Child Attachment Expert: We're Stressing Newborns & It's Causing ADHD! Hidden Dangers Of Daycare!

Child Attachment Expert: We're Stressing Newborns & It's Causing ADHD! Hidden Dangers Of Daycare!

The Diary of a CEOMar 3, 20252h 38m

Erica Komisar (guest), Steven Bartlett (host)

Child mental health crisis and root causesAttachment theory, early development (0–3) and adolescence (9–25)Mothers’, fathers’ and hormones’ distinct roles in caregivingDaycare, early separation, and stress biology (amygdala, cortisol, ADHD)Attachment styles and adult relationshipsSocietal shifts: feminism, individualism, work culture, and low birth ratesPolicy/structural changes: parental leave, flexible work, and support systems

In this episode of The Diary of a CEO, featuring Erica Komisar and Steven Bartlett, Child Attachment Expert: We're Stressing Newborns & It's Causing ADHD! Hidden Dangers Of Daycare! explores early Parenting Myths Fuel Child Mental Illness, ADHD, And Fragile Adults Psychoanalyst and parenting expert Erica Komisar argues that today’s mental health crisis in children is largely rooted in how modern societies raise babies and young children, especially from birth to age three.

Early Parenting Myths Fuel Child Mental Illness, ADHD, And Fragile Adults

Psychoanalyst and parenting expert Erica Komisar argues that today’s mental health crisis in children is largely rooted in how modern societies raise babies and young children, especially from birth to age three.

She claims daycare, early separation, and the cultural prioritization of careers and individual fulfillment over consistent parental presence dysregulate children’s stress systems, producing attachment disorders, ADHD-like stress responses, and long‑term emotional fragility.

Komisar emphasizes distinct but complementary evolutionary roles for mothers and fathers, contends that secure attachment and physical/emotional presence are the true foundations of resilience, and criticizes medication‑first approaches as “pain management” that ignore root causes.

She calls for structural changes like paid parental leave and more flexible work, as well as personal changes in priorities, to give parents the time and support needed to raise emotionally secure children and repair damage later in adolescence where possible.

Key Takeaways

The first three years are a critical, non‑repeatable window for emotional brain development.

Komisar says 85% of the right (social/emotional) brain is built by age three, driven heavily by the caregiving environment. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Secure attachment is the strongest known protective factor against later mental illness.

Longitudinal attachment research cited by Komisar shows that infants who are securely attached at 12 months are overwhelmingly more likely to be secure and mentally healthy 20 years later, while those insecure at 12 months are far more likely to develop anxiety, depression, ADHD‑like behaviors, and personality disorders. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Much ADHD is better understood as a chronic stress response than a fixed disorder.

Komisar frames ADHD behaviors (hyperactivity, impulsivity, distractibility) as manifestations of fight‑or‑flight: “fight” yields aggression and acting out; “flight” yields distraction and inattention. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Mothers and fathers are not interchangeable; they provide different, complementary functions.

Drawing on hormone research, she argues that oxytocin in mothers promotes vigilant, sensitive, empathic nurturing and buffering from stress, especially in infancy. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Daycare and institutional care in the first three years carry emotional and biological costs.

Komisar strongly criticizes early daycare, saying research shows it elevates salivary cortisol in infants and toddlers, and correlates with increased aggression, anxiety, behavioral issues, and attachment disturbances later. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Many adult problems in relationships trace back to early attachment styles.

Komisar describes four patterns: secure (healthy bonds, trust, flexibility), avoidant (difficulty committing, emotional distance), ambivalent/anxious (clinginess, fear of abandonment, emotional volatility), and disorganized (cycling between clinging, avoidance, anger; strongly associated with borderline personality traits and self‑harm). ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Preventing and repairing damage requires both personal sacrifice and systemic change.

Komisar’s “three Ps” are presence, prioritization, and prevention. ...

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Notable Quotes

We have a mental illness crisis in children, the likes of which we've never seen in history, and it has everything to do with how we're raising our children.

Erica Komisar

Attachment security is the foundation for future mental health.

Erica Komisar

Daycare is good for children for socialization. No. It's so bad for their brain.

Erica Komisar

ADHD is not a disorder. It is a stress response.

Erica Komisar

You can't have a fabulous career and then come home and be present for your child on your time. It needs to be on their time.

Erica Komisar

Questions Answered in This Episode

You argue that daycare before age three is broadly harmful; what, if anything, would a daycare system need to change—staff ratios, continuity of carers, environment—to truly approximate the attachment benefits of a home caregiver?

Psychoanalyst and parenting expert Erica Komisar argues that today’s mental health crisis in children is largely rooted in how modern societies raise babies and young children, especially from birth to age three.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

For a couple where both partners already hold inflexible, high‑pressure jobs (e.g., medicine, law, hedge funds) and a baby is on the way, what concrete, step‑by‑step plan would you recommend they implement in the next 12 months to realign their lives with the attachment principles you describe?

She claims daycare, early separation, and the cultural prioritization of careers and individual fulfillment over consistent parental presence dysregulate children’s stress systems, producing attachment disorders, ADHD-like stress responses, and long‑term emotional fragility.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Your framework leans heavily on sex‑based hormonal differences; how do you respond to critics who say this risks reinforcing regressive gender norms or underestimates cultural learning, especially in light of families that appear to thrive with non‑traditional role configurations?

Komisar emphasizes distinct but complementary evolutionary roles for mothers and fathers, contends that secure attachment and physical/emotional presence are the true foundations of resilience, and criticizes medication‑first approaches as “pain management” that ignore root causes.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

If a 30‑year‑old adult recognizes themselves as an avoidant or disorganized attacher after listening to you, what are the first three practical actions you’d have them take in the next six weeks to begin repairing their attachment style without overwhelming their existing relationships?

She calls for structural changes like paid parental leave and more flexible work, as well as personal changes in priorities, to give parents the time and support needed to raise emotionally secure children and repair damage later in adolescence where possible.

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

You’re highly critical of ADHD medication as a default pathway, yet many adults report dramatic functional benefits at work and in relationships; what empirical markers or clinical criteria would you use to decide when prescribing stimulants is justified versus when it’s masking a treatable relational or environmental problem?

Get the full analysis with uListen AI

Transcript Preview

Erica Komisar

One in five children will not leave childhood without developing a serious mental illness. Anxiety, depression, ADHD, behavioral problems. And what pisses me off, it's that we're not really educating or telling parents the truth as to why.

Steven Bartlett

Why is it that what you say is so troubling for some people?

Erica Komisar

Sometimes facts are an inconvenient truth. But everything I'm gonna say is supported by research.

Steven Bartlett

Erika Komisa is a parenting expert and psychoanalyst.

Erica Komisar

Who uses over 30 years of research...

Steven Bartlett

To challenge the societal norms on parenting and early child development.

Erica Komisar

There's some myths that really have to be debunked about how to raise a healthy child, and the first is, daycare is good for children for socialization. No. It's so bad for their brain, and it's been known to increase aggression, behavioral problems, attachment disorders, because babies need their mothers in the first three years for emotional security.

Steven Bartlett

Can a father do that?

Erica Komisar

So, fathers are important in a different way, and I'll go through all of that. But they're both critical, because if you're raised without one, you are missing a piece. And then there's quality versus quantity time. Myth. You need to be there a quality of time as well as a quantity of time. You can't have a fabulous career and then come home and be present for your child on your time. It needs to be on their time. And there's more.

Steven Bartlett

And we're gonna go through all of them, but are there any areas of privilege that you need to acknowledge? Maybe someone who doesn't have a partner there, or someone who is in an extremely difficult economic situation?

Erica Komisar

I do. But there are ways to creatively deal with it, and I'll go through each of them. So there's...

Steven Bartlett

This has always blown my mind a little bit. 53% of you that listen to this show regularly haven't yet subscribed to this show. So could I ask you for a favor before we start? If you like this show and you like what we do here and you wanna support us, the free simple way that you can do just that is by hitting the subscribe button. And my commitment to you is if you do that, then I'll do everything in my power, me and my team, to make sure that this show is better for you every single week. We'll listen to your feedback, we'll find the guests that you want me to speak to, and we'll continue to do what we do. Thank you so much. Erica, you're clearly on a mission, and I get that energy from you that there's really an idea that you believe that much of the world doesn't believe or is struggling to accept in some way, but it's an important idea. What is the mission that you're on?

Erica Komisar

I like to think of it as three Ps, presence, prioritization, and prevention. And I'll go through each of them. Um, my mission is to educate parents and, uh, policymakers and clinicians and educators about the, the fact that for children to be mentally healthy in the future, you have to be physically and emotionally present for them throughout ch- childhood, but particularly in the two critical periods of brain development, which are zero to three and nine to 25, which is adolescence. So in those two critical periods of brain development, uh, particularly zero to three, um, much of a child's development depends on their environment, and you are their environment. So, I run around the world talking about the importance of physical and emotional presence, attachment security. Attachment security is the foundation for future mental health. Prioritization. We prioritize everything today other than our children. We prioritize our work, our careers, uh, our material success, our personal desires and pleasures. But what we're not prioritizing is children. Um, and, you know, that's a problem because if we don't prioritize them, they break down. They may break down at three, they may break down at eight, or they may not break down till they're in adolescence, but eventually they break down. And prevention, there's so much that we can do. We have a mental health crisis now in the world. It varies to a certain degree in America. One in five children will not leave childhood without breaking down at some point, without developing a serious mental illness. Anxiety, depression, ADHD, behavioral problems, um, suicidal thoughts. So, uh, we have a problem. In the UK it's one in six, in America it's one in five. Uh, it's, around the world it's about one in five. That is a shocking figure, and so... And the, and the truth is we can do a great deal to prevent that. The idea that we are trying to put out fires without talking about what is the origin of these issues. The way that the mental health care system works now, it's like what I call cutting the grass. Uh, children are medicated, which is basically just pain management. Um, they're given CBT therapy, which again, is just pain management. But why aren't we asking the important questions, which is where does emotional regulation originate? Where does it come from? When does it start? How do we foster development in children from a very young age to promote resilience to stress and adversity in the future? And so those are my three missions.

Install uListen to search the full transcript and get AI-powered insights

Get Full Transcript

Get more from every podcast

AI summaries, searchable transcripts, and fact-checking. Free forever.

Add to Chrome