By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
Dr Rangan ChatterjeeThe Most EYE OPENING Speech On Success & Happiness NOBODY SHARES! | Elizabeth Day
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Great conversations run long. Their best ideas don't have to.
uListen is free on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, and Claude.
See howTranscript
85 min read · 17,230 words- 0:00 – 0:37
Question society’s script for success and happiness
- EDElizabeth Day
Always question the premise of what you've been told makes for a successful or a happy life. It's not what society's telling you, and it's not what a company is trying to sell you. I'm a firm believer in the power of constructive pessimism [laughs] . And what I mean by that is-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I'm really excited to talk to you. You have become sort of very well known for putting failure on the map over the past few years. As a little girl, was it ever one of your dreams, when I'm older, when I'm an adult, I'm going to be an expert in failure?
- 0:37 – 1:38
Early ambitions: writing, communication, and the origin of ‘How to Fail’
- EDElizabeth Day
I love that question. What a great question. [laughs] The short answer is no, because podcasts didn't exist then [laughs] , being a child of the '80s. Um, but it was a dream of mine to communicate, and my first way of doing that was writing, because I loved books from a very, very young age, and I was very lucky in that my parents read to me, and it was a house with lots of books in it. And I remember just loving the tangible object of a book. And so aged four, which I know sounds absurdly precocious, but that's when I decided I wanted to write books myself, and then everything else has stemmed from that. And I had a career in journalism, and then I wrote my first novels. And then the podcast came unexpectedly into my life in July 2018, which we can go into more detail on. But I do remember my first failure as a child,
- 1:38 – 3:43
A first memory of failure—and why it sticks
- EDElizabeth Day
and I think it's because, as I've discovered doing the podcast, it's far easier and far more human to remember the things that have gone wrong, to remember that one time someone criticized you, rather than the hundred times someone said something nice. And so it's one of my earliest memories, and I was about two years old, and my sister had chickenpox, and she was ill in bed. She's an older sister. And I just wanted to make her feel better, and I knew that when grown-ups were sick, they liked hot water bottles [laughs] . And I knew where my parents kept them, and so I toddled off to find a hot water bottle. But I didn't know how to fill it, and obviously I was two, so I luckily didn't know how to use the tap at all. So, uh, I just went to the bathroom and I, I knew it was, there was a hot tap and a cold tap, and I chose the hot tap. I didn't wait long enough for it to heat up. So basically, this hot water bottle filled with tepid water, and then because I was two, I couldn't screw the cap on tightly enough. So when I toddled back into my sister's bedroom and gave it to her, and she clutched it to her fevered chest, it just like spilled out all over her pajamas. And she started howling, and she was even more upset than before. And I felt like such a failure. I felt terrible about it, and it's stuck in my mind ever since. And I wrote about it in a book, and my sister read it and was like, "I don't remember that at all." [laughs] So I do remember failure.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
You, you describe yourself on many occasions as being intensely competitive.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Um, and I wanna talk about that, but in relation to failure, as someone who considers themselves very competitive, or certainly has done for a lot of their life, it strikes me that talking about failure in some ways is almost at odds with that. You know, we, we often say, don't we, that authors write the books that they need to write for themselves, and given how much time you've spent writing about failure, talking about failure, I guess there's something there, isn't there, whereby-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... this is an, this is something you've had to address for you.
- 3:43 – 6:09
Competitiveness vs. vulnerability: two drives that coexist
- EDElizabeth Day
Definitely. And it does feel like a bit of a contradiction, unless I'm competing to be the best at failure. [laughs] But no, I'm, I'm joking. Um, I think I'm competitive in certain ways, in the give me a metric and I will try and nail it. I will try my hardest to get the best marks, uh, to win the race. And that exists separately in my head from my yearning to share and connect. So I believe that if I have a purpose, it is to connect and communicate with others, and I need to do that to feel human. And I believe, and have come to know, that the quickest form of connection is by sharing vulnerability, by sharing the failures, the things that have gone wrong, the things that you didn't manage, and that's a shortcut to who someone really is. And so the two things can coexist for me, and I, I actually don't think that my comp- to, my competitive aspect is innate to me. I think it's a learned response to various problems that probably don't exist anymore. But because I'm so used to it, it's difficult for me to get out of that mindset, and I need to make an active effort to get out of it and to remind myself what really matters. And it's not someone saying, "Oh, you're number one in this arbitrary list." It's actually someone saying, "Thank you for that podcast episode. It helped me through a really rough patch." And it's more meaningful when it's an individual rather than a mass. So I'm, I'm striving to get better at not being as competitive.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And I'm always c- I should say, sorry, that I'm mostly competitive with myself. I, I have high standards for myself, and that can be quite an exhausting way to live.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I, I wanna talk more about competition. Maybe we'll come back to that a little bit later. Um, you mentioned there that you realize when you share, when you are vulnerable, that it's a shortcut to connection. Do you remember when was the first time you realized that?
- 6:09 – 7:39
Shame, silence, and the first big lesson in being real
- EDElizabeth Day
That's, again, that's given me an enormous pause for thought. Um, I can remem- I, I actually think it was quite late on for me, [laughs] very late on. I think it was in my 30s, which for me were a decade of intense transition, where I had met someone who I got married to, and that turned out to be the wrong relationship for me. And I felt an enormous amount of shame in admitting that, even to myself, and so I didn't admit it to anyone for a really, really long time. And when it finally got to the stage where I felt that to continue in that relationship would be at the cost of losing myself, and I had to leave, I was astonished, pleasantly astonished, by how the people closest to me responded in such a positive way. As in, they were just unquestioningly supportive. All of the things that I'd been fearful of, the shame. Like, people who'd come to our wedding and given us gifts, I felt such shame over that. It sounds trivial, but it was actually, like, indicative of m- far bigger feeling of shame and responsibility and guilt. And actually, my best friend Emma, who's in the audience tonight, just immediately got it and said, "I love you more when you're not on a pedestal, when you're being real, when you're being authentic and vulnerable." And that was a huge wake-up call for me. So, I think it was probably that moment.
- 7:39 – 11:59
Podcast vulnerability and the power of speaking what’s hidden
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. And that's very powerful. And I guess having a, a, a close network, close friends who you can, you know, take off those masks and be yourself is, is incredibly powerful. Um, sharing, though, with your friends is very different from sharing on a podcast like yours, which has a huge reach. So, as someone who also shares a lot on my own podcast, I guess I'm really interested in this, because I feel that my podcast, for me, has taught me-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... has, uh, showcased to me the power of sharing, about being vulnerable, about sharing things that maybe, you know, the truth is for much of my life I'd be too ashamed to admit to anyone. But I remember, I think it was episode 37, I had, um, this wonderful gentleman called Dr. Gabor Maté on the show, and I remember admitting some stuff to Gabor in conversation that I don't think I'd ever said in public before. And I remember just seeing the response-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... and seeing how it connected with people. And I, I, I don't think that for me there, there was one big moment where I suddenly realized, oh, this is important. But I think the more I did it, the more liberating it felt for me, the more freeing it felt, the more it connected with other people. So I, I certainly feel my podcast has taught me that probably more than my own personal life. Do you know what I mean?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah. I do. I do know exactly what you mean, which is that sometimes what you think of as the most personal thing can have a degree of universal resonance that you could never have imagined if you kept it inside yourself. And I think that's the thing about shame, the precondition to shame is silence. Once you make the decision not to be silent, the shame dissipates. And not only that, but it's a generous act for other people who might be feeling the same kind of shame. And similarly to you, the podcast was where I first opened up about my fertility journey, and that was something that, again, I hadn't ever spoken about beyond my core group of friends. But also society, I don't feel, really spoke about way back in 2014 when I was going through it. And I was so shocked to discover so many other people felt the same, and they were grateful that someone had said something, and that in turn made me feel less alone and more seen, and that's the beauty of a conversation that's grounded in vulnerability. And you mentioned earlier that thing of, like, wearing a mask, and I think for a lot of my childhood and perhaps, I know that y- you might be able to relate to this, and perhaps many listeners and members of the audience here will be able to relate to it, I grew up in an environment where emotions were largely repressed. That's a generational function, but it's also a function of the fact that I grew up in the north of Ireland at a time when it was riven with civil war, basically, [laughs] and where you had to be very careful what you said. And m- the most meaningful things were often left unsaid, because it was a dangerous climate to exist in, especially when you have an English accent like me. And so I got very used to wearing a series of masks, and at some point, I made a deliberate decision to be different from that, because I don't, that's not how I wanted to live my life, 'cause it feels like you're consigning yourself to a life half-lived if you never take the risk of being yourself.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah, the risk of being yourself. I mean, it's, it's quite a contradiction in many ways, but I completely agree. The, it is a risk, isn't it? Anything, when it comes to connecting with others, whether it's a partner or a friend, there kind of is an element of risk. But it's, it's by taking that risk that we actually do connect, and-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... you know, conversely, actually, I think when we try and play it too safe, like I also have done for much of my life, um, you don't really connect. You know, you don't connect with others. You don't even connect with yourself. You, you start to actually, I think you are, you start to disguise yourself to yourself.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
You don't actually know who you are anymore.
- 11:59 – 17:34
Control, the unknown, and why growth lives in the ‘dark space’
- EDElizabeth Day
Totally. And, and I think you can be very fearful of the unknown, which is completely understandable. Because if you're seeking to exert control, an illusory control over your life, then obviously you don't want to go into the dark corner and you don't know what's kinda lurking there for you. But where else are you going to grow into- If it isn't the unknown. [laughs] Like, actually another word for the unknown is the space left to be explored, and I think that that's a really important thing to remember, that actually there's like opportunity and adventure and growth and self-worth can often lie in that dark space that you're so scared of, and it is taking that leap that will open all of those-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... opportunities for you.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I, I remember, um, a few years ago, a chap coming in to the consultation room, uh, a young man who was basically addicted to online pornography. And, and I can sort of remember the way he came in and the way he looked to me, i.e., he couldn't look at me. Eyes were down. He was literally ridden with shame.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I think I was the first person he'd actually told. Um, and shame thrives in secrecy.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And it was so liberating for him. I, I, I know, I thought at the time, but I certainly know since, to actually be able to open up, tell someone. I actually remember saying to him, "I've seen many people like you this week." It was, it... You could just see, go, "Well, I'm not alone."
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Because shame often does that. You know, you think you're the only one. And it wasn't actually that difficult to help him, um, get through that and understand that that was a symptom of a lack of belonging, a lack of community in his life, but it all started with him being able to open up. And I think many people these days, unfortunately, don't feel as though they have those people who they can open up with. Maybe, or maybe they do and they don't feel comfortable doing it, so they go to like a, a third party, like a doctor or a therapist.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Which, again, can be very powerful. But all these things, like shame, addiction, um, guilt, they, they thrive in secrecy, don't they?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes. The, i- it's that thing of fearing that you're the only one.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And I, and I suppose that's what lies behind that whole premise. You know, every mental health awareness campaign is rooted in the idea that it's good to talk and it, and you must talk, and it can be lifesaving to talk. Which is absolutely true, but sometimes I think that when you're in the darkest depths of despair, it's really hard to talk. It's really hard to verbalize what you're feeling. And sometimes, for me anyway, it's easier to write, and that's why it's incredibly important that there are text help lines as well for people who are in very dark frames of mind. But that's how I make sense of the world, and that's how I continue to share and continue to release any sense of shame that I have. Do you have that with your writing?
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah, I think, I think writing for me helps me get to know myself better. Uh, I, I love the writing process. I love the kind of, the starting process where you think, "Okay, what can I create? What can I put together that is actually a, a fresh idea?" But, but I think speaking to what you're talking about, I feel that at the end of each book or even through the process of writing it, I, I understand myself better.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Particularly with this last one, I must be honest. It, in many ways I feel both the podcast and the books, although in some ways they're very selfless things to do because they help so many people, in other ways they're actually very selfish things to do because I get so much out of them personally.
- EDElizabeth Day
And the two can coexist.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. Exactly.
- EDElizabeth Day
I, I think we've been taught that they're mutually exclusive, but they're not. Because actually you need to pay yourself as much attention and as much kindness as you would pay your best friend or the reader of your book or the listener of your podcast. It's that cliche of putting on your oxygen mask first.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. No, for sure. I wanna talk about... Well, we'll get to your new book, Magpie, shortly. Failosophy: A Handbook for When Things Go Wrong is-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... just brilliant.
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs] Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Honestly, it really is.
- EDElizabeth Day
Thank you.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
It's just, um-
- EDElizabeth Day
I'm gonna quote you on the next edition.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Please do.
- 17:34 – 20:18
Redefining failure: plans, catastrophic events, and finding meaning over time
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes. So my definition of failure changed during the time that I started the podcast. So I started the podcast in July 2018, and I hadn't really thought about what failure actually was. I hadn't re- I hadn't done that thing of looking it up in the dictionary. I just sort of thought I, I knew. And actually, part of the joy of the podcast is understanding how other people view failure and what they categorize as their failures. But after about two years of doing the podcast, I realized that I needed to get more precise about it. And so my definition of failure is when something doesn't go according to plan. And then you have to think to question, well, whose plan is it? Is it my plan? Is it society's plan? Or is it a plan that is informed by social conditioning? And then you question the very metrics of what success and failure are. But the other side to that definition is that sometimes there are failures so cataclysmic that there doesn't seem to be any plan at all. So a failure like a global pandemic, a chronic illness, a death, those failures cannot be easily assimilated in the way that, say, a failed driving test could. So it would be monstrous of me to sit here and say, "You just learn from all failures, and it makes you a better person," because some failures will be life shaping, and they won't just go away. But it's my profound belief that in the fullness of time, and you must allow yourself the grieving process, but in the fullness of time, I believe that every single failure can teach us something meaningful, something that we needed to know. That's not to say that the failure in and of itself has meaning, but we can choose to find the meaning by living alongside it. So that's my definition of failure.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
There's a definition of happiness by Mo Gawdat that you've written about in the book, and, um, I've spoken to Mo about on my podcast like you have. And I see a, I see a kind of similarity i- in a really nice way, where Mo talks about happiness being greater than or equal to our, um, perception of events-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... minus our expectation.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Right? Which I think is really beautiful.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And you're saying failure is what happens when things don't go according to plan, which kind of speaks to, you know, your expectation about the plan and it not getting there, you know, it not meeting up to that. And so what do you think is the relationship between failure and happiness?
- 20:18 – 26:09
Happiness, expectations, and ‘constructive pessimism’ as a risk tool
- EDElizabeth Day
Well, first of all, I love Mo to distraction, and, um, he came on my podcast in twenty nineteen and changed the course of the podcast, but also changed the course of my life. Like, I, I honestly consider him to be my... a, a dear friend, but also my own personal life guru because that way of thinking was so unbelievably helpful to me. Alongside another part of his algorithm is that you are not your worst thoughts, and the anxious narration of your stressed out brain is not who you are as a person, and there is a way of training yourself out of that. And he talks about giving his brain a name, and he calls his brain Becky because he imagines her as this annoying girl at school who was always pointing out the things that would [laughs] go wrong. And, um, and when his Becky brain offers him something that is very negative, like you're a rubbish parent or you're a failure in business, he stops himself and says, "Becky, what's your objective evidence for that assertion?"
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
"Because if you don't have objective evidence, I'd like you to take that negative thought and replace it with a positive one." And it sounds unhinged, and there'll be a lot of stopping yourself in the street talking to yourself, but it genuinely works-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... because you question the premise. And I think that's the relation. Always question the premise of what you've been told makes for a successful or a happy life because we are all individuals, and so our answer to that question will by necessity be unique and individual to us. It's not what society's telling you, and it's not what a company is trying to sell you. Your definition of each has to be fully grounded in your intuitive knowledge of who you are. And to get to know that instinct, you need to find your own path to it, but a lot of the time you need quiet and stillness and peace and to switch off from the white noise around you. And I think that's the relation. It's like, I could constantly make myself feel like a failure over and over again by having plans for myself that are far too lofty and unrealistic. I used to be someone with a five-year plan, and my five-year plans were things of infinite and varied beauty, and I would know exactly what job I'd be doing. I'd know exactly what relationship I'd have, where I'd be living, what kind of coffee I'd be drinking, and then I'd get to that five-year point, and I'd be five years older. I'd be living in a different city, I'd have given up coffee-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
... I was doing a different job, and that relationship had ended. And so I didn't want any of the same things, but because I hadn't achieved them according to the plan that I'd set myself five years earlier, I felt like a failure. And after a while, I just thought,, I don't want to live my life like that. And so that, I think, is the relation between Mo's algorithm and how I think of failure. It's, it's all really about being in the present moment, but also, and this isn't Mo, but I'm a firm believer in the power of constructive pessimism. [laughs] And what I mean by that is imagine the worst thing that could happen. So if you're going for a promotion at work and you're scared about the interview process, what's the worst thing that could happen? The worst thing that could happen is that you get found out, you get fired, you lose your job, and you spiral from there on out. Could you cope with that? You might not want to, but could you cope with that? And you probably could cope with that.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
So in a world where you conceive of the worst possible outcome, the best possible outcome also has to exist. The best possible outcome, you get the promotion, you become CEO, you become a billionaire by the time you're thirty-five. Also unlikely. [laughs] The extremes are unlikely. The most likely route is somewhere down the middle, and I find that a really helpful way of, of evaluating what risks I, I want to take, rather than having-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... this rigid five-year plan.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I l- I love that because, you know, having the five-year plan By your definition of failure, you know, things not going to plan, you- you're just setting up a, a kind of almost an un-meetable target.
- EDElizabeth Day
Totally. Just throw out the plan. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah, throw out the plan, exactly. Um, and I guess it's, it's not that there's necessarily anything wrong with having a rough plan. I think it's, or certainly to me, if we cling too tightly to it, we don't allow space for life to happen, things to change-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... us to evolve as people. So for, for me, plans, I, I kind of think more of as kind of, I don't know, just like a, a compass of, um, sort of where I wanna set the direction for my life going forward, but leaving lots of room and space for things to develop and evolve depending on who I meet, how I might evolve, what I might think in the future, uh, rather than having that fixed plan.
- EDElizabeth Day
I totally agree, that you can have a mood board, a metaphorical mood board for the future.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And obviously, you know, you should save for a pension, like you can have that kind of plan, but it's more about being able to do something practical today towards that.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And if you can't, then there's no point worrying about your future self, because you haven't met that person yet. But you know yourself as you are now, and I think you're, you're, you're totally right. You can have a kind of rough idea, but for me, I think my issue was I'd overintellectualize and overanalyze life. [laughs] And so I was trying to, like, squeeze it all into some kind of timetable, and actually, that was making me unhappy, because like you, I really value being able to respond to things in the moment and feeling like, "Oh, that's an interesting person," or, "a great opportunity. Let me do that," rather than feeling stuck.
- 26:09 – 31:41
Spirituality, faith, and choosing a meaning-making framework
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Would you describe yourself as spiritual in any way?
- EDElizabeth Day
I would. I don't know if other people would, but, um, I would, and I have always had a belief in something greater than us, and there are many different things that you can call that. Some people are uncomfortable with the word God, which I completely understand, but you can call it the universe. Um, we can be very scientific about it and just call it the fact that every single atom that exists has existed here forever. Have I got that right? You're more of a scientist. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
Okay. Which means that anyone who has ever died, any being who's ever died, makes up the atoms all around us. Isn't that mind- And in us.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mind-blowing. So I think there's a great convergence of science and spirituality, and yes, I believe that there is something greater than us, a more evolved being of some description or a collective consciousness or soul that we can lean back into and have faith in.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
The reason I ask is because as I have gone through this book, there's lots of little bits in it which make me feel, "Yeah, I, I wonder if Elizabeth is or regards herself as spiritual." There's something I underlined on page four, which if you don't mind, I'm gonna read out to you. Your-
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... your own words. "I firmly cling to the belief that the universe is unfolding exactly as is intended, and that although we as imperfect humans can't hope to understand it all at the time-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... life will generally teach us the lessons we need to learn if we're open to the possibility."
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah. I, I, I still believe that, and again, I know that that's not for everyone, but I believe that, and that's how I choose to live my life.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I think the words there are really telling. "That's what, that's how I choose to live my life." I, I love it. I actually, uh, I also subscribe to that belief. I also choose to subscribe to that belief-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... because I feel it helps us deal with those inevitable obstacles and stresses that are gonna come up if I believe that there is actually a reason or this is meant to happen, I'm meant to learn a lesson here.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
As you say, not everyone has to believe in that. I find just generally I'm happier and more content when I believe that.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
That sort of approach, I would think, helps someone deal with failure.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Is that something you feel you've always had, or you feel that you've really tuned into more since talking to people week in, week out for, what, four years now?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
On the subject of failure.
- EDElizabeth Day
I've definitely tuned into it more.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
I, I've had it for most of my life. Like, I remember I didn't grow up in a religious household, but I remember around the age of seven feeling that there was something bigger than us, and but it's, but it's been genuinely through the people that I've met doing the podcast, through the extraordinary conversations that I've been privileged to have, and I know you feel the same with your guests, that has... I d- I feel like I've connected with other people who see the world as I do, but who have also informed and evolved my thinking on it. So absolutely, it's b- it's definitely become a, a much bigger part of my daily practice now.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. Failure as a concept, as a term, I'm fascinated. You've spoken to a lot of people now who reveal their three failures to you.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Which-
- EDElizabeth Day
You among them.
- 31:41 – 38:01
Who gets to fail: privilege, gender patterns, and changing norms around vulnerability
- EDElizabeth Day
E- that's a super interesting question, and I will take the second half first, which is that I think there are people in the modern world who are given continuous chances to fail upwards. [laughs] One might look at our government and see some of them there, who, um, these are beacons of privilege. They are people who have had everything. They've had the most elite educations. They've, they're born white and male and into the image of the world, and they get repeated chances. Now, if you are a marginalized person in any way, someone who lives with a chronic illness, someone who's a carer, a person of color, you are not given as many chances to fail, and that is something that I absolutely feel that I have to acknowledge any single time I talk about failure, because my experience of it as a white middle class woman is by necessity going to be very different. But interestingly, I had a, a fascinating conversation recently with a, a forthcoming guest on How to Fail, who is a brilliant novelist, and she is a young Black woman, and she believes that talk of privilege is actually flattening the discourse, because she's someone who studied maths at Cambridge, had an incredibly lucrative job in the city for 10 years, and she's like, "You know, actually, I have privileges myself that get obscured if we're just talking about who I am as a Black woman," and she prefers not to focus on race for that reason. And I thought that that was a really interesting and evolved way at looking at something, which, because I am who I am, I don't have as much nuance in that. So I'm constantly being educated. In terms of men and women, I definitely noticed when I first started the podcast, so it launched in July 2018, and I genuinely didn't really know what I was doing. I just knew that I wanted to do this kind of interview. I drew my own logo, as you can probably tell, with felt tip pens one night.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
I, um, I, like, hired a sound engineer who I found on Google. I DM'd a hummus company and asked if [laughs] they wanted to sponsor the first season-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
... which they did. And, um, and then I basically asked my friends and contacts to be my first eight guests. And I'd been a journalist by then for 15-odd years, so I had quite a lot of contacts. And what I noticed was that every single man I approached said to me, "Well, I don't think I have failed."
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
So [laughs] probably not for me, this podcast. And I was like, "Okay. But would you, would you just consider doing an interview?" He was, "Okay, well I'll, I'll do, I'll do the interview, but I d- I haven't failed, so..."
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
So I was like, okay, it's up to me as the interviewer. And every single woman I approached, bar one, said, "God, I failed so many times, I can't whittle it down to just three." And it was fascinating, because when I got to do each of those interviews, of course those men had failed, and they were wonderful guests, and they really opened up. It's just that they hadn't categorized their mistakes or their phases where they experienced less success. They hadn't categorized it as a failure in their own head, whereas the women had no issue with that. And what I think was going on there was that if you are lucky enough to be born into a world that is friendly to who you are from the outset, you're less likely to think of a failure in that way. You see it as an overcomeable obstacle on your path to eventual success, because eventual success is guaranteed for you.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
But if you are a woman, a marginalized person, a person of color, you're far less likely to see that, and a failure can be a really difficult and permanent knockback. And that was just really interesting. I'd never thought of that in quite that way before, and I think it's partly why we still live in a world where overwhelmingly women won't put themselves forward for promotions if they meet six out of ten of the criteria. There's been some research done in Carnegie Mellon University about this. Whereas a man who meets six out of ten of the criteria will think, "Well, I'm overqualified and I've got this in the bag."
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
And they will go for it, and they will put themselves forwards. Now, I have to say that that was 2018, and that has changed beyond measure the more of the podcast that I've done and the more the, the world has changed around it. And now I get amazing men like you, who come ready, willing, able, and humble, and open up genuinely about their failures rather than using it as an excuse to humble brag, which used to happen. But, um, now there's... I, I don't see any difference, and I think that we do men a disservice by assuming that they're not categorizing it as failure because they're already arrogant.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
It's actually because so many of them weren't able, they weren't equipped emotionally and they weren't given the license emotionally to open up about those kind of things. And now, you know, we live in a far less binary age in all senses, and I'm so grateful for that, and I feel like all genders are so much more open to vulnerability, and I'm really proud to be a tiny part of that.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah, I, I think what you said there about the difference between men and women, I think is so powerful, especially not to then jump to that obvious conclusion. Uh, but actually, there is more nuance, because we're all influenced hugely by the way that we're brought up, and how we see the world, how our parents did, what the people around us did. If we did have, you know, people around us who were succeeding, we probably expected we're gonna succeed as well, and therefore, you're right. Uh, you can totally see how our, um, perception of whether that is called a failure, 'cause failure still, I think, has a negative connotation around it. I think that's one of the big problems for me, when I think about the term failure. Failure can actually be a beautiful thing.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Right? It can be a wonderful thing. It can be a tool for growth and progression and evolution in who we are. But I still think you hear the word failure, certainly for me, certainly for, I think, for a lot of society, I think the first thing that comes up is, i- is kind of a negative thought. Failure is bad.
- 38:01 – 44:21
Language that harms: medical ‘failure’ talk, fertility, and identity labels
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah. Well, I think it's quite a dehumanizing term. Like, y- you hear about systems failures, don't you [laughs] ?
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
You don't hear about someone who just had a bad day. I mean, you do, but it's not, it's not seen in the same way, and that's why I'm really passionate about de-stigmatizing the language, 'cause language is so incredibly powerful. And one of the examples that I give is my own experiences with fertility medicine, where, um, again, this is going back quite a few years, but when I first did IVF in 2014, I was repeatedly seen by male consultants, and some of them were great. But the one thing that a male consultant could never fully empathize with is what it was like to have a miscarriage. Like, they hadn't had periods, so how could they... Th- it's a leap of imaginative empathy that happened to lie beyond some of those consultants. By no means all. But I was repeatedly told that I was failing to respond to the drugs, and this is something I've spoken about a lot before. A friend of mine was told that she had an inhospitable womb. Someone else was told that their cervix was incompetent. Like, this is language-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Medical jargon, honestly.
- EDElizabeth Day
Well, I know [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
It's just, failure to thrive, failure to respond. It's like it's-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... it's nuts.
- EDElizabeth Day
And I so want to hear what you have to say about it, because medicine is all about the human, and yet so much of the language is dehumanizing, and is designed to make you feel like you're the system that's failing. And when you are a woman who has grown up in a culture that rightly or wrongly has made you believe that your biological prerogative is to have children, and you're not doing that, you already feel like a failure in your own head. And then to be told that there's this additional layer of failure where, for some reason, you're this weirdo who won't f- respond to these drugs that we give everyone else, was really hurtful.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And that's why the language is really important. And actually, I've been contacted by a lot of people in the medical profession since speaking openly about it, who are so willing and open to change. And I had this beautiful experience in the last couple of years of being treated by a woman who used such warm language. So y- she com- this is probably way too much information. She was talking about my internal organs. She, you know, I, I had an issue with my womb, and I, again, I'd been used to being told things like, "Oh, it's inhospitable," et cetera. And she just said, "Your womb is a beautiful room, and it has these columns, and we need to remove the columns to make more space." And I was like, that, just that, seems so simple.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
But it made me feel so seen and safe, and like I wasn't at fault. So just tiny things like that. But tell me about your perception of medical language.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I mean, there's so many ways to, to tackle this. I, I, I th- I think it's incredibly problematic. I've come to the conclusion that a lot of what we're taught as doctors and the jargon around it only serves to make us more and more disconnected with the people we're talking to. You know, they say in medical school, I think you learn the equivalent of a new language.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
So y- you're literally learning that many new terms and words, but the problem is then when you wanna, um, communicate [laughs] with people who are not, who've never learned that language, then you c- then you've got a bit of a problem-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... unless you can translate it in a way that means something to them. And, and I think the way we communicate as doctors, I, I really feel it's cr- it's crucial to the outcome as well.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
It's not just a nice thing to do. It influences how someone feels. It influences whether someone feels they've got autonomy over their life and their body and what happens, or whether they feel like a passive kinda recipient of something. Um, e- even the way we label people, I'm very careful now in a way I probably wasn't 10, 15 years ago. Like, I, I'd like to think I was, but I think I've learnt and evolved, where I don't even like saying, you know, "You've got depression," for example, or, "You've got type 2 diabetes." For me, it's some- it's always, "Well, look, at the moment, your blood sugar is consistent with a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes," or, "You've got symptoms that, yeah, they are consistent with a diagnosis of depression." But by not labeling them, "So you are depressed," you know, "I have depression," that then makes the illness become a part of who that person is.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And then it can be very difficult to free yourself from that label. So, um, I don't know. W- was that clear the way I said that?
- EDElizabeth Day
It was so clear, and I love it. And I wanted to ask you a question about where you think medical terminology arose from. Did it arise from the need for a clinician to distance themselves? Because if you're connecting- On the level that we've been talking about with vulnerability, with openness, with honesty to every single patient, is there a risk that you just can't take all of that pain on? That y- actually you need to slightly step back from that empathetic flexing of a muscle?
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. I mean, I don't know the truth where- where this has come from. I don't know the, in detail, the history of it, but, you know, I imagine it was done with the right intentions. And I also think medicine used to be very much of the model where patient comes in, there was a kind of paternalistic relationship where the doctor would tell you what was wrong and tell you what you needed to do. Therefore, you know, did you need to connect? Was it not just, you know, tell me the prescriptions, tell me the diagnosis. Whereas I think it's evolved because a lot of what we see now, you know, I think 80 to 90% of what we see is in some way related to our collective modern lifestyles.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And therefore, that didactic approach I don't think works very well. It has to be a partnership. The patient has to be an active participant. How can you be an active participant if you don't understand the language the other person's speaking? And you said before about what that, um, female fertility doctor said-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... to you, and you felt seen, you felt heard, right? You felt held.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Well, you know, this is what we all want-
- 44:21 – 48:59
Failure in medicine: perfectionism, fear, and the lack of space to process mistakes
- EDElizabeth Day
Final question on this, though. [laughs] So, um, my father's a doctor, so I literally have a paternalistic relationship with medicine. [laughs] And he's a very good one. Retired now. But, um, I interviewed at the height of the COVID pandemic an, an ICU doctor called Jim Down, who then wrote a book about it, and after I interviewed Jim, I spoke to my father about it and he said, "Well, did you ask him about the fact that failure in medicine is this huge shadow that remains unspoken a lot of the time?" Because you fear it, because actually if you make the wrong call in a situation, that's literally life ending. Do you-- So do you think that you have a medical perception of failure?
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. I think, um, if you think about medical school even, and I think, you know, doctors in general, in my experience, and I'm, I'm well aware there are some doctors in the audience, some of my good friends, so they might have a different, uh, viewpoint to this. But for me, I think medicine attracts a lot of super competitive people.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Uh, I think a lot of people end up in medicine not because they wanted to do it, but because they were good at school and it was a good career path. And I, I, I think failure is something... It is, medical school is quite competitive. I, I certainly remember being in the old Royal Infirmary in Edinburgh, you know, with, you know, being scared of being asked a question by the professor and being literally petrified I'm gonna get something wrong. Um, which is no real way to learn productively, [laughs] is it?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Um, I also remember as you asked that question, a moment when I was a, uh, in my second year as a junior doctor. Back then, you know, you were a junior house officer in your first year, and then after that you were a senior house officer. And I remember I was at the Western General in, um, Edinburgh, and I started off on a week of nights and, um, we didn't really have much cover in the hospital. I was like, oh, after me there's no registrar, there's just a consultant and they're at home. That's your- you and your other SHO are literally running the hospital at nights. You'd only qualified a year ago. And I remember a sick patient came in to the coronary care unit, and I can't remember the exact ins and outs of what happened, but I certainly felt a bit out of my depth. I think I was trying to get some help. But I do remember the next morning, the consultant on the ward rounds, um, made me feel as though I had done something wrong or I delayed something that was really important. And, you know, that doesn't feel good. You know, and I'm sure many doctors and medical students have had that experience where you're like, "Oh man, should I have done something earlier?" You know. And you kind of internalize that. I don't think there's any good mechanism to talk about that stuff in medicine.
- EDElizabeth Day
No.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
So, um, yeah, that kind of stuff sits with you and I think drives you on to think you have to be perfect and you can't make a mistake. But why would a doctor not make a mistake? What, what... When, who... Which human being doesn't make a mistake? We, we sort of think, don't we, that maybe a doctor has to be this superhero who never makes a mistake, but how realistic is that based upon how fallible all of us are as humans?
- EDElizabeth Day
Totally. I think we're extra scared about doctors making mistakes-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... because of what it might mean for us and the trust that we place in them, but that was exactly my dad's point, that there is no way in the hospital system to acknowledge failures and move on from it because everyone's sort of scared about it, and that's super interesting hearing your insight. 'Cause I failed to ask that question of Dr. [laughs] Jim Down, and so I've been just searching for a doctor ever since-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
... that I can ask that of. So thank you. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
No, no worries. Um, you have these seven failure principles-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... uh, which I wanna get through. Um, but before we do that, 'cause I think they're very, very instructive and they're gonna be very helpful for people. You have been very, very open about a lot of your failures or what you consider to be your failures. Um, I guess there's quite, there's quite a few I wanted to talk about.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
There was one that really got my attention.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
It was to do with anger.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
"Failure to express my anger. Instead, masking it with socially acceptable sadness."
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Can you elaborate?
- 48:59 – 53:44
Anger, ‘good girl’ conditioning, and the hidden costs of suppression
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes, I'm thrilled to elaborate. I've leaned into my rage in my 40s. [laughs] So that all came about because I remember, again, I'm just gonna quote Emma, um, who is my best friend. She's also a psychotherapist, which is just the best possible combination, and she's who I do Best Friend Therapy with, my other podcast. And, uh, it was when I was going through that marital breakdown that I referred to earlier, and she said to me, "How are you feeling?" And first of all, I found it difficult to answer because actually I think I tend to go numb when I'm in crisis and to disassociate from my body. But then I said, "I'm feeling really sad." She was like, "Mm, do you?" [laughs] Or might you feel angry but you feel like sadness is more palatable? And it really unlocked something in me, because actually there was so much that I was angry about, but I hadn't ever allowed myself to acknowledge it. And I think it's because as a society, we're not tremendously comfortable with anger, and we're not comfortable particularly when anger is expressed by people or genders who we stereotypically expect to be compassionate and kind and pliant and pleasant people-pleasers. And as a girl who was raised in the '80s, I was one of those. And I remember vividly when I was about 10 locking myself into a cupboard at school because I was about to lose my temper, and I locked myself into this cupboard and I had a talk, I, like, gave myself a good talking to and I was like, "You cannot be this angry person because no one will want to be friends with you. You need to leave your temper behind." And from that day, like, I've never lost my temper unless I'm behind a wheel in a car. [laughs] Like, road rage is absolutely where it comes out for me. [laughs] 'Cause I feel protected only when I'm driving on my own. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
And no one else is there to witness it. And, um, I, I think a lot of people can relate to that, and I know that a lot of women can relate to it. And so throughout my 20s I sort of masked my anger, and then in my mid-30s my life kind of imploded and I realized that I was really angry about how I'd allowed myself to be treated and what I'd allowed society to tell me was acceptable. And if I can talk a bit more about women specifically, angry women are misinterpreted through the centuries, and they're either made absurd or shrewish or crazy or unhinged or completely maligned as sort of benign. So someone like Rosa Parks, who sits in the whites-only bit of the bus and launches a whole aspect of the civil rights movement, through history has been portrayed as a sort of benign old woman. "Oh, a little old lady who just one day was sick of it." She was a furious, a righteously furious civil rights activist for years up to that point. And that's just one example. There are loads of other examples of, of women whose anger, they've been disenfranchised from claiming it. And so I just realized that part of the reason that happens is because anger, when used appropriately and when used in solidarity with other people's anger, can often be an enormous force for good social change. And I think we saw that with Black Lives Matter, for instance. Like, what is protest if it isn't anger founded in the need to make a change for the better? And so I've really learned now to acknowledge my anger when it rises, rather than tamping it down-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... and denying it and pretending it's something else, because actually then you end up, like we were talking about at the very beginning of this conversation, you end up masking yourself to yourself, and that's not a comfortable way to live.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Something I, I think about a lot these days is about emotional stress, and I, I say a lot these days that emotional stress is real. It's not neutral. It has to be processed in some way.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And when I think of your story there, you know, little girl, lock yourself up in the cupboard, give yourself a talking to-
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... and you never then lose your temper again.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
You know, that is pretty profound. Maybe 20, 25 years before you actually sort of-
- EDElizabeth Day
It was
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... deal with that, what was the cost of suppressing your anger?
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
You know, what, what, how did that show up in your life? Because that anger has got to go somewhere.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Right? It doesn't just vanish just 'cause you decided not to show your temper in public.
- 53:44 – 1:01:33
People-pleasing, manipulation, and learning direct communication
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes. I think alongside anger, I suppressed a lot of my own desires. So my way of going through life was to try and be really good [laughs] and to try and tick every box, to pass every exam, to please every employer when I got into the workplace, to say yes to the overtime and to the jobs that other people didn't want to do, in the hopes that I would eventually be rewarded for being a good girl, a good person. [laughs] And the knock-on effect of that, and I did it in my romantic relationships as well, when a, when a boyfriend would say, "Where do you want to go for lunch?" I genuinely wouldn't know. I'd say, "I don't mind. Wherever you want to go. I don't..." To an extent that it ended up sickening me and I, I just, I lost sight of what I wanted in my life, because what I was doing was creating a scenario where I was people-pleasing to such a degree that I was outsourcing my sense of self to other people's opinions of me. And at that point- You realize that it's not sustainable. [laughs] At some point, I believe you have to make a decision to live your own life according to what you want, and so I think that's how it played out. I got into a series of relationships, romantically, in friendships, at work, that did not serve me, but they definitely served the other people involved. I just spent all of my time trying to please them. And the irony is, is that I didn't end up pleasing them because I ended up letting them down because I wasn't being honest about myself, because I'd forgotten who that was. And I think that's how it played out, that I had to get to a point where I hit a wall [laughs] and it could not continue. And the cost of that was that I imploded my life, and I ended a lot of relationships, most notably that marriage I spoke about. And that's, like, a huge thing to do, and it hurts other people. And I think that many of us are taught the myth that people-pleasing is a self- a selfless act. And actually, the extent to which I took it, it ended up being selfish, because I needed to take the time to know myself, be in tune with my desires, and to understand what I was feeling and what I wanted from life.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
So much I wanna talk about with respect to people-pleasing. I resonate with so much of that. I think I described myself to you on your show as a people-pleaser in recovery-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... um, which I think fits, sits very nicely with me. I think one of the, one of the most instructive things I think I've learnt about people-pleasing, and I can have compassion where it comes from, because I think, honestly, for most of us, it comes from a place of lack, about not feeling good enough in who we are-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... so we have to act in a certain way to get that validation and love from other people. But it's when I came to learn that actually, in some ways, it's quite a manipulative thing to do. We're actually trying to manipulate other people's perception of us. How does that sit with you?
- EDElizabeth Day
Uncomfortably, but it's probably true. [laughs] I think both are true. I think, um, the sense of ensuring safety because no one is annoyed with you, that can be quite a primal thing, and that, that feels very real or did feel very real to me. 'Cause like you, I'm a recovering people-pleaser. [laughs] Um, and yes, I think there is absolutely an element of manipulation to that because you're trying to control the uncontrollable. You're trying to seek safety by controlling others' responses to you. And if you're good at it, that can absolutely be a form of manipulation. And I think I was doing it unconsciously, but it wasn't making me happy, and it definitely wasn't making the people I was with happy either.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
Because there's a fundamental lack of honesty there, I think. And now I really check myself. Actually, literally today, I had to write an email to get some information that I needed that I was owed, and it was an email directed at someone who is not being very good at their job. [laughs] And I had to stop myself from saying, "I'm just checking in on this." I stripped out the word just. I was like, "I don't want my email to have mitigating words that are designed to make this person feel warmly towards me. I need to get my point across, and I need to make sure that they do what they said they were going to do." And so as opposed to saying, "I was just wondering," and, "Would you mind?" and, "I'm so sorry to bother you," and l- you know, "Lots of love, xxx," [laughs] I was like, "No." I need to communicate a straightforward message because that's not just about me. That's also about paying respect to the other person. They need to know where they stand. They need to know what my expectation is, and they need to know what the contract is.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. That, that's really powerful, I think. Really, really powerful. Because even when we walk that path of recovery from people-pleasing, like many people are doing or certainly trying to do, you can fall into those little old habits in correspondence like that-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... soften everything, make sure they like you as you do it. And it's, you, as you say, it's a, it's a disservice to yourself. It's a disservice to other people, and there's a kind of fear, isn't there? It comes down to a fear of being honest.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah, and a fear of being disliked as well, which probably has its roots in many millennia ago when it genuinely was a matter of life or death whether you were going to isolate yourself from a tribe or not. Like, being part of a tribe was a means of protecting yourself.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And that instinct is still extremely strong in us, as it should be, because it's also a driver against loneliness. Like, we seek out the companionship of other people, and there's been lots of research that shows that not having friends is more damaging to your life expectation than smoking 20 cigarettes a day.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
So it has an important function, but I think sometimes we take it to an extreme, and we override the positive aspect of that function, and we're just trying to grab any safety we can get.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. A lot of these things, if we take them to extremes, they become problematic. As I get older, the more I realize that very few things are true in the extremes.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
You know, whether we talk about, you know, people-pleasing. Well, it's kinda like, well, there's nothing necessarily wrong with, uh, doing things that people around you like. It, it's where is that coming from?
- EDElizabeth Day
Exactly.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
That, that's the key, I think. Where does that drive come from? Um, you know, you mentioned competition at the, at the start of our conversation. And it's interesting, y- what you said was, "I don't think being competitive is actually who I am."
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
It's a learned behavior. Now, that fascinates me because when I was researching for this conversation, I heard a conversation with you where you were hypothesizing that maybe that is who you were. So I guess my question is, did you used to think that being competitive was who you are, that's who Elizabeth Day is?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And is that quite a recent realization-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... that actually it isn't?
- 1:01:33 – 1:11:21
Rethinking competitiveness: where it comes from and how to loosen its grip
- EDElizabeth Day
So when I say I don't think it's innate, I don't think I was born with it. I think that I have been nurtured to become competitive by myself and other people, and now it is a fundamental part of me that I have to look at fondly if I possibly can and just think, "Oh, funny you being competitive again. [laughs] How absurd, but that's sweet. It's part of you." That's how I need to think of it. I can't deny that part of me, because we all know where denial leads to.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
Um, and so I need to treat that part of me with compassion. But I think I learnt to be competitive very young because I have an older sister who's four years older, and four years is a really interesting age gap because she would always be able to do things better than I did. Always. [laughs] There's just no, there's n- there's actually no competing with that. But I would strive to be like her because I thought she was amazing and I wanted to be more like her. And then I got into a situation where I applied that mindset at school, and when I happened to do well in an exam, I got praise for it, and I got praise from the people I loved for it, and I wanted more of that. And so it became this cycle that I kept on doing it, and I kept on attempting to achieve and perform and compete because I thought that what I got in return was love and validation, and actually, it wasn't. It was someone saying, "You did well in an exam," which is a completely different thing, or it should be, from your identity. But my identity got really mixed up in that, and I think as a result, my 20s were a really tough and tricky decade, and I think they are for many people because for many of us, it's the first time that we've come out of full-time education, and adult life is bafflingly free of that kind of exam-related signposts that can tell you you're doing a good job as an adult. You actually need to find your own way and navigate at a time when you're also having to forge a career, forge meaningful relationships and friendships, earn enough money to pay the rent, and it's really exhausting to try and do all of that if you're stuck in that internal feedback loop.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. Being competitive, from the outside it can look, yeah, that, that's a really helpful trait because it, it's driven you to work hard. You've had an incredible amount of success in your career, journalist, author, podcaster. W- you know, y- you are someone who society would regard as very, very successful. What are the downsides to having that trait of competitiveness?
- EDElizabeth Day
So I think you're right. Part of being compassionate with myself is also acknowledging that my competitive drive is fuel that I have been able to turn to and use to work really hard. The downsides are that when I'm stressed or tired or overwhelmed, the place that I go to to put my stress is into a kind of competition. So it's a competition channel that I tune into because I'm very used to feeling like that, and I get very critical of myself when I'm in that mode of thinking, and it's, it's a s- it's a way of metabolizing stress that actually comes from elsewhere, but competition's how I know how to do it. And so what that looks like on a practical basis is I always expect more of myself. So I've been really lucky and I've worked hard and I've achieved some things, but there are also always more things to achieve. There are always more people to connect with. There's always more guests to get on my podcast. There's always more books to sell. There's always more ideas to have. I just-- And it's not, it's absolutely not greed that drives that. It's fear that it's all gonna go away, and it's also excitement that I want to be able to connect with as many people as I can, and I want to be able to leave a tiny mark on this world that leaves it a better place. And so I can never feel fully relaxed in what I have achieved, and it's something I don't like in myself, and I'm really grappling with it.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah, I mean, the, the reason I'm so passionate about this is because this is something I've, I would say suffered with, um, and, and I, I don't say that lightly. I have been competitive for pretty much all of my life, super competitive, but I'm not anymore.
- EDElizabeth Day
I know, and I need you to teach me your ways.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Well, I can only share with you my experience of what I've seen, but my fundamental view now, and this applies to everyone actually, is that who we are is not who we have to be. It's who we became Right? Much of who we are, much of our personality, we think it's us, you know? People would say my whole life, you know, Rangan's super competitive, he won't lose, right? I, I very much like you, um, was a pretty sore loser with board games when I was seven.
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And I was reading this morning that I think you were a pretty sore loser-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... with board games. Uh, lots of similarities in our stories.
- EDElizabeth Day
So many.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
We both like neighbors, for example. I read that this morning, you know?
- EDElizabeth Day
The soap opera-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I know
- EDElizabeth Day
... not the actual neighbors. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. [laughs] Um, but I think being competitive has been a very lonely place to live, and my competitiveness was fueled by a feeling of lack. So I'm not enough in who I am.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I got my self-worth from the validation from other people, hence the people-pleasing. Uh, and I know from your story, you, you ha- you share this in common with me, that you got your self-worth from getting good grades and being validated by your teachers or whatever. Or for me, it was from my parents. But if you think about it, developing the personality trait of being competitive is a fantastic strategy, because it's gonna help you keep feeding that need to do well. 'Cause like you, I've also, you know, ticked many of these boxes of societal success, and it looks as though everything is going great. But, uh, I honestly, until three or four years ago, I don't think I felt truly content inside, and a lot of that is because I've let go now of that competitiveness. I genuinely am not that person anymore because that hole in my heart that I felt for much of my life, that I wasn't enough turning up as just me, and that I had to be something else, I've, since my dad died just over nine years ago, I've done a lot of internal work. I've stopped looking out there for answers. I've turned it around to look inside. And as I feel now, I actually really like the person I see in the mirror, right? As I like myself, or dare I say it, love who I truly am, I have no need anymore to be competitive. It doesn't help me anymore, and actually it is gone. And so I generally believe everyone has the possibility to reimagine what their life might look like. But I think in order to actually move beyond it, we actually have to understand where it came from and what role it served.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm. I'm so sorry about your father, and thank you for sharing that, because I aspire to that. [laughs] And you're a whole year older than me, so I feel like by the time I'm 44, I'll have nailed it. But, um, I think you're so right, and I know that logically. I know that that's where the answer is, and I think that for a lot of my life, I've used an analytical system for a soul problem, soul, S-O-U-L problem.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And it's never gonna solve it. Like, there are two different systems-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... at play there.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Exactly. And, and for me, um, a big part of this was a, a form of therapy called internal family systems, which I did a podcast on about, I don't know, 10 weeks ago, something like that, which connected with so many people. I actually did a session on the show with the guy who founded it, and i- it's really transformative because you go back to where that came from. Like for me, let's say a seven-year-old little boy, um, developing that idea that he's not enough, and you go back as your adult self, and you have to trust initially, because if you're used to everything being rational and understood... I remember the first session I did, you know, you have to really trust, is this doing anything? It is unbelievable how many people this helps, because you go back in, you make peace with it. Literally in that moment, you talk to that seven-year-old self or that eight-year-old self, whoever it is, as your 44-year-old self, and you say, "Yeah, I understand," you know? You, you actually have a conversation. And when you go back in, understand where it's coming from and reprogram it-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... and it's actually relatively simple to do. You, you just find that your life afterwards changes. Like I'm, I'm not trying not to be competitive. It's not like an effort now. I, I just, I just don't feel it anymore, and it's so liberating.
- 1:11:21 – 1:16:50
Success without attachment: contentment, criticism, and focusing on the work
- EDElizabeth Day
So first of all, I'm gonna go back and listen to that podcast episode. And secondly, how did it feel for you getting a number one Sunday Times bestseller?
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
This was actually a real-life scenario, what, five, six weeks ago, that actually was a real-life situation that showed myself, oh man, I really am changing. Because, you know, you're a fellow author, right? You know, I'm sure most authors would give their right arm to be a number one paperback Sunday Times bestseller, right? Ask me five years ago, I, I would've said the same thing. Like literally what happened, I can remember it, the, the, it was Tuesday, my, uh, editor at Penguin, my senior editor, she-- I got a text from her saying, "Can you give me a call?" I thought, "This is weird." Like this is quite-
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Normally it's email. Go on.
- EDElizabeth Day
You, so you didn't immediately think, "What have I done wrong?" 'Cause that would be my response. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I did.
- EDElizabeth Day
Okay.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Pa- pardon me, 'cause that's my natural prone.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
What, what have I done?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Have I messed something up somewhere?
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Um, so I phoned her, and she was like jumping through hoops, really, really excited, said, "The whole team is celebrating. We just found out this Sunday you're gonna be number one on the paperback list." And I'd never been that before. And honestly, right, I can tell you, five years ago, if that had happened, I would've been-- I would've jumped through the roof. I would've texted my mates. I would've called them all. I honestly just felt a quiet contentment. I thought- Yeah, cool. Okay, great. I'm, I'm, I'm really pleased the book's gonna help people. I'm not-- I promise I'm not just saying that. It was a r- I actually thought, "Actually, I still need to wash my daughter's, uh, sports gear for tomorrow, and the kids need feeding." Uh, that's generally what was going through my mind. And I, I-- There was just a quiet contentment rather than an artificial ego elevation-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... which I think I've had in the past. Now, that doesn't mean I take it for granted. It's very, very different. It means that I'm no longer attached to that external validation and that success like I have been since I was a kid, and it feels absolutely fantastic. It feels liberating and free. And, um, it, it's funny, Elizabeth, because I was chatting to a mate before the book actually came out, um, and, and I genuinely had got to a place with this book where-- You know what it's like, you know, we, we put ourselves out there each week on a podcast or with books and, you know, when you're someone who very much needs the opinions of others to validate who you are, it can be pretty hard being out in the public eye. And I know you've said before you struggle with criticism sometimes online-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... or those sort of things. I had genuinely made peace before this book came out. Honestly, with zero arrogance, I, I actually said to my friend, "You know what? I know this is a great book. This is the best I can do at this point in my life. Whether this is a success or not says nothing about who I am as a person."
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Right? Maybe it will connect, maybe it won't. It's still a great book that I'm really proud of. I don't think I've ever felt like that before, before a book came out. And so the irony is, you know, you mentioned about, you know, spiritual thoughts and feelings. The irony is, is that I've never had a book that's more successful.
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs] Oh, no.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yet-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... I'm totally detached from needing that external validation.
- EDElizabeth Day
It's so interesting because it says nothing about you as a person, and also the weird thing is, actually, the way-- the kind of two-dimensional way in which society deems something successful says nothing about the quality of the work.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Exactly.
- EDElizabeth Day
That's the, that's the thing that I've just realized. It's like actually someone harassed who's running late for their flight, who's running through WHSmith at Heathrow Airport, who grabs a book from the shelf and is a product of their entire life experience up to that point, the emotional and the physical baggage they're carrying to get on the plane, and they like the color pink over the color orange, and they reach for a book, and that's the book that gets sold that day. I just realized recently like, oh, so little of it is to do with what's contained within.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And I think you're right that true enlightenment comes from being engaged in the task itself rather than the outcome.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. And, and going back to what you said before, it's, you know, when you used to not allow yourself to feel anger, would hide it with sadness, like acceptable sadness. The only reason I've got to this place is because I went into these uncomfortable emotions. I had, you know, often it, it r- requires these big moments in life, doesn't it? Like a, a parent dying to suddenly cause you to ask these big existential questions. That was it for me where I then go inward and actually go into these kind of dark places that you've covered up, that you don't allow yourself to feel-
- 1:16:50 – 1:26:00
Living alongside grief: infertility, hope, and ‘Magpie’ as an artistic container for loss
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Um, one of your failures that you have spoken about is, um, well, I guess your miscarriage and your, your infertility.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
How are you feeling about those things these days?
- EDElizabeth Day
It's a really big question, and so as not to take up the next two hours of everyone's time, I'll just say that it is one of those painful, grieving experiences that I live alongside rather than being over, and I think that grief is often like that. Um, we live alongside it, and it, it's like a droplet of red paint i- in a vat of white paint. It forever changes the color. And I've had a really long journey. I spent the best part of a decade sort of trying and as yet failing to have a baby in the biological way, and I'm, I'm still engaged in that. But there are aspects of it, of recurrent miscarriage, of IVF, of all of the things that I've been through that I'm profoundly grateful for. I'm grateful for the fact that it's taught me that I'm so much more resilient and stronger than I thought. I'm grateful for the fact that it's given me a life I never expected, which there can be some pain attached to that, but also there can be a great deal of liberation. It encourages you to think differently about the kind of life that you want to live. And I'm also extremely grateful that it's brought me into contact with amazing women and men who are On this journey with me, and I might not ever have met them. We might only ever have exchanged one DM, or they might have come to one of my shows, and they might have sent an email after a podcast episode. And I feel we are this army [laughs] engaged in the same battle, and I no longer feel alone. And so I'm extremely grateful for all of those reasons because I think it's given me a far more profound understanding of life's infinite texture, and it's- it's given me a lot. Um, but it's caused me a great deal of sadness, and I hope one day still to be a mother, and that's where I'm at with it.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. You wrote a, um, a beautiful Mother's Day post this year on your-
- EDElizabeth Day
Thank you
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... Instagram feed, which I read this morning. And, you know, it was really, um, it was just so beautiful, so touching, and it really made me stop and think actually. Um, perhaps you could share some of the thoughts and sentiments that went into that.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah. So Mother's Day can be a real trigger point for many people who don't identify or aren't parents in the way that they would like to be. And I see one of my roles, given the platform that I do have, to speak to those people because I think that so often we can get ignored in a culture that really fetishizes a certain kind of parenthood. And so I wrote this post about how if you're currently engaged in this battle to conceive or to become a parent in whatever way you desire, if you're actively engaged in that struggle, what I believe that's doing, it's preparing you for parenthood in ways you can't even imagine. You're already a parent because of the fight that you're fighting for your child who doesn't exist yet, and that's how I make meaning of it. It's like all of this is equipping me. I am a warrior in a battle, and I am equipping myself-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... for the ferocity of love that will come on the other side of that. And I wrote something along those terms.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. Do you ever allow yourself to imagine, you know, what- what happens if this doesn't happen for you? Do- do you- do you ever go there, or is it still very much hope?
- EDElizabeth Day
Well, I think anyone who has been on this sort of fertility journey gets very practiced at balancing hope and expectation alongside the knowledge of loss, and it's a very ambiguous and difficult head space to occupy. But I- I've got really used to it, so I hold all of those things in my head simultaneously. And one of the stresses, I think, is that, you know, we live in an age where we talk a lot about the power of manifestation, and that's so wonderful in so many ways. But it does mean that sometimes if you fail at something that you've imagined with such hope and such yearning, and you've imagined it so powerfully, and it doesn't happen, you internalize that failure. And that's sometimes been my experience, that I can't hope wholeheartedly because I'm also realistic and because of everything that I've been through, and I'm of a certain age. But when I tell you, and this comes from my spiritual and intuition and intuitive beliefs, when I tell you I just know, I know it's gonna happen. [laughs] So I know it alongside all of those different emotions.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. How has your experience over the past 10 years with this influenced your brand-new book, Magpie, the novel that's just come out?
- EDElizabeth Day
Well, Magpie was written in two halves. I'd written about 15,000 words before the first national lockdown hit, and at the beginning of that lockdown, I'm now married to a lovely person. [laughs] We found out we were pregnant, and that was a really unmooring place to be. I'd had two miscarriages, and then a global pandemic happened, and then we discovered that we were pregnant really quite unexpectedly, and I couldn't write. And so I set Magpie aside because there was just too much else going on in my head, and very sadly, at eight weeks, we lost that pregnancy. And in the aftermath of that, there was this shattering absence and a great deal of sadness and- and it also felt like it was such a lonely time for so many of us, lockdown. Um, and so we were kind of confronted with our grief in a way that normal life allows you to step outside of it. We just had it there. And one of the only things that I could do then was to write because writing and reading is how I make sense of the world. It's how I communicate, and I wanted something to exist where otherwise there would just have been absence. And that's when I wrote the rest of Magpie, and it was hugely influenced by what I was going through. And I wanted to write a book that was a novel of the kind that I would have liked to have seen my experiences reflected in when I was going through them, when I was going through IVF, when I was going through the first of those three miscarriages. I- Didn't read that in fiction. And I think we've got a lot better at talking openly about these things, and there's an increasing amount of nonfiction being written about it, which is really wonderful and powerful. But I wanted to put it in a novel, and I wanted to put it in a novel that was accessible and gripping for anyone who hadn't been through any of that trauma [laughs] .
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah.
- EDElizabeth Day
And so I hope what you have with Magpie is a really, really compelling read, and there's one massive plot twist in it. And, and, and I don't, yeah, I don't think I would've written that book had I not gone through what I'd gone through, and I'm very grateful that I have an outlet to put all of that emotional experience into.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Uh, I guess it speaks to something you said before about failure that, um, you know, that, that there's always an opportunity to learn something from it.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Whatever that might be. And I know you caveated it as you always do so beautifully. You know, you made... Which, which something I've-- Also one thing I've noticed, um, with you, I don't think I know anyone better at always prefacing any answer with a caveat first or acknowledging, let's say, privilege or anything like that. Um-
- EDElizabeth Day
Thank you. That's actually a really lovely thing [laughs] for you to say. I'm glad.
- 1:26:00 – 1:30:29
Learning by listening: caveats, being corrected, and emotional regulation
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
No, I, I, I've noticed you do, you do it all the time. Is that something that comes naturally to you? You know, where-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... has that come from, do you think?
- EDElizabeth Day
I think it does come naturally to me. I'm trying to think where it might come from. I think I've always felt like, again, caveat [laughs] , I'm aware of how absurd this might sound sitting here on stage as someone who is white and privileged and middle class, but I've always felt like an outsider. And I'll explain that, because when I was four we moved to Northern Ireland, and I had this English accent, and we lived in Derry. And if anyone has watched the amazing show, Derry Girls, the weird English cousin in that show, that was me. So-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
... I was someone who, I didn't have a great time at secondary school. I became someone who didn't speak that much 'cause I didn't want people to identify me or have perceptions of me through my accent, and I became an observer, a listener, and someone who really, I think, felt compassion for the underdog and the people who weren't-- who were misunderstood. So I think I've had that from an early age. And then honestly, being a journalist and doing a lot of interviews, you become very practiced at listening, and I think that it's such an important quality for anyone to have. And so if you're listening, then you'll hear people have so many different life experiences, and it's crucial to make people feel seen, as I've discovered myself on, on my particular journey through life. And I had this, uh, experience recently where I did a podcast episode and I asked an in-inelegantly phrased question. And a trans listener emailed me saying, "I know you probably didn't intend this, but I felt really unseen when you said that for these reasons." And it was such a beautiful email because it wasn't angry. It was, it was understanding, but it was making a point that it was very important to him to make. And I think 10 years ago, I still would've ref- received that in a very defensive mindset and been like, "Well, I didn't mean that." So, and actually, I just heard what he was saying and I was like, I don't-- I hate the thought of causing that person pain, and I apologized for it on the podcast. And I felt this is so much better-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... because we've listened to each other, and it's just so much better-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... to acknowledge if you've got something slightly wrong.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
No, I, I, I love that. Um, and, and I think for me, this is one of the reasons I'm so passionate about us all learning to emotionally regulate better and not respond when we're feeling triggered and actually-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... go inwards and figure out, "Well, why, why did I get triggered here? What, what, what is it inside of me that's showing up in this moment?" Rather than putting the blame somewhere else. And when-
- EDElizabeth Day
Exactly
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... 'cause when we're able to do that, if you were that listener and you're able to... You know, 'cause if that's an angry email to you, the whole trajectory goes different. You know, I imagine you, you will hear it differently, you will receive it differently. There might be a defensiveness. But if it's, if the emotional sting's gone or it's been processed and then it's sent-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... the, the outcome is very different. That way we communicate, it is just so, so important, and I don't think, I don't think many of us realize sometimes how the state of our nervous system, how wired it is at any particular moment influences the way we perceive the world and see the world. And you, you see this online, you know, people expressing unprocessed emotions all the time, and I, I just don't think that's helpful for that person. That's why I'm, I, I'm very passionate that the ability to regulate our emotions, understand where they're coming from is, it really is a superpower.
- EDElizabeth Day
And also to explain to someone else who might not get it-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... that, uh, there just needs to be more room in the world-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah
- EDElizabeth Day
... to say, "I don't know. Please tell me" [laughs] . And for that to be okay. We don't all have to have an immediate response and an immediate opinion. We can ask someone to teach us.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. I've been trying for about an hour to get to these failure principles.
- EDElizabeth Day
I know [laughs] .
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Um, we've been through quite a few without actually-
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah
- 1:30:29 – 1:37:46
Breakups aren’t tragedies: relationships as lessons and the case for direct communication
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... calling them as they are. You know, failure just is. You are not your worst thoughts. Almost everyone feels like they failed in their 20s. I mean, we've covered those. Um, other than number five, failure is data acquisition. Um, but I think the one I'd love to just go into is number four- Breakups are not a tragedy
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes. Mind-blowing, isn't it? [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah, but I th- I think there's something in this. And I guess did you mean when you were writing that, were you primarily talking about romantic relationships or romantic breakups? 'Cause I kind of feel that applies to friendship breakups as well.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah. No, I was, uh, using romantic relationships as a way in to discuss that principle, but it can be applied, as you rightly say, to any form of relationship, friendship, work. And the premise of it is that a, a relationship of any sort is not a failure just because it ends. Because sometimes you outgrow a relationship, or sometimes that relationship or that person has taught you what you needed to know, and they move on. But when something ends, you still have all of those learnings, all of those memories, all of those experiences. Like, that's still part of you. And I was taught this by Alain de Botton, the philosopher, and he compared it to a parent raising a child. A functional, good parent raises a child in order for that child to be able to leave home and survive on their own. What if you applied that kind of thinking to any kind of relationship? Perhaps your ex who broke up with you has, in whatever way, taught you the lessons that you needed to know, that have equipped you for your future relationship, that have taught you, that have been data acquisition for your future relationship, for the relationship that's going to be better for you because of what you've learned. And that was a way for me of, as you say, taking the sting out of heartbreak, because it's so heartbreaking [laughs] when you go through a breakup, and I mean that in friendship terms too. You know, I've been ghosted by a really close friend a couple of times, and it's incredibly difficult to come to terms with because there's no explanation there. So in that vacuum, I choose to make my own meaning, my own explanation from it, and think, "Well, what have I learned from that?" And it's always helped me think of that person so much more fondly in retrospect.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. I think all of us can look back on previous friendships, romantic relationships, whatever they might be, and I guess if we're honest, there are lessons.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
There are lessons there, whether we chose to engage in them, whether we were able to engage with them or not. But there, there, but there were lessons that you can then apply, and you beautifully write about it in, in philosophy that people are sent to you to teach you that lesson.
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And again, it's these sort of things that really, they really make me feel this kind of deeper connection you have, you know, that's, that, you know, there's something greater than us. I'm drawn to that, the way you described it before, "I choose to believe this."
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
That's empowering, isn't it? Because you don't have to believe that all relationships are being sent to you to teach you a lesson, but I feel that for most of us it's more empowering if you do.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes. Having faith in something bigger than you is about doing as w- like, you have to work at that. It's not just a gift. You have to work at it, because ultimately what you're doing is, is taking that leap into the unknown, is making yourself vulnerable. It's literally taking a leap of faith that you're going to believe that something is there, that something is greater, and you have to achieve that by doing it as well as living it.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. I, I think one of the things that I circled in the book that you have learnt from previous relationships is to not magically expect the person you're with to know what's in your head.
- EDElizabeth Day
[laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Is, is that, is that a fair reflection of what you wrote?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes, absolutely. I think for a really long time, you know, I grew up with 1980s rom-coms, and they are wonderful films for entertainment, but you shouldn't live your life according to their parameters. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
And I think one of the things that I came away with the notion of is the idea that your perfect soulmate will completely understand you, will complete you. You are a shattered half of a person-
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
... until you meet this mythical soulmate, and they will automatically know everything that you need and your heart's desire, and actually that's some bullshit. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
[laughs]
- EDElizabeth Day
You need to do the work on yourself and complete yourself first before you're ready to meet anyone else, and then you just tell them what's going on. Like, straightforward communication is one of the most underrated and the most important romantic qualities.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Yeah. I, I completely agree.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah. [laughs]
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
I, I mean, you know, one of the things, I, I mentioned this on my book tour recently, but, um, like, honestly, one of the most transformative things in my marriage has been the realization that my wife doesn't always want me to fix something when she shares a problem with me. Sometimes she just wants me to listen.
- EDElizabeth Day
Yeah.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
And, you know, it took me a while to learn that, but now we have a really great way of communicating. If, if, if she's opening up with something, I will literally say, "Hey, Vid, would you like me to listen or provide a solution?" She goes, "Just want you to listen."
- EDElizabeth Day
I love that. You see, that's so straightforward.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Literally.
- EDElizabeth Day
You literally are like, "Tell me what you want-
- 1:37:46 – 1:39:36
Closing message: failure is inevitable—meaning comes from your response over time
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
Um, to bring this to a close, um, we've covered all kinds of different areas tonight. Uh, of course, the, the underlying theme has been failure. The podcast is called Feel Better, Live More. When we feel better, we get more out of our lives. I guess you would say when we fail better, when we get good at failure, we're gonna get more out of our lives. For people who are struggling with failure, who are struggling with their lives, who don't want to, I guess, make peace with failure-
- EDElizabeth Day
Mm-hmm
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
... have you got any final words of wisdom for them?
- EDElizabeth Day
Yes. So I would say it's not actually about failing better, because I want to reassure people that there is no way of failing at failure. [laughs] You can fail however you want, and some of those failures you won't be able to get over immediately, and that's absolutely fine. But I do believe that in the fullness of time, there will be meaning carried within that failure. So instead of failing better, it's about being at peace with the idea that it will happen, because it will happen. It's inevitable, no matter who we are. It's a very democratizing thought. Failure will happen to you. The only thing that you can be in control of is your response to it, and that's where your character is formed. So rather than feeling like you have to fail better, fail with meaning, and don't be afraid of it.
- RCDr. Rangan Chatterjee
If that conversation resonated with you, here is another incredibly powerful one that I really think you're going to enjoy. Give it a click and let me know what you think. I promise you, it's not as hard as you think to make a change. I know that you feel lost from time to time and you struggle with motivation, but these practices will really make a difference
Episode duration: 1:39:36
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode -G44L7ftOW8