By playing, you agree to uListen's Terms and Privacy Policy and YouTube's Terms of Service.
The Twenty Minute VCOpenAI Restructuring: Who Wins and Who Loses & Mercor Raises $350M at a $10BN Valuation
Summaries, chapters, transcripts, and FAQs on this page are made by uListen, not YouTube.
Transcript
90 min read · 18,151 wordsIntro
Jason Lemkin 0:00 I just can't think of a retail IPO that would be more popular than OpenAI. To me, going from 23 billion to 30 billion, I don't even consider it an up round. It's not enough
Rory O’Driscoll 0:09 If they really have gone from 100 to 150 in less than six months, then I can make this conversation really quick. There's no way they should sell. Andreessen Horowitz is the Red Army of the venture industry. What you're basically saying is, "Rory, you can win a deal, not 'cause I've grafted for 30 years and returned, you know, frankly, billions of dollars to my investors, but because I'm on a [censored] pod." If that sentence is true-
Jason Lemkin 0:29 No
Rory O’Driscoll 0:30 ... if that sentence isn't true, then 100% Marc Andreessen was right all along.
Jason Lemkin 0:35 I think Bezos would lay off half his company in a fortnight if it was the right thing. I don't think he'd even care. Ready to go? [upbeat rock music]
Harry Stebbings 0:51 We have so much to discuss this week. It's my favorite show of the week. Um, and we were talking, Rory, about-
Jason Lemkin 0:57 It's at least in the top two each week, isn't it? At a minimum, it's gotta be in the top two, right?
Harry Stebbings 1:00 Do you know, I, I would say it's a top two show, for sure.
Jason Lemkin 1:02 Always, right? [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 1:03 Yeah, always a top two. Does that, does that make you feel special now? Yeah.
Jason Lemkin 1:07 They say the silver medal is the toughest one in the Olympics, but I don't know about Rory. I'm good with it here. I'm good with just a silver.
Harry Stebbings 1:11 I'll take a silver. Okay, so we were talking about where we were gonna start, Rory,
OpenAI's Restructuring: Winners and Losers
Harry Stebbings 1:16 before this, and you were like, "I think we should start with OpenAI given the news today." And so learning from the feedback that we get, I would love to start with you just explaining a little bit about the news that's just come out about OpenAI and their structure, and we can start there.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:30 Sure. I mean, the big news today is OpenAI cut their deal. They cut their deal with Microsoft, and they cut their deal with the attorneys general, the plural of attorney general, um, of Delaware and California, which means they have been able to implement their restructuring, which means they can raise their capital, which means they're tr- they are out of the messy, complex trap they had put themselves in all those years ago in terms of their structure, and they've gotten it done. That's the big picture news. There's lots of information one level down about who won, who lost, who got what economics, but that's where we're at. And you know, it's still got some opposition. Elon can still litigate and say, "I don't think you should do that because I gave this money to a charity," but possession is nine-tenths of the law, and once the attorneys general have allowed it and they've actually converted, uh, you know, it's a lot harder to unwind. So as of now, as of this morning, as I understand it, OpenAI, there is the charity, the charitable foundation, which is now one of the well- most well-capitalized charitable foundations on the planet. Underneath that, there is the company itself, OpenAI, which is a, it's a PBC, I can never remember the initials. Basically a, a for-profit company, but also has to take into account, um, more than just ma- shareholder maximization. I'm, I'm sorry, I'm having my dyslexia there, right? So that's the entity that's created, and that's the entity into which you can invest. There are other companies like that. I think Patagonia, for example, has the same status. This is not a crazy thing now. This is not some weird... Like the old OpenAI used to have this disclosure, "You should regard this as a donation. It can all go to zero." This is a real honest, honest to goodness American corporation, a different kind of American corporation, but they can go public with this. They've gotten out of the straitjacket. So that's the bi- and it's big news. It means, you know, what... For example, it means an OpenAI IPO is one enormous step closer. Not saying they have to, not saying they will, but big news today.
Jason Lemkin 3:26 I'll just throw one thing that jumped out at me on the deal. Um, the overall structure, Microsoft owning 27%, the employees owning 20-something percent, uh, the, uh, the nonprofit owning 20-something percent, those are all roughly what we all expected, right? There's, there's some nuances on, uh, how AGI worked that are a little interesting. But the craziest thing in this deal, 'cause it's unprecedented, I think, in our lifetimes, is OpenAI said that Sam Altman will still have no shares, no shares in the combined entity. And we've ne- we, at the same time, we've got Elon Musk arguing he deserves a trillion dollar pay package so the robots don't kill us, which I, I think he deserves, okay? His, I think his VCs will say he deserves it, okay? There is something, uh, unimaginable to 99, to almost anyone in the world to say he should have a trillion dollar pay package, but the scale has to be relevant to the, to the outputs, right? I don't believe it will ensure the robots don't kill us. It's a little crazy. But on the other hand, Elon wants a trillion, and everyone was saying, "Show Sam the money," when he was fired as CEO over a very long weekend, right? The Night of Knives or whatever. Was fired. Fired by this crazy nonprofit. Um, everyone had to revolt to bring him back. Fast-forward to today, that, th- that same nonprofit's in charge still. The same... Now listen, there's been turnover, but it's still sort of charge... And he has no shares. Um, I, I, we could hypothesize why. He's pretty transparent. I actually think it gives him, in some ways, more power as well as less power. Um, you can't assail the man for, for capitalism [laughs] when his other billion-dollar entities are the ones that let him finish off the McLaren collection. But we've never seen someone own nothing, have we, like this? Have we ever seen anybody own nothing? It's crazy.
Harry Stebbings 5:04 If we just drill down on, on winners and losers from this structuring change, who, who are the winners and losers here?
Rory O’Driscoll 5:10 I think the lesson here is a lesson that every attorney knows, which is you often hear this expression when litigators, what's the case worth? In other words, they look at the filings on both sides, and experienced litigators look and go, "Okay, we got these three points. They got those five points. In the end, we're gonna win on the three. They're gonna win on the five. This is the way it's gonna come out." And then there's a whole load of human drama, 'cause humans are like that, and we yell and we scream and we have juries and the... And then typically things settle out for what they're worth, right? This settled out for the, where the cases worked. Let me tell you what I mean by that, right? Is when you look at the thing, as Jason said, not only no surprise, but you know, no surprise for a long time. Microsoft had a fair amount of leverage. They used it. They got a great deal, right? They put in 13 million do- $13 billion. They got a 10X on their money as of today. They got a lot of AI leverage.They got some going forward AI property rights, they got some, a significant going forward contract for Azure business if they want it, which we can come back to. Overall, they didn't push it to the point of breaking, but they got pretty much what they were going... And they still have some rev share, which surprised me. So they got a great deal. Again, I go back to my comment, Microsoft corporate development and lawyers deserve a gold star for, from their shareholders in a way that frankly Microsoft R&D does not, and the proof of this is this morning Microsoft stock is up nicely. They're like, "Thank you for the $100 billion, we're up." There's three big winners. The second big winner is, just to step back, the charitable foundation, right? You know, there are some people again, even today, griping and saying, "We did this all for charity. It feels wrong that there's any capitalists involved." And I, I get that, especially if I'd given the seed money. But stepping back, somehow in the midst of this, we've ended up funding a wonderful $135 billion charitable foundation. If, you know, that's a significant contribution to whatever good they hopefully will do with that money, and they already made some announcements about AI for medicine. So there's $135 billion out there that's not going into someone's pockets to, you know, buy yachts, uh, boats, and football teams. It's actually going to try and solve world's problems. Now, whether they can or not, TBD. But yay, 'cause I would have laughed in 2016, but the people who started OpenAI saying, "We want to do good for the world," have at a big picture level succeeded. They built something, worth $130 billion, which is a foundation that they can be proud of. So th- th- it's a win for them. Obviously, the employees own a third and now it can get liquid. Yay them. And then, um, you know, the remaining, the investors can kind of exhale, get a sigh of relief. SoftBank can put in their $22 billion, and the, the investors as a group, I mean, think SoftBank will own about 10% and everyone else will own low single digits. And everyone won and everyone got roughly what the leverage would make them get. And then the final winner, I just got to say, and I know this is a lot, but Brett Taylor just wins the best board chairman of the year award again for the second time in the last five years. He totally won it as board chairman of Twitter, where he jammed that down Elon's throat for $44 billion despite his opposition, and he won here today 'cause he unraveled the mess and set it all up for a win. So I, it, it's a really good settlement for everyone.
Jason Lemkin 8:23 So there's no losers?
Rory O’Driscoll 8:26 Well, if, I mean, the, the losers would be the, Elon feels he didn't want any of this to happen, so he's miffed. And the people who think, um, "Oh my God, it should all have stayed not-for-profit," they m- they, they feel they're losing. There's a lot of that Twitterverse comments today. But pragmatically speaking, I mean, if you think about it, Microsoft put $13, $14 billion in here, right? And they've made a 10X, which is a good return, but we'll talk about returns. It's not like it's pr- it's not like it's rapacious relative the risk they took. No one else was writing OpenAI a billion dollar check in 2019. Microsoft did, and they got their return. So-
Jason Lemkin 9:06 And the IP for a, for an extended period.
Rory O’Driscoll 9:07 And the IP, absolutely.
Jason Lemkin 9:08 And the IP.
Rory O’Driscoll 9:08 No. So-
Jason Lemkin 9:09 Yeah.
Rory O’Driscoll 9:09 Yeah, so I, I don't think there's any losers at all. I don't think anyone got much more than they deserved for the risks they took and the work they did.
Jason Lemkin 9:20 So I can tell my LPs that the little 6% stake deal I'm doing today is okay, because here's, look at OpenAI, I don't need to get double digits. Point, point to this one.
Rory O’Driscoll 9:29 Totally.
Jason Lemkin 9:30 Don't, don't beat me up on the double digits. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 9:32 Totally. No, exactly, and y- you're right, Jason, it just shows rules of thumb are made to be broken. 90% of the time your ownership target is a really meaningful metric, and it should run your business on it, and, you know, 10%, 1% of the time, who the hell cares? 1% of the biggest company on the planet is $5 billion. There you go.
Jason Lemkin 9:51 The one micro thought I just thought was it's very con- you know, there's so, all the circular financing, who, who, Nvidia giving them money, AMD giving them 10% of the company, Oracle raising a, a, a, a, a, an unprecedented amount of debt.
Rory O’Driscoll 10:06 Yeah.
Jason Lemkin 10:06 So what I mean is, I don't know how much equity OpenAI needs, but it seems to me if they're coming up on being the first trillion dollar startup and more, if they could IPO at two trillion, which is crazy by any historic, so is a CEO with no stock, maybe they could raise another two hundred billion, right? I mean, at least in theory. That's a lot of capital to access, but my point is this unlocks maybe f- four times more equity for them potentially if the public markets are different than the private because of the potential valuation they could IPO. They may need that, they may need an extra two hundred billion to go the distance.
Rory O’Driscoll 10:40 I, I think that's an excellent point, Jason, and you're exact- it means that there's one more set of winners here. All those people who stock popped because they have a bullshit promise from OpenAI to buy a whole bunch of their stuff in the future with money OpenAI didn't, didn't have, now at least can say they can go get that money. You know, the probab- I mean, I, as you know, I'm skeptical that Oracle will collect the last dollar of that cloud contract, but at least you can now say hand on heart the customer, OpenAI, now has a sensible corporate structure. They obviously have an amazing business, and if they need to raise another hundred billion, it's not like crazy anymore, it's just, it's just banking and math. So you're exactly right. This thing may fail for, you know, there, there may be business issues around, you know, return on thing, but we're out of the stupid corporate structure getting in the way of everything stage of business.
Jason Lemkin 11:28 I just can't think of a, of a retail IPO that would be more popular than OpenAI, right? Just bringing everyone out of the woodwork to put a little bit of their life savings to do it, to ignore the v- well, even if the valuation makes no sense, I just s- this would have to be the most popular retail IPO of all time, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 11:46 I think you're exactly, I think y- yes, you're exactly, and it's now it's doable.Yeah. I mean, people aren't gonna be reading the prospectus and saying, "Maybe we won't make profits." They're not gonna be reading the thing about $250 billion of cloud commits to third parties. They're just gonna be, "Let me get some of that OpenAI," right? I, I think it would be interesting actually, to your point, it'd be interesting to check on the secondary pr- valuation pop today for OpenAI trades. I mean, 'cause right now... The weird thing right now is SoftBank is closing two separate deals right now. They're closing their roughly 300 billion pre-direct investment, and they're also doing a share buyback from exist- from some existing employees of 500 billion. So well, I mean, literally you, you have the same security trading at two different prices, and I think that's true for other investors too. They've locked in the earlier price. When the other investors, I think Thrive is in this too, when they committed to OpenAI a while back, they said, "Hey, we'll give you money at 300 billion, but you gotta get, get your conversion done first." So now that the conversion's done, they're gonna put the money in, but already they've already had a markup before the mon- oh my God, they've had a markup before the money's gone in, right? Because SoftBank is marking itself up by doing business at 500 billion in a secondary, right? So literally you're gonna wire money at 200 billion or 300 billion, whatever the number is, and then sec- next day you can say, "Hand on heart, current valuation of this is 5 billion, 500 billion, so there you go. You have 40% IRR in an hour"
Harry Stebbings 13:11 Do you think they'll be a trillion-dollar company in 2026?
Rory O’Driscoll 13:14 On the current trajectory, maybe all I can answer is on the current trajectory and without the euphoria Jason mentioned, it's probably two y- 'cause, you know, you do get some attenuation of growth at scale and, and, you know, at the current thing they're tra- I mean, at 500 billion and, you know, 12 billion, let's call them boring GAAP revenues rather than ARR, it's kind of, you know, 40 times GAAP and if it's 20 bill- and 25 times ARR run rate. So my guess is it would take two years in the normal course, but you, you know, you might see that euphoria moment. But it's not crazy. It's not like it's never gonna happen. It's, it's, it's within the trajectory, it's within the strike zone if anything like the current growth rate continues. If it slows, I mean, as a reminder, when you're trading, and we saw this in '21, if you're trading at 40 times revenues and your growth rate slows, it's, it's nasty and you fall sheer. But right now they're growing, so they can get it.
Harry Stebbings 14:05 I would love a $2 trillion IPO. [laughs] That sounds great.
Rory O’Driscoll 14:09 [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 14:09 [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 14:10 ... from here. Actually, the interesting question will be, are the dynamics of the negotiat- again, when you have master corporate financier like Taylor and Sam Altman on your s- it'll be fun to watch the bankers beg for that. They might pretty much do it for half nothing just to be on the biggest IPO of all times. I mean, I think technically Saudi Aramco had a kind of a couple of trillion dollar market cap, but nobody really cares, let's get real. It's an oil company in Saudi Arabia. Um, yeah, th- th- this would be one for the ages, and I think every banker on the planet will be making decks as we speak and calling on Mr. Altman and Mr. Taylor.
Harry Stebbings 14:45 Dude, you'd do it for free for the credit.
Rory O’Driscoll 14:48 He probably would.
Harry Stebbings 14:49 Yeah.
Rory O’Driscoll 14:49 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 14:50 No doubt. Um, is there anything on OpenAI that we haven't covered that we should cover, do you think? The browser, the RFUs, anything that you're like, "Ah, have to cover that"?
Rory O’Driscoll 15:01 I mean, it's all second-order stuff. We can come back to it if we have time, but I don't know if it's... I mean, that's the big story. They're free.
Jason Lemkin 15:08 You know, the only thing that's mildly interesting in the browser is just, um, will... I, I'm just waiting to see, unlike Sora and such, will the world really care? I just wonder how many... It's just, uh, tough to keep track of how many stories tech VCs and X create. Um, it's not that, it's, it's not that it's not interesting, right? I mean, obviously the browser is where, is where we live a lot of our lives, but, uh, it, it could be like MCP. It could end up being, uh, interesting, but not, uh, not really the game changer that, uh, that, uh, VCs and others think it'll be. We'll just see. I don't know.
Harry Stebbings 15:43 Hmm.
Jason Lemkin 15:44 Right?
Harry Stebbings 15:44 Yeah.
Jason Lemkin 15:44 I, I haven't, I, it, it, it, it... I don't know that it will, it, that, uh, every sing- the average consumer will find it a game changer to find a new browser, um, rather than type ChatGPT into their browser and get enough memory. We'll just see whether they really want it to, to, to, uh, you know, to, to pick its Spotify selections for us. I just don't know if it's a, it's a game changer or, uh, or, or more, uh, or more of a land grab, and so we, we will just see.
Andreessen Horowitz's Raise $10BN in New Funds
Harry Stebbings 16:12 Okay, we're gonna talk about Andreessen's new funds. Andreessen dominates so much of the venture microphone today. $10 billion split across $6 billion in growth, $1.5 billion in AI apps, $1.5 billion in AI infra, $1 billion in defense. My word, what a big raise. Um, I would love to understand, is this just a new normal of General Catalyst and Lightspeed and the mega platforms raising like this? Is this different? How did you analyze this news?
Jason Lemkin 16:45 Honestly, I thought they were small, and what, what I mean is, it, I didn't think it was small until I saw the breakdown of the funds, right? Um, at first I... When we talked about this before, I was like, "10 billion, that's unprecedented," right? But when I look at that and the new Sequoia Fund, $200 million Sequoia seed fund, that's not that big compared to 20VC. What's the 20- 20VC's 150 out of 400 or something, right?
Harry Stebbings 17:07 125, yeah.
Jason Lemkin 17:08 Yeah. And Ro- and Rory's more A and B, but it's not tw- 200 million doesn't really get, get, get you out of bed at scale. And then 1.5 billion for AI apps when you're investing in ElevenLabs and Friends and, and Replit doesn't seem to get you, doesn't really seem to get you very far. The seed funds and the AI fund for Sequoia and Andreessen were smaller than I would have expected in today's insane world, where even 50 million at a YC Demo Day could be a low valuation, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 17:36 Wasn't expecting that. Uh, no, I, I thought it... Look, step back. Is it the new normal? Yes. It is the business model that Andreessen and a couple of other firms have brilliantly pursued. This is the world we live in today, and as investors, we'll live in for the next four to five years, right? I mean-Somewhere down the line, you'll either have the it works over across a cycle, and then this will be the norm forever, and you could envision a world where this is a little like where venture becomes more like investment banking, where there's Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, and the rest of us are boutique players, right? Or the other thing that could happen is the returns from the bigger funds are l- slightly disappointing and kinda there's a little bit of a tilt back to more mid and small cap ventures. But this is the dominant modality today. These are, this, this is what top dog venture investing looks like. This kind of scale, this kind of dollars at work, and there's four or five other firms doing this.
Jason Lemkin 18:38 Is there any excuse to, that I can't compete with Sequoia? I mean, I mean, Scale can outbid them. I think you can compete with a $200 million seed fund or a 1.5 billion AB fund. I think you can compete.
Rory O’Driscoll 18:49 Yeah, I, I, I agree. The, the, the sentence, "I can't compete at a seed with Andreessen 'cause of check size," doesn't make sense except in one very derivative way, right? 'Cause I agree. At the end of the day, if someone's raising 10 million and you have 10 million and the other guy has 10 million, end of, right? There could be one... There's one of two arguments against what you're saying, though, right? The two ways, the, 'cause there's two ways in which the, the fact that one checkbook comes 10 out of... Let's just pick on Harry. One checkbook comes 10 out of a $400 million fund, and one checkbook comes 10 out of a $10 billion colossus, right? Let's just say. There's two ways in which the colossus has an advantage. The first is they can literally decide they're not pricing this round, they're buying an option on the next round. If Harry's trying to make his money on seed and they're simply trying to set themself to make the m- money on the B, they can by definition pay a higher price, 'cause any option [laughs] always trades higher than the intrinsic value of the asset in question by virtue of the time value. So they can, they can pay a s- quote unquote, "a stupid price," right? 'Cause they have a different model. And then the second way they can out, they can win, and I'm really internalizing this now, is the wall of news, right? At the end of the day, when you have a $10 billion fund, you always have shit going on. You don't talk about your bad stuff, but, and provided you're modestly competent, and these guys are far beyond modestly competent, they're extraordinarily competent, you always have some good news in the portfolio, right? You always have exciting things. You're probably gonna be in some winners. So the wall-
Jason Lemkin 20:16 I don't buy the wall of news anymore.
Rory O’Driscoll 20:18 What? Okay.
Jason Lemkin 20:19 I'll tell you why I don't buy a wall. I've learned this first from Dr. Harry Stebbings, and now I've learned it others, okay? Look, Harry's in some great, great, uh, investments that he, he quietly but, but, but relentlessly reminds m- us of, the, the, the-
Rory O’Driscoll 20:32 Yes
Jason Lemkin 20:33 ... complexities and the Mercors.
Rory O’Driscoll 20:35 No, no, and, and Harry-
Jason Lemkin 20:35 Harry says it with his British accent. How do you say Mercor in British? Mercor. He like, he elongates the vowel or something like that, right? And he tells us all, all the great stories. What I'm saying is you can get coverage. You don't have to write t- $10 million checks to be the with participation fund guy. You really don't. You don't. You could write the... Scale could do 50 deals if you wanted with participation from Rory from Scale, who we love from the pod. So just, I, I he- the, the, the option thing's a bigger deal. I just wonder if a $200 million seed fund at Sequoia, how many options can you afford before your whole fund is options, right? That's the question.
Harry Stebbings 21:13 The one thing I will say is the with participation thing does not work-
Jason Lemkin 21:15 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 21:15 ... for publications, and this is very w- in the weeds and granular. W- with the with participation, you playing in rounds with smaller checks-
Jason Lemkin 21:23 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 21:23 ... does not work unless you have an existing brand. For random tier two-
Jason Lemkin 21:28 Yes
Harry Stebbings 21:28 ... tier three firm, if you were to do with participation, no, the TechCrunches, the big brands-
Jason Lemkin 21:33 You mean you won't even be at the end of the fifth paragraph? You, they'll cut you off?
Harry Stebbings 21:35 No, they don't. Honestly, they don't.
Jason Lemkin 21:37 Okay.
Harry Stebbings 21:37 They really don't listen. And so, and so yes, we do have that.
Jason Lemkin 21:39 But Rory has a following now after this pod. He's got a pretty big following.
Harry Stebbings 21:42 R- Rory now would be.
Jason Lemkin 21:44 Yeah.
Rory O’Driscoll 21:44 Even if I did, which I would get-
Jason Lemkin 21:46 I'm not kidding. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 21:46 Stop. It makes me cringe, but even if I did, the w- actually you'd be proving my point, which is it's not 'cause... I mean, what you're basically saying is that you promote... What you're basically saying is, "Rory, you can win a deal," not 'cause I've grafted for 30 years and returned, you know, frankly, billions of dollars to my investors, but because I'm on a fucking pod. If that sentence is true-
Jason Lemkin 22:03 No.
Rory O’Driscoll 22:04 Let me finish. If that sentence is true, then 100% Mark Andreessen was right all along, and he said, "It's not... I don't think in the end investing is a media business." But I do believe that... And I'm gonna give them enormous credit. I, I admire people who pull off strategy, articulate a strategy and pull it off. They tilted the table with their media strategy and, you know, here I am on this podcast in my little tiny humble way trying to say, "Okay, this is the new game," right? So I, I, I do disagree with you, Jason. I think the wall... And, and I think the wall of sound is a combination of the 10 billion and the media presence they generate and all the things. I think at the margin, at the margin, the bigger funds are harder to beat, right? And you just have to say that. It's not by any means impossible, but I'm ju- I'm, what I'm saying is I think Andreessen, I think this $10 billion raise, and I think by the way, the structure of it actually also makes sense, the three different individual funds and then the growth fund, and it makes sense I think both for structural investing reasons and probably also for human capital management reasons. You can give your chief lieutenants each a little fiefdom where they can feel in charge, which is a good way to keep them. Um, uh, I think the strategy, I think the strategy works, and as I said, provided the long-term returns are there, in terms of tilting the field of play in their favor, I think it's been successful.
Harry Stebbings 23:26 I would argue actually that there is massive advantages to them. I, I, I get you, Jason. We've got $275 million for a Series A fund versus their one and a half. That is a lot more money for management fees to pay great people. That is a lot more carry. That is a lot nicer offices, which founders do get wowed by. Like it or not, they get wowed by it. That is a lot more events to host where you can have serendipity. There are a lot more things, I think, that Scale and AUM buys-
Rory O’Driscoll 23:53 Got it
Harry Stebbings 23:53 ... that do increase your chances.
Rory O’Driscoll 23:54 The, the, the... One of my favorite expressions is from the Russian Red Army, which is, "Quantity has a quality all its own." In other words, when you [laughs] when you wanna take Berlin, at some point what you do is you just get two million people willing to die and you march them forward, right? And you know, Andreessen Horowitz is the Red Army of the venture industry now. They got the 10 billion and they're gonna march it forward, right?
Jason Lemkin 24:14 But it's not... Listen, we can move on. It's, here's my point you guys didn't address. It's not... Of course it's 10 billion. It's 10 billion of 30% carry and 10 billion of 2% fees and 10 billion of all this. But when you break apart the funds, I really don't think Sequoia having 200 million is that different than what Harry has, and I don't think-
Rory O’Driscoll 24:31 No, I agree with that. I totally agree with that
Jason Lemkin 24:32 ... a one and a half billion for their AI app funds, I think it's only twice the scale. So I just don't think like Aircover, it's an excuse. You have to work twice as hard as they do? That sounds right. You should have to work about-
Rory O’Driscoll 24:42 Yeah, I agree
Jason Lemkin 24:42 ... twice as hard and, uh, but, but-But it's not as-- it's not really ten million in a billion, right? From a-- when you break the funds up, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 24:51 I agree with that. You do have to work twice as hard. I, I totally agree with that. But as a comment here, again, I mean, hard nos is as a comment, the definition of a good strategy is if you have a strategy that doesn't allow you to have to work that hard, right? And therefore, by definition, having ten billion is a good strategy. I mean, I think the interesting thing, and we said this before, but my bigger high is this. The only people for whom this might be a net negative is the LP investors. And as I say-- and then, and we don't know that yet. Maybe it'll be a wildly successful strategy, in which case it will run the table, or maybe it'll be modestly successful, in which case in five or seven years, the LPs will start going, "Hey, you know that late-stage fund? It gives me a good return, but it's twelve, thirteen percent, and maybe I could get that in the markets now that there's more IPOs. Maybe we should just throttle back our allocation. We love the early-stage stuff." Some version of that. But until something like that happens, for every other player in the market, having ten billion is better than not having ten billion, right? So that's what the game is.
Harry Stebbings 25:49 I do also think for everyone listening, they don't often understand the stapling that is required to be in these funds, which is if, if you're an LP and you want to be in the early-stage fund, you will often, very often with top-tier brands, have to put in two times that into another fund to get that one dollar in the other. And, like, you don't get your pick of which fund. Very often, you have to be across all of them.
Rory O’Driscoll 26:10 Yes. And when you see that, you realize that intuitively, leaders of venture firms understand the concept of bundling at their core, right? Bundling and rent extraction is fully understood. [chuckles]
Mercor Raises $350M at a $10BN Valuation
Harry Stebbings 26:22 Jason, you said about this company, uh, M-M-Mercor, I think it was. I think it might be a twenty VC company, to be fair. Um, but they announced yesterday they've raised, uh, three hundred and fifty million dollars at a ten billion dollar valuation led by the person who led their last t-round at two billion dollars only eight months ago, which is Felicis. Now, this company has gone to five hundred million in revenue faster than anyone else, I believe, in history. I think it was seventeen months. Um, also, again, this is not bias. I hate freaking bias shows. I sometimes listen to them. A lot of people say it's not real revenue, it's GMV. I wanted to hear, how did you guys feel about this round, the speed of revenue acceleration, if it's real revenue? I want your thoughts.
Rory O’Driscoll 27:09 It is quote-unquote "real revenue," right? Uh, in the sense of it's, you know, they, they ship things, they get paid, right? GAAP requires you to book it as revenue. Maybe step back and give people some context. Merc, what they do is they provide humans with specialist knowledge to, and their customers are the large foundation model companies, and what they do is they bring this human talent to bear to help the foundation model companies train the models by providing human feedm-feedback. You-- people would have heard RLHF, reinforcement learning through human feedback. These are the humans that do that, right? So if I'm OpenAI, and I want to quote, "Teach my nate-- teach my latest model how to do advanced math," what I need is a whole bunch of doctorates and PhDs who understand math that are available to pose questions to the model, judge model questions, give feedback on which answer is correct, which answer is not. So by doing that, you effectively, by giving this human feedback, I think of it as you pound the model into submission, where it eventually says, "Okay, I've learned this shit," by adjusting the weights. That's what's going on here, right? It's an astonishing amount of... We think of this all as happening in NVIDIA GPU chips. There's an astonishing amount of human training that is required to make these models work, right? So that's kind of the market these guys are playing into, right? Scale AI, which was acquired by, partially acquired by Meta, is in the same broad market. These guys have done-- Mercor has done an amazing job because five years ago, as Jason said, I love the expression, five years ago, we were labeling cats, right? And, you know, you had people often overseas charged with labeling cats and not getting a lot of money. I think Mercor realized that the market today is not labeling cats, it's in fact answering complex physics questions, math questions, bio questions, because the models know how to label cats now, and what they need to do is the outer edges of human knowledge. So it's a very different set of humans that you need, and Mercor did an amazing job of assembling all these kind of high-end folks and making that product available to the model companies to do it. So that's kind of what they do. And the-- and in that context, the growth quote isn't surprising because if you think about it, these model companies have grown faster than any company in human history. They're spending three, four hundred billion dollars on compute. They're probably spending three, four billion dollars on RLHF, and they were spending zero five years ago. It's an explosive growth market. So, you know, it didn't happen in a vacuum. This happened because our customers want our stuff.
Harry Stebbings 29:43 I actually obviously spent quite a lot of time in the market, which will surprise you, Rory, to hear that I've been thinking, uh, about markets more deeply. But it, it all started with, like, talent acquisition. If you got the talent and could provide it, fantastic, we'll pay you. That's pillar one. Pillar two is get the talent, number one. Now we want data acquisition, which is you provide it to us, not we extract it. You provide it to us, and then you measure the quality of it too. That's the second pillar. And now we're adding the third pillar, which is the implementation layer, which is we now expect you to not only do those first two, but we expect you to implement it efficiently and make sure our models get off the ground more effectively. And with that, you also see increased pricing and the willingness to spend much, much more from the model providers. The other thing I will say is you have concentration of buyer unlike any other industry.
Rory O’Driscoll 30:30 Right.
Harry Stebbings 30:31 Two buyers are fifty percent plus of every one of these-
Rory O’Driscoll 30:35 Totally
Harry Stebbings 30:36 ... labeling providers' revenue. So there is real revenue concentration there. It's, it's high-quality customers, but you do have that dynamic as well.
Rory O’Driscoll 30:44 Agreed. And that was well put because it, it, it actually sp- it, it kind of-- it makes it an interesting question from an investing perspective, because on the one hand, there's nothing better than a customerWho's got an urgent and compe- who's well-funded, we just agreed they're well-funded, who's got an urgent and compelling need to get a bunch of stuff done that you can help them with and wants you to grow with them. And what you're saying is you're exactly right. OpenAI and all these people, five years ago, they had simple requests. The more the complexity goes up, the more you meet that complexity as a vendor, and Mercor has done that in spades, the more revenue they're gonna give you. So they're gonna be shoveling money at you, 'cause you're solving their problems. They got a, they got other shit to be solving. They don't need to be thinking about this. Mr. Mercor, if you can make this go away and get me, you know, five thou- five hundred doctors and this data and this answer and integrated to our system, I will pay you money 'cause money I have in spades, time I don't got.
Jason Lemkin 31:34 For sure, but I've got to imagine y- you, you guys, and especially Harry would know better than me, I, I don't think it's stressf- it may not be stress-free. I have a portfolio company that was doing a, a, a vaguely similar attach to a, to a lar- to a large AI business model where the contract was growing to, uh, eight figures, okay? That renewal was stressful AF.
Rory O’Driscoll 31:55 Yes.
Jason Lemkin 31:55 [laughs] Nobody-- Once you get to, once you get to eight figures, okay, I know, know, I know these guys i- i- i- have more money and time than engineers, but there's a point where you turn around and you say, "Maybe we should do a little," you know, OpenAI is building its own chips. I'm not saying this happened at Mercor or Scale. I'm just saying it's, um, H- Harry's point of having to, to radically go up the value chain is both more revenue but more stress because I don't, I don't, I don't think anyone's just shoveling money at, uh, at Datadog and, and Mercor without even thinking about the, the margins.
Rory O’Driscoll 32:26 I totally agree, and that's what makes the adventure fun and challenging is that you've got one, and I mean, like, you look at the checklist and you have one enormous positive, great big honking market growing like a weed, you're exploding, and then you got two negatives. The first is your margin profile is not amazing because the gross revenue is five hundred million, but you give seventy percent of it to the doctors and the mathematicians who are doing all... Or whatever it is, some percentage, I'm not gonna speculate. And then the second fact you have against you is massive customer concentration, and at some point they're gonna say, "Hmm, giving you two hundred billion, which means you're making thirty percent on that sixty million. Hell, maybe do it for forty," right? So from a long-term value extraction pers- I prefer to be O- you know, you prefer to be OpenAI and have eight hundred million customers than to be Mercor and have two. The-- When you look at those positives and negative, what you say to yourself is, "This is fundamentally a bet that the AI CapEx train will keep running for two or three or four more years." If the AI CapEx train slows down and, like, OpenAI is only gonna-
Jason Lemkin 33:26 Is that, is that enough? Is two to three years enough to justify ten billion?
Rory O’Driscoll 33:27 Well, whatever, at least. You're right, Jason. At least three to, three to five years. In other words, that it's a permanent new thing at growth. Because OpenAI is not gonna focus on getting efficient until it's dealt with hypergrowth. So as long as it's not getting efficient, you probably can lean in. If it slows down, then the positives, which is the growth rate, goes away, and then all the negatives come back to bite you. So it's a, it-- If you were to say to a public or a hedge fund guy, "Find me a bet that had the maximum exposure to hyper AI CapEx growth," this would be, you know, right up there with Nvidia. I'd say, "Yeah, I like this risk, man," you know?
Harry Stebbings 34:03 If you're, if you're doing this at ten billion, what are you underwriting it to? What does that maths look like?
Rory O’Driscoll 34:09 Um, I mean, y- as we're gonna discuss later, you should be writing anything to a three X, so you gotta be thirty billion to make it worth your while, and thirty billion and, you know... [sighs] So, you know, I, I, I'm just doing the math in my head. At, even at five X revenues, my God, that's six billion. You know, you're, you're underwriting a lot of training data, [laughs] you know? That's the, that's the sobering thing.
Jason Lemkin 34:34 In the short term, though, in the short term-
Rory O’Driscoll 34:36 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 34:36 ... if they're at five hundred million, at ten billion, growing at an unprecedented rate-
Rory O’Driscoll 34:40 You're so likely at some-
Jason Lemkin 34:41 We're all ignoring gross margins in twenty twenty-five, twenty... It's only twenty times revenue. So, like, it doesn't seem... This is where actually we're seeing revenue compression, right? Which we talked about [laughs] with Cliff and others. He doesn't like the revenue compression at Canva, right? Where this twenty X ARR, h- was, was your last deal lower than that, Harry and Rory? Higher or lower than twenty X ARR, the last deal you did?
Rory O’Driscoll 35:03 It was higher, and I-
Jason Lemkin 35:04 Higher. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 35:05 And, and, and, and, and Jason, you're exactly right. Actually, you said something else that was really insightful, your comment is, there's two modes of thinking about an investment. And I think it's really insightful, Jason. There's one mode that says, "Pencil me out the next five years. How do I think end state? What market do I have?" Right? And then there's the other mo- and therefore, what return are you underwriting? And I think if you assume five times revenue and you wanna be at three X, you're underwriting thirty billion, which means six billion in training revenue, which makes a man pause. On the other hand, you can say, "It's growing five X, and if the multiple just stays contact and it grows five X for another year, I'll be five X up." Right? And in fact, that's just what happened on the last round. It was at two billion, I don't know, at a hundred million, and now it's at eight billion, uh, sorry, ten billion at five hundred billion. So it's kind of the, the near-in revenue traction is saying to everyone, "As long as, as long as this keeps happening, you can go and validate quite quickly," 'cause watch. You look back now and, I mean, 'cause, you know, we're talking about is, is it worth ten billion, but go back, give them credit. You now look at the two billion that somebody paid six, seven months ago, and you're like, "Oh my God, that seems cheap," because you're like five hundred million already. So this is wh- when h- when high growth happens, it, it's tempting and it often pays to lean into that growth, and yeah, you very quickly, just like I think, you know, the Anthropic round at sixty-seven billion earlier this year now looks dirt cheap. If the hypergrowth comes, the, at the s- at the size of growth we're dealing with now, which is not, to your point, Jason, trouble, trouble, double, double. It's, I can't, I don't know what the word is, but fipple, fipple, deco, deco. [laughs] You know, I don't know, right? If you grow five or seven X, you can grow into almost anything. So this whole thing, top to bottom, is one big ass bet on AI CapEx hypergrowth. And as long as it keeps happening, you know, I don't wanna Chuck, quote Chuck Prince, but we all know the quote.
Harry Stebbings 36:56 No, we don't
Rory O’Driscoll 36:57 Oh, you're young then, Harry. Chuck Prince famously said in 2007 at Citigroup as, as some, some version of, "As long as the band keeps playing, I'm just gonna... You gotta stay on the floor and keep dancing." And it turns out he should've stepped down and not danced anymore, obviously-
Harry Stebbings 37:13 [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 37:13 ... given the way 2008 happened. But in other words, it's the quote of when things are working, everyone just tends to lean in.
Harry Stebbings 37:18 Well, when things are working, everyone just tends to lean in, baby. Ramp is a fundraising machine. Guys, they, they raise every few months.
Rory O’Driscoll 37:27 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 37:27 Uh, I mean, every- uh, it's nuts. Uh, reports that they're raising a new round at a $30 billion valuation reportedly. Uh, I mean, what are they doing with all the money? Eh- eh- do they need it? Is this a game of customer acquisition and brand? Do, do we just do rounds now to continuously stay relevant, to Jason's point?
Rory O’Driscoll 37:48 We talked about this a few weeks ago on the last raise, and I have nothing to say that I, I feel like I just had these comments. Yeah, there does appear to be a combination of, you know, insane demand for the pro- for the co- for the stock, um, uh, an ability to use that to create this aura of inevitability. And, you know, to some extent, as I remind you, this is, more than most companies, this is one where constant growth requires lots of capital because you're in a capital advancing business, so you probably have, you know, every dollar you add of revenue takes $5 of capital because you've gotta finance purchases 'cause you're effectively recreating Amex. So it may well be, I haven't seen the numbers, that there's a larger demand for capital here than the average deal, right? And I'm, I'm sure they can leverage some of that, but if you're going to a billion dollars, you have, probably have a $5 billion balance sheet. I remember doing the math at one point in time. So if someone's lending you four billion of that, they're probably gonna want a one billion equity cushion.
Jason Lemkin 38:47 Going from 23 billion to 30 billion, I don't even consider it an up round. It's not enough. It's not enough. No, let's say I'm a s- let's say I was a seed investor. I've probably had a, a token of dilution, okay? Let's, so let's imagine I'm down to, to 2%, which would be great. I have a $400 million position at the last round, right? Now it's worth 480 million with dilution after this next round. I mean, it's a lot, but, like, it does- it's not, it's not doubling my position like a classic round is. These, these little rounds, 22, 25, 30, and then with a lot of... Not, maybe not at Ramp, but with a lot of AI companies, a lot of dilution or a lot of others, right? You could see 10% annual dilution in these companies or more. You, you might go from t- 22 to 30 and, and have the same price per share. It's possible, right? I just don't really care about these micro step-ups that look great. You're like 30 billion. Well, if the last round was at 10, impressive, right? If the last round's at three, like Mercor, very impressive. Here I'm like, meh.
Rory O’Driscoll 39:43 That's cute, but I'm, I'm pushing back-
Jason Lemkin 39:45 For real. For real.
Rory O’Driscoll 39:46 No, I, I, I, I know it's for real. I know you. Um, but comment here, another spin on what you're saying is with the exception of the new AI companies, that probably is the kind of IRR you should expect to get in a mature growth private company, right? Remember, one of my insights over the last... I mean, sometimes I just realize the obvious, is that there's really, you know, there's early and late stage venture, and then there's venture for companies that already could comfortably be public, and I think we need a different word for that. It's not even late stage. It's, you know, private as public, right? Ramp could just as easily be a small, a mid-cap stock at this point in time public, right? And you don't expect mid-cap stocks to gap up 3X in a year. You expect, you know, the overall market will go up by 11, the best companies grow at 30, 40% year on year. So I look at this and I go, there's no reason to assume that the return to the stock should be different just 'cause it's held in a different corporate structure. You know, it, the company is the company independent of it's public or private. So I think, and that's, and the reason I mention this at such pedantic length is I think as you think about these late, super late growth fund things, the return they will realistically get absent the AI lift is some version of what was the small cap, high growth public market return, right? So for those guys, it... 'Cause you, you're going in, Jason, which, um, which, which correctly, which a venture role of thumb, right? And even on a late, let's call it a late stage company, company doing 50 million, going 100 million, it should be that two, 3X step-up financing event to financing event. When you're doing a billion dollars, you're near profitable, you should be public, you're gonna see this kind of step, these much smaller percentage step-ups because you're just in a, you really are a different asset class. You're public stocks hiding in private. Which is why, you know, the Stripe's most recent change was from 91 to 110. It's the same kind of thing.
Jason Lemkin 41:40 Right, but do, but you just said we- we're still underwriting. Harry asked you what we're underwriting to. You said at least 3X. So if I'm underwriting to 3X and I did the last Ramp round at Ramp at 23, meh. Like, it's, it's not really getting me to my 3X, is it?
Rory O’Driscoll 41:52 No, but Jason, uh, you, you, you, you are, dare I say it, confusing on your pronouns, right? And let me tell you what I mean by that.
Jason Lemkin 41:57 I believe you.
Rory O’Driscoll 41:58 Uh, but you said we're underwriting or you are. You're underwriting to a three. I'm trying to underwrite to a 3X. If you're running money at doing companies at 30 billion pre, you're probably not underwriting to an overall 3X on your fund. Now, you might get... You know, let's be fair. The most iconic company of its generation, uh, OpenAI, will give you a 10X, but I don't think you're, I don't think you are underwriting to a 3X when you're doing ultra late stage billion dollar revenue runway at $30 billion valuations. And you're definitely not underwriting to a 30% IRR, you know, right? So this is what you get. Again, going back to there's no reason to assume that just 'cause the s- companies are still private versus public, that you should get more return than you would've gotten if they were public. And we know-
Jason Lemkin 42:45 I'm with you.
Rory O’Driscoll 42:46 Yeah. So-
Jason Lemkin 42:46 Well, listen, we, I just, my only meta point is, and Harry's made this, Harry's made this in the early days, like the massive dilution at Anthropic and others, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 42:52 Oh, totally.
Jason Lemkin 42:53 I'm just less excited. I've found that things that move the needle for my little portfolio, some of these headline rounds don't always do itLike, it's not always that simple, right? It's not al- it could be years have gone by, there could be, uh, massive increases to the round, massive dilution. You might have forgotten that the last round was, was pretty high too, back in 2021. [laughs] Like, you might even be flat or down. It looks great, but, like, I just... They're not always as sexy for the IRR or the markup as you might expect. That's all.
Rory O’Driscoll 43:23 I, I... By the way, I totally agree with that, and I think that's because you're busy trying to turn, you know, 10 million into 100 million or 200 million-
Jason Lemkin 43:30 Yeah
Rory O’Driscoll 43:30 ... but there's someone else out there who is-
Jason Lemkin 43:31 It's a fucking jungle
Rory O’Driscoll 43:31 ... very happy to turn a billion into two billion. Very happy indeed. And it's gonna make more money than you, just to make it even sadder, dude, right? Way more money.
Jason Lemkin 43:39 More money. And keeping your IRR, trying to keep your IRR above 40% is not easy on a fu- as, uh, later in life of the fund. It gets really hard, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 43:47 Agreed. And but for those g- again, I go back to, and for those guys, a different game. So yeah, we... The, the aha is, to me, the two biggest changes of the last three to five years have been the advent of what's happening in AI and the transformation of the late stage and IPO marketplace to this ultra, ultra late stage where companies are way beyond the IPO threshold and still private. Those are the biggest two changes in the game.
Harry Stebbings 44:16 I completely agree, and on the second, I go back to actually Jason's point on the modest size of the Andreessen funds, 'cause when you take the $6 billion growth fund minus... No, just pause. At minus fees, you're at 4.8. You've got 20 $200 million checks. It, it's not that much. It actually feels very reasonable in terms of size.
Jason Lemkin 44:34 To their credit in that, in that, in that, that chart that went around, they did do a good job of recycling. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 44:39 Yes. Well, I mean, Jason-
Jason Lemkin 44:40 They did, they did an excellent job of recycling. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 44:43 Yes. And recycling is good.
Jason Lemkin 44:44 So we can assume they get the full six out, but fair point. [laughs] It's not a lot of checks.
Harry Stebbings 44:48 David George is very, very good. I'm always impressed by
Spray and Pray: Does it Work: Data Breakdown
Harry Stebbings 44:51 him. Uh, I wanna move to spray and pray. There's different models of venture. Um, you can be concentrated or you can be spray and pray. Spray and pray, for those that don't know, is obviously having a broadly diversified portfolio, investing in lots of different companies rather than few with more money. Um, there's always a question of does spray and pray work? There was some data released by Carter. What did the data say, and how do we think about spray and pray today?
Rory O’Driscoll 45:17 I disagree. I, I, I read the data. I also read, Jason, your blog, the blog post on SaaStr, and I think your, your characterization of the... Your, your characterization of spray and pray is wrong, to be very direct. I think the data was awesome. Let's start back with the comment. The, the Carter data was awesome and very pleasing. Stepping off it, what it w- what it told people, for listeners, is they looked at all 547 2018 Series B investments, and then they did a histogram of where they come out in less than a 1X, you know, one to a 2X-
Jason Lemkin 45:48 Oh, that was Series B?
Rory O’Driscoll 45:49 So 547, and then, you know, 20... 18% of them greater than a 5X, about 10% of them greater than a 10X, and one deal, Figma, returned 100X, right? And what's... Well, I... That's a pretty sizable chunk of information. What's it telling you, right? And, you know, and w- yeah, I find it really interesting 'cause in fact, you know, we typically do As and Bs, and I'm very pl- I was very happy actually, by the way. It was exactly what the distribution for our fund model we think has to be, which is 30%. They were actually 35. We would've said 30 less than a 1X. We do wider buckets, 1 to 5X, 50%. They broke that into two buckets, and greater than a 5X, 20%. So the distributions on 547 deals match pretty much what we're saying, right? That's a long answer. So if you hit those three buckets correctly, the blended return, I know it from our fund model, is 3.7X gross, 3X net to the LP, right? So if you look at that business, if you look at all those things and you get your... and you put... you get enough slots in the buckets, right, in each of the buckets, the good buckets, the 5X bucket and the 10X bucket, you end up with a 3X net to the LP. So the first piece of good news is if you do it right, the return was available to you. The interesting thing is, to your point, is the right strategy spray and pay? And I, I don't think that's what it... And that's why I was jumping back on it. I don't think that's what it said. I mean, I think it says, you know, you gotta pick very carefully, 'cause obviously if you do a lot of deals, but... I mean, Jason picked on the s- looking at the same data, Jason picked on the negative, which is two-thirds of all deals are less than a 2X, which means they just don't help. Correct, Jason? That was, that was the point you made in the blog, right?
Jason Lemkin 47:31 Yes.
Rory O’Driscoll 47:32 And, and, and what it says is picking is so important because if, if, it, you know, if, if, if-
Jason Lemkin 47:38 But did it, did, did it say that?
Rory O’Driscoll 47:41 I... No, your blog didn't say that, but I'm saying... I think the data says that.
Jason Lemkin 47:44 But, uh, first of all, you're right. I mean, at... To me, the data was shocking as someone that is a concentrated investor because this is scary risk for me, but it did blend out to 3X net. Plenty good, right? So, so you're right, and, um, but at, at Series B, everyone thinks they're a great picker, don't they? This isn't pre-seed. Everyone's a great picker at Series B, right? So does everyone have the same logarithmic distribution across the, across these deals or, um... I, I don't know.
Rory O’Driscoll 48:13 No, they probably don't. I mean, I, I wouldn't say ev-everyone... I, I'd say three things. Everyone thinks they're a great picker. Not everyone is a great picker. But the third sentence is you have to be a great picker to win, right? Because if you look... I was thinking at it. You, you kinda articulated those two strategies. You can, at this... You know, a-again, faced with this s- opportunity set of 547 Series Bs in one year, right? That's the... It's a very clear data point, right? Um, I think if you don't pick, if you, if, if you're not a good picker, you will end up with more... Remember, to Jason's... Jason said a different set of buckets, but his buckets are more scary. He said two-thirds of all these deals are less than a 2X. If you skew... And that's on average. If you skew instead of 66%, if you skew 75, 80% in that less than 2X bucket, your math doesn't work.And it's not that hard to be that bad because on average, it's sixty-six percent is my point, right? It requires a fair amount of discipline and picking to pull this off. I don't think the spray-and-pay strategy would work here. It might work at seed. I'm not as familiar with seed. But here, the cost of spraying just gets too high. The picking doesn't work. The only way it does, and I can see Harry doing his I don't agree face, is I think there's actually three stra- there's actually three approaches. There's picking, there's spraying, and then the third one, which is someone big like Andreessen can do, which is optioning, right? You can s- you can spray if you have opti- if you're just doing options. But if you spray and that's the only way you make your money, the probability of being wrong is just too high.
The Role of Option Checks Venture Capital
Harry Stebbings 49:52 So that's exactly what I was gonna say, which is actually in reference to an amazing graph that was released a month or so ago about seed bets by multi-stage firms. And Andreessen did seventy-two seed bets compared to Score in number two at twenty-seven. And exactly to your point there, Rory, you said you can't win without being a great picker. I'm not saying Andreessen are not great pickers. I'm not saying anything against them. But you can if you have seventy-two option bets.
Rory O’Driscoll 50:16 Agreed. Agreed.
Harry Stebbings 50:16 And you pay that.
Rory O’Driscoll 50:16 There are three strategies. There's spraying, picking, and optioning, right? And to, to do the optioning strategy... And 'cause, 'cause the beauty about when you can option, you can afford to spray more. Optioning allows you to spray more, right? The... You're exactly right. No, I, I think it's super clear at every stage. And again, it goes back to structurally... I mean, once upon a time, you thought seed was all about option value, and anything beyond that wasn't. Because we're dealing with gargantuan sums of money, it is now plausible that for some people, As and Bs are partially options. And really it's if you're gonna deploy two hundred million in the growth round, you know, you don't wanna be totally slipshod at the A and the B, but you can think of it as more option value, right? And that, and that's absolutely a, a superpower that a wall of money gives you, right? I can't afford to do that because most of my money goes in on my initial round. At most, fifty, sixty percent comes in follow-ons. So I can't afford to be wrong on two-thirds of my money [chuckles] to be right on one-third. That's not gonna make me a dollar, right? So poor me, I'm stuck having to pick.
Harry Stebbings 51:21 Does the ever-expanding outcome scenarios that we're seeing today, you know, before thirty billion dollars was insane, insane valuation for a company. Now we're kind of like, "Meh" with Ramp, "Meh," ten billion with Mercor, and w- we're not blown away by it. The outcome sizes are getting so much bigger. Does that not favor a spray strategy? 'Cause all that you need to do if you're early is just get into the winners. Who cares? Uh, not who cares, but five hundred K or two million, it doesn't matter. Spray the five hundred Ks 'cause the only thing that matters is Mercor and Ramp and everyone are in yours.
Rory O’Driscoll 51:57 No, because what you're doing is you're taking a plausible theory and extrap... and, and, you know, and extrapolating to the point where it no longer holds true. You can spray as much as your bankroll will allow you. The more bankroll you have to build up option value... I mean, well, step back. You could be talking about two things, Harry, and you gotta break them apart. Are you saying simply spray because I'm not gonna make my money on follow-ons, but it's the seed argument. I have to be in the very best deal, and I have to cover wide versus concentrated to do that.
Harry Stebbings 52:28 Mm-hmm.
Rory O’Driscoll 52:29 Right? And that's one thread, and then the separate thread would be, how much easier is the, is the spray constraint if I also have option value at the back end, right? And that's easier. There's no doubt the more option val... Let's agree the following. The more option value you have at the back end, 'cause you have a ten trillion dollar fund, the easier it is to spray because you can amortize the cost of the losses over the one winner. Provided you get to stick five hundred billion in the winner, the rest is noise.
Harry Stebbings 52:54 But if you're a seed fund and you're David Tisch today, who, and, uh, uh, he won't mind me ca- calling him out, he, he explicitly does respectfully spray and pray. He does fifty-plus companies plus plus in a portfolio with low ownership. But my word, he is in some of the biggest companies, including Ramp, consistently.
Rory O’Driscoll 53:13 Again, going back to the Carder data, what I like about Carder is it's actual data, not words. There were five hundred and forty-seven series Bs in two thousand and eighteen. I'm gonna guess graduation rate probably about... that implies eight hundred As, that probably implies one thousand six hundred seeds. So even what you are pejoratively calling, quote-unquote, "spray and pray" is doing fifty deals out of one thousand six hundred. There's still a huge element of picking involved in that. The only people on the planet who have a structural business where they can de-emphasize picking 'cause they can write checks, option checks at scale is Y Combinator, 'cause they have a structured advantage in terms of their economics. They are the only people who've built a mass production seed business. But for everyone else, if you're trying to pick even fifty and there's one thousand six hundred places, right? I mean, and we know that at the B, only five hundred of them get to the B. There are one thousand one hundred places to put that money that doesn't work out. It'll always be true that if you pick the single largest outlier in any vintage, like if one of those deals was Figma, where the B made a hundred, so probably the A made, I, I can tell, about, about two hundred, and the C probably four or five hundred. I don't... Right? Of that order of mag- the numbers are available. Three hundred, right? Even if it's three hundred, if you did an index and did every deal, you know, you made a three hundred X and you did all one thousand six hundred deals equally, it's only a point two, it's only a point two return. Do you understand me? In other words, if you put a dollar into everything, your Figma check doesn't re- quote-unquote, "return the fund," right? If you did the whole industry, right? Now, maybe an OpenAI would. Maybe there is one deal so big that it would literally return the vintage such that if you just bought the entire vintage, you're good. That probably happens maybe once every decade or two, right? Most of the time, even at the seed stage, if there's not an element of picking to it-Yeah. You, you can't just say it's praying, is my point. There's an element of picking up and down the stack. I mean, it's funny, I was more- the Jason headline, only one in three deals double investors' money per carta data. That's a... It's so sobering. It's like it makes you remember how much of this business is disappointment. You know, you, you remember your deals, you remember your 10Xs and your 15Xs and your 20Xs, and you just forget, you just... And I think actually the best investors and just learn to-
Harry Stebbings 55:37 You, you become numb to it, Rory
Rory O’Driscoll 55:40 ... I don't. I get all sad. I'm a bit lame. Um-
Harry Stebbings 55:44 I had a shit out- I had a shit outcome this morning, and now I'm really, like, upset by it. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 55:50 Yeah. You get vested. Well, we can talk about that-
Harry Stebbings 55:52 I know, you know, I, I had the w- I had the worst, which is a company gets bought by another company, and you get stock at some insanely high price. I mean, it's just the worst.
Rory O’Driscoll 56:04 That's not the worst. No. The worst, it's... Let me... Dude, the worst is you're on the board, you try and sell the company, it doesn't close, you're on the hook for shutdown costs, and you have to wire 300 or, or 400 grand just to pay severance costs, which you should do as a board member, and you're probably legally obliged to do, and then write that money off straight away 'cause you waited too long. That's the worst.
Harry Stebbings 56:23 Wow, I thought my day was bad. That's, that's perspective for you, kids. [laughs]
Jason Lemkin 56:26 That's why I just do everything on a SAFE.
Harry Stebbings 56:31 [laughs]
Jason Lemkin 56:32 I have no rights-
Harry Stebbings 56:34 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 56:34 ... no visibility, no financial statements-
Harry Stebbings 56:36 No meat
Jason Lemkin 56:36 ... no understanding of anything. But if it goes south, [laughs] I can just ghost them. [laughs]
Harry Stebbings 56:44 Are you serious though, Jason?
Jason Lemkin 56:46 What?
Rory O’Driscoll 56:46 No.
Harry Stebbings 56:47 About just doing everything on a SAFE?
Jason Lemkin 56:49 No. But, um, but the SAFE does have some comforts. I, I do like the post-money cap as a seed investor. I don't have to worry about the pool or other things. Um, and I like the fact that, um, it's a, it's a, it's a medium commitment. It's a me- like, I'm not the only guy. Like, I don't always love being the only guy in the cap table, the only director. The SAFE is like, "Listen, I'm only sorta committing, guys. [laughs] Good luck to you. If it goes great, I'll invest some more. If it doesn't, I'll, I'll write cheery responses to your monthly updates. But you didn't ask me to, to... You didn't ask me to get married and commit, so I'm not committed." You think I'm joking, but I... That stuff Rory talks about is awful, right? This, this end of life stuff or a decade of a struggling company where you're on the board. I, I, I... I'll take the SAFE over that. [laughs] The unsafe SAFE. The... Because the commitment is low back. Founders should be... Founders are... If you're gonna raise on S- in Saturday on a SAFE, she can't expect too much.
Harry Stebbings 57:47 S- speaking of commitment and marriage, I'm really intrigued to hear your thoughts on this one, Jason, 'cause you've said like, "Oh, I encourage founders to sell. I encourage-"
Jason Lemkin 57:55 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 57:55 "... founders to sell when the offer comes in."
Jason Lemkin 57:57 So there's no regrets.
Harry Stebbings 57:58 Well, Syn-
Jason Lemkin 57:58 So there's no regrets. Yeah
Harry Stebbings 57:59 ... Syn- Synthesia, one of the hottest, fastest growing AI companies-
Jason Lemkin 58:03 Yeah
Harry Stebbings 58:03 ... you know, now at 150 million in ARR, reportedly turned down a $3 billion offer from Adobe to be acquired, and they're gonna be raising a new round at well north of 3 billion following this. [laughs] Jason, if you were on the board, would you have told them, "Sell for 3 billion"?
Jason Lemkin 58:20 I mean, yes, and I'm not saying it's the right decision, but one, he's been at it for a while. Like, Synthesia is one of these stories like Replit and Vercel that, like, blew up with AI, but it's a journey, right? And so... And there's competition, and it's a while. And, um, I would tell him to take it, um, unless you're 100% sure you're gonna build a $20 billion public company, $10 billion public company. And if you are, do it. Like, but I like to stress the test, right? Um, um, so I'm not saying that's the right thing to do, but I wanna be the guy that gives that advice.
Harry Stebbings 58:55 10 or 20? 'Cause that's two different outcomes.
Jason Lemkin 58:58 Even 10 is not really worth it for a founder. It is worth it for the VCs. Excel gets another play, right? Three to 10 for Excel. Here's the issue, right? Three to 10 for Excel, huge difference, right? So let's say they own 15% out of a what? $450 million fund. Who knows? Let's make it up, right? So instead of a 1X fund returner, it could be a two or 3X. You, you make that bet as a VC all day long, right? For the founder, let's say he owns 10%. What the hell is the difference? There's no difference, right? There's no difference, right? We've had billionaires on ours. You've had billionaires, Harry. I don't think Jeff Lawson would be living the better life with half the money or twice the money. It's the same dude. So, like, that... Th- we... There is a weird disconnect between three and 10 here for VCs versus founders. 'Cause 1X your fund and 3X, that's a lot more carry.
Harry Stebbings 59:41 I, I would say with an Excel and Index, you're absolutely right. They'll absolutely take the risk for another turn because they have the luxury of do-
Jason Lemkin 59:47 Ah
Harry Stebbings 59:47 ... because they have the luxury of doing so. They don't need to return cash to LPs in the same way that maybe other managers do. If you are not a tier one GP, though, you will wanna provide DPI to your investors, especially-
Jason Lemkin 59:58 I don't believe that. I don't see it. I've asked my LPs. I've asked a few others. If you're a strong manager, okay? If you have a track record and their goal is not a 3X seed fund, but if they really want 5X or north out of you, they get the game is you gotta keep playing another card. Uh, no matter what they say. I, I've, I, I've asked my LP, and I guess it's a small set, "Do you want more money back," right? Even asked my most conservative LP, like a university endowment that isn't, that, that, that is small, right? That has stress. I asked, "Well, would you want your money back?" I mean, with the gain, they're like, "No, we're just telling you we're really worried about it. Like, we really want DPI, but we don't want it... We, we want you to play another card." So, uh, I think if you tell them, it... I, I, you know, I'm... I, I seeded into Synthesia and we've got a chance to 3X it, they're gonna tell you to go for it. The, the fu- it... We're gonna trust the fund manager's discretion here. I, I just don't know that there's this massive DPI pressure if you have a hot ha- if you have a hot hand. I think there's DPI pressure if you have a mediocre hand, in which case, so what? Because it's not enough DPI. What the hell is the re- what's the hel- this is the other thing on X. What the hell's the point of returning 0.2% of your, 20% of your fund? Hooray, I got an exit today. I returned 21% of my fund. Like, it's, that's just... That ain't the full job, friends. [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 1:01:12 So the first question really should beIt's actually what Jason said is, "Victor, you know, I, I, I admire Synthesia enormously as a company. We tried to contact them. They, they didn't get back to me. They got the deal done. I'm so disappointed. We have another investment in the space. I love the space. I admire Synthesia a ton, and m- many of the investors there." I think the first question is y- how do you feel about the business? And you threw out a statistic there. They, they, they said they were at 100 million in ARR when they took the Adobe money in April, I checked, right? And if they really have gone from 100 to 150 in less than six months, then I can make this conversation really quick. There's no way they should sell, because that thing's exploding, right? It's a great category and I think-
Jason Lemkin 1:01:54 It's a good point.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:01:54 Right?
Jason Lemkin 1:01:54 And it probably is. That probably-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:01:55 And probably. I don't know
Jason Lemkin 1:01:56 ... that sounds good. I don't think that's Sony money, but that sounds right to me.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:01:58 You know, even if not, even if they got, you know, doubling kind of growth, it just feels like a good category. There's a reason we made another investment in the space. We like the category. We liked... And I think there's, you know, I think there's runway there for that kind of human interface to compute. So the q- I always tell the CEO, "Now would be a really good time for you, A, to look into your own heart and see how you feel, right? And if there's something about the business that's really worrying you and you haven't told us, now would be a good time to share," right? And sometimes stuff comes out.
Jason Lemkin 1:02:29 The other reason I tell CEOs this, one, I, I would tell Victor to sell at 3 billion, and it's okay if he says no. I would do it because I wanted to be the guy-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:02:36 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 1:02:36 ... even if it wasn't in my direct interest as a gambler, uh, I would tell, I, I want to be the guy that has that conversation with him. There's another thing that's under-discussed, and I've had this conversation twice with founders in the last 12 to 18 months in similar situations, is, um, are you really an IPO guy? This is where I... There was one where I love everything about this company. I love the founders. I love everything. There's nothing negative. Uh, and I told them to take the offer even though I didn't want them to as an investor. I told them to take the offer because they said, "Are you sure? You're such a great set of founders." But I don't know if today I, I see you living the, living the, what these public companies CEO life. Like, I just don't see it. The-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:03:14 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 1:03:15 ... the way you have to do it, the constraints, the stress, I just don't think that's what you want to do. So I think you should take the deal because I don't know if, if it's Synthesia or Synthesia Prime, you're gonna get another offer like this before the IPO. That's the thing. You have to assume it's IPO or bust, and if you're not that g- then you're gonna bring in an outside CEO or you're gonna... Uh, it's just a mess. So that's the question I have. Do you, can you really run a, do you really want to run a public company for real?
Rory O’Driscoll 1:03:39 That's an excellent question, Jason. Genuine. That is really an excellent que- Because you're right. At, at 3 billion, there's not gonna be a ton of people coming in to view offering five. You either got to become cash flow positive and settle down and just become the Collison brothers and compound private forever to, you know, to universal befuddlement, or you got to go public. And yeah, that's, it's, it's a great question, and it's... And the fact, by the way, that it is perceived by so many CEOs as a pain in the butt is, in my view, the thing about being public that has to change. Because what you're doing is you're allowing this thing to get in the way of people en- entrepreneurial ambitions. I think it's a sh- I think you're right that it's a pain, and I think it's a shame that it's a pain, and I hope it changes.
Jason Lemkin 1:04:21 I mean, I was at this, uh, Dreamforce, uh, Benioff dinner. It was great, and I saw maybe 10 public company B2B CEOs that we know that have all been on Harry's show, and Rory's invested in some of them. And I got-- And it was great, and it was fun. I got some hugs. Um-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:04:35 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 1:04:35 ... believe it or not, I'm a hu- I don't give the hugs, but I like to get them. Um, but, um, man, the stress on, on the, on those guy- You could just smell it out of the pores, you know, the stress. It, it... Or, or more the weight. They weren't stressed. No one's stressed, right? The weight, the weight of being a pub- It's so heavy today, right? We could see it when we'd had Jeff Lawson on, and Cliff didn't have any of it at Canva. He didn't have any of the weight. It's crushing. It's just, like, crushing, and, uh-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:05:00 I have Mike Cannon-Brookes on the show from Atlassian.
Jason Lemkin 1:05:03 Yeah.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:05:03 Um-
Jason Lemkin 1:05:03 Some crushing weight there too. I saw it. Some crushing weight I saw on that one, right? You saw it, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 1:05:07 Yeah. Yeah. The wei- the weight of being the unreasonable man. Yeah, his co-founder calls him the unreasonable man, the guy who wills things into existence, and, and the weight of that you could see on his face.
Jason Lemkin 1:05:17 Totally. And when I look at the Ramp and the Mercor and the Stripes, like, these are epic companies, right? But I don't see that weight yet. N- I'm not saying it's not... It's the hardest job in the world, don't get me wrong, right? B- but I don't see the, the deep crow's feet and, and, like, you know, Aaron Levie going from, from, going gray at 28 or whatever. I just don't see that [chuckles] level of, of Anvil level Wile E. Coyote weight on their, on their heads yet. [chuckles]
Rory O’Driscoll 1:05:43 That, that, that will go to something about Andre and capital efficiency. Rory, I just have to ask you. You said there about, like, "Hey, we, we tried to get in contact with Synthesia. They didn't get in touch." I- I've learned over time if you want to be in Andre, then that is best thing is just to, to pay the higher price for Andre, not to try and be in the next one. You said you've got the sa- a- another play in the space. Why not just be in Synthesia? And do you not think this market takes the way most markets do in terms of composition and the winner accrues the most value?
Jason Lemkin 1:06:15 I do. I think we're, uh, it's a broad way. We have a very different product. It's kind of real-time interactivity versus, um, you know, um, asynchronous avatars. So there's a big difference in terms of the interaction. It's a company called Tavis. So basically, instead of pre-recording an avatar saying something or having a written, you actually have real-time interactivity with the avatar, right? So it's, it's, at high level, it's the same conceptual trend, but I agree. We, because we looked... Look, we looked at a Synthesia wannabe at the time, I'm not gonna mention the name, and we decided Synthesia is one. I'm not in, you're not in the business of doing modest number twos. Agreed. So you're playing the broad trend in a different pa- i- in a different, in a, in a related but different market. I agree. You never wanna do the, "Number one wouldn't have me. I couldn't get into them," or, "They had just raised a round." You either pay up for the later round... I made that mistake in 2013. I won't mention the two companies.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:07:07 You know, we had missed the rounds that were the typical scale round for company A. We actually had a chance with a lot of networking and put-- to do a very late-stage round in company A, or we could do a more normal scale round in company B in exactly the same market. The two most head-to-head companies I've ever done. We did B, we got a two X. We didn't do A, we left a fifteen X on the table. Literally, every time we discuss this in the offsite, one of my partners I love, I love them dearly, "Oh, uh, the canonical example has become that decision." And I'm like, "Am I gonna hear about this till I die, people?" Right? I know I got that one wrong, but, uh, they're right. They're right to mention it. That was a you thunk through... Exactly. You never wanna do the way behind sa- exact same category number two if they're way behind. It's just too hard. Yes. I've made-- I've, I've, I, I remember the week I got that learning. I can tell you where exactly where I was when I took those two phone calls.
Amazon's Struggles: How Do They Return to Greatness in AI
Rory O’Driscoll 1:08:03 Don't do that.
Harry Stebbings 1:08:04 Okay. We can do Anduril capital efficiency, we can do Amazon layoffs, we can do Amazon cloud wars or Oracle debt. You choose.
Jason Lemkin 1:08:14 I feel bad for Roomba, but you choose.
Harry Stebbings 1:08:16 Ooh, y- you wanna do Roomba?
Jason Lemkin 1:08:18 Kind of. Kind of, uh, 'cause this whole talk is about how everything's up and to the right. Poor Roomba gets an offer from Amazon to buy them for one point seven billion-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:08:27 Yeah, and then go down the list if we've time
Jason Lemkin 1:08:29 ... blocked by antitrust. They raised two hundred billion, million of debt to finance the gap, and now it's all spent and they're probably gonna go bankrupt. This is why maybe, maybe, maybe take the Synthesia offer. Owning maybe a half dozen Roombas over the years, it's a tough, it's a tough end to a founder journey, isn't it? [sniffs] Sorry, maybe that's not the story you wanted to pick. You go ahead.
Harry Stebbings 1:08:49 Do you sue the government in that case?
Rory O’Driscoll 1:08:51 No, cro- uh, I think in the UK it's called crown immune. It's, it's hard. It's very hard. I mean, I can't remember because you can sue the g- I mean, in the UK you have crown immunity where literally governments are protected from incredibly dumb acts 'cause they're the government. I think over here we have more rights, but still, and I'm winging it here now, now. Like I, I can't remember, did they actually... If the DOJ blocks something on antitrust count, you can, uh, you can take them to court and pe- and those DOJ decisions have been overturned. I can't remember in this case did they take it to court or did they just decide to fold? And if you decided to fold, then you probably can't sue because you had a statutory remedy and you chose not to take it. I mean, so again, zooming out for people, the story here is iRoomba had a, had a deal to be sold to Amazon and the FTC, led by Lina Khan, chose to block that deal be- uh, 'cause that's, I think Benedict, uh, Evans said in his plea, because of an insipid monopoly in the house vacuum cleaner marketplace.
Jason Lemkin 1:09:50 [laughs]
Rory O’Driscoll 1:09:50 Very tongue in cheek, right? It was an absurd decision at the time, and it only got more absurd since because unfortunately the poor company, which is a consumer, consumer hardware business with all the gross margin profile that requires, struggle on a standalone basis and you right now faces the risk of going bust. It's a horrible and unfair outcome for which the government and Lina Khan and the FTC is entirely responsible based on an outdated, stupid and foolish paper. There's just nothing, and beli- and, and a foolish belief about how things work. Beyond done.
Jason Lemkin 1:10:21 It's, it's also another... I mean, there's, there's the, there's the whole how the antitrust killed the company. The, the, it's the edge of no politics rule, right? But not past it. It's also a reminder that like when you go into the, the M&A offer, the Synthesia, sometimes you'll get, like the acquirer will pay a multiple that only sort of kind of makes sense, a revenue multiple that makes sense-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:10:41 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 1:10:41 ... for them but you couldn't get. And so, you know, when you get one of these deals it's a, it's, it's tragic it died, but you gotta take it, right? You gotta take it. Um.
Harry Stebbings 1:10:51 I don't know. If you're Synthesia, you're looking at Dylan and Figma going, "God, do I wanna put myself in that potential-
Jason Lemkin 1:10:56 No
Harry Stebbings 1:10:56 ... eighteen-month waiting period?"
Jason Lemkin 1:10:58 I, I, exactly.
Harry Stebbings 1:10:59 By which time I'll be four hundred million in revenue being acquired for three billion. Pfft, no.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:11:05 You think you're getting this great multiple of, oh, they're paying me thirty times revenue, but the damn thing's gonna close in eighteen months, by which time you might be down to ten times and it's just not gonna feel that much. Like I don't think Wiz has closed yet. I could be wrong. I think it was early twenty-
Jason Lemkin 1:11:19 But that's the crazy one that hasn't closed. It's crazy, right?
Rory O’Driscoll 1:11:21 And you know, if you think about it, everyone's like, "Yeah, you got a two and a half X in six months." No you didn't, you got a two and a half X in two years, right? And this antitrust, this prolonged antitrust process really is kind of sand in the gears for a lot of these M&A decisions and at the margin probably pushes people to push o- either, A, push on, or B, in the case of the crazy deals, when the acquirer only wants the people then they do the, you know, the, the, the, the Silicon Valley acqui-hire routine. But you know, when you're buying the vacuum cleaner company, you want the freaking vacuums. [laughs] You know?
Why IRR is a BS Metric and What Matters More
Rory O’Driscoll 1:11:54 Right.
Harry Stebbings 1:11:54 That duration period though is also why I think it's our responsibility as early stage managers to be much more proactive in secondary markets 'cause we get cash back way sooner and the age old thing of a four X fund over seventeen years is the same as a two point five X fund over ten, and duration matters and time matters and IRR is king.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:12:12 It's not the only king, 'cause obviously a, you know, a... I mean, back to Jason's comment, the f- I mean, he was just sneering at a f- 'cause look, in this very show Jason was going, "Oh, it's only a thirty percent IRR ramp from the two, twenty-two billion to thirty billion." From an IRR perspective that looks amazing. So I don't think, I don't think IRR matters. I actually think, for the record, formulation of the optimization function is the maximization of multiple subject to a constraint on a minimum IRR. Just to be a total geek here. Basically, you should know what your target IRR is, and let's just say it's twenty-five percent. Let's just say, right? You wanna maximize the multiple provided you don't dip below twenty-five, right? That's actually what you're trying to do, right? So a f- so for example, a thirty percent IRR in one year isn't as good as a twenty-five percent IRR for four years. But if you hold on too long and that twenty-five starts dipping to nineteen, eighteen, seventeen, then you've gone to a different place. That is the rule, right? 'Cause in the end you want the maximum amount of capital to investAnd you, and you get that because you are held accountable at the investor level, at the IRR basis, because at some point they're looking at you, they're looking at the public markets and they're saying, "Risk-adjusted, I need me my twenty percent." So it is the constraint because it's what prevents money from coming down the spigot to you, but you're actually trying to maximize your multiple.
Harry Stebbings 1:13:34 So the shit is hitting the fan at Amazon before we do, uh, agree or disagree. Ten percent largest layoffs in history, ten percent of white collar that is, that very sizable. Falling behind in cloud wars from thirty-- fifty percent of cloud revenues in twenty eighteen to thirty-eight percent today. Uh, Raymond James sees Amazon's AI cloud share falling to seven percent. Then we had the outage, billions of damage. I mean, f- this was a bad fortnight.
Jason Lemkin 1:14:05 You know what? Maybe it's not fair, but what I was thinking is contrast this with Sergey Brin coming back to Google, everything else happening. Maybe, maybe this was a tough time for your founder to leave and go to Miami. Maybe this was not-- Maybe it seemed like a very stable time to do a transition, right? I mean, long, long wa-- Jeff Bezos' longtime as CEO, but maybe this wasn't the perfect age of it. Maybe stepping down just before AI hit was suboptimal for Amazon.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:14:33 Or that's, that... Yes. Or maybe it was brilliant for Jeff because maybe, you know-
Jason Lemkin 1:14:39 He's off the hook [laughs] .
Rory O’Driscoll 1:14:40 'Cause, 'cause, 'cause you're implying in that, that had he stayed, all these bad things wouldn't have happened. And it's plausible just given his, you know, world top two or three entrepreneurial achievement of the last t- three decades. But it's just worth pointing out what the two big problems they have are. The first problem is in their retail business, they over-invested for COVID, and now they're trying to replace people with robotics because the technology is there, and that's just something that had to be done, right? That's just, that's just more of the same. And in cloud, it's less that their core AWS business has folded up. It's like all the new compute, which is ten X and twenty X larger in terms of demand for these customers, is AI-related compute, and you, you know, you've neither built something compelling standalone nor have you partnered, except to be fair, a little bit with Anthropic. You didn't made it-- make a meaningful partnership, and you haven't found a way to get some of that compute, right? You know, not clear-
Jason Lemkin 1:15:41 But he had four years. Andrew Jassy took over in July fifth-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:15:44 Agreed. No
Jason Lemkin 1:15:44 ... twenty twenty-one. Bezos checked out right at the peak-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:15:48 He won. No
Jason Lemkin 1:15:48 ... of the last era when, when products were frozen in time for a decade, when AWS was the same product for a year. So were most of the companies we invested in, all three of us. In twenty twenty-one, they were the same products as twenty fifteen.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:00 Totally.
Jason Lemkin 1:16:00 It was the great time to go to Miami because nothing ch- was w- changing in the world. It was just go-- just stock prices were going up and revenue, but the products were the same. So why wouldn't you retire? There's, there's not gonna be any change.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:10 Punched out at the top. No, gets, gets an A++ from Mark Tatami.
Jason Lemkin 1:16:14 No. He-- I think he gets an F.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:17 Oh, God. Um-
Jason Lemkin 1:16:18 If he sold, if he sold his company-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:20 True
Jason Lemkin 1:16:20 ... you get an A+.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:21 That, that's true. But even-
Jason Lemkin 1:16:23 Yeah. Like my last deal, SalesLoft December twenty twenty-one, th- you know, two and a half billion.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:27 Yeah.
Jason Lemkin 1:16:27 That was the last deal of the era.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:29 Kyle, Kyle won.
Jason Lemkin 1:16:29 You know, Kyle and team get an A+ for timing. This is not the same.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:33 I wanna congratulate Kyle. Exactly. This is not-
Jason Lemkin 1:16:35 This is not the same. This is punching out at twenty twenty-one and not punching back in like Sergey.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:16:40 S- cynical comment here. You're right. But when you've got a couple of hundred billion dollars, my guess is you're not maximizing money, you're maxing psychic pain and joy. My guess is his psychic joy in the last three or four years doing what he's been doing has been significantly higher than the psychic pain that would have been involved in realizing you've never done a big acquisition in your life. You've got to do a huge corporate deal in AI to matter. And B, all those people you hired in twenty-one trying to do the right thing for COVID and expand, you all gotta lay them off. So i- I don't think it would-- My point is-
Jason Lemkin 1:17:11 I think Bezos would lay off half his company in a, in a-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:17:13 Not even blink
Jason Lemkin 1:17:14 ... fortnite if it was the right thing. I don't think he'd even care.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:17:15 Well, he'll have that chance. He's, you know. But again, also-
Jason Lemkin 1:17:19 I mean, Chegg had to bring in poor Dan Rosenwick out of retirement to rerun Chegg. After laying off eighty percent of the company, they had to bring him back.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:17:26 That didn't work out either.
Jason Lemkin 1:17:26 They gotta bring Bezos back [laughs] .
Rory O’Driscoll 1:17:28 I think, a- and to be fair, one thing we shouldn't do here, and, you know, you saw a lot of it with Google too, is that you don't wanna overcompensate. I mean, if you look at the two, i- if you kinda, like, there's a bunch of bad news in one day, and it is bad, right? The layoff going on, the layoffs, right. But again, going back to your position in retail is broadly good. You're a little sh- you know, I think you've become a little schlocky in terms of the c- shopping experience, but you have dominance because of your distribution, and you're doubling down on that. You're reinvesting in robotics, you're cutting costs, and the Amazon wins in, in their retail business because they can deliver shit faster than anyone else on the planet pretty much anywhere, and you're doubling down on that. So that's like a win. On the compute biz, on the AWS business, your problem is you just, you're not relevant in the new world, so just knuckle down and figure that out. To be fair, of the three hyperscalers in the, um, pre-AI world, if you look at it, Google was able to be relevant because they had their own model. Microsoft went and rented a model from OpenAI, and now, [chuckles] now the contract's nearly up, and they, they, you know, they did it to make a lot of capital gain, but they didn't actually, I-- in my view, really develop something compelling that they own from it, and you did nothing. So you lose. You, you need to do something. They got a set of problems on the AWS side. They have to get AI relevant without, frankly, doing what Oracle I fear is doing, which is taking on a whole bunch of subpar economic transactions. They do have a good slug of Anthropic, not as much as Google, who I think owns fourteen percent.
Harry Stebbings 1:18:58 Google own fourteen percent of Anthropic.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:19:00 Google, yes, Google win, yeah. I mean, again, we should be promoting all these corp dev guys. They're doing great.
Harry Stebbings 1:19:06 Unbelievable. I think people forget that. Um, guys, we're gonna do agree or disagree, okay? I got three statements. Rory, you love this.
Jason Lemkin 1:19:14 I hate this because of the policy.
Harry Stebbings 1:19:14 Come on. You, you can, you can hide your, hide your excitement, Rory. It's too much. I know.
Jason Lemkin 1:19:18 It's pure shit out of your ass. I hate it.
Harry Stebbings 1:19:20 No. Oh, I know, and the previous hour and a half wasn't.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:19:25 I do, I do research, Harry. That's the difference between us
Harry Stebbings 1:19:27 [laughs] Ah, dear. It's ve- very fair point. I c- can't, can't disagree with this. Um, okay, first one. I would rather own Brax at 13 than Ramp at 30. Ramp is at a billion in revenue. Brax is at 700. They're both around the breakeven to moving profitable phase
Rory O’Driscoll 1:19:47 And you've given me all the information except the only information I need, which is what's the... Oh, which is what's the growth rate?
Harry Stebbings 1:19:53 Mm.
Jason Lemkin 1:19:53 Brax said 50%. They just said they're growing 50% now. I don't know what Ramp is. This is where my cognitive bias-
Rory O’Driscoll 1:19:59 Yeah
Jason Lemkin 1:20:00 ... I'm gonna go for Brax because it's lower.
Harry Stebbings 1:20:02 Mm.
Jason Lemkin 1:20:03 I can't help my- I cannot help myself. I can't help myself. For real. You think I'm kidding? I can't help myself. If you, if you gave me... I must... I don't have that much money to invest. If you gave me a great deal at 100, if you gave me Ramp at 100 million and Brax at 30 or 40, I'm still gonna do Brax probably. Um, probably.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:20:21 I could assign a homework assignment that would make this actually an interesting discussion. It's watch... We have all the data points we need. We have the relative size, the valuation, and the growth rate of Brax, right, at 50%. The correct question is, what growth rate should Ramp have such that you're indifferent between those two prices? In other... If Ramp is at 100, you probably want Ramp. If Ramp is at 50, you definitely want Brax. It's actually the fundamental question I would argue in all of venture is, how much extra do you pay for how much extra growth? If you could buy Ramp at whatever it is, 700 billion growing 50% for 13 bill- 700 million, 50% growing at 13, breakeven.
Jason Lemkin 1:20:59 That's Brax, yeah.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:21:00 And Ramp, 1 billion at 30 billion, there is an equilibrium growth rate that would make you indifferent between those two prices, and it's actually a v- because it's actually a very fun exercise because it actually is the core problem you face over and over again in venture, which is, how much extra do you pay for 70% growth over 60, over 50? You pay almost two to two and a half times the revenue multiple. How much more growth would you want from that? I'm missing 700. I-
Jason Lemkin 1:21:26 This is your job on the show, Rory. You gotta tell me.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:21:28 Yeah, I know. It's hard to think and talk at the same time. Keep going.
Harry Stebbings 1:21:31 [laughs] You weren't relying on us for analysis, were you, Rory?
Rory O’Driscoll 1:21:34 Uh, shocker. Yeah, I was. Keep going.
Harry Stebbings 1:21:37 Come, come on. Um, okay. Uh, Andreessen deserves the prize for best performing mega platform of the last 12 months.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:21:50 They're going to get the prize no matter what I say. It doesn't matter. They're getting the 10 billion. That's prize enough for those guys. They'll be fine.
Harry Stebbings 1:21:56 I, I've been impressed by them. I've invested with them across the board, and I think one thing that people often say about Andreessen with absolute respect to them is they have so many people, and that almost suggests that they can't all be good. They have so many people, so, like, whatever. I have worked across the board with the different partners. They are as good as the partners at smaller firms with three to five partners, and they have been fantastic. Like, I'm a big bull on Andreessen now, where I was a not before.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:22:25 I, I agree. They've been operationally excellent. I mean, what they did is my... I've been thinking about it. What they brought to the venture business from 2007, '8 on is they went into it solving the problem from the founder back with operational excellence, right? And on that, they've delivered in spades. They figured out what the founder wants. They've aggregated and delivered to him. I've always said the question always is the im- the, the return profile of that has been excellent. I mean, I've seen the numbers. They've been excellent, and the question... Th- that was the question, and they pulled it off, right? And for... A- and I agree with you on the, on the human capital thing. They... And that's why they... I think it's smart the way they have... I mean, obviously they've just lost... I can never pronounce the German name, Andre, but very impressive. I've heard him speak. He's going to do his own thing.
Harry Stebbings 1:23:14 Andre Mitta. Yeah.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:23:15 Yeah. I mean, super talented guy. I heard him speak. I'm very impressed. Um, yeah, they have a constant churn, and I was thinking even that's okay because they have a platform that transcends. They'll find other good people. They'll have, um, they have the little pockets to play with, so they can, you know, they can give you your little w- info world. They can give you, Chris, his crypto world. Everybody can have their thing. It's just like investment banks where, you know, you're the j- you're the second co-head of North America. Everyone's got a great title, and Mark and Ben sit at the top, and life is good. It's, it's, it's a well-functioning scale machine, and the reput- and the, the take, the take 15 years ago was venture couldn't scale, and it's TBD how far it can scale, but they've scaled it far more than anyone else would've thought 10 years ago, and for that, they get a prize.
Harry Stebbings 1:24:03 When we sit and look at series A, we don't sit and be frightened by Index or Accel or the big European players. We sit and be frightened of Andreessen coming into Europe. They're the ones who beat you.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:24:15 Okay. Good to know.
Jason Lemkin 1:24:17 Well, look, I, I think you wanna be, you wanna be in the top two choices for a founder at your stage. That's when you win in venture. Um, it'd be nice if you're in every, every stage and every deal, right? Um, and I think Andreessen has elements of that today, a top two choice in so many stages from so many types of founders. YC has that a- in a sliver, as do others. If you're not, man, it's just, it's just a different game than when you're a top two choice. It's just a different game. That's what you want. So I agree with you. There's only, only two people can be in the top two, right?
Harry Stebbings 1:24:50 Final one. Of all the could be public but are private late-stage companies, I would rather be a shareholder today in Anduril, the hottest at 50. Agree or disagree? And if disagree, which would you rather?
Jason Lemkin 1:25:13 No. One, not interested in the company personally. Just personally at this point in life, I just wanna do things I'm interested in to a fault. Not interested in building weapons and stuff like that. Just not my vibe. Um, two, I don't go to enough parties in SF because if I did, and this sounds facetious, but you know when I'm joking, I'm never really joke- fully joking is what it is. There's no better brag at a party than Anduril, that you did it, right? It's the ultimate Founders Fund brag. It's just, it's just the ultimate brag, and if I... And, and, um, you know, one of the psychic benefits of investing is bragging, right? At, at many levels. There's different types of bragging. There's bragging because I have a sense of worth in my life that I don't. I have a... I'm bragging because I wrote a tiny check, but, but I'm validated in my, in my, in my soulless job. There's so many levels of validation, but I just don't go to enough of those parties since 2020. So, but if I did, uh, I'd wanna, I'd wanna have that one, uh, on my chips to, to talk about at parties, but I don't care, and I'm not into bombs and weapons. So I'm, I'm out on this one.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:26:14 The amount of self-knowledge embodied in that last two minutes from Jason is just stunning. I mean, the therapy's clearly working, dude. Right? You, you [laughs] know. Well done.
Jason Lemkin 1:26:23 It's just called being happier [laughs] .
Rory O’Driscoll 1:26:24 It's go- That's okay. Uh, wait, I think it's actually called getting older and wiser. I love it.
Jason Lemkin 1:26:28 Maybe. Maybe.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:26:28 Yeah.
Harry Stebbings 1:26:29 Listen, guys, o- on that incredibly hearty note, uh, thank you. This has been fantastic, and I've loved it.
Jason Lemkin 1:26:36 All right. Rock and roll. Thank you, Harry. Thank you, Rory.
Rory O’Driscoll 1:26:38 Thank you
Episode duration: 1:26:49
In the uListen app, the transcript lights up word by word as you listen. Get uListen
Transcript of episode 4PNd9qV5FzA