 25

David George 26:46 ... it's way more than 25.

Jack Altman 26:48 Yeah.

David George 26:48 Like i- it's just the most exciting time, you know, to ever be an investor and in the technology markets. Autonomy specifically, I, I think it's just very underappreciated. Like the auto industry and people driving cars is one of the biggest industries in the world, obviously. Um, right now, okay, so if you rewind all the way to like taxi driving, right? Um, that was like less than 0.1% of the overall miles traveled in the US.

Jack Altman 27:16 Yeah.

David George 27:16 And there were a bunch of reasons why that was the case. Then the rideshare companies came along and, you know, I was an investor in Uber, you know, obviously y- you guys were too. Um, the big thing that happened obviously was like a better business model, but it was, it was really like the 10X'ing of the market size. So like, you know, taxis were 100 million bucks in San Francisco, and then they became a billion dollars like three years into Uber and Lyft. Um, and so it 10X'd the market size because you delivered a much better product. Autonomous driving, we're gonna look back 10 years from now and say like, "Oh, there was another obvious 10X'ing that

27:49 – 30:46

Autonomous driving and why it's underappreciated

David George 27:49 would happen there." Um-

Jack Altman 27:50 At least.

David George 27:50 At l- m- at least just on the ride hail side. So if you have a product that is 14 times safer than a human driver-

Jack Altman 27:58 Then it's barbaric to drive.

David George 28:00 It's actually, so like this is my view now on the cities-

Jack Altman 28:03 Like don't you think like if you're like, how many people die a year from a human driver? If it's safer, isn't that-

David George 28:07 You know-

Jack Altman 28:08 'Cause isn't the data like pretty abundant now?

David George 28:09 It's 14, it's, it's millions of dri- millions of miles traveled in Waymos, and they're like between 10 and 14 times safer than a human driver.

Jack Altman 28:16 Yeah.

David George 28:16 So like it is barbaric to not actually allow for these things to diffuse into your economy. So, um, I think like history will look back on people and judge them very poorly if they don't let it happen.

Jack Altman 28:27 Yeah.

David George 28:27 Um, but for the consumer side, just start with that. If you can drive in something that's 10 to 14 times safer, you would pay a massive premium.

Jack Altman 28:35 Yeah.

David George 28:36 I think there's a very clear case for, um, how you actually get the cost below the cost of Uber and Lyft today. Um, so right now, owning a consumer car equates to like 80 cents per mile, like it fully loaded, depreciation, insurance, gas, all that stuff. Um, like that's your like cost of an incremental mile. Um, riding in an Uber or Lyft is probably like two bucks and change per mile. Um, this market is like massively elastic. So like if you can get, you know-

Jack Altman 29:06 The cost down

David George 29:06 ... the cost of a Waymo or a Tesla or whatever, you know, ride hail service-

Jack Altman 29:10 Everything

David George 29:10 ... which I think there'll be others.

Jack Altman 29:11 Yeah.

David George 29:11 Um, down below that, like there's going to be an explosion of demand. So it's 14 times safer. It's only gonna get better, by the way. It's gonna get safer. It's gonna be 20 times safer soon. Um, and you know, it's gonna be less than the cost. Like you will see a 10X plus.

Jack Altman 29:25 Yeah.

David George 29:25 Then you talk about personal car ownership. Uh, and so there's 17 million cars sold a year in the US new. Um, and by the way, there's like 250 million cars in the US. Um, just in the US, like how much would you pay for full autonomous features for a, a passenger car that you owned?

Jack Altman 29:42 A lot. It's like double.

David George 29:44 10,000. Uh, yeah, like minimum $10,000.

Jack Altman 29:46 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

David George 29:46 Right? Um, and so-

Jack Altman 29:48 I mean, once you're used to it, it is extr- and I can't even-

David George 29:49 Yeah, you can't, can't not have it

Jack Altman 29:50 ... it's really hard to go back. Yeah.

David George 29:51 So you could sell it upfront, you could do a subscription, but like call it minimum 10,000 bucks a car, 17 million cars. Then you have all of like the Western world, and then, you know, eventually it'll get cost, you know, compelling enough to, to reach developing markets. Um, so it's going to be one of these things where 50 years from now-

Jack Altman 30:07 Yeah

David George 30:07 ... it like the whole, the whole-

Jack Altman 30:08 Like no one will be driving

David George 30:09 ... composition. Yeah, no one will be driving. Like the composition of everything looks different. It takes time 'cause you gotta produce the cars. Um, people are always struck like how many Waymos there are, right? Like Waymos, if you're in one of the cities where they are, they feel ubiquitous.

Jack Altman 30:21 Yeah.

David George 30:22 There's like less than 10,000-

Jack Altman 30:24 That's crazy

David George 30:24 ... in the US.

Jack Altman 30:24 Yeah.

David George 30:25 In the whole US.

Jack Altman 30:25 Yeah.

David George 30:25 Uh, and so, um, you know, it's one of those areas where, you know, there's, there's Waymo, there's, you know, Tesla. I think there'll be other players. Like we've backed a couple that I think have a real shot at it. Um- And it's not gonna be 10 players, and it's gonna be a massive market.

Jack Altman 30:39 Yeah.

David George 30:39 And so it's easy to lose sight of markets like that 'cause it's like, you know-

Jack Altman 30:42 Totally

David George 30:42 ... the, the growth of AI. Um, but, like, those are gonna be huge,

30:46 – 33:25

Robotics and what comes next

David George 30:46 huge markets, um, that we're super excited about.

Jack Altman 30:48 Yeah, and then, you know, related, there's robotics, which is gonna be enor- I mean, not, there's nothing quite going yet. I mean, but you see the glimmers of it now, and it's like you go into the labs that are working on it and, you know, like the startups that are doing it. Obviously, Tesla's very good at it. There's... But it's, it's clearly gonna work.

David George 31:04 It's clearly gonna work, yeah. And, like, it, it'll be a bigger market than language, right?

Jack Altman 31:07 Yeah.

David George 31:07 When it does work.

Jack Altman 31:08 Yeah.

David George 31:08 Um, because it will have, you know, B2B, you know, applications. It'll have consumer applications. Like, I think we're probably pretty far off-

Jack Altman 31:15 Yeah

David George 31:15 ... from having-

Jack Altman 31:16 It does feel like we're-

David George 31:17 ... ro- robots in our house.

Jack Altman 31:17 Yeah.

David George 31:18 Um, but you know, for-

Jack Altman 31:20 But for like-

David George 31:21 Like, defined use cas-

Jack Altman 31:22 ... you know, in a factory.

David George 31:22 Yeah, factory.

Jack Altman 31:23 Yeah, exactly. Yeah.

David George 31:23 Like, relatively defined use cases with, like, redundant tasks with safe environments.

Jack Altman 31:28 Yeah.

David George 31:28 Like, we see it.

Jack Altman 31:30 Yeah.

David George 31:30 Like, we invested in, um, you know, one of my partners led an investment in, um, uh, in mind robotics. And so, you know, s- Sarah did this deal, and it's the founder of Rivian, and, you know, he basically was like... First of all, he's an exceptional founder.

Jack Altman 31:44 Yeah.

David George 31:44 Um, and has produced a great company with great products. Um, but he's going to put robots on the factory floor, and so they'll do, you know, manufacturing assembly work on Rivians. It's relatively, you know, defined use cases with pretty high ROI today, and then it's an embedded customer. You know, you kinda have it, and you can not only get revenue from that, but you can also have the models learn from the work that you're doing.

Jack Altman 32:09 Yes.

David George 32:10 And so you have this feedback loop in the field that you can actually work on. Um, you know, there's other stuff that is kinda picks and shovels stuff that we're excited about, but, like, we will have a ChatGPT moment for robotics. I don't know when it's gonna be.

Jack Altman 32:22 Yeah.

David George 32:22 Like, I think it's within five years, hopefully.

Jack Altman 32:24 Yeah.

David George 32:24 Um, there's very, very smart teams working on it.

Jack Altman 32:27 Yeah.

David George 32:27 And I think it's gonna be one of the biggest markets, so it'll be bigger than language.

Jack Altman 32:30 Yeah. And, and it almost, like, has to be when you think about what it's gonna do.

David George 32:33 Think about the industrial impact of it, right?

Jack Altman 32:35 Yeah.

David George 32:35 Um-

Jack Altman 32:35 And this is one of these things where it's like the physics doesn't prevent it from happening, and you can see the glimmer. So it's... This'll take... I agree with you. This is gonna take more than 10 years to get all the way there, but, like, I just don't see why it wouldn't all work.

David George 32:46 Yeah. I think it's, I think it's gonna work.

Jack Altman 32:48 Yeah.

David George 32:48 Yeah, I think it's gonna work, and I think we'll have them, you know, everywhere. And a- and, and I think, like, by the way, the byproduct of this is that we'll have, like, massive productivity booms.

Jack Altman 32:57 Yeah.

David George 32:58 Like, I think that's gonna be the economic impact, and quality of life will go up.

Jack Altman 33:01 Yeah.

David George 33:01 Um, you know, we'll have to think hard about, like, job impacts-

Jack Altman 33:04 Yeah

David George 33:04 ... and stuff like that.

Jack Altman 33:04 Yeah.

David George 33:05 And, you know, are workers kinda trained to make a transition, especially if it happens fast?

Jack Altman 33:09 Yeah.

David George 33:10 Um, but, like, the history of all these technology breakthroughs is that we find higher order things to do.

Jack Altman 33:16 Yeah.

David George 33:16 Um, like 60, you know, whatever, 60% of jobs didn't exist 70 years ago, like, that we have today. So, like, we'll have a similar transition period, um, that happens. Uh, but

33:25 – 34:11

Benchmark's new growth fund

David George 33:25 I think it's gonna be a massive productivity boom. It's gonna be awesome.

Jack Altman 33:27 So I wanna talk about capital and financing a little bit.

David George 33:30 Yeah.

Jack Altman 33:30 We, we at, uh, Benchmark just raised our first growth fund in history, and, you know, the, the baseline for that was something... Yeah.

David George 33:36 We- welcome to the dark o- w- welcome to the dark side.

Jack Altman 33:38 Yeah, exactly.

David George 33:38 [laughs]

Jack Altman 33:39 It's like, uh, you know, the, uh, the forbidden fruit. And, um, some- you know, but the, the thinking for us behind it was something along the lines of venture returns now happen at growth in a way that they didn't used to.

David George 33:51 Yeah.

Jack Altman 33:51 And, you know, this conversation we were, that we've just had really supports it because, you know, the outcomes are that big, and the things that run really run, and it's all gonna work, and all of these things. And that sorta led us to the thinking that, you know, the sort of 10 to 100x or 1000x, whatever, you know, the, the, the really big multiples can happen all along the way.

David George 34:09 Yeah.

Jack Altman 34:10 Um, which I know

34:11 – 34:53

Why growth investing is compelling now

Jack Altman 34:11 you believe that obviously.

David George 34:11 Preaching to the, preaching to the choir. [laughs]

Jack Altman 34:13 Um, I wanna connect this though. So, you know, I, I, I would like to hear your thinking on that, and I would also like to hear... You know, we just talked about the product cycle and where we are, but there's also this related but not exactly the same thing of the capital cycle.

David George 34:25 Yeah.

Jack Altman 34:25 And the capital following the products and investing behind them and all of those things. So, uh, I would just be curious to hear your take on where we're at from a capital perspective, from a growth investing perspective.

David George 34:34 Yeah, of course. I, so, um, you know, as it, as it relates to, like, why go do growth and, like, is it a compelling category, obviously, you, you have, you have seen the light. Um, but, um-

Jack Altman 34:46 The dark light

David George 34:47 ... the, the dark, it's, it's great. Um, i- the market that we're in is, like, a $5 trillion market, so it's

34:53 – 37:57

Half of private market returns happen at growth

David George 34:53 like, you know, whatever, it's like 20% of the S&P 500. So if you're not actually, you know, playing the full, you know, the full sort of gamut of that in the private markets, like, you're probably leaving a lot of money on the table. Like, we did this analysis a long time ago that basically showed, um, half of, half of private market returns get generated between the seed and the B, and then half of returns get generated from the C+. And so, you know, if you're not aggressively playing from the C+, you're-

Jack Altman 35:21 You miss half

David George 35:21 ... you're, you're definitely leaving off half. And by the way, that was during an era when companies went public earlier. So now that companies are staying private longer, if you could fast-forward five years, the ratio's gonna be even more extreme. It'd probably be 70/30 or something in favor of the late stuff. Um, you can also give venture outcomes because the power law is so crazy strong today, right? And so, you know, when you get it right, like, it can really go right. And we're in this dynamic market where the power law is more extreme than in the past, and I think it's a result of a few things. One, um, is just, you know, we're, we're early cycle, and so, you know, the, the early companies can establish themselves as leaders earlier. Um, secondly, this one in AI is unique because if you throw more money at it, it can just scale up-

Jack Altman 36:07 Yeah

David George 36:07 ... and get better, right? So, like, that is different than previous cycles, right? If you threw endless amounts of money at ServiceNow or Workday or Salesforce, like, during the SaaS era, they would get all messed up.

Jack Altman 36:21 Mm-hmm.

David George 36:21 Like, we saw this experiment with, like, the Vision Fund, right? Like, you throw money at these things, and the companies get screwed up, right? Or if it was a consumer company, they would spend it on Google and Facebook, and, like, that's not a good thing either.

Jack Altman 36:33 Was that the mechanism for why the Vision Fund was... Was it just, like, dumping too much money in companies that didn't need it, or was it hitting, you know, the cycle at too late of a time, or was it both?

David George 36:42 I think it was both. I think it was like- Well, first of all, like, I don't think it was a bad idea. Um, I think it was just, like, wrong time of the cycle, and then we were not in an environment where if you put more money into something, it got better-

Jack Altman 36:54 Yeah

David George 36:54 ... just automatically, like with, with no scale limitations. Like, that is what happens with AI.

Jack Altman 36:58 Yes.

David George 36:59 Like, it, it used to be, you know, if you put, you know, a $40 billion fundraise into Salesforce, like-

Jack Altman 37:07 The company's worse

David George 37:07 ... what are they gonna do? Like, go hire a bunch of sales reps and engineer? Like, it just wouldn't work.

Jack Altman 37:11 Yeah.

David George 37:11 Whereas if you put $40 billion towards training, you know, these models-

Jack Altman 37:14 Things get better. Yes

David George 37:15 ... you know? Like-

Jack Altman 37:15 Yeah

David George 37:15 ... they get much better.

Jack Altman 37:16 Yeah.

David George 37:16 And so that is very unique, uh, in the moment that we're in right now. You know, I, I think about the world as, like, product cycles and capital cycles and, um, I tell my team, like, the ideal state of the world would be you're in a great position on the product cycle, like scale of one to 10, 10 being good, one being not good. Like, in 2021, we were at, like, a one, which is like, we didn't realize it at the time.

Jack Altman 37:39 Yeah.

David George 37:39 Um, but that was-

Jack Altman 37:41 It was like-

David George 37:41 ... like, late SaaS-

Jack Altman 37:42 It had played out

David George 37:42 ... late cloud.

Jack Altman 37:43 Yeah.

David George 37:43 It was post-mobile phone growth. Like, all of the incremental consumer time spent was going to the major, you know, the major technology companies already. Um, so there was, like, no room for something new.

Jack Altman 37:53 Yeah.

David George 37:53 Um, so product cycle was, like, a one out of 10, and in 2010

37:57 – 41:54

Product cycle vs. capital cycle

David George 37:57 it was, like, a eight out of 10.

Jack Altman 37:59 Yeah.

David George 37:59 Like, it was very good.

Jack Altman 38:00 Yeah.

David George 38:00 Um, so right now product cycle is, like, a nine or 10 out of 10.

Jack Altman 38:05 Yeah.

David George 38:05 For all those reasons I have laid out.

Jack Altman 38:06 Yes.

David George 38:06 Like AI, autonomy, American dynamism, robotics, bio health, like, all these things are gonna happen over the next 10 years. Um, capital cycle, you know, your ideal would be, like, a 10 on product cycle and, like, you know, a 10 on capital cycle, meaning valuations are really low.

Jack Altman 38:20 Yes.

David George 38:20 They almost never coincide-

Jack Altman 38:22 Yes

David George 38:22 ... because there's, like, excitement about the current-

Jack Altman 38:23 Yeah, it'd be like it was like the best part of the product cycle ever and no one else saw it but you.

David George 38:27 Like, 2023, like, early days of when AI started working-

Jack Altman 38:31 That was probably pretty good

David George 38:32 ... and the capital markets were a little more benign-

Jack Altman 38:34 Yeah

David George 38:34 ... and, like, some of the crazy stuff and run-ups hadn't happened yet, like, that was like, I don't know, like, a seven.

Jack Altman 38:39 Yeah.

David George 38:39 And you know, like, 2010, you know, you could buy, like, SaaS companies and B2B marketplace companies for, like, you know, whatever, four times revenue or something. Like, that was pretty good, too.

Jack Altman 38:48 Yeah.

David George 38:49 Um, right now capital cycle-wise, like, people see the excitement, and you can still find ways to do good investments, and the companies are growing so fast, and they're so dynamic, it's fine, but, like, we're probably at a six or something.

Jack Altman 39:03 Yeah.

David George 39:03 You know, like, it's, it's okay-

Jack Altman 39:05 Yes

David George 39:05 ... but not great. Um, but the thing that drives our business over 10 years, whether it's venture or growth, is the product cycles.

Jack Altman 39:11 Yeah.

David George 39:11 And that's, like, a nine or 10 out of 10 right now.

Jack Altman 39:13 Right. Yeah. It's sort of like, um, I think it's... I can't remember if this is, I heard this first from Thrive or somebody, but it was like, you know, one way to be contrarian is to believe a thing nobody else believes. The other way is to believe the same thing everybody else believes, but believe it 10 times more or something like that.

David George 39:28 Yeah. And that's sort of like, that's a little bit our motto as a firm, I would say, is just, you know, especially at the growth stage, incrementally believe, like, what could go right.

Jack Altman 39:37 Yeah.

David George 39:38 And, like, sp- spend the time thinking about what could go right.

Jack Altman 39:40 Yeah.

David George 39:40 Um, you know, like, I, I always say, like, our business is we, like, pay fair prices for great companies. Um, and, like, the alpha you get is always on the revenue side.

Jack Altman 39:51 Yeah.

David George 39:51 It's not like, "Is this gonna end up a higher margin business than not?"

Jack Altman 39:53 Yeah. Yeah.

David George 39:53 Like, it's like... And so that's, like, market insights, product insights, and it's, um, you know, like, it, the, the market doesn't appreciate sometimes, like, the things that can really, really, really grow fast for a long period of time. Like, Databricks is an example of this.

Jack Altman 40:08 Yeah.

David George 40:08 Um, you know?

Jack Altman 40:09 By the way, we, um, I got to have dinner with Ali recently, and oh my God, what an amazing CEO.

David George 40:15 Like, so-

Jack Altman 40:17 Yeah

David George 40:17 ... I, I, I, I, like, coined this phrase, like, model busters or whatever, which is basically, like, the first time we invested out of the growth fund, obviously, you know, Ben did the series A, and then we did basically every letter, and I think we're on, like, M now.

Jack Altman 40:28 [laughs]

David George 40:28 I t- I, like, joke with Ali that, um, you know, we're gonna be, like, s- stadium seating and get to, like, double A.

Jack Altman 40:33 That's funny. Yeah.

David George 40:34 You know? Like, you know-

Jack Altman 40:34 You have to

David George 40:35 ... to w- we're g-

Jack Altman 40:35 Just stay private forever

David George 40:36 ... I don't, I don't think so. Yeah. But, um, uh, but the first one, one that we did out of the growth fund, um, was right when we started the growth fund, and we did a round at, like, $6 billion. And, like, the technical terminator Ali has, like, figured out seven years later his, his revenue has accelerated. It's like he has figured out more new products. And, like, our observation when things really go right, it's often the founder that figures out the next thing.

Jack Altman 41:01 Yeah.

David George 41:01 And, you know, his business is now positioned to benefit from AI. That's why it's growing so fast. Um, and our bet is he'll figure out the next thing and the next thing-

Jack Altman 41:09 Yeah

David George 41:09 ... and the next thing, and he's great. And, like, he, like, those founders like that, like as you guys have a, a growth business, like late stage venture business, like those founders are the asset class. Like, if you back them, they're gonna figure out all these amazing things to do.

Jack Altman 41:22 Yeah.

David George 41:23 Like, when we, when we did SpaceX, you know, like, Starlink wasn't even GA yet. Like, the, it was like, you know, and they had theories as to, and the economics were terrible, and, like, it didn't work. And, um, you know, like, here we are. That is, like, one of the best business segments ever created.

Jack Altman 41:39 Yeah.

David George 41:40 And he's got an AI business on top of it, and he's gonna have, you know, orbital compute, which is also gonna work. And so those founders are the things that you have to bet on, and, you know, the outcomes of the companies can be much larger than you would ever

41:54 – 43:14

The importance of narrative

David George 41:54 put in a financial model.

Jack Altman 41:54 Yeah.

David George 41:54 And, like, that is the thesis that we have.

Jack Altman 41:57 One of the things that I really look up to about Andreessen is I think you got the sort of importance of narrative right from the beginning. You know, like, I think about even when the firm was started, there was such an understanding that, you know, at the time it was, you know, media was very important, but there was just an understanding that stories matter and that, you know, the way you present matters, and being loud and in the conversation is really important. And I feel like obviously from, when from, what, 2009 or something?

David George 42:26 2009, yeah.

Jack Altman 42:27 You know, since then, obviously things have changed a lot and, you know, very, uh, I think in a very happy, uh, update, we've had sort of the lulification of everything where people are going direct and owning their own narrative, and you get more authenticity. You know, you guys have, uh, you know, a lot of, like, new media going and all these other things. But I think Andreessen has understood the importance of narrative

David George 42:48 Yeah

Jack Altman 42:48 And it seems to me that narrative is, like, louder than ever right now for companies. You know, it's like... And it's at all stages. It's like a company's launching, you see these beautiful videos, and companies at the later stages have their investors kind of, you know, creating stories for them in various ways, and they're owning media, and it's all just loud. But I think it's important, and I'm curious how you think about narrative now at this point in the cycle when we're all, you know, living on X

43:14 – 46:20

Why vibes matter

Jack Altman 43:14 and we're living in, in the news and, you know. How do you think about this all?

David George 43:17 Yeah. Look, I, th- this is just, like, the vibes, right? Like, the vibes, the vibes matter tremendously.

Jack Altman 43:21 But they matter.

David George 43:22 They matter a lot.

Jack Altman 43:23 Yeah, right.

David George 43:23 I, I actually have a funny story from, um, a meeting that I was having with Ben in 2018. So this was, I don't know, three or four months before I joined, and we were kinda hashing out, you know, what is our strategy gonna be. And, uh, and so, you know, I had all these ideas of, like, these are the new teams we need to build and this is what the investment team looks like, and he's like, "Well, what's your marketing strategy?" And I was like, "We don't really need a marketing strategy. It's not really a thing in growth." And he just, like, looked at me and said, like, "That's the dumbest fucking idea I've ever heard." Uh, and like, venture firms didn't market themselves, and then we did and it worked really well, so, like, why would you not do it here? Um, and so I came along. You know, I came from a place that was a lot more conservative and, uh, and so I've, I've sort of seen the light. Um, vibes matter. Let's just talk about why the vibes matter. So the vibes matter because, um, of fundraising, of your valuation, um, for retaining your employees and for hiring new employees-

Jack Altman 44:19 Yeah

David George 44:19 ... among other reasons.

Jack Altman 44:20 Yeah.

David George 44:20 And, and, and, like, in some markets, the vibes matter for your customers too. But, like, at a minimum, it's those things. Um, if you look at, um... And, and this is basic, but, like, why does a higher valuation matter? Like, a higher valuation means, you know, less dilution, more ability to raise capital, um, and, um, you know, you can use that as a weapon if things go sideways.

Jack Altman 44:39 And in a world where capital actually makes your company better-

David George 44:42 Yeah

Jack Altman 44:42 ... it's worth more.

David George 44:42 Exactly. It's worth more. Um-

Jack Altman 44:43 It was worth less when it was not, you know, the thing.

David George 44:45 Yeah. And, like, now every investor and every employee and potential employee is, like, living on X-

Jack Altman 44:52 Yeah

David George 44:52 ... and, like, consuming the vibes. So if you look in the public markets, the companies that have done a great job of this, like, there's a direct line to their valuation and their life gets a lot easier with a higher valuation, right? So, like, famously right now it's, it's Palantir and Karp, and, um-

Jack Altman 45:07 Yeah

David George 45:07 ... you know, he's got, like, a cult following. We-

Jack Altman 45:08 You know what's amazing to me on that one, is that he... I mean, Palantir had a huge multiple before the recen- like, now it's... I think the growth has inflected recently, right?

David George 45:18 Yeah, it has. Yeah, it's massively accelerated.

Jack Altman 45:19 Massively accelerated.

David George 45:20 Yeah.

Jack Altman 45:20 But it had the premium before it had that.

David George 45:23 Yes.

Jack Altman 45:23 And there's something interesting there.

David George 45:25 Yeah. And, like, by the way, to tell you how much it's vibes, like, no one knows what ontology means.

Jack Altman 45:32 No, I don't know what that is.

David George 45:33 Right? It's not even, like, a thing, right? And, you know, but, like, the, the big thing obviously that happened recently-

Jack Altman 45:38 I think a lot of people don't even really know what Palantir does.

David George 45:40 Yeah, yeah, for sure. Like, in- including, like, big holder, retail holders of the stock.

Jack Altman 45:44 Yeah. Yeah.

David George 45:44 Like a friend of mine who has a huge position and I'm like, "Explain it to me," and he's like, "Eh. Good vibes."

Jack Altman 45:49 Good vibes. Yeah.

David George 45:50 But what ha- what has happened, right? Like, they've massively accelerated in commercial, and they are now seen, um, you know, among CEOs as, like, a trusted place to go implement your AI. So it ac- it has actually given them a direct benefit on the commercial side-

Jack Altman 46:02 Yeah

David George 46:03 ... because they're seen as, like, the ones that will navigate the situation for you and they're trusted. Um, the valuation is a huge benefit for them, and then it's massive for them retaining and hiring employees. Similar to the Elon companies. Like, Elon, you know, obviously, like, having a big valuation allows him to have a bigger war chest, to buy companies,

46:20 – 49:39

Never short a messianic founder

David George 46:20 to raise more capital, uh, to have loyal following. So you can look at, like, the high retail ownership stocks and there's, like, a, a correlation if they're doing well-

Jack Altman 46:29 Yeah

David George 46:29 ... a correlation to, you know, to the valuation. Um, uh, this is funny. I heard from a hedge fund guy the, this theory on shorting stocks, and his theory on shorting stocks was, "I never short a messianic founder and I never short a product that people love." The inverse of that is if you have a messianic founder and there is a product that people love, you, you can actually, like, trade very high and have all these benefits, right? Um, right now in AI, obviously you said why the capital side matters and valuation side matters. It is incredible that the whole market is, like, hanging by a thread on the performance of, like, two-

Jack Altman 47:08 I know

David George 47:08 ... two, now kind of three private companies-

Jack Altman 47:10 Yeah

David George 47:10 ... um, on, like, a monthly basis. Like, there's-

Jack Altman 47:12 I mean, I, I was just thinking as you were talking that the narrative, what- however strong the narrative is now, it, the importance of it all is about to go, like, hyperbolic as these companies get public.

David George 47:21 Yeah. And, um, you know-

Jack Altman 47:22 But you can even see it. You know, there's this funny bit I, I mentioned to you of, you know, you can see investors and, you know, people who are on the opposite side kind of jockeying about, like, trying to set expectations around these companies.

David George 47:34 Oh, yeah, like Anthropic and OpenAI's revenue and all that stuff. Yeah.

Jack Altman 47:37 Yeah. And it's like, but, you know, and it doesn't all... It's not like the insiders are all pumping, you know, crazy numbers. It's actually, like, expectation management versus, you know, and it's just, but it, the amount of calories going into controlling these stories is just gonna be wild.

David George 47:50 Yeah. And there are... It's not even just the CEO. So, like, I talked about how the asset class is the founder and I talked about Karp and I talked about Elon. Ideally, if you have a dynamic founder who can be the face of the company, it's like Palmer with Anduril-

Jack Altman 48:05 Yeah

David George 48:05 ... right? Like, that will benefit you in many ways.

Jack Altman 48:08 Yeah.

David George 48:08 Again, if you have a product that people love, that messianic founder thing is, like, a massive asset, and it will make people care at every, at every layer that matters, right? Capital side, employee side, customer side. Um, and if you don't have that, if you're, like, some no-name, like, SaaS CEO, it's, like, very hard to command people's attention and, like, make them care.

Jack Altman 48:28 Yeah.

David George 48:28 Um, it also matters for people down in the organization, right? So, like, right now I think the person who's doing the best job of this in the market is Tebow from OpenAI and, like, he's very direct, and, you know, not only is it feeding good vibes among the investor community and good vibes among employees, but it's driving a lot of behavior on the customer side too. And so I think when done right, um- You know, it can have massive benefits.

Jack Altman 48:54 Yeah.

David George 48:54 And it's not to be underestimated. It's something we talk to our founders about all the time now. It's like, "You gotta go direct. You gotta own the narrative. You're the face of the company. You need to tell a compelling story." And if you don't, yeah, some people will care, but a lot of people aren't gonna care.

Jack Altman 49:07 Yes. And someone else with a almost as good but not quite as good product can come along and tell the story better.

David George 49:11 Yeah, exactly.

Jack Altman 49:12 Yeah.

David George 49:13 Exactly.

Jack Altman 49:13 Yeah. My last question, and I, I think I asked, I had both Mark and Ben on, um, at different times, and they both were... You could just feel the ambition and the scale and sort of the mindset around all of it. And, um, you know, this shows up in a lot of ways and, you know, uh, you know, I was just joking to you before we sat down that, you know, Benchmark's pretty small, Andreessen's pretty big, you know, in terms of, like,

49:39 – 53:11

How big can Andreessen Horowitz get

Jack Altman 49:39 its team and sort of all these things. Um, I guess my question is, how far, given that we're looking at not $25 trillion, but something bigger, like, how far can this all go? Like, how big can a venture firm, you know, get? What rate limiters, if any, are there on what you can do? Like, how do you think about, you know, what's left above, you know, the already, you know, large size you guys are at?

David George 50:04 Yeah. Look, we, we talk about this all the time 'cause there's p- there's pieces of our business that are scalable and there's pieces of our business that are not, right? And something that you said, which I think is super smart, is if you wanna go fast, you know, be small. If you wanna go far, you gotta be big, right? And so, um, there are things that we do that may cause, you know, more organizational overhead, but allow us, we think, to go further.

Jack Altman 50:27 Yeah.

David George 50:27 And, you know, pa- part of that is scaling our investment approach and scaling our team that does investing. And then a big part of that is the 650 employees that we have that help our companies. Um, so how big can it get? Yeah, $25 trillion of market cap creation. Um, tech is, call it, like, a third to a little higher percent of the overall market cap in the economy. Um, if you look at previous, um, eras, right, as a percentage of the overall market, different industries were actually much larger in the past. So, like, railroads and financial services and stuff. Like, they, they... At their peaks, they would be, like, 80% of the market. Um, I don't see a reason why tech will not continue to ascend as a percentage of the market cap. Like, right now, eight of the top 10 most valuable companies in the world are, you know-

Jack Altman 51:17 Yeah

David George 51:18 ... US venture, previously venture-backed technology companies in the US.

Jack Altman 51:21 Yeah, and they, and, and they all kinda look cheap.

David George 51:23 And they all look kinda cheap, and they're probably the best businesses ever created.

Jack Altman 51:26 Yeah.

David George 51:26 And then, and then by the way, like, we have OpenAI and Anthropic and SpaceX on their heels-

Jack Altman 51:31 Yeah

David George 51:31 ... that are, like-

Jack Altman 51:32 So you have more-

David George 51:33 ... growing faster.

Jack Altman 51:33 Yeah.

David George 51:34 And, and that are gonna get bigger.

Jack Altman 51:35 Yeah.

David George 51:36 Um, and then by the way, if you go back to those big trends that I see coming over the next 10 years, like, we don't even have the players on the board yet for those. So, um, in terms of, like, macro side, I see no limit on how big it can get. Um, in terms of our share and our ambitions as a firm, um, we probably have, like, 20% market share. Like, we measure this at least in growth land.

Jack Altman 52:01 Yeah.

David George 52:01 And, like, if you look at, like, a real frame of our market, we probably have 20% market share. Now, ideally, we would have 20%, you know, the top 20%, right? Like, we would do the 20 best of-

Jack Altman 52:10 Yeah

David George 52:10 ... the 100 things. Um, but there's kind of no limit on, like, how much more we could scale.

Jack Altman 52:16 Yeah.

David George 52:16 We just want to be doing the top 20% to 25% of things. So I think you're gonna see, like, massive macro market growth. Um, I think our share could grow a little bit, but, like, that's not a goal.

Jack Altman 52:28 Yeah.

David George 52:28 Um, I think it's more, like, we can ride the wave really well and-

Jack Altman 52:32 I mean, and even keeping up with it is gonna be hard

David George 52:33 ... keeping up with it is gonna be hard, right? Um, and so our ambitions are to be involved in the best companies across all the areas that we focus on. Um, you know, they're all technology focused, but they're pretty discreet, right? Like, there's infrastructure, there's applications, there's American dynamism, there's bio health, crypto. Like, th- those all require different things. Um, but there's gonna be new waves, and so hopefully we can, like, be part of those new waves and then ride the market growth. Um, and that's, that's kind of the sum of the goal.

Jack Altman 53:03 Yeah. Love it. David, this was great. Thanks a bunch for making the time. I really enjoyed it.

David George 53:06 Yeah, me too, man. Thanks. [upbeat music]

Episode duration: 53:11

In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen

Transcript of episode 4H1FbNRdtM0

Get more out of YouTube videos.

Read along on your phone, search it beside the video, or ask your favorite AI app what was said.