Skip to content
Jay Shetty PodcastJay Shetty Podcast

Blocked by Fear of Being Judged? Here's How to STOP Caring & UNBLOCK Your Creativity!

Today, Jay sits down with author, artist, and creative mentor Amie McNee for a heartfelt conversation about reconnecting with the artist inside all of us. Known for her honest take on creativity and self-expression, Amie opens up about her journey, from battling self-doubt and shame to finding her voice as a writer and artist. Amie shares real stories of rejection, depression, and learning to embrace imperfection, reminding us that art doesn’t need to be perfect, it just needs to be real. Jay and Amie explore the common myths that hold people back from creating. The idea that creativity has to be profitable, that art must be perfect to be valuable, or that we need permission to begin. They discuss how shame, perfectionism, and fear of judgment often silence our creative instincts, and how practices like journaling, self-mothering, and small daily acts of creativity can help revive them. They also reflect on the emotional vulnerability of sharing your work, the importance of protecting your inner artist, and the delicate balance between wanting to be seen and creating for the pure joy of expression. In this interview, you'll learn: How to Reclaim Your Creativity Without Shame How to Make Art When You’re Struggling with Self-Doubt How to Start Creating Even If You Don’t Feel Ready How to Deal with Fear of Judgment and Being Seen How to Turn Jealousy into Creative Motivation How to Promote Your Art Without Selling Out Whether someone is writing a novel, posting their first poem, or simply daring to call themselves an artist, this conversation is a gentle yet powerful reminder—they are on the path, and their voice matters. With Love and Gratitude, Jay Shetty What We Discuss: 00:00 Intro 00:49 Are We Born Creative or Can It Be Learned? 02:12 Why Everyone Is an Artist in Their Own Way 03:50 What Happens When You Suppress Your Creativity 06:37 How Journaling and Self-Compassion Can Heal You 08:30 You Owe Everything to the Past Version of You 13:03 How to Move Through the Fear of Being Judged 16:07 Why Art Exposes Both Light and Darkness 17:25 Let Go of Needing External Validation 19:30 Everyone Just Wants to Be Seen and Heard 24:31 Stop Dismissing the Parts of You That Want More 26:28 Stuck in the Wrong Job? Try Small Creative Steps 30:56 How Perfectionism Fuels Procrastination 33:11 Embrace the Beautiful Chaos of Art 34:17 What the 30 Circles Test Reveals About Creativity 36:44 How to Share Your Art Without Losing Yourself 39:07 Real Artists Are Meant to Break the Rules 40:29 What to do When No One Sees Your Art 41:54 If You Hate It, Stop Doing It 44:19 Don’t Chase Virality, Make Meaningful Art 46:40 Yes, You Can Make Money from Your Art 50:10 Every Creative Act Has Value So Honor It 53:12 Charging for Your Art Is Not Selling Out 57:39 Oversaturation Is a Myth, There’s Room for You 01:00:53 Your Voice Is One of a Kind Use It 01:02:25 Use Jealousy to Guide, Not Derail You 01:03:49 How to Inspire Others by Owning Your Path 01:07:12 Amie on Final Five Episode Resources: https://www.amiemcnee.com/ https://www.instagram.com/inspiredtowrite https://www.facebook.com/AmieFionaMcNee/ https://www.tiktok.com/@amiemcnee https://www.amazon.com/stores/author/B09DKVNGNJ https://www.instagram.com/jayshetty https://www.facebook.com/jayshetty/ https://x.com/jayshetty https://www.linkedin.com/in/shettyjay/ https://www.youtube.com/@JayShettyPodcast http://jayshetty.me

Amie McNeeguestJay Shettyhost
Jul 15, 20251h 11mWatch on YouTube ↗

At a glance

WHAT IT’S REALLY ABOUT

Stop fearing judgment: reclaim creativity with shame-free, messy, meaningful art

  1. Creativity is an innate human drive, and “art” should be reclaimed as any form of making—from writing and cooking to gardening and podcasting.
  2. Suppressing creativity often creates an internal war of shame and “irresponsibility,” which can fuel depression, disconnection, and chronic self-betrayal.
  3. Journaling and self-compassion (re-parenting the inner artist) help rewrite destructive narratives and build the courage to create despite fear of judgment.
  4. Perfectionism and procrastination reinforce each other, and progress comes from playful experimentation, “shitty first drafts,” and small daily commitments.
  5. Sharing and monetizing art can be ethical and aligned when you resist virality-chasing, embrace authentic connection, and treat art as valuable work worthy of payment.

IDEAS WORTH REMEMBERING

5 ideas

Everyone is an artist; “art” is broader than fine art.

They argue creativity shows up in many forms—podcasting, makeup, cooking, gardening—and treating art as “only for the talented” keeps people from starting.

Suppressing creativity can harm mental health and identity.

Amie describes shame-driven suppression leading to depression and a constant internal conflict between the need to create and the demand to be “responsible.”

Journaling works as a tool to expose and rewrite your inner critic.

Her practice: write the harsh narratives out, witness how violent they sound, then intentionally end with a compassionate “mothering myself” voice to rebuild safety and self-trust.

Assume you’ll be judged—and create anyway, with protective boundaries.

Amie reframes judgment as inevitable and survivable; she even blocked people from her past to create a “cocoon” where her emerging artist-self wouldn’t be interrupted.

Don’t wait to be healed or confident before you begin making art.

They note art reveals both “light and darkness,” so insecurity will surface during the process; delaying creation until you feel ready becomes a lifelong stall.

WORDS WORTH SAVING

5 quotes

Since literally the day I started journaling, I haven't stopped, and it ... Everything changed because I allowed creativity back into my life shame-free.

— Amie McNee

My brain is, like, a place of just, like, violence and vitriol.

— Amie McNee

You are a one-time phenomenon that will never, ever be seen again, and if you choose not to take action on this idea, then that's done.

— Amie McNee

Creation itself will never be safe. It's inherently risky, and that's why it's inherently rewarding.

— Amie McNee

Perfectionism will destroy your creative career. It will destroy it.

— Amie McNee

Redefining art and everyday creativityShame, depression, and the suppressed inner artistJournaling as narrative rewiring and re-parentingFear of judgment and boundary-setting (including blocking)Perfectionism–procrastination loop and “shitty art” practiceSmall-step creative routines (300–500 words a day)Promotion, algorithms, integrity, and monetizing art

High quality AI-generated summary created from speaker-labeled transcript.

Get more out of YouTube videos.

High quality summaries for YouTube videos. Accurate transcripts to search & find moments. Powered by ChatGPT & Claude AI.

Add to Chrome